The WORST Mario Fan Comic!!! (2K Subscriber Special)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2025
- #supermario #fancomic #review
This Video Is Made For A GENERAL AUDIENCE
Warning, This Video Contains Strong Language, Viewer Discretion Is Advised!!!
NOTE: DO NOT HARASS ANYONE FOR MY OPINION!!!
Two Thousand Subscribers!!! Thank you all for helping get this far. This calls for a celebration, and what better way to celebrate my success than by raging at someone else's failure.
Follow Me On
Twitter
@Jay_Skeletyn
And On
Intagram
jayskeletyn
Super Mario Bros
Owned By Nintendo
All Other Clips And Comics Belong To Their Respective Owners
Music
Paper Mario Sticker Star OST
By: Taro Kudo
SpongeBob Creature From The Krusty Krab
By: Matt Black
Little King Story OST
By:Yutaka Minobe
Good Fan-Comics/Series:
Nintendrawer
www.deviantart...
Flower Crown By DemonyRichy
tapas.io/serie...
sarahsketchesluigi
www.instagram....
MikisArt94
x.com/MikisArt...
ilikeicecoffee
x.com/ilikeice...
Ethantendo
x.com/ETendo64
GhostingWix
x.com/Ghosting...
Nintendo High By Foozle
/ @foozle
I redact my statements made at 27:12 - 27:55 and at 37:00 - 37:05 because I see those points are no longer accurate. (Who knew that all I had to do was talk to decent people with different opinions.)
It's okay, Jay. We still see why you don't like the Rosalina x Daisy subplot in Chapter 2 and how artists being inspired by it didn't help. Good video nonetheless and happy 2k subscribers
Can you cover fnaw
You should have thought of that first, Mr skeleton.
Domado
@jayskeletyn No one cares about your harassment disclaimer, dude.
“It’s my beef, not yours” is something that needs to be said more often to the internet.
Agreed
the type of hating i respect ngl
But saying, the word beef in any capacity makes me hungry
Its need to also be followed more often
I mean yeah, i would judge his opinion but overall i respect it because opinions are valid.
Three Little Princesses should have just ended after the first chapter.
The first chapter would honestly make for a good animated short adaptation.
I honestly thought it did lol, never knew there was three chapters until today
Oh, so the biggest problem with this comic as it went too longing gotten a bit thinned out OK 👍🏻
Agreed.
This comic was actually my childhood
There was a dub of it when Rosalina met the two others, but I can understand the issue
I remember the sleepover getting a dub
Yeah I remember a channel that had a dub of the first chapter, it also did a dub of the super Mario adventures comics.
My exact childhood oh my god
Oh yeah, I am recalling all this too
i agree with every other points but i think rarepair shippers are fine as long as they're not harmful and the point of stereotyping tomboys was a bit of a stretch
making a fanfic to write rosalina as a creepy stalker is example of harmful
Also non of this needs to be canonical lmao
That ain't Peach, Daisy, and Rosalina. It's their evil doppelgangers Nectarine, Daffodil, and Rosalina #2.
How about "Rottin-lina"?
@@mariosonic9153Rosalina #2 is infinitely funnier than trying to actually give her a name. I think it should be kept.
@@OpiupAlmaManiac k
Or "Elsa"
@@OpiupAlmaManiac Nah, just Rosalina Two
They are people who hate roselina as a playable charcter? In my opinion rosalina as a playable character is cool
Well, I respect Jay's opinion that he hates Rosa as playable, and as a character. I always find Rosalina a cool character, but the author did made Rosa extremely dirty NGL.
@tasmanianmarsupial1646 I agree with you! (This is Barnett. btw, i wasn't expecting you to be here!)
@@Gemz-wh9zb Ay! I didn't know you were here, too!
There are Mario fans who hate Rosalina because they feel like her design is too "fanservicey" for a series like Mario (completely neglecting Pauline who's been consistently portrayed as very attractive in-universe).
@@AluminumFusion22 You do make a fair point.
If you want the worst fan fictions then look up loud house revamped
Sonichu
@sonicexe66613 the loud house revamped tops sonichu the conic because it's longer then the bible
@@landaclay9331 Jesus Christ (no pun intended)
@@landaclay9331Loud House Revamped may be longer, but Sonichu is way worse…
@fernandodavidpaezcontreras6586 oh yea definitely just the backstory makes it worse
If you consider this "the worst deviantart comic" then hunny, you gotta a big storm coming
Yeah, like his sample size _must_ be lower than a snake's balls.
Well, he appears to also find "All of JaviSuzumiya's 'Content'" to be trash, if the last bit if the video is to be believed, so I guess he may be aware of... _that_ comic.
@@ArendAlphaEagle well it's kinda unnecessary for him to call the artist of the comic such names when all he did is wright some nintendo characters diffrently. If someone wants to make fan content of a nice sweet character as a greedy jelous bitch then they are free to do so.
Especially since there are much much worse fan comics out there
Bro speaking facts.
@@Goat81093 Didn't he say in the beginning all his anger was belated for entertainment value
Funny that in chapter 1 of The 3 Little Princesses you said Peach Daisy and Rosalina act like Spongebob Patrick and Squidward considering both groups have the same color scheme pink yellow and blue
I didn't realize till now
If people can ship Jack Frost and Elsa, people can ship Daisy and Rosalina. Who cares if they've never interacted? That's never stopped people before and it's not going to stop them now.
Honestly yeah, as long as the ship isn't pedophilic or incestuous, I don't see the issue
"your ship will never be canon" like yeah, unironically it's entertaining to ship characters that haven't even interacted, damn, Rebecca sugar herself made entire spicy doodles of crazy ships with her characters like Pearl and Greg, and even Rose x Bismuth(even though the canon ship is Greg x Rose) and even Sadie x amethyst (even though Sadie has a partner)
And even crackships, people unironically ship characters from other completely different franchises that would never interact like Pearl x Rick Sanchez, William Afton x emperor Belos, I even have my own crackships
Said a lesbian woman of color.
@@valentinaodette1463 And then there’s the real people fics…
@@justin2308 yeah that too
*The best part of “The 3 Little Princesses”* was when the princesses said "IT’S 3 LITTLE PRINCESSING’ TIME!!!” and 3 Little Princessed all over those Koopas
Your video was overall good but I have a few things I wanna bring up in regards to the shipping section. First of all, yes if you ship something canon that’s fine if it’s your favorite. However, non toxic fans who ship something that is not canon even with a canon ship already established is also fine. It’s just something that gives them joy and they like to write/draw about it like RarePairs and OC x Canon ships (I’m mainly referring to those and not actual problematic ships). Second, Multishipping does not condone nor is meant to condone Cheating. It’s basically stating that you support more than one ship because you see the possibility in both ships. As a Multishipper myself, this just rubbed me the wrong way a bit. Other than those two factors, I think the shipping part is spot on.
I have 2 opinions on this video.
1, I like your points, every character is misrepresented that these comics would likely fall into a parody. Rosalina stalking being an afterthought is definitely something that should have been addressed, (I doubt it was intended since the warm lights suggest otherwise)
2, I know Twitter isn’t a place of positivity, but taking fan-made content thats made for fun of a fictional franchise so strictly serious is unnecessary. Users who do so are doing it for fun even if their logic of going against canon seems hypercritical. Deviating from the source material ain’t my cup of tea either, but it’s not worth having malice against those who don’t.
@@ryanlee5512 You're definitely right about that
HOLD UP. So you’re telling me that Nintendo took down Yuzu, Ryujinx, and a lot of other cool fan projects while 3 Little Princesses is still being sold WITH CHARACTERS OWNED BY NINTENDO?! That is the biggest load of BS.
I was today years old when I learned that it wasn’t a one-shot.
Allow me to join you.
Same here
Same bro
Yeah, me too.
Can i join in?
Notice how Mario specifically wanted a vacation away from the princess all the way back in chapter 1. And with the newer chapter’s portrayal of Peach being not so favorable…
Did he know? If so, does this make Mario the smartest character in the comic?
Wow, I've never thought of that. This is totally true!
Wow, that actually did aged well, in Super Mario Odyssey no less!
I like the comic, but I never heard people actually talk about it despite its popularity, so let me hear your take on it
@@kendjicornely6401 Thank you, and if you like the comic despite my complaints, that's completely fine. I can't control your opinion
Although I will admit now that I think about the peach personality and the issues between dasiy and rosalina, you were definitely right to call that out now that I'm thinking about it
@@jayskeletyn
Honestly props to you for not being toxic about this. I think you're being a bit hyperbolic when you say it's the _worst_ since, y'know, there's redeeming qualities (though to be fair you did later say it was the worst popular one, which is a fair assessment), but I can definitely understand why it's your least favorite.
Also wow, I had no idea the creator of T3LP was this much of a [dolphin noise].
Thank goodness.
Sorry if what I said was a bit hyperbolic as you said
Ehh, once you read Dipper Goes to Taco Bell, everything else seems tame. This isn’t a flex btw, I let my curiosity get the best of me and I regret it
Or Bench Tails.
Or My Immortal.
Or Shrek is Love, Shrek is Life.
Or Phineas and Ferb So Busted.
Or Sonic goes to High School.
Or anything Mega Man x Roll.
@@supreme-ss777 PLEASE tell me you didn’t actually read all of those.
@@supreme-ss777as a Megaman fan, that last thing you said was a fucking jumpscare
@@justin2308I read Phineas and Ferb So Busted. It starts out typically normal, but then Phineas and Ferb get grounded after being busted by Candace, they get revenge on her with a prank that goes horribly wrong, Ferb is the only one that feels guilt, and Phineas and Isabella learn something from Candace and Jeremy and start to…do things, and become more aggressive towards Ferb (who did nothing wrong) and then out of nowhere, Phineas dies during a bungee jumping accident and his death is explained in graphic detail.
Yeah, it’s pretty bad.
i just read the whole thing. genuinely WTF?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
Super Crown: *fuses the three princesses*
I don't think that's how fusions work.
I just came up with this, but what if the whole "Retro Daisy" arc was more like Return of the Raggedy Android from My Life as a Teenage Robot? Daisy accepts the more ladylike persona on a day where Peach and Rosalina are busy, but the alter-ego refuses to release her grasp, and the other girls catch on and try to help their friend.
I like that idea
A lot of people, myself included, liked and still like Rosalina because she actually had a story to her. And in a mainline non-RPG Mario game no less. Be mindful that, for a lot of people, Daisy (and Waluigi) just... showed up for no rhyme or reason. And for even more, Mario just decided to go and save some other princess that wasn't Peach. Rosalina had a backstory which a lot people do get invested in, so her popularity isn't unfounded. Nintendo took notice, capitalized on it for as long as they could before then giving Daisy the limelight.
And its not like Daisy was forgotten, since Mario Party and Mario Kart still has her as a base character. And those games are still quite popular.
But Daisy has been in the Mario series way longer than Rosalina as she did appear in Super Mario Land. She does have stories, her own kingdom and everything but it was barely explored. That's the point, her character or her origins were never explored or took advantage of. She literally became only playable in a mainline mario game this year, whereas Rosalina was playable way back in Super mario 3D world and Smash. Obviously, Rosalina may be far more interesting but that doesn't mean Daisy was treated fairly as if she just appeared out of nowhere.
The first chapter was my childhood. I grew up with it and it holds a special place in my heart. Chapters 2 and 3...yeah I'll just ignore those.
24:11
In early 2D mario games, you would just immediately become mini mario even if you had a fire flower like in the first Super Mario Bros.
Super Mario world, super Mario 3 (i think), for example
In the Japanese version of Mario 3, you immediately shrink when hit while using the fire flower
it's really frustrating how this video went from "i don't like this fan comic because it mischaracterizes daisy, peach, and rosalina" to "YOU CAN'T SHIP ANYONE IF IT'S NOT EXPLICITLY CANON"
like the comic is hot garbo ngl but i don't think the tirade on why dasilina is an invalid ship because it's "not canon" was really necessary or constructive. ultimately tho i do respect the dedication that went into making a 41 minute video on mario twitter drama. congrats on 2k billy bones
@bald_peter I mean, I did redact the statement made at 27:12 - 27:55 but overall, I guess that's just how the cookie crumbles.
@@jayskeletyn But seriously, what were you thinking?
@@Mohammed1000real That the ship isn't good
a ship doesn't need to be canon for ppl to enjoy it. that's kind of what a ship is 🤷♀️
also how could he have sent his audience after you if he deliberately did not name you in the tweet 😭
@PeachyCatty Wait a minute, I recognize you from Twitter. Also, he made that soon after I made my criticism and deleted it after I apologized. No one else was criticizing the comic that I could find, and he still told his audience to go after critics. Whether directed at only me or not, you can not defend that behavior.
@@PeachyCattyHe didn't need to make the tweet in the first place. Dude is a grown up adult
As a lesbian, yeah I'm gonna be real, this comic feels like "guy who wants to goon to lesbians because they are hot" and not actually wholesome. There are plenty of femslash fics of Mario characters who don't mind what is and isn't canon (my personal favorite being the Vivian/Goombella shipping,) that are healthy and don't feel icky at all. This dude is… weird, lol.
As for being OoC, I've read a lot of Touhou doujinshi in my time that do similar things and wish they got more flack for it. I hope you plan on looking at more bad Mario webcomics and fan-fiction, such as Daisy Falls Apart.
>Touhou
So real so based
@@theincrediblegeneral5135 Pc98 Marisa pfp spotted, ultra based.
@@graveyardsmash2711 I love mystic square
Oof i feel you with the Touhou one, the characters being always portrayed as villanous in crossovers and as pathethic loverstruck girls when there's a male character (ignoring that in canon the girls don't give a crap about romance) and not to mention the champion of mischaracterization: KKHTA.
though i do like when they expand the personalities of the characters, even if they do take some liberties witht their origins
@@ironmaster6496 KKHTA is actually the one I like. I'm talking about stuff like IOSYS and Innocent Key where it's blatant fetish fuel doujinshi.
I respect your opinions, but I think you’re taking this whole comic too seriously.
Thank you I thought I was the only one who dot that. Like I understand some of his Criticism especially I guess about the ship and I definitely understand his problems with the creator, But everything else seemed a bit much
@@kingj9664He literally said at the beginning that he's acting mad for entertainment.
@@fernandodavidpaezcontreras6586 Oh, I'm most definitely am
Yeah, especially that quick mock to Erma's mom saying that she's unfaithful to her husband, despite the art is not canon, was made in a wholesome way to say that things will go ok like a heartwarming way, and of course, is was not added next to the official comic like other art, which yeah, is very petty of him to do that
@chicofnaf7114 I just thought it was funny.
35:07 WHAT!? 50 bucks? For an IP they don’t own? Wow Im shocked thats allowed? Is there some sort of legal loophole I don’t know about?
He probably calls it fair use, but I doubt that's valid
Ask that to the guy who sold Starved Eggman for $300
on an unrelated note, MAN YOU USED SPONGEBOB CREATURE FRON THE CRUSTY CRAB OST!!!!
ITS SOUNDTRACK IS SO FIRE
I knew someone would catch it
I’ve been waiting to hear your thoughts on this fan comic ever since you did the super Mario Bros review
i really hope this isn't strike down by the creator, this is an actual good analysis of my childhood (at least the first chapter)
My only problem with this comic (which wasn't mentioned) is that it never provided a reason why N64 Daisy was a bad thing, other than a forced allegory. In fact, this comic went out of its way to tell us that Daisy was happier being N64 Daisy ( and to make matters worse, she was actually in character to post-GCN Daisy, the definitive Daisy.) What Yves should have done was make it so N64 Daisy was True Daisy (which seems to line up with his opinion apparently), and have Daisy be the one to confront Peach.
FINALLY! Someone mentions Nintendo High in on of thier video! I'm so glad to know I'm not the only one who likes it! Can't wait to see your review!
I like the ice king joke with daisy but that’s probably just because i love adventure time. Also nice to see your a fellow Tomas fan.
Was honestly looking forward to this one, I remember reading Chapter 1 as a little kid and thinking it was alright, but looking back on the series as a whole, there's definitely a lot of improvements that could have been made for sure
I love the fact you used a skeleton for your channel and the fact there’s so many emotion in those skeleton pictures
Why does any of this need to be canonical
The spectrum does strange things to people...
I was introduced to T3LP on a youtube comic dub recommendation one day in the early 2010s. I watched it and really enjoyed it, when the sequels came out I was surprised because I had no clue that a sequel even existed in the first place, only to find out they were both recent. I watched it and kinda liked it for the most part since I'm a hardcore Daisy fan. But years later, just a few months ago I decided to watch the 3 comic dubs once more when I remember it existed and it became instantly clear to me that 2 and 3 fall flat in comparison to the first one. The first one is a classic Mario fan comic, despite its flaws I really love the sleepover trope in TV shows and thought this was a close *enough* representation of it all. But 2 and 3 miss the mark completely and I despise it for that, I never even finished the third one until my rewatch for a reason I don't remember. So yeah, if I'm ever gonna revisit this series I think I'll just stick with the original.
I was going to make a small rant of, while not completely logical, there was still something understandable with Daisy's whole jealousy thing
But then I thought, "Wait, if this chapter is meant to be commentary on how Rosalina became more prominent than Daisy for a time, why is Peach the one getting all jealous? Shouldn't Rosalina be more jealous in this scenario if it is meant to be some form of meta commentary on her taking Daisy's spotlight?"
Wait a minute, you're actually right. I'm shocked that didn't cross my mind.
But no, shoehorning in a dumb ship for no reason was much more important than having a plot that actually makes sense.
It's odd... I don't personally agree with your opinion and yet I still find this video very entertaining, good work 👍
It's being able to agree to disagree, it's important to be able to disagree on things and still be civil (also the video objectively has rather well done production)
@@jpgartist110 i think ultimately a persons points matter more than production value, i dont really agree with most of the points in this video but i also think thats fine because he still manages to present his arguments in a way thats understandable and i still get why he feels the way that he feels despite me disagreeing
You think that’s bad! I bet you didn’t know there existed a fanfic that ships Luigi and Wendy O. Koopa that is 65 chapters.
Ew
There was one in the past where Funky Kong and Daisy fell in love but the artist deleted it.
ISN’T WENDY CANONICALLY 16!?
Resturant Wendy or Gravity falls Wendy?
I bet you 100$ that was inspired by that one scene from the Super Mario Bros. 3 cartoon
I only recall Chapter 1 (the sleepover) as a thing; read that YEARS ago, wasn't aware there was more made like a decade later. I thought the sleepover was fine, as its own thing. The other two chapters didn't need to be made, if this critique indicates anything.
Also, you've got an interesting take on who the three main Mario girls are. Personally, I never really saw Toadette as part of the dynamic because... well, first of all, she's not a human, and second, her primary colors are the same as Peach.
My idea, personally, especially in recent years, is that there's FOUR of them: Peach, Daisy, Rosalina... and _Pauline._ Pauline's been appearing more and more recently in spinoff titles ever since her resurgence in Super Mario Odyssey, so I thought it'd make sense to let her join the group (plus it doesn't make Rosalina a "third wheel" anymore, for lack of a better term). In addition, back in the "let's forget about Daisy" era from Nintendo, I remember a Nintendo Girls puzzle image from the StreetPass PuzzleSwap game, which includes Peach, Rosalina and Pauline as well as two Zeldas (and this was back when Pauline's only significant roles were in Mario vs Donkey Kong), so I suppose it's not ENTIRELY unfounded.
I swear everyone was all Bowsette this, Bowsette that.. REAL FANS stand with Bowletta
Bowletta is at least _canon._ (And frankly, Cackletta in Bowser's body is more appealing)
I only seen the first, somewhat the second and third, and I didn't mind it as a child, but you're criticism is your criticism regardless if people like it or not, what an interesting video, you're doing great man!
I enjoyed this one when i was younger, but i thought it was a one shot 😭
I remember watching comic dubs of the first chapter when I was younger. wasn't expecting it to get worse over time lol.
I remember having fond memories of this comic, but yeah I can see the problems.
Also this can be bought for $50???? How in the world has Nintendo NOT strike that down???
well, theirs one thing to say: "what did they do to my girls"
Can't believe Peach outsmarted what it seems to be God in her universe, although Rosalina can get pushed around and belittled in the spin-offs idk.
Ever since I found this channel, I’ve been waiting for your review on this comic so this is kinda fan service in a way…
i just came across this vid and thought "oh hey, i saw this comic before." and, lemme be clear, i loved this comic, but i DO see where you're coming from. BACK IN YE OLDEN DAYS, i was a stupid child back then and didn't see the problems with the comic (except peach's character being butchered), but now that u pointed it out...yeaaaaa it's pretty bad. ESPECIALLY part 2.
the art style of part 2 and 3 is slightly better imo, part 1's style is good tho! (also, i may be new here, but congrats on 2k subs!)
Nice video well done and congrats on 2k subscribers I loved this video and might be my favorite video from you and as they say in Super Mario Bros Wonder
WONDERFUL
i would crumble if someone compared my art to ralph breaks the internet while i also fully agreeing to that statement
btw i absolutely love this over the top hyperbole commentary but still somewhat respectful content (i yearn AVGN) will be staying for more :)
Speaking of ships, the person who drew the art at 29:44 ships Rosalina and Pauline, which i honestly don't mind
@@bluehat6109 I know. I actually really like his main works. (To bad he's kind of a prick sometimes)
What you mean a prick?
@@jayskeletynwhat you mean a prick?
@@jayskeletyn Ey, not cool.
I only ever read the first chapter out of boredom, and I really don't get why people think it's anything special. Like, I can appreciate it as a relic of internet humour but the whole comic just has this juvenile randem funnyface XD deviantart comic humour that was everywhere in fan comics in the 2000s to early 2010, which was awkward to read since these characters are supposed to be adults but act like they're 12. I appreciate your comments on how mischaracterised the princesses are (glad I'm not the only one who thinks Daisy isn't a tomboy), but I feel it's a problem with the overall fandom that this comic is a mere symptom of. When you spend more time engaging with fanworks than the source material one's vision of the characters can definitely become warped, especially with how much more fancontent there is compared to canon material.
What I don't understand is your reasons for hating the Daisy x Rosalina ship in general. Yes it is portrayed terribly in this comic, and you've had unpleasant experiences with a couple shippers, and I can see how that might impact how you conceive of the ship, but you can't condemn every shipper or shipwork based on one bad portrayal of it since every ship will have bad pieces of content for it like how every fandom will have bad content in general. The ship isn't inherently problematic or toxic. While I don't ship this pairing myself, people who do haven't done anything to deserve the hatred you've laid on them as a whole. You actually come off as more out-of-touch than the "deluded" people you're flaming. The overwhelming majority of these shippers know it's not canon and never will be canon, they just think that these characters' personalities would make for a fun pairing and they like speculating how they would interact if they were to get into a relationship, and it's interesting to bounce ideas and see different people's interpretations of this pairing. After all, a lot of fanworks are built off of putting characters in what-if scenarios and the discussions surrounding that, and shipping for both canon and non-canon is just an extension of this principle. Heck, Luaisy gets so little official interactions and development it's practically a fanship since the dynamic you see in fanworks is building off the interpretations fans have come up with as opposed to anything we've actually seen in-game. Also, I'm not sure if you realise this, but no one is obliged to like Daisy x Luigi or any canon ship for that matter. Fandom is supposed to be fun so if someone has more fun drawing Daisalina than Luaisy and isn't promoting anything harmful, then let them be. It doesn't automatically mean that they think Luaisy isn't canon or that they hate Luigi, their preferences are just different from yours. This purist and limiting mindset you have towards shipping isn't constructive for anybody and only makes the fandom experience worse for those who already have to deal with these comments.
I'd be interested in that Nintendo High review and hearing why you think it's so good. I've watched every episode at least twice and writing-wise I'd say it has some good moments at best but is mostly just okay to poor. If you see this, hopefully this comment has given you a different perspective to consider for that review before you scream at viewers for daring to see potential in Waluigi x Rosalina.
What does constitute a tomboy, exactly? Since Daisy actually isn't one?
@@chiebukachibee-zoraedu If someone were to make a list of tomboyish attributes you'd end up with things like being rough and tough, enjoying or not minding getting dirty, having more labour-inducing hobbies like woodworking or camping or sports, having more traditionally masculine likes such as cars and monster trucks, video games and comics and action movies, barbeque and legos, and having what society considers masculine traits like being messy and putting little effort into one's appearance. Basically tomboys are defined by the fact that their interests are mostly in opposition to feminine things, so for the most part they have little to no interest in make up, fashion, shopping, romance, and other stereotypical stuff like that.
Obviously a girl doesn't have to fit all of these characteristics and dislike all girly things in order to be a tomboy, but the thing with Daisy is that while her character descriptions say she's a tomboy, she doesn't actually have any tomboyish qualities besides being sporty. She's far more conventionally feminine than she is conventionally masculine - she wears jewellery, like flowers, shopping [Mario Kart Tour Promo Art, and her team name with Toadette in Mario Part 6 is "Shopping Buddies"], does cheerleading [Mario Sports Mix] and most of her Mario Kart Tour alts are very feminine presenting. So I think calling her a tomboy is a stretch.
@@invadercat3505 okay, I see. Thank you 😊
He did make a comment saying he retracts what he said about Rosalina x Daisy
@@agentblackbird9435 yeah, I just read it
The worst Mario Fan comic…
…And apparently it’s not Motherfucking Mario.
Just like all the spinoffs games, nobody plays the main character (usually) lol.
For me it's usually easy to convince me why someone in general wouldn't like something.
Person: I really don't like this.
Me: But Why?
Person: I think it's Stupid
Me: I immediately get where you're coming from.
I actually think peaches portrayal as a character is actually done on purpose. You see, even though peach is not portaid as a controlling, stupid, and selfish person in Canon. That's how a huge amount of the mario fanbases meme culture portrays her. The joke/meme of her being a soulless damsel in distress that evilly inslaves toads to do her bidding is quite a common one amongst the meme culture of the online mario fanbase. So I'm pretty sure he was trying to replicate that meme/joke perspective of peach rather than trying to make her authentic to the games
Honestly, I wouldn't mind Rosalina being pushed again as a main heroine. Though yeah, I do think that it shouldn't come at the expense of Daisy. And it's good that more recent titles seem to finally be giving Daisy the attention she deserves. And your rant on Peach's characterization is spot on. Peach is one of the kindest and most selfless characters in the series and it does honestly irk me when people write her out of character and portray her as a selfish and egotistical prick, which is the polar antithesis of what Peach is.
This was an actually pretty interesting critique! 3LP is a comic I grew up with since I was young, and was also one of the folks that was hyped to see it getting a sequel comic. I was also one of the folk who found the sequel just fairly entertaining, and I wouldn't lie if I said I had rose tinted goggles on for most of the plot and easter eggs. Although the opinions about who should be main cast and who should side cast I don't agree with all that much (let all the characters have their fun and all, ...and also a rosa fan who'd eat anything they shove her in) The critiques about characterization are valid points as someone who enjoys a good characterization myself! Overall thoughts on the comic is still "its a fun ride but could've gone better." And also big respect for you, even when not liking a certain thing and certain folks, you still gave them a bit of credit and shout outs. Overall, pretty healthy critique.
(You already cleared this statement up but I guess my overall thoughts about the ship in particular is... Daisy & Rosa is a fun pairing, I do like the calm and cheery dynamic where one shows the other how to have fun and open up more and a sorta wacky way. With this thought, I at least can come up with more ideas than whatever the waluigi and rosa ship is cookin... I'm not sure what theyre dynamic would be. Anyway yeah those are my extra two cents)
But why is this comic so mean to Luigi tho?
Also based on your community post for this video.
Mario: “Why are Peach and I so rude in this? I would always love to bring her and Luigi on a vacation.”
Luigi: “Am I really that much of a chatterbox?”
Rosalina to is one of those "I like my interpretation of the character more" its just mainly the lore I gave her, her personality and just the overall universe proably because when you write a story as a hobby you have more freedom for your brain to work in my opinion at least
Edit: Just a small edit to give people an idea of how I write the characters. I admit I like King Boo acting like an Interpretation of what King Boo would act like if he behaved like Mark Hamill's Joker and even talked and laughed like him
Good video, but I have a couple criticisms of it.
Peach doesn't have to have the same personality as in the games, especially since it isn't an official comic. It's perfectly okay if you don't want her to be different, but the creator of the comic doesn't have to agree with that preference.
You keep saying there's a lot of "Family Guy humor" in the comic but you use the same example every time. That gives off the impression that there's actually only one joke like that.
omg this is the first time I've seen someone mention Flower Crown on youtube! How exciting!!
28:16 bro said there was no chemistry and then gave 3 examples 💀
@@Da_Homie_Don Honestly, I could've mentioned that, but it slipped my mind. Funny how they can shoot their own argument in the foot like that.
WDYM 3 LITTLE PRINCESSES IS THE WORST MARIO FAN COMIC?????????
This comic turned Rosalina into Cia from Hyrule Warriors. (Except Cia actually faced consequences)
I’m a fan of the first chapter, but didn’t really care about the other two. Glad to see you bring light to the subject.
Well, it’s good to see Daisy again in her old art style
I had only seen the first chapter, and I'm glad that was the case.
Woah, blast from the past. I totally forgot this comic existed, but remembered it from back in the day! I cant wait to have my entire opinion reformed on this comic :D
huh, i never knew this comic got revived.
kinda wish i still didn't.
You know not all fan fictions have to like the source material they can be there own story that includes the characters and stories they can be changed for the reason of the fictions
That what's im saying
Did he forget this isn't cannon
Doesn't have to be like cannon characters
Random rewrite idea I got near the 32 minute mark that would make Roaisy (IDk what the shipname is) better would be, and hear me out on this
Rosa is attracted to classic daisy at first, being more polite and funloving than the previous Daisy from chapter 1, but as she hangs out with her more, the cracks start to appear, and it comes to a head with the seperation, but then Daisy finally achieves her true self, a balance of her modern and classic, and this is when Rosa realizes, Daisy has become the best version herself, and she likes it, and at the end maybe have a stinger where she asks Daisy to hang out, mana e mana, not only tying back to the intro of chapter 2 but also fulfuilling Daisy's wish in a healthier manner
I still like Luigi x Daisy a bit more cause, ya know there's more to go off of, but I think if that was how the comic went Daisalina would but a more likable ship
As terrified as I am to ask (I enjoyed the "Three Princesses" dubs but like your review), I'm curious. If you seen them, what are your thoughts on NintenDrawer and "Super Mario Adventures" (like "Driven Miss Daisy")? Which series do you prefer?
@@jenneacubero1036 I love Nintendrawer
I will say this the three little princesses is pretty much a mixed fan comic but if you want a worst fan comic of all time you should see it's not your fault (a loud house fan comic) which is a loud house fan comic with topics that are so messed up that it makes you ask why would the creator put that in.
Also Paper Mario Sticker Star is a good game and I can understand it has flaws with the story but it got an amazing soundtrack and a pretty unique battle system in my opinion.
@@miguelescobedo5112 Why do you think I hate Javi so much? That comic makes me sick, but I'm never gonna talk about it.
I don’t understand the hate. Isn’t this supposed to be a parody? I love the comic and its story.
I also don't understand the hate; it seems like people forget that this is just fiction and everyone has the right to do what they want. I mean, people have the right to not like his comic, but all this hate is really unnecessary?? I know how that comic means a lot to the artist, so yeah... definitely doesn't deserve all this hate.
I don't to insult you, but if you believe that this is the worst Mario fan comic, then you never readed Motherfuckin' Mario.
But don't worry if you never heard about, is a little lost media...
Got to say, I’m glad I found your account again! This was well made. Can’t wait for the future videos!
Tails gets trolled, is way better than this comic.
As much as I hate to admit it, I'm with ya.
The first chapter of 3 little princesses just brought back childhood.
I'm a bit confused as to how the comic could be sold. I always thought fanfiction can't be used for monetary gain.
Maybe this was possible through... bribery?
@@mysterykiddo2167I don’t think Nintendo can be bribed… *only delayed*
this comic is like modern day eeveelution squad but actually kind of readable
24:09 Depends on the game. SMB1, SMB3 (the Japanese version anyway), and SMW all revert you back to normal form whenever you get hit.
Did Jay even played the NES games?
24:03 while i understand the argument, they ARE going up against an army led by Land 1 Daisy, and if you've played that or any previous Mario titles, you'd know that getting hit regardless of powerups _always_ makes you small.
I really enjoyed this Review. Great points and good Humor. I enjoyed these comics. But you could say that Peach in chapter 2-3 could be compared to Edward in Edward Strikes out lol
I do admit, I kinda like the art style and especially the expressions, I probably might be a sucker for kind of exaggerated expressions. and kind of do like a dynamic trio it’s seeing how they interacted playoff each other, yeah I feel like if it was done with different characters it probably might help.
(yeah I think I might be a bit blinded, due to me probably wishing to make a comic series that had as a very similar concept.)
If this was an official comic series by Nintendo, then sure, you could complain about the various inconsistencies with the characters. However this was made by just a fan that took creative liberties to convey how they perceive these characters. If you have THAT big of a problem of how he portrays the characters, then why don’t you make your own comic and write them in the way that you think they should be written?
I only ever read the first chapter way back when and enjoyed it so now learning that this continued and where it went is interesting. I’m gonna read it myself before I make any opinions myself though.
Hi, first time viewer. This feels like an early 2010s rant video in a good way. I remember reading Chapter 2 and I remember thinking "why is Peach such a jerk?" in the back of my head but I also haven't read it in a while so I can't definitively say I disagree or not. I have no dog in any shipping wars cuz that's a rabbit hole I refuse to go down.
most normal mario adult
First time I’ve heard that one.
Nah, the real Mario adults are the ones getting butthurt over this video on Twitter lmao
It’s all an act my guy 3:28
I liked the first comic but I didn’t read the other two and didn’t knew that they existed. But after watching your video, I am probably not going to even bother with the other two chapters. I think the first chapter is more than enough with this comic series.
The shipping bit. I personally ship Bowuigi, but I acknowledge that it's never going to actually be cannon. It's just fun. I can't believe people try to make their crack ships cannon.
i was like "wait there's more than chapter 1 ?" honestly i was entertained enough by the first chapter (which i guess was supposed to be just one chapter) and actually since at the time i didn't know english i instead stumbled upon a french translation with background music and what i remember the most is that every time they would announce a sleepover there'd be a music for suspense and hyping up while it zoomed (and maybe some other YTP windows movie maker style edits) on their grinning faces. i haven't watched the rest of the video but i don't think i will comment anymore especially on things i haven't seen.
I ship Luigi and daisy and still headcanon them as both bisexual so I can still have lgbt rep in straight ships :). It’s a win win for me. I Also headcanon Rosalina as being aroace cuz my gurl is better doing her own thang >:)
12:39 lol that was a dig at his honour man straight devious 🤣🤣🤣
As for my actual thoughts on the comic: I think it could’ve just stayed at chapter 1 (as lots of people have already said) and idk why Yves continued it a decade later. There’s some (pretty small) things I liked about the next two chapters like some of the more minor gags from chapter 2 (like the mario party rejects shack and some of the ads in the hotel mario casino especially the amiibo bets), and chapter 3 has some pretty fun ideas imo. Stuff like an evil gb version of daisy taking over the world with old mario enemy sprites and yes, I even kind of like the big princess tri-fusion. Sure it’s stupid and completely inaccurate to the games in every way (and it is visually over designed even if I don’t think it’s a necessarily bad design) but that’s part of the reason honestly. It’s just too campy not to like. (for me at least bc I know how you feel about it)
All in all this would’ve been a better fan comic if it just didn’t decide to take itself seriously all of a sudden after 10 years. I don’t have too much of a problem with the mischaracterizations of the three princesses bc of how blank slate-ish most mario characters are which I think leaves a lot of room for different interpretations for better or for this comic. Also I think the Daisy and Rosa ship in the comic (while not being well written or well hinted at) did have some good will behind it and was kinda sweet like the works of Nintendude and KB but the shrine at the chapter 3 ending ruined it all. Anyways yeah this comic was a product of its time that should’ve just stayed that way if Yves never improved on his writing within the time he had.
Good video but you lost all credibility when you said Luigi’s Day Out sucked at 34:16 lmao (not actually tho I think it’s one of the better “Mario’s an asshole” parodies on yt but it is just as excessively edgy as stuff along the likes as Racist Mario even if I find it to be funnier and a bit more original than the former)
Small note, the word you were looking for is leeway instead of leverage at 9:00
@@PaperMario931 That’s what I get for being a C student in language
The Paper Mario Games are an alternate universe but sure ok.
But the star spirits also appeared in Mario Party... wait, what's going on?
@@Mohammed1000real Aaaaand explanation time:
In Paper Jam they sorta showed and predicted but didn’t tell this concept. Think of Ni No Kuni: Wrath of The White Witch….or Wizard of Oz if you don’t understand what I mean there. If one person lives in that regular world they live in that other magical world too. Same goes with the Universe of Paper inside the Book in Paper Jam which houses the Paper Mario Alternate Universe.
In PJ, there is a convo between Roy and Wendy Koopa that predicts the Paper Koopalings debuting in the next PM game, Color Splash one year later. Roy asks why there aren’t any paper versions of them since there seems to be of everyone else included in PJ. Wendy brushes it off as them either taking a vacation or handling important things in their world and that the regular 7 of them are more than capable of dealing with Mario Luigi and Paper Mario.
So with this concept in mind, it means there’s flesh and blood versions of the Partners in the series or any surviving baddies old or unique or new that were initially from the Paper World out there, and also Paper Versions of any new or old characters, good or bad, that are flesh and blood or regular from the regular Mario world. Maybe they both don’t need to be alive to exist separately either, since the Koopalings and both Kameks “die” in PJ yet the Paper Koopalings and Paper Kamek are back in Color Splash.
So if both separate versions in these separate worlds can live separately like Oliver without Shadar in Ni No Kuni, then there could be a real version of Bleck or Dimentio, or Grodus and the X nauts or the Shadow Queen or Cortez or King Olly out there and just are either living completely different lives, are sealed, or just haven’t struck yet.
Conversely, there could be Paper Shroobs, Paper Stuffwell and Starlow, Paper Antasma, Paper Pillo people, Paper Broodals, Paper Snow King, Paper Fawful and Cackletta, or even Paper versions of the Villains in the upcoming Brothership now that they exist! You see how this works now?
And then of course there’s the Star Spirits. Which are affected by this concept as well. Which is exactly now why they are in Paper Mario, a separate universe, and also Mario Party 5, which is in the real Mario universe. They are just two different versions of each other in 2 different worlds.
And our skelly boi here talks as if they are all the same universe in the 2020s. Yeah no. At the time of the first chapter of the comic yeah this wasn’t the case but since 2015’s Paper Jam, this is just how it works and I personally think it works fine. There ya have it. Hope this helped clear the air!
Daisy only appeared in spin offs until 2023 and everyone has her personality figured out… your point being??
@@josiahtheawkward6008 What are you talking about? A bunch of games set in a parallel universe and a bunch of in-universe spinoffs, canon or otherwise can be two completely different things. Also….when did I mention anything about Daisy exactly? I mean she isn’t in the PM universe yet officially but that doesn’t mean she doesn’t exist there considering she’s already in the main Mario universe. Live in one world and you live in the other, too.
I recommend you really read my other big reply and do your research from here if you don’t know what I mean, but long story short my point is that our skelly boi didn’t seem to know about the Paper Mario games being in their own universe and not just spinoffs so I felt the need to correct that. That’s all.
Unless you aren’t talking to me but the other fella for some reason and if that’s the case I apologize. Have a Blessed Day