It's impressive how despite how much the community has improved and the standards have risen over the years, NO H1L5 recreation sounds like the original
@@Molten546 ? No, they did really, really good! This stage is EXTREMELY close to its original counterpart. There's always room for improvement but "So much better" is just exaggerating.
The recreation of each section is flawless and perfectly captures the original environment. It feels like experiencing it all over again! Kudos to everyone involved, fantastic work.
Honestly freaking impressive how you got I1 *just about spot on.* So much of this project sounds so accurate to the original EATEOT, and yet... So distinguished and unique as well. J1L1 and J1's ending is just about as good as it gets, and the Stage 2 Heartaches layer of G1 is absolutely fabulous (6:55 to 17:05). H1 was freaking amazing too, with the Hell Sirens perhaps being the best portion of it and the portion following the Hell Sirens as well. However, I1 may be the most accurate I1 I have ever heard, and I'm amazed with how it disintegrates near the end of the track like how the original EATEOT I1 does, something that a lot of other fan projects/recreations of EATEOT just do not do. Excited for Stage 5 and how that goes.
I am in love with I1. Was in love with it in the original EATEOT, and love that its able to be pretty much perfectly replicated in here. It means everything.
its honestly difficult to tell the difference. the way it transitions to slowly getting quieter until the notes are barely audible is incredibly accurate.
samples: the curator - our troubles gone beyond recall the curator - a vacant joy transcending the universe the curator - so invested in his personal universe
They used the EXACT (Bunny Paul) sample I had in a fantrack for the 3rd Heartaches sample, I believe? It sounds good, goes without saying. EDIT: God YT ads suck, but otherwise a seamless experience, personally glad they stayed with the same "Mission by the sea" sample
Too bad that I was so late to this, but anyways... I'm right now into G1 where J1L4 appears and I feel overwhelmed. This is by far so good and so close to the original EATEOT. I feel like crying but I can't.
I listened to this, this is a solid 9/10, only small problem is the ending of it all, the little beeps (idk what they’re called) don’t really hit as much as the original EATEOT does, but either way, good job!
@@Recycled_Babiesyeah, also another problem is the hell sirens, it’s REALLY GOOD the only problem is how it sounds like it was slowed down using TH-cam’s feature (The weird crunch thing that’s apart of it)
are you stuck in 2018 as of 2024, ALL samples in stage 4 have been found after weeping dancefloor was deconfirmed in G1L3 and J1L4, and by the seaside too in G1L1 if anything, some effects that James Kirby used in stage 4 are perhaps still unknown but most of them have been and as i said earlier, all samples in this stage are found
@TheButtoner , Firstly, is it possible without negativity? why do you always address me with negativity, even in my old videos that I have already deleted Secondly, I mean about the samples of this stage of EIADU:FE, not EATEOT, because today (and I wrote this comment at one o'clock in the morning) many samples are unknown here, only melodies, because these are alternative samples
@@Oven_Play you are still wrong, pretty much all samples from all layers have got alternative versions of them used here, if anything i'd say the only exception is ancient court whisperings (G1L3, J1L1, J1L4) where they had to use a whole different sample because there isn't another rendition of the song anywhere, but besides that i'm pretty sure every other sample got an alternate version, even Don't put the blame on me (G1L4) tho it is not a piano here because that was the only other version of the song
Alright so, This sounds too much like eateot, this recreation is pretty much perfect, hope you Nail stage 6 and do Q1 corectly, Cuz at this point, this is on the same level as Natmos:r. (anyways, absolute banger everything sounds great.)
![The Curator - Everywhere in a different Universe: Final edition - Stage 2 [FULL ALBUM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/y7ztF1qr-s8/mqdefault.jpg)
![The Curator - Everywhere in a different Universe: Final edition - Stage 2 [FULL ALBUM]](/img/tr.png)
27:43
~pain, forgotten every word...~
ive said forgotten every tear you've shed we're still in love
It's impressive how despite how much the community has improved and the standards have risen over the years, NO H1L5 recreation sounds like the original
kirby must've done a fuckin ritual to get that distortion
It's about as close enough as you're going to get it. The entire stage is, and they did a damned good job on it.
@@marzolaxo2456 they couldve done so much better
@@Molten546 ? No, they did really, really good! This stage is EXTREMELY close to its original counterpart. There's always room for improvement but "So much better" is just exaggerating.
@@marzolaxo2456 the hell sirens are really disappointing, but everything else is great
they even included the little glitch at 11:25 this is so detailed
I absolutely love that you gave the Post-Lucidity tracks individual names as opposed to them all being the same thing
5:21 they even got the D5 clarity in here, my lawd
5:18 🤓👆
36:33 - The Inferno Horns (Nightfall Malady) segment
Scary
why do they sound like that
Sections
G1
Layer 1- 0:00 - 8:18
Layer 2- 6:55 - 17:05
Layer 3- 9:50~ - 14:46~
Layer 4- 15:55 -19:43
Layer 5- 19:44 - 22:09
H1
Layer 1: 22:09 - 25:49
Layer 2: 25:09 - 28:40
Layer 3: 28:20 - 31:58
Layer 2: 31:35 - 32:38
Layer 1: 32:22 - 33:51
Layer 4: 32:56 - 35:57
Layer 1: 35:08 - 36:33
Layer 5: 36:33 - 38:59
Layer 6: 38:55 - 41:55
Layer 1: 41:24 - 43:32
Layer 3: 42:58 - 43:59
Layer 1: 43:49 - 44:00
J1 tmmrw
@bingobeego thx
I1
Layer 1: 44:01 - 1:05:03
Layer 2: 44:01 - 1:05:03
J1
Layer 1: 1:05:03 - 1:13:12
Layer 2: 1:13:04 - 1:16:07
Layer 3: 1:15:56 - 1:20:17
Layer 4: 1:19:29 - 1:27:19
correct me if im wrong, its pretty hard to make out
The recreation of each section is flawless and perfectly captures the original environment. It feels like experiencing it all over again! Kudos to everyone involved, fantastic work.
Honestly freaking impressive how you got I1 *just about spot on.* So much of this project sounds so accurate to the original EATEOT, and yet... So distinguished and unique as well. J1L1 and J1's ending is just about as good as it gets, and the Stage 2 Heartaches layer of G1 is absolutely fabulous (6:55 to 17:05). H1 was freaking amazing too, with the Hell Sirens perhaps being the best portion of it and the portion following the Hell Sirens as well.
However, I1 may be the most accurate I1 I have ever heard, and I'm amazed with how it disintegrates near the end of the track like how the original EATEOT I1 does, something that a lot of other fan projects/recreations of EATEOT just do not do. Excited for Stage 5 and how that goes.
THIS IS SO GOOOD!
Anyways good luck on stage 5 👍
I am in love with I1. Was in love with it in the original EATEOT, and love that its able to be pretty much perfectly replicated in here. It means everything.
Big Fan! ;D
its honestly difficult to tell the difference. the way it transitions to slowly getting quieter until the notes are barely audible is incredibly accurate.
25:25 the best section in stage 4 (Both here and original eateot) Begins
samples:
the curator - our troubles gone beyond recall
the curator - a vacant joy transcending the universe
the curator - so invested in his personal universe
@@Recycled_Babies actually a retake of our troubles gone beyond recall with 2 new samples in it
@@blockheadstransfers does it has Alexander Van Phillip's version of Its All Forgotten Now
the post awareness titles being different for each reappearance is really cool
holy shit, PhiSigma hitting the cover art out of the park once again
17:00 "Don't put the blame on me" by Herman Darewski Also i'm talking about the low pitched horns, not the bells.
YES FINALLY YEAS
They used the EXACT (Bunny Paul) sample I had in a fantrack for the 3rd Heartaches sample, I believe? It sounds good, goes without saying. EDIT: God YT ads suck, but otherwise a seamless experience, personally glad they stayed with the same "Mission by the sea" sample
"Everywhere in a nearly same but still different universe" basically (really well done btw, it's pretty close to the original)
i love g1 layer 2 soo much in this one
17:00 I think sample of G1 Section C is Albert Benzler - Belle of the east, but version of 1906, 1912 version was used in G1 Section C of EATEOT
it looks like the sample I found was added to the EIADU:FE stage 4 Fandom (Wiki)
I’m just gonna say this is really good. Nothing added to it…
Too bad that I was so late to this, but anyways...
I'm right now into G1 where J1L4 appears and I feel overwhelmed. This is by far so good and so close to the original EATEOT. I feel like crying but I can't.
This is the final "All samples discovered" stage guys, enjoy it while it lasts :^)
There are only 2 unknown melodies in stage 5, I don't think it's that big of an issue lmao
@big_numbers Darn, I must be stuck in 2022. Next you'll tell me they've made as much progress on stage 6. On second thought it's likely the case.
I listened to this, this is a solid 9/10, only small problem is the ending of it all, the little beeps (idk what they’re called) don’t really hit as much as the original EATEOT does, but either way, good job!
i think its just missing more reverb to emphasize the notes more
@@Recycled_Babiesyeah, also another problem is the hell sirens, it’s REALLY GOOD the only problem is how it sounds like it was slowed down using TH-cam’s feature (The weird crunch thing that’s apart of it)
@@AHHHH722 yea i noticed that too, still pretty scary
I agree with the Hell Sirens part, like, It looks very robotic and not so organic, but the rest of the album sounds good
@@AHHHH722 it uses pitch and tempo shifter (partially), which may have damaged the sound a lot
yeah baby
about time
But it is misplaced?
@@Thetakecarerr maybe
ITS FINALLY HERE!
WOO YEAHH
Oh my lord, it’s here.
Incredibly similar
36:33 YES. I'M THE FIRST TO TIMETSAMP THIS
hell sirens here are scary af
update: I made a visual for him! based on the version by user "Sublime Beyond Loss" who for some reason has a username which is gibberish now
th-cam.com/video/g58nhQH_WJA/w-d-xo.htmlsi=c0DtE6K0ZazKW0jx
ok?
The Hell Sirens Sounds Like It's From A Robot Movie.
Masterpiece
Please tell me how to recreate the drone effect 🙏 in the first layer of g1
valhalla shimmer
8:25 C3 with 1 million ping
Yeah i found that quite odd too
@bingobeego its in the original stage 4 too, its just harder to make out since it uses a lower trumpet instrument
its pretty accurate to eateot, the instruments just dont blend too well. its a sample issue unfortunately
Nice
this is truly in a whole different universe
YOO
Wait, so essentially its just a recreation of the original? Although it uses the same samples its different covers right?
yeah
Imagine if EATEOT becomes lost media and people find this instead of the original
With that small possibility wouldn’t there be an EIADU of EIADU
@@candlelight20 it would then probably unknowingly use the same samples as EATEOT
i mean its literally printed on physical vinyls so it will prolly be fine lol
god this is so peak holy shit
so far, no samples have been found only for G1SD, H1SF, J1SA and J1SD, I think
are you stuck in 2018
as of 2024, ALL samples in stage 4 have been found after weeping dancefloor was deconfirmed in G1L3 and J1L4, and by the seaside too in G1L1
if anything, some effects that James Kirby used in stage 4 are perhaps still unknown but most of them have been and as i said earlier, all samples in this stage are found
Bro doesn't know
@TheButtoner , Firstly, is it possible without negativity? why do you always address me with negativity, even in my old videos that I have already deleted
Secondly, I mean about the samples of this stage of EIADU:FE, not EATEOT, because today (and I wrote this comment at one o'clock in the morning) many samples are unknown here, only melodies, because these are alternative samples
And yes, The Caretaker Fan is my second channel (TCF)
@@Oven_Play you are still wrong, pretty much all samples from all layers have got alternative versions of them used here, if anything i'd say the only exception is ancient court whisperings (G1L3, J1L1, J1L4) where they had to use a whole different sample because there isn't another rendition of the song anywhere, but besides that i'm pretty sure every other sample got an alternate version, even Don't put the blame on me (G1L4) tho it is not a piano here because that was the only other version of the song
Why are there only like 3 clear heartaches moments in G1 layer 2
And it hasn't D3 clarity at the end of J1SB
@@Oven_Playmaybe u shoulda submitted a layer with those stuff
@@FortuneEight__ yes, I have not yet got used to the fact that now these are layers, not sections, and they are numbered, not indicated by letters
44:20
The Hell Sirens Sound More Robotic Now.
57:36
Alright so, This sounds too much like eateot, this recreation is pretty much perfect, hope you Nail stage 6 and do Q1 corectly, Cuz at this point, this is on the same level as Natmos:r. (anyways, absolute banger everything sounds great.)
WHAT
LETS GO
actually peak
Caught it 5 minutes late :(
Hell Sirens in this album be creepy af 😭
Oh boy
Ok
People are still making EATEOT parodies?
Whens stage 5
seeing as it took over 6 months for stage 4, and stage 5 is a lot more complex, i would guess 10+ months
Caretaker fans try not to be impatient challenge (impossible)
@Clidesterlol me when natmos r complete edition year 5 and 6:
honestly the original eiadu stage 4 was better
Are you joking?
nope
No
reminder this is the guy who made the f8 drone and goddamn i hope ur joking
the original was honestly really underwhelming, ur def being sarcastic
Finally!