In my opinion, Nations inside of the states also have boundaries (tangible) in some contexts. Some nations inside of the states also later achieve autonomous states (but might not achieve the level of states - in relation to recognition from other states, or diplomatic actions). There are nations (but still part of the states) exercising executive, legislation, judicial and a self-determined economic. Not just as imagined communities, but as a tangible political organization. Thanks for this video...
Dear sir. Thank u so much for this initiative n providing us this quality content free of cost. I think i can rely upon ur lessona fot my optional preparation.
India is clearly a multinational state. And that is fine as nations within the federal state are willing participants and have their fair share of self-rule. This would bring us to a secondary question in the line of "is the Tamil nation a stateless nation?" I would say that not because it has its own self-rule and is (AFAIK) willing participant in the Indian Union. More delicate would be asking the same question about Kashmir or Assam however. Side note: nobody says "Basque Region", not even Spaniards. It's always the "Basque Country", that's because "country" has a primary meaning of territory with some sort of demographic homogeneity (ethnic identity or sometimes just sub-ethnic "regional" one) and only secondarily is used as synonym of state. This is particularly true in French and Spanish language contexts: Pays Basque but also Pays de la Loire (Country of the Loire, which has no ethnic or national identity). In Basque it'd be more nuanced because the term is Euskal Herria, where Euskal = Basque and Herria = Country, People, Nation and even village.
Yes, Palestinians are currently members of a stateless nation, although the sovereignty of Palestine has been recognized by 135 member countries of the U.N. The term “State of Palestine” is only used officially by Sweden.
Belgium, Canada, India, and Spain are state-nations. Each has geographically concentrated ethnocommunal differences..."State emphasize/ promotes /sponsors nationalism" in these countries .
You may mean "nation-state" (never heard "state nation"): it means a state that is also a nation, ideally no ethnic minority of relevance exists within its borders. However many so-called nation-states actually have a core nation (ethnicity) and also oppress minority nations, for example Turkey is a "nation-state" that oppresses the Kurdish nation, Spain is a "nation-state" (of the Castilians, alias Spaniards) that oppresses nations like mine (Basque), Catalans, Galicians, etc. France is a nation-state of the French oppression various minor nations such as Corsicans, etc.
@@TheGeoecologist - So "state nation" is an Indian specific concept? I may have got lost in translation, so to say, in lack of the exact cultural reference. In any case a strict nation-state would be something like Hungary, whose borders have been cut so much that what remains is purely ethnic Hungarian. In South Asia the only strict nation-state I can think of would be Maldives. But what is a "state-nation"?
Link for eBook ( downloadable pdf) : mithilacraft.com/product/simplified-political-geography-e-book-by-dr-krishnanand/
In my opinion, Nations inside of the states also have boundaries (tangible) in some contexts. Some nations inside of the states also later achieve autonomous states (but might not achieve the level of states - in relation to recognition from other states, or diplomatic actions). There are nations (but still part of the states) exercising executive, legislation, judicial and a self-determined economic. Not just as imagined communities, but as a tangible political organization.
Thanks for this video...
Dear sir. Thank u so much for this initiative n providing us this quality content free of cost. I think i can rely upon ur lessona fot my optional preparation.
Explained clearly with the basics. Thankyou!
Thankyou for the explanation.
Sir what are attributes of a state is it the shape, size or tge population etc?
Maza aa gaya explanation sun ke! Awesome content!
Thank u Dear. its excellent presentations so if you are demand a need your lecture again on international political economy
Just I love your concept sir g
Thank you so much sir 👏👏
India is clearly a multinational state. And that is fine as nations within the federal state are willing participants and have their fair share of self-rule.
This would bring us to a secondary question in the line of "is the Tamil nation a stateless nation?" I would say that not because it has its own self-rule and is (AFAIK) willing participant in the Indian Union. More delicate would be asking the same question about Kashmir or Assam however.
Side note: nobody says "Basque Region", not even Spaniards. It's always the "Basque Country", that's because "country" has a primary meaning of territory with some sort of demographic homogeneity (ethnic identity or sometimes just sub-ethnic "regional" one) and only secondarily is used as synonym of state. This is particularly true in French and Spanish language contexts: Pays Basque but also Pays de la Loire (Country of the Loire, which has no ethnic or national identity). In Basque it'd be more nuanced because the term is Euskal Herria, where Euskal = Basque and Herria = Country, People, Nation and even village.
Appreciated 👏👍
Thnk u sir
Hello sir , can't understand point number 6 in ' state vs nation '
It's okay to not understand everything...keep learning
Sir, can we say India is a multi nation state?
I'd say so.
Your video was good and clear all the points but for your kind information, Balochistan isn't a stateless nation !!
Can Palestine be labelled as a Stateless Nation too?
Yes, Palestinians are currently members of a stateless nation, although the sovereignty of Palestine has been recognized by 135 member countries of the U.N. The term “State of Palestine” is only used officially by Sweden.
Great video sir can you provde this ppt presentation file on telegram it will help to make note
Sir geography optional ka paper discuss kare
Coming soon 😊👍
What is "State Nation"? Some examples of State Nation.
Belgium, Canada, India, and Spain are state-nations. Each has geographically concentrated ethnocommunal differences..."State emphasize/ promotes /sponsors nationalism" in these countries .
You may mean "nation-state" (never heard "state nation"): it means a state that is also a nation, ideally no ethnic minority of relevance exists within its borders. However many so-called nation-states actually have a core nation (ethnicity) and also oppress minority nations, for example Turkey is a "nation-state" that oppresses the Kurdish nation, Spain is a "nation-state" (of the Castilians, alias Spaniards) that oppresses nations like mine (Basque), Catalans, Galicians, etc. France is a nation-state of the French oppression various minor nations such as Corsicans, etc.
It's a new perspective on state sponsored nationalism...new discourse in subcontinent.
@@TheGeoecologist - So "state nation" is an Indian specific concept? I may have got lost in translation, so to say, in lack of the exact cultural reference.
In any case a strict nation-state would be something like Hungary, whose borders have been cut so much that what remains is purely ethnic Hungarian. In South Asia the only strict nation-state I can think of would be Maldives.
But what is a "state-nation"?
Please see : www.journalofdemocracy.org/articles/book-review-discovering-the-state-nation/
We Love Sir From Pakistan 🍀🌺