2023 HWS Round Robin - Round 3, Room A
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ส.ค. 2024
- Motion: This house would legalize active non-voluntary euthanasia.
Information Slide:
1) Active euthanasia is where proactive steps are taken to hasten someone’s death with the aim of minimizing suffering.
2) Non-voluntary euthanasia involves patients not competent to consent (e.g., those in a coma, with dementia, etc.), where someone else consents to hastening their death.
3) If a patient has (while competent) officially filed an “advance directive” about hastening their death under their current health circumstances, then this is NOT a case of non-voluntary euthanasia.
Opening Government: McGill
Opening Opposition: LSE CC
Closing Government: Princeton CL
Closing Opposition: Malaya
NOTE: Speakers are assigned their topics and positions (i.e., for or against) by the tournament, so none of the statements by any speaker should be understood or represented to reflect the actual beliefs of that person, nor do the speakers guarantee the veracity of any claims they articulate. They should be understood to be playacting their advocacy.
Results:
Panel 1 - OG > CG > CO > OO
Panel 2 - CG > OO > OG > CO
speaker points?
Format:
Speaker: Notes Panel, No-notes Panel
PM - 82, 80
DPM - 83, 81
LO - 77, 80
DLO - 79, 82
MG - 81, 82
GW - 81, 83
MO - 78, 80
OW - 79, 80