This is a lovely song but Minnelli staged it terribly so it’s no wonder it was cut. Judy Garland’s comical expression at the end sums up beautifully her own feelings about the routine. So glad however the footage survived as anything that turns up with her in it is so precious.
Judy's voice sounds amazing. But those middle-aged clowns with giant tail feathers are downright bizarre and totally upstaging a very thin Judy. Thank you very much for this fascinating clip.
The clowns are played by Swedish clowns Jean and Rene Arnaut, known as the Arnaut Brothers. Although uncredited, they appear in the edited movie In the walk-around at the start of the Sunny circus.
Agreed! It's odd that it would have come right after "Sunny." It would have slowed it down to a crashing halt. The staging is terrible, it's almost like a dry run before anyone decided what to do although that wouldn't be in full costume and makeup, nor filmed. A rare case of Minnelli totally missing the mark!
This is a lovely song but Minnelli staged it terribly so it’s no wonder it was cut. Judy Garland’s comical expression at the end sums up beautifully her own feelings about the routine. So glad however the footage survived as anything that turns up with her in it is so precious.
Her voice never fails to amaze me
Love seeing new footage of Judy. Thank you 💙
She’s so beautiful 😵💫
Anything and everything Judy ever recorded for MGM was flawless and breathtakingly beautiful! 🧐🤔🥰♥️
What gem this is❤
Judy's voice sounds amazing. But those middle-aged clowns with giant tail feathers are downright bizarre and totally upstaging a very thin Judy. Thank you very much for this fascinating clip.
Shes like smaller than ariana grande in this and the clowns really are bizarre lol
❤ you Judy !
Love this ❤. Thank you for sharing.
Judy looks very thin but beautiful here
Thanks for sharing..
The clowns are played by Swedish clowns Jean and Rene Arnaut, known as the Arnaut Brothers. Although uncredited, they appear in the edited movie In the walk-around at the start of the Sunny circus.
Judy was very thin , but the costumer did a great job hiding the fact that she was 5 months pregnant ...
The feather shadow on judy's forehead at the end is a glaring disaster.
Kinda scary looking clowns ... Ugh 🤣😫 ... just my opinion
I can see why it got cut. It's not special and the clowns are annoying.
They were right to cut it, bad song.
Oh, I think the song is fine, but I don't care for the staging with the clowns AT ALL.
Yes, the staging sucks.
Agreed! It's odd that it would have come right after "Sunny." It would have slowed it down to a crashing halt. The staging is terrible, it's almost like a dry run before anyone decided what to do although that wouldn't be in full costume and makeup, nor filmed. A rare case of Minnelli totally missing the mark!
The song is pretty the video is weird with the men
I like the words they are lovely. shes singing beautifully her dress is gorg clowns r creepy