How can a litigant look a judge in the eye and say "Yeah there's a leash law but no one enforces it at this park"? That's like claiming I shouldn't get a speeding ticket because usually there's not a cop at that intersection.
My moms in her late 60s and barely know how to work the camera on her phone. It’s totally believable that an 80 year old man didn’t know how to snap a pic on a cell phone.
I was working in a frame shop and somebody's dog ran into the room while the owner was at the counter getting something framed and jumped on me while I was working with fine art. Dog people are so entitled. That man never bought his dog back into the frame shop after that
Judge said it right. I am dog lover and have two big dogs who are sweethearts, but they are still animals and I get there are people who don't like dogs or are scared. Not everyone has to love my dogs. As I don't want every dog in my personal space.
Thank you as dog lover to admit that others are not dog lovers and do not want someone's dog sniffing or attacking them. I don't hate dogs but I don't like when people allow their dogs to jump on others or sniff or just invade my space.
My dog isn’t even 10lbs and I still keep her by my side . She hasn’t bit anyone but at the end of the day she is a dog and she’s my responsibility! She does not leave my sight. I’ve watched enough people’s court to know things happen completely randomly!
The thing of it is, in the USA all local laws indicate that in public, you must have your dog on a leash. Law. And the defendant also lost control of her two dogs.
My dog would probably run rather than bite, and I always have him on a leash walking to my left when we go out, because he’s a foot tall and no driver would see him (there’s no sidewalk in my neighborhood). Leashes are important for the safety of the dog just as much as the safety of other people.
Judge was ready to whip out her old saying. " Phones aren't just for Nast pictures ya know " 😂.. I bet she looked at the producers like ( 😮 , I can't use it guys )
I was looking for your comment! Maybe $5,000 was steep but $500 ????? IM ASHAMED TO HAVE HEARD THAT AMOUNT. I BET IF IT WAS THE JUDGES KID THAT GOT BIT SHE WOULD HAVE GAVE THE BIGGEST SPEECHES AS TO WHY $5,000 SHOULD BE GIVEN. IM ANGRY AT THE AMOUNT 😂
Damn, you people act like an aging human body is disgusting. Just wait, with any luck it will be you in a few years. You think you will always be this young?
I can't believe that she had her dog off the leash and actually put in the effort to research laws that could get her out of not paying her victim. SMH.
6:02 one of the worse things to happen in pet ownership in recent years. Fake service animals, and emotional support animals that go places they’re not meant to (they are NOT allowed in stores and restaurants), are dangerous to real service dogs (and the dogs’ handlers).
The verdict should have been more.especially if he had to pay out of pocket for the medical bills.plus all the time he takes on going to the doctors and submitting the law suit.
The defendant really made me mad in this case. Dog people have a strange ego where they think that everyone likes dogs or that it's OK to let your dogs run around off leash which is against the law. Judge Milian is absolutely right some people have dog phobias or are allergic. I think some dogs are cute but I don't want them jumping on me or barking at me or biting me. People need to have more respect for others....
@@elvickRULES EXACTLY that's the big reason why people air their drama on t.v. like this. I don't think I could ever appear on a court show like this I am too much of a private person.
Thank ypu I agree my daughter is extremely afraid of dogs. That only got worse when a dog came running at her, resulting in her almost knocking me down and her jumping into the trunk of a care. Dogs have more rights than people now today.
Dog owner not paying attention to her dogs, can't see what they are doing or where they are because she has her attention on a stack of newspapers. She had no control of her dogs because she did not have hold of the leash in a place where she is required to have hold of the leash.
This case hits a little too close to home, my granny had just turned 80 when the neighbours dog bit her, she died a few months later😢. People should have better control over their pets.
As someone who has been bit on the butt by a dog I can say it's VERY PAINFUL when you sit,so unless this 80 yr old guy is standing most of the day then he's feeling ALOT of pain and should have received the $5,000 he wanted!!!
I have a 8lbs toy poodle. I was in my neighbours backyard with my dog on a leash we were chatting, her husband arrived and suddenly my dog bit him ! I was very surprised because my dog is very friendly... animals are unpredictable.
💯 And thanks for sharing I think pet parents don't talk about it enough and most times they think because the dog is a certain breed/size it's not possible for a bite to happen. A dog of any breed any size can bite period. 👏🏽🐾💯
Why is she so cheap? Should have given him at least $1000. Not his fault that defendant was irresponsible with her dogs and he had to get a tetanus shot....
The defendant dropped the leashes to let them frolic. It's illegal and beyond reckless. Hopefullly Animal Control will cite her because the stupid NYC law called "one free bite" doesn't apply.
Just $500? That was a terrible judgment. Judge Milian really surprised and disappointed me there. The man was in pain. And he lost time getting his wound treated. $2000 would have been more appropriate.
Has she tried holding the phone with two hands, or resting it against a wall? I often have pretty shaky hands, so that’s what I do to keep my photos from being blurry. :)
I don't like it either but I think it only applies to hiking trails. The dog owners are required to review a video and affirm that their dog is "within their sight and will respond to a voice command". They pay for a "Green Tag" allowing their dog to be off leash. If it's off leash and has no green tag it's a huge fine. I bet it's illegal to have an off leash dog in downtown Boulder.
I had a family reunion a month ago, nice day, took our 6 month old puppy because dogs were allowed in the area we were in. There were signs everywhere saying dogs had to stay on a leash, we had him on an extendable leash so he could move about and at all times someone held onto his leash. He was happy greeting everybody and just running around in his limited space. But it was surprising the amount of dogs walking with their owners off leash.
The plaintiff telling the story in the beginning had me like “huh?” Lmao Edit: and then the defendant started talking and I GAGGED. 😂😂 Definitely should’ve been awarded more.
My mom is 80, totally does her best to be up with the times--but she still has a hard time figuring out how to take a photo with her phone. Check her camera roll--hardly any photos on there and if there is, we take photos for her, or we had to walk her through how to save photos we’ve sent her on her camera roll. That an 80-year old man who lives on his own doesn’t know how to take a photo with his phone is completely believable.
You shouldn't treat your dog any different to taking a child out in public. Always in eyesight! you wouldn't let ur toddler run off and not know where they were
I don’t like dogs or animals really. I love that other people love their dogs. But I don’t, so please keep them on a leash away from me. If I saw unleashed dogs at the park I wouldn’t even go in the park.
I think that some dog bite victim if they just ask the dog owner to pay for a reasonable or their hospital bill and not ask for a payday I’m sure most of the claims will not be in court. Again, this does not make the owner to let their dog off leash.
What kind of person let's their dogs loose "to graze" for crying out loud?!? Or tells the judge things like, "There's a leash law, but it isn't enforced"? (Yeah, that one didn't go over very well with Judge Milan, lol), and let's not forget the ole stand by "It's never happened before..." Arrgg! That one gets me every time! It's like these people get off on playing 'Russian Roulette" with our lives, without giving one iota of thought to how horrifically bad things could get due to their intentional misconduct. Take this lady for instance: She admitted to going to the park, sitting down, and simply dropping her dog's leashes so they could 'graze' while running loose. What if?!? Instead of the elderly man they found had been a young child, and God forbid, they killed that child. What on Earth would that stupid woman say then? "But, but, They don't enforce the leash laws!" Yeah, right! Tell THAT to the judge! because Recipe For a Law Suit: 1. One (or more) Weaponized Pit Bulls 2. One (or more) Stupid Pet Owners. Directions: Add one (or more) pit bulls to one or more stupid dog owners and B-I-N-G-O! You've got yourself a 4-figure law suit (up to 5-figures depending on your state). (NOTE: This is in no way meant to be construed as legal advice.)
I was bitten by my neighbours pitbull on my calf muscle and there was no hole in my denims. The teeth drove the material into my flesh. So it truly makes sense to me that there was a lack of puncture to the 79yr old trousers.
My 55 lb pitsky loves everybody,she's pretty,sweet face,most people want to pet her,however i keep her leashed always in public because she,if loose,will run up to people to say hi and will jump up on them.constant training is breaking that habit but i don't want a loose dog running up to me,i am a stranger and u don't know what they will do
Kinda glad she didn't go to the, they dont just take naughty pictures. Kinda felt her nudging that way... until it was obvious some 80 year old has no clue what his phone does
3:28 anyone else know that the people are full of shit when they start telling their side of the story like it's a novel. "It was a beautiful Sunday in April"....... Which has nothing to do with anything....... When somebody starts talking like that my immediate reaction is oh here we go. 😂😂😂
He's got a pretty common name so unless there's a picture in an obituary or something there's no way to really know. But there's tons of guys in their 70s and 80s with that name. I would understand if it was a less common one.
@@amandamatheny3675 the obituary lists James McCarthy of Bronx, NYC in 2021 including a fine photo. He did migrate from Cork Ireland at 18 years of age and proudly served his new country in the United States Army. I salute him for it.
I usually agree with the judge, but this old man at 79, could've died from shock, from falling after encountering 2 pitbulls off lead. My husband runs marathons and managed to outrun 2 bull mastiffs chasing him.
@@clovermccombs8597 Actually it does, it's called circumstantial evidence. In this exact case at this court it's the preponderance of the evidence the judge needs to make her judgement
@@anotherblonde "Circumstantial evidence" doesn't mean looking at hypothetical scenarios. It just means non-direct evidence used to support what actually happened (not hypothetical could haves). The plaintiff did not die from shock, he was not chased, these were not two pitbulls. Circumstantial evidence has nothing to do with entertaining those things.
Many animal owners never seem to understand that animals should always be under your personal care and control at all times. There is no wiggle room when it comes to that fact! If you can't see that and follow those rules then you don't have any business owning them...
DH, I agree. So many of these dog owners are negligent when it comes to taking the proper care, control and responsibility of their animals so that these types of incidents don't happen. It is annoying because it happens way too often..
You actually speak the truth when it comes to animals. I rehomed a German Shepard (neighbors left the puppy in the heat and took off) puppy cause I realized no way in hell could I take care of a big dog. He got a good home with people who gave him what he needed and had another high strung breed. I'll stick to my cats and small Chihuahua mix dogs.
JML: Why is it that people like you think that it's your world and the rest of us just live here? Defendant: Well, that is true and i understand that... (me: somewhere between hilarious and incredulous)
How can a litigant look a judge in the eye and say "Yeah there's a leash law but no one enforces it at this park"? That's like claiming I shouldn't get a speeding ticket because usually there's not a cop at that intersection.
My moms in her late 60s and barely know how to work the camera on her phone. It’s totally believable that an 80 year old man didn’t know how to snap a pic on a cell phone.
Especially if his phone doesn't even have a camera. On the other hand, I'm 74 and programming Linux.
That’s why the judge mentioned his friend. Why didn’t his FRIEND snap the picture of his injury is what she said.
Maybe because it was close to his bum and they were BOTH embarrassed??
My dad is 87 and knows how to take a picture with his flip phone. So it's possible. But I'm not saying this gentleman knows how to.
I was working in a frame shop and somebody's dog ran into the room while the owner was at the counter getting something framed and jumped on me while I was working with fine art. Dog people are so entitled. That man never bought his dog back into the frame shop after that
Judge said it right. I am dog lover and have two big dogs who are sweethearts, but they are still animals and I get there are people who don't like dogs or are scared. Not everyone has to love my dogs. As I don't want every dog in my personal space.
I own two big labs and I don’t want them in my space all the time lol
@@ashleyquam Exactly 😅 specially when they think my bed is theirs
Thank you as dog lover to admit that others are not dog lovers and do not want someone's dog sniffing or attacking them. I don't hate dogs but I don't like when people allow their dogs to jump on others or sniff or just invade my space.
The look on Douglas' face when Judge Marilyn says "would you like my bailiff to take a picture" 😂😂😂
Hahaha! I paused the video to check the comments for that! Douglas' face 😳😑Too funny!
I so caught that too!! I got SUCH a laugh 😂😂 at his eyes getting BIG, then looking away! 😂😂
@@JamieM470 This is why he decided not to return to her new show after this show got cancelled earlier this year!
I'll say this again dog owners are responsible for their dogs. No excuses 💯
As a dog owner I agree
My dogs don’t listen to no one, not even the cops.
@Chchchchchivo well then you are a bad animal owner
@@Chchchchchivothen you should shell out money for training or give them up. You're a bad owner otherwise.
@@Chchchchchivoand it would be "my dogs don't listen to anyone". I know elementary school English is tough. 🤣
My dog isn’t even 10lbs and I still keep her by my side . She hasn’t bit anyone but at the end of the day she is a dog and she’s my responsibility! She does not leave my sight. I’ve watched enough people’s court to know things happen completely randomly!
The thing of it is, in the USA all local laws indicate that in public, you must have your dog on a leash. Law. And the defendant also lost control of her two dogs.
My dog would probably run rather than bite, and I always have him on a leash walking to my left when we go out, because he’s a foot tall and no driver would see him (there’s no sidewalk in my neighborhood). Leashes are important for the safety of the dog just as much as the safety of other people.
Judge Milian was 10000% correct about irresponsible dog owners and how people need to take more personal responsibility.
Judge was ready to whip out her old saying.
" Phones aren't just for Nast pictures ya know " 😂.. I bet she looked at the producers like ( 😮 , I can't use it guys )
$500 was nowhere near enough.
I was looking for your comment! Maybe $5,000 was steep but $500 ????? IM ASHAMED TO HAVE HEARD THAT AMOUNT. I BET IF IT WAS THE JUDGES KID THAT GOT BIT SHE WOULD HAVE GAVE THE BIGGEST SPEECHES AS TO WHY $5,000 SHOULD BE GIVEN. IM ANGRY AT THE AMOUNT 😂
A quick nip lol, I love how dog owners say stuff like that. A quick nip still hurts.
Douglas has a glamorous job 😂😅😂😂
The defendant is a trip, she just literally made excuses for her lack of accountability 🤦🏽♀️
He looks fantastic for 79!!!
Douglas was like, “Seriously?! I have to look at this old guy’s butt?!” 😂
Lmao my thought was "Poor Douglas."
lol ... we're all glad the doubting defendant didn't demand to see the ass pic uploaded to that big HD monitor.
😂😂 right Douglas was like damn how I get voluntold to take the pic 😂
Damn, you people act like an aging human body is disgusting. Just wait, with any luck it will be you in a few years. You think you will always be this young?
The plaintiffs accent is adorable ❤
It is! He’s so adorable
Probably an Irishman but idk
GREAT GUY AND A VET
I can't believe that she had her dog off the leash and actually put in the effort to research laws that could get her out of not paying her victim. SMH.
Jill walked into court with a pep in her step and a fire in her belly!
How you go from your dogs didn’t bite him because they were right next to you, to you can’t be sure because you didn’t see or hear anything? Lady..
I wish Judge Judy had heard this case.
Love to see HER reaction when the defendant said "Shut up and let me tell my story."!!!!!
I couldn't believe JM let that slide!
Judge Judy? Case is dismissed.
I know. I was like, 😳
Another dog owner that doesn't think that leash laws apply to her and is not willing to accept that her dogs bit someone.
6:02 one of the worse things to happen in pet ownership in recent years. Fake service animals, and emotional support animals that go places they’re not meant to (they are NOT allowed in stores and restaurants), are dangerous to real service dogs (and the dogs’ handlers).
he should of gotten more than 500 to teach HER leash your dog lady!!!!
The verdict should have been more.especially if he had to pay out of pocket for the medical bills.plus all the time he takes on going to the doctors and submitting the law suit.
Love Judge let this entitled woman have it!!!!
Judge Milian is GLOWING!!
Always
20 years ago, my 80 year old Grandmother wanted a cell phone but half the time she couldn’t figure out how to use the landline 😂
The defendant really made me mad in this case. Dog people have a strange ego where they think that everyone likes dogs or that it's OK to let your dogs run around off leash which is against the law. Judge Milian is absolutely right some people have dog phobias or are allergic. I think some dogs are cute but I don't want them jumping on me or barking at me or biting me. People need to have more respect for others....
The way the camera caught Douglas go 👀👀👀 when the judge volunteered him to take a photo of the plaintiff's ass had me witch cackling 💀
If you engage an attorney to sue for damages from a dog bite, you will get more than you do in this court even though you have to pay the attorney.
You might never get paid that way. This way you’re guaranteed money.
@@elvickRULES
EXACTLY that's the big reason why people air their drama on t.v. like this. I don't think I could ever appear on a court show like this I am too much of a private person.
@@elvickRULESif they are home owners you can. You can even sue the landlord if they are renters.
The look on Douglas' face when he realized that he's going to have to take a photo of this old guys butt. 🤣🤣🤣
Amazing 😂
lol .. and we're lucky the Judge didn't upload the photo of his bum to the HD monitor.
haha, the look douglas gave the judge
Thank ypu I agree my daughter is extremely afraid of dogs. That only got worse when a dog came running at her, resulting in her almost knocking me down and her jumping into the trunk of a care. Dogs have more rights than people now today.
THANK YOU JM LEASH LAWS ARE FOR A REASON! ✔️🐾
Dog owner not paying attention to her dogs, can't see what they are doing or where they are because she has her attention on a stack of newspapers. She had no control of her dogs because she did not have hold of the leash in a place where she is required to have hold of the leash.
This case hits a little too close to home, my granny had just turned 80 when the neighbours dog bit her, she died a few months later😢. People should have better control over their pets.
Sorry for your lost❤
As someone who has been bit on the butt by a dog I can say it's VERY PAINFUL when you sit,so unless this 80 yr old guy is standing most of the day then he's feeling ALOT of pain and should have received the $5,000 he wanted!!!
he should've but unfortunately, he had no pictures from when the scene took place (he could've taken them once he got home)
I thought she was 100% going to say that her dogs were both on leash, but nope, lol! 😂
I have a 8lbs toy poodle. I was in my neighbours backyard with my dog on a leash we were chatting, her husband arrived and suddenly my dog bit him ! I was very surprised because my dog is very friendly... animals are unpredictable.
💯
And thanks for sharing I think pet parents don't talk about it enough and most times they think because the dog is a certain breed/size it's not possible for a bite to happen. A dog of any breed any size can bite period. 👏🏽🐾💯
Why is she so cheap? Should have given him at least $1000. Not his fault that defendant was irresponsible with her dogs and he had to get a tetanus shot....
She always goes very low on "rough justice."
Because the show is paying
that opening angle was more cinematic than usual 😂
The defendant dropped the leashes to let them frolic. It's illegal and beyond reckless. Hopefullly Animal Control will cite her because the stupid NYC law called "one free bite" doesn't apply.
No, she actually used a much more poor choice of words. She said that she let them GRAZE. And graze they did.
Just $500? That was a terrible judgment. Judge Milian really surprised and disappointed me there.
The man was in pain. And he lost time getting his wound treated. $2000 would have been more appropriate.
Stop making excuses for your pet keep them on a leash or else .
As a dog owner ouch I know but you are responsible unless they are under your control. A fenced yard or a leash in your hand.
My mom is in her 60s and can work her camera on her phone but can't take a clear picture to save our lives!!
Has she tried holding the phone with two hands, or resting it against a wall? I often have pretty shaky hands, so that’s what I do to keep my photos from being blurry. :)
Guy is a dead ringer for the old guy in the Garfield Halloween Special
LOOK AT DOUG'S EYES!!! (when he had to take the pic)
The arrogance of the defendant really rubs me the wrong way.
In Boulder people have their dogs off leash all the time and I hate it.
I don't like it either but I think it only applies to hiking trails. The dog owners are required to review a video and affirm that their dog is "within their sight and will respond to a voice command". They pay for a "Green Tag" allowing their dog to be off leash. If it's off leash and has no green tag it's a huge fine. I bet it's illegal to have an off leash dog in downtown Boulder.
She doesn’t want her name mentioned? Already a strike against her before hearing the case smh
Only $500?! Swap him out for a 10 year old and he would have got $5,000.
He should have went to Judge Judy 😂😂 she would have at least awarded him $1500.
And would have had a life lesson for the defendant when she said "Shut up and let me tell my story."
Just said the same thing.
I had a family reunion a month ago, nice day, took our 6 month old puppy because dogs were allowed in the area we were in. There were signs everywhere saying dogs had to stay on a leash, we had him on an extendable leash so he could move about and at all times someone held onto his leash. He was happy greeting everybody and just running around in his limited space. But it was surprising the amount of dogs walking with their owners off leash.
Why do people bring dogs to a family reunion?
What kind of puppy?
@@mikieanthony777 He was only a few months old and suffering from separation anxiety, he is getting over it now.
@@LoveChild71 A cross between a Japanese Spitz and a Toy Poodle, looks more like a fluffy terrier with a tail that gurls over like a samoyed.
@@mickm6309
Oh. I get it now.
@4:35 Well, the defendant is about to have the law enforced on her. What a silly comment and lack of personal responsibility.
The plaintiff telling the story in the beginning had me like “huh?” Lmao
Edit: and then the defendant started talking and I GAGGED. 😂😂
Definitely should’ve been awarded more.
The way she gave us so much unnecessary info about how it was a nice day, down to the fact that she had newspapers to read. Lady, no one cares.
@@Amy-ej2px 😂😂😂
I grew up in that neighborhood. I know that park. People let their dogs roam free in that park all the time.
Don't underestimate people in their 60's & 80's.
My mom is 80, totally does her best to be up with the times--but she still has a hard time figuring out how to take a photo with her phone. Check her camera roll--hardly any photos on there and if there is, we take photos for her, or we had to walk her through how to save photos we’ve sent her on her camera roll. That an 80-year old man who lives on his own doesn’t know how to take a photo with his phone is completely believable.
The D still isn’t apologetic at all! She should be ashamed! Apologize!!!!
HMMMMM THEY DON'T APOLOGIZE FOR SHIT.
Grandpa should have gotten more than 500.
Lmao the bailiffs face when judge Milian says he would take a picture that close ro his bottom 😅😂
The plaintiff wanna score extra money and lying, he was just slightly bit.
My diary of pain 24/7 💔😂
You shouldn't treat your dog any different to taking a child out in public. Always in eyesight! you wouldn't let ur toddler run off and not know where they were
I don’t like dogs or animals really. I love that other people love their dogs. But I don’t, so please keep them on a leash away from me. If I saw unleashed dogs at the park I wouldn’t even go in the park.
The plaintiff looks a kind guy. He kinda reminds me of The BFG
I think that some dog bite victim if they just ask the dog owner to pay for a reasonable or their hospital bill and not ask for a payday I’m sure most of the claims will not be in court. Again, this does not make the owner to let their dog off leash.
I am with the Judge!
U gotta watch ur dogs at all times especially when u go on walks and stuff. Some people are slack like that .
What kind of person let's their dogs loose "to graze" for crying out loud?!? Or tells the judge things like, "There's a leash law, but it isn't enforced"? (Yeah, that one didn't go over very well with Judge Milan, lol), and let's not forget the ole stand by "It's never happened before..." Arrgg! That one gets me every time! It's like these people get off on playing 'Russian Roulette" with our lives, without giving one iota of thought to how horrifically bad things could get due to their intentional misconduct.
Take this lady for instance: She admitted to going to the park, sitting down, and simply dropping her dog's leashes so they could 'graze' while running loose. What if?!? Instead of the elderly man they found had been a young child, and God forbid, they killed that child. What on Earth would that stupid woman say then? "But, but, They don't enforce the leash laws!"
Yeah, right! Tell THAT to the judge!
because
Recipe For a Law Suit: 1. One (or more) Weaponized Pit Bulls 2. One (or more) Stupid Pet Owners.
Directions: Add one (or more) pit bulls to one or more stupid dog owners and B-I-N-G-O! You've got yourself a 4-figure law suit (up to 5-figures depending on your state).
(NOTE: This is in no way meant to be construed as legal advice.)
I was bitten by my neighbours pitbull on my calf muscle and there was no hole in my denims. The teeth drove the material into my flesh. So it truly makes sense to me that there was a lack of puncture to the 79yr old trousers.
Old man trying to rob this lady lol
My 55 lb pitsky loves everybody,she's pretty,sweet face,most people want to pet her,however i keep her leashed always in public because she,if loose,will run up to people to say hi and will jump up on them.constant training is breaking that habit but i don't want a loose dog running up to me,i am a stranger and u don't know what they will do
Kinda glad she didn't go to the, they dont just take naughty pictures. Kinda felt her nudging that way... until it was obvious some 80 year old has no clue what his phone does
did you see his eyes when she said my balif will take the pic for you
3:28 anyone else know that the people are full of shit when they start telling their side of the story like it's a novel. "It was a beautiful Sunday in April"....... Which has nothing to do with anything....... When somebody starts talking like that my immediate reaction is oh here we go. 😂😂😂
And stop bringing your dogs into stores that sell food!!!!!!!!! It's unbelievable the nerve of some people...........
He passed away in 2021
you mean the plaintiff? How do you find that out?
@@amandamatheny3675Probably Googling his name.
He's got a pretty common name so unless there's a picture in an obituary or something there's no way to really know. But there's tons of guys in their 70s and 80s with that name. I would understand if it was a less common one.
@@amandamatheny3675 the obituary lists James McCarthy of Bronx, NYC in 2021 including a fine photo.
He did migrate from Cork Ireland at 18 years of age and proudly served his new country in the United States Army. I salute him for it.
3:47 they all called each other the night before lol
$70 for some pants. Expensive pants
The plaintiff reminds me of Burt Mustin...😊
Riverdale? Did the defendant see Archie, Reggie, Veronica and Betty while she was reading her stack of newspapers in the park?
Just fyi. You can’t just easily fly with dogs anymore. You have to register them with the tsa
I usually agree with the judge, but this old man at 79, could've died from shock, from falling after encountering 2 pitbulls off lead. My husband runs marathons and managed to outrun 2 bull mastiffs chasing him.
The law doesn't deal with what ifs or what could have happened.
@@clovermccombs8597 Actually it does, it's called circumstantial evidence. In this exact case at this court it's the preponderance of the evidence the judge needs to make her judgement
@@anotherblonde "Circumstantial evidence" doesn't mean looking at hypothetical scenarios. It just means non-direct evidence used to support what actually happened (not hypothetical could haves). The plaintiff did not die from shock, he was not chased, these were not two pitbulls. Circumstantial evidence has nothing to do with entertaining those things.
@@newsflash7609 Falls and complications thereof are one of the most common causes of death to the old
So he should have gotten $5,000?
Wow doesn't think she needs to follow the laws, if there isn't a police officer right there watching her.
Must have missed something. There was no testimony about the actual bite incident.
500?? That's it?? Sheesh...
$500. OUTRAGEOUS $3000>5000
Wow! I didnt think he was 80! … well 79 but still!
Many animal owners never seem to understand that animals should always be under your personal care and control at all times. There is no wiggle room when it comes to that fact! If you can't see that and follow those rules then you don't have any business owning them...
There are so many pet owners like the defendant and it's so fkn annoying.
DH, I agree. So many of these dog owners are negligent when it comes to taking the proper care, control and responsibility of their animals so that these types of incidents don't happen. It is annoying because it happens way too often..
You actually speak the truth when it comes to animals. I rehomed a German Shepard (neighbors left the puppy in the heat and took off) puppy cause I realized no way in hell could I take care of a big dog. He got a good home with people who gave him what he needed and had another high strung breed. I'll stick to my cats and small Chihuahua mix dogs.
That's true
I agree. She didn't consider that kids are in the park. If a child "backs up" in fear of a dog they become prey. This could have been a lot worse.
Hahahahaha lady he won
The defendant thinks she is entitled and let her dogs do whatever in the park she is delusional
Awful, $500👎👎👎👎
JML: Why is it that people like you think that it's your world and the rest of us just live here?
Defendant: Well, that is true and i understand that...
(me: somewhere between hilarious and incredulous)
You were walking briskly but have to sit down for court?
So typical of "Riverdale" folks.. so privileged.
Clever letter 13
Happy Thursday all, except for Mick from Australia, happy Friday
7:45😳 😂😂😂
Clever soldier 69