@@hassansaeed9839 people say that this which prohibits women this was before the prophet allowed it. So its issue of naasikh mansookh. And there is a narration of Ayesha R.A and she said that prophet allowed to visit the graves. Its in sunan ibn majah. She is a woman. She said its allowed. Its a saheeh narration not hassan, not ghareeb, not da'if but Saheeh.
Don't bring your emotions into Islamic rulings first of all and secondly, yes, its definitely impermissible due to the hadith of the prophet (peace be upon him) cursing the women who visit the graves.
@@osamamanan2723 Sure and if it is an issue of nasikh mansookh, then women were not included in that category, because the hadith of cursing still exists. Its a saheeh narration not hassan, not ghareeb, not da'if but Saheeh.
Assaĺaam alikum wrwb Sheikh. I dnt understand why many scholars make it so complicated n argue on this. Many says that the strong opinion is women shouldn't visit the graves. As said in one of the Hadiths by Prophet SAW that "Allah cursed women who visits graves" n making many men of every house hold to argue on this...n with lack of knowledge differences created between families. It's such a shame. Very true that Men n women both hav to die so why only men hav to learn lesson n remind themselves not women....as Prophet SAW later said that both can visit the graves to remind themselves, soft hearts. May Allah swt guide us all to follow the true path of our Islaam Ameen sum Ameen
There wasn't any specification towards women being in that category. And no offense to you, but what qualifications do you have to come and try to question the saheeh ahadith and rulings? These are all emotional arguments to deny the impermissability.
Some scholars when they want their culture to be over Islam they will use any hadith to justify their desires When the Prophet Sallallahu alai wa sallam wanted to direct women in something he would specify that Allah Knows Best and Allah Please Forgive us if we say wrong Ameen
Ur allowed to. What is not allowed is visiting frequently and being in a state of wailing and mourning. There use to be a practice where women would mourn and slap their face and put dirt of themselves. That isn’t practiced anymore. But that is not allowed. It’s heavily disputed. But some agree to disagree. Do what u feel is right.
@@wingsofhope1088 why leave it? she has the right to know! If you can't give an explanation, you should have kept quiet! But don't discourage women from knowing about Islam. Islam didn’t come for men only.
@@sadiashibbirhumaira8921 u missunderstood me. I'm not against gaining knowledge no matter men or women but if u have any doubt in Islam and u don't have any option to get knowledge. In these situations atleast do obligatory things.
Women have less patience? If anything, women have *more* patience. Maybe women have less patience with the guy in the video, because he treats them rudely.
Women do have less patience in matters of death and demise of someone. That is what he meant. and my observation is the same. Most women are crying out loud on funerals whole men are sad and cry silently. The point is that only men will take the burial to graveyard to bury. Women may visit later is they will to but with proper etiquette.
Ur allowed to. What is not allowed is visiting frequently and being in a state of wailing and mourning. There use to be a practice where women would mourn and slap their face and put dirt of themselves. That isn’t practiced anymore. But that is not allowed. It’s heavily disputed. But some agree to disagree. Do what u feel is right.
What is this for nonsense? Man and Woman are equal! I know most religions don’t agree, but that just to make men feel superior. And why don’t women have patience? Are you serious? Is this a parody?
Why do women get money when they get married and men don’t? Why does raising 2 daughters gain you paradise and two sons doesn’t? Why does a husband have to pay for everything for his wife?
@@sz.1up541 Why do women get money when they get married and men don’t? That is a cultural difference, because here in the Netherlands this is NOT the case. And why do you feel replying with more religious nonsense like that daughters versus sons and paradise counters my arguments? I don’t believe in this nonsense and this is specific Islamic bullshit. Other religions don’t state this, and again I don’t believe in it, and I don’t agree with it! And a husband should not have to pay for everything for his wife! Again a cultural rule that is not existent here in Western Europe. Here both partners work and pay equally for the household. Even when going out on dates it is now normal that you both pay for your own meal. A culture in which women are seen as less should be changed as soon as possible. Women and men should have the same rights and responsibilities.
@@sz.1up541 But that is not true, both the Islamic and Christian god (Which should be the same but aren’t) state that women are not equal at all. Especially spiritual but definitely also practically in daily lives. Women and man are equal in ALL ways! Obviously there are physical differences but that shouldn’t determine any legal or practical differences.
![[UNCUT] The Loyal Pin ปิ่นภักดิ์ EP.15 (3/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IVwR87OH0_A/mqdefault.jpg)
Happy I came across this video. I was so sad to think us women were not allowed.
@@hassansaeed9839 people say that this which prohibits women this was before the prophet allowed it. So its issue of naasikh mansookh. And there is a narration of Ayesha R.A and she said that prophet allowed to visit the graves. Its in sunan ibn majah. She is a woman. She said its allowed. Its a saheeh narration not hassan, not ghareeb, not da'if but Saheeh.
What’s really sad is that you are so blinded by this cult that a you follow it blindly without exercising common sense.
Don't bring your emotions into Islamic rulings first of all and secondly, yes, its definitely impermissible due to the hadith of the prophet (peace be upon him) cursing the women who visit the graves.
@@osamamanan2723 Sure and if it is an issue of nasikh mansookh, then women were not included in that category, because the hadith of cursing still exists. Its a saheeh narration not hassan, not ghareeb, not da'if but Saheeh.
Assaĺaam alikum wrwb Sheikh. I dnt understand why many scholars make it so complicated n argue on this. Many says that the strong opinion is women shouldn't visit the graves. As said in one of the Hadiths by Prophet SAW that "Allah cursed women who visits graves" n making many men of every house hold to argue on this...n with lack of knowledge differences created between families. It's such a shame.
Very true that Men n women both hav to die so why only men hav to learn lesson n remind themselves not women....as Prophet SAW later said that both can visit the graves to remind themselves, soft hearts. May Allah swt guide us all to follow the true path of our Islaam Ameen sum Ameen
There wasn't any specification towards women being in that category. And no offense to you, but what qualifications do you have to come and try to question the saheeh ahadith and rulings? These are all emotional arguments to deny the impermissability.
Thank u for making this vid🤍
Whenever there is confusion
Its better to stay away from it.
May Allah protect you
جزاك الله خير بارك الله فيك
May Allah bless you 😍
Jazakallah khair for sharing🌺
JazakaAllah known the unknown
May Allah guide us all
حَدَّثَنَا إِبْرَاهِيمُ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ الْجَوْهَرِيُّ، حَدَّثَنَا رَوْحٌ، حَدَّثَنَا بِسْطَامُ بْنُ مُسْلِمٍ، قَالَ سَمِعْتُ أَبَا التَّيَّاحِ، قَالَ سَمِعْتُ ابْنَ أَبِي مُلَيْكَةَ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ، أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ ـ صلى الله عليه وسلم ـ رَخَّصَ فِي زِيَارَةِ الْقُبُورِ .
Grade: Sahih (Darussalam)
Reference : Sunan Ibn Majah 1570In-book reference : Book 6, Hadith 138English translation : Vol. 1, Book 6, Hadith 1570
Some scholars when they want their culture to be over Islam they will use any hadith to justify their desires
When the Prophet Sallallahu alai wa sallam wanted to direct women in something he would specify that
Allah Knows Best and Allah Please Forgive us if we say wrong Ameen
Exactly
So we cant visit a graveyard but men can because of patience? Sorry I’m very confused??
Ur allowed to. What is not allowed is visiting frequently and being in a state of wailing and mourning. There use to be a practice where women would mourn and slap their face and put dirt of themselves. That isn’t practiced anymore. But that is not allowed. It’s heavily disputed. But some agree to disagree. Do what u feel is right.
There's no really an actual explanation from the prophet (peace be upon him) himself regarding this hadith. He only said it.
If u have confusion then leave it. And do compulsory things😊
@@wingsofhope1088 why leave it? she has the right to know! If you can't give an explanation, you should have kept quiet! But don't discourage women from knowing about Islam. Islam didn’t come for men only.
@@sadiashibbirhumaira8921 u missunderstood me. I'm not against gaining knowledge no matter men or women but if u have any doubt in Islam and u don't have any option to get knowledge. In these situations atleast do obligatory things.
Women have less patience? If anything, women have *more* patience. Maybe women have less patience with the guy in the video, because he treats them rudely.
Women do have less patience in matters of death and demise of someone. That is what he meant. and my observation is the same. Most women are crying out loud on funerals whole men are sad and cry silently. The point is that only men will take the burial to graveyard to bury. Women may visit later is they will to but with proper etiquette.
Ur allowed to. What is not allowed is visiting frequently and being in a state of wailing and mourning. There use to be a practice where women would mourn and slap their face and put dirt of themselves. That isn’t practiced anymore. But that is not allowed. It’s heavily disputed. But some agree to disagree. Do what u feel is right.
Ewen chester oky oy lgj mere
What is this for nonsense? Man and Woman are equal! I know most religions don’t agree, but that just to make men feel superior. And why don’t women have patience? Are you serious? Is this a parody?
Why do women get money when they get married and men don’t? Why does raising 2 daughters gain you paradise and two sons doesn’t? Why does a husband have to pay for everything for his wife?
They are spiritually equal in the eyes of god but have different qualities and responsibilities physically
@@sz.1up541 Why do women get money when they get married and men don’t? That is a cultural difference, because here in the Netherlands this is NOT the case. And why do you feel replying with more religious nonsense like that daughters versus sons and paradise counters my arguments? I don’t believe in this nonsense and this is specific Islamic bullshit. Other religions don’t state this, and again I don’t believe in it, and I don’t agree with it!
And a husband should not have to pay for everything for his wife! Again a cultural rule that is not existent here in Western Europe. Here both partners work and pay equally for the household. Even when going out on dates it is now normal that you both pay for your own meal. A culture in which women are seen as less should be changed as soon as possible. Women and men should have the same rights and responsibilities.
@@sz.1up541 But that is not true, both the Islamic and Christian god (Which should be the same but aren’t) state that women are not equal at all. Especially spiritual but definitely also practically in daily lives. Women and man are equal in ALL ways! Obviously there are physical differences but that shouldn’t determine any legal or practical differences.
@@sanderdeboer6034 why you commenting on an Islamic video bro🤣🤣