Summary: 1. Sugar is subtly sweet. Ketones dropped and blood glucose level increased. 2. Stevia shows mixed results. 3. Allulose tastes good and does not affect ketones or blood glucose level. Bad GI distress though. 4. Sucralose is intensely sweet and does not affect ketones or blood glucose. 5. Erythritol tastes almost as good as Allulose and has similar/no effect on ketones and blood glucose, but also causes GI distress. 6. Monk fruit is not as sweet as sugar and has a vanilla hint (might have to use more for taste). It also safe for the Keto diet. 7. Xylitol is not worth consuming even though it tastes close to sugar. It negatively impacts ketones and blood glucose level. Mixed GI results. 8. Maltitol has a gummy consistency. It greatly impacts ketones and spikes blood glucose level. 9. Aspartame seems to be Keto-friendly and diabetic-friendly, but not necessarily healthy. Open to corrections if needed. 😊
Marianne Wade IMHO sucralose tastes very good in the flavored drops form, rather than taking it pure. For example my favorite sweetener of all are caramel sucralose drops, and I'm quite sensitive to the bad aftertaste some sweeteners have. That being said I have yet to try erythritol, I think that might be still a tastier option.
Stevia -> good Allulose -> good, gastric distress Sucralose -> good, people hate for no good reason Erythritol -> good, second worst gastric distress after Allulose Monk Fruit -> good, not as sweet as Stevia Xylitol -> bad, tastes good Maltitol -> very bad, basically sugar Asparatame -> good, bad for health
I have been drinking diet Pepsi (Aspartame) for about 35 years or whenever they started using it in Pepsi. I'm 78 and the same weight as when I was 19 years old! My weight is great. My wife even thinks that I'm a bit on the thin side. All my friends who warned me about the dangers of Aspartame died by the age of 72. They started dying at the age of 65. They all suffered from obesity problems. What more can I say.
“A spoonful of sugar helps the medicine go down!” I have to say kudos to both of you for eating straight sweeteners and poking your poor fingers all for the sake of science and all of our well-beings! LOTS OF LOVE ❤️ 🙏🥰
Poking fingers is actually easy if you use different fingers, and even different parts of that finger. Everyone should be doing it. At least 2 or 3 times daily. Basically, as long as you dont puncture in that spot too soon for it to heal. You can also use your palm.
Keto has been my saviour. I was 270lbs exactly 10 weeks ago and today im 209lbs. Incredibly i lost 22lbs in first 2 weeks. Ive slowed down to a couple pounds per week but its all good. I was doing no carbs one week then 25g the next and it worked for me. Im a 47 year old man and im back into clothes ive not worn in 5 years. Thanks keto.
@@BricktopsPigs YES, I know what you mean .... even though I have not ever been really overweight, there was a time that I gained about 15 lbs - I’m only 5’ - and even though I wasn’t seriously overweight, I just didn’t feel comfortable in my own skin - couple fun facts I’ve heard about weight - don’t know for men, but for women, 8 lbs. is a whole size difference ! Also, I have heard from a couple of sources that for every pound you lose, it takes 4 pounds of pressure off your knees - you’re young, but believe me, you want good knees - also, the younger you are when you lose weight, the better condition your skin is in to snap back after the loss - so try not to “yo-yo” too much ! You should be really proud of yourself ! I have since lost most of the weight I gained, but it also gets harder to lose weight as you get older - keep up the good work !
Thank you for this. I am a diabetic trying out sugar subtitues and wasting my time...lol You eliminated ones I hadn't tried and pointed to ones I didn't know about. So glad I happened on your video.
Not if done right. Use the side of the fingertip to avoid most of the sensitive nerve endings. Using a lower number on glucometre tip on side of pinky finger gives bigger blood sample with much less possible discomfort. I use a Contour Next glucometre. I test at least 12 times everyday. I find it doesn’t hurt.
I cannot tell you how valuable and appreciated this test is. Out of all the conflicting information out there, this is a definitive breath of fresh air.
@@Suge212 that is true but the video was referencing sweeteners not chocolate. I dont think people realize how lethal xylitol is for pets and it is now used in many products. Just a buyer beware heads up!
This is one of the most helpful videos since most of us don't have the discipline to do this, have to rely on manufacturers, and the fact that you are both testing. So great. Thank you!
My wife and I want to take the time out of our day to say thank you tremendously for this video. We had no idea what a couple of those sweeteners were doing to our blood glucose levels. Again, thank you both so very much!
Ordered some erythritol this evening coz I'm shocked at the reading xylitol gave. That's been my stock std for years now. Thanks for the super informative video, guys
I'm so glad I found your channel. I was just diagnosed diabetic and it crushed me. I was thinking I'm never going to enjoy any foods again. But your channel has lifted spirits and I've learned a great deal of knowledge. Thank you
You can reverse your diabetes in months. Along with these great keto recipes channels, please look at videos by dr Jason fung, a kidney specialist and md that regularly reverses diabetes with keto and intermittent fasting and any video by butter Bob Briggs. The science is even better than the food videos! You can really understand what happens in your body and exactly how to reverse it. My story; a month ago, my fasting blood sugar had climbed to 245. That is bad! With keto and intermittent fasting my fasting glucose is 101 and my glucose after a meal is 127! Normal post meal is anything under 140. You can eat amazing food, you can feel great and, even better, your diabetes does not have to progress! Good luck to you! Oh and I've dropped 13 lbs in the time that blood sugar and blood pressure has corrected itself.
Hi Mark, You are too young to be sick. workout, and follow a healthy lifestyle and you should be off of med soon. I joined a few "keto group" on facebook. and they are helping me a lot. be healthy by eating healthy
Mark, I was diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes 4 months ago. With low carb eating (no medication), I've been able to lower my blood glucose to normal numbers (within 3 months) as well as losing weight.Many people with diabetes are now eating low carb and seeing these benefits. It can be done!
Even though I dont watch your channel and am not Keto, as someone with SIBO I have found this particular video invaluable. Thank you for testing all these substances in your body and giving us the real data on how they responded. Thanks for doing the work.
Fantastic video. I’ve been doing a low carbohydrate diet since late 1999 and even though I am diabetic, keep my blood sugars mostly in the non-diabetic normal ranges. I now mostly use pure monk fruit as a sweetener, but have wondered about the blood sugar impact of some of the ones you tested. One note, when you are doing this kind of test don’t forget about the dawn phenomenon. This is where your liver stores glycogen overnight and releases it in the early morning, so even though you have not yet eaten anything, your blood sugar can still go up. While you usually see the dawn phenomenon written about in connection to diabetes, it is a biological process that happens in all of us.
Glad to know that you have maintained your blood sugar levels. I am planning to use Monk Fruit as sugar replacement. Would you recommend it based on your experience?
Some early research on The Dawn Phenomenon was on US Vietnam soldiers that were held captive for years. They were kept in complete darkness for very long periods. They became so in tune with their body, that they could always tell when it was around 4- 6 am. Their body’s would tell them. I’m diabetic and both Dawn Phenomena and “Waking Stress” as my Dr from Johns Hopkins tells me. My sugars will rise in the early morning hours but I don’t get up until later. After getting up (past the Dawn Phen) my sugars continue to rise.
I discovered this channel this week. This is the video that pushed me to subscribe! I'm not doing Keto but following a low carb diet and I love your straight forward info and advice.
Love you two! I'm six months into my keto journey, started on day of diagnosis. Blood sugar controlled within weeks and so far 50 lbs lost. You two provide so much information and you're nice to watch, thank you.
Sucrolose adversely affected my heart, for 2 years of using it, heart palpitations that got worse and more severe over time, exhaustion, light headed.. docs couldn't figure it out. Stopped using Sucrolose ie Splenda.. symptoms faded away, I never felt as strong after that episode either.. bad stuff imo
The reality is that these alternative sweeteners are either too new to have been rigorously studied, or there's just not enough independent interest in doing so, and we aren't really going to know all the long-term effects of using them for many years. We certainly cannot rely on the conclusions reached by the companies who make them, as we know historically that food manufacturers will lie, cheat, and steal to make a profit. The best bet is to limit your use of all of them until long-term studies show them to be definitively safe.
@@migeru243 I feel the same, there are so much money involved that you cannot really rely on what these companies are saying. People knock fruits lately, but are ok with these things. Why? Yes, an apple has some sugar, but good things as well. I know it is not fashionable to say these days, but some balance does not hurt.
I cannot believe the effect of the xylitol! It's been my go to sweetener. DOH! It does explain a lot so thank you both for putting yourself through the digestive issues for this!
Awesome guys. My husband is diabetic and wore a continuous glucose monitor. We tested keto breads. Wow, most spiked his blood a lot! Aunt Millie was the best. If you just worried about keto (me) a lot of stuff is probably fine, but diabetes, wow. It’s not always what you think! Good vid guys!
I think your two are amazing! Thank you so much for being who you are. I am so excited 4 weeks and 20 lbs!! I used to be on Atkins for years and now I am on Keto that is Atkins 2.0 lol
Thanks for doing this guys. Very helpful. I have been on keto since March last year and have totally stayed away from sweeteners and the sweet taste as a whole. I have occasionally eaten sweet stuff but always mindful of the fact that it was a bit of treat. I’m always scared of the slippery slope phenomenon whereby I once again embrace the sweet taste and start adding loads of sweeteners and yet feel dissatisfied. If I decide to try a sweetener, this video will be my starting point. Thanks for taking one for the team.
I use monk fruit in my bullet proof coffee and desserts/fat bombs and was wondering if I needed to switch... so I really appreciate this video... Thanks so much for the info...and for induring the GI distress in performing this testing to help others... I hope it wasn't too bad... much appreciation from this Keto newby...
I love to watch this video every now and then just to remind me about the sweetener info. It all is so confusing sometimes! God bless you two for all the work you do for us - and have for such a long time! It has been fun to watch your lives evolve too.
i know 2 people who loved their aspartame...one guy took 6 packets per cup of coffee ..tho other 3 packets each cup of coffee but drank coffee all day ...............both got pancreatic cancer ,,one is no longer with us
Thank you for testing these products in this way. I consider myself to be quite on top of the sweetener industry. I use a Xylitol/Stevia blend in everything and recommend this to everyone. As a result of your testing, I am switching to Erythritol rather than Xylitol. This is important information. I would like to see you do more videos comparing the dangers of artificial sweeteners. Very good job.
Thank you for making this video. I use Monk Fruit because it has antioxidants. I'm glad to know it doesn't mess with blood sugar levels and doesn't mess with digestion.
I use erythritol and stevia. I would like to see Leto/glucose reaction to high fiber foods like chai seeds or flaxseed or different beans.... And/or different vegetables like green beans/tomatoes/spinach.
This was interesting. I would like to see it done with insulin levels, which is probably impossible due to how hard it is logistically and financially to test this much. Many argue that even tasting sweets causes an insulin response, even if it doesn’t cause a glucose spike. Maybe that’s explains why glucose levels actually dropped after the some of the sweeteners. If it causes an insulin response, whatever glucose was in the blood was reduced by the insulin that was triggered by the body thinking it was eating sugar.
What you pointed out is CRITICALLY IMPORTANT to those of us who are obese and have hyperinsulinemia --Dr Fung Intermmitant fasting expert says that although no studies have been done on effect of sweeteners on insulin - None of the obese people who are substituting sugar with sweeteners BIG TIME are losing weight - so - perhaps just the taste of sweet triggers insulin response
@@selini7774 That's a fair point, although correlation does not always equal causation, as they say. It's not because obese people who substitute sugar with sweeteners are failing to lose weight that the sweeteners per se are to be held accountable. Often, overweight individuals, particularly Americans, will go out for fast food and choose a Diet Coke over a regular Coke, thinking it'll make them "healthier"; they'll then procede to consume 2400 calories through cheeseburgers, fries, milkshakes, etc. It's absolutely futile to replace sugar with sweeteners if you continue to gorge such inordinate, exorbitant amounts of ultra processed junk. I'd like to see the weight evolution of people who follow healthy diets yet consume sugary beverages recplace such beverages with sweeteners. Just my two cents.
Was thinking the exact same - the blood glucose level drops seem to indicate an insulin spike, which means the sweeteners are putting the body into the fat-gain state and would explain why artificial sweeteners seem to stall weight loss in many people.
I can’t touch stevia - it makes me SO dizzy! Lankato’s Monkfruit blend has allowed me to love lower carb. Yay! Thanks, y’all, for doing this. You’re amazing!
Yes, same here. Stevia is the devil for me. Love the Lakanto. BochaSweet tastes just like sugar with no aftertaste but I can't find much info on it other than the claims on the packaging.
Hey great video. Like your approach, I am a chemist and recently diagnosed as Type 2 Diabetic. In the past year I have come down from the low 300's to 235 pounds. Mainly following a keto diet. As you state everything in moderation, also I have been organic for a number of years, my wife and I raise, hunt and grow most of our own food. I am not a fan of 'artificial' anything including sweetners. I would like to point out a few things that you might want to consider if you run this again. Data points you might want to include in your DOE (Design of Experiment) I would like to see your blood glucose levels at 30, 60 and 120 minutes. Different compounds will digest and absorb at different rates. Also you should drink water with your "sugar" to assist in dilution and absorption into your digestive tract. You might have done this but it was not in the video. Getting your morning baseline is good. Thanks for the work.
Thanks for this video! I’ve been wondering why my ketones level has been dropping, even though I’ve been eating very low carb. I’ve been enjoying some lovely sugar free baked goods bought from my local supermarket which are labeled as ‘keto’. Reading the ingredients, I see they are sweetened with Xylitol. That would explain my dropping ketone levels. Thanks for the info!
Fantastic video I have to admit my wife Roxane tried to get us to do this a few months ago but you pulled it off three years ago this will be a thing I refer people to constantly
But these guys are not diebetics so we cannot say the blood glucose results of their small experiment is representative for a diebetic. Secondly and most importantly, we do not know the long term impact of these substances. How they impact kidneys in the long run?.
@@TheMrgoodboy2 The one I was taking was absolutely not good for me nor my health. I wasn't going off their meter readings, as much as I wanted to find options better than, you guessed it, Apartame. I swapped over to Monkfruit. I'm new to keto, but within days I have lost weight and my DK is no where in site. I was suffering so bad but here I am feeling loads better.
@@quirkyavocado_-3558 very happy to hear that. I am a diebetic my self. But i am really worried how stevia, monk fruit or arithratol impack my kidneys long run. As diebetics, kidney protection is the most important thing.
Xylitol is good to be used in ice cream you want to store for longer times in the fridge, it helps to avoid getting superhard icecreams as you get with Erythritol.
Great video, thanks for risking your health for us. I'm interested in fiber syrups like fiber yum and sorbitol. Matt, did you retest the stevia? What were the results?
It’s funny how people have different tastes, I find erythritol and stevia extremely bitter yet others find it okay Erythritol by itself tastes okay but as soon as I put it into something it tastes bitter, lots of aftertaste.
YES. although the maltitol would have killed me. I can do erythritol and allulose without too much bother but sorbitol and maltitol put me on the porcelain all day!
I'm so glad to hear my monk fruit is safe. It is the only sweetener I like. I can't stand stevia, it tastes bitter to me. I would love some input on Boca Sweet. I guess It's a pentose sugar.
And it *can* upset the microbiome balance, leading to increased inflammation, so those of you low carbing due to Lyme disease, this one is a big no-no.
I am so glad you guys did this. I was not surprised with aspartame but it has been my experience that if I consume too much of it over time, my blood glucose is affected negatively and not only just after consumption but on overall readings throughout the day and night. I am glad to see monk fruit in the selections and was pleased with your results. Primal Edge Health uses it and swears it is the gold standard, so it is nice to see that he is right again. I was not surprised by maltitol but I was a little thrown off by xylitol so this will go on my ingredient watch list. Also, I love how consistent and methodical you two are with your experiments, so thanks again for another great video and take-aways.
Love this vid and can't thank you enough for making it ...HOWEVER.. as a type 2 diabetic I'm keto mostly because of my concern about insulin resistance. Blood sugar spikes are only markers of the underlying problem dealing with insulin levels and a look at both blood sugar and insulin levels are key to knowing the impact of these sweeteners and Carbs in general. What I really want to know is do these sweeteners cause a spike in insulin. Having said that, thanks again so much for this and all of your most informative videos. I'm a fan and am grateful.
I think testing glucose as a proxy of insulin is really the best we can do, and is a pretty good indicator but obviously is not perfect. Thanks for the feedback.
I found Megha and Matt’s review of sweeteners extremely helpful! I know now to avoid xylitol and look out for maltitol on products that claim to be Keto friendly. They aren’t! This information is particularly important for people with cancer that are following a Keto diet because sugar is rocket fuel for cancer cells. Keep up the great work, Megha and Matt. Just bought a Kindle version of your cookbook and expect it will be as helpful as your videos.
I've wondered if glycerin affects blood sugar. Your stevia is in glyerite I think. Can you test just plain and concentrated stevia powder vs. stevia in glycerine?
Stevia causes my sinuses to become inflamed. At first I thought it was a random reaction to the air or something else, but it kept happening without fail. After doing a little reading on it, turns out stevia is a relative of ragweed.
This is the best video I’ve ever seen comparing the different sweeteners and their effect on blood sugar and blood ketone levels
Dr. Berry and KetoConnect together. This is excellent.
Is coconut sugar ok to eat on keto? Does anybody know if there's a video like this about it?
It is not. It's just sugar.
LOL...really?
Was this about the sugar comment? If so, then yes. Coconut sugar is sugar. It has a lower GI than cane sugar, but it still spikes blood glucose.
Summary:
1. Sugar is subtly sweet. Ketones dropped and blood glucose level increased.
2. Stevia shows mixed results.
3. Allulose tastes good and does not affect ketones or blood glucose level. Bad GI distress though.
4. Sucralose is intensely sweet and does not affect ketones or blood glucose.
5. Erythritol tastes almost as good as Allulose and has similar/no effect on ketones and blood glucose, but also causes GI distress.
6. Monk fruit is not as sweet as sugar and has a vanilla hint (might have to use more for taste). It also safe for the Keto diet.
7. Xylitol is not worth consuming even though it tastes close to sugar. It negatively impacts ketones and blood glucose level. Mixed GI results.
8. Maltitol has a gummy consistency. It greatly impacts ketones and spikes blood glucose level.
9. Aspartame seems to be Keto-friendly and diabetic-friendly, but not necessarily healthy.
Open to corrections if needed. 😊
Hey thanks that's really useful. I'll put that in my notes
Sucralose is the best one?
Perhaps sucralose is best for a keto eater, but it does have quite an aftertaste. Blech.
Excellent summation thank you! Wonder if all those sugar substitutes have an aftertaste.
Marianne Wade IMHO sucralose tastes very good in the flavored drops form, rather than taking it pure. For example my favorite sweetener of all are caramel sucralose drops, and I'm quite sensitive to the bad aftertaste some sweeteners have. That being said I have yet to try erythritol, I think that might be still a tastier option.
Stevia -> good
Allulose -> good, gastric distress
Sucralose -> good, people hate for no good reason
Erythritol -> good, second worst gastric distress after Allulose
Monk Fruit -> good, not as sweet as Stevia
Xylitol -> bad, tastes good
Maltitol -> very bad, basically sugar
Asparatame -> good, bad for health
Thank you. I was not watching all that. I knew someone had it for us to read ❤❤
I'm so lucky to have bought stevia instead of the other ones xd
Awe man! No more sugar free hard candy for me. It has maltitol in it. I never would have guessed!
I have been drinking diet Pepsi (Aspartame) for about 35 years or whenever they started using it in Pepsi. I'm 78 and the same weight as when I was 19 years old! My weight is great. My wife even thinks that I'm a bit on the thin side. All my friends who warned me about the dangers of Aspartame died by the age of 72. They started dying at the age of 65. They all suffered from obesity problems. What more can I say.
@@mikescott1029 Than you are an exception, not a statistic.
“A spoonful of sugar helps the medicine go down!” I have to say kudos to both of you for eating straight sweeteners and poking your poor fingers all for the sake of science and all of our well-beings! LOTS OF LOVE ❤️ 🙏🥰
You two people are really loved by me it would be awesome to have you 4 my family ,can I adopt you both please.love from joy parrott,your the best.
Poking fingers is actually easy if you use different fingers, and even different parts of that finger. Everyone should be doing it. At least 2 or 3 times daily. Basically, as long as you dont puncture in that spot too soon for it to heal. You can also use your palm.
Sugar 1:59
Stevia 3:30
Allulose 4:18
Succhralose 5:28
Erythritol 6:38
Monk fruit 7:42
Xylitol 8:45
Maltitol 10:41
Aspartame 12:51
Thank You !!!
And the large graph is at 14:53 . . . Thanks for these timings, Jeremie!
What about honey?
vivabanana94 toosweet
@@angelfiremimosa need less and not artificial tho. Thats why o was woundering
I love how you guys finish each other's sentences but never really interrupt each other 😍
its like they are soulmates =)
Great chemistry!
It's actually super-fascinating to watch.
Keto has been my saviour.
I was 270lbs exactly 10 weeks ago and today im 209lbs.
Incredibly i lost 22lbs in first 2 weeks.
Ive slowed down to a couple pounds per week but its all good.
I was doing no carbs one week then 25g the next and it worked for me.
Im a 47 year old man and im back into clothes ive not worn in 5 years.
Thanks keto.
Congratulations ! I bet you feel so good !
@@Melody-285
You know it!!
Physically but maybe moreso mentally.
@@BricktopsPigs YES, I know what you mean .... even though I have not ever been really overweight, there was a time that I gained about 15 lbs - I’m only 5’ - and even though I wasn’t seriously overweight, I just didn’t feel comfortable in my own skin - couple fun facts I’ve heard about weight - don’t know for men, but for women, 8 lbs. is a whole size difference ! Also, I have heard from a couple of sources that for every pound you lose, it takes 4 pounds of pressure off your knees - you’re young, but believe me, you want good knees - also, the younger you are when you lose weight, the better condition your skin is in to snap back after the loss - so try not to “yo-yo” too much ! You should be really proud of yourself ! I have since lost most of the weight I gained, but it also gets harder to lose weight as you get older - keep up the good work !
Melody o
👍👍👍😍😍😍
Thank you for this. I am a diabetic trying out sugar subtitues and wasting my time...lol You eliminated ones I hadn't tried and pointed to ones I didn't know about. So glad I happened on your video.
God Bless you two for sacrificing yourselves for science and for all of us.
Amen
Does it hurt to prick for blood ... I want to track mine but I am scared
Str8 up.
@@Mr.Helper. it's not that bad, like a mosquito bite
Not if done right.
Use the side of the fingertip to avoid most of the sensitive nerve endings. Using a lower number on glucometre tip on side of pinky finger gives bigger blood sample with much less possible discomfort.
I use a Contour Next glucometre.
I test at least 12 times everyday.
I find it doesn’t hurt.
as a diabetic this information is huge. Thank you so much!
Amen
The sweetest thing in this video is this couple.
Awww hehe
Oh BARF!
FACTS THEY'RE SO SWEET
King David I eye rolled so hard at that statement.
Awwww...😁
MATT, your blood glucose rose 9 points on STEVIA. Did you retest STEVIA as you said you were going to do, and what was the outcome? Thank you!
I’ve been on a very extreme keto diet, and have lost over 220lbs. This video REALLY opened my eyes on artificial sweeteners.
Wow!! Thats amazing :) big kudos to you and go get em tiger!
@@jooreuable Thank you so much. Down 300lbs now. Almost done
@@matthewwilson9749 you should post your journey
@@matthewwilson9749 you’re a hero ❤️💯 congratulations 👏
@@ChandanaCTV I’m no hero, but thank you so much. I’ve lost over 300lbs down now.
This video is keto gold! Thank you
OMG - the fact that you are eating that stuff straight up is incredible. Gross but incredible!
I cannot tell you how valuable and appreciated this test is. Out of all the conflicting information out there, this is a definitive breath of fresh air.
"Lets just become smarter as a society" ahhhh what a nice refreshing phrase these days. Thank you
Everyone is talking about herd immunity nowadays, and here I am just wishing for herd intelligence.
Xylitol is lethal for dogs. It should have a warning label on it!!
Amen. A huge one! Also products using it.
So is chocolate.
@@Suge212 that is true but the video was referencing sweeteners not chocolate. I dont think people realize how lethal xylitol is for pets and it is now used in many products.
Just a buyer beware heads up!
@@badjimmy2561 Good point.
Who and why would you give sugar substitutes to a dog?
This is one of the most helpful videos since most of us don't have the discipline to do this, have to rely on manufacturers, and the fact that you are both testing. So great. Thank you!
My wife and I want to take the time out of our day to say thank you tremendously for this video.
We had no idea what a couple of those sweeteners were doing to our blood glucose levels.
Again, thank you both so very much!
Benefits of xylitol - th-cam.com/video/uLN1jrrmI_E/w-d-xo.htmlsi=D1TM0PuNhyqEvy-V
Ordered some erythritol this evening coz I'm shocked at the reading xylitol gave. That's been my stock std for years now. Thanks for the super informative video, guys
I'm so glad I found your channel. I was just diagnosed diabetic and it crushed me. I was thinking I'm never going to enjoy any foods again. But your channel has lifted spirits and I've learned a great deal of knowledge. Thank you
You can reverse your diabetes in months. Along with these great keto recipes channels, please look at videos by dr Jason fung, a kidney specialist and md that regularly reverses diabetes with keto and intermittent fasting and any video by butter Bob Briggs. The science is even better than the food videos! You can really understand what happens in your body and exactly how to reverse it.
My story; a month ago, my fasting blood sugar had climbed to 245. That is bad! With keto and intermittent fasting my fasting glucose is 101 and my glucose after a meal is 127! Normal post meal is anything under 140. You can eat amazing food, you can feel great and, even better, your diabetes does not have to progress! Good luck to you! Oh and I've dropped 13 lbs in the time that blood sugar and blood pressure has corrected itself.
Stick with it. My husband was off meds in a month and maintains a normal blood sugar with keto. You can do it!
Hi Mark, You are too young to be sick. workout, and follow a healthy lifestyle and you should be off of med soon. I joined a few "keto group" on facebook. and they are helping me a lot. be healthy by eating healthy
You can reverse it.
Mark, I was diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes 4 months ago. With low carb eating (no medication), I've been able to lower my blood glucose to normal numbers (within 3 months) as well as losing weight.Many people with diabetes are now eating low carb and seeing these benefits. It can be done!
I’m a diabetic and I was wondering why my numbers were higher with certain ingredients. Thank you so much for doing this video!
I'm an aries but I'm not diabetic 😁
@D B I don't eat junk food clown . Get a life and get lost
Remember every body is different and might affect different.
there are a lot of low calorie sweeteners that negatively impact blood sugar levels
And if your sweetener has maltodextrin in it it’s impacting your blood sugar in a huge way. That stuff is worse then table sugar.
Even though I dont watch your channel and am not Keto, as someone with SIBO I have found this particular video invaluable. Thank you for testing all these substances in your body and giving us the real data on how they responded. Thanks for doing the work.
Wow, you guys are hard core taking that stuff straight. High quality info, thank you very much.
Oh, and PS. Xylitol is deadly to dogs. So if you use it, don't leave this lying around where they can get to it.
This needs to be at the top
It's deadly to all animals I belive!
only in LARGE amounts. research.
The lethal dose is 0.1g per kg of the dog's weight. 1 stick of gum can have .3-.4 g in it. So it's not that large a dose to kill.
I was really hoping they'd mention that. Especially since they have a dog themselves.
Clearly, this video is now the gold standard for keto sweetener tests.
Fantastic video. I’ve been doing a low carbohydrate diet since late 1999 and even though I am diabetic, keep my blood sugars mostly in the non-diabetic normal ranges. I now mostly use pure monk fruit as a sweetener, but have wondered about the blood sugar impact of some of the ones you tested. One note, when you are doing this kind of test don’t forget about the dawn phenomenon. This is where your liver stores glycogen overnight and releases it in the early morning, so even though you have not yet eaten anything, your blood sugar can still go up. While you usually see the dawn phenomenon written about in connection to diabetes, it is a biological process that happens in all of us.
Glad to know that you have maintained your blood sugar levels. I am planning to use Monk Fruit as sugar replacement. Would you recommend it based on your experience?
Some early research on The Dawn Phenomenon was on US Vietnam soldiers that were held captive for years. They were kept in complete darkness for very long periods. They became so in tune with their body, that they could always tell when it was around 4- 6 am. Their body’s would tell them. I’m diabetic and both Dawn Phenomena and “Waking Stress” as my Dr from Johns Hopkins tells me. My sugars will rise in the early morning hours but I don’t get up until later. After getting up (past the Dawn Phen) my sugars continue to rise.
such good info. Thanks guys, Your Keto advice has helped me drop over 110 lbs now, since July of this year. I hope you have an amazing holiday.
MrTangtheCat wow 👏🏼
Can you make a video with the different Keto Breads and flours? With the blood test and keto tests please. Wraps would be welcome as well.
I watched this again after 1.5 years of doing keto. Lost 36 lbs. 13 lbs to go.
I discovered this channel this week. This is the video that pushed me to subscribe! I'm not doing Keto but following a low carb diet and I love your straight forward info and advice.
Some interesting results, matt how did you go when re tested stevia?
Love you two! I'm six months into my keto journey, started on day of diagnosis. Blood sugar controlled within weeks and so far 50 lbs lost. You two provide so much information and you're nice to watch, thank you.
“You *my* sugar.” 🥰
I think Megha was expecting a little more than just a simple "thanks" from Matt when she said that to him.. lol. Bless.
@@citizenk8125 He shoulda answerd : So you tryna say i knock you out of keto you dumb Bitch?
Thank you for this! I have xylitol and erythritol and mistakenly thought they had the same glycemic index. Makes all the difference to know.
Sucrolose adversely affected my heart, for 2 years of using it, heart palpitations that got worse and more severe over time, exhaustion, light headed.. docs couldn't figure it out. Stopped using Sucrolose ie Splenda.. symptoms faded away, I never felt as strong after that episode either.. bad stuff imo
hope you tried some ubiquinol and ribose to heal your heart
Glad you are feeling better
Stevia can cause heart and kidney issues with too much consumption too
The reality is that these alternative sweeteners are either too new to have been rigorously studied, or there's just not enough independent interest in doing so, and we aren't really going to know all the long-term effects of using them for many years. We certainly cannot rely on the conclusions reached by the companies who make them, as we know historically that food manufacturers will lie, cheat, and steal to make a profit. The best bet is to limit your use of all of them until long-term studies show them to be definitively safe.
@@migeru243 I feel the same, there are so much money involved that you cannot really rely on what these companies are saying. People knock fruits lately, but are ok with these things. Why? Yes, an apple has some sugar, but good things as well. I know it is not fashionable to say these days, but some balance does not hurt.
I thought I was crazy because the Akins candy makes my sugar go through the roof. Makes sense now, thank you 😊
I cannot believe the effect of the xylitol! It's been my go to sweetener. DOH! It does explain a lot so thank you both for putting yourself through the digestive issues for this!
Hi keto Christina. I love your videos. So does my wife.
Awesome guys. My husband is diabetic and wore a continuous glucose monitor. We tested keto breads. Wow, most spiked his blood a lot! Aunt Millie was the best. If you just worried about keto (me) a lot of stuff is probably fine, but diabetes, wow. It’s not always what you think! Good vid guys!
I think your two are amazing! Thank you so much for being who you are. I am so excited 4 weeks and 20 lbs!! I used to be on Atkins for years and now I am on Keto that is Atkins 2.0 lol
Thanks for doing this guys. Very helpful. I have been on keto since March last year and have totally stayed away from sweeteners and the sweet taste as a whole. I have occasionally eaten sweet stuff but always mindful of the fact that it was a bit of treat. I’m always scared of the slippery slope phenomenon whereby I once again embrace the sweet taste and start adding loads of sweeteners and yet feel dissatisfied. If I decide to try a sweetener, this video will be my starting point. Thanks for taking one for the team.
What’s the effect of these on gut health, ghrelin, and leptin production?
Loved how direct you guys were.
I love Xylitol.....that should have been my first warning sign.
I don't know why I found this humerous! Lol, But so true
It is the closet taste to sugar and to me even better than sugar, guess it's going to have to go.
Kellye Raiborn erythritol is way better in most ways!
em nesia omg yes, I spent most of a night in the bathroom
😹😹😹😹😹😹 lol
Hi thank you can you please try
Vitafiber
coconut suger
and fruit that be intresting
thank you for do this for as
I use monk fruit in my bullet proof coffee and desserts/fat bombs and was wondering if I needed to switch... so I really appreciate this video... Thanks so much for the info...and for induring the GI distress in performing this testing to help others... I hope it wasn't too bad... much appreciation from this Keto newby...
Thanks for sharing this video! What an experiment it really opened my eyes to maltitol
I love to watch this video every now and then just to remind me about the sweetener info. It all is so confusing sometimes! God bless you two for all the work you do for us - and have for such a long time! It has been fun to watch your lives evolve too.
i know 2 people who loved their aspartame...one guy took 6 packets per cup of coffee ..tho other 3 packets each cup of coffee but drank coffee all day ...............both got pancreatic cancer ,,one is no longer with us
Jennie Spooner wow!! That’s terrible
Wow sad to hear..but thanks for sharing
Thanks guys. This was really a great video. I would like to see you test different fruits.
Very, very helpful. I thank you and your days of digestive distress for this video!
Thanks for being our test dummies
you guys have gotten so much more comfortable on camera and its great to see everything evolve, keep it up!
Thank you for testing these products in this way. I consider myself to be quite on top of the sweetener industry. I use a Xylitol/Stevia blend in everything and recommend this to everyone. As a result of your testing, I am switching to Erythritol rather than Xylitol. This is important information. I would like to see you do more videos comparing the dangers of artificial sweeteners. Very good job.
Thank you and I wish you could tell us witch one of those substitutes are better for our health.
Thank you for making this video. I use Monk Fruit because it has antioxidants. I'm glad to know it doesn't mess with blood sugar levels and doesn't mess with digestion.
The most helpful video I have ever watched for keto. Everyone doing keto should watch this!
At first I thought it wasn't a great test due to how the impact of interplay of food . With sweetner but leave it to these too I'm assured.
Great video, this was exactly what I was looking for. I think I will get erythritol and monk fruit.
Great video. I just trashed my xylitol. Thank you so much.
You make me feel better about drinking Stevia water while fasting. Thanks!
I just started my Keto journey, so this was SUPER helpful! Thanks so much for doing this :)
I agree that this is the best video I have seen on sweeteners. As a diabetic information like this is gold to us
I use erythritol and stevia.
I would like to see Leto/glucose reaction to high fiber foods like chai seeds or flaxseed or different beans....
And/or different vegetables like green beans/tomatoes/spinach.
Susan F. That’s a sweetener.
Was the Xylitol you tested made with corn or birch?
Debra Curry ...corn
Thank you very much for this video! I’m heart broken about the maltitol in my beloved Atkins bars, but I needed to be aware since I’m diabetic.
karen campanaro that was malitol syrup that they tried.. it’s different . Check your blood sugar after you eat the Atkins bars. I too love them
Thank you for the experiment!! I have been wanting to know the truth behind all the substitute sugars!!!
What about sucralose in protein shakes? I’m guessing it depends on the brand. Guess I’ll stick to eggs & chicken now... for my proteins.
I’m curious as to what the affects of honey would be. Great video. Thanks for doing this for us.
And coconut sugar too
@@nellkells3290 And yacon syrup, please
Off course like normal sugar
This was interesting. I would like to see it done with insulin levels, which is probably impossible due to how hard it is logistically and financially to test this much. Many argue that even tasting sweets causes an insulin response, even if it doesn’t cause a glucose spike. Maybe that’s explains why glucose levels actually dropped after the some of the sweeteners. If it causes an insulin response, whatever glucose was in the blood was reduced by the insulin that was triggered by the body thinking it was eating sugar.
What you pointed out is CRITICALLY IMPORTANT to those of us who are obese and have hyperinsulinemia --Dr Fung Intermmitant fasting expert says that although no studies have been done on effect of sweeteners on insulin - None of the obese people who are substituting sugar with sweeteners BIG TIME are losing weight - so - perhaps just the taste of sweet triggers insulin response
@@selini7774 That's a fair point, although correlation does not always equal causation, as they say. It's not because obese people who substitute sugar with sweeteners are failing to lose weight that the sweeteners per se are to be held accountable. Often, overweight individuals, particularly Americans, will go out for fast food and choose a Diet Coke over a regular Coke, thinking it'll make them "healthier"; they'll then procede to consume 2400 calories through cheeseburgers, fries, milkshakes, etc. It's absolutely futile to replace sugar with sweeteners if you continue to gorge such inordinate, exorbitant amounts of ultra processed junk. I'd like to see the weight evolution of people who follow healthy diets yet consume sugary beverages recplace such beverages with sweeteners.
Just my two cents.
Was thinking the exact same - the blood glucose level drops seem to indicate an insulin spike, which means the sweeteners are putting the body into the fat-gain state and would explain why artificial sweeteners seem to stall weight loss in many people.
Thanks for testing Allulose. There's not much info about it online as it's still new. Glad to hear it falls in the good category.
I can’t touch stevia - it makes me SO dizzy! Lankato’s Monkfruit blend has allowed me to love lower carb. Yay! Thanks, y’all, for doing this. You’re amazing!
Yes, same here. Stevia is the devil for me. Love the Lakanto. BochaSweet tastes just like sugar with no aftertaste but I can't find much info on it other than the claims on the packaging.
we can find Monk fruit in amrica
@@nadash3186 I found mine on Amazon.
@@i.l.3113 Same here, and I just love it!!! 🤗🖐
Hey great video. Like your approach, I am a chemist and recently diagnosed as Type 2 Diabetic. In the past year I have come down from the low 300's to 235 pounds. Mainly following a keto diet. As you state everything in moderation, also I have been organic for a number of years, my wife and I raise, hunt and grow most of our own food. I am not a fan of 'artificial' anything including sweetners.
I would like to point out a few things that you might want to consider if you run this again. Data points you might want to include in your DOE (Design of Experiment) I would like to see your blood glucose levels at 30, 60 and 120 minutes. Different compounds will digest and absorb at different rates. Also you should drink water with your "sugar" to assist in dilution and absorption into your digestive tract. You might have done this but it was not in the video. Getting your morning baseline is good.
Thanks for the work.
erythritol isn't artificial
@@guswrethman2156 While it does occur in nature, what is used in food processing is synthetically manufactured...
Thanks for this video! I’ve been wondering why my ketones level has been dropping, even though I’ve been eating very low carb. I’ve been enjoying some lovely sugar free baked goods bought from my local supermarket which are labeled as ‘keto’. Reading the ingredients, I see they are sweetened with Xylitol. That would explain my dropping ketone levels. Thanks for the info!
Fantastic video I have to admit my wife Roxane tried to get us to do this a few months ago but you pulled it off three years ago this will be a thing I refer people to constantly
As a diabetic, it's nice to know these things to take care of my health. This definitely was great information. Thanks!
But these guys are not diebetics so we cannot say the blood glucose results of their small experiment is representative for a diebetic.
Secondly and most importantly, we do not know the long term impact of these substances. How they impact kidneys in the long run?.
@@TheMrgoodboy2 The one I was taking was absolutely not good for me nor my health. I wasn't going off their meter readings, as much as I wanted to find options better than, you guessed it, Apartame. I swapped over to Monkfruit. I'm new to keto, but within days I have lost weight and my DK is no where in site. I was suffering so bad but here I am feeling loads better.
@@quirkyavocado_-3558 very happy to hear that. I am a diebetic my self. But i am really worried how stevia, monk fruit or arithratol impack my kidneys long run. As diebetics, kidney protection is the most important thing.
@@TheMrgoodboy2 Moderation is probably the key to preserving the kidneys. Some over do it, but I'm not one who wants to end up on dialysis.
Y’all did a great job!! Thank you guys for doing this!! Y’all should check what kind of impact honey has. Keep up the great videos!!
Blood sugar peaks after 1 hour, I’d be interested to see if there were any differences after than amount of time.
And, if there's a phantom sugar insulin response to the artificial sweeteners.
Yeah, I would have tested at an hour and mayhe even 90 minutes to get a better perspective.
Thank you for this video.
My 13 yo granddaughter has diabetes and this is incredibly informative!
Thank you!
Xylitol is good to be used in ice cream you want to store for longer times in the fridge, it helps to avoid getting superhard icecreams as you get with Erythritol.
Great video, thanks for risking your health for us. I'm interested in fiber syrups like fiber yum and sorbitol. Matt, did you retest the stevia? What were the results?
So glad Erythritol came out so well! It's what I enjoy in baking and my tea!
It’s funny how people have different tastes, I find erythritol and stevia extremely bitter yet others find it okay
Erythritol by itself tastes okay but as soon as I put it into something it tastes bitter, lots of aftertaste.
@@adeliaemailnelson136 They all taste terrible to me.
@@adeliaemailnelson136 its in ur genetic. .same effect cilantro get to some ppl..taste like soap to them.
Thank you for this video and sacrificing yourselves in the pursuit of beneficial knowledge! I’m curious about coconut, maple, and date sugars/syrups.
great work guys really appreciate the hassle and effort you put in this video
Thank you for risking your GI to bring us this research
YES. although the maltitol would have killed me. I can do erythritol and allulose without too much bother but sorbitol and maltitol put me on the porcelain all day!
I'm so glad to hear my monk fruit is safe. It is the only sweetener I like. I can't stand stevia, it tastes bitter to me. I would love some input on Boca Sweet. I guess It's a pentose sugar.
Hey girl, I love Boca sweet too, but monkfruit is cheaper. They are my two favorite.
When Sucralose first came out, I read a study that it does interfere with the function of the mitochondria
And it *can* upset the microbiome balance, leading to increased inflammation, so those of you low carbing due to Lyme disease, this one is a big no-no.
It also is linked to contributing to cancers
I am so glad you guys did this. I was not surprised with aspartame but it has been my experience that if I consume too much of it over time, my blood glucose is affected negatively and not only just after consumption but on overall readings throughout the day and night. I am glad to see monk fruit in the selections and was pleased with your results. Primal Edge Health uses it and swears it is the gold standard, so it is nice to see that he is right again. I was not surprised by maltitol but I was a little thrown off by xylitol so this will go on my ingredient watch list. Also, I love how consistent and methodical you two are with your experiments, so thanks again for another great video and take-aways.
Габрюша Б try liquid sucralose.
I loved this ... I swear you guys are the blue print to this keto thing lol
Thak you for this video, trying to reverse my diabetes. I am also doing intermittent fasting.
How are you?
@@behealthy9398 better, thank both of you.
@@michellemarsh1366 keep moving forward toward vibrant health! The Lord is carrying me through to save my life! He will do the same for you!
I always come back to this video whenever I want to try something new to check with y’all first. Thanks you guys!
Love this vid and can't thank you enough for making it ...HOWEVER.. as a type 2 diabetic I'm keto mostly because of my concern about insulin resistance. Blood sugar spikes are only markers of the underlying problem dealing with insulin levels and a look at both blood sugar and insulin levels are key to knowing the impact of these sweeteners and Carbs in general. What I really want to know is do these sweeteners cause a spike in insulin. Having said that, thanks again so much for this and all of your most informative videos. I'm a fan and am grateful.
I think testing glucose as a proxy of insulin is really the best we can do, and is a pretty good indicator but obviously is not perfect. Thanks for the feedback.
I found Megha and Matt’s review of sweeteners extremely helpful! I know now to avoid xylitol and look out for maltitol on products that claim to be Keto friendly. They aren’t! This information is particularly important for people with cancer that are following a Keto diet because sugar is rocket fuel for cancer cells. Keep up the great work, Megha and Matt. Just bought a Kindle version of your cookbook and expect it will be as helpful as your videos.
A.J, Cresswell While Aspartame may work-it’s Cancer causing....
I've wondered if glycerin affects blood sugar. Your stevia is in glyerite I think. Can you test just plain and concentrated stevia powder vs. stevia in glycerine?
Whats the difference?
ALWAYS appreciate all the testing you both do to help the Keto community. Glad you guys aren't Diabetics...
I commend y’all for eating straight sweetener. It grossed me out! But very informative!!
Matt, did you retest Stevia? Results?
Second
Fourth
Fifth
Sixth
7th
Very good info to have. Thank you for this video. I was wondering if you have ever tested raw honey?
Revisiting this video to remember the difference btwn these sweeteners!!! so helpful. thank you guys!!!
Stevia causes my sinuses to become inflamed. At first I thought it was a random reaction to the air or something else, but it kept happening without fail. After doing a little reading on it, turns out stevia is a relative of ragweed.
KC P me to
Valuable info. Thanks!
Wow!!! Thank you!!! KC P!!!
@@jadedoptimist6364 dont mention it 🙂
Wow I’m dealing with horrible sinuses right now. Thank you!