1:49 When he did that sudden decrescendo on the word “peanut”, I was impressed by that! That takes a lot of vocal control to do that! He’s got good range, he hit a lot of really low chest notes there. He has a great personality. I think they made a huge mistake in rejecting him! He should have gotten a golden ticket! Plus, this is his own original song, most contestants only cover well known pop songs.
Ooooh! He was so talented! Seems you could have listened to him sing another style song! I wish the judges would read these comments. This many people raising an objection to there decision can’t all be wrong!
If he respects the music instrument of his voice, he would develop his skills and vocal technique - instead of riding around on a unicycle, playing a cello and treating his voice like a circus act.
They’ve taken a bunch of people without much talent or uniqueness, yet they let this guy go? I think he could have done something interesting on the show. What a shame.
Colescott I do wish that the judges would have asked you to sing a cover song. Please come back next year and sing a strong cover song that they can't say no to. 🙏
I know I’m VERY late to this, but, the fact that he got turned down was such a shame I mean he had everything: talent, charisma, uniqueness, and good looks too 💖 I just hope the whole world gets to know him more…
He is amazing, original and fun. He has a wonderful voice. Why couldn't they give him another song to sing and have someone like him in this competition??
They knew their chances were very low, but they did bring their Circus Act. If American Idol was around in the 1920s ...who knows how far they could have gone.
😂live the unique entrance 🎉always believe a Circus needs to travel 50 States and American Idol combined with AGT 🎉have enough as these 2 great cycling performers 🎪
I am a Portland native and he's the side of Portland people that most people don't think about when they hear the name lol. Keep Portland Weird is a real thing. Makes me homesick lol
What?!?! How could he get an immediate no from the judges?? He was talented and had a big range vocally. When he hit those low alto notes towards the end, it was a done deal for me with putting him through. That was impressive! The judges got this one wrong. 😑
I thought it was a great performance good voice they didn’t even give him a shot!!! He definitely had a voice and could control it. He probably should have went out for AGT well he could probably do better being a performer at Disneyland or broadway. I enjoyed it ☝🏽❤️🙏🏽
Hello he has a great voice , maybe his song choice was not the best but they should have asked him to sing something else, they have done it before with less talented contestants !
Now, that was different, entertaining and captivating... The guy has incredible musical talent. They should have asked if he could sing a more serious song just to see what he could do. Maybe something rockabilly. Big Mistake letting him go.
How could this not go viral? You just have to love this.
Thank you! Please check out their albums too!
My favorite so far ❤true original & made my heart sing 😮out with him, too, just like you. WOW.
The charisma is just rolling off Colescott in waves! Such talented young men, both of them!
Thank you
I love this peanut butter song, very catchy, very fun. My son is already singing it around the house lol
I will definitely listen to this audition again! 😮
thank you
Me too👍
LMFAO that was really catchy and entertaining. I honestly would say yes just for the entertainment.
😍
I actually like these judges, but they were very wrong this time.
This guy has EVERYTHING that Idol is about.
thank you!
What extraordinary, joyful, and original talent, watch out world, Rubin brothers will make your hearts smile!
Thank you!
1:49 When he did that sudden decrescendo on the word “peanut”, I was impressed by that! That takes a lot of vocal control to do that! He’s got good range, he hit a lot of really low chest notes there. He has a great personality. I think they made a huge mistake in rejecting him! He should have gotten a golden ticket! Plus, this is his own original song, most contestants only cover well known pop songs.
They wouldn't go and buy a circus cd contestants have sang songs by all three of the judges and some didn't go through who sang them but a lot did
Letting him go was a big mistake. No doubt in my mind that is versatile that many other contestants, and a lot more fun.
Yes! I was hoping he'd go through. Talented and fun!
Too wholesome for Hollyweird.
Thank you for your kind words! Glad you enjoyed it! :-)
Really who's going to go out and buy a circus cd
Ooooh! He was so talented! Seems you could have listened to him sing another style song! I wish the judges would read these comments. This many people raising an objection to there decision can’t all be wrong!
Loved watching this! So fun and entertaining. Would be a joy to watch them live!
He knows he wouldn't make it! it's for exposure! Now the world saw him and so did the judges who enjoyed his performance.
If he respects the music instrument of his voice, he would develop his skills and vocal technique - instead of riding around on a unicycle, playing a cello and treating his voice like a circus act.
They’ve taken a bunch of people without much talent or uniqueness, yet they let this guy go? I think he could have done something interesting on the show. What a shame.
Blame the American Idol producers
Colescott I do wish that the judges would have asked you to sing a cover song. Please come back next year and sing a strong cover song that they can't say no to. 🙏
YOU SHOULD HAVE LET HIM ON. WE WANT MORE.
Why, thank you! There’s more on IG under my name!
I know I’m VERY late to this, but, the fact that he got turned down was such a shame I mean he had everything: talent, charisma, uniqueness, and good looks too 💖 I just hope the whole world gets to know him more…
That was the most fun, happy, beautifulloving life performance better than all idle!!!!❤❤❤❤❤
Thank you. - Mom
Thank you so much for listening!
Somebody that talented should have been given a chance. I loved them. Reminiscent of Squirrel Nut Zipper, Cherry Popping Daddies.
Thank you!!! Please check out their albums.
Save Ferris! I love that time…wish ska would come back!
He is amazing, original and fun. He has a wonderful voice. Why couldn't they give him another song to sing and have someone like him in this competition??
The Judges don't have any vision. This guy should have been let onto Idol. He could have taken it to the next level and taken out of the boring.
I think they need to reconsider - but I'm his mom - lol
He had a great voice!!
They should have him come back and sing another song. His voice was good and when he sang deeper was also great. Bring him back
He would do great on americas got talent!
I haven't seen anyone with an upright bass since Casey Abrams back in 2011; let alone someone with a unicycle!
They knew their chances were very low, but they did bring their Circus Act. If American Idol was around in the 1920s ...who knows how far they could have gone.
This was awesome perfect jingle for Skippy, Peter Pan. Come on peanut butter companies get on this quick!
😂live the unique entrance 🎉always believe a Circus needs to travel 50 States and American Idol combined with AGT 🎉have enough as these 2 great cycling performers 🎪
This needs to be on spotify immediately.
Someone sign these two guys up! Mr. Peanut commercial a must! Or a peanut butter ad.
There are four of them altogether actually! Four Rubin Brothers!
It's a hoot made me smile
I am a Portland native and he's the side of Portland people that most people don't think about when they hear the name lol. Keep Portland Weird is a real thing. Makes me homesick lol
This song as it stands is an American classic. Spirited word play, syncopation, memorable melody and fun!
What?!?! How could he get an immediate no from the judges?? He was talented and had a big range vocally. When he hit those low alto notes towards the end, it was a done deal for me with putting him through. That was impressive! The judges got this one wrong. 😑
Judges totally wrong . The guy is fantsstic. I love it. What a shame he do not go to Hollywood.
Thank you (says Mom)
That was fun! Maybe not Idolistic but definately entertaining!😉😜😘
He'll fit right into those 1960s movies.
Why is this such a bop
They should try making some songs for children. If this was in a Yoto card I'd totally buy it!
They perform for children all the time (in hospitals, for groups of special needs kids, etc.)
HELL YEAHH! u guys killed iiiiiitt🎉
Ahhh thank you!
That was nuts.
:0)
He’s awesome and so talented!
I thought it was a great performance good voice they didn’t even give him a shot!!! He definitely had a voice and could control it. He probably should have went out for AGT well he could probably do better being a performer at Disneyland or broadway. I enjoyed it ☝🏽❤️🙏🏽
awesome. give him a ticket👍
The child in me loves loves loves this song!
Very talented! I bet he can sing anything!
So cute and very catchy!!
He might have better luck on America's got talent.
Love him
Love them.. Katies correct; The should go on America's Got Talent!
love this makes my day. !!😇😇
that vibes like hell ^^
Get this duo on PMJ! That was so good ❤
I love it!
This was sooo cool 😅
Fun performance
A yes from me.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Too funny
I demand a re-vote!!!
so fun
Aw I feel like he should had gone through
Love love snd love yourself for a great entertainer going to go have my favorite peanut butter honey sandwich and munch...
Katy's reactions 😂
How did the judges know the words to his original song if this was the first time he sang in front of them?
I will ask
Haha they edited out the part where I taught them the hook!
Give that man a Peanut Butter Jingle for JIF
Am i the only one that hasn't ever heard this goofy song? All the judges seemed to know it...
He said it was an original.
I liked him
I want to dance 🕺🏻😜
How did you not let him through!
He was good
Forget Idol! He needs to go onto AGT 😊. Lots of talents here.
This is so cute lol
Very catchy song I've seen video quite a few times
I knew he was from Portland before he said anything
Lol
Haha!!
Guilty as charged 😅
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Yes for the act No for watching the show anymore.
Hello he has a great voice , maybe his song choice was not the best but they should have asked him to sing something else, they have done it before with less talented contestants !
Why not for Idol? I have two words, "Leon Redbone".
Love a gimmick
They were good I thought the judges were a bit disrespectful
Reminds me of Roger Miller talent kind of
DESREVE A CHANCE AND MORE.COULD HAVE BEEN A REAL FUN AND SURPRISING.. PITTY
Much better than than that 17 year old country father, that they had sing another song
I’d have liked him to sing a regular song.
😁🤭👏👍🤗
What a mistake not giv I ng him a ticket please revonsider
Fun and entertaining but American Idol material, well.........!
Now, that was different, entertaining and captivating... The guy has incredible musical talent. They should have asked if he could sing a more serious song just to see what he could do. Maybe something rockabilly. Big Mistake letting him go.
Annnnnd that’s when the judges listened to style over the VOICE
why not Idol? voice not good enough? incapable of multiple styles?
I actually liked his voice. Maybe things were too gimmicky for the judges?
Perfect!!!! Love it!!! The judges are stupid!!!!
Not staged at all. 🙄
What?
What was this guy thinking?! This is not the place for that!
And yet…I am being ME!
@@colescottrubin well, you picked a hell of a time to be you.
@@robertnegron6804 Pobrecito. 😢
@@Quantumtraveler707 Pobregringo!
@@robertnegron6804 LOL! Good one, Amigo!
I like you now!
Have a great day! 😊
That’s definitely circus it’s a no from me dawg
How can I add a comment when I am not getting my utube
No ticket?