About Whitlock. He's been a multi inning guy this year and the Red Sox see him as a starter down the line, possibly as soon as next year. Inheriting the closer role seems unlikely.
yeah especially with matt barnes having signed a two year extension, as well as with both josh taylor and darwinzon hernandez having showed promise for the future
Gotta have some love for John Brebbia. Was a Cardinals Rule 5 pick from the Yankees, I think. Was a great middle relief, set-up guy until he had TJ surgery.
Yo jolly, you should check out matt olsen's 2017 season. he had 1.003 ops in 59 games. out of his 49 hits, 24 of them were home runs!!49% of his hits were home runs. that's crazy! he had a 166 ops+ and had a .392 ISO. that could be a cool video
You missed 2 important details: Rule 5 eligibility is for players with 4+ years in the minors and no mlb service and only players over 24, and in order to keep them, they must spend an entire season on the 26-man roster unless injured, with rule 5 status carrying to new team in a trade.
Some of the other rules for the Rule 5 draft are: You cannot have played in the MLB at any point, only MiLB. (Idk if this is still true, but it used to be) You must have spent at least 4years in the minors if you were drafted at 19 or older, five if 18 or under. You have to have at least 90 days of active service of your new team to stick with them, unless you were injured, and even then you are expected to pick it up where you left off the next season you are cleared to play.
what about top 5 one team wonders: Guys who played out their entire career in one city and really became that city; and then conversely the top 5 who we though would stay put but left, EG: Ken Griffey Jr, Anthony Rizzo, etc.
You could probably add players who have been on multiple teams but are well known for being with one team for a long period of time Like Miguel Cabrera being the face of the Tigers despite originally playing for the Marlins
@@Karmy. Barry Bonds - Pirates, Sammy Sosa - White Sox, Mark McGwire - A's, kind of a weird coincidence but all 3 of these guys kinda fit that mold lol
@@Karmy. For sure; I think Spicy Man was listing those three players’ original teams. That said, I associate McGwire with Oakland a little more than I do with the Cardinals, if anything. But maybe that’s uncommon, I don’t know.
Last year the Oriole's Anthony Santander was in running for AL MVP before he lost the last month or so of the season to an injury. In 2021 his production's suffered primarily due to more injuries, but when he's healthy, he can rake. He also has an above-average throwing arm from right field. If he can stay on the field, next year could be a breakout one for him. Tyler Wells, who the O's selected in last year's Rule 5 from the Twins, is someone to watch. He's flown under the radar a bit. He won Minnesota's 2018 Minor League Starting Pitcher Award, then missed 2019 due to Tommy John surgery, and last year because the minor league season was shut down. The 6'8" right-hander was decent before the break, finishing with a 4.10 ERA, but he's really flourished since then, having yet to give up an earned run in 10.2 IP. On Sunday he earned his first save, and it wasn't a cheapie, getting a one-two-three ninth at Yankee Stadium against Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and Anthony Rizzo to seal an 8-7 win against a team still in the playoff hunt. His stuff (heater that reaches the high '90s, wipeout slider) is good enough that there's been talk about putting him in the rotation next year, but he's also valuable in a late-inning role. So, thanks for the video, and, yeah, a follow-up or two might be in order at some point (you can always hold one back for the winter meetings). Also, doing a historical Rule 5 video would be interesting, because it includes Hall of Fame players: www.mlb.com/news/complete-history-of-the-mlb-rule-5-draft-c210225288
The 2018 rule 5 draft was the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen they draft an 18 y/o whose only eligible because of a technicality, and he stays and contributes positively, and now the Jays have a young arm that can properly develop. Then Travis Bergen was taken in the draft, who was returned mid season, and promptly flipped the next year for Robbie Ray, and then re-acquired. Then as mentioned Romano was taken then returned and became an elite closer. Fun fact about Romano is that he was never supposed to be a starter, like he never even started a single game in College, and his 2014 season in the minors the reason he was made a starter was, was to get him the innings he needed after missing 2015 with Tommy John, and because in the minors you can succeed with 2 elite pitches as a starter, CHW and TEX got tricked into thinking he was a starter, and for some reason didn't want to give him a shot in the bullpen, worked out pretty well for the Jays I'd say. All told for the 2018 Rule 5 draft the Jays came away with a promising still very young arm, an elite closer, a CY Young winner and the compensation pick for said CY Young winner departing.
For anyone into mlb the show franchise mode a must take in the rule 5 draft is seth beer. Hes always available and always competes for rookie of the year
You missed the fact that there are most nuances to the section pool: Players signed at age 18 or younger need to be added to their club's 40-Man roster within five seasons or they become eligible for the Rule 5 Draft, Players who signed at age 19 or older need to be protected within four seasons.
They really need to make some changes to the Rule 5 draft. Last year the Angels lost Jose Soriano to the Pirates. He was recovering from Tommy John surgery. I guess the Pirates decided to have him pitch way too soon and he needed another Tommy John surgery. The Angels got him back recently but how much time will he miss now? If a pitcher in the minors has Tommy John surgery everything should freeze for them. All that should matter is getting them back to being able to pitch. They should also stay on the 60 Day IL until they're healthy.
A correction, every rule 5 draft player makes the majors. If you draft a player, you must play them in the majors, of you send them to the minors you have to sell them to their former team for half the price you bought them
@@pohorex6834 After double-checking, you do seem to be correct on that detail. I was under the impression that someone like Ivan Nova's experience with being a Rule 5 pick was the norm, where they got cut before opening day. I was wrong there. Regardless, some guys do get cut and returned before opening day, and some of those guys never make the majors even after being Rule 5 picks. Some examples I found over the last decade of guys who never made the majors even after being returned are Kevin Gadea, Anyelo Gomez, Zack Jones, Kevin Munson, and Michael Almanzar.
@@Padsquad2010 that does happen, typically they get at least the first week or so of playing though from what I've seen, but many do get returned very quickly
@@pohorex6834 yeah. but then those guys, less numerous than I initially believed, where they don't make the opening day roster aren't major leaguers, which was my initial point.
I’m pausing at 09 seconds to say if Whitlock isn’t on this list I’ll be disappointed. Garret Whitlock has been lights out rookie of the year type pitcher for the Boston Red Sox this season.
You poorly discribed the rules of the rule 5 draft.... if a team does not want to keep the player drafted on their active major league roster, if they wanna send them down to the minors they have to offer them back to the original team
@@Mostillist lmfao i know you’re just saying that to make yourself feel better about it😂he’s been a huge part of the bullpen this year whether u like it or not.
@@Mostillist bro i know you’re just saying all that to make yourself feel better, like just stop😂yall are literally ahead in the standings idk why you’re so emotional about it😭
![ออกพรรษาน้ำตาหล่น - แอน อรดี [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PFZtOcY9ONA/mqdefault.jpg)
I keep seeing comments saying "where's Adolis Garcia?" but he's not a Rule 5 Draft guy lol
safe to say he already peaked
@@booce6969 debatable
@@booce6969 yikes...
Ill take the L
Best waiver claims of the last decade? Just an idea.
This is a fun idea
Great idea
Cody Ross for the giants right
@@JollyOlive gio
@@JollyOlivestill waiting Jack
Akil Baddoo deserves at least a few minutes, if not a full video imo. Genuine ALROY candidate after never playing above A+
Agreed
As a twins fan im definitely upset we let baddoo go
the greatest rule 5 pick of all time was Roberto Clemente
150% truth
Fun Fact: That's not how percentages work.
@@ShadowWizard123 fun fact : youre almost funny
@@nicholaso4302 come one you're gassing him up way too much
Shane Victorino was an amazing rule 5 pick for the Phillies
Had to bring up Brooks Kriske man 😭😭
It was too easy
@@JollyOlive saved it by putting Nestor in
About Whitlock. He's been a multi inning guy this year and the Red Sox see him as a starter down the line, possibly as soon as next year. Inheriting the closer role seems unlikely.
yeah especially with matt barnes having signed a two year extension, as well as with both josh taylor and darwinzon hernandez having showed promise for the future
Gotta have some love for John Brebbia. Was a Cardinals Rule 5 pick from the Yankees, I think. Was a great middle relief, set-up guy until he had TJ surgery.
The up and down Career of steve Pierce from multiple DFA to WS MVP. IJS
Best PTBNL in trades in the last decade.
Props to you for including Cortes in that thumbnail
Yo jolly, you should check out matt olsen's 2017 season. he had 1.003 ops in 59 games. out of his 49 hits, 24 of them were home runs!!49% of his hits were home runs. that's crazy! he had a 166 ops+ and had a .392 ISO. that could be a cool video
You missed 2 important details:
Rule 5 eligibility is for players with 4+ years in the minors and no mlb service and only players over 24, and in order to keep them, they must spend an entire season on the 26-man roster unless injured, with rule 5 status carrying to new team in a trade.
Best draft picks from the 10th round and later would be cool, highlighting some of the best diamonds in the rough
Roberto Clemente was a Rule 5 draft pick. He was originally a Dodger(I think).
Never knew this was even a thing! Great vid
Some of the other rules for the Rule 5 draft are:
You cannot have played in the MLB at any point, only MiLB. (Idk if this is still true, but it used to be)
You must have spent at least 4years in the minors if you were drafted at 19 or older, five if 18 or under.
You have to have at least 90 days of active service of your new team to stick with them, unless you were injured, and even then you are expected to pick it up where you left off the next season you are cleared to play.
I need Brooks Kriske to never appear in a Yankee uniform ever again
As a Red Sox fan I do
what about top 5 one team wonders: Guys who played out their entire career in one city and really became that city; and then conversely the top 5 who we though would stay put but left, EG: Ken Griffey Jr, Anthony Rizzo, etc.
You could probably add players who have been on multiple teams but are well known for being with one team for a long period of time
Like Miguel Cabrera being the face of the Tigers despite originally playing for the Marlins
@@Karmy. Barry Bonds - Pirates, Sammy Sosa - White Sox, Mark McGwire - A's, kind of a weird coincidence but all 3 of these guys kinda fit that mold lol
@@spicyfood6943 I think of Bonds more with the Giants
@@Karmy. For sure; I think Spicy Man was listing those three players’ original teams. That said, I associate McGwire with Oakland a little more than I do with the Cardinals, if anything. But maybe that’s uncommon, I don’t know.
@@IdliAmin_TheLastKingofSambar and Sammy with the Cubs
I’m glad Garret Whitlock is on this list. The Yankees screwed up by not protecting him
NASTY
NESTOR
babe wake up, another jolly olive banger dropped
Last year the Oriole's Anthony Santander was in running for AL MVP before he lost the last month or so of the season to an injury. In 2021 his production's suffered primarily due to more injuries, but when he's healthy, he can rake. He also has an above-average throwing arm from right field. If he can stay on the field, next year could be a breakout one for him.
Tyler Wells, who the O's selected in last year's Rule 5 from the Twins, is someone to watch. He's flown under the radar a bit. He won Minnesota's 2018 Minor League Starting Pitcher Award, then missed 2019 due to Tommy John surgery, and last year because the minor league season was shut down. The 6'8" right-hander was decent before the break, finishing with a 4.10 ERA, but he's really flourished since then, having yet to give up an earned run in 10.2 IP. On Sunday he earned his first save, and it wasn't a cheapie, getting a one-two-three ninth at Yankee Stadium against Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and Anthony Rizzo to seal an 8-7 win against a team still in the playoff hunt. His stuff (heater that reaches the high '90s, wipeout slider) is good enough that there's been talk about putting him in the rotation next year, but he's also valuable in a late-inning role.
So, thanks for the video, and, yeah, a follow-up or two might be in order at some point (you can always hold one back for the winter meetings). Also, doing a historical Rule 5 video would be interesting, because it includes Hall of Fame players: www.mlb.com/news/complete-history-of-the-mlb-rule-5-draft-c210225288
I was hoping to see Jays reliever Joe Biagini. He had a good season in 2015 when he was claimed from the Giants
The 2018 rule 5 draft was the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen they draft an 18 y/o whose only eligible because of a technicality, and he stays and contributes positively, and now the Jays have a young arm that can properly develop. Then Travis Bergen was taken in the draft, who was returned mid season, and promptly flipped the next year for Robbie Ray, and then re-acquired. Then as mentioned Romano was taken then returned and became an elite closer. Fun fact about Romano is that he was never supposed to be a starter, like he never even started a single game in College, and his 2014 season in the minors the reason he was made a starter was, was to get him the innings he needed after missing 2015 with Tommy John, and because in the minors you can succeed with 2 elite pitches as a starter, CHW and TEX got tricked into thinking he was a starter, and for some reason didn't want to give him a shot in the bullpen, worked out pretty well for the Jays I'd say. All told for the 2018 Rule 5 draft the Jays came away with a promising still very young arm, an elite closer, a CY Young winner and the compensation pick for said CY Young winner departing.
great vid bro!
absolutely do a part 2
I’m late but Michael king glow up this year and whitlock glow down is so litty
Odubel Herrera was a rule 5 pick in 2015. He was an all star in 17 and been a decent mlb player
Best PTNBL’s of all time. Like Michael Brantley in the CC Sabathia trade
If you wanna go back further you can say that Jose Bautista, however he had more success in Toronto and not Baltimore.
Omar Narvaes is a White Sox fan favorite since he was bearable to watch when we were trash.
He's had a bad season but Brad Keller was a great rule 5 draft find.
For anyone into mlb the show franchise mode a must take in the rule 5 draft is seth beer. Hes always available and always competes for rookie of the year
You should do compensation picks
You missed the fact that there are most nuances to the section pool: Players signed at age 18 or younger need to be added to their club's 40-Man roster within five seasons or they become eligible for the Rule 5 Draft, Players who signed at age 19 or older need to be protected within four seasons.
Good to see that you too are a Nestor Truther
Great video
Another great vid
Great video and great mets gear!
Best international signings
They really need to make some changes to the Rule 5 draft. Last year the Angels lost Jose Soriano to the Pirates. He was recovering from Tommy John surgery. I guess the Pirates decided to have him pitch way too soon and he needed another Tommy John surgery. The Angels got him back recently but how much time will he miss now? If a pitcher in the minors has Tommy John surgery everything should freeze for them. All that should matter is getting them back to being able to pitch. They should also stay on the 60 Day IL until they're healthy.
Going back through these videos through the months has been great except to see the NFT sponsor. Thats sad.
Top 10 no. 1 prospects who turned their career around.
A correction, every rule 5 draft player makes the majors. If you draft a player, you must play them in the majors, of you send them to the minors you have to sell them to their former team for half the price you bought them
Most of them get sent back though, and, as a result, don’t make the majors.
@@Padsquad2010 most get sent back after playing for a bit and sucking, therefore, minimal major league playing time
@@pohorex6834 After double-checking, you do seem to be correct on that detail. I was under the impression that someone like Ivan Nova's experience with being a Rule 5 pick was the norm, where they got cut before opening day. I was wrong there.
Regardless, some guys do get cut and returned before opening day, and some of those guys never make the majors even after being Rule 5 picks. Some examples I found over the last decade of guys who never made the majors even after being returned are Kevin Gadea, Anyelo Gomez, Zack Jones, Kevin Munson, and Michael Almanzar.
@@Padsquad2010 that does happen, typically they get at least the first week or so of playing though from what I've seen, but many do get returned very quickly
@@pohorex6834 yeah. but then those guys, less numerous than I initially believed, where they don't make the opening day roster aren't major leaguers, which was my initial point.
Fuzzy watching this video:😢
Standout vid! New sub incoming :)
Hector Rondon
Ryan Flaherty mvp
2012 O’s rule 5 guy
8:19 josh jonaldson lmao
RULE 5 FOR LIFE
Shane Victorino!!
How about the best pitchers to win a silver slugger
How can you not mention the greatest rule 5 of all time Roberto Clemente?
In regards to the intro of the video… isn’t the entire point of the rule 5 draft that drafted players have to be on the club’s major league roster?
Nester Cortes looks more like a plumber than a pitcher, but the dude is the #1 starter on the Yankees right now.
I’m pausing at 09 seconds to say if Whitlock isn’t on this list I’ll be disappointed. Garret Whitlock has been lights out rookie of the year type pitcher for the Boston Red Sox this season.
Personally I think Brooks Kriske is the greatest pitcher of all time and the Yankees definitely made the right choice in protecting him
Odubel Herrera snubbed
Nasty Nestor is a GOD.
Best non-tendered players?
Brad Keller is an interesting case with the rule 5
Hope Yohel Pozo from the Rangers is on this list someday 🙏🏼
Another Mets fan
NASTY NESTOR
Glad Jolly snuck in a Yankees jab it’s rare us Mets fans get to do that lmao
3
GARETT WHITLOCKKKK
What happened to Brady Aiken? Odd draft situations
Though he doesn’t fit the video title, the best Rule 5 draftee is Josh HamiltonS
I’m glad u didn’t pick baddoo or adolis Garcia
Badoo could be on one of these someday
Josh Hamilton was a Rule 5 pick
A decade is 10 years.
Haven't watched it yet but if Mark Canha isn't near the top...
Goodbye Canha, We've loved having you
Whitlock has damn well been the Red Sox most reliable bullpen arm throughout this entire season.
"While the Yankees bullpen is already good"...it is?
What adolis Garcia where you at bruh
You poorly discribed the rules of the rule 5 draft.... if a team does not want to keep the player drafted on their active major league roster, if they wanna send them down to the minors they have to offer them back to the original team
Described*
This video made me even more mad at the Yankees for the garret whitlock decision
Garrett Whitlock
Odubel Herrera?!?!?
We should find the one person who disliked this and cut him. DFA joke
Whitlock gets zero credit for how great he has been since joining the Sox. Basically came out of nowhere to be one of the best relievers in the league
Ace nasty nestor
Damn nft stuff is disappointing, hope he's realized what a scam those were
Why the fuck is Akil Baddoo not on this list
Bullpen already good do you follow the Yankees our bullpen sucks
Marwin Gonzalez 🤢
They really kept Kriske over Whitlock. Cashman is a disgrace
lmao the yankees really gifted both whitlock and ottavino to the red sox😭😂
@@NateRamos69 ottavino is average
@@Mostillist lmfao i know you’re just saying that to make yourself feel better about it😂he’s been a huge part of the bullpen this year whether u like it or not.
@@NateRamos69 his era is a 4 and walks so many batters he would be our 5th or 6th best reliever
@@Mostillist bro i know you’re just saying all that to make yourself feel better, like just stop😂yall are literally ahead in the standings idk why you’re so emotional about it😭
Had to skip Marwin Gonzalez, i dont want to watch any bit on a cheating player.