@MerriamPianos Thank you! Can you also pass on my thanks to Stu and the production team for bringing these awesome reviews and comparisons videos. Makes it so much easier when trying to decide which keyboard to buy, also very entertaining! :)
Thank you so much! And thank you for the suggestion. I will certainly pass it along to our production team for you. I'm sure they will do their best to tackle that. :)
Don't expect a revolution in this price range as FP-30x already has all the modern features (USB-Audio, Bluetooth Audio/Midi, etc.), maybe except a screen, but I doubt they'll put a screen, even though it (the screen) costs $5.
the operating system, screen interface, method of operation, functions, etc all require time to design, develop, and testing, maybe even firmware upgrade down the product life span. all of these cost something, definitely not 5$ per the hardware price.
Not a beginner but I have a Kawai GL40 Grand I got new a few months ago, a Yamaha P515, Roland FP60X and a Kawai ES920 that just arrived and I’m about to unbox. I also have a Casio GP510. I just like having a variety . Same with guitars
Don't sleep on the Roland FRP Nuvola that is sold at costco. It's basically an FP-30X with some slight changes like having unlimited polyphony and access to the Roland Cloud.
The FP10 is an excellent piano for the money! If you are looking to optimize the action and playing experience, it is tough to find a better model than the FP10 in my opinion. The ACR is an upgraded version, which has increased polyphony and improved piano tones.
Love your videos - the most informative on youtube. I'm UK based and I can't decide between P145 and FP10. I've done tons of research and the music teacher at the school where I work really rates the FP10, although the school uses yamahas in the classroom. I know you may prefer not to advise which one to buy, but should I just toss a coin?! At the moment, P145 retails at £350 (with £50 cashback) and the FP10 £400 including a stand, stool and headphones....
Thank you so much! We appreciate the kind words. For me, the Roland FP10 is the superior option both in terms of touch and tone. The PHA4 action is wonderfully-authentic. That would be my recommendation is price is not an issue.
Hi Stu, thanks for another high quality piano video! My 7-year-old son has been learning piano for more than 2 years using Yamaha P45. We love the sound of this piano, but he really needs an upgraded digital piano (not necessarily portable) with better key actions (feel like acoustic piano with escapement) and 3 pedals. If its sound is closer to acoustic piano that’ll be even better. He almost never uses the headphone but just the speaker. Our budget is around $2000 USD. Any recommendations?
Hi there! Brent from Merriam Music here! Thanks so much for supporting the channel and writing in with your question! :) If you're looking for an excellent portable digital piano that checks off all of the boxes, the Kawai ES920 would be my top suggestion. It has a wonderful tone and touch that greatly outperforms its price tag. If you're looking for a console digital piano, the Kawai CN201 would be my top suggestion. It has quite comparable features to the ES920 (with the exception of the tone tone engine; the ES920 has a more advanced tone engine), but with a nicer aesthetic.
I've seen shops in Europe selling off their Yamaha P45 stock for 250-300 Euro. That's difficult to beat for beginners at that price. Even if it is quite an old model now.
Hoy en español, Brent. No os voy a matar porque desde España vuestra tienda me pilla un poco a trasmano. Un año mirando videos, vuestros y de algunos de vuestros colegas en Canadá, en USA y en Europa, revisando características y comparaciones,... Y cuando ya he decidido que mi próximo piano debería ser un Kawai CN201 de alrededor de 1300€, viene Stu y me demuestra que el KDP120 de alrededor de 900€ es la elección correcta para mis capacidades y mis aspiraciones. Os voy a odiar. 😂😂😂😂😂😂 Va a ser siempre un placer ver vuestros vídeos. Y, como siempre, un abrazo para ti, que Stu ya tiene suficientes fans.
Haha we apologize for making the decision a little trickier! ;) The KDP120 and CN201 are both excellent instruments for their respective price points. So, in either case, you really can't go wrong! Thanks so much for the support! As always, it is greatly appreciated!
FP10 ACR was already available at Costco last year. I got it but returned a few months later because of the action clicking noise (I really do not like PHA-4)
It is all a matter of preference of course. Some players love the PHA4 actions; some players may find it too heavy or dislike some of the mechanical key noise that comes along with a heavier action.
I just purchased an AODSK B-83S 88-weighted key digital piano (not reviewed here) with a nice black upright piano looking stand (with designer music shelf) for our recent college graduate. We wanted something that looks and sounds great, but not too expensive, in case she loses interest and we have to sell it. I also bought the matching padded bench and the whole thing looks great! Better than just a keyboard, or keyboard with an 'X' stand. Total cost (2024) $400.
You're very welcome! Thanks for the suggestion! We will do our best to tackle that for you. :) The main differences are increased polyphony and an improved piano tone.
Kawai ES120 provides probably the best value for money in this list - especially if you are looking just for good piano action and sound. Other models are also solid choice, I would also include yamaha P-225, which is just slightly more expensive than P-145 but offers significant improvements.
I think I agee. I haven't been able to try an ES120, but reports are good. The P-225 is cheaper and probably more robust than the ES120. Its action is the same as on the P-145, but which sounds best (CFX vs CFiiis) is truly a subjective issue. The P-225 benefits from proper lineouts and more sounds than on the P-145 - important issues for some of us.
Hi, nice video! I wonder, what do you think about Px s5000 is a better option over Px s1100? Those can be used as MIDI controllers? I would like to have a keyboard for practicing and for recording with pianoteq 😊 Great video 👌
Hi! Brent from Merriam Music here! Thanks for tuning in and writing in with your question. We appreciate it. :) The PXS5000 is the same piano as the PXS1100 with the exception of the action. The composite resin/wood action of the PXS5000 is a bit heavier and more authentic feeling. Both of these pianos have MIDI capabilities and could be used as MIDI controllers. :)
"If you enjoy the Yamaha sound" sounds a bit ike a coded message, especially since beginners won't know what sound sounds best/most realistic. In the US it appears the fp10ACR is just an FP10 in a bundle. Also, in the US the FP-30x is actually a little cheaper than the Casio shown here, might be a stronger competitor (albeit with heavier keys).
The FP10 ACR is an improved version of the FP10. It has an upgraded core piano sound and increased polyphony. The FP30X is quite the powerhouse offering as well!
Great video as always. Do you have any recomendations for speakers/monitors to use with digital pianos, for someone who has the keyboard in a small room? Thanks
Thanks for tuning in! There are a number of excellent speakers that can be used in conjunction with digital pianos. Personally, I've always been a bit partial to Yamaha studio monitors. The HS5 and HS8 monitors are worth looking into for instance.
Hi! Thank you so much! We appreciate that. It is a matter of personal preference really. The RD88EX and FP60X use different tone engines. I wouldn't say that one is superior over the other, they are simply different. Personally, I prefer the FP60X's SuperNATURAL piano tones. If you are mainly using the piano for piano playing/practice, the FP60X would be my recommendation. If you are looking for a stage piano, the RD88EX would be more appropriate in my opinion.
@@MerriamPianos Ok my friend, thank you very much for your opinion, I really need it for home and for MIDI since the KeyScape is irreplaceable for me jjjj ,I really appreciate it
Hi, thank you for your great reviews. I have a question, which of the known brands can deliver the best "Joep Beving Sound"? Not necessarily these models. I love the classic piano sounds, but also that softer piano tone from a lot of todays modern players like Beving. thanks in advance!
Hi there! Thanks for tuning in and for the question! I am not personally familiar with Joep Beving, so I cannot comment on which option would be the best to achieve that particular sound. Perhaps, one of our helpful community members will be able to share some insights. :)
Hi there! We have tackled comparison videos examining all of the digital actions from Kawai and Roland. But, we will try to tackle more in the future. :)
As black friday is approaching I think this comparison is very welcomed. I am hoping to purchase Kawai CA-901 in the coming weeks. Will there be a comparison in the higher price range too?
The CA901 is a truly impressive instrument! It is a very good choice. :) I don't believe there are plans to tackle the top-end range, but I will be happy to pass on the suggestion to our production team for you.
This is very interesting. The spec looks fantastic. A lot will depend on how the RHL action plays - the L means light. So, the new Roland and Kawai models might give Yamaha a bad time.
Any recommendation on Korg LP-380U vs KDP120? Excellent vid btw, been struggling on picking a piano for my son who is only been playing for a year and needs to move up to an 88 weighted key. No preference on playing low or high volume, just want him to be as familiar with the sound and feel of an acoustic piano
Hi there! Brent from Merriam Music here! It all comes down to personal preference. For me, the KDP120 would have the edge. I think the SK-EX piano samples are incredibly authentic sounding, which yields a very rewarding musical experience. The RHCII action is also quite exceptional too. :)
I am looking for a new keyboard option...I currently have an ancient yamaha motif ES8. I don't need all the workstation stuff...I need to be able to carry it around to gigs. I am partial to piano and piano sounds. I want 88 keys and weighted...I hate the "plasticy" (is that a word?) feel that the newer machines have. However, after watching about 5 of your videos, I LOVE the sound of the kawai's....wow...and you play crazy beautiful, my friend!!! WOW!!! I don't want a beginner keyboard...I'd like something in the mid-range. What do you recommend?
Hi there! Brent from Merriam Music here! Thank you for your question. If you are a fan of the Kawai sound, I would strongly recommend the Kawai ES920. It is an exceptional top-tier piano. Despite being Kawai's flagship all-in portable digital piano, it sits in the mid-range price bracket. It is a wonderful piano on all fronts. :)
Thanks for your reply for roland rd 08 reg bank but there are only 5 select buttons on board as in the case of roland rd 88 there are 10 buttons for reg memory to recall our favorite tones. Kindly clarify.
Hey Stu, I'm torn between the Kawai KDP-120 and Yamaha YDP-165. Currently I have a Roland F120 (10+ years old), so I want to try something else. Saw a lot of your videoes and cant really tell which one I should go for. The YDP-165 is 150 EURO's more in Denmark compared to the KDP-120. Honestly budgetwise its no issue, and I just want to try something new and great which is somehwat close to the mentioned price point. YDG165 is kind of the upper level in terms of my budget, but I would still be open for similiar options in that price - from either Kawai, Roland or whichever you would recommend. Also do you think it would be an upgrade to actually go for one of the mentioned - compared to my old F120? Or should I go a level higher in terms of quality/price? Thanks for the videos!
Hi, Brent from Merriam Music here! Thanks for reaching out with your question. It really comes down to a matter of personal preference. For me, the Kawai KDP120 is the superior piano in terms of touch and tone. I find the warmer voice and richer low/low-mid register gives the KDP120 a more authentic tone in comparison to the YDP165. But, that is strictly my opinion. I'm sure many players would disagree with me. To be entirely honest, the KDP120 and YDP165 would be more of a parallel move from your F120. While the newer generation models have slightly upgraded technology, you may find jumping up a category (to the Kawai CN201/CN301 or Roland DP603/HP704 for instance) to be a more meaningful upgrade. Thanks and hope this helps!
Hi there! Brent from Merriam Music here! Thanks for watching! We appreciate it. Unfortunately, we don't get any info regarding release plans in other regions. Hopefully, this improved FP10 will be available in Europe though. :)
@@MerriamPianos OK thanks Brent. I would advice all in Europe to wait for the ACR version. Will it manage triple pedals? The FP10 did only manage one pedal (sustain)
I'm from Belgium. Initially I didn't want to spend more than 1k € for a piano as I'm a beginner but after some testing, the Kawai CN301 sounded too good and got it! 1569€ but surely worth it 😊
The YDP145 has more polyphony than the P145. Haven't fully checked the specs yet, but if anything I think the YDP145 is more of a P225 in a cab with a GHS action🎹🎶
Yes, the actions are different. I'm undecided about which is better. I always recommend the YDP-165 with the GH3 action. It's worth paying the extra dollars IMO. Too few Yamaha dps have this action.
It's disappointing that Merriam has moved to these bite-sized videos. Maybe Stu doesn't have the time to do the more detailed ones but boy do I miss those.
We are always experimenting with the format and approach. It is not a matter of insufficient time. We are simply trying to keep things fresh. But, we appreciate the honest feedback. I'll be sure to pass it along to the production team. :)
the best deal at this price point is the Casio PXs 5000.Its worth spending acouple hundred over the 1100 to get superior wooden keys which actually none of the mentioned pianos have.
Huh, is the FP 10 ACR really an upgraded model of the FP 10? That came out just now? I looked online since I literally bought the FP 10 6 days ago, so that new model would have been a bit unfortunate, but what I found is that the FP 10 ACR is a model branded for Costco and that has been in sale for a while now - at least since January 2024 (I found several reddit threads and used offerings from January and February, so probably even longer) O.O The model is also not listed on Roland's website for me. I dug a bit deeper and saw that it was also sold in a bundle with a stand - that bundle being called "FRP-2-ACR". But I found no specs, only the manual on Rolands FRP-2-ACR support site. XD Roland is really weird about that..
yeah, the FP 10 ACR was only sold at costco in the FRP2 bundle. It's more than a year old at this point and is already discontinued. Roland has a new bundle at costco with the Nuvola. It's an even bigger upgrade over the FP 10 with a new sound engine and unlimited polyphony, etc. It's basically an FP 30x with the same speakers and body. same pedal unit and stand as the fp 30x as well. Also it's on sale for $599 as a whole bundle. amazing deal
The FP10 ACR is an upgrade to the base FP10 model. It has an improved piano sound and increased polyphony. The core piano sound is a bit richer sounding. :)
I believe they are parallel in terms of specs. The PX765 is a Costco exclusive to my knowledge. Sometimes, piano companies rebrand/rename the same model when they're being sold through big-box retailers like Costco.
They're both amazing options! Personally, I would give a slight edge to the KDP120 as I gravitate towards warmer tonal profiles. I also find the KDP120's RHCII action to be a bit heavier and more responsive.
@@MerriamPianos Thanks for the response. I'll be mainly playing with low volume levels, and in your comparison you said PX-870 has a slight edge in those circumstances? Will I be missing out there with KDP-120?
@@MerriamPianos Thank you for reply. I've found some info that it might be Costco exclusive but can't find any official confirmation of this. Roland mentions the ACR variant in FRP-2-ACR bundle but with no details. Unfortunately, it is not available in Europe. Anyway, on one hand FP-10 seems like the best entry level option for me, but some users reported issues with PHA-4 action that it might get very loud on key return after some usage. Have you ever noticed it on any piano with this mechanism?
Thanks for the suggestion! We will do our best to tackle a comparison of those models. I would say that those are all mid-tier offerings opposed to entry-level/beginner pianos though based on their price point.
The P225 is a solid piano and $550 sounds like a good price. We just feel that there are stronger competitors in the category. However, it is all a matter of personal opinion of course.
Many players prefer Roland actions or Casio functionality, but IMO Yamaha still has the best piano sounds and speakers at this pricepoint, and at many others. It's my (largely) subjective opinion, but a lot of players share it, so don't feel lonely in your decision - enjoy your new Yamaha!
actually, that may not be true... if 2007, you see iPhone as being really good, and "only" put in $30k into Apple stock, then today you have $2M, enough to retire modestly and not subject to the corporate a*shole managers. Only that when you are eating dinner, your wife and kids will be all sliding on their iPhones
@@MerriamPianos I know, I remember the worry of the Y2K bug, and then the "end of the world" of 2012, and now it is 24 years after... if I accidentally have a kid with my girlfriend in the year 2000, the kid would be 24 year old now... of course, that girl may have chased down a rich director guy, or kiss up to some director or manager in the corporate world to get a good job, good bonus, good stocks, while together they hire some contractors to do the work, low hourly pay, no bonus, no 401k match, no ESPP, no stock, no vacation, no holidays, no sick days, no health insurance, no life insurance, no dental, no vision. This is the sh*t state of the world of 2024
The idea of having a piano tagged as ''for beginners'' is odd. I believe that if you want a beginner to become a Rubinstein or an Argerich, let them play on the best piano.
I know what you mean. To that point, perhaps "entry-level" is a more appropriate term given that it relates a bit more to the price point than the intended skill level.
Many complaint about roland fp 30x , 10x action to be Sluggish, super slow and noisy action that starts making unintended clicking noises within a few hours and really poor dynamics and the worst customer service on the planet: Roland.
We have not had those experiences here in Canada. The PHA4 action is exceptional and quite authentic feeling. There were a batch of PHA4 actions that had some grease issues, which led to clicking keys. With that said, Roland corrected all of these issues under warranty. The latest batches have not had any of these issues. We have also found Roland Canada's post sale support to be exceptional.
In this video Kawai is only one who uses sound samples not digitally made sounds, it is very hard to argue with Stu about this. I was bandwagon Roland guy but when I try Kawai digital piano, I never go back to digitally made sounds pianos. I am thinking to upgrade to Kawai CA level digital piano, CN series are very good but I want to upgrade to different keys.
like your knowledge and straight honest reviews and your expertise in anything piano related thanks
Thank you kindly! We really appreciate that. :)
I bought kdp120 according to your advice. Despite the fact that it costs 1700$ in Belarus, I am very satisfied with it.
Congrats on your KDP120! It is a marvellous instrument. I'm happy to hear that you're pleased with it. :)
I LOVE THE REPORT CARDS ! Very helpful!
We're glad you enjoy them! It is a fairly new addition to our videos. ;)
I'm about to buy a Kawai es120, can't wait to start playing it
Congrats! The ES120 is a remarkable piano. I know you will be quite pleased with it. :)
@MerriamPianos Thank you! Can you also pass on my thanks to Stu and the production team for bringing these awesome reviews and comparisons videos. Makes it so much easier when trying to decide which keyboard to buy, also very entertaining! :)
Love your videos. Can you do a similar video for those ready to move up from their first purchase?
Thank you so much! And thank you for the suggestion. I will certainly pass it along to our production team for you. I'm sure they will do their best to tackle that. :)
Can't wait for the successor of Fp30x. Will be on my wishlist for sure
It will be interesting to see what Roland does with the next generation of FP models. :)
Don't expect a revolution in this price range as FP-30x already has all the modern features (USB-Audio, Bluetooth Audio/Midi, etc.), maybe except a screen, but I doubt they'll put a screen, even though it (the screen) costs $5.
@@amitev A better speaker system would be nice. Not a fan of downward facing speakers
the operating system, screen interface, method of operation, functions, etc all require time to design, develop, and testing, maybe even firmware upgrade down the product life span. all of these cost something, definitely not 5$ per the hardware price.
@@m3rc743the current speaker system is terrible. Except that it's a really good piano.
Hey man I'm really impressed with your keyboard playing
Hi! Brent here! Thanks for tuning in! I know Stu appreciates your kind words about his playing. :)
Not a beginner but I have a Kawai GL40 Grand I got new a few months ago, a Yamaha P515, Roland FP60X and a Kawai ES920 that just arrived and I’m about to unbox. I also have a Casio GP510. I just like having a variety . Same with guitars
That is quite the arsenal of excellent pianos! You have a very wonderful palette of musical colours available to you. :)
Don't sleep on the Roland FRP Nuvola that is sold at costco. It's basically an FP-30X with some slight changes like having unlimited polyphony and access to the Roland Cloud.
There are certainly some very solid deals on the market right now as we approach the holiday season. :)
Seen a lot of people recommend the FP10 but I only just heard from you about its ACR upgrade!
The FP10 is an excellent piano for the money! If you are looking to optimize the action and playing experience, it is tough to find a better model than the FP10 in my opinion. The ACR is an upgraded version, which has increased polyphony and improved piano tones.
👏👏👏💯
Nice. Rich content.
Kudos for editing 🙂
Thanks so much! We're glad you enjoyed it. I'll pass on the kind words to the production team! :)
Love your videos - the most informative on youtube. I'm UK based and I can't decide between P145 and FP10. I've done tons of research and the music teacher at the school where I work really rates the FP10, although the school uses yamahas in the classroom. I know you may prefer not to advise which one to buy, but should I just toss a coin?! At the moment, P145 retails at £350 (with £50 cashback) and the FP10 £400 including a stand, stool and headphones....
Thank you so much! We appreciate the kind words. For me, the Roland FP10 is the superior option both in terms of touch and tone. The PHA4 action is wonderfully-authentic. That would be my recommendation is price is not an issue.
@@MerriamPianos Thank you so much! Decision's made!
Hi Stu, thanks for another high quality piano video! My 7-year-old son has been learning piano for more than 2 years using Yamaha P45. We love the sound of this piano, but he really needs an upgraded digital piano (not necessarily portable) with better key actions (feel like acoustic piano with escapement) and 3 pedals. If its sound is closer to acoustic piano that’ll be even better. He almost never uses the headphone but just the speaker. Our budget is around $2000 USD. Any recommendations?
Hi there! Brent from Merriam Music here! Thanks so much for supporting the channel and writing in with your question! :)
If you're looking for an excellent portable digital piano that checks off all of the boxes, the Kawai ES920 would be my top suggestion. It has a wonderful tone and touch that greatly outperforms its price tag. If you're looking for a console digital piano, the Kawai CN201 would be my top suggestion. It has quite comparable features to the ES920 (with the exception of the tone tone engine; the ES920 has a more advanced tone engine), but with a nicer aesthetic.
I've seen shops in Europe selling off their Yamaha P45 stock for 250-300 Euro. That's difficult to beat for beginners at that price. Even if it is quite an old model now.
Here in Venezuela is around $1000 😢
That is a very attractive price point. Thanks for sharing!
Just bought that one for 299 and discount for the standard and the stool
Hoy en español, Brent.
No os voy a matar porque desde España vuestra tienda me pilla un poco a trasmano.
Un año mirando videos, vuestros y de algunos de vuestros colegas en Canadá, en USA y en Europa, revisando características y comparaciones,...
Y cuando ya he decidido que mi próximo piano debería ser un Kawai CN201 de alrededor de 1300€, viene Stu y me demuestra que el KDP120 de alrededor de 900€ es la elección correcta para mis capacidades y mis aspiraciones.
Os voy a odiar.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Va a ser siempre un placer ver vuestros vídeos.
Y, como siempre, un abrazo para ti, que Stu ya tiene suficientes fans.
Haha we apologize for making the decision a little trickier! ;)
The KDP120 and CN201 are both excellent instruments for their respective price points. So, in either case, you really can't go wrong! Thanks so much for the support! As always, it is greatly appreciated!
awesome review 👍🫰👏🙌🫶👌
Thanks so much! We really appreciate that! :)
FP10 ACR was already available at Costco last year. I got it but returned a few months later because of the action clicking noise (I really do not like PHA-4)
It is all a matter of preference of course. Some players love the PHA4 actions; some players may find it too heavy or dislike some of the mechanical key noise that comes along with a heavier action.
I just purchased an AODSK B-83S 88-weighted key digital piano (not reviewed here) with a nice black upright piano looking stand (with designer music shelf) for our recent college graduate. We wanted something that looks and sounds great, but not too expensive, in case she loses interest and we have to sell it. I also bought the matching padded bench and the whole thing looks great! Better than just a keyboard, or keyboard with an 'X' stand. Total cost (2024) $400.
That is awesome to hear! We're glad to hear that you found an excellent solution that worked out well for you. Thanks for sharing! :)
Thank you very much STU for your careful introduction😆
Hi! Brent here! Thanks for tuning in! I know Stu appreciates the support as well. :)
Thank you for including my FP10. Please do a review on the 'ACR' and if it's worth upgrading for that.
You're very welcome! Thanks for the suggestion! We will do our best to tackle that for you. :)
The main differences are increased polyphony and an improved piano tone.
At where i'm from, the FP30X selling the same price as P225 and ES120. So i guess it is no brainer to go for FP30X right?
It comes down to a matter of musical preferences of course, but I would personally favour the FP30X for its action out of that selection. :)
Kawai ES120 provides probably the best value for money in this list - especially if you are looking just for good piano action and sound. Other models are also solid choice, I would also include yamaha P-225, which is just slightly more expensive than P-145 but offers significant improvements.
I think I agee. I haven't been able to try an ES120, but reports are good. The P-225 is cheaper and probably more robust than the ES120. Its action is the same as on the P-145, but which sounds best (CFX vs CFiiis) is truly a subjective issue. The P-225 benefits from proper lineouts and more sounds than on the P-145 - important issues for some of us.
Hi there! Thanks for sharing your thoughts! The ES120 is quite the impressive piano. The tone in particular is remarkable for its price point. :)
Hi, nice video!
I wonder, what do you think about Px s5000 is a better option over Px s1100?
Those can be used as MIDI controllers? I would like to have a keyboard for practicing and for recording with pianoteq 😊
Great video 👌
Hi! Brent from Merriam Music here! Thanks for tuning in and writing in with your question. We appreciate it. :)
The PXS5000 is the same piano as the PXS1100 with the exception of the action. The composite resin/wood action of the PXS5000 is a bit heavier and more authentic feeling. Both of these pianos have MIDI capabilities and could be used as MIDI controllers. :)
@MerriamPianos Thank you Brent, i would love a aunthentic keybed feel! Hopefully I'll be able to get the Px s6000
"If you enjoy the Yamaha sound" sounds a bit ike a coded message, especially since beginners won't know what sound sounds best/most realistic. In the US it appears the fp10ACR is just an FP10 in a bundle. Also, in the US the FP-30x is actually a little cheaper than the Casio shown here, might be a stronger competitor (albeit with heavier keys).
The FP10 ACR is an improved version of the FP10. It has an upgraded core piano sound and increased polyphony. The FP30X is quite the powerhouse offering as well!
Great video as always. Do you have any recomendations for speakers/monitors to use with digital pianos, for someone who has the keyboard in a small room? Thanks
Thanks for tuning in! There are a number of excellent speakers that can be used in conjunction with digital pianos. Personally, I've always been a bit partial to Yamaha studio monitors. The HS5 and HS8 monitors are worth looking into for instance.
Hello, thank you very much for your videos, one question... does the new Roland Rd 88 EX have better sound quality than the FP 60 x?
Hi! Thank you so much! We appreciate that. It is a matter of personal preference really. The RD88EX and FP60X use different tone engines. I wouldn't say that one is superior over the other, they are simply different. Personally, I prefer the FP60X's SuperNATURAL piano tones. If you are mainly using the piano for piano playing/practice, the FP60X would be my recommendation. If you are looking for a stage piano, the RD88EX would be more appropriate in my opinion.
@@MerriamPianos Ok my friend, thank you very much for your opinion, I really need it for home and for MIDI since the KeyScape is irreplaceable for me jjjj ,I really appreciate it
Hi, thank you for your great reviews. I have a question, which of the known brands can deliver the best "Joep Beving Sound"? Not necessarily these models. I love the classic piano sounds, but also that softer piano tone from a lot of todays modern players like Beving. thanks in advance!
Hi there! Thanks for tuning in and for the question! I am not personally familiar with Joep Beving, so I cannot comment on which option would be the best to achieve that particular sound. Perhaps, one of our helpful community members will be able to share some insights. :)
Can you pls do a comparison among different hammer actions in digital pianos if available? Thanks!
Hi there! We have tackled comparison videos examining all of the digital actions from Kawai and Roland. But, we will try to tackle more in the future. :)
Complimenti per il video!!! Perché visto che è piaciuto a molti non fate un altri video per le fasce di livello successivo?
Thanks for the suggestion! I will pass it along to the production team. It would be fun to tackle the other categories as well. :)
@MerriamPianos cmq vi seguo sempre siete bravissimi!!!!
As black friday is approaching I think this comparison is very welcomed. I am hoping to purchase Kawai CA-901 in the coming weeks. Will there be a comparison in the higher price range too?
The CA901 is a truly impressive instrument! It is a very good choice. :)
I don't believe there are plans to tackle the top-end range, but I will be happy to pass on the suggestion to our production team for you.
There's a new Kawai out that seems to be going for roughly the P-145's price range called the ES60.
Thanks for the info! Looks like a competitor to P-145 and Roland FP-10.
This is very interesting. The spec looks fantastic. A lot will depend on how the RHL action plays - the L means light. So, the new Roland and Kawai models might give Yamaha a bad time.
It is an exciting addition to an already excellent line! :)
@@MerriamPianos will you be doing a comparison ?
Any recommendation on Korg LP-380U vs KDP120?
Excellent vid btw, been struggling on picking a piano for my son who is only been playing for a year and needs to move up to an 88 weighted key. No preference on playing low or high volume, just want him to be as familiar with the sound and feel of an acoustic piano
Hi there! Brent from Merriam Music here! It all comes down to personal preference. For me, the KDP120 would have the edge. I think the SK-EX piano samples are incredibly authentic sounding, which yields a very rewarding musical experience. The RHCII action is also quite exceptional too. :)
I am looking for a new keyboard option...I currently have an ancient yamaha motif ES8. I don't need all the workstation stuff...I need to be able to carry it around to gigs. I am partial to piano and piano sounds. I want 88 keys and weighted...I hate the "plasticy" (is that a word?) feel that the newer machines have. However, after watching about 5 of your videos, I LOVE the sound of the kawai's....wow...and you play crazy beautiful, my friend!!! WOW!!! I don't want a beginner keyboard...I'd like something in the mid-range. What do you recommend?
Hi there! Brent from Merriam Music here! Thank you for your question. If you are a fan of the Kawai sound, I would strongly recommend the Kawai ES920. It is an exceptional top-tier piano. Despite being Kawai's flagship all-in portable digital piano, it sits in the mid-range price bracket. It is a wonderful piano on all fronts. :)
@@MerriamPianos Any second favorites? The reviews from several are not promising. Any other ideas?
Thanks for your reply for roland rd 08 reg bank but there are only 5 select buttons on board as in the case of roland rd 88 there are 10 buttons for reg memory to recall our favorite tones. Kindly clarify.
You're very welcome! The additional buttons on the RD88 are for different onboard sound banks, but not user registration scenes specifically.
Hi, can you make a video of the best digital piano/keyboard under $1000 or $1500?
Thanks for the suggestion! I'll be happy to share it with our production team. :)
Hi, is there registration bank in roland rd 08 for storing our tones to play in church.
Hi there! Yes - you can create your own patches. These are referred to as "Scenes" on the Roland RD models. :)
Hey Stu, I'm torn between the Kawai KDP-120 and Yamaha YDP-165. Currently I have a Roland F120 (10+ years old), so I want to try something else. Saw a lot of your videoes and cant really tell which one I should go for. The YDP-165 is 150 EURO's more in Denmark compared to the KDP-120.
Honestly budgetwise its no issue, and I just want to try something new and great which is somehwat close to the mentioned price point. YDG165 is kind of the upper level in terms of my budget, but I would still be open for similiar options in that price - from either Kawai, Roland or whichever you would recommend.
Also do you think it would be an upgrade to actually go for one of the mentioned - compared to my old F120? Or should I go a level higher in terms of quality/price?
Thanks for the videos!
Hi, Brent from Merriam Music here! Thanks for reaching out with your question. It really comes down to a matter of personal preference. For me, the Kawai KDP120 is the superior piano in terms of touch and tone. I find the warmer voice and richer low/low-mid register gives the KDP120 a more authentic tone in comparison to the YDP165. But, that is strictly my opinion. I'm sure many players would disagree with me.
To be entirely honest, the KDP120 and YDP165 would be more of a parallel move from your F120. While the newer generation models have slightly upgraded technology, you may find jumping up a category (to the Kawai CN201/CN301 or Roland DP603/HP704 for instance) to be a more meaningful upgrade.
Thanks and hope this helps!
Hi Merriam Music. May I ask, which, key action is heavier PHA-4 from roland or RHlll from Kawai?
Hi there! While they are quite similar in terms of weighting, the PHA4 is slightly heavier and has more pronounced escapement than the RHIII.
@@MerriamPianos Thank you 🙏🏼 for answering. 🎹💛
Merriam Music, when are you expecting to receive Kawai ES60, please?
We are expecting them in late December/early January.
@ Thank you 😊
Thanks for the video Stu. I Europe/France we cannot buy the Roland FP10 ACR. Do you have any idea on when that will be possible? Thanks
What's the difference?
@amitev The FP10 ACR has a better sound engine and better speakers...
Hi there! Brent from Merriam Music here! Thanks for watching! We appreciate it. Unfortunately, we don't get any info regarding release plans in other regions. Hopefully, this improved FP10 will be available in Europe though. :)
@@MerriamPianos OK thanks Brent. I would advice all in Europe to wait for the ACR version. Will it manage triple pedals? The FP10 did only manage one pedal (sustain)
Will you review the Roland EARTH piano?
I will be happy to pass the suggestion along to our production team! It is certainly a possibility. :)
I'm from Belgium. Initially I didn't want to spend more than 1k € for a piano as I'm a beginner but after some testing, the Kawai CN301 sounded too good and got it! 1569€ but surely worth it 😊
Congratulations on your CN301! It really does have a remarkable tone. I know you will be quite thrilled with everything it has to offer musically. :)
@@MerriamPianos Thank you! I've watched your review of that piano a couple times and saw you were pleasantly surprised! That helped
Thanks
i got my roland RP 701 💟
Congratulations! The RP701 is a fantastic instrument. I know you will be pleased with it! :)
Have you guys received the new Kawai es60?
Not quite yet! But, we are looking forward to giving it a test drive. ;)
The YDP145 has more polyphony than the P145. Haven't fully checked the specs yet, but if anything I think the YDP145 is more of a P225 in a cab with a GHS action🎹🎶
That is one way to look at the YDP145! :)
Yes, the actions are different. I'm undecided about which is better. I always recommend the YDP-165 with the GH3 action. It's worth paying the extra dollars IMO. Too few Yamaha dps have this action.
Now costco sold PX-765 with bench bundle for $599. Is it a good deal?
Given the specs, I would say that is a very solid offering.
You mention the Roland FP10 ACR is the lowest price entry point - is the Kawai ES60 more expensive?
We haven't received exact pricing for the ES60 model in Canada yet, but it is going to sit somewhere right around the FP10 in terms of pricing.
It's disappointing that Merriam has moved to these bite-sized videos. Maybe Stu doesn't have the time to do the more detailed ones but boy do I miss those.
We are always experimenting with the format and approach. It is not a matter of insufficient time. We are simply trying to keep things fresh. But, we appreciate the honest feedback. I'll be sure to pass it along to the production team. :)
Did you record all sound from line out?
Yup! Unless otherwise indicated in the video, we capture the audio from direct line out feeds. :)
the best deal at this price point is the Casio PXs 5000.Its worth spending acouple hundred over the 1100 to get superior wooden keys which actually none of the mentioned pianos have.
The PXS5000 is a bit of a dark horse in the market, but I do agree that it offers a meaningful step up from an already great piano in the PXS1100.
Huh, is the FP 10 ACR really an upgraded model of the FP 10? That came out just now? I looked online since I literally bought the FP 10 6 days ago, so that new model would have been a bit unfortunate, but what I found is that the FP 10 ACR is a model branded for Costco and that has been in sale for a while now - at least since January 2024 (I found several reddit threads and used offerings from January and February, so probably even longer) O.O The model is also not listed on Roland's website for me. I dug a bit deeper and saw that it was also sold in a bundle with a stand - that bundle being called "FRP-2-ACR". But I found no specs, only the manual on Rolands FRP-2-ACR support site. XD Roland is really weird about that..
yeah, the FP 10 ACR was only sold at costco in the FRP2 bundle. It's more than a year old at this point and is already discontinued. Roland has a new bundle at costco with the Nuvola. It's an even bigger upgrade over the FP 10 with a new sound engine and unlimited polyphony, etc. It's basically an FP 30x with the same speakers and body. same pedal unit and stand as the fp 30x as well. Also it's on sale for $599 as a whole bundle. amazing deal
The FP10 ACR is an upgrade to the base FP10 model. It has an improved piano sound and increased polyphony. The core piano sound is a bit richer sounding. :)
need help! what's the difference between Casio PX-765 and PX-770?
I believe they are parallel in terms of specs. The PX765 is a Costco exclusive to my knowledge. Sometimes, piano companies rebrand/rename the same model when they're being sold through big-box retailers like Costco.
@@MerriamPianos Thank you! Now costco sold PX-765 with bench bundle for $599. Is it a good deal?
Kawai KDP-120 or Casio PX-870 ? I just can't decide between them.
They're both amazing options! Personally, I would give a slight edge to the KDP120 as I gravitate towards warmer tonal profiles. I also find the KDP120's RHCII action to be a bit heavier and more responsive.
@@MerriamPianos Thanks for the response. I'll be mainly playing with low volume levels, and in your comparison you said PX-870 has a slight edge in those circumstances? Will I be missing out there with KDP-120?
Need help: Casio PX-770 for $649, is it a good deal to get?
That sounds like a very solid deal for a new PX770! :)
@@MerriamPianos Thank you! I just found there is another deal $599 for PX765, is it good as well? And what's the difference between px770 and px765?
I can't find info about FP-10 ACR anywhere.
The Roland FP10 ACR is an upgraded FP10. The core differences are a more refined core piano sound and increased polyphony. :)
@@MerriamPianos Thank you for reply. I've found some info that it might be Costco exclusive but can't find any official confirmation of this. Roland mentions the ACR variant in FRP-2-ACR bundle but with no details. Unfortunately, it is not available in Europe.
Anyway, on one hand FP-10 seems like the best entry level option for me, but some users reported issues with PHA-4 action that it might get very loud on key return after some usage. Have you ever noticed it on any piano with this mechanism?
CLP825 vs CN301 vs APS450 ?
Thanks for the suggestion! We will do our best to tackle a comparison of those models. I would say that those are all mid-tier offerings opposed to entry-level/beginner pianos though based on their price point.
I am quite sad that the Yamaha P225 does not make it to the list, I was able to buy one brand new for $550 bucks. Do you guys think it’s a good deal?
The P225 is a solid piano and $550 sounds like a good price. We just feel that there are stronger competitors in the category. However, it is all a matter of personal opinion of course.
Many players prefer Roland actions or Casio functionality, but IMO Yamaha still has the best piano sounds and speakers at this pricepoint, and at many others. It's my (largely) subjective opinion, but a lot of players share it, so don't feel lonely in your decision - enjoy your new Yamaha!
Too bad the Kawai ES-60 wasn't released soon enough to make the list.
It is not quite available, but we are excited to see what it has to offer!
Why didn't you add fp 30x to the list? Is it not worth for the price?
The FP30X is an excellent option, but given that the FP10 is the most affordable option in the Roland line, it got a slight edge in this case.
tried the Roland FRP Nuvola and it felt like a cheap toy compared to the fp10 acr.
The FP10 ACR is quite the exciting instrument - that is for sure! :)
wow we are getting close to 2025... when are we getting out the sort of like "curse of the 2000"
actually, that may not be true... if 2007, you see iPhone as being really good, and "only" put in $30k into Apple stock, then today you have $2M, enough to retire modestly and not subject to the corporate a*shole managers. Only that when you are eating dinner, your wife and kids will be all sliding on their iPhones
Time certainly flies! That is for sure. I remember when Y2K was happening. It is crazy to think it has been a quarter of a century.
@@MerriamPianos I know, I remember the worry of the Y2K bug, and then the "end of the world" of 2012, and now it is 24 years after... if I accidentally have a kid with my girlfriend in the year 2000, the kid would be 24 year old now... of course, that girl may have chased down a rich director guy, or kiss up to some director or manager in the corporate world to get a good job, good bonus, good stocks, while together they hire some contractors to do the work, low hourly pay, no bonus, no 401k match, no ESPP, no stock, no vacation, no holidays, no sick days, no health insurance, no life insurance, no dental, no vision. This is the sh*t state of the world of 2024
@@winterheatyou’re a strange person indeed.
@@Gustavo-x8f3q right, that manager and young lady not strange but i am strange
The idea of having a piano tagged as ''for beginners'' is odd. I believe that if you want a beginner to become a Rubinstein or an Argerich, let them play on the best piano.
I know what you mean. To that point, perhaps "entry-level" is a more appropriate term given that it relates a bit more to the price point than the intended skill level.
Roland fp e50 is the best of the best
It is a very attractive value proposition! That is for sure. :)
Many complaint about roland fp 30x , 10x action to be Sluggish, super slow and noisy action that starts making unintended clicking noises within a few hours and really poor dynamics and the worst customer service on the planet:
Roland.
We have not had those experiences here in Canada. The PHA4 action is exceptional and quite authentic feeling. There were a batch of PHA4 actions that had some grease issues, which led to clicking keys. With that said, Roland corrected all of these issues under warranty. The latest batches have not had any of these issues. We have also found Roland Canada's post sale support to be exceptional.
This guy is a total kawai p*mp rn 😂.
Kawai makes wonderful pianos, so it is hard not to get excited about them!
@@MerriamPianosthey do indeed. My two main pianos are a Kawai GL40 Grand and the Kawai ES920
In this video Kawai is only one who uses sound samples not digitally made sounds, it is very hard to argue with Stu about this.
I was bandwagon Roland guy but when I try Kawai digital piano, I never go back to digitally made sounds pianos.
I am thinking to upgrade to Kawai CA level digital piano, CN series are very good but I want to upgrade to different keys.
@@someguyfromarcticfreezer6854 CA901 is good