I think i read a study or report on a helping effect for people with PTSD caused by a military duty or beeing civilian in war situations, when they play videogames that include war or similar themes.
the flashback is what actually happend but the voiceover is him talking to his child so he was probably only saying that because he didnt want to frighten her
“He never got older, and here I am still. Who decides such things?” That line hits me so hard, the loss of life at such a scale. So many families and friends torn apart and for what? Not just the soldiers but civilians too…
And contrary to history, the allies were technically the ones that started both world wars too. After all, we backed Serbia, and they're the ones that killed the Austrian leader. Then after world war 1 ended, Georges Clemanceau (France) went out of his way to punish Germany with that Versailles treaty bullshit where they had to cough up 7 billion in reparations just as the great depression hit. Which turned into a major reason why the second one started. Keep that in mind while thinking about this.
@@jtvhq5723 My German's more then a little rusty but is that "That's how it is in the Fatherland"? No option to translate on here and Google translate doesn't have keys for certain characters.
@@wholesome_masochist4113 It was not Serbia who killed the Archduke it was an AustroHungarian citizen who was ethnically a Bosnian Serb! The Serbian Goverment actually warned the AH Gov. about a possible incident in Sarajevo, AH Gov, had chosen to ignore the warnings! They wanted an excuse to invade and conquer Serbia since the 1908 Anexation of Bosnia
Man how far Battlefield franchise fell since BF1. Storytelling on BF1 was absolute peak. Didn't paint any side as inherently evil but still portrayed the absolute horror that is war, for all participants.
@@sc0ttishnutj0b75 The Germans were fucking evil. You clearly don't know your history. Oh, and the Canadians matched the vibe. But without the chemical warfare.
@@sc0ttishnutj0b75 Every nation willing to draft their youth, in the tens of thousands, into a confusing total war for motives other than the defence of territorial sovereignty is evil.
@@LoSpartanoItalianoWasn't the German empire in the central powers along with Austria hungary? I'm sure there were some battles were germans were sent but anyway what do you call a group of germs? Germany
Well yeah, because in WW1 Italy got nothing out of it. All the losses for nothing. And that pissed them off, somewhat like with Germans and Weimar Republic (not even hyperinflation but just general societal shift, you'd feel right at home if you're a modern liberal American who can speak German).
@@-WarCriminal-22...and you would have to be a liberal to understand it?....dude do me a favor and save your opinions on what is going on till the election. No one wants to hear your nonsense argument.
"White friday, I'll take the stairway to heaven. I'm sky high when I die, I'll be immortal. Forever, I never, I wo t return to Blood mountain, I am the soldier of heaven.-" o7
Gameplay. They didn't want you to have it while you just ran around, plus that would mean a whole bunch of specific effects and animations would have to be made just for that. Not cost-effective.
Actually most of not all the armour he wears is factual,usually used by Arditi stormtrooper style troops or combat engineers. Yes it could stop low velocity hits from pistols,rifle bullet ricochets,slower flying shrapnel but not direct hits from rifles or machine guns.
@@MrRedeyedJediYou start to realize how old we are now and how young we were then, huh? Games that had come out after I became an adult, and no longer had time, are now considered many folks' childhoods.
The only thing I had wrong with this, was how he immediately runs into the same trajectory of the crashing aeroplane and them removes his armor, his still useable though damaged armor, and later picks up a skin and bones sub-machine gun from the rubble, as if it didn’t get damaged so badly that it was “trash” like his armor, by the crash, or the fire.
@@alessandromazzini7026 I can’t imagine the person who thought that such a weapon was that would be a good defensive option, the game shows how fast it burnt through ammo, but that’s my opinion.
@@nonsuspiciouscat4221 Say hello to World War One aircraft weapons. That was better than a standard issue rifle or pistol. Spits a lot more lead much faster. Until you get to the synchronisation gear, your options are either mounting a VERY limited defensive/over wing gun, or small arms, small arms were ESPECIALLY common in the early war.
World War 1 armor was famously cumbersome, rigid, and made the wearer particularly slow. Armored Italian soldiers were mowed down at the Battle of Asiago.
@@bigmanbigman2544 the Italian film Many Wars Ago, is based on Emilio Lussu's memoir Un anno sull'altipiano ("One year on the plateau"), recounting his experiences at the Battle of Asiago. In one scene, Armored Arditi advance forward to cut holes in the Austrian line barbed wire, only to be brutally cut down.
In reality, that armor had the same level of protection as if you would wrapped your naked body in cellophane and run across the no man's land. Even Navaho paints and chants would protect you more against the bullets.
Thats just a ridiculous exaggeration though. Yes it couldnt stop rifle or machinegun rounds, thats just for gameplay experience but it wouldve easily stopped smaller calibre rounds and more importantly shrapnel which was the biggest caused of fatalities and combat injuries. Armour like this was used in certain engagements by the Italian "Arditi" regiment and at the battles of monte grappa, one of which is depicted in game, it was used.
White friday I am take the Stairway to haeven I'm sky-high When i die I'll be immortal Forever, i never I won't return to Blood mountain I am the SOLDIER OF HEAVEN
the implications of these stories always strike me as odd. dude has been looking for his brother, finds him dead and it is played as a tragedy, yet how many people died by the dudes hands in the 14 minutes this story took place in. i counted 60. something something ludo narrative dissonance
@@thesittingacheroraptor7565 you are missing the point. how many brothers/sons/family fathers did he kill in this short amount of time? how much suffering did he inflict on others just as they inflicted on him here? Yet that angle does not get brought up whatsoever.
I think that can be argued as the point. At the end of the level he says “who decides such things” right after he just gunned down scores of men. He contributed to the horrors of war yet he still had something to lose other than his own life.
Didn't give me PTSD, just makes you wonder how bad war actually is. Especially losing your fellow comrades that served with you or a closest friend that was family to you😢
This is the first ever game i have ever played on the xbox One. Sure, i played others on 360, but this was my first one on the xbox One. No other games or friends, so i played the campaigns over, and over, and over again.
Honestly that was a very well written emotional chapter, this whole game was well written and if you try to put yourself in the place of these soldiers during this war especially once you go through the initial scenes where you inevitably die. it's tough, especially if you take the meaning that you want to make each of these soldiers lives count, or you might turn the tide of the war.
Fun fact, in real life the italians had divisions in the first waves who were suited up in metalic knight like armor, which they thought to be bullet proof. Which they were not and just made their troops have extreme difficulties in moving and slaughtered by machinegun fire
I loved the Bristol plane story and the Tank story and how Clyde and Wilson start off rough, then become comrades and Clyde takes a good long hard look at himself, and becomes determined to prove he's not a backstabbing, cheating coward. I especially enjoyed how Mcmanus manned up and admitted he'd lost himself and became best friends with the tank Driver Edward. I admired how their commander Townsend kept fighting to the last until his end.
I still despise this game for not giving us a war story from the centela powers' perspective. Its ww1 for christs sake not ww2 where thats a little more acceptable. Ugh!
What the frick is that gun? The ammo doesn't advance. The shells that are ejecting are not the same size. The Gun clearly has a Forword ejection ramp the empty shells are not coming out of. How is he shooting if both hands are on elevation and travers? Also, no armor you could ware would stop a bullet from an airplane.
Since I suffer from PTSD, will I get super PTSD after watching this?
yes
Brotha Stay Strong
Why? I already do.. stupid people making up stupid comments and titles.
I think i read a study or report on a helping effect for people with PTSD caused by a military duty or beeing civilian in war situations, when they play videogames that include war or similar themes.
@@jamerv86 Don't think my comment is stupid as I have PTSD from serving in Afghanistan. It's called humor something most people seem to lack nowadays.
"Nothing could dent it" He says, covered in dents
the flashback is what actually happend but the voiceover is him talking to his child so he was probably only saying that because he didnt want to frighten her
Tis but a scratch!
@@dorian447yeah that’s what thought
armar Steel suit soldier 💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼 🫡 mask steel 💪🏼 👍🏻
Figure of speech
"Of course nothing could dent it" thats not what you should be worrying about
He must have felt so much lighter taking off that heavy gear
what should he be worrying about then? i dont understand
@@Sir_Hammock All the force of impact transferring through the armour into the wearer.
Spalling has joined the chat.
Overpressure has joined the chat
“He never got older, and here I am still. Who decides such things?”
That line hits me so hard, the loss of life at such a scale. So many families and friends torn apart and for what? Not just the soldiers but civilians too…
And contrary to history, the allies were technically the ones that started both world wars too. After all, we backed Serbia, and they're the ones that killed the Austrian leader. Then after world war 1 ended, Georges Clemanceau (France) went out of his way to punish Germany with that Versailles treaty bullshit where they had to cough up 7 billion in reparations just as the great depression hit. Which turned into a major reason why the second one started. Keep that in mind while thinking about this.
@@wholesome_masochist4113
So ist es Grüße aus Deutschland
@@jtvhq5723 My German's more then a little rusty but is that "That's how it is in the Fatherland"? No option to translate on here and Google translate doesn't have keys for certain characters.
@@wholesome_masochist4113 sure do know your history better than I do😊
@@wholesome_masochist4113 It was not Serbia who killed the Archduke it was an AustroHungarian citizen who was ethnically a Bosnian Serb! The Serbian Goverment actually warned the AH Gov. about a possible incident in Sarajevo, AH Gov, had chosen to ignore the warnings! They wanted an excuse to invade and conquer Serbia since the 1908 Anexation of Bosnia
That moment when your just that good of a aa that the enemy's have to drop a entire mountain on top of you
For your heroic deeds in the war, we award you with this highly coveted 'Achievement unlocked: AA Menace'
And he lived.
Seeing this ending reminds of my brother. He died young at 23. He never got old. And today is his birthday. Happy birthday, Alexandru!
Hey happy birthday Alexandru!
Condolences bro
@@midget4878 🙏 Thank you
Happy birthday, Alexandru! Rest in peace for eternity
@@deadwolf7847 Thanks! it means a lot to me.
Man how far Battlefield franchise fell since BF1. Storytelling on BF1 was absolute peak. Didn't paint any side as inherently evil but still portrayed the absolute horror that is war, for all participants.
No sides were evil in the First World War.
@@sc0ttishnutj0b75Or all sides were
@@sc0ttishnutj0b75no sides were good either
@@sc0ttishnutj0b75 The Germans were fucking evil.
You clearly don't know your history.
Oh, and the Canadians matched the vibe. But without the chemical warfare.
@@sc0ttishnutj0b75 Every nation willing to draft their youth, in the tens of thousands, into a confusing total war for motives other than the defence of territorial sovereignty is evil.
00:41 "Oh mother... Fokker-"
Lol
Smart
When you have apparently impenetrable armor, but then you remember you're the main character anyways, so you strip out of it.
Standing in one place firing a gun, yeah you could wear 100 lbs of armor. Running with it is a problem though.
@@denisl2760 I mean he was doing exactly that in the first act, with an even bigger gun than what he picks up in act 2
Its actually sad that after they fought them and many devastating lost to them, they later join the people they fought in its 2nd biggest meat grinder
we were fighting austrian not german in ww1
@@LoSpartanoItaliano mostly, at caporetto the german division wiped the italians from the montain and at Monte Grappa germans also participated
@@LoSpartanoItalianoWasn't the German empire in the central powers along with Austria hungary? I'm sure there were some battles were germans were sent but anyway what do you call a group of germs? Germany
Well yeah, because in WW1 Italy got nothing out of it. All the losses for nothing. And that pissed them off, somewhat like with Germans and Weimar Republic (not even hyperinflation but just general societal shift, you'd feel right at home if you're a modern liberal American who can speak German).
@@-WarCriminal-22...and you would have to be a liberal to understand it?....dude do me a favor and save your opinions on what is going on till the election. No one wants to hear your nonsense argument.
The game is wonderful, but the plot armor is so effective
Made funnier by the fact he was wearing literal armor and not just a field uniform
This is even sadder when you study about the Italian Front in WW1.
"White friday, I'll take the stairway to heaven.
I'm sky high when I die, I'll be immortal.
Forever, I never, I wo t return to
Blood mountain, I am the soldier of heaven.-"
o7
bf1 had just a way of telling stories about war in such an emotional way. Masterpiece
This was my favorite part of this campaign i felt like a one man army
What game?
@@Acetyebaseballkid battlefield 1 when you play as the Italian in the campaign
This reactivated a repressed memory.
Says the man with a clown on avatar. Lol
arditi armor was good and all but it wasn't impenetrable
Keep in mind this is a soldiers perspective he probably didn't want to frighten his child
Complete nonsense, the Arditi fought without armor. Only then did they become the feared shock troops.
I sorta expected that from an arcade shooter
Got an expert here
@@armorist_8712 Bro that armor Is not going tò stop a Plane machinegun
i still don’t understand why he took it off, it didn’t exactly get a catastrophic failure
he was just hit by a plane lol, the armor was very heavy. He took it off so he could move
@@moewboiiiiiiiiiii1405It didn't look that heavy when he took it off.
@@Trebor74ahh yes trying moving heavy steel after you were knocked to the ground and out of breath
Even if it was broken, he could have kept just the breastplate and he’d still increase his survival chances by a lot
Gameplay. They didn't want you to have it while you just ran around, plus that would mean a whole bunch of specific effects and animations would have to be made just for that. Not cost-effective.
You massacre the enemy unit showing no mercy realizing your friend is dead..
‘War is hell, War makes men mad’😢
Valiant Hearts mentioned
@@napatthananthongprame5678 yea 😔😢
True, but video games aren't so bad 😆
@@ralfybaby you’re but it makes u upset. When the campaign cames to ended.
Actually most of not all the armour he wears is factual,usually used by Arditi stormtrooper style troops or combat engineers.
Yes it could stop low velocity hits from pistols,rifle bullet ricochets,slower flying shrapnel but not direct hits from rifles or machine guns.
What about small aircraft's
Back when battlefield was cared for
I gotta say, storm of steel, much more of a ptsd machine.
i remember trying to beat this part when I was young it was so hard
My "when I was young" was medal of honour underground on playstation 1 lol
@@MrRedeyedJediYou start to realize how old we are now and how young we were then, huh? Games that had come out after I became an adult, and no longer had time, are now considered many folks' childhoods.
@MrRedeyedJedi how I would love to know how many hours I spent on that game. One of my handful of childhood go to games.👌
I remember struggling to beat ice age on the wii
This scene broke me the first time I played it, all that fighting just to find him dead, absolutely soul crushing
I can't believe bf1 is 8 years old. Had such great moments with this game
Ahh damn, here I was thinking I got my PTSD from active service, but it was the game all along 🤦
Behold, the upside down vertical Sten that hits everything but the target!
It just hit the target...
The only thing I had wrong with this, was how he immediately runs into the same trajectory of the crashing aeroplane and them removes his armor, his still useable though damaged armor, and later picks up a skin and bones sub-machine gun from the rubble, as if it didn’t get damaged so badly that it was “trash” like his armor, by the crash, or the fire.
That skin and bone machine gun was on the Plane, that One was in the defensive turret
@@alessandromazzini7026 I can’t imagine the person who thought that such a weapon was that would be a good defensive option, the game shows how fast it burnt through ammo, but that’s my opinion.
Heavy af metal armour I guess, that’s why he took it off.
@@nonsuspiciouscat4221 Say hello to World War One aircraft weapons. That was better than a standard issue rifle or pistol. Spits a lot more lead much faster. Until you get to the synchronisation gear, your options are either mounting a VERY limited defensive/over wing gun, or small arms, small arms were ESPECIALLY common in the early war.
Plot armor plates
It’s a video game
Battlefield WW1: no
Memefiled modern warfare WW1 : YES
I’m just going to say, the voice of the veteran and the sounds of the airplane engines just perfect
World War 1 armor was famously cumbersome, rigid, and made the wearer particularly slow. Armored Italian soldiers were mowed down at the Battle of Asiago.
No they were not… best to stop lying
@@bigmanbigman2544 the Italian film Many Wars Ago, is based on Emilio Lussu's memoir Un anno sull'altipiano ("One year on the plateau"), recounting his experiences at the Battle of Asiago. In one scene, Armored Arditi advance forward to cut holes in the Austrian line barbed wire, only to be brutally cut down.
More like Asiastop.
In reality, that armor had the same level of protection as if you would wrapped your naked body in cellophane and run across the no man's land. Even Navaho paints and chants would protect you more against the bullets.
Thats just a ridiculous exaggeration though. Yes it couldnt stop rifle or machinegun rounds, thats just for gameplay experience but it wouldve easily stopped smaller calibre rounds and more importantly shrapnel which was the biggest caused of fatalities and combat injuries. Armour like this was used in certain engagements by the Italian "Arditi" regiment and at the battles of monte grappa, one of which is depicted in game, it was used.
This is the one level I couldn’t beat as a kid, thanks for uploading
no video game can give you ptsd
White friday
I am take the
Stairway to haeven
I'm sky-high
When i die
I'll be immortal
Forever, i never
I won't return to
Blood mountain
I am the
SOLDIER OF HEAVEN
I’m still wondering, after beating the Italian campaign in battlefield, why bro took off his armor
I litteraly clicked on this video without knowing it was about Battlefield 1 while playing it lmao
WWI was built differently.
War can be so brutal, so sad, and yet there are good reasons why we fight wars.
the implications of these stories always strike me as odd. dude has been looking for his brother, finds him dead and it is played as a tragedy, yet how many people died by the dudes hands in the 14 minutes this story took place in. i counted 60. something something ludo narrative dissonance
I mean... killing the enemy is one thing, but losing your brother is another thing
@@thesittingacheroraptor7565 you are missing the point. how many brothers/sons/family fathers did he kill in this short amount of time? how much suffering did he inflict on others just as they inflicted on him here? Yet that angle does not get brought up whatsoever.
@@eccomi21 fair enough, lets just pretend this is him just not caring about the enemy when retteling the story
@@eccomi21Chi se ne frega dei cani austro ungarici morti? Un soldato del regio esercito all'epoca se ne sarebbe infischiato e per eccellenti motivi.
I think that can be argued as the point. At the end of the level he says “who decides such things” right after he just gunned down scores of men. He contributed to the horrors of war yet he still had something to lose other than his own life.
This gives you ptsd lol. Really
Didn't give me PTSD, just makes you wonder how bad war actually is. Especially losing your fellow comrades that served with you or a closest friend that was family to you😢
Name of the video should be changed to "This gameplay will give you PTSD" feel like im watching my dad trying to play a video game
Smh Americans in the comments are salty that there’s a cool CoD character that’s not American.
Nice pfp
Nice pfp
Smh non Americans in the comments making stuff up
I'm an American and I can say Americans are always salty
1:05 dude looking like he just got out of the hair salon
Dont believ this guy even knows what ptsd is
PTSD? Apparently paintball is more dangerous, you're out after you get hit. The audio and graphics are great though.
This is the first ever game i have ever played on the xbox One. Sure, i played others on 360, but this was my first one on the xbox One. No other games or friends, so i played the campaigns over, and over, and over again.
So the planes couldn't punch through this guys armor but they could blow up the mountain side...got it.
Honestly that was a very well written emotional chapter, this whole game was well written and if you try to put yourself in the place of these soldiers during this war especially once you go through the initial scenes where you inevitably die. it's tough, especially if you take the meaning that you want to make each of these soldiers lives count, or you might turn the tide of the war.
That was my first playthrough thought but obviously the game is not written to predict what would have happened if axis won... like Wolfenstein
I played this game many years ago and completely forgot about the ending. No PTSD. watched this again, still no PTSD.
I keep expecting a mech to walk out of the fog, Iron Harvest style.
Humans wearing fully covered armor looks better then without wearing fully covered armor
Fun fact, in real life the italians had divisions in the first waves who were suited up in metalic knight like armor, which they thought to be bullet proof. Which they were not and just made their troops have extreme difficulties in moving and slaughtered by machinegun fire
Dad telling his story when he was young:
What actually happened: 😃
What grandpa tells about his story when he was young: 😃
What actually happened:
Nothing is PTSD except PTSD. Don't underestimate the danger of actual PTST by using this word to express your frustration or excitement
Every episode of the muppetshow gives u more ptsd
Apu knight of 1918
The last good Battlefield
Yes, everyone was just running around with machine guns in WW1
imagine this in vr
most probably became blackshirt after war
Wrong there was a italian association that opposed mussolini regime(see arditi dell popolo)
@@GKOYG_and_KAAF_is_epic Which one had more former veterans of arditi?
His daughter has an American accent, so he probably immigrated to the US after the war
This is hits in the feels but the ending of the last tiger from battlefield 5 hit me harder
Wait until this man discovers Valiant Hearts: Great War
We need more games like this
I loved the Bristol plane story and the Tank story and how Clyde and Wilson start off rough, then become comrades and Clyde takes a good long hard look at himself, and becomes determined to prove he's not a backstabbing, cheating coward. I especially enjoyed how Mcmanus manned up and admitted he'd lost himself and became best friends with the tank Driver Edward. I admired how their commander Townsend kept fighting to the last until his end.
I thought a giant monster was coming out of the mountain.
0:03 "Gun's firing but the bullet on the belt fed stays still" *ding*
This is a good franchise
I just now noticed the rounds dont move to feed into the gun when he was firing.
The red flashing your screen, means you're being hit with bullets. In reality; if you get shot, it's game over.
Bullet can't passed through me but not that plane
Ah yes the suppressed drum mag smg of world war 2…
this is why I forced my friend to play this campaign first. the PTSD :D
That armour is amazing..
i want that armour
Ptsd of what you didnt even go to war
I still despise this game for not giving us a war story from the centela powers' perspective. Its ww1 for christs sake not ww2 where thats a little more acceptable. Ugh!
this game was beautiful.
I was sad about this ending, but not as near as the runner ending, god I was so sad
This is just a game. I imagine It cannot be compared to a real war.
Gave me nowhere as much PTSD as the halo reach ending did
That fucking plane has ptsd as-well 0:01
I dont care what you opinion is about EA or battlefield but one thing they do fantastically is story and getting a point across
Press F for respect for the Lost Generation.
I thought this would be a dope elite skin for r6 Maestro
a man destroyed all airforce
Did the Germans even HAVE planes on the Italo-Austrian front? The Austrians HAD an air service...
War is hell.
When I played this mission in BF1 for the first time, I cried at the end.
Cause I remember how my best friend died
Such a great game
This is below easy difficulty.
I already had PTSD so yeah…
i said "wait i know this game' and then i realized
he might aswell jump off cuz he removed all his armour and stood there and ran into battle with nothing?
BF1 is fantasy or Dieselpunk at best. Far from realism. Thats what broke immersion for me. Historical Setting would have been way better.
More boring though.
Buon compleanno means happy birthday. He says it at the end. Also, title is bait.
He looks like mason from black ops
I played this mission. By the way the game is battlefield 1
The average Monte Grappa experience:
Bf1 is the best battlefield game, its hard to make an argument against it
What the frick is that gun? The ammo doesn't advance. The shells that are ejecting are not the same size. The Gun clearly has a Forword ejection ramp the empty shells are not coming out of. How is he shooting if both hands are on elevation and travers? Also, no armor you could ware would stop a bullet from an airplane.