India in Modi’s Third Term
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 เม.ย. 2024
- Beginning on April 19, India will hold the largest national election in recorded history and it is likely to keep Prime Minister Narendra Modi in office for a third term. The last ten years in India’s history have witnessed conspicuous transformations. What do the next five years hold for India’s trajectory?
Join Ashley J. Tellis, the Tata Chair for Strategic Affairs and a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment, for a conversation with Alyssa Ayres, dean of the Elliott School of International Affairs and professor of history and international affairs at George Washington University, and Ashok Malik, a partner at The Asia Group and Chair of its New Delhi-based subsidiary.
Sign up to receive Carnegie invitations: bit.ly/3Bfsca5
Like and subscribe to our channel: bit.ly/38sljlH
The Carnegie Endowment advances international peace by leveraging its global network to shape debates and provide decisionmakers with independent insights and innovative ideas on the most consequential global threats and opportunities.
Support Carnegie’s work: carnegieendowment.org/donate
Visit our website: carnegieendowment.org/
Like us on Facebook: / carnegieendowment
Follow us on Twitter: / carnegieendow
Follow us on Instagram: / carnegieendow
#foreignpolicy #CarnegieEndowment
Manmohan Singh actually destroyed Indian Manufacturing.
Manmohan was a puppet. Gandhi & Co managed from back door. Waste of opportunities, selling off our small scale industries to China under a agreement with congress.
no man is perfect. the politics did not let him, at least he liberalized the economy I will forever have respect for him even if hes a leftist.
@@deflexion3677 He liberalized the economy or the IMF? Lets get honest with ourself. Manmohan Singh as CEA in 1970s proposed top tax rate at 94%.
It was IMF that forced India to liberalize in exchange for the Bail out. PVNR needed a dumb bureaucrat to implement the IMF plan and who better then Manmohan.
not true
@@deflexion3677Yeah just ignore PV Narasimha Rao ever existed.
If anti-Hindu Congress comes democracy is Safe
If BJP comes democracy is in danger
Did Ashley ask the question when Congress got 400 seats
cong is more manageable by them
West doesn't care whether its Dictatorship or Tyrants, as long as they are Puppets of the West.
This is why West questions India on Demcratic and Secular Values, Not Saudi Arabia or Qatar or Singapore or Japan.
Ashley works for CIA so ofc he is gonna says such things
Ashley in his mind thinks, as I am Christian,I am equal to white. But I am afraid,they are just using them as a brown sepoy because a brown Christian is a best sepoy they can get
@@xendit1635 TRUTH. HE LOOKS DARKER THAN MODI. MODI IS ACTUALLY QUITE LIGHT SKINNED FOR SOMNEONE FROM INDIA
Western crap gets repeated so often that it’s nauseating. Enslaving blacks for 100s of years, wiping native Americans from the map, these guys have gal to lecture others specifically about complex society of 1.4 billion people.
Oh, bhakt, this is how think tanks operate.
You are 2 steps away from taking your sahada namazi. That's not how talks work. Hypocrisy have also it's limits.@@DataCrusade1999
@@sanjaiyadav2080 Typical bhakt spent his whole life dedicated to Modi bhakti and in that bhakti process destroyed whatever neurons he had left in his brains. The bhakt thinks that every think tank operates like Reliance funded Observer Research Foundation(ORF).
@@DataCrusade1999 don't care let them get screwed, right along with you.
Ppl who call themselves "americans" are upset that even after getting r id of Indians and putting the few left in reservations, there are still so many Indians left free.
We Indians, our freedom and existence in large numbers, remind them everyday of what they did to Indians and hence they resent us.
Congress had a policy of encouraging manufacturing? Seriously? 10 yrs of UPA was when manufacturing was decimated.
i think it's absurd when people say there are no minority representation in the current dispensation as the 2nd most powerful person(amit Shah) in the cabinet is from minority community(Jain) and Textile minister smriti irani as well (Parsi) even a sikh present as well. People only think certain community and from that community certain individual who toe their ideology to become the minister. Hypocrisy without fact is a dangerous path to follow.
Amit Shah is not a Jain, he belongs to Vaishnava community. Smriti Irani is a Hindu, her husband is parsi.
Everybody in India is a minority, depending upon how you define it.
@@easwaransanthakumar297Amit shah is a Jain indeed. Smriti is parsi after marrying husband like happens in all marriages.
I want Land and Agricultural reforms to be brought by Modi 3.0
We need farmer's law back
That farmer laws need to be brought back with consultation of stakeholder and farmers from panjab and west UP can't just keep doing their nonsensical protest....
Muslims are not the only minority in the country despite the constant insinuations by people like AT who are determined to present a false narrative. The fact is that out of 78 ministers , 27 are OBC, 12 SC, 8ST, 11 women, and 1 each from Buddhist, Christian, Sikh and Muslim communities. The reason Muslims are not well represented is because they vote en masse for opposition parties and even vote against Muslim candidates nominated by the BJP. You may ask why liberals/communist are not represented in a USA Republican administration.
Muslims are the second largest majority.
Modi will bring unprecedented economic reforms in 3rd term just like he had done in his 3nd term in gujarat . First two terms were to destroy the opposition thoroughly, third term for economic reforms, fourth term will be for succession of next generation leader .
It's like expecting a different outcome by putting the same horse in the race thrice. Despite the anticipation for a winning run, if the horse has stumbled in the past due to its own limitations or shortcomings, it's prudent to reconsider whether persistence alone will lead to victory, or if a fresh contender might offer a better chance at success.
@@anujsethi7845 you mean indi alliance the people who abuse each other , can't stand each other , call each other names and if they win the only thing they'll do is corruption , appeasement, lawlessness and bickering with each other . Also modi brought land acquisition laws, NJAC to reform Juidiciary, farm laws to reform Agricultural sector , etc but he had to backtrack bcoz of farmers and Supreme Court refused to accept njac . I still see him bringing good reform in his 3rd term now that the opposition has been decimated completely.
@@anujsethi7845 I am not voting in a bunch of donkeys who will fight each other for 5 years . I am voting in a strong dictator who will do the needed reforms using Sam dam dand bhed . Remember modi had brought land acquisition and 3 farm laws but sadly they had to backtrack bcoz of bad protest politics .
@@anujsethi7845 indi alliance will kill each other than stand with each other in a room for more than an hour . They'll bicker like 5 year little toddlers .
@@anujsethi7845
Who exactly is this "fresh contender" ?
33:00 The debate on manufacturing or not is such a stupid elitist debate. Those are against manufacturing are defeatists who think just because we might have automation (I doubt manufacturing will be fully automated, it will be heavily mechanized) we have to give up. At the end of the day, manufacturing still provides value, it provides jobs. One manufacturing job created means one person that is no longer underemployed/unemployed, is vastly more productive and that's one less job that needs to be created to employ the unemployable. When will academics especially like Raghuram Rajan get this simple concept in their head? We might have missed the bus but better late than never. Honestly, folks who argue against it should be debarred and their academic credentials should be revoked.
100% agree with you mate.
Modi and BJP is doing a good job and will be reelected with more majority
First term was spent coming to term with mess left by old establishment.
Second term certain policy changes, infrastructures, a growth plan is worked out.
3rd term will bring in drastic changes in the ground . Get up & vote .
It's 100 billion dollar of investment from EFTA countries not 10 billion dollar
it's 10 billion per year for 10 years
not a kind of mistake we expect elites to make
Ashley is not an elite but a typical Indian overseas worker wanting to impress his boss and payday lol also details usually don't matter much for the trolling work he does though
The mistake 99% of western outlets make when analyzing Indian people & Indian Government is that these journalists & "experts" think from the perspective of western interest. They think which government in India would be better for WESTERN interest. So accordingly they make negative comments about Modi government since it doesn't toe the line dictated by west.
Whereas Indian people, who are the actual voter, when they think about choosing the government they think of what's good for INDIAN interest(As it should be).
You call yourselves journalists & experts but can't even do an objective analysis of a country's government & politics. It's always biased reporting cuz the present government is not in YOUR INTEREST & you wanna replace it. But guess what. it's in OUR INTEREST. The Indian people that actually reside & vote in India. So get lost
They aren't mistaken, it's a propaganda
INDIVIDUAL IS THE SMALLEST MINORITY IN THE WORLD THAT MUST BE APPEASED. INDIVIDUAL’S HUMAN RIGHTS & ECONOMIC RIGHTS ARE MOST IMPORTANT.
PM Modi rightly identified this minority (Individual) rather than religious minority.
Hundreds of millions of Indians under PM Modi got access to toilets, cooking gas, electricity supply, bank accounts, micro-finance, interest subvention on housing loans etc and are now in the process of getting piped water in every house & healthcare facilities.
Millions of oppressed Muslim ladies got dignity with elimination Halala & triple talaq.
A billion Hindus got right to worship at their apex religious site in Ayodhya to fulfill their spiritual needs.
Thousands of persecuted minorities thrown out of the neighboring Muslim countries & living dejected life for decades under clutches of psudosecularism were set free & are being given life of dignity & honor with Indian Citizenship.
PM Modi knew that investment in the people is the real progress. Fulfillment of peoples' basic needs comes before everything else. This is what governance is for. This is what governments are for. This empowerment of people led to rapid economic growth. Still better life is on the cards during PM Modi's 3rd term.
How the education and electrification doing in India right now? I remembered during the pandemic many people could not attend school online
We have too much of education .
What we need is business , industries , job
@@ostrakos4785 Electrification and online schools, work from home went on smoothly during the pandemic. These were not even an issue as far as I can remember. However Hospitals in Delhi and many states ran out of oxygen for covid infected patients during the peak of the pandemic due to mismanagement of state and national politicians who were fighting and blaming each other for the mess. Fortunately the Airforce and Navy carried out extensive ops and bought in oxygen from other countries and stabilized the situation which was the biggest life threatening problem of that time.
@@ostrakos4785electrification is complete, there is still load shedding in some rural areas but not in major cities any more. Education coverage is now universal but median quality is still poor. New education policy is good but implementation is too complicated because we don't have enough skilled teachers across the country
Voting congress means throwing India to wolves
what this guyz are smoking ?
1) Democracy did not die or was in danger when gandhi imposed nehru over Sardar patel even when he had 0 votes
2) Democracy did not die or was in Danger when congress(one family) ruled for decades with out any opposition with unlimited power
3) Democracy did not die or was in danger when emergency was imposed and rights were stripped off people
4) Democracy did not die or was in danger when riots and terrorism were rampant because of congress policies
but now it is because unlike congress BJP does not work as stooge of western powers
Sensible observations👍
Duffer malik M0di cabinet has ministers from minority community. Sikh and Jain.
Such a easy question.. You could not answer
Exactly. I find it illogical that many Indians as well as the westerners consider only the second largest assertive majority of India as the only minority.
Question was about Muslim minority
@@deadlyninja8391 no watch again question was about ministers from minority community
@@RP027 its implied
Don't be so harsh in your criticism. Ashok was quite balanced without swinging too much to any side!
Ashok Malik doesn't seem to aware the transformation that has taken place in the Indian Toy Market
Specifically the Indian sex toy market.
@@TamBramThankyouMam No idea
PM Modi, much like President Xi Jinping of China, is a highly intelligent leader who is committed to steering India towards development. If he secures a third term with a significant majority, his vision could elevate India to a level comparable to present-day China. Notably, India's advantageous relationships with the West (America, Europe), African nations, Russia, and East Asia (Japan, Philippines, Taiwan, South Korea, Singapore, ...) set it apart from China, giving PM Modi a strong strategic edge.
Without growth we cannot raise per capita GDP this is a given the question remains unanswered why has India’s growth not proportionately raised the per capita GDP. India ranks 111 out of 125 countries in the hunger index so again Ashok extrapolates his circumstances as that of the country as a whole.
what was indias gdp in 2014 and in 2024?
2003-2013 GDP per capita rose 1.67 times 2013-2022 1.4 times
Carnegie on whose name this organisation is established, he was founding father of the theory that "Anglosaxons are the chosen one by God to rule this world" imagine
They don't know what's going on in India.. don't gather a panel that is not grounded with facts..
India Doctor of Thorium ,after Rus we are only approximately Frist country in the world who have indigenous Atomic technology that converted "Achay Urja " by fast brider reactor. imagine it became under production level,and India will become richest country.
Bharat again saying Golden Bird ,like his inceant time.
Poor English,read with correction.
Not approximately, we are the only country who have a serious plan on Thorium but it is lingering at best. This govt is at least building 8 or so more but we are long way away from switching to pure Thorium cycle removing dependency on imported uranium/plutonium
Two hallelujah specialists discussing on the table with a dinosaur who thinks he has a birth right to advise.
With regards to reliance on China Ashok Malik answers a question with a question. The actual question was what is India’s China policy, for e.g. have we restricted trade in sensitive sectors? There is a 21% growth no signs of restrictions in fact an expansion in the deficit to a $100bn.
India is prospering under PM Modi's leadership. More power to PM Modi.
Jai Hind 🇮🇳.....Jai Shree Ram 🚩
When will US stop interfering in India's affairs. It is rumoured that Biden admin asked Musk to defer his India visit as it may benefit Modi in the election process.
Most likely just a rumour, Musk will probably do the opposite if Biden asks something like this!
This seems to be one of his antique negotiation tactics to see as a last attempt if Indian govt will budge, either that or may wait to see if there is weaker govt (for eg. if BJP doesn't get simple majority and has to depend on NDA allies) then Tesla will be in stronger position to negotiate
Free speach is good for over fed people . Not the hungry lot .
Caste census and redistribution of wealth are bad ideas proposed by the Congress Party of India. The caste system survives in India due to bad policies from the government, the Congress Party was expert in dividing Indians in the name of caste when the party was in power. Modi made it even worse by saying that this policy was suggested by the Congress Party to please the Muslims. Indian politicians will lose their power without the caste system.
Who here only listened to Malik Paajee?
I had to watch at 2.0 speed, they were talking really slow 😅😅😅
1:17:00 I like the Lady’s question. She’s all about the money.
Sadanand Dhume's wife.
45:00
He has even said that Akbar was trying to form a new religion called din e ellahi. So he was very open minded secular accommodating ruler. The fact that he didn’t adopt Hinduism for himself passed mr Ahmed by.
Good to see great American Nationalist Ashley Tellis here after the vitriol of bile at the shady camden conference.
Ashley hardly manages to hide his Modi hatred, because Modi put a stop to free for all conversion to Christianity through cash and kind, with Bible Belt money, all in the garb of an intellectual. Modi and Hinduphobia seems to the surest route to ‘acceptability’. Like they say the new converts are the most virulent.
18:22 : Hahahaha …..look within first !!! Before pointing fingers
Pretty good discussion guys! 👍
US needs to look beyond EU to recognise diversity of peoples and opinions 😊
I gave my vote to BJP on April 26. You guys keep crying.
36:30 peach of an answer!
Edit: I found the discussion reasonably balanced, seen more biased takes on Modi in Indian debates. Not sure why people are criticizing the panel, Ashok especially who was quite balanced and clear enough. Not everything you hear has to align 100% to what you think, doesn't mean we have to lap up their views as we historically did but unless you get a sense that they are deliberately maligning India or Modi, let's not be unnecessarily bitter
Modi 3.0 will further expand private sector participation in Indian economy.
India’s miinority is not AMerica’s problem. It will follow independent policies.
Hopefully Modi will get re-elected and complete his term. If get some reason he does not, then I would prefer Jaishankar to the others.
Nobody is perfect. But what we need is strong leadership. That's what we will get.
I am at 11:59 min, before they start let me dare to predict BJP will get comfortable majority based on events so far !! You do not have to get experts to discuss this common knowledge !! Just visit India, in-fact this should be a discussion about 2029 then it might have carried some value.
Ashok Malik is not as impressive as I thought he will be
Well they can debate about India… not so much CCP 😂
i like discussions. but just make sure that the debators dont have anti modi agenda. its best to be unbiased.
I was wondering what happened to Ashok Mallik!
Under which rock you dugout this human relic Ashok Malik from ?
He's been forgotten and left behind a decade ago.
😂when the guy asked question about Congress menifesto about wealth distribution loved how they ran immediately from question exposing their hypocrisy😂😂
This.is.my.nation.who.are.you.deside..who.?
Assshoo. As a host why are having people to set your tone
This is Alyssa's stick to beat India with and .i.e Jobs and everybody from Rural areas moving into cities. Thats just not possible.
Food Security is very important for India as is territorial security. 68% of India's economy is agricultural and naturally that employs largest section of Indians. Hence, commonsense says, invest in Agriculture. The farm laws is the beginning of that Policy. Agriculture has potential to provide min. Income worth $500 per month to people involved with it. That and Narendra Modi's Rurban concept can transform things in a short time. People wont have to cities for menial jobs as they will have a decent life in their home town in Rural India with urban facilities.
Alyssa is a dreamer of the Great American dream. Well USA when it was growing in early 20th century did not have any rules to follow. India will never become China . Dictatorship.
Hence, Alyssa must look at what the Govt of India is doing and lend them support.
Vote for KHANgress = Vote for corruption and poverty
Vote for BJP = Vote for progress and prosperity
Vote wisely.....Vote for BJP 🚩
what a waste of time, I get better arguments in Amitabh Agnihotri Show
My one question why us hv concerns too much about what happens on other countries rather than looking its iwn behavior of aggressor and killing of mass millions in asia
Ashok’s response was round about and completely missed the point 15-20% of the population having less than 5% political representation has nothing to do with the middle class
It is not modi's job to develop opposition , minorities whose alligence is with Mecca & Vatican.
@@ramkinister of course its not his job to develop the opposition, the party he represents is responsible to provide representation, unless its a right wing Hindu nationalist party
@@karthikashok the communities are responsible for ensuring they get represented in the Party and in Lok Sabha. It is not the other way around. If they vote for Mecca and Vatican, then they get candidates in Mecca and Vatican not in New Delhi.
@@libshastra elections in India are about big money and powerful political parties so if they deny you seats the odds are stacked against you, This is not your class elections in high school.
@@pernemlong9363 why wouldn’t they get the approval of the minorities?
Are we now calling elections before the first vote is cast?
Yes 💯 percent modi going to win with larger majority
Thanks to the opposition's lack of credibility, inability of identifying genuine issues concerning ordinary citizens instead of imaginary & wishful issues concocted by pseudo-intellectuals sitting in their ivory towers.
It is indeed sad how incompetent & clueless the opposition has made itself irrelevant and thereby handed over this election on platter. The only saving grace is that PM Modi is a rational & wise nationalist.
Sandeshkhali silence gang agrees. Jihadis keep crying
Bottom line ms Georgetown
Starts at 9:30
Ye ashok haklata kyu itna
Ashok Malick doesn't deny India has lot of fault lines and says clearly Social Media amplifies ALL these issues, but what is the govt doing about it? Where is the long term vision? What is Indian about it? Why haven't they come up with something like UPI that is designed with Indian conditions in mind? This is their biggest blind spot and weakness. They have acquired power and influence using Social Media's many negative features. And therefore they don't see them as issues. This is the greatest danger to the future of India. Any change to social media architecture threatens Modis source of power and influence. So he can't change it while Ashok Malick & Co are admitting social media is amplifying India's fault lines.
we want dictator MODI
dictator? lol.. do you know what elections means?
@@nealrutgerskid nah I am from mars just landed in china going india through Tibet. 😌.
This joker Ashley Tellis is talking nonsense
Ashok Malik is such a weak debator.
For manufacturing India basically needs 3 things:
1. Land law
2. Labour Law
3. Tax Law
Simple
But BJP or RSS will never let that happen because that would mean touching the farmers and that would mean they getting rich and geting EMPOWERED and thats exactly they dont want ...why because they dont want lower castes to move up the ladder
🇵🇰 Abdul......Come with your real id 😂
@@Maverick-zo4kc This is my real ID man, I am dalit from central India
India is growing at a decent pace," Modi said. "India will achieve double-digit growth when I become PM," he also promised, along with pledging to make it the third-largest economy by 2025. However, Modi failed to deliver on both promises.
Wake up and smell the coffee.
Haters gonna hate and you are a hater!
Lol 😆 we have grown more than any other big economy. Lie to yourself but don't ignore facts . 💯
@maybeen9294 correct. Covid has been the biggest disruptor of the century. Sometimes it is gives me shivers when I think if it was Congress at the helm when the covid hit India 😢 can't imagine the situation people would have found themselves and scams of massive scales that Congress would have pulled in purchasing all necessary medicines, equipment and also the vaccine...!!
@@maybeen9294 lol before COVID we were in double digit growth rate 😂😂.
Modi promised 5 trillion economy by 2025 after the COVID.
So this government loves to catch headlines.