Valya is basically like Oswald Cobblepot. A hypocrite who makes excuses to get what she wants. I won’t be suprised if Valya gets Tula killed in the end.
It will probably be the reverse, Tula is who will rebuild the Sisterhood. Until her revenge plot, the inferences were that she was the weaker of the two. She might be tired of being bossed around by Valya.
Jessica Barden and Emma Canning were fantastic young versions of Valya and Tula! Jessica has so much internal rage which she seethes and channels as Valya! She really brings out that full on Type A personality who is ruthless, ambitious and power motivated! And Emma as Tula though kinder and more empathic, gets her full on spy moment, killing off nearly all the Artreides including her own lover. Though it caused her so much emotional pain, she is so mentally objective and clear in her mind on why she had to do it, to get back at them for murdering her older brother. Fantastic stuff and can't wait to see the rest of the eps!
Couldn’t agree more. These actresses are doing such a spectacular job. And it’s nice to see a show not treat me like I have a TikTok attention span. I’m still reeling from how insultingly baby-brained the Rings of Power show imagined all its viewers were.
Milo Callaghan as Orry Atreides stood out for me, he portrays that silent strength and empathy that The Atreides are known for (for better or worse) very well. You can definitely see him being the ancestor to Leto I and Paul.
That kid wasn't atreides only Orrry was because that can't be Kirans father when's he's like 25 years younger than tula and born when she was the age in the episode. Orry prolly got a sister or brother atreides
@@KeldarMJ how is he the father if he's the father that means he had krian at that age wtf. Because krisn is in his 30s on the show. And 30 years after the massacre
That was a nice setting, while Valya seems the strongest, it is Tula that actually change things. She initiate a forked prophecy. Who is the twice dead ?
God this show is so good. It’s everything I needed. I feel like there’s a trend in media to wring hands over even slightly morally gray characters. And here we have some proper political drama with complex characters. Gorgeous. And Emma Canning killed it (and everyone else) this episode. 👏👏👏
I never read the books 📚. But I'm loving this Dune universe we are getting But only 6 episodes I hope alot of people watch so we can get a few more seasons. Travis Fimmel to me was the best actor on vikings when I heard he was in this I was like yes I'm in. So I hope we get a s2 and I hope they don't kill of Desmond after 6 episodes
This episode isn't as bad as others are making it out to be. I actually prefer this one over the first two and I think it should've been the pilot because I finally see who Valya and Tula are as characters and what their motivations are. Also, I now see that Lila is our focal point in the story and not Princess Ynez
It’s set 10,000 years before the events of the first Dune book. So I think it would be weird to portray them as equally technologically advanced. Especially since they only just did the Butlerian Jihad.
young val screaming looks like old tula actor. intentional? lol anyways. a bit rushed on the og story bruh. music not as on point as counterpart, which had 15 episodes before the full bgs ep dropped
Young Valya Harkonnen is too ANNOYING. Ugh. I'm sure it's the actress, not the character, because older Valya is also annoying in her ways, but I don't hate her nearly as much. I LOATHE the younger version.
The pacing of this series is infuriating. Most episodes are INCREDIBLY slow, just to have some "revelation" take place in the last 30 seconds. I'm sorry but 30 seconds of "wow" will not make up for 60 minutes of poorly written dialogue.
Honestly I prefer seeing desmond hart and the imperium the bene gessereit characters are just kinda meh wish they did not a do a whole episode on it but oh well.
@@remi_gio You do realise Dune is the GoT before GoT. Everything in the Duneverse surrounding the political machinations, House system and scheming was all done before GoT became a pop culture phenomenon. So yes it will seem like it recycling to average viewers when it actually is the Godfather of the genre.
@Alejojojo6 It's just bad - dialogues, plot, settings, characters...at least to me it doesn't feel like it was written by an educated (knowledge in modern technology and politics, etc.) adult person. But I'm happy for everyone who likes it. No need for ad hominem. TH-cam is not for writing lengthy explanations. You can drop by and leave a short comment/opinion is all.
Watch more of the HBO Original Series Dune: Prophecy here: th-cam.com/video/s_ODJPCas34/w-d-xo.html
Disappointing the more episodes I watch.
Valya is basically like Oswald Cobblepot. A hypocrite who makes excuses to get what she wants. I won’t be suprised if Valya gets Tula killed in the end.
Sacrifices must be made.
@@SameerAli-qw1hnYupppppp 😂😂😂
Either that or Tula will be put in a position against Valya and it'll parallel to this episode
IDK I kinda see Tula as the more dangerous of the pair now🤔
It will probably be the reverse, Tula is who will rebuild the Sisterhood. Until her revenge plot, the inferences were that she was the weaker of the two. She might be tired of being bossed around by Valya.
Jessica Barden and Emma Canning were fantastic young versions of Valya and Tula! Jessica has so much internal rage which she seethes and channels as Valya! She really brings out that full on Type A personality who is ruthless, ambitious and power motivated! And Emma as Tula though kinder and more empathic, gets her full on spy moment, killing off nearly all the Artreides including her own lover. Though it caused her so much emotional pain, she is so mentally objective and clear in her mind on why she had to do it, to get back at them for murdering her older brother. Fantastic stuff and can't wait to see the rest of the eps!
not really as potent acting as would have want
Couldn’t agree more. These actresses are doing such a spectacular job.
And it’s nice to see a show not treat me like I have a TikTok attention span. I’m still reeling from how insultingly baby-brained the Rings of Power show imagined all its viewers were.
Milo Callaghan as Orry Atreides stood out for me, he portrays that silent strength and empathy that The Atreides are known for (for better or worse) very well. You can definitely see him being the ancestor to Leto I and Paul.
RIP Himbo Atreides😥
This is the idea of the kid escape and continue the Atredies line.
That kid wasn't atreides only Orrry was because that can't be Kirans father when's he's like 25 years younger than tula and born when she was the age in the episode. Orry prolly got a sister or brother atreides
@@Khanviewss how do u manage to do age math on all this
@@Khanviewsswhat? They were all literally shouting „Atreides”. That kid who escaped is probably his father.
@@KeldarMJ how is he the father if he's the father that means he had krian at that age wtf. Because krisn is in his 30s on the show. And 30 years after the massacre
Last scene activated my neurons. Mah Baron
This show is giving more real Dune vibes than the movies. Good job everyone.
Tula making hard choices.
That was a nice setting, while Valya seems the strongest, it is Tula that actually change things.
She initiate a forked prophecy.
Who is the twice dead ?
Maybe Lilia
Twice dead must be Desmond Hart
Both is possible, lilia or Desmond.
Thus a forked prophecy.
Hopefully, we will see the unveiling in later episode, or better, in later season.
@@lonesomefencesitter3186Lilia was something but it was Actually Paul. The Reverend Mother saw Paul. This was a misdiagnose
@@sov4956 Nice tidbit !
This ring true.
Tula went "kiss,marry and kill" too letteraly 😂
God this show is so good. It’s everything I needed. I feel like there’s a trend in media to wring hands over even slightly morally gray characters. And here we have some proper political drama with complex characters. Gorgeous.
And Emma Canning killed it (and everyone else) this episode. 👏👏👏
I never read the books 📚. But I'm loving this Dune universe we are getting
But only 6 episodes I hope alot of people watch so we can get a few more seasons. Travis Fimmel to me was the best actor on vikings when I heard he was in this I was like yes I'm in. So I hope we get a s2 and I hope they don't kill of Desmond after 6 episodes
This was the best episode.
I almost cried for that horse
This was a good flashback episode. Emma Canning did good job as young Tulya Harkonnen. Helps make the Harkonnens compelling villains.
You can see why valya ended up the way she did " truth is a tool indeed.
Anyone else think that the new Harkonnen nephew is actually Tula's son with Atredies?
Yep
Which means that all the harkonnens that we see on dune movies were partially Atredies..😂
@@abhaym1778 Must really grind Valya's gears
This episode isn't as bad as others are making it out to be. I actually prefer this one over the first two and I think it should've been the pilot because I finally see who Valya and Tula are as characters and what their motivations are. Also, I now see that Lila is our focal point in the story and not Princess Ynez
This is a great show
"Thou shall not make a machine in the likeness of the mind"
Uhh, Uh Oh.....😏😏
Who was the old guy at the end?
Valya's uncle, the new head of the Harkonnen family.
Robert harkonnen 🤣
@@Alejojojo6 what happened to the mother and father?
Evgeny Harkonnen, Uncle to Valya and Tula.
I thought that was her father?
Winterfell vibes 😢❤
This is a good show 👏
im going to be very disappointed if we never see a proper weirding way fighting style in these modern adaptions
The last episode has battle, no worries.
Seems like all the Dune stuff has so much potential but no one is able to do anything particularly good with it.
Capitulazo!!!!
Whts orrys real name and age ?? Plzz tell me guysss
Milo Callaghan
Why don't we have "inside the episode" of #LikeWaterForChocolate ??
it is a bit too medieval. Even the Fremen have some high technology. You saw no technology on the Harkonnen homeworld at all.
It’s set 10,000 years before the events of the first Dune book. So I think it would be weird to portray them as equally technologically advanced. Especially since they only just did the Butlerian Jihad.
@@hisime13 So they were fighting advanced AI with sticks?
Would have been a 10/10 episode if Tula said "The North Remembers" after killing the atreides camp.
hahahaha. I'm saying "hahahaha" just to make you feel good
🤭that made me giggle
young val screaming looks like old tula actor. intentional? lol anyways. a bit rushed on the og story bruh. music not as on point as counterpart, which had 15 episodes before the full bgs ep dropped
why harkonen dont speak their language
Dune series
the actress who plays Tula should be the princess more than the one we had (personal opinion)
A dumbed down version of a masterpiece
Young Valya Harkonnen is too ANNOYING. Ugh. I'm sure it's the actress, not the character, because older Valya is also annoying in her ways, but I don't hate her nearly as much. I LOATHE the younger version.
@@trayntp u spoke the words of my heart omg
The pacing of this series is infuriating. Most episodes are INCREDIBLY slow, just to have some "revelation" take place in the last 30 seconds. I'm sorry but 30 seconds of "wow" will not make up for 60 minutes of poorly written dialogue.
I hope the 1973 Yom Kippur War is made into a film
Honestly I prefer seeing desmond hart and the imperium the bene gessereit characters are just kinda meh wish they did not a do a whole episode on it but oh well.
This was a disappointing episode. An entire episode of flashback in a flashback show.
Why are people so obsessed with fast-paced everything?? this was essential character building to understand their motivations as adults
Why not ? It builds up characters and now we know their motivations. Would you prefer a rushed empty storyline ?
Easily destroy the Penguin and all DC
trash (unfortunately)
you are
@@Alejojojo6 He's not. It's just an opinion. Not everyone will like this show. I'm personally enjoying it a great deal.
Gives me GOT vibe way too much.. recycling much?
@@remi_gio You do realise Dune is the GoT before GoT. Everything in the Duneverse surrounding the political machinations, House system and scheming was all done before GoT became a pop culture phenomenon. So yes it will seem like it recycling to average viewers when it actually is the Godfather of the genre.
@Alejojojo6 It's just bad - dialogues, plot, settings, characters...at least to me it doesn't feel like it was written by an educated (knowledge in modern technology and politics, etc.) adult person. But I'm happy for everyone who likes it. No need for ad hominem. TH-cam is not for writing lengthy explanations. You can drop by and leave a short comment/opinion is all.
The show is good but not as good as the dune movies
That's a tall order. Dune Part 1 was amazing. Dune Part 2 is the best movie I've seen in a decade and an absolute cinematic achievement.
@@Justanormalperson777 very VERY hard to compete especially since the prequel books are from the son
this show sucks what a disgrace to even have the name dune
Oh no, gonna cry ?
No it doesnt
You're entitled to your opinion.
No it doesn't. Kiss grass. I love this show.
This love story looks intriguing but I think I’ll pass, too many other shows worth watching.
there is no love story, but ok. go watch something else. i find it weird that people who "hate" this show keep commenting well into episode 3.
If you're gonna be reductive, atleast watch the episode to the end 😅
lol tell me you didn't watch the episode without telling me you didn't watch the episode