@@ThirdEyeTy okay this might be controversial, but I'm putting her in Guest Crew Mate teir. I like her character but i don't think she has gotten enough character development for me to put her in crewmate. Her introduction was pretty sudden. Who knows, i still need to reread Wano so my opinions might change. There is a lot more behind her character and i feel a lot of development can still be done with her in terms of story.
I find it hilarious you put Luffy up there first and said “he will not be moved“ and then you proceeded to move him immediately with the addition Buggy!!! 😂 😂
26:08 what do you mean you don't have a navigator?!?!?! What about Perona?! She not only was the navigator for Moria, but she was also able to deliver ZORO after the 2 years time skip, and he was the FIRST to arrive! How amazing of a navigator you'd have to be to do that?! With Perona you wouldn't net lost like....ever.
I think its interesting that every time Law has left us, he says that the next time they meet will be as enemies And then they are allied the next time they meet.
@@yozarian86 I think there will be a point where Law will call Luffy his friend, and then the next time they meet they will have to fight for one reason or another.
@@Treblebeatgames They might have a fight to see who’s really top pirate, but that’s only if Law lives to see Luffy again. I don’t get the feeling he’s about to die, but he might before they meet up again.
I love how Merphy's brain works. Everytime she lists the powerhouse members of her crew she doesn't mention Luffy the strongest member because she just imagines him arguing with Buggy the whole time instead of fighting
Not including Sanji in your crew would be a huge waste of the opportunity, considering you would be missing out on many delicious and never-before-tasted food, as well as one of the powerhouses who has considerable potential to further get stronger.
"Next is Laboon, who will be protected at all costs, i don't need explain myself on that, if you think I do, you're a monster!" hahaha i loved the video and the tier Merphy, my thoughts: - I love how Brook took a place in your heart after a bad fisrt impression. - I think your tier is pretty clean, i just feel bad for Garp, but its ok. - I didnt know that community was so intense with Koby, in spanish community, that intensity is for vivi xD - I absolutely know that you did this full tierlist and video, just for atack, hate and throw out of the manga to that stupid swamp guy... the rest is all a distraction.
I read protect at all costs and immediately thought of Bon Clay, but he didnt even make it on the list, we need another list with how many characters we have
I always feel sorry for Sanji because he's such an amazing character but out of everyone he was chosen by Oda to be the pervert character. 😭 (Because In every shonen anime/manga in the 90s there was a pervert character, it was a very popular trope just like the trope of main character being dumb and loves to eat and the female character who loves hitting the main character) and i wonder if Oda didn't choose to make him a pervert he would have easily become my favorite character in the story. I just love everything about him especially that when I watched the show as a kid dubbed in Arabic, they used to cut those scenes where he was acting like a simp/pervert so i never knew he was a pervert and that helped me appreciate him as a character more.
@@agreatmannamedlieu5122 That's a pretty good read, actually. He would have been too complex and could take too much time if he wasn't a pervert, his interactions would be hard to write with other crew members and even women. But still, it's a detriment that many people can't get over.
I just don't understand why Oda feels like he has to go so far into the pervert trope. LIke OK yeah you can make him a simp for women and have that be his flaw, but he could just leave it at that and not go into the whole creepy, predatory, groping, over the top, "making women uncomfortable and comrpomising their feeling of safety is a joke" thing. Thank goodness for the liva action showing us how good Sanji could actually be!
Kohza’s dad Toto’s arch was top teir. That scene when Vivi couldn’t recognize him because he had lost so much weight. I cried. And he kept digging and staying positive. Never giving up on the king. AMAZING. Fully agree with putting him in top tier.
You actually made me like pudding a lot more than I used to! I never hated her, but I wasn't a huge fan either. But looking at her the way you do, I've grown to really like her! So thanks!
I feel like Vivi is such an underrated character. Tbh, I think Vivi really shaped who Luffy was as a captain. In Drum Island, Luffy was ready to go fighting, just like any pirate crew would interact, but Vivi setting Luffy's priorities straight and get him to humble himself I believe set the tone of greeting new people. Also, I think if this didn't happen, Idk if Luffy would've bowed his head down to Hammock to free Margarette. Although I think Jinbe would be a decent navigator. I mean, he captained the Fishman Pirates and he even knows the sea currents and everything.
I didn't see Vivi in that light but that's a good point. I like her because she's one of the few princess (or kind/"innocent" woman) who puts efforts and even risks her life for her country. This type of character usually have good intentions and rely on others to take action since they're weak. Vivi couldn't do much since she's not strong but I respect her for going undercover to gather more information and giving her best. I prefer her as a Strawhat member than Yamato.
@@xenon5426 Yeah. And she has a good grasp of diplomacy. I really admired her when she didn't do anything to Wapol for slapping her because she knew that she represents Alabasta and her actions can harm the people of Alabasta. She knew if she did anything, it would become an international incident. The Yamato thing is your preference, but I don't consider Yamato a Princess. Otama for princess of Wano XD although for princess of Wano, that's Hiyori.
Glad to see your love for Law and Corazon! They belong to a special top-tier list for me as well. It has a slightly different meaning from yours though haha.
I also have mixed feelings about Sanji, I really liked the formula where he would do some cool, subversive stuff (Mr prince, enies lobby gate) and I thought it was funny when it was undercut by turning into a fool around a pretty woman. I love how he makes high effort cocktails for Nami and Robin, completely ignoring everyone else. But god damn I cannot stand him being a huge pervert, with the nosebleeds and peeping
I love how this list is judged by a mish-mash of the literary quality of the characters, her personal feelings about the characters and how they would be to be around, and the actual usefulness of the characters on her hypothetical crew. And it's never consistent which qualities weigh how heavily. Perfect chaos.
Not including Sanji is kinda insane...I get that especially women probably get turned off by the simping.. but dude, hes consistently the most reliable strawhat. Hes smart, he's szrong, he's loyal, hes saved the crew so many times. I had to stop the video because I also saw Nami wouldn't make it either.
If it’s not obvious form my pfp, Corazon is also my favorite character so I could not agree more with the placement of him. Also, I have the same issues with Enel that you do, I was consistently extremely annoyed that no one actually died from his lightning. It’s honestly comical how many people took took hits from him and ended up just fine. I think he could have been a great and intimidating villain, but the tension was absolutely killed by how nonlethal he turned out to be.
Bon clay deserves a tier all on his own. Like a "make oda bring them back" tier. Or a "first mate" tier. Bon clay in my opinion is one of the greatest fictional characters ever written
*Merphy puts Crocodile in her crew* “What could go wrong?” Me wondering how she could do this to Robin. That must be pretty awkward, the man almost killed her and she was his second in command.
@@thedoctor3528 Well, I have no idea! I am currently taking my last class before I start nursing school and probably starting this simultaneously will help me to relieve some stress.
Its weird how your absolute favorite characters come from arcs you didn't S-tier. Like Corazon came from Dressrosa and I think that was an A tier arc for you? And same w Pops.
Time to watch Merphy dig herself into a new hole. Don't you know tier lists are the most important and serious thing ever?! (Jzst kidding, of course ;) )
I feel like I'm in the minority of people who like Ace. Take marineford for example, most of the time I hear people say, "Ace dieing was sad but I'm more upset that Luffy lost his brother" I'm the opposite I was narratively thrilled that for the first time Luffy straight up loses, not a setback, not a I'll come back stronger and win, he just loses, but I was absolutely devasted that it had to come at the cost of Ace's life.
Buggy isn’t high enough. We need a separate God tier at the very top just for him. Robin, Doflamingo and Hancock are my favourite characters at the moment. I slept on Jimbei for so long. I didn’t dislike him, but he wasn’t that high up on my favourite characters list. Hearing Merphy’s love for him over this last year made me realise just how good he is though and he’s now moved way up to probably my top 10-15 favourite characters list. Hawkins was a top 5 character for me upon his introduction in Sabaody just based on his abilities and character design. I thought he was pretty cool and I was waiting for him to get focus for so long. I still want to really like him but I just don’t think he got enough to do in Wano to justify keeping him that high up as much as I really want too. 😂
enel lowkey one of the strongest in the series purely of his df but it is just incredibly unlucky for him that luffy had the one df power that makes his one completely ineffective, the rest of the crew at that time didn't stand a chance and enel showed very good observational haki (mantra) back then as well, his cover story was really cool and i would like to see him return to the story if we can at one point
IF the live action ever reaches Marineford, I hope they time the Luffy, Ace and Sabo flashback to before the war or even some time way earlier. It could fix the whole thing IMO.
You have strong feelings about a lot of the dressrosa centered characters. Seems like it was one of the high points for you in the series. Im glad cause it gets disrespected by a lot of people :)
I love your crew list. You would definitely be the pirate king/queen with them. Just don’t make Zoro be your navigator, would love to see a spin off series of that lol.
I read one piece just because you started making videos on it and i wanted to understand the reference because I love watching you and I couldn't be anymore grateful than I am ❤️❤️ thank you.
Wholesome fact about Cora Sanji is making sandwiches for the crew at one point on Punk Hazard, and Law asks for his without bread. In an sbs it's revealed that Cora hated bread, so Law had gone as far as to model his eating habits after his mentor.
I think you could also rate characters by how well written & developed they are, rather than who would you want in your crew. It hurt my soul to see where you put Sanji & Usopp, since so far in this story, I consider them the best written & most developed characters in One Piece. Doflamingo too. I realized we're missing some of fan favorites. Where are Oden, Mihawk, Kin'emon & Hancock? I also love Pudding. Oh and fun fact, Sabo was foreshadowed waaay back in Logue Town and also with Ace's tattoo with crossed S.
Ooh what was the foreshadowing in logue town? (Been a while I can't remember) - I happen to love Sabo (not sure if I'm in a minority or not but I do have a long list of reasons)
I also love how with the tattoo in hind sight is foreshadowing but at his introduction it just made it look like either he or the artist spelt his name wrong and just decided to cross the s out (which to me semmed like the chillest response ever)
My thought as well. Yes Sanji simping is annoying. But he's so damn loyal, smart, strong and reliable...but apparently Robin is muscle enough. Ugh I dunno how I feel about this. I just discovered Merphy and I disagree with a lot of her takes.
Big Mom the most underrated underloved character for real. The most human of all the powerhouses and she's hated for it. Idk, to each their own, but I thought characters were supposed to have emotions and weaknesses, not be perfect fighting machines that should never lose or who's Haki (although we know hers isn't as good as Kaido's) should never let anyone weak person even touch them. Even though Kaido has been pierced by a dying Kin'emon. I just think people don't actually understand Haki, but maybe that's just me. Haki isn't an invincible steel barrier that's always active, btw
Oh boy i was JUST polishing my pitchfork! perfect video!
Oh, wow! Great timing!
Finally, a use for this comically large torch i bought
*awkwardly putting back my rake...
Where do you put Yamato? Interested if u can drop a comment
@@ThirdEyeTy okay this might be controversial, but I'm putting her in Guest Crew Mate teir. I like her character but i don't think she has gotten enough character development for me to put her in crewmate. Her introduction was pretty sudden. Who knows, i still need to reread Wano so my opinions might change. There is a lot more behind her character and i feel a lot of development can still be done with her in terms of story.
" If You Disagree You're Wrong"
Spoken like a true One Piece fan. Glad to have you here with us.
I just loved that!
The shanks clone is actually Bon Clay and deserves to be protected at all costs
But he is in level 5.5
This is the only excuse i can come up with to forgive that neither bonchan nor iva sama are even on the list otherwise.
Clay claps the Yonko
@@isakmerilainen286 exactly, but he still deserves to be protected
@@royalfun1031 bon clay solos the whole op universe
Kuma got "protect at all cost" before the reveal of his backstory
“…if you disagree you’re wrong”
We all know you’re talking about Buggy 😂
Nah, Buggy goated 🐐
@@El-Californio That's why
Buggy best boy. Started at the bottom and stayed there all the way to the Top!
I see a trend here... wholesome fans tend to like Buggy
Corazon and Law in S Tier is all I needed to see. 👍
I find it hilarious you put Luffy up there first and said “he will not be moved“ and then you proceeded to move him immediately with the addition Buggy!!! 😂 😂
26:08 what do you mean you don't have a navigator?!?!?! What about Perona?! She not only was the navigator for Moria, but she was also able to deliver ZORO after the 2 years time skip, and he was the FIRST to arrive! How amazing of a navigator you'd have to be to do that?! With Perona you wouldn't net lost like....ever.
Also jimbei who was controlling the sunny in a godly way during whole cake
I think its interesting that every time Law has left us, he says that the next time they meet will be as enemies
And then they are allied the next time they meet.
Lol, facts!
It’s because he wants to be an edgy “bad boy” so badly, but he’s not. Lol
@@yozarian86 I think there will be a point where Law will call Luffy his friend, and then the next time they meet they will have to fight for one reason or another.
@@Treblebeatgames They might have a fight to see who’s really top pirate, but that’s only if Law lives to see Luffy again. I don’t get the feeling he’s about to die, but he might before they meet up again.
@@yozarian86
I mean, I don't think he will have his devil fruit by the end of the week XD
Gotta love that both Mihawk and Hancock didn't even make it on the list, but Karibou is here, I see how it goes
Whoever made it is trash and has no taste
I mean, by now, he's more of a main character than those two, thanks Oda :'D
And there are two shanks
Caribou has more screen time than Mihawk, Hancock, Shanks and Koby combined.
@@webcamrandomness14 Not Hancock. She has a dedicated arc of her own 😅.
The absolute vitriol for Caribou never gets old.
"put your tongue in your mouth man" swear i died in that moment
I love how Merphy's brain works. Everytime she lists the powerhouse members of her crew she doesn't mention Luffy the strongest member because she just imagines him arguing with Buggy the whole time instead of fighting
Not including Sanji in your crew would be a huge waste of the opportunity, considering you would be missing out on many delicious and never-before-tasted food, as well as one of the powerhouses who has considerable potential to further get stronger.
Couldn't agree more
I cant believe you left Sogeking out of this tier list, when Sniper Island is in your heart
"Next is Laboon, who will be protected at all costs, i don't need explain myself on that, if you think I do, you're a monster!" hahaha i loved the video and the tier Merphy, my thoughts:
- I love how Brook took a place in your heart after a bad fisrt impression.
- I think your tier is pretty clean, i just feel bad for Garp, but its ok.
- I didnt know that community was so intense with Koby, in spanish community, that intensity is for vivi xD
- I absolutely know that you did this full tierlist and video, just for atack, hate and throw out of the manga to that stupid swamp guy... the rest is all a distraction.
I read protect at all costs and immediately thought of Bon Clay, but he didnt even make it on the list, we need another list with how many characters we have
I'm still so happy someone else is giving Kuma the respect he deserves! Can't wait to learn more about his story.
are you reading the manga!? its been a great ride the past few weeks
Me too! I cannot wait to start the series!
@@RoofTopRenegade Oda keeps hinting at more information, but hopefully we will get something big next week.
@@yozarian86Guess you can say we got something really big.
That Alabasta grandpa being ranked higher than any of the Straw Hats was spectacular.
It's not a "best to worst" tierlist..
The Yuba guy one of the hardest working people in the entire series
Merphy talking about Caribou is 10/10 content
I always feel sorry for Sanji because he's such an amazing character but out of everyone he was chosen by Oda to be the pervert character. 😭 (Because In every shonen anime/manga in the 90s there was a pervert character, it was a very popular trope just like the trope of main character being dumb and loves to eat and the female character who loves hitting the main character) and i wonder if Oda didn't choose to make him a pervert he would have easily become my favorite character in the story. I just love everything about him especially that when I watched the show as a kid dubbed in Arabic, they used to cut those scenes where he was acting like a simp/pervert so i never knew he was a pervert and that helped me appreciate him as a character more.
He’s interesting because backstory explains why he likes women so much.
@@agreatmannamedlieu5122 That's a pretty good read, actually. He would have been too complex and could take too much time if he wasn't a pervert, his interactions would be hard to write with other crew members and even women. But still, it's a detriment that many people can't get over.
@@BoltAtlas I cant understand how ppl get so affected by comic relief, brook is as much of a pervert.
I just don't understand why Oda feels like he has to go so far into the pervert trope. LIke OK yeah you can make him a simp for women and have that be his flaw, but he could just leave it at that and not go into the whole creepy, predatory, groping, over the top, "making women uncomfortable and comrpomising their feeling of safety is a joke" thing. Thank goodness for the liva action showing us how good Sanji could actually be!
He was too OP
A sign that I have less popular taste when it comes to the Straw Hats is that my three favorites were all in Guest Crewmates 😅
Kohza’s dad Toto’s arch was top teir. That scene when Vivi couldn’t recognize him because he had lost so much weight. I cried. And he kept digging and staying positive. Never giving up on the king. AMAZING. Fully agree with putting him in top tier.
The moment she didn automatically put sanji on the crew the list becomes invalid.
You actually made me like pudding a lot more than I used to! I never hated her, but I wasn't a huge fan either. But looking at her the way you do, I've grown to really like her! So thanks!
Did Nami dirty by basically saying all she would do is yell and tell you where to go
To be fair to enel, he didn’t know that voltage isn’t what matters when electrocuting people and he should’ve measured his attacks in amperes
Yeah he was all flash. All arc and no bite, if you will. For reference, a static shock is high voltage (-20 kV)
I love your enthusiasm and fun conversational approach!
I feel like Vivi is such an underrated character. Tbh, I think Vivi really shaped who Luffy was as a captain. In Drum Island, Luffy was ready to go fighting, just like any pirate crew would interact, but Vivi setting Luffy's priorities straight and get him to humble himself I believe set the tone of greeting new people. Also, I think if this didn't happen, Idk if Luffy would've bowed his head down to Hammock to free Margarette.
Although I think Jinbe would be a decent navigator. I mean, he captained the Fishman Pirates and he even knows the sea currents and everything.
I didn't see Vivi in that light but that's a good point. I like her because she's one of the few princess (or kind/"innocent" woman) who puts efforts and even risks her life for her country. This type of character usually have good intentions and rely on others to take action since they're weak. Vivi couldn't do much since she's not strong but I respect her for going undercover to gather more information and giving her best. I prefer her as a Strawhat member than Yamato.
@@xenon5426 Yeah. And she has a good grasp of diplomacy. I really admired her when she didn't do anything to Wapol for slapping her because she knew that she represents Alabasta and her actions can harm the people of Alabasta. She knew if she did anything, it would become an international incident. The Yamato thing is your preference, but I don't consider Yamato a Princess. Otama for princess of Wano XD although for princess of Wano, that's Hiyori.
@@vailingbow1068 You misunderstood me. I don't consider Yamato as a princess either. I was saying I prefer Vivi joining the Strawhat crew.
@@xenon5426 Ohhh. Well, I don't agree with that tbh.
@@vailingbow1068 Do you mean that you want Yamato to be a Strawhat member?
Corazon truly was the heart, Loved his flashback with Law. But where is Bon chan!
It feels like it missed a tier of "People I would like my crew to beat"
Glad to see your love for Law and Corazon! They belong to a special top-tier list for me as well. It has a slightly different meaning from yours though haha.
I also have mixed feelings about Sanji, I really liked the formula where he would do some cool, subversive stuff (Mr prince, enies lobby gate) and I thought it was funny when it was undercut by turning into a fool around a pretty woman. I love how he makes high effort cocktails for Nami and Robin, completely ignoring everyone else. But god damn I cannot stand him being a huge pervert, with the nosebleeds and peeping
I love how this list is judged by a mish-mash of the literary quality of the characters, her personal feelings about the characters and how they would be to be around, and the actual usefulness of the characters on her hypothetical crew. And it's never consistent which qualities weigh how heavily. Perfect chaos.
Not having Nami as a crewmate?! Blasphemous. Romance Dawn’s gotta stick together forever. ❤️🩹
Not here
Not including Sanji is kinda insane...I get that especially women probably get turned off by the simping.. but dude, hes consistently the most reliable strawhat. Hes smart, he's szrong, he's loyal, hes saved the crew so many times. I had to stop the video because I also saw Nami wouldn't make it either.
Fax
If it’s not obvious form my pfp, Corazon is also my favorite character so I could not agree more with the placement of him. Also, I have the same issues with Enel that you do, I was consistently extremely annoyed that no one actually died from his lightning. It’s honestly comical how many people took took hits from him and ended up just fine. I think he could have been a great and intimidating villain, but the tension was absolutely killed by how nonlethal he turned out to be.
Bon clay deserves a tier all on his own. Like a "make oda bring them back" tier. Or a "first mate" tier. Bon clay in my opinion is one of the greatest fictional characters ever written
Without Bon Clay One Piece would have ended right there in Impel Down.
@@Alex_the_Mex facts. He was such a legend
Missed opportunity for a “donuts” tier with katakuri and ace lol
you said "he saw his brother and he smiled" and i started crying... one piece is incredible
2:22 Luffy
2:49 Buggy
3:26 Robin
4:12 Arlong
5:18 Ace
7:35 Perona
9:01 Madam Shyarley
10:11 Brook
11:29 Vivi
12:31 Franky
13:39 Vinsmoke Judge
14:11 Shanks
15:24 Jinbe
16:08 Big Mom
17:22 Sanji
19:06 Kuma
20:24 Crocodile
21:24 Corazon
22:19 Caribou
23:22 Enel
24:43 Moria
25:49 Nami
26:25 Blackbeard
27:29 Garp
27:47 Usopp
28:09 Chopper
28:23 Law
29:22 Toto
29:32 Kaido
31:39 Doflamingo
32:37 Clone Shanks?
32:59 Zoro
33:43 Kobe
35:17 Pell
36:17 Kureha
36:49 Sabo
37:53 Pudding
39:26 Laboon
39:39 Roger
40:02 Pops (Whitebeard)
Corazon is your #1 favorite character? YES dude
Yesss I’m excited!! Hope everyone puts their fave characters in the comments too, that stuff is always fun to read. For me my number 1 is Usopp :))
Card carrying Zoro-fanatic
Nami is the n°1 for me
Bon clay is my favorite. I have watched every episode with him in it multiple times and some episodes even more than 25 times
Luffy, Zoro and Law are all my number one
I love how you were giving this whole heartwarming speech about Corazon and then "Oh look, it's Caribou! DIE."
Thank you!!! Brook has been my favorite character for years now. You are still rockin it, but keep it up! Love to see ur videos!
Great to see we share favorite characters! Corazon is the best. I'm personally a big fan of Shanks too though
I'm so happy to know that I'm not the only one that loves Corazon
Oh.. what I coincidence.. let me just pick up this unattended torch over there..
*Merphy puts Crocodile in her crew* “What could go wrong?”
Me wondering how she could do this to Robin. That must be pretty awkward, the man almost killed her and she was his second in command.
YES! Tier List's, Merphy has amazing choices.
Yes! I really like tier ranking videos!
I do not know if it is just me but just watching this makes me even more excited to start this series!
*Thank you all for the likes, guys!
Why haven't you started yet?
@@thedoctor3528 Well, I have no idea! I am currently taking my last class before I start nursing school and probably starting this simultaneously will help me to relieve some stress.
You're gonna have a really fun (and sad) time! Happy starting 🙏
@@123rikin Thank you so much!
@@britneynicole8903 it weirdly gives u back the senses of wonder and awe u had as a child, transporting u to it’s fascinating world.
Don’t worry, I understand why you love Perona so much. She’s been - arguably - my favorite recurring character in the entire series
Kuma and Corazon’s placement was indisputable and I agree wholeheartedly… :’)
I almost screamed! Corazon is also my number one favourite in all of One Piece!! 💗
Same!!! I had to pause the video and just silently revel in Corazon love solidarity!!! ❤
Its weird how your absolute favorite characters come from arcs you didn't S-tier. Like Corazon came from Dressrosa and I think that was an A tier arc for you? And same w Pops.
It was a pretty surreal experience to follow fighting game community since about 2010 and to see how tier lists went mainstream. Truly bizzare.
I think this list tells us that there’s too many One Piece characters to even remember let alone rank in a tier list lol.
Time to watch Merphy dig herself into a new hole.
Don't you know tier lists are the most important and serious thing ever?!
(Jzst kidding, of course ;) )
I've never been a big White Beard guy, but Merph's added perspective has really given me new value in his character.
I’d love to see where the power couple of Rayleigh and Shakky would fit on this list for you?
You know, people don't give Perona enough credit for being able to singlehandedly defeat the monster trio in no time.
i’m so happy i’m not the only Kuma fan
Merphy going through the comments picking out all the characters she "forgot" for a part 2 if this does well
THE ONE PIECE!!! THE ONE PIECE IS REAL!!! CAN WE GET MUCH HIGHER!!!
,,...even Jack, wo can´t do anything". You couldn´t describe Jack better.
Luffy is an untouchable character out of all characters here merphy 😮💨, well at least in my opinion. kk, a fine list
23:43 I feel this so hard, this is one of the reasons that Skypeia feels like it didn't do as good as it could have been..
WHOOO! I'm going to love this!
Edit: Wait, liking Samwise better than Luffy is a sin? Geez people, grow thicker skin lol
Law being tsundere about luffy friendship. Makes me like him more than I would otherwise for sure.
We need a separate tier list for *Bon chan*
I feel like I'm in the minority of people who like Ace. Take marineford for example, most of the time I hear people say, "Ace dieing was sad but I'm more upset that Luffy lost his brother" I'm the opposite I was narratively thrilled that for the first time Luffy straight up loses, not a setback, not a I'll come back stronger and win, he just loses, but I was absolutely devasted that it had to come at the cost of Ace's life.
Buggy isn’t high enough. We need a separate God tier at the very top just for him.
Robin, Doflamingo and Hancock are my favourite characters at the moment.
I slept on Jimbei for so long.
I didn’t dislike him, but he wasn’t that high up on my favourite characters list. Hearing Merphy’s love for him over this last year made me realise just how good he is though and he’s now moved way up to probably my top 10-15 favourite characters list.
Hawkins was a top 5 character for me upon his introduction in Sabaody just based on his abilities and character design.
I thought he was pretty cool and I was waiting for him to get focus for so long. I still want to really like him but I just don’t think he got enough to do in Wano to justify keeping him that high up as much as I really want too. 😂
Honestly I'm just waiting for the day Oda reveals that Buggy was secretly the main character all along
Good luck keeping nami around when she learns you're allied with arlong 😂
enel lowkey one of the strongest in the series purely of his df but it is just incredibly unlucky for him that luffy had the one df power that makes his one completely ineffective, the rest of the crew at that time didn't stand a chance and enel showed very good observational haki (mantra) back then as well, his cover story was really cool and i would like to see him return to the story if we can at one point
"THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR" -Stephen A Smith voice
IF the live action ever reaches Marineford, I hope they time the Luffy, Ace and Sabo flashback to before the war or even some time way earlier. It could fix the whole thing IMO.
Merphy stirring the pot and loving it
I saw that immediate plot twist with the crew tier coming and it still stunned me, almost oda levels of setup and pay-off with that one!
I can see zoro training and you just casually reading a book on top of the weights 😂
Chopper post time skip is merch only
I am surprised, that the Dark King Silvers Rayleigh didn't make it on the list, my 2nd fav character over-all in One Piece
The buggy plot twist was so funny xD
Corazon as number one. I'm like you fr fr, brings me to tears every time
When you brought up your daughter while talking about Whitebeard, I was like "please don't tell me you named her Whitebeard after him".
Can I name a single One Piece character? No. Am I going to watch this anyways? Yeah.
You have strong feelings about a lot of the dressrosa centered characters. Seems like it was one of the high points for you in the series. Im glad cause it gets disrespected by a lot of people :)
I love your crew list. You would definitely be the pirate king/queen with them. Just don’t make Zoro be your navigator, would love to see a spin off series of that lol.
Unless you buy into the joke/theory that his internal compass is pointed at laugh tale so if you follow him you get there faster
zoro being navigator would cut off 90% of the series as we'll find the OP just like that.
HAHA that picture of Law, not sure if you're playing into the meme or genuinely unaware
Merphy needs to be on One Piece D&D with Rustage and co.
I read one piece just because you started making videos on it and i wanted to understand the reference because I love watching you and I couldn't be anymore grateful than I am ❤️❤️ thank you.
Yes!!!
Aw man now I feel bad who was out here bullying Merphy about her tier list
Whitebeard is everyone's adopted father!
Wholesome fact about Cora
Sanji is making sandwiches for the crew at one point on Punk Hazard, and Law asks for his without bread. In an sbs it's revealed that Cora hated bread, so Law had gone as far as to model his eating habits after his mentor.
Merphy: protect law at all cost.
Me: pls do… he is in great danger
I like any list that isn't power scaling.
That's a lot of character development from merphy putting brook in crewwmate tier
"Oh look it's Caribu, DIE!"
Aaaaand I lost it, that was hilarious!
Merphy, you forgot Sniper King
I think you could also rate characters by how well written & developed they are, rather than who would you want in your crew. It hurt my soul to see where you put Sanji & Usopp, since so far in this story, I consider them the best written & most developed characters in One Piece. Doflamingo too. I realized we're missing some of fan favorites. Where are Oden, Mihawk, Kin'emon & Hancock? I also love Pudding. Oh and fun fact, Sabo was foreshadowed waaay back in Logue Town and also with Ace's tattoo with crossed S.
I do know about the tattoo but what was in logue town?
Ooh what was the foreshadowing in logue town? (Been a while I can't remember) - I happen to love Sabo (not sure if I'm in a minority or not but I do have a long list of reasons)
I also love how with the tattoo in hind sight is foreshadowing but at his introduction it just made it look like either he or the artist spelt his name wrong and just decided to cross the s out (which to me semmed like the chillest response ever)
My thought as well. Yes Sanji simping is annoying. But he's so damn loyal, smart, strong and reliable...but apparently Robin is muscle enough. Ugh I dunno how I feel about this. I just discovered Merphy and I disagree with a lot of her takes.
Big Mom the most underrated underloved character for real. The most human of all the powerhouses and she's hated for it. Idk, to each their own, but I thought characters were supposed to have emotions and weaknesses, not be perfect fighting machines that should never lose or who's Haki (although we know hers isn't as good as Kaido's) should never let anyone weak person even touch them. Even though Kaido has been pierced by a dying Kin'emon. I just think people don't actually understand Haki, but maybe that's just me. Haki isn't an invincible steel barrier that's always active, btw
That aint the issue