Porsche 911 992 Carrera S vs Aston Martin Vantage REVIEW POV on AUTOBAHN by AutoTopNL
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 มิ.ย. 2024
- Porsche 911 992 Carrera S vs Aston Martin Vantage REVIEW POV on AUTOBAHN by AutoTopNL
Subscribe to be the first to see new content! bit.ly/2aWQXw9
Check out our 100-200 GPS Scoreboard bit.ly/2PSakev
Check out our Brand Store: IgnitionCollection.com
Instagram: bit.ly/22Yp1yw AutoTopNL Facebook Fanpage: on. 1jlG5pQ
#AutoTopNL
UK: Auto-Top is an honest and pure car filming and testing company. We're not interested in eco & green (unless it's like, really superfast). Screaming exhausts, whining superchargers and blowing turbo's is what we want to hear! We review all sorts of performance cars. In the different playlists you can enjoy exhaust sounds, acceleration tests (0-100, 0-200) with launch control, onboard cams and the revving sound of each car. Exotic cars, hothatches, power sedans. We have it all!
DE: Wir nehmen alle möglichen leistungsstarken Autos unter die Lupe. In den verschiedenen Playlists könnt ihr ausreizende Sounds genießen, Beschleunigungstests (0-100, 0-200) mit Startkontrolle, onboard-Kameras und den hochtourigen Sound der Autos. Exotische Autos, sportliche Kompaktwagen und kraftvolle Limousinen. Wir haben sie alle!
FR: A travers les différentes playlists, vous pourrez apprécier des bruits d’échappements, des tests d’accélérations (0- 100, 0-200), des caméras embarquées ainsi que le son à l’accélération des voitures. Des voitures de rallyes aux berlines surpuissantes en passant par des bolides hors-norme...nous avons tout ce qu’il vous faut !
PL: Testujemy i oceniamy samochody - w naszych playlistach posłuchasz dźwięku silników, obejrzysz testy
przyspieszenia (0-100, 0-200) z launch control, kamerami wewnątrz kabiny i wibrującym dźwiękiem każdego
samochodu. Egzotyczne auta, hothatch, sportowe sedany - znajdziesz je wszystkie tutaj!
IT: Auto-Top è una società che si occupa di riprese e test drive. Non siamo interessati a macchine che consumano o inquinano poco (a meno che non siamo veramente veloci). Noi vogliamo sentire scarichi che urlano e turbo che soffiano!! Facciamo recensioni su ogni tipo di auto sportiva. Nelle nostre playlist troverai sound di scarichi, riprese onboard, test di accelerazione con launch control (0-100, 0-200) e il suono unico e riconoscibile di ogni auto. Supersportive, hothatches e berline cavallate.. Proviamo di tutto!!
ES: Auto-Top es una empresa de pruebas y grabación de coches sincera. No estamos interesados en la ecología. Tubos de escape rugiendo y motores echando humo, es todo lo que nos interesa oir! Hacemos reviews de todo tipo de coches. En las listas de reproducción podéis encontrar desde sonidos del ultramundo hasta tests de aceleración (0-100, 0-200), cámaras a bordo de los coches, hasta el sonido de aceleración de cada coche. Coches exóticos, coches compactos, deportivos. Lo tenemos todo! - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
As much as the Aston Martin looks nice from the outside, from the inside it just looks old already.
Agreed. Same goes for the DB 11 and DBS in my opinion. They really falls behind with the same old interior.
Looks a bit like a Nissan GTR
Mercedes heart with Aston skin🤭
Dynamoduck 1234 yea the seats on the DBS are nice but the infotainment system and other parts suck
And Mercedes bits in it already and I mean A LOT of EM. It is loosing it's own mark. slowly. Hope Aston will get out of this!
Both cars are so nice!!!
I would personally choose the Porsche 992!
Me too. It´s the better car although the Aston speaks a little more to the 4 year old in me.
@@jimbeam4736 Thanks for your reply mate!😉👍
The same it's unbelievable car
@@user-ze2yl8fo1t For sure my friend!!!
@@SupercarsinGreece me too
Aston Martin should release an all electric vantage and call it the Aston Martin Voltage
Lol
ba dum tss
Nice
Voltaje 👌🏾🤵♂️
Ha ha ha
9:43 when you want to close the door but the interior design is so crazy that you cannot even find the handle 😂
Car Buying 101.
You Buy the Porsche
You Lease The Aston
Not all VWs are equal
Porsche is reliable
James Eisenmann porsche makes the most reliable sports cars lmao
@@DB-yi5sm You sound so delusional. Porsche, Audi, Lambo, are all very much reliable when it comes to sports/performance vehicles. All being under the same family tree.
James Eisenmann come on man lexus sports cars are trash compared to porsche’s performance tho
@@Squeezemycrackers Nah, you can buy this Aston used. The AMG 4.0 powerplant is pretty reliable as is the ZF transmission. The electronics are Siemens and Mercedes so again, pretty reliable.
I would never encourage buying new for a standard Aston because they don't hold value. Better buy at 20% depreciation. That is where the car is worth its value and it won't lose much more than 30%, over its lifespan anyway, as even though they're not in demand, they're not built for mass market in the way that some other cars are.
I would say they're good value at around 90K but not 130K.
You should make more comparisons like these, they are awesome, and can see the difference right away. Excellent job guys, well done!!
The 911 is superior as a car but after seeing this I honestly think the Vantage is the one that actually makes you smile everytime you drive it. Plus, the Aston looks so damn cool inside and out.
You right 100%
Just by the look.
Yes i know my dad have this aston
Superior at blending in at the mall no doubt!
I just noticed the 1.8 mil subscribers. Crazy! I remember the algorithm recommending these videos back around 100k subs. Congrats!
Singularity true
3,75 :))
Porsche is the Girl you marry
Aston is the Mistress you fantasize
@Kiphy .... How old are you? And do you have any idea Where you are talking about?
@@dordrecht0784 He probably is 10 years old and thinks he knows a lot about cars.
@Kiphy shut up boy. not cool
ur literally comparing 510hp to 450hp.
agree, 992 is the one to keep
I can’t get out of my head that the Aston feels very cheap inside : old Mercedes infotainment, plastics...
Va B Astons have always had rubbish interiors. Which is pity since their exteriors are gorgeous and engines sound amazing
Because they only use the last-generations interior by Mercedes-Benz (they have a contract that Aston can use their older infotainmentsystem)
@@brandonczw wrong certainly not ' rubbish interiors' hand made not robot stitched
It's all leather too, the only thing I wish they had changed about the AM is they found a way to fold the screen down like in the old ones. It would look more timeless. Other than that, a manual one is a dream car. Sounds boss, very comfortable, amazing to look at on the road and something a bit different to the usual.
@@stevielowe2853 Noticed the shortness of the thigh support.
Love both cars! My brain says get the Porsche and my heart the Aston Martin. What would I honestly buy.... The Vantage
Yup it's a really special brand
For me it’s the Aston. I love the drama, the looks, and well…the name. Both are beautiful in their own right and can’t go wrong either way.
The Aston sounds so damn good 🔥
Looks, Sound, and is considered an exotic Aston wins but you should only ever lease an Aston. Porsche you buy and never really have to worry about depreciation, better handling, better gearbox. Overall pretty dead even all depends what you want.
Yes, it's too hard to admit Aston is a ultimate winner, isn't it..
I prefer the Porsche sound. More distinct. Aston just sounds like a louder mustang.
I prefer the sensation the Aston gives in whole. The exterior, the sound, the concept, the sense of being a part of James Bond trilogies. Aston is a legend.
Skyrider of a kind.
The porsche is simply a luxury car a must have after a Rolex to stay in a "pack".
@@Squeezemycrackers I call it "sort of compromise"
The Aston is a winner ".. Yeah.. but.. you can only lease..
Make it count as a disadvantage for the porsche sake
you lease both. It's normal Carrera, it will depreciate like everything else
2:47 front design inspired from mazda mx5
LOL
This ugly ass Front destroys the whole aesthetic of the Aston for me. Looks SOOO cheap...
@@l.1244 yes
@@l.1244 How does it look cheap
Is that right?i`m sure Porsches didnt look like that.
Aston martin interior looks like stuck in 1999 ...
Your mom is your mother
for real only idiots take the aston
Elon Musk 👍🏽
I think it looks nice
Elon Musk 👍🏽👍🏽
I've had both. If you park up in a busy car park dozens will stop and look at the Vantage with admiration. Only the odd petrol head looks at the 911 as there's just too many Porsche models that look similar. The Vantage exterior is so modern and eye catching. As for the inside the infotainment screen and IT lets it down. The base leather of the Vantage quality is great and will look better than the 911 after 2 years.
Porsche for me on the track, daily and even under the water!
This was actually a really constructive, good comparison. Even though I’m totally bias towards the Aston, I enjoyed the review of the Porsche as well! Goed gedaan jongens!
The ultra wide angle kills the looks of the cars
Together they both look like a couple. Together they will make beautiful rivals.
Personally I will take the Aston. Just looks and sounds better to me. I am sure the performance be close enough between the two but that Aston is just a *show stopper* by every stretch of the term.
@n s In terms of performance and benchmark, it very much is apples to apples. Both are entry level luxury sports cars in some form, even if the Aston is more overpriced. The Turbo/S is more of an entry supercar-supersports in-between.
@n s Turbo is as much more expensive than the vantage... than the vantage is more expensive than the S...
and a modified exhaust is still going to sound dreadful on the turbo... as well as being boring...
@n s 3 things...
1. the Vantage EVERYWHERE is about 10% cheaper than the turbo... Here in Toronto for instance... a vantage starts at 171k and a 911 turbo starts at 183k
2. Options... The vantage comes standard with things you MUST option on a Turbo for it to be livable. This isn negative... As I applaud Porsche for making the base car very stripped down... but it is disingenuous to say "after options"
3. Used prices aren't even close... 911 Turbo's are generally 20% or more higher...
Don't be a fanboy... there's plenty to like about the Porsche 911 Turbo. No need to bend the truth
Facts
@CoffeeLover Unfortunately... the AMG GT is really quite ugly from the back. The only real contenders in this race are the 911... the f type svr and the vantage. That is if you value the way the car looks...
Ever wondered why the Porsche has sold more sports cars than any other brand?
Really good mass customization marketing strategy!! They allow spectrum of customizable option making the car YOURS and it wont be the same as others :)
The Porsche 911 has the best resale value because its iconic shape never changes.
That's because porsche makes sports cars that can rivalize the ones from brands like Ferrari and Lamborghini but don't cost as much. Of course, their quality is also unquestionable
As a UK viewer - I find the pace of these reviews very good. They quickly get to the real points of interest and seem to give a balanced view. The marketing people of both brands featured here might like to know that my tendency to support the Aston gradually waned. For me, the Porsche emerged as a more practical and engaging way to enjoy that sort of motoring.
Really loved this review of both cars
That Astin sounds and seems to handle like a beast! Love the head cam footage by the way - it's like I'm driving, so I appreciate that angle.
its amg v8 engine bro
@@benbenanas98and my dad collection cost 10 milion and one of his cars is this aston so What color is your aston
Great video, thanks. I already own a couple of Porsche’s so I’m biased. I think the Aston does sound more exciting and it probably is marginally faster than the 911 (not that it really matters when you live in the UK and all our average speed cameras) but I’d buy the Porsche every single time. It will be more reliable and easier to drive for longer and in more situations
love the posts idea!!!
20 years ago I started with the boxster, followed by a 911. Bored from that I drove several Ferraris (California, 488 Pista, Portofino) and a DB 11 superleggera. One year ago, I "accidently" drove the 992 turbo S of a friend...and I was back at Porsche. It may not be as exciting or exotic, but it works every day, summer and winter and is - in the end - unbeatable in many ways.
Finally comparation video! Bravo!
I think the Porsche is better. It has the better quality in the Interior and it looks way better from the inside of the car. In my opinion, the Porsche is the winner. I don't care about the sound 'cause you can always upgrade it. As Max also said, the Porsche is more suitable to drive. These are the reasons, why I think, the Porsche is the winner
You are right... Porsche is best 👍😆
I 100 percent agree with you but in terms of look from outside I say the aston it just looks sexy reply if you agree
Agree with everything that you said except your opinion on the sound. You can't modify a 6 cylinders to sound like a v8.
@@christmasisawesome9348 you mean porche or aston
@@joshumone3301 911's 6 cylinders engine.
Porsche, guaranteed performance but the aero on the Aston looks pretty intense. This will be a good test.
The 911 gives you a lot of confidence on the road but it completely shifts character on the track. It becomes very tail happy with a lot of understeer when you apply the throttle.
Love your content ❤
911 is best at being driven and enjoyed everyday. Great video as usual ❤️
Excellent review with NO hiccups in the video.
While being a V* GT kind of guy and liking the AM a lot, I would choose the Porsche. A GTS model would probably be even more persuasive.
The Aston Martin is just leaps and bounds above anything in every aspect. What a sports car.😎🥂👍
Nice video. Thank you for sharing. Watching from San Francisco. USA...
Amg’s V8 on an Aston Martin
Name a better combo
Easy, flat six in the rear.
@Phil They were not performing though, it was time for an engine from the present, not the past.
pls give us more of that videos and pls allways with your commentary ...thx max
It’s a head and heart decision. The Porsche in many ways is objectively a better car that you will like driving…but the Aston has that emotional connection that will enable you to love it for years.
Quality and reliability are no brainer! I already bought a brand new 992 4S last week!
Congratulations. I'm extremely jealous
I would take the drama every day. That’s my pick. The Aston. Classy, different and drama. Yep. In Red please.
@Elon Musk Do you drink English tea? Any tea? Coffee?
Do you like nature seasons?
Nothing changed since forever yet we still appreciate and recognize it. Classic remains classic no matter what.. Time unbeatable. Legendary.
Other things come and go in 50 years time you won't even recognize what was the concept of the brand at the first place.
Igo for The Aston because they managed to adjust the entire English character with personality traits in the car brand concept Added some unspoken secret national traits in details, wildness, untamed will and unique sensation.
Aston is a 007 in the mission, you conquer the world.. The Porsche is. The Secretary - assistant for a summer beach vacation.
Absolutely the aston just look at it and listen to it....
@@StudioValeria3000 yea that’s why Aston Martin’s market share has plummeted and almost no one talks about the brand because they’re so clueless. Yet, Porsche continues to see insane sales. Aston used to be great, but it’s a washed up, out of date, and frankly, out of touch car brand with cars that lack elegance and refinement. There’s no soul left in those cars. Sad, but true.
@@horologie to comprehend AM you got to be capable to sense its truth. It smells Ike sky rider secret agent. It's not about moderation, adjusting renovation,, competition first price validation, it's about. Unique style, being wild, legend, and classy.
The Vantage is a beauty and talks the talk but doesn’t walk the walk! The Porsche is just so sophisticated and great. Probably the only overall car brand that becomes more valued over the years. I totally understand why!
Tried them both and gave myself the Vantage for Christmas! Mine has $14,700 in interior upgrades, all la eat her everywhere. I’m very happy!
How Is it
Love the Aston Martin vantage
Heard a Vantage in real life... honestly I didn't expect it to be that loud, those turbo engines produce a lot of low frequencies, especially that "big" V8, the video doesn't do it justice IMO
Porsche's interior looks more refined and elegant. But the exterior and sound of the Aston...wow
I sat in a Vantage last week and have to say the interior is levels above how it appears on videos. Can't get away from the dated infotainment system but I think it can be slightly rectified with an Apple CarPlay integration, if you have an iPhone. Overall, I think the Porsche is a mature purchase and the AM is a childish one - I'd take the AM everyday! That soundtrack won't be available out of the factory for much longer.
Thank you for the very informative video which doesn't show the author during 90 % of the time like most other car videos!
Nevertheless I urgently recommend that you engage a camera man. The nervous movements of the head camera are VERY uncomfortable to watch and there isn't even one single normal and quiet view onto the exteriors of the cars.
Porsche takes it for me
Not for me, here in Switzerland you see almost daily a Porsche 911 but only rarely an Aston Martin Vantage, it just feels more special and you got the Bond feeling driving it😎
Please do more video like this
Hi
How are they similar when you’re not taking any corners ?
Nothing can talk to a 992
All boxes ticked = balance = finesse
Porsche is the best in everything i love it ❤️ and about the sound i like the Porsche too because it's not very loud and not quite it's just perfect
I watched Porsche 992 verses Aston and saw that you use a speed app to measure speed and seconds. Pls provide the app and if it is available for iPhone. Thanks! Can’t wait am getting my 992 C2 cab in April!
-If you have anything valueable never give it to Martijn
*2sec later*
"Martijn gets in Aston and storms past"
*OKAY*
Hi, cool review, can you say which exact color this is on the Aston?
you buy a porsche with your head
and you buy an aston with your heart :D
Frodokeuh I don’t buy an AMG though, so Porsche all day...
and buy vw polo with pocket
and with an mercedes engine
I don't hate the new Vantage but it strayed too far from the previous gen Vantage, especially on the front-end. I absolutely love the previous gen design language, even now. I'm sure it's a beast though.
Legit exactly what I wanted to see these are the two I’m looking at tough choice but it be the 4s
Fav video❤️
Ever since I tried the 992 in a Porsche driving experience event, I’ve been completely in love with it. Everything about it felt perfect. But that Aston, damn it has a beautiful and elegant look. If I were to chose only one of them.... that would be an impossible mission!
I test drove 992 carrera S and v8 Vantage, same 8-mile loop here ij San Diego and oh God does Aston give you that childish excitement and a huge smile. Not sure which I would pick, probably Aston.
You should have softened up the suspension for the Autobahn run imo. Track suspension is to stiff on regular roads
I’d definitely choose the Porsche due to reliability and German engineering is the best!! 🇩🇪💪
The aston has a german engine so stop being a german fanboy and actually pick being neutral
So true
That Aston is at least 35% German and Japanese engineering is more reliable. 🤷
@@F1ll1nTh3Blanks Korean too :)
That's a myth
Will it possible to increase launch rpm on Aston?
Could anyone answer this? I assume the 911 has LED rear taillights like the Aston. But why aren’t they flickering on camera like the Aston?
Hello Max ! My name Vladimir . You video so beautiful very cool video. Thanks for your
here , Aston Martin is best with high quality stuffs.
Performance> luxury> looks.
I like the outside of the AM but inside its YUK where as the Porsche is functional & neat
First impression of the title...."the moment of Truth"
So everyone is talking about the astons reliability and quality. All of the historically unreliable issues are now done by mercedes Benz. Amg motors are bullet proof and mercedes mbu infotainment is one of the best in the biz. As far as build quality the stitching, fit and finish of the aston have always been praised.
Perfect, monster power
I'm the first one...love this channel!!
AMG GT vs 911 is more reasonable as a comparison
very nice ✌🤙🚗💨
Does it still make that little strange but beautiful noise at low rpm?
Should've made polls in the video, 100% easier
AutoTopNL, is there any plan to drive the F1 edition in the future?
After that we just need short and long lease offers. Love to lease Aston march to september...
Verry nice
Aston martin is crazy and it feels the real sports car and loud
And the Porsche is too Crazy even comparing with Aston ,Porsche is lil loud when driving normally like a formula car sound! Both are crazy💥
What app do you use for your speed test?
The back of the Aston looks like if you squish your face with your hands
What app do you use for the 0-60 test?
If only the Aston had the Porsche gearbox and they designed it so the satnav folded away. The ZF isn't a special enough gearbox imo. I bet the manual will be a hoot to drive with the dog leg gearbox making it feel like a unique experience. The 992 is probably the most sensible option and has the smartest interior, but the AM looks so mean on the road, sounds ace and is really comfy.
4k60fps + wide angle = you can really feel the speed :D
Just like the magazine like when I saw Audi vs Mercedes Benz and Mabe this could be a Aston Martin vs Porsche 911 carrera cars magazine
The Aston Martin sounds so good but the interior of Porsche is something else , is unique
Well I have both and can see both sides but truth be told the Aston makes you feel amazing driving it and yes I get a few compliments on it every day and also you will not find paint finishes as good as you do on an Aston Martin
My brain chose 911 but my heart chose Vantage.
The best decision came from heart. Great choice.
Lol this assetto corsa vr is becoming more real than ever :P
He does it seamlessly like his not even speeding..if it was going on such speeds I'll be freaking quiet and my hands and eyes in sync..😳😳😳
this song from aston martin is so niceeeeeee
I drive a 992 chalk carrera S daily and I’m considering switching to the Aston, this slightly helped but also didn’t):
even een tip.. niet vloeken, nergens nodig voor. Leuk dat je vertel over dingen maar waarom. waarom stuurt die goed. wat voel je tijdens het rijden.
wat voel je bij het remmen? wat zijn der mindere dingen aan de autos.
Когда вы снимали видео? Как же у вас тепло. Golfstream rulles
Taking delivery of my 911 s 992 next month.
I sat in a vantage. The 911s is superior. It’s German too which i love. The Aston Martin looks like a Mazda mx5. I’m unimpressed.
I always go by a simple rule: do not buy British sports cars as a general rule. After market support and valuations are horrendous. Porsche, whilst not perfect, are a superior brand in nearly every where.
How monstrous the turbo s is going to be...
10:05 oh hello Darth Vader
5:00 Did I hear a squake?