Was Nagini A Woman? | Harry Potter Theory
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ส.ค. 2024
- Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald just released a new cast photo so J dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to discuss Claudia Kim's new character and if she come become the great snake: Nagini
Hey Super Carlin Friends! ►► bit.ly/196DDlu
Google Autofill Playlist ►► bit.ly/1DCdQNm
Theories ►► bit.ly/1z5uZcS
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)
![Why the Horcrux in Harry Wasn't Destroyed by the Basilisk [Harry Potter Explained]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/h6scJZPJo7E/mqdefault.jpg)
At this point you guys need a playlist just labeled "WE TOTALLY CALLED IT!!!!"
So true
Heck yeah
DEFINITLEY
BRING IT TO US
Missy Barbour yes
YOU GOT IT SPOT ON
MKVD exactly 😄
MKVD I literally came here just to say this 😂
Same haha
Same
yep, I think Mrs Norris was a woman too
The Brothers Situation
SuperCarlin : *posts video*
Warner : *sweats anxiously*
J is a wizard and knows the history.
Wow big brain
I'm watching this in 2020 so Fantastic beasts has already confirmed this theory which makes this video even better
10 months after this video and we get a trailer confirming that the girl's name is nagini. *boom*
Ira Teves I KNOW!! IM FREAKIN OUT!! 🙀
I've been sending the link to this video to everyone I know (who was shocked/affected) by the reveal hahaha
*unfuckingbelievable* 💥💥💥😱😱😱😱😱😱😲😲😲😲😲😲 wowwwww
Ira Teves
-boom boom, we are not pirates (lol)
*bOoM*
YOU CALLED IT J OMG. In the final trailer Credence calls her Nagini.
Lol was just about to make this same comment
I am shakinggggg
👏🏻👏🏻
Just saw the trailer, heard credence and was like HAAAAY BROTHER
Omg I just immediately came back to this video!!!!
2017 ME: HMMMM MAYBE NAGINI IS A WOMAN
2019 ME: OMG HE GOT IT CORRECT
2021:
@@niceguy1891 mirror verse wait he call it on vid that explains how dumbodore got the stone in the mirror
Okay, I have a theory about how Nagini could ‘become’ Bathilda: Nagini was human, so she could take polyjuice potion and be restored to a human form for a small amount of time.
Yeah, that could be the case but how could they time it so perfectly and have polyjuice on hand?
But when Nagini was pretending to be Bathilda she could still only speak in Parseltongue.
in the book, Nagini is inside Bathilda by black magic and literally bursts out of Bathildas corpse. Yeah. lovely
She shouldve shaved her head should she could've drank loads of polyjuice pofions
Yes! I love this theory.
does this mean that Miss Norris could have been a human in the past? If she was, and Filch knew her, it would explain why he cares so much for her, and why she's so clever.
i always thought that it's his wife or daughter
Oh my gosh, yes! That would explain so much!
MoonChild I️’ve always thought Mrs. Norris was a person!
oh my god that is so creepy weird, but makes total sense as well.
MoonChild OMG yassssssssss!
In Indian mythology 'nagini' or 'nagin' is the woman who can transform herself into snake whenever she wants.
preeti patel how do you know that
Fun Things It's a pretty well known mythology in India. A lot of old bollywood movies have a Nagin/ Nagini as the villain or heroine. Pretty much any Indian would have heard this myth.
preeti patel ... Nagina...
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW!
It is called ichhadhari nagin (transforming at will just like an animagus) and not just any common nagin.
Theory: The brothers actually know the wizarding history because they're wizards in disguise.
Interesting hmmmm
Here to tell us some things so we trust them but still keep enough a secret so we don’t get too smart
You should make videos where you react to former theories... like "we totally called it" or "well that one didn't add up buuuut..." i would totally love that
who came here after watching the final trailer?
mee 🙋♀️🙋♀️
Toooootes!
Me. I kinda feel like my life is a lie
Me.
meee haha
I have a theory that might sound crazy. What if Mrs. Norris is actually a witch? Or maybe, was a witch. For one thing, she's the only animal visible on the Marauder's Map, almost like how Animagi are able to be seen on it. And Filch treats her like his closest companion. So, what if, Mrs. Norris was actually a witch, perhaps someone Filch was close to, like a best friend, or even a possible love interest, but something happened, turning her into a cat. My theory, stemming from this new information released about Fantastic Beasts 2, is that Mrs. Norris is a Maledictus, whose blood was cursed, so she became a cat. Filch, who cared about her, kept her as his 'pet', but gives her free roam of the castle, like a person would have. Think about it. It's often mentioned in the books how she seems to be keeping eyes on the students and such, like a lookout for Filch. Can you picture a normal cat doing that? And, in Chamber of Secrets, it's Mrs. Norris that gets attacked, rather than Filch, who is a Squib. It never made sense to me that Voldemort/Tom Riddle would pull his punches like that, rather than attacking what would be a more suitable target. I don't know. It might just be a coincidence.
Singing Wolf OH SHIT YOU ARE RIGHT!!!
Yeah, and think about it. Crookshanks is never seen on the map. Or Hedwig. So why is Mrs. Norris?
I always used to think about this exactly thing when a I was a child
Singing Wolf the only thing that u got wrong is that mrs Norris wasn’t purposely petrified it was just an accident when she looked into the water outside of moaning myrtles toilet
I guess that's true.
Y'ALL TOTALLY CALLED THIS!!!!! Pottermore has an article about Nagini, and I'm kinda upset that they didn't give you credit for calling it 10 FREAKING MONTHS IN ADVANCE!!!
Actually I remember the fifth book of Harry Potter, there was a floor for blood curses and some diseases in St. Mungo's...when the Weasley family and Harry went to visit Arthur post his injury. Need to check that up though. It could be a great placement/ call back to it! I wonder if At Mungo's set up this department in reaction to that?
Hey brothers
THIS THEORY HAS BEEN CONFIRMED BY THE FINAL TRAILER FOR FANTASTIC BEASTS 2
I'M FREAKING OUT SO MUCH,I CAN'T BELIEVE THEY WERE RIGHT!
ikr same. i still have the chills
CAME HERE TO SAY THIS, OMG
👍🏻
Oh, thank you for the spoilers! Very helpful, now I can finally watch the trailer without the surprise!
Dictus isn't to speak, it's has been spoken. So Maledictus would be 'Evil has been spoken' AKA cursed
Cathy Box omg even better🙃
Correct. "Maledictus" just means "curse", like "malediction" - opposite of "benediction". I don't think there's anything else to learn from the word itself. It's a perfectly cromulent Latin word.
I am also a Slytherin
THANK YOU. It was driving me crazy the whole time he was talking about it.
Cathy Box, Thanks for mentioning that! Yep, it just means "the cursed one". In analysis "someone who has been told something evil". Just like "benedictus" means "someone who has been praised".
mark my words, in Fantastic beasts 3-5 we'll meet two people of similar powers. A stuffy McGonagall type character named Mrs. Norris, and a scruffy shady Rogue type character named Crookshanks.
Isn't going well rn
I still believe crookshanks is the potters cat named Anna
According to Indian folk tale nagini is a female half snake half human, it can shifts its shape to any living form and it protects a precious stone named "nagmani"... Most of stories of nagin is always about getting revenge!
Its from the indonesian mythical creatures that they called 'Naga Gini' ... jo said that herself
@@jepe.14 Jo said that but it doesn't change the truth. Indonesiansian lore also has tales of snake humans but the concept originated from India and later spread to the Southeastern regions of Asia.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not denying Indonesian myth of Naga Gini but it's annoying when ignorants shout that Naaga is exclusively Indonesian myth and not Indian.
@@jepe.14 dude Indonesia was under Hindu rule only
@@superpeanutcrusade9208 Yep and a Hindi one too I think
This theory makes a good amount of sense to me. One thing that has always bothered me about Nagini is the fact that she doesn't match any known species of snake, in real life or in Harry Potter. Her massive size indicates that she would by some sort of python, a constrictor, but her fangs make her seem more like a viper, a venomous snake. There is no venomous snake of that size in real life or (if memory serves) listed in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them. To me, the idea that Nagini might be a human cursed into snake form similar to a werewolf (which, despite supposedly turning into a wolf at moonlight, turns into something significantly different and far more dangerous, like Nagini's different form relative to a snake) could explain her significant deviation from standard serpent species, as well as the magical properties of her venom. Also, if Credence is the father and Nagini is his and the unnamed woman's child, that could explain her ability to turn into the elderly woman in Deathly Hallows. Credence, being an Obscurial, is able to shapeshift to and from human form almost at will. If his daughter inherited something like this ability, it could be how she transforms back to human, and help explain some of the dark properties of ehr very being.
Nate TSO YES
Nate TSO I don't think being a obscurial is hereditary, but I'm pretty sure strong magic is and I'm pretty sure that Credence has been shown to be one, as it is the only way he could've survived as an obscurial as said in the movie, so perhaps that's how Nagini is able to transform into Bathilda Bagshot. I'm not sure if a person with her disease retains their magic after transforming, but if they do then that would be a good explanation. Of course this is still assuming Credence is the father.
He is saying that the girl in the picture is Nagini
Sophia Ponnuru I doubt it is either, just something I wanted to suggest. I mean, Credence's entire body transforms into the obscurus and back, so that could include his DNA, but obviously this is magic we're talking about so that means nothing. That is a good point you make that it might be Credence's strong magical blood that enables Nagini to maintain some of her magic once in animal form. I would assume that they normally lose their magic upon transforming, as keeping it would kind of defeat the purpose of the curse, just allowing them to transfigure themselves back to human. This would also fit well with Credence, who in and of himself bears a curse, but is an exception to many of its supposed rules, so his daughter could be an exception to the rules of her own curse.
+Underrated Ravenclaw Who is saying that? The video is saying that she is the possible mother to nagini based on a snakes life in the series it would be highly unlikely that claudia is in fact nagini herself but her mother. So possibly Credence and Claudia are the mother and father to whoever becomes Nagini.
*The ability to speak parsletongue makes you a parslemouth, the language itself is parsletongue.
Gus Waldspurger I came here for this comment 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Parseltongue*
Thank the gods; spelling aside, this was driving me nuts.
Oh, take a chill pill, Maggie Niemeyer. Are you perfect? When you're perfect, then you can start telling people what to do. Until then, keep your mouth shut. Thank you! And have a nice day.
Macy Taylor So by that logic criticism shouldn't exist.
"Voldemort,Voldemort ,Voldemort , HA take that" 😂😂
shakir ghoul
Try saying it 7X...
Everyone's obsessing over the Nagini reveal that apparently happened yesterday, but I've known that Claudia would play Nagini for at least a month now. Her character has been listed on IMDB for a while.
Mariah Hillegas Girl you a genius
Ok?
this wasn't even a theory I wanted to know until I read the title.
SuperCarlinBrothers fake stop it
Same
THEORY CONFIRMED SUPERCARLINBROTHERS!!!!!!
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
J Kreh SUPERCALLEDITBROTHERS
I think that Warner Bros either just watches their videos and uses their theories
Or they let them watch their movies in advance.
They tried red contacts with Ralph fienns when playing voldermort which went well, but the directors said they lost a lot of emotion shown through the eyes with them in so they decided to leave the contacts and focus more on his emotions
You guys should make a theory on how Trelawney's predictions where almost always right. Even when she got his birthday wrong she was just seeing Voldemorts birthday. and his short age line could have been because he was supposed to die when he was only one year old and she would have never seen an age line that short. She even got the when 133 dine together right because Peter was already at the table and Dumbledore stood up first.
gg you just solved harry potter
they did it :o
Plot twist: She's actually Fluffy
EPIC!
I'm pretty sure Fluffy was male
What if she's the basalisk
TreeFairy42 but basilisks love for hundreds of years, I thought the basilisk was as old as the castle
Jason Johnson yeah I guess you're right lol I was just making a wild guess
I watched this video in 2017 and I was like “nah, that can’t be right!” But I just watched the movie yesterday and I’m like “JESUS CHRIST HE CAN SEE THE FUTURE!”
I know Claudia is Nagini, but I LOVE THE IDEA THAT EACH MOVIE WILL FEATURE AN ILVERMORNY HOUSE MASCOT!!
You guys were right! The newest Fantastic Beasts trailer confirms it! (I'm not even surprised, you two are geniuses.)
IS MRS NORRIS A MALEDICTUS? like why is it mrs intead of miss? maybe filch married her and then she turned into a cat. it could explain why shes so intelligent, and why filch is so close to her.
dang i forgot she said that. maybe she said it before she came up with the disease? i doubt it though, but it'd be pretty cool
Hi Im Max oh flap
Hi Im Max red Fr 3rd e
yeah. i feel like she made up the fantastic beast storyline fairly close to when she made the harry potter books, so she may have thought it all out before pottermore came out. dunno tho lol
I like this theory
Maledictus can also simply be translated to "curse" or "cursed"
Omg I just watched the finale trailer for Crimes Against Gridalwald and I'm amazed *heavy aplause*
Lol how many people had to instantly come back to this video after the new trailer?
me as fuc-
Me
RATSINMYROOM like, I HAD to 😂😂
I'm just glad that Credence seems to have a decent Hairstyle now
This is officially my go to channel for all things Harry Potter...
All Indians knew naagini was woman
Oh cool, how? Is it in the name? 🤔
@@pll3924 cultural thing
True
Yep....While I was reading the books, I always had this subconscious inkling that Nagini might be a woman in animal form.
True
Okay, I just watched the final trailer of Crimes of Grindelwald, and you guys are officially the best at what you do.
Finally some indian
Yeah and I just watched it; and if you turn on captions when the snake lady talks she is captioned as "nagini"
What about that blue eye though?!
I dunno. Kay?
The blue eye is pretty cool
Not sure yet, haven’t watched the full video yet but I️ know this video is going to be great!
SuperCarlinBrothers um for Harry's eyes the producers said that he did wear eye contacts but it was because he was allergic to them in the scene where he's saying goodbye to hagrid his eye is twitching and swollen
SuperCarlinBrothers i thought you guys were pretty cool ;( ;(
When your parents tell you to not believe everything you see on the internet after you watch a supercarlin video.
*Disgruntled elephant noises*
This aged well
Confirmed! She is Nagini
From all of the crazy theories around the web, this is by far my favourite... Another fact that we're all missing, is that the movie's title is Fantastic BEASTS, so this woman might as well turn into her snake form, and
-may be- for some reason she exiles herself to some Albanian forest.
THEORY CONFIRMED!
I wonder if blood curses could be removed by some sort of muggle dialysis...
NEVER LET VOLDEMORT PLAN A WEDDING
SuperCarlinBrothers stop it scammer
sharmaine Hill it's a bot don't bother talking to it
Walder Frey holds the record for worst wedding planner tho
Never ever ever 😂
sharmaine Hill I just reported as many of the bot posts as I could.
Or maybe Maladictis (Ill Speaking) is just the American Name for Parseltounge, the American Wizards have very different names for muggles why not parsletounge
DON'T CLICK THE ABOVE, THEY ARE BOTS!
in other news, harrington little you pose a very interesting point. how much of the Wizarding World has problems with translations No-Maj = Muggle, maladictis could mean parseltongue and there are others : biscuits = muffins cookies = cakes or something
I don’t think that talking to snakes would be considered a curse.
Harrington Little i
Parselmouths don't end up turning into a beast though. :/
What the British call biscuits are referred to as cookies by Americans. Cakes are cakes though. Do British call American Biscuits muffins? Then what do they call muffins? Why is this so confusing lol
OHMYGOD I just saw the new trailer before one of your other videos and I'm so secondhand proud!
So many people writing about how right they were. This is so crazy 😂
so is ben just chillin off to the side the whole time you film lol
eli m. Go check out J’s and/or DK’s vlog channels, you can see their office and they are quite well shot and entertaining!
☝That is a fake channel don't click the link.
eli m. He’s probably behind the camera
eli m.
Who's here to rewatch this after seeing the final trailer for Crimes of Grindelwald?
HE ACTUALLY GUESSED IT SPOT ON!!
Edit: thanks for all the likes!
YES!!!!
YEAHHHHHHHH BOIII
EXACTLY
BLA BLAAA
I watch the MOVie
Arguably the most exciting part of seeing this movie in theaters was that this theory was confirmed
Well if I was you, I'd get a torn rotator cuff from patting myself on the back. Effin' NAILED IT. Well played.
"And while I don't always like to consider The Cursed Child canon,
I think we can use it as a reference here, just to determine how it might work."
*THIS IS THE WORDS I LIVE BY YOU GUYS, THANK YOU JONATHAN FOR YOUR WISE WORD!*
I think the question is "Why DOESN'T he like to use the Cursed Child?
Nihar Behere No one likes Cursed Child.
I can see your point, but I, personally, enjoyed the book
Nihar Behere You are the minority
The public opinion on Cursed Child seems very mixed, maybe with a slight lean towards the negative (though I get my information from online surveys, which aren't exactly scientific). I personally thought it was a decent story, in fact there are some scenes that I actually like to go back and reread, but I don't consider it required reading.
So here is what EXPLAINS VOLDEMORTS EYE COLOR. The producers thought that making Ralph Fiennes eyes red would take away from the emotion from his eyes. So they decided to stick with a color that is capable of showing emotion.
Daniel Rivera OOOOR... they just didn't want to fuck up the color palette of the film. Plus who the fuck has red eyes? Do you want to get terminator Voldemort? Cause that's how you get Terminator Voldemort!
Speaking of which... I would like to see a version of Harry Pottee with prime Arnold Schwarzenegger as Voldemort!
i like that point, having emotion shows how human he is, even though his efforts were to be immortal. (did you know that Voldemort lived to be [if i remember right] 77. ) However it is known that he is incapable, or doesn't know love, so in the end, I'm not really sure of my opinion.
Voldemort does not show emotion
Underrated Ravenclaw Voldemort shows anger, fear, surprise, joy, regret, etc in the books
Sure he does.
The way you detailed this all the way bag to that forgotten Bathilda scene. Good job man super impressive how much thought you put into this, I'd love to have that "eureka" moment lol
4:26 VOLDEMORT VOLDEMORT OOOOOO VOLDY VOLDY VOLDY VOLDEMORT
Hearing the definition of maledictus stirred something in my memory. We've seen an animal that has human like behavior and is treated by the owner as if it was a real person. That's right. I'm talking about Mrs Norris. Think about it, jkr says that she is not a kneazle(a kind of wizard cat that is known to be adept at stopping mischief) STOPPING MISCHIEF! Filch talks about her like she can actually understand him, and most of the time, it seems she does. This could explain her human like behavior! But I dare take it one step further.What if Mrs Norris was a caretaker? She is DETERMINED to stop anyone causing trouble or mischief in the school. And why in chamber of secrets when she's petrified it affects her the same as everyone else. Because she used to be a human! She's also so incredibly dedicated and sympathetic towards Filch because she understands what he's going through! Dumbledore has been known to hire WEREWOLVES. Possibly the most hated half human in the wizarding world, honestly for him, its not that big a stretch! PLEASE MAKE THIS INTO A VIDEO!! Love your account!! Do more marvel and stranger things theories!!
Danielle Wagner this makes a lot of sense actually.
And there is one big detale that confirms this theory: MARUDERS MAP! She was the only animal visible on the map.
MiraCleSillence omg I never thought of this!!!! Thank you!!!
WOW
Wow ! you just came up with a new theory
I need an answer guys... if a Phoenix is reborn from its ashes.. where did the first Phoenix come from?!
Maybe a cremated bird or something? Good question
Which came first the phoenix or the flame?
Heather Mueller neither its a circle
I think the answer is that a circle has no beginning.
Well when a mummy Phoenix and a daddy Phoenix love each other very much a stalk brings a baby Phoenix to them........
What if the reason why Aberforth was obsessed with goats, was because he was trying to find a way to reverse the maledictus curse his wife/Credence's mom suffered.
I`ve watched this video months ago, already thinking it was quite possible, but the fact that you guys got it spot it on blows my mind
The new Fantastic Beasts confirms this!!
👏🏻
I CAN'T WAIT!!!
You Sir, should be awarded?
Yes I should
I'm rereading goblet of fire and I'm a little creeped out by wormtail “milking” Nagini. I haven't reread this book in ten years.
Apparently in the context of a snake, that means collecting the venom. At least, that's what one of the bros said in another video. In which case, it's less awkward. Still a little weird, but less than it could have been
Back here after watching the LATEST and FINAL trailer. You guys totally nailed this!!!!!
Well Jay, in terms of translating, you are both wrong and right. Assuming that J.K. took the 2 parts of Maledictus from classical Latin like she likes to do, then Male comes from the Latin word Malum, meaning Bad or evil. Dictus is the 4th principal part of the Latin word Dicere, which means to speak, and in this case it translates to "having been spoken", and it is classified as a adjective, so it makes sense that it comes after the noun, male. Therefore Maledictus translates roughly to "Evil has been spoken", which could mean that someone cursed or hexed the young woman and or her family. Overall, great theory, can't wait for the film.
Um, actually "maledicere" is not an invention by J.K.
There is a part in Ovid's metamorphoses (about the Lycian peasants) which says
"(...) Sed nunc quoque turpes
Litibus exercent linguas pulsoque pudore,
Quamvis sint sub aqua, sub aqua maledicere temptant."
which (roghly) translates to "But even now they continue to make the nastiest remarks and, because they got rid of their decency, they, although being under water, try to say nasty things under water."
("maledicere" here means "saying bad things about a person" in a sense of bitching etc.)
Also, since "benedicere" is the usual Latin version of "to bless" or "to praise", "maledicere" is more or less the opposite.
So, "maledictus" quite literally means "the cursed one" or "the despised one"
Meledictus is "maldito" in Spanish or "maledeto" in Italian. So in English is literally "coursed" or "damned".
Split the etymology of "meledictus" is a mistake, you should translate it directly.
Yeap. In Portuguese "cursed" means "maldito". Similar in Italian and Spanish. So, I do not think that's too much about the word "maledictus". It's literally means that someone was cursed.
Yes of course, "a adjective"
Aayy fellow Latin enthusiast Salve amicus
David Heyman (producer of hp films) said that with red eyes, you would be more drawn to the red than the emotion. Director Mike Newell also said that if you don't leave an enormous chunk of human behind there,then he isn't going to scare you. So that's why Voldemort didn't have red eyes in the film. (Correct me if I made any mistakes!!)
Millierose Ravenclaw Then why did they make him explode at the end, instead of hacing a human corpse? Ahhhhhhh such inconsistencies.
Sara Munoz they made him explode, I believe, to add finality to his death. Voldemort always came back, even when it seemed like he should be gone. When he dissolved, I saw it as Voldemort being truly gone and unable to come back from that.
Millierose Ravenclaw, I think I remember reading that somewhere, so I believe your right
Lily Potter yea, it was in a book I read about hp
Keltsey Jacob (SHFA) :)
So interesting!
But what if Credence and Claudia (Snake girl) have a daughter, and it's Astoria?! That would be amazing. 😄
Rachel Benedict it would have to be Astorias mom or grandma if anything
I just watched the trailer and looked back at the release date of this video and I was so confused😂 you were spot on
they did not change voldy's eye colour because as the film producers say "it would look very wired and unatural and goofy."
yes, indeed friend but I believe they could've gone with a dark cherry red and give it a brighter glint when something was serious, or needed attention =} dark cherry red looks a bit more natural, but still has the ability to look right.
though, that's just my thoughts =}
Theory proven by the last trailer of Fantastic Beasts : Crimes of Grindelwald!!
I watched The Crimes of Grindelwald and was like “hey I thought somebody did a theory on Nagini?”
Great job calling this one J. You did make me think of something though. When Nagini take over of Bagshot. Being able to look human and speak, maybe the horcrux allowed her to overcome the blood-curse once Voldemort was fully restored because he could "activate" it somehow to bring her back for a short time. I am assuming that she hadn't been human for a long time before then so maybe she needed to horcrux as a template to allow her to regain her form.
Didn't she speak pastel mouth still tho
I've got a cool theory I've never heard before. Snape's killing curse didn't kill Dumbledore. We know from Moody's lesson that you've got to be full of hate and rage to make it work. Snape didn't hate Dumbledore. The freezing spell stopped Harry from screaming out when the spell hit Dumbledore and only lifted a short time later. I think the fall killed Dumbledore. The spell knocked him form the tower so Snape is still responsible but I think it makes Snape a more redeemable character knowing he didn't have it in him to perform the killing curse properly
If this is true and Dumbledore was conscious for his fall even without a wand I'm pretty confident he would have had the capacity to save himself but he chose not to. This was because he was nearly dead anyhow and if he survived Snape's curse then Voldemort would have killed Snape. Also the power of the elder wand would have died with him if he killed himself
Harry Barber omg!!! You have given me a new meaning of life😂
That's actually a pretty cool theory, never thought of that
Omg, that means he would have been alive all the way down, though. Maybe even conscious.
Harry Barber Whoa, that’s real solid, especially with the delayed fall of the spell on Harry backing it up.
This is so cool! I would have never thought of this
I think I was most angry about Lily's eyes....brown? really? spent the whole franchise talking about how Harry has his mother's eyes but you give her brown eyes?....alright.
Kennis Pieper right? XD
I know! If they couldn’t find a way to make Daniel Radcliffe’s eyes green, they could have at least chosen an actress who had blue eyes like his so that Harry would HAVE HIS MOTHERS EYES like they mention 3 billion times in the whole series haha
Kelsybabe-P In the book they kept talking about Lily's GREEN eyes and Harry's GREEN eyes
The actor they cast as adult Lily (Geraldine Somerville) had blue eyes, so her eye color changes in the movies too. *sigh* Fuck consistency I guess?
Lola Crazy calm down dude they’re talking about the movie franchise not the books
Good point also there is a clip in one of the trailers of Fantastic Beasts 2 showing her transform into a snake, BUT she looks MUCH too big to be Nagini, even though Nagini was pretty big she wasn’t as big as that snake was.
A person as a horcrux is another interesting questions. Besides Harry this would be the second instance of a live horcrux.
J! OF COURSE HE OWNED NAGINI BEFORE HE TRIED TO KILL HARRY! Harry is the final, accidental horcrux. Therefore, he had to have owned her!
Michaela B actually nagini is the final horcru Harry is the 6th
SuperCarlinBrothers
Stop spamming
No that's not true! Dumbledore says (I believe in "King's Cross" in Deathly Hallows) that Voldemort used Nagini to kill Bertha Jorkins in Albania, and that he realized at that moment how useful she was to him, and decided to make her a horcrux afterwards. (Correct me if I'm wrong, I don't have the books with me to verify, but I'm pretty sure it's something like that)
Ezra K. That isnt them, it's a fake. Check there channel
I don't have the books on me either, as it is. But Harry is the final horcrux - the one that was never meant to happen. It only happens because at this point Voldemort has already split his soul into 6 different parts - he is so unstable that his soul fragments and a piece attaches itself to Harry. Therefore, Nagini is already a horcrux, because all the horcruxes are made.
Okay so since this is a common mistake people make Parseltounge is the language of snakes, and a Parselmouth is a person (human) who speaks Parseltounge.
Sophia Ponnuru THANK YOU! I’ve seen so many comments on here talking about how Parselmouth isn’t a thing, but I clearly remember Dumbledore mentioning it in the HBP when he and Harry and looking at the Gaunts through the Pensieve!
You're welcome lol.
Dear SuperCarlinBrothers,
You have done it again! Nagini is her! She is Nagini! Your theories are amazing!!!
After watching Fantastic Beasts on the Big screen, I stumbled on your vlog about Nagini! Loving the cute piggy behind you! 🐷
🐍
SuperCarlinBrothers you aren’t real SuperCarlinBrothers
Ambition yeah I agree
Yes
🐍
SNAKE
How does Coco fit into the Pixar Theory??
Woah whats this??
MarKreations Studios I hope you didn't click that because that site was possibly a virus.
It appears to be a giftcard site
WTF
dont click this its not the real channel
Congratulations on nailing this one! Can’t believe this was made a year ago!!!
When you made this, it was a year before the movie came out, yet you got this right!
Harry's eye colour in the movie:Blue
Lily's eye colour in the movie:Brown
Everyone's line to Harry ALL THE TIME:You Have Your Mother's Eyes
................
HOW HOW DOES HE HAVE HIS MOTHER'S EYES?!?!?!
SHAPE?!?! SIZE?!?!? LASHES?!?!? CERTAINLY NOT COLOUR!!!!!!!!
Lucky Clover hahahahahhaha 😂😂
Might just be one of the many things overlooked in the movie
Soph - Then they would say that they see Lily in Harry (in some vague fashion), or when they look into his eyes, but not his eyes themselves. makes no sense.
Elias - Maybe not so much "overlooked", as much as.. not prioritising eye colour with casting.
When you see the title and are like no way, but you know when the video is done you'll be like J is a genius how did I miss that?
Dumbledore: scratches his head
SuperCarlinBrothers: DID DUMBLEDORE HAVE BRAIN CANCER!?
and because hocruxes need to be immortal , she might have became immortal because of that curse, running in her blood... which was used by voldemort later to get back to life in Goblet of fire... maybe that bllod contained elixir of life kinda thing
Yes! You got it. You're the only one who did, haha. Nagas in Hindu mythology carry the elixir of life in their venom. I think Nagini did as well because of her being a Maledictus, which is why she was able to aid Voldemort in his rebirth. I don't think ordinary snakes would do because Voldemort could have used one anytime before or instead of the Philosopher's Stone, but the fact that he risked going after the Philosopher's Stone instead of using one tells me that it had to be a Maledictus, and it would also be a strange and far too powerful quality to associate with every snake in existence, especially when compared to the other ingredient that came from Unicorns. Perhaps the reason he made her a Horcrux was her symbolising and practically carrying immortality, which was a fine way to seal his Horcruxes.
THIS👏🏼NEEDS👏🏼TO👏🏼BE👏🏼CONFIRMED👏🏼PLEASE👏🏼
I really hope this is true, this is an awesome theory!
guys, it took me forever, but I thought of something: IS MISS NORRIS A MALADICTUS!!?
THINK ABOUT IT! Miss Norris and Filch share a bond--a magical one: they can read each others minds. (SHUT UP SNAPE!), or at least see from each others eyes. Miss Norris is special, she's magical. Neither Nagini or Miss Norris are normal animals. Nagini has magical venom, and Miss Norris is a naturally gifted Lagilimancer! (uses Lagilimency)! Filch seems to like her in a way that not every cat owner does... he lover her like a wife!! BOOM!! J'S THEORY IS CONFIRMED AND I HOPE YOU BELEIVE MINE TOO!
Zayne Walsch no. No! NO! NO JESUS CHRIST THIS MUST BE TRUE! PLEASE SAY IT IS!
What is Lagamancy?
I think she means legilimency...
I thought that Miss Norris was a kneazle or half-kneazle like crookshanks?
my heart just broke with that theory
Wow! Your hypothesis is stunning. I'm shocked because I watched this one after the final trailer in Sep 2018. And you were right for 1 year in advance.
On Voldemort's eyes, they said they didn't want to alter his eyes because that would hamper Ralph Fiennes' performance as an actor; a lot of emotion is conveyed in the eyes. For Harry's eyes, J.K. said they didn't have to be green as long as they matched whoever played Lily(Geraldine Somerville), and they do.
The thing about venom being used in a potion is that chemicals entering the bloodstream directly can affect the body differently than ingesting it. So Nagini's venom entering from a bite could have a very different affect than mixing it into a potion with other ingredients.
Tom Keaney also magic :D
Tom Keaney every thing you eat eventually gets into your bloodstream.
Tom Keaney Also being a horcrux it's not a huge stretch to reason that as nagini is part of voldemort it would act akin to a blood transfusion as it is something generated by a physical vessel of his soul that it could help sustain another artificial vessel.
Drawnimate Carson Poisonous = you ate it/consumed it. Venemous = it bit you and affected your nervous system. Very different. Snakes are venemous. Poison dart frogs are poisonous. Komodo dragons are neither.
Tom Keaney and venom has been known to be used as a medicine.
If the unicorn blood curses you, maybe the venom reverses that curse.
no i believe thats because he split his soul
It makes perfect sense!!!
Just saw the final trailer of "Crimes Against Grindelwald" and Credence said Nagini's name.
I think maybe the most common maledictus might be a snake because the evil speak in Harry Potter is parcel tongue