Because Clan of Xymox show they respect the original song entirely, and have no problems in reproducing it to the best of their ability, without trying to make it their own style.
Brilliant! Thanks to that dude that was standing in line in Charlotte a year or so ago at the Peter Murphy show for telling me about Xymox doing this cover songs album. I would not have found it probably and am now just getting around to looking this stuff up. Fantastic !!
When I saw this I was quite fearful as JD music is very sacred territory in my mind but this is a worthy tribute to Ian Curtis etc. The synth settings are practically the same so it makes it very easy to listen to.
Absolutely fabulous , puts my cover to shame ,,, what synths did you use please ? I use the same synth JD used the Arp Omni 2 . This is the best cover on here , I've subscribed so I can see more from you ,, seems we have the same tastes in music
I don't understand how being a fan of a band = hating when other bands cover them. This is a good cover, but that aside, who cares? The original still exists and covers don't erase it.
I quite liked this but why have you changed the end keyboard line from dfgg dfgg dfgg etc to a much happier/less melancholy dfga dfga dfga? Takes all the sombreness away :/
No se por que me encanta esta musica la amo debe ser por lo oscuro de la iglesia cristiana que ya me canse creer en dios si solamente existe el dolor d la realidad que me di cuenta de que no existe dios que existo yo en este mundo cruel de la realidad y que nada me va a poder salvar de dulce y oscuro sufriento de la soleda y si no creo en dios ni en Jesus por que no esta mi alma en el cielo donde mi vida es oscuro ya que mi alma pertenece al inframundo y no tengo miedo creer en lo amo por que es la realidad ya me acostumbre a ver la vida de color negro y oscura!
No es que tenga depresion si ya de a poco me estoy acostumbrando del dolor y al sufrimiento sin llora donde m haogo en la vida del dulce y anocheser del sufrimiento donde la vida no existe la felicidad eterna que te dice dios que te va a dar la felicidad eterna para a todos los cristiano la felicidad eterna no existe es pura mentira dios y Jesús se pueden ir a la chingadamadre me canse se cristian y creer en dios
Gorgeous, deep, fascinaring... Saddest song ever; superb!
Excellent cover of a haunting song.
Pow quelle version fabuleuse, un bel hommage rendu à Ian Curtis et son groupe 🖤
I very rarely like Joy Division covers, but this one is wonderful. Well done.
Because Clan of Xymox show they respect the original song entirely, and have no problems in reproducing it to the best of their ability, without trying to make it their own style.
Really like Xymox. And can honestly say they have done the original song justice.
Brilliant! Thanks to that dude that was standing in line in Charlotte a year or so ago at the Peter Murphy show for telling me about Xymox doing this cover songs album. I would not have found it probably and am now just getting around to looking this stuff up. Fantastic !!
When I saw this I was quite fearful as JD music is very sacred territory in my mind but this is a worthy tribute to Ian Curtis etc. The synth settings are practically the same so it makes it very easy to listen to.
Eseguita con stile e rispetto nulla da dire!!!
Great cover for which is my favourite of JD songs! Thanks!
Nessuna differenza sostanziale ma l'originale rimane sempre un capolavoro
semplicemente...fantastica
Hate covers of joy division as a uber fan but the is really good they stayed true to the feel and mood of the song well done!
th-cam.com/video/6Sj0-ZPmdAs/w-d-xo.html
GRANDE JOY DIVISION
excelente cover, sicodélico, gracias!!
Saudações Brasileiras!
Wow amazing
GENIALES
best cover
Acceptable, which is the highest rating you can give to any Joy Division cover
fantastic cover and video!!!!!!!
Clan of Xymox did well on this version!
Cover muito boa...very good
Bravi i Clan...sono riusciti a creare un'ottima cover
Dość ciekawa przeróbka joy Division
Super cool and haunting.
So great Cover thanks for up it
They made so few changes to the song, and Ronny made his voice sound so similar to Ian's... I don't know what to think about this.
ficou perfeita
nicely cover -:)
They can't go wrong. Cover or not.
good cover!
Muito bom...muito
This is a tribute to this great dark song
Meu chará, entregaram o ouro em 3 minutos pro lixo do Flamengo...lamentável!
Is it cover?
Sounds likr original
Absolutely fabulous , puts my cover to shame ,,, what synths did you use please ? I use the same synth JD used the Arp Omni 2 . This is the best cover on here , I've subscribed so I can see more from you ,, seems we have the same tastes in music
lindissimo.
this song is so sad..
+lerr thats why this is beautiful no?
+clairelenoir sad songs can be beautiful
oh yes
It is Joy Division, in all fairness
Where have they been? Where have they been? HYPNOTIC
thought I was going to hate, but its all love from me
respect
Ottima versione manca solo la disperazione di Ian...nessuno può cantare sue canzoni
thick & dark, hopeless - thats a fucking great cover - thanX4sH
great!! i am a drummer and i am searching for musicians who 'll do like playing covers of joy division but its hard to find please help me!!!!
I don't understand how being a fan of a band = hating when other bands cover them. This is a good cover, but that aside, who cares? The original still exists and covers don't erase it.
Where have they bean?
who? Xymox and never stopped releasing albums
I quite liked this but why have you changed the end keyboard line from dfgg dfgg dfgg etc to a much happier/less melancholy dfga dfga dfga? Takes all the sombreness away :/
This is not terribly different from the original. But still good.
No se por que me encanta esta musica la amo debe ser por lo oscuro de la iglesia cristiana que ya me canse creer en dios si solamente existe el dolor d la realidad que me di cuenta de que no existe dios que existo yo en este mundo cruel de la realidad y que nada me va a poder salvar de dulce y oscuro sufriento de la soleda y si no creo en dios ni en Jesus por que no esta mi alma en el cielo donde mi vida es oscuro ya que mi alma pertenece al inframundo y no tengo miedo creer en lo amo por que es la realidad ya me acostumbre a ver la vida de color negro y oscura!
No es que tenga depresion si ya de a poco me estoy acostumbrando del dolor y al sufrimiento sin llora donde m haogo en la vida del dulce y anocheser del sufrimiento donde la vida no existe la felicidad eterna que te dice dios que te va a dar la felicidad eterna para a todos los cristiano la felicidad eterna no existe es pura mentira dios y Jesús se pueden ir a la chingadamadre me canse se cristian y creer en dios
Emilce Lopez ja, ja ja, ja es más triste tu ortografía
Empezaste relax, acá depresiva y luego mandaste a la chingada a dios con un tono enfurecido: eso sí me agradó :-)
If you are covering the best track ever recorded do something original. Not impressed
хорошо они ее повторили