Her grasp of the concept of relative time is mind-blowing and profound -- real evidence of high-level thinking. As this type of language work continues, I can imagine limitless doors opening into our understanding of just how much dogs and other animals can comprehend. And this raises penetrating questions about how we treat them.
Not only has she mastered the concept of time, but she knows there was BIG talking. She understands that the amount of talking this morning was a lot relative to the normal amount of talking. And she's thinking about that now. That's huge!
Animals can understand time. I feed feral cats and they will come right before the time that I usually feed them. If I change the time they’ll start showing up at the new time.
Exactly! They are far more than what we as humans have labeled them. They think, feel, solve problems, create and dream just like we do! I can’t wait until we learn THEIR languages! Imagine how we will communicate then. We aren’t the top of the food chain. We’re just a different species on the same playing field. This open minded teaching experiment is just the first step in making our world what it is meant to be for all of us. 😊
@@GrumpyGrebo when she communicates the difference between morning and afternoon “talk big.” She knows that presently she is speaking to her mom in the afternoon, and that previously she had “talk big” in the morning. She also distinguishes night from day, and night from morning and afternoon. She understands the nuances of now, later, soon and tomorrow/today as well.
@@Khaleesi_Of_Kittens It's been said a bunch of times that this is what her mama asked for - long on top for a fun bun when it's long enough, and a shaved face so her facial expressions can be read easier.
We’ve all talked about Bunny’s grasp & even advanced thinking on concepts & our gratitude that you are sharing her with us & giving us a peek at just how intelligent poodle hybrids can be & it’s astounding. So thank you again for all of that. Right now; in a bit shallower moment….I am so taken with how expressive her eyes are; even more now that I can see them so much easier with this hair cut. Eyes really are the windows to the soul & it’s not just a cliché! We’ve seen someone who takes her time thinking on what she wants to convey & now can see it in her eyes also! The confidence & the satisfaction….wow!
She’s so awesome!!! This is just the tip of the iceberg. She has a great lexicon of vocabulary she uses to communicate with but it’s nothing compared to what she can understand. Love watching your family grow! Can’t wait to see what’s next!!!
I started doing this with my two year old lab because he talks like a Husky sometimes and he already had non verbals like bow means outside and lip smack means hungry. It’s crazy how fast he gets it. Started with cheese / hungry. Day two already knows what it means. I just say “Otis want”. Also, we went for a hike and he wanted lunch after so he pressed it on his own. Day three he learned outside vs hungry buttons. It’s really really amazing! Thanks for sharing this information! So excited to see how far he gets!
That never goes away and pushes your buttons, quite literally, all the time. Exhausting. We all know what our dogs are saying without forcing them to learn rudimentary English. Waste of a dogs life
I am liking. Bunny's new look. AT first I missed her muppet face but I now can see her expressions better without the fur obscuring her expressiveness of eyes and tilted gestures.
bro, reality being self-awere is something most animals are. But we humans love to measure intelligence after our standards instead of thinking from the animals perspectives.
when she looked directlyat at her human, I saw such intelligence and love for her human in her eyes. I love her haircut, and her over all style. Shes a winner.
She is just incredible...I love watching her speak and wait for your response...then think about what you said before responding. Listening, thinking before speaking...great communicator
How intelligent is an animal who reflects on how much conversation they engaged in earlier in the day? Either Bunny is the Isaac Newton of dogs or we have sure underestimated the minds of dogs. And then think about other species that most would guess are brighter than dogs? What is really going on in the 16 pound brain of a sperm whale?
There is some evidence that dolphins have tried to teach humans their language (and got frustrated with us), and their brains are slightly bigger than ours, with bigger frontal lobes (where we process logic). Whatever is going on in cetacean brains is probably grossly underestimated.
@@KatharineOsborne yes, if we accept that animals have intelligence not completely dissimilar to ours and dogs are about as bright as toddlers and crows in some ways smarter than 7 year olds and intuitively that a whale is brighter than a crow, my question is, why does whale intelligence have to be squeezed between crow and humans? or chimps and humans? i think that the given brain mass and the argument that they got big to support the brain mass, not the other way around plus the idea that they might need vast intelligence to navigate the millions of cubic kilometers of ocean, to keep mental maps and communicate perhaps in some 3-D language related to their sonar system they may have minds that are far beyond those of humans. Yes, we think we are smarter but my cat pretty much told me, more than once, that I was stupid. And I am sure I am smarter than she was.
@@animalntelligence3170 My dog is long gone, but in light of this recent animal communication boom, I'm sure she thought I was an idiot. I always thought I was good to her, but now I feel guilty. She deserved more!
All mammals, and many birds, are emotional, and many are intellectual level thinking machines, which means that they have to take others' perspectives into account when trying to solve problems. This means modeling changes over both space (me vs you) and time (someone in the past and future). This has been known for a very long time. But it's not taught to kids in mainstream schools very well, I guess, so most humans have no idea what's going on in other animals' brains since they don't talk like we do, and can't literally tell us. But now they can, so I'm glad others are learning this valuable understanding of neuroscience/biology.
I believe that all thats happening is something called the “clever hans phenomenon” in which the dogs actually just looking at visual cues to press the buttons in.
You haven't seen enough of the videos. This is just one, there are plenty that show trained animals using these buttons having a contextually accurate conversation with their owners. Their still animals so their intellect is still limited to an extent, but the conversations are cognizant and they generally know what buttons they're pushing
@@FirstnameLastname-yc2mt you're delusional. No amount of videos can overturn a thousands academic papers on animal behaviour. Seriously, I bet you believe in astrology too don't you
We do the same thing teaching our babies to talk. We fill in gaps that may or may not be what the baby or bunny wants to say, until we find or stumble onto the thought she wants to express. The baby/bunny becomes more animated. Communication advanced. Both parties are excited and reinforced. This takes patience and willingness to keep trying on both sides. Bunny is willing to keep trying because her owner is loving, patient and tries new things. Parents who use the same strategies form children who want to talk to them. I miss working with children on language development, and I LOVE Bunny.
She look so ‘grown up’ with her new haircut. Big sister looks good on her. Amazing things you’re opening humanity up to here. I wish you continued success.
@@dr.emilschaffhausen4683all these people commenting have lost their minds...yes, the dog maybe knows that some buttons will cause the owner to act in a specific way- if theres a button lets say the button says im feeling bad and the owner goes to her to fondle the dog, sure the dog knows quite litterally "which buttons to push" . But that she understands the words and even can comprehend conversations and is self aware is total bollocks. Just look at some videos of this channel how she is haveing "conversations" through these buttons with the dog, and you will laugh your as off... how naive and stupd some people can be is fascinating
@@majokuntzen5631The dog used strangers and pain to describe a torn in its food in another video. A) that was set up B) you wrong, as that is case of higher level thinking. But Dogs are allrady proven to be super smart (well some of them)
Sometimes Bunny looks at you like "why don't you get what I am saying?" You can almost see the frustration. Sometimes I think she means things you don't pick up on, but that is to be expected. She is so smart - this is not a series of coincidences and never was. "Talk...afternoon" let's talk about the afternoon.
I'm sure there are plenty of things she would like to express that there isn't a button for, or even might not be a human word for. Dogs think differently than us (and necessarily so because they experience the world differently) and Bunny likely has many moments of "there's no word for that here." The fact that she has progressed so far into being able to utilize the words taught to her is astounding. Some day humans might eventually come to realize the truth of comprehending the nature of other species and begin to see that this entire planet is a giant community, and dogs might just end up being the key to that... But it might be a loooooong way down the road because, as a species, we still haven't learned how to truly communicate in a meaningful way with each other. We should be able to communicate with other primates, dolphins, horses, even rats in a meaningful way by now and understand the difference in how we interact with the world and each other, but we still haven't managed to do that (as a whole species) with ourselves yet. We like to think we're so incredibly smart, but really we've skipped over a lot of the most important questions and experiences that we need to grow, and in some cases we used to know, but have "forgotten" them. Why? You'd think that would be an incredibly complex question to answer. Actually, it's all just a side effect of modern society. From the time we're born we are forced to pursue money and power for survival. Any knowledge and wisdom that can't be leveraged into income or an advantage over others is merely a novelty, when it should be the most important kind of understanding. /Rant
@@HyperactiveSloth79 I love what you said! I think that the animals all have a far more intelligent way of thinking and communicating. ..our big mouths got in our own way of acquiring their abilities. We probably could learn of We could just shut up and listen without judgement! Lol!
Does she understand the difference between morning and afternoon? What a clever gal! Edit: I just wanted to comment on how cute it was, please don't start anything in the comments
When she asks to talk, will you try asking her questions? Instead of saying okay we can talk, you offer something for her to talk about. I think that might help her. Maybe she is interested in talking but doesn't know what to say
Probably best not to push her *too* hard. She's still just learning language, like a baby. It's kind of like the half-babble of a 2 year old "we talked a lot this morning! yeah we talked a lotttt" except she doesn't vocalize as a baby so it comes off as more adult and intelligent. The interesting part to me is what is *not* said. The dog has to be economical with EVERYTHING because the options are so limited. The implication in what Bunny was saying, to me, was that Bunny ENJOYS talking.
@@inkajoo Amazing how you ramble on about how TALKING TO HER is TOO HARD on her. Then end with she enjoys talking. Unbelievable. No one said to ask her to fix world hunger, to stop crime, or hell, even how to preform brain surgery. I simply stated, OFFER HER A TOPIC. But, if you didn't go off the rails, you wouldn't have had an opportunity to try and show the world just how brilliant out think you are. Just not briiant enough to realize that asking bunny about her toys, or about her friends, is OFFERING A TOPIC. COMMON SENSE tells everyone else, that it should be an appropriate topic. Everyone that is, except you. Maybe your not so brilliant after all.
I think she uses a system a linguistic researcher came up with, to organize the words into cognitively similar groups. That might be the secret to their out of the ballpark progress.
I’m sure there’s an element of projection involved, but there’s too much consistency and intentionality in what this dog is doing to say that she doesn’t understand what she’s saying. Even if the meaning that her owner or we as viewers take from the buttons she’s pushing is misunderstood or projection, it doesn’t diminish the absolutely amazing accomplishments of this animal.
@@Iluvpie6 She probably just has the dog pushing the buttons at random for long enough until she can make up something. It's complete bullshit. Dogs can't recognize speech like that.
this is mind blowing like you are literally part of history with this dog the amount that she understands and is able to communicate properly like she knows to emphasis, to add more words and the proper words like was and in pretty much right order wow. like every video blows me away more and more what are we doing with this info? scientists technically we could make a communicator that reads brainwaves, and associates the brainwaves with the button press, and so does automatically so it reads the brain waves and then says the word and we have tech that reads brain waves easy
Sadly, "scientists" who decided to look into it came to the conclusion that it's just an illusion. Their explanation was that she's just taking cues from her owner and that without the owners interaction they would just be hitting random buttons. In other words; the "scientists" don't actually want to even consider it's possible and just come up with excuses why they shouldn't look into it any further. They basically start with what's already "known" about dog psychology and just try to make this new information fit into it instead of ever considering they could have been wrong about anything. They still adamantly believe that dogs can't even have complex emotions involving judgement or subjectivity, such as guilt. They just chalk it up to interplay. According to them dogs only "appear" to feel guilty as a reaction to our being upset. Of course, that doesn't explain in any way why a dog will act guilty before their owner ever sees them and will act guilty before the owner discovered what they're acting guilty about. They don't seem to want to learn what dogs are capable of (probably because it would contradict decades of "findings"), but instead just make excuses for why us laymen are wrong.
Hyperbole at its best. Yes it’s impressive that she understands time relativity (some ADHD humans struggle with this lol) but quantum theory is a stretch. Just the fact she has the ability to reflect on past thoughts/actions to any degree and wants to express that is pretty neat but she’s not going to recite the works of Shakespeare anytime soon
Your dog does not talk or understand these words this is repetitive actions on your part that reinforce its actions your dog does not know English give me a break
I just don't like the way she looks now .... Really ... Either keep her with full hair or nothing .. only her tail is enough to make her look good she kind of looks very weird ..... I mean her head......
What a mean thing to say! I have a dog that resembles Bunny and her fur is difficult to manage. Even with daily brushing she gets mats. She also gets too hot with longer fur. The only option to keep her comfortable is to keep her fur cut short. Now hows about you post a picture of yourself so we can critique your hair
@@tinap8955 I have had 2 Old English Sheepdogs. The only reason that I ever thought required more hair was if you were going to show them. Which I didn t do. That hair mats up no matter how much time you spend grooming. Neither of my dogs had a rough coat so grooming was tortur for them. It wasn t worth it so I kept it fairly short. The one thing that I found about the hair on the head is that they seemed to prefer at least some over their face. They were kind of shy when it was cut way back. They tended not to hold their heads up and make eye contact for a while. I saw them walk into walls when they turned. Itcwas as though their depth perception was off. It took at least a week for them to adjust. I wish that I could have talked to them like she can with Bunny. It would have made the adjustments better, easier for them.
@@karencrawford4068 My Jesse is a rescue and hates having her legs and feet touched so brushing and dematting them is a struggle. I can clip her hair with minimum fighting then it only takes light brushing/combing which works out for both of us. I do leave a bit of a top knot on her head but shave her tail. She may not be beautiful to anyone else but she is to me
@@tinap8955 my Duffy was a rescue, too. He hated anyone touching his legs while grooming. I could pet just not brush. He had his definite opinions which I respected!
![[UNCUT] The Loyal Pin ปิ่นภักดิ์ EP.15 (3/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IVwR87OH0_A/mqdefault.jpg)
You can see her thinking about her words
Her grasp of the concept of relative time is mind-blowing and profound -- real evidence of high-level thinking. As this type of language work continues, I can imagine limitless doors opening into our understanding of just how much dogs and other animals can comprehend. And this raises penetrating questions about how we treat them.
Not only has she mastered the concept of time, but she knows there was BIG talking. She understands that the amount of talking this morning was a lot relative to the normal amount of talking. And she's thinking about that now. That's huge!
Animals can understand time. I feed feral cats and they will come right before the time that I usually feed them. If I change the time they’ll start showing up at the new time.
Where does she demonstrate a grasp of time?
Exactly! They are far more than what we as humans have labeled them. They think, feel, solve problems, create and dream just like we do! I can’t wait until we learn THEIR languages! Imagine how we will communicate then. We aren’t the top of the food chain. We’re just a different species on the same playing field. This open minded teaching experiment is just the first step in making our world what it is meant to be for all of us. 😊
@@GrumpyGrebo when she communicates the difference between morning and afternoon “talk big.” She knows that presently she is speaking to her mom in the afternoon, and that previously she had “talk big” in the morning. She also distinguishes night from day, and night from morning and afternoon. She understands the nuances of now, later, soon and tomorrow/today as well.
Bunny will soon be putting a pot of coffee up, breaking out the biscuits and talking bout your bestie's new boyfriend
Oh, I hope so!
@brew 😂🐾🐕🐾🤣
Lmao 🤣
😂😂
Bunny is on anti depressants
She’s so clever ❤
She was proud of herself I think. What a good girl.
Wow! Abstract thought, time sense, and value judgment.
undestanding the flow of time is just crazy
I love when she says something new and looks at you with those soft brown eyes...
With the new haircut I can see her pretty brown eyes. She is so smart and sweet.
Omg still can't get over her new haircut, she looks so funny!
It looks like she's wearing a hat. 🤣😁
Yeah, poor baby. Her groomer really jacked her up.
Like a poodle on steroids :)
@@Khaleesi_Of_Kittens It's been said a bunch of times that this is what her mama asked for - long on top for a fun bun when it's long enough, and a shaved face so her facial expressions can be read easier.
I think she looks cute!
We’ve all talked about Bunny’s grasp & even advanced thinking on concepts & our gratitude that you are sharing her with us & giving us a peek at just how intelligent poodle hybrids can be & it’s astounding. So thank you again for all of that. Right now; in a bit shallower moment….I am so taken with how expressive her eyes are; even more now that I can see them so much easier with this hair cut. Eyes really are the windows to the soul & it’s not just a cliché! We’ve seen someone who takes her time thinking on what she wants to convey & now can see it in her eyes also! The confidence & the satisfaction….wow!
I couldn't remember all these buttons, I know my dog would like to talk so I understand better...he does a good job of getting my attention
She’s so awesome!!! This is just the tip of the iceberg. She has a great lexicon of vocabulary she uses to communicate with but it’s nothing compared to what she can understand. Love watching your family grow! Can’t wait to see what’s next!!!
Bro are you going crazy?
I started doing this with my two year old lab because he talks like a Husky sometimes and he already had non verbals like bow means outside and lip smack means hungry. It’s crazy how fast he gets it. Started with cheese / hungry. Day two already knows what it means. I just say “Otis want”. Also, we went for a hike and he wanted lunch after so he pressed it on his own. Day three he learned outside vs hungry buttons. It’s really really amazing! Thanks for sharing this information! So excited to see how far he gets!
it's like meeting up for a coffee with an old friend :)
In 3 months it will be shaggy lol
That never goes away and pushes your buttons, quite literally, all the time.
Exhausting.
We all know what our dogs are saying without forcing them to learn rudimentary English. Waste of a dogs life
I am liking. Bunny's new look. AT first I missed her muppet face but I now can see her expressions better without the fur obscuring her expressiveness of eyes and tilted gestures.
Wow. Understanding of time, quantifying of the activity, reflecting upon it’s significance. I’m kinda blown away.
I hardly understand what you wrote😂
The fact that the dog is self-aware...
bro, reality being self-awere is something most animals are.
But we humans love to measure intelligence after our standards instead of thinking from the animals perspectives.
THIS IS THE CUTEST THINGGG
Bunny really does bring to light how much education can help us communicate. Sad to think animals had to use buttons for us to finally listen.
Bunny eyes are so expressive, you can tell she understands you and certain concepts, just is really amazing‼️
So cute, her expression.
when she looked directlyat at her human, I saw such intelligence and love for her human in her eyes. I love her haircut, and her over all style. Shes a winner.
I tell people all the time that dogs are like human children. They're a lot smarter than many people realize.
And cats, octopi and dolphins too!! So smart, these creatures :')
@@tanie3543 I really want to know what octopuses are thinking about.
@@lainey7985 give one some buttons haha
It really depends on the breed and the individual of the dog.
Yes they are like more trustworthy and serious 3 or 4 year olds (if they get older and are well trained)
Her new haircut cracks me up
She is just incredible...I love watching her speak and wait for your response...then think about what you said before responding. Listening, thinking before speaking...great communicator
How intelligent is an animal who reflects on how much conversation they engaged in earlier in the day? Either Bunny is the Isaac Newton of dogs or we have sure underestimated the minds of dogs. And then think about other species that most would guess are brighter than dogs? What is really going on in the 16 pound brain of a sperm whale?
There is some evidence that dolphins have tried to teach humans their language (and got frustrated with us), and their brains are slightly bigger than ours, with bigger frontal lobes (where we process logic). Whatever is going on in cetacean brains is probably grossly underestimated.
@@KatharineOsborne yes, if we accept that animals have intelligence not completely dissimilar to ours and dogs are about as bright as toddlers and crows in some ways smarter than 7 year olds and intuitively that a whale is brighter than a crow, my question is, why does whale intelligence have to be squeezed between crow and humans? or chimps and humans? i think that the given brain mass and the argument that they got big to support the brain mass, not the other way around plus the idea that they might need vast intelligence to navigate the millions of cubic kilometers of ocean, to keep mental maps and communicate perhaps in some 3-D language related to their sonar system they may have minds that are far beyond those of humans. Yes, we think we are smarter but my cat pretty much told me, more than once, that I was stupid. And I am sure I am smarter than she was.
@@animalntelligence3170 My dog is long gone, but in light of this recent animal communication boom, I'm sure she thought I was an idiot. I always thought I was good to her, but now I feel guilty. She deserved more!
All mammals, and many birds, are emotional, and many are intellectual level thinking machines, which means that they have to take others' perspectives into account when trying to solve problems. This means modeling changes over both space (me vs you) and time (someone in the past and future). This has been known for a very long time. But it's not taught to kids in mainstream schools very well, I guess, so most humans have no idea what's going on in other animals' brains since they don't talk like we do, and can't literally tell us. But now they can, so I'm glad others are learning this valuable understanding of neuroscience/biology.
This explains Vegans.
Reminds me of my standard poodle, too dam smart
So in love with this floofy, gentle genius. ❤️
This is very enjoyable to watch. Amazing dog with high awareness of time.
I just love Bunny's thinking face. She's such a sweetie!
I believe that all thats happening is something called the “clever hans phenomenon” in which the dogs actually just looking at visual cues to press the buttons in.
She presses the buttons so fancy and lady like 😂 I love it!
😮 we did a lot of talking this morning.. she wants the same kind of big long talks in attention too. Fact that she understands TIME is mind boggling
the new cut is a very serious look for a hoppy, happy girl
Adorable dog ❤
Dog presses random button and you make up interpretations. This is just like astrology.
You haven't seen enough of the videos. This is just one, there are plenty that show trained animals using these buttons having a contextually accurate conversation with their owners.
Their still animals so their intellect is still limited to an extent, but the conversations are cognizant and they generally know what buttons they're pushing
@@FirstnameLastname-yc2mt you're delusional. No amount of videos can overturn a thousands academic papers on animal behaviour. Seriously, I bet you believe in astrology too don't you
We do the same thing teaching our babies to talk. We fill in gaps that may or may not be what the baby or bunny wants to say, until we find or stumble onto the thought she wants to express. The baby/bunny becomes more animated. Communication advanced. Both parties are excited and reinforced. This takes patience and willingness to keep trying on both sides. Bunny is willing to keep trying because her owner is loving, patient and tries new things. Parents who use the same strategies form children who want to talk to them. I miss working with children on language development, and I LOVE Bunny.
They can understand the concept of past present and future, quite extraordinary!
She's incredibly beautiful and such a smart girl,❤I love it!
The innocent curiousity behind her eyes is always so sweet to see. Shes so cute ☺️❤️
That dog just pressin buttons my guy
No it isn’t.. it KNOWS WHAT IT IS PRESSING.
example: “dog why dog?” **stares into mirror**
She look so ‘grown up’ with her new haircut. Big sister looks good on her. Amazing things you’re opening humanity up to here. I wish you continued success.
You are making it up as you go along 😂😂😂😂
?! You cant be serious
@@annother3350 I assure you I can
@@temerson2 You can't be this dumb!!
@@temerson2 Dont be so foolish
@@annother3350 don’t be so foolish
They have deep hearts, feeling far more than people have realized.
The dog: "If I press random buttons maybe this human will give me attention"
Bingo. The number of individuals thinking this was a real exchange is nothing less than frightening.
@@dr.emilschaffhausen4683all these people commenting have lost their minds...yes, the dog maybe knows that some buttons will cause the owner to act in a specific way- if theres a button lets say the button says im feeling bad and the owner goes to her to fondle the dog, sure the dog knows quite litterally "which buttons to push" . But that she understands the words and even can comprehend conversations and is self aware is total bollocks. Just look at some videos of this channel how she is haveing "conversations" through these buttons with the dog, and you will laugh your as off... how naive and stupd some people can be is fascinating
@@majokuntzen5631 Politicians know how naive they are!
@@majokuntzen5631The dog used strangers and pain to describe a torn in its food in another video.
A) that was set up
B) you wrong, as that is case of higher level thinking.
But Dogs are allrady proven to be super smart (well some of them)
That dog is crazy smart. Bunny's the best. So freaking cool
Sometimes Bunny looks at you like "why don't you get what I am saying?" You can almost see the frustration. Sometimes I think she means things you don't pick up on, but that is to be expected. She is so smart - this is not a series of coincidences and never was.
"Talk...afternoon" let's talk about the afternoon.
I'm sure there are plenty of things she would like to express that there isn't a button for, or even might not be a human word for. Dogs think differently than us (and necessarily so because they experience the world differently) and Bunny likely has many moments of "there's no word for that here."
The fact that she has progressed so far into being able to utilize the words taught to her is astounding.
Some day humans might eventually come to realize the truth of comprehending the nature of other species and begin to see that this entire planet is a giant community, and dogs might just end up being the key to that...
But it might be a loooooong way down the road because, as a species, we still haven't learned how to truly communicate in a meaningful way with each other. We should be able to communicate with other primates, dolphins, horses, even rats in a meaningful way by now and understand the difference in how we interact with the world and each other, but we still haven't managed to do that (as a whole species) with ourselves yet. We like to think we're so incredibly smart, but really we've skipped over a lot of the most important questions and experiences that we need to grow, and in some cases we used to know, but have "forgotten" them.
Why? You'd think that would be an incredibly complex question to answer. Actually, it's all just a side effect of modern society. From the time we're born we are forced to pursue money and power for survival. Any knowledge and wisdom that can't be leveraged into income or an advantage over others is merely a novelty, when it should be the most important kind of understanding.
/Rant
@@HyperactiveSloth79 I love what you said! I think that the animals all have a far more intelligent way of thinking and communicating. ..our big mouths got in our own way of acquiring their abilities. We probably could learn of We could just shut up and listen without judgement! Lol!
I've always found it so amazing how some animals look at us with pure love in their eyes. It's a gift, truly
I love this. These buttons show you just how bright and caring dogs are. It's just wonderful.
Man the little tufts of hair, expression, head movement and eyes almost make great boy look human. Who knows, past life maybe.
I see so much PROJECTION in the comments
Awwww. I would see that as a sign that they are proud of themselves 😊
Does she understand the difference between morning and afternoon? What a clever gal!
Edit: I just wanted to comment on how cute it was, please don't start anything in the comments
Well, it's probably inherited from wolves.
I don't think that's unique. She's just one of the only dogs who know how to tell us.
Bunny is very beautiful and precious..She is a real person.. No dull moment with her.
Bunny knows her buttons
When she asks to talk, will you try asking her questions? Instead of saying okay we can talk, you offer something for her to talk about. I think that might help her. Maybe she is interested in talking but doesn't know what to say
That's the remarkable thing: she came up with the topic of cyclical time on her own and decided to talk about it -- as far as I know, it was her idea.
Probably best not to push her *too* hard. She's still just learning language, like a baby. It's kind of like the half-babble of a 2 year old "we talked a lot this morning! yeah we talked a lotttt" except she doesn't vocalize as a baby so it comes off as more adult and intelligent.
The interesting part to me is what is *not* said. The dog has to be economical with EVERYTHING because the options are so limited. The implication in what Bunny was saying, to me, was that Bunny ENJOYS talking.
@@inkajoo Amazing how you ramble on about how TALKING TO HER is TOO HARD on her. Then end with she enjoys talking. Unbelievable. No one said to ask her to fix world hunger, to stop crime, or hell, even how to preform brain surgery. I simply stated, OFFER HER A TOPIC. But, if you didn't go off the rails, you wouldn't have had an opportunity to try and show the world just how brilliant out think you are. Just not briiant enough to realize that asking bunny about her toys, or about her friends, is OFFERING A TOPIC. COMMON SENSE tells everyone else, that it should be an appropriate topic. Everyone that is, except you. Maybe your not so brilliant after all.
I've seen 3 videos of her now, and my mind is blown every time!!!!!
You make meanings from every random button the dog press.
SHES THE CUTEST DOG EVER
A big talk:3
Omg, she is just awesome, I'm on awe of how smart and loving she is, what a pure soul, love her, sending kisses, muuuaaahhh
How do dogs remember which buttons they need when there’s dozens of buttons. I mean, they can’t read the prompts… so they just remember??
they introduce new buttons a few at a time, and keep them in the same places on the board so they can be found that way
I think she uses a system a linguistic researcher came up with, to organize the words into cognitively similar groups. That might be the secret to their out of the ballpark progress.
Love your dog, but I realize you have put so much time in on training her, that’s why she is able to be so amazing.
That's a human haircut! 😎
For the human dog! Lol
I've seen several dogs using that same talk pad and it's amazing how they can use it to speak it's almost unbelievable
Talk big 😆
It still boggles my mind she really understands what she says with the buttons !!!❤❤❤
I love bunny's new look.
Omg what a beautiful smart pup!
He prolly really hopes talk means walk n cant tell the difference
I just can't with the cuteness !!!! .... Plus I'm amazed how she thinks about what she wants to put together.
I miss bunnies old look
Bunny’s eyes so strange what They can have in mind
Always nice to watch her think and talk ❤
Terrific!
Precious, Adorable pup-pup ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤LOVE the Adorable Afro ❤️💕💖😍♥️💗😊
What up with the new ‘do?? Sorry but BunBun is not a poodle 🤪 prefer more Sheep than doodle 🤪🤣🤣🤣
She is amazing as are you for teaching her.
I am still convinced 90% of the videos about those buttons are projection
I’m sure there’s an element of projection involved, but there’s too much consistency and intentionality in what this dog is doing to say that she doesn’t understand what she’s saying. Even if the meaning that her owner or we as viewers take from the buttons she’s pushing is misunderstood or projection, it doesn’t diminish the absolutely amazing accomplishments of this animal.
@@Iluvpie6 She probably just has the dog pushing the buttons at random for long enough until she can make up something. It's complete bullshit. Dogs can't recognize speech like that.
This is the human mind wanting to believe. Words can be put together so many different ways that it’s nearly impossible to not make sense.
@@Iluvpie6 The only thing the dog knows is that when it clicks button it gets attention and treats sometimes
@@OrdinarySchizo then it would click any button, but she chooses buttons based on context.
this is mind blowing like
you are literally part of history with this dog
the amount that she understands and is able to communicate properly
like she knows to emphasis, to add more words and the proper words like was
and in pretty much right order
wow. like every video blows me away more and more
what are we doing with this info? scientists
technically we could make a communicator that reads brainwaves, and associates the brainwaves with the button press, and so does automatically
so it reads the brain waves and then says the word
and we have tech that reads brain waves easy
Sadly, "scientists" who decided to look into it came to the conclusion that it's just an illusion. Their explanation was that she's just taking cues from her owner and that without the owners interaction they would just be hitting random buttons.
In other words; the "scientists" don't actually want to even consider it's possible and just come up with excuses why they shouldn't look into it any further.
They basically start with what's already "known" about dog psychology and just try to make this new information fit into it instead of ever considering they could have been wrong about anything. They still adamantly believe that dogs can't even have complex emotions involving judgement or subjectivity, such as guilt. They just chalk it up to interplay. According to them dogs only "appear" to feel guilty as a reaction to our being upset. Of course, that doesn't explain in any way why a dog will act guilty before their owner ever sees them and will act guilty before the owner discovered what they're acting guilty about.
They don't seem to want to learn what dogs are capable of (probably because it would contradict decades of "findings"), but instead just make excuses for why us laymen are wrong.
“WHERE ARE MY TESTICLES, SUMMER?”
😂
Poor baby love you bunny 💙💙💙
Anthropomorphism at its best. So cool she understands time relativity, and maybe next, quantum theory?
It's funny, right??
Hyperbole at its best. Yes it’s impressive that she understands time relativity (some ADHD humans struggle with this lol) but quantum theory is a stretch. Just the fact she has the ability to reflect on past thoughts/actions to any degree and wants to express that is pretty neat but she’s not going to recite the works of Shakespeare anytime soon
@@SobrietyandSolace Thing is, there's nothing in the video to suggest the dog can do any of this things. 🌴
This seems like a play on the theme ‘dog day afternoon’. 🎬📽️
Bunny's very smart and knows what she wants to say. It's amazing to watch her use her buttons with such proficiency. I love Bunny so much! ❤
Your dog does not talk or understand these words this is repetitive actions on your part that reinforce its actions your dog does not know English give me a break
I think it's so cool Bunny communicates so well with the aid of these buttons. And her communication is becoming more precise. It's fascinating. 👍❤️
Animals will never be on our level. They aren't smart or dumb. We need to stop projecting.
Bunny amazes me with her thoughtfulness, and careful choice of words. Seriously awesome‼️
This is all about the owners response. The dog is just pushing buttons...
Oh my gosh . .
The Color of her Eyes is so beautiful, that its mesmerizing me !
I just don't like the way she looks now .... Really ... Either keep her with full hair or nothing .. only her tail is enough to make her look good she kind of looks very weird ..... I mean her head......
What a mean thing to say! I have a dog that resembles Bunny and her fur is difficult to manage. Even with daily brushing she gets mats. She also gets too hot with longer fur. The only option to keep her comfortable is to keep her fur cut short.
Now hows about you post a picture of yourself so we can critique your hair
@@tinap8955 I have had 2 Old English Sheepdogs. The only reason that I ever thought required more hair was if you were going to show them. Which I didn t do. That hair mats up no matter how much time you spend grooming. Neither of my dogs had a rough coat so grooming was tortur for them. It wasn t worth it so I kept it fairly short.
The one thing that I found about the hair on the head is that they seemed to prefer at least some over their face. They were kind of shy when it was cut way back. They tended not to hold their heads up and make eye contact for a while. I saw them walk into walls when they turned. Itcwas as though their depth perception was off. It took at least a week for them to adjust. I wish that I could have talked to them like she can with Bunny. It would have made the adjustments better, easier for them.
That's a puppy cut for poodles
@@karencrawford4068 My Jesse is a rescue and hates having her legs and feet touched so brushing and dematting them is a struggle. I can clip her hair with minimum fighting then it only takes light brushing/combing which works out for both of us. I do leave a bit of a top knot on her head but shave her tail. She may not be beautiful to anyone else but she is to me
@@tinap8955 my Duffy was a rescue, too. He hated anyone touching his legs while grooming. I could pet just not brush. He had his definite opinions which I respected!
Seeing the dog lift it’s paw and aim for the exact button it knows to press always blows my mind
She understands so much; it’s amazing!
"Was morning talk big" wow!! Full sentences & understanding of time
I love how she looks at you she so cute and curious
Bunny is so unbelievably precious‼️♥️. Thank you for sharing her with us. ♥️🥰
Everytime I watch a video, Bunny blows my mind!!!
Your dogs are so smart. I love watching them communicate with you.
That was a full sentence! Such an amazing thing to watch.
I just love her!!! Those eyes!!!
Such a beautiful love❤❤❤ blows my mind how smart ❤I can see and feel her thinking so much. Incredible. Such a baby love, so adorable ❤❤❤❤
Her eyes tho and how she is thinking stuff...just amazing