I'm on the Fence... || The Lost Metal Book Review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2024
- I've been thinking about it ever since I finished the book, but I'm still unsure how to feel about aspects of #thelostmetal Look forward to my spoiler filled discussions of the conclusion of #mistborn era 2 over on @LiteratureScienceAlliance 's channel and elsewhere.
_______________________________
Please consider supporting me on Patreon -
/ michaelknipp
Merch Link -
teespring.com/...
_______________________________
Affiliate Links for Books Discussed:
The Lost Metal - amzn.to/3TM95eL
_______________________________
My Setup -
Affiliate Links -
Lighting - amzn.to/2PUSzxU
Microphone - amzn.to/2Ps9kkb
Boom Arm - amzn.to/2QZBX8w
Audio Interface - amzn.to/3mlUxU2
XLR Cables - amzn.to/3fJqV1M
Sony A6400 - amzn.to/3mmXd3W
Camera Lens - amzn.to/3fGYukK
Tripod - amzn.to/2OkK7HC
_______________________________
Please Subscribe!
/ @questlegacy
My Discord Channel: / discord
My Goodreads Profile: / michael-knipp
My Twitter: / michaelknipp
IG: / michaelknipp
Website: michael-knipp.com/
___________________________
Michael S Knipp
PO Box 465
Plattsmouth, NE 68048
If you want to send me any Kindle books - michael@wackmatters.com
Amazon Wishlist:
www.amazon.com...
It felt like it being so cosmere oriented changed its tone and it didn't quite fully match the time from the first 3. Does that make sense? Like it didn't fit with this trilogy to suddenly blow up in scope in cosmere stuff, while limiting the world building?
Still packed some great punches, got me emotional, and I do love seeing all the cosmere stuff and finally getting answers!! I now love the characters that I loved from the beginning even more!
Agreed
I think part of it is that Mistborn Era 2 wasn't originally planned and isn't quite its own Era but morphed into being the almost pre-era to Mistborn Era 3 so I think a lot of the remaining questions will get answered / explored in Mistborn Era 3. Also with how quickly technology is evolving, I think the time skip between Era 2 and Era 3 won't be that long and we may even see bits and pieces of characters from Era 2, especially the younger characters.
Given that era 2 wasn't originally planned at all and when AOL was written it wasn't initially going to be a trilogy, I think he wrapped this up almost perfectly. A lot of the larger threats werent meant to be fully dealt with until era 3 or 4. I loved all of the character conclusions we got and we now have a much clearer picture of whats in store for era 3. We now better understand the players and the stakes for the fate of Scadrial.
I wanted another trilogy of Wax and Wayne adventure. It was a sad ending instead.
Soo interesting man. Haven't read the book yet, but the trend really seems to be that people that were not really into era 2 are loving it, and people who loved it are having mixed feelings
I loved the first one, liked the second and didn't like the third. Curious to know where that's gonna lead me
Yeah it seems like that, I was never really info Era 2 then this book happened and it's probably in my top 5 Cosmere books.
Not done with the book yet, but it's already by far my favorite of Era 2. And definitely a top 10 favorite Cosmere book. The Cosmere connections are absolutely WILD.
I feel like Lost Metal works okay as a Cosmere book, but it doesn't feel as much as a Mistborn Era 2 book
I think the ending works considering that there will be another era / that series are entertwined as while it isn't finished it is the overall aspects that need to be explored/intrigue for future books. The alloy of law specific character arcs felt finished to me.
Interesting review! I feel like i need to read before I can totally understand a lot of the points you made haha
I’m pretty sure era 1 wasn’t a decade, handful of years I can see, but decade feels like a stretch with what I remember
I double checked this and you are correct. Era 1 takes place over about 4ish years from what I can tell. So Era 2 technically is longer timeline-wise
I just finished the book and I absolutely love it . I didn't expect to like it so much didn't expect to make me tear up love it. but I agree it didn't feel like an ending it feel like to be continued
Just coming to me watching this, would Hoid really have taught himself to drive and aquire both cars and boats whereever he needed them? Or would he have used Awakening on a pile of Scadrial junk and just told it "take me where I need to go, and act natural"? And would that mean TaravOdium may be influencing the effects of his breaths with some Shardic blurring?
I read all the published cosmere works, and Aether of Night and i hate how info dump in your face cosmere stuff is in this book. Main reason for that is that i liked searching and descovering all the little connections by myself and it felt rewarding.
I really liked the Lost Metal and era 2 as a whole, if only there was more Mistborn to read.
May I suggest...
I agree with you a lot. Feels like book was on rails with some add-ons for fans. A little disappointed with how it wrapped the story. Seems half-baked. I liked it but have this feeling that I missed something in my book
I enjoyed it so much but still felt kinda disappointed. I'm conflicted.
I'll be honest: it served its purpose
Another fantastic video, thank you so much!
Thank YOU for watching and commenting!
It's so interesting to me that you have mixed feelings, I loved this book so much, but the rest of the Era 2 was just fine to me.
Oh NM you DO have a review already,....
It was a blast and the Cosmere connections were so sweet!
@@QuestLegacy I’m sad though. I liked Wayne more than wax , I think Wayne could/should have had his own side arc/book … something.
Nice! Also, 3* more eras :)
100% vibe
Wasn't "misborn era 2" actually supposed to be mistborn era 1.5? I don't think he'd ever planned for the wax/wayne series to be completely self contained but more as bridge between the "main" eras. But basically the southern continent shenanigans are complete setup for era 3 and could basically be cut from this book with no damage to the plot. I also don't feel the need to have complete self contained story to have a satisfying conclusion. In fact I like mistborn era 2 a lot more than mistborn era 1 which I think has a young adult feel, not because it was written as a young adult work but more on the account of Brandon being a youngish adult when he wrote it, because of more interesting (if somewhat comic-bookish style) characters.
8:40 Yes.
As someone who's read all of the cosmere except Stormlight, would you recommend reading Lost Metal now, or waiting? I just finished Bands of Mourning, so I'd like to finish Era 2 while I'm here, but I don't want to ruin anything from SA.
Unless you can draw a ton of conclusions with essentially no context, you definitely shouldn't have anything from The Stormlight Archive spoiled by reading The Lost Metal now. Personally I'd recommend you go ahead and read it now. As a huge Stormlight fan, I'd suggest you just read that next because its awesome haha.
@@QuestLegacy Thank you! I'll start it tonight then. Believe me, I'm incredibly excited to see what all the hype is about with Stormlight. Can't wait!
I actually think that reading the lost metal before storm light would be helpful to its plot. Especially before reading rhythm of war.
Probably stormlight is the least of cosmere references in The Lost Metal. Elantris and The Emperor's Soul are the major tie-ins.
I think reading LM will spoil a big reveal in Rhythm of war tbh. I don't know if it's significant enough to read 4 thousand plus page books before LM, but for me personally, I wouldn't want it spoiled so I would read SA first 😅
Did you just voice a typo??🤭🤭💖
Wouldn't be the first or last time hahaha
@@QuestLegacy Saaammee tho! 😆 I kinda love it; we should start a club for it 😉 ^-^ LOLL
a mixed bag...oke 😂😂
I like your comparison of getting the cookies of Cosmere lore but not the vegetables of Mistborn 2 characters. Expect for me, the Cosmere lore feels like the vegetables, which is why I'm pretty disappointed with the book
p̲r̲o̲m̲o̲s̲m̲ 😜