Wake up and realise these farmers are taking the Mickey! Pay your inheritance tax like everyone else. Or sell up and live a comfortable lifestyle! I have absolutely no sympathy for them that chose this profession and have dodged loopholes holes for years!
jeremy Clarkson explicitly stated that avoiding inheritance tax (IHT) was one of the motivations for buying his farm. In a 2021 interview with The Times, he mentioned that purchasing farmland was a strategic decision to ensure that his estate would not be significantly reduced by inheritance tax upon his passing.
@@full_marx3047 his big gob came back to bite him in the ar$e , victory Derbyshire just called him out on his own comments and he didn’t like it , tbh he made himself look pretty stupid and the farmers shot themselves in the foot getting him involved and don’t get me going about that clown farage ! He got the farmers out of Europe with his lies and over 50% of farmers voted for it ! You couldn’t make it up 😞😞🥱🥱🥱
Jeremy is this really the quality of your program? You didn't explain the issue at all. It's rather simple. Due to inflated land prices in the UK, it's very easy for a farm to be worth several million pounds. If a farm is valued at £2 million, the inheritor will have to pay £400,000 to farm the land. However, the person receiving the land doesn't have access to that money - it's locked up in equipment and the land. Most farmers earn very little a year, meaning the £400,000 could take several years (even over a decade) to pay it off. Also, why do all Labour politicians have a speech impediment? I think they're all defective.
Your point about money being locked up in the farm is a good one, but I'm afraid your figures are incorrect - ironically, it seems it wasn't as simple as you thought. Firstly, the threshold for a couple is effectively £2.65M, so someone inheriting a £2M farm from parents wouldn't pay any tax. But for arguments sake, less say it was a single farmer leaving a £2M farm to their kid. The 20% tax is only on the *excess* over the threshold. So, in your example the inheritor would be *£200'000*, not £400,000, payable over 10 years. Byline Times reported "Tax expert and Labour supporter Dan Neidle, who runs the Tax Policy Associates research outfit, rejected the figures being put out by lobby groups as “hyperbolic fake stats”. “For most farmers, the real cap [will be] £1.5m. For a married couple, £2.65m+…The only data that matters here is the actual data on APR claims [Agricultural Property Relief, the inheritance tax exemption for much agricultural property]. “That shows only about 100 farm estates each year are worth £2.65m. Out of the [roughly] 200,000 farms in the UK, that is a tiny number.”
@fionamunro3381 I made a slight, but significant mistake as well - Business Property Relief will be combined with APR now. However, the point still stands about it being more than £1m and about it being on the excess. £1m is the limit for a single person, and excludes the property on the land, which is a further £500k. As joint owners of the farm both qualify for relief, this makes the total possible relief £3m. Once equipment is included, its fair to say more than 100 farms will be above £3mn. Nonetheless, I still think the farming unions figures are OTT, and theyre fearmongering. Saying "two thirds of farms will be affected" doesn't tell us anything about *how much* they'll be affected. E.g. a farm worth £4mn will have 10 years to pay off £200k. And that's assuming they haven't planned ahead or been able to transfer to children before death.
@fionamunro3381 and to answer your question of why we're being told that, I'd put it down to: Lazy journalists Unions/anti-Labour groups have a vested interest in framing the conversation around the worst case scenario. Which i don't blame them tbh, and I don't wish ill on anyone, but that's why you need journalists to provide balance.
@ not the fact they state there’s a 22billion black hole in U.K. finances, yet the Carbon Capture Project also happens to cost 22bill🤔 the carbon footprint of building it negates it purpose- planting trees would be better. Then there’s another 90mil of other wasteful nonsense…
JEREMY CLARKSON IS NO FARMER!!! HE DOES NOT CONTRIBUTE TO NATIONAL FOOD STOCKS….it his HOBBY for tax evasion reasons Victoria Derbyshire exposed him with his own words and simple questions, the man had his pants drawn in front of his village idiots..!!!
Tax the wealthy - they have a 3 million pound exempt limit .. more if you factor in other reliefs available Its only over the exempt limit they are liable for inheritance tax and at half the rate everyone else is liable too Plus they have 10 years to spread and pay the liability No sympathy for the rich wealthy millionaire land owners that will actually be subject to the tax - especially the dukes and lords with thousands of acres And this is coming from a uk tax specialist. Ask the tax specialists on how this change will actually work - it doesn’t target small family farms
Pathetic bigots .. comparing the murder of thousands of children to millionaires fighting for tax cuts on their million (not for the general public and average jo) Get some education Hire a British Palestinian Muslim tax lawyer if you have to teach u about tax law
@@davidadams8027 it has everything to do with MONEY,so that includes the 8 million a day spent on illegal immigrants being put before people already living here who have paid their taxes.
It’s really simple maths. 8.5 billion on foreign aid. Cut that to 7 billion then they could keep the heating allowance for pensioners. 22 billion new money for the NHS. Cut that to 21.5 billion and then no need to raise IHT on farmers. They’ve made political choices with awful consequences.
A baker starts work at 3am every day. They work incredibly hard. Rubbish hours. If they're fortunate to end up with an estate worth over £350/500k, they'll fall in the bracket for being eligible for inheritance tax at 40%. Why should it be different for farmers?
A baker will fall into the BPR category so will have been OK before the budget changes, all businesses will be hit by this governments theft off working people
As a chartered accountancy and tax advisor I can tell u it’s wealthy business .. I’m not talking income and annual profits but wealth and net asset building .. so yes u can fool the poor but speak to accountants and uk tax specialists for the truth on how this works
Only right everyone pays tax Inheritance tax on farmers is only over 3 million pounds and pay 20% over that then they'll have 10 years interest free to pay.
There are several things to unpack here. 1. There are many people vital to society; farmers, police, nurses, firefighters, etc. ALL get paid very little but ONLY farmers pay NO inheritance tax. 2. Everybody paid IHT until 1986, when Lawson gave Farmers exemption (39 year with NO IHT). 3. Now farmers are complaining because they have to pay IHT of 20% (payable over 10 years - so 2% a year) with a threshold of £1m. Meanwhile, everybody else pays 45% over £325,000 payable immediately. How does this look? Well, an average farm in the UK is 250 acres, which in land terms means it is valued about £2.5m + £500k equipment. This would attract an IHT bill of £400k (20% of £2m) or £40k a year over 10 years off a £3m asset! Compare to a middle class person who passes his £1m house onto his son and his £500k pension and savings (these are not extreme values). The IHT bill for the son would be 45% of £1.5m or £675,000. So a non farmer passing on a house and pension worth half that of a working farm, pays double the tax compared to a farmer - using the new regime. Under the old regime the farmer would have paid ZERO tax. Finally, I would remind you that Clarkson (and all of the other 'business' farmers) all bought farms to minimise their IHT bill. They might moan but even today, they will only pay 20% whereas everybody else pays 45%, so a nice 25% saving. The trouble is that here, the likes of Jeremy Clarkson (who admitted in 2021 that he purchased all his land to avoid paying inheritance tax) and other rich land owners and farmers have managed to convince the every farmer that this will affect them. Well it won't and it is about time the rich started paying in to this country to help it.
We should definitely let the dukes off from paying inheritance tax. Dukes shouldn’t have to pay tax just because they are dukes, as their ancestors were mates with the kings or queens so it’s only fair. Just let anyone off who has more than a million quid. Millionaires shouldn’t have to pay tax. Tax is for peasants.
It might be a good start to ban really big landowners from registering their land in a trust in tax free havens abroad. But I guess that won't happen any time soon.
An easy example - a doctor with 5 million in estate assets will end up paying 1.6milluon in inheritance tax A farmer with 5 million in estate assets will end up paying only 400k in inheritance tax (and thats not even taking into account the additional business property relief the farmer would receive in stock and machinery) Who works harder and contributes more to the society - a doctor or a farmer?? Or both and if both then why is a farmer getting an easier ride with tax then a doctor with the same value estate?
Not paying tax=not allowed to vote!!! Brexit equals £billions lost because of Farage. Economists and analysts at Cambridge Econometrics found that, by 2035, the UK is anticipated to have three million fewer jobs, 32% lower investment, 5% lower exports and 16% lower imports, than it would have had been. The report states that the UK will be £311bn worse off by 2035 due to leaving EU.
''Farmer versus Starmer'' is exactly the problem. No, I don't choose ''a side'', because I think it's absolutely correct to close these tax loopholes. Do I agree that there needs to be clearer assurances regards just who this should effect? Yes.
We need to set up more farms on a co-operative basis so we can ensure UK food supply. We do not want farms being bought out by foreigners. The vast majority of farmers will not be subject to IHT but the government needs to make sure UK food supply stays at a level to maintain national security as it is definitely a matter of national security!
Tax millionaires with a wealth tax .. taxing 1% to those with net wealth over 10 million. .. research and calculation show this will raise more in the first year then any other tax policy
We had to pay iht tax and his farm wasn't worth 3 million not even a million same when our mother died what she left once paid tax off we had £700 to split between the 4 of us
The caller with the farmer husband doesn’t understand how the tax works Yes machinery and livestock is included but that comes with additional tax reliefs above the 3 million exempt threshold .. people need some real education on tax law in this country and they’ll see how the rich get away with avoiding tax Half these people that are supporting farmers don’t understand how the inheritance tax and all the APR and BPR and other tax reliefs farms are subject to work
That's of the Tory one when they said once you are dead your left with nothing like thatcher said you save ten poon we will have that you can have the pound
What planet is this northern guy on at 6 mins. Being supported? Wtf…..Farmers lost eu subsidies, government didn’t support alternatively, margins and weather are terrible. Now inheritance tax with tax on some farms at similar level to income. It’s totally bonkers.
Farmer V Starmer: Whose side are you on? Feat. Jonathan Ashworth & Lin Mei | Jeremy Vine 19.11.24 1206pm the folk song... which side are you on, referee...? they've right to express their dissatisfaction. they also make a hell of a lot of peoples' lives a misery...
@@Grrreeeeeeeeeeeew There’s no chance of a good economy with Starmer and his amateurish front bench in charge! And alongside a failing economy goes hand in hand with a disfunctional society.
Farmers haven’t got £3 million to spend on luxuries for themselves. They are too busy toiling away on their farms from morning till night just to feed ungrateful people such as yourself! 🥵 When they are lucky enough to get a profit, they reinvest that on farm machinery, crops, animals etc etc.. But profits aren’t at all guaranteed, which means a lot of farmland will gradually be sold off as farmers die. Once it’s gone, it’s gone for good! 😢
I’m a farmer and I wish I had 3 million as well, but I don’t. I’ve got a 365 days a year, 7 days a week, 16 hours (minimum) a day job. I’ve got animals to look after, I’ve got land that needs to be taken care of, I’ve got a heritage to protect, I’ve got people to feed. I’m a mechanic, I’m a midwife, I’m an accountant, I’m a diet specialist, I’m a meteorologist, I’m a horticulturist. I don’t own the land, the land owns me and it’s my responsibility to look after it and everything that lives here. My sons have grown up tending this land and the generations of animals that live here, they know it, they’ve lived and breathed it and they want to pass that knowledge and love down to the next generation. They’ve attended agricultural college and are more than qualified but they won’t even get the opportunity to continue what they’ve been doing alongside me if this iht goes through. They’ve been working for bed, board and essentially pocket money their whole lives. Where are they supposed to find this money when I die? What happens to all the work they’ve invested in this land? So yeah, I wish I had 3 million as well!!
@@brianbell3836 What an ignorant thick stupid comment! It's so stupid it's hardly worth bothering to reply so I'll just say this: Will you be happier if the farmers sell up and the farms close down if it means food prices increase and your food shopping bill becomes expensive? Without proper food security during these uncertain times it's not inconceivable that the country will slowly starve itself! Don't start complaining if any of these things happen because you're not bothered if farms close down!
Not paying tax=not allowed to vote!!! Brexit equals £billions lost because of Farage. Economists and analysts at Cambridge Econometrics found that, by 2035, the UK is anticipated to have three million fewer jobs, 32% lower investment, 5% lower exports and 16% lower imports, than it would have had been. The report states that the UK will be £311bn worse off by 2035 due to leaving EU.
Wake up and realise these farmers are taking the Mickey!
Pay your inheritance tax like everyone else. Or sell up and live a comfortable lifestyle!
I have absolutely no sympathy for them that chose this profession and have dodged loopholes holes for years!
Farmers are always whining
@brianbell3836 you'll be whinging when there's no food
@@adrianbellemy4420 I like cheap foreign food. British stuff's too expensive.
Got a better idea, no-one pays inheritance tax, the civil service is overinflated & trimmed accordingly to pay any deficit.
jeremy Clarkson explicitly stated that avoiding inheritance tax (IHT) was one of the motivations for buying his farm. In a 2021 interview with The Times, he mentioned that purchasing farmland was a strategic decision to ensure that his estate would not be significantly reduced by inheritance tax upon his passing.
Fake News!
@full_marx3047
He's not the only farmer in town. Many family owned farms barely make a living
@@ehilton96 Maybe they should sell up and do something else?
@@full_marx3047 his big gob came back to bite him in the ar$e , victory Derbyshire just called him out on his own comments and he didn’t like it , tbh he made himself look pretty stupid and the farmers shot themselves in the foot getting him involved and don’t get me going about that clown farage ! He got the farmers out of Europe with his lies and over 50% of farmers voted for it ! You couldn’t make it up 😞😞🥱🥱🥱
Jeremy is this really the quality of your program? You didn't explain the issue at all. It's rather simple. Due to inflated land prices in the UK, it's very easy for a farm to be worth several million pounds. If a farm is valued at £2 million, the inheritor will have to pay £400,000 to farm the land. However, the person receiving the land doesn't have access to that money - it's locked up in equipment and the land. Most farmers earn very little a year, meaning the £400,000 could take several years (even over a decade) to pay it off.
Also, why do all Labour politicians have a speech impediment? I think they're all defective.
Your point about money being locked up in the farm is a good one, but I'm afraid your figures are incorrect - ironically, it seems it wasn't as simple as you thought.
Firstly, the threshold for a couple is effectively £2.65M, so someone inheriting a £2M farm from parents wouldn't pay any tax. But for arguments sake, less say it was a single farmer leaving a £2M farm to their kid.
The 20% tax is only on the *excess* over the threshold. So, in your example the inheritor would be *£200'000*, not £400,000, payable over 10 years.
Byline Times reported "Tax expert and Labour supporter Dan Neidle, who runs the Tax Policy Associates research outfit, rejected the figures being put out by lobby groups as “hyperbolic fake stats”.
“For most farmers, the real cap [will be] £1.5m. For a married couple, £2.65m+…The only data that matters here is the actual data on APR claims [Agricultural Property Relief, the inheritance tax exemption for much agricultural property].
“That shows only about 100 farm estates each year are worth £2.65m. Out of the [roughly] 200,000 farms in the UK, that is a tiny number.”
@@hackneyjazz so they have to pay back a loan and keep the farm running you are a communist.
@fionamunro3381 I made a slight, but significant mistake as well - Business Property Relief will be combined with APR now.
However, the point still stands about it being more than £1m and about it being on the excess.
£1m is the limit for a single person, and excludes the property on the land, which is a further £500k. As joint owners of the farm both qualify for relief, this makes the total possible relief £3m.
Once equipment is included, its fair to say more than 100 farms will be above £3mn. Nonetheless, I still think the farming unions figures are OTT, and theyre fearmongering.
Saying "two thirds of farms will be affected" doesn't tell us anything about *how much* they'll be affected. E.g. a farm worth £4mn will have 10 years to pay off £200k.
And that's assuming they haven't planned ahead or been able to transfer to children before death.
@fionamunro3381 and to answer your question of why we're being told that, I'd put it down to:
Lazy journalists
Unions/anti-Labour groups have a vested interest in framing the conversation around the worst case scenario. Which i don't blame them tbh, and I don't wish ill on anyone, but that's why you need journalists to provide balance.
@@fionamunro3381it's much more like £3 million
American farmers pay taxes. British farmers shouldn’t be exempt. 50% of your food is already imported and they’re the ones that voted for Brexit.
Exactly. If they're not happy, sell up and live in luxury. There must be a reason they stick at it.
Cancel Labour’s 90billion Net Zero schemes as the U.K. isn’t even 1% of global emissions, and then cancel the land grabbing Farming inheritance tax
But the NetZero stuff was in the manifesto.
@@Kratos40595 💯
@ not the fact they state there’s a 22billion black hole in U.K. finances, yet the Carbon Capture Project also happens to cost 22bill🤔 the carbon footprint of building it negates it purpose- planting trees would be better. Then there’s another 90mil of other wasteful nonsense…
do it effect you get your facts right first
@@janeharper9329 Eh?
Farmer , Farmer , Farmer NO FARMER NO FOOD ! WAKE UP !
50% of your food is already imported. You’re not gonna starve.
JEREMY CLARKSON IS NO FARMER!!! HE DOES NOT CONTRIBUTE TO NATIONAL FOOD STOCKS….it his HOBBY for tax evasion reasons Victoria Derbyshire exposed him with his own words and simple questions, the man had his pants drawn in front of his village idiots..!!!
Danish bacon, French cheese, Lurpak, Foreign beers...on and on. Stop panicking, Anna
@@annablue7457 STFU they don’t produce the majority of our food stock PERIOD!
@@brianbell3836 blah blah blah, still nothing legit to say? Why say anything?
Farmers get my vote , not liebour
Clarkson's millionaire protest.
Why should he have to pay tax?
Tax the wealthy - they have a 3 million pound exempt limit .. more if you factor in other reliefs available
Its only over the exempt limit they are liable for inheritance tax and at half the rate everyone else is liable too
Plus they have 10 years to spread and pay the liability
No sympathy for the rich wealthy millionaire land owners that will actually be subject to the tax - especially the dukes and lords with thousands of acres
And this is coming from a uk tax specialist. Ask the tax specialists on how this change will actually work - it doesn’t target small family farms
100& behind the farmers labour again showing how nasty they are
Have farmers been lying to HMRC so the government has a different idea of how many farms are worth more than 3 million quid?
Just fixing the tories shambles brexit included.
Farmers voted for Brexit. More fool them
The guy boasting about Leicester and Leicestershire and claiming to protect rural communities. When he got booted out
This programme needs boycotting,its so out of tune,with the general public
Starmer all day ... reap what you sow farmers 😂😂😂😂
Starmer wont care one bit. The farmers should've hired 2000 Muslims to protest with them...
Or waved Palestinian flags!
100%
Pathetic bigots .. comparing the murder of thousands of children to millionaires fighting for tax cuts on their million (not for the general public and average jo)
Get some education
Hire a British Palestinian Muslim tax lawyer if you have to teach u about tax law
It’s two tier policing,people on Palestinian marches get away with much more which is why I mentioned the flag NOT to do with the terrible war itself.
Why should farmers get away with it?
Stop the boats…plenty of money for people here then.
This discussion has nothing to do with boats
@@davidadams8027 it has everything to do with MONEY,so that includes the 8 million a day spent on illegal immigrants being put before people already living here who have paid their taxes.
HOW?
The boat people will pay tax unlike the farmers and the lazy benefit claiming Brits!!!!
It’s really simple maths. 8.5 billion on foreign aid. Cut that to 7 billion then they could keep the heating allowance for pensioners. 22 billion new money for the NHS. Cut that to 21.5 billion and then no need to raise IHT on farmers. They’ve made political choices with awful consequences.
Raising this tax on farmers is about fair play
@ but not fair on Farmers. Listen to them
@@familymatterslowepeel8092 Of course, it's fair.
Oh no it isn’t
@@familymatterslowepeel8092 Oh, yes, it is!
A baker starts work at 3am every day. They work incredibly hard. Rubbish hours. If they're fortunate to end up with an estate worth over £350/500k, they'll fall in the bracket for being eligible for inheritance tax at 40%.
Why should it be different for farmers?
Because without the grain the bread cannot be baked.
@@ehilton96doesn't mean they get away without paying !
A baker will fall into the BPR category so will have been OK before the budget changes, all businesses will be hit by this governments theft off working people
Certainly not on the side of this inept Government!!
Raising funds to save the country. Reform want to sell the NHS to their American friends.
Farmers make less than 1% on the value of the property. If you want to pass it on to your family the maths do not work out.
As a chartered accountancy and tax advisor I can tell u it’s wealthy business .. I’m not talking income and annual profits but wealth and net asset building .. so yes u can fool the poor but speak to accountants and uk tax specialists for the truth on how this works
So, sell up.
Only right everyone pays tax
Inheritance tax on farmers is only over 3 million pounds and pay 20% over that then they'll have 10 years interest free to pay.
If they don't like it, why not sell up?
Artificially increasing the population and reducing our food production. Hmm.
Not a fan of farmers for various reasons BUT if they have to pay inheritance tax then so should the Royals.
Agreed
There are several things to unpack here.
1. There are many people vital to society; farmers, police, nurses, firefighters, etc. ALL get paid very little but ONLY farmers pay NO inheritance tax.
2. Everybody paid IHT until 1986, when Lawson gave Farmers exemption (39 year with NO IHT).
3. Now farmers are complaining because they have to pay IHT of 20% (payable over 10 years - so 2% a year) with a threshold of £1m. Meanwhile, everybody else pays 45% over £325,000 payable immediately. How does this look?
Well, an average farm in the UK is 250 acres, which in land terms means it is valued about £2.5m + £500k equipment. This would attract an IHT bill of £400k (20% of £2m) or £40k a year over 10 years off a £3m asset!
Compare to a middle class person who passes his £1m house onto his son and his £500k pension and savings (these are not extreme values). The IHT bill for the son would be 45% of £1.5m or £675,000.
So a non farmer passing on a house and pension worth half that of a working farm, pays double the tax compared to a farmer - using the new regime. Under the old regime the farmer would have paid ZERO tax.
Finally, I would remind you that Clarkson (and all of the other 'business' farmers) all bought farms to minimise their IHT bill. They might moan but even today, they will only pay 20% whereas everybody else pays 45%, so a nice 25% saving. The trouble is that here, the likes of Jeremy Clarkson (who admitted in 2021 that he purchased all his land to avoid paying inheritance tax) and other rich land owners and farmers have managed to convince the every farmer that this will affect them. Well it won't and it is about time the rich started paying in to this country to help it.
I support the farmers and also Jeremy Clarkson
We should definitely let the dukes off from paying inheritance tax. Dukes shouldn’t have to pay tax just because they are dukes, as their ancestors were mates with the kings or queens so it’s only fair. Just let anyone off who has more than a million quid. Millionaires shouldn’t have to pay tax. Tax is for peasants.
Quite right. And give landowners an annual cheque just for having unused land.
💯 supporting our farmers inheritance tax should be abolished it's a tax on death
It might be a good start to ban really big landowners from registering their land in a trust in tax free havens abroad. But I guess that won't happen any time soon.
Those people lobby MPs
Farmers have my vote
Starmer is an operating enemy to all brits, how pathetic to have the SHADOW GIVERNMENT as an enemy 😅 so backwards the UK is 😂😂
Eh?
Donkey
An easy example -
a doctor with 5 million in estate assets will end up paying 1.6milluon in inheritance tax
A farmer with 5 million in estate assets will end up paying only 400k in inheritance tax (and thats not even taking into account the additional business property relief the farmer would receive in stock and machinery)
Who works harder and contributes more to the society - a doctor or a farmer??
Or both and if both then why is a farmer getting an easier ride with tax then a doctor with the same value estate?
Absolutely.
Not paying tax=not allowed to vote!!! Brexit equals
£billions lost because of Farage.
Economists and analysts at Cambridge Econometrics found that, by 2035, the UK is anticipated to have three million fewer jobs, 32% lower investment, 5% lower exports and 16% lower imports, than it would have had been. The report states that the UK will be £311bn worse off by 2035 due to leaving EU.
''Farmer versus Starmer'' is exactly the problem.
No, I don't choose ''a side'', because I think it's absolutely correct to close these tax loopholes.
Do I agree that there needs to be clearer assurances regards just who this should effect? Yes.
I don’t that’s their Brexit benefit!
We need to set up more farms on a co-operative basis so we can ensure UK food supply. We do not want farms being bought out by foreigners. The vast majority of farmers will not be subject to IHT but the government needs to make sure UK food supply stays at a level to maintain national security as it is definitely a matter of national security!
Farmers !
GET ORFF MY LANDS!
I’m surprised he didn’t mention the so called 22 billion instead of just going on about this 3 million.
Ask them about all the EU Subsidy they were getting
Exactly
It's not interest free over 10 years.
So many big farmers in England ! It wasn't that long ago that the lazy English landlords took our land and made our farmers tenants!!🇨🇮🇨🇮🇨🇮🇨🇮
Tax millionaires with a wealth tax .. taxing 1% to those with net wealth over 10 million. .. research and calculation show this will raise more in the first year then any other tax policy
Literally the uk version of the view
We had to pay iht tax and his farm wasn't worth 3 million not even a million same when our mother died what she left once paid tax off we had £700 to split between the 4 of us
A lot of farmers are tennants the arstockracy King Dutchy etc own it
Jonathan Ashworth: "We produce the best British food and drink in the world." Doh!
Wow. You're hard. Slip of the tongue. Be more tolerant of those with whom you disagree.
The caller with the farmer husband doesn’t understand how the tax works
Yes machinery and livestock is included but that comes with additional tax reliefs above the 3 million exempt threshold .. people need some real education on tax law in this country and they’ll see how the rich get away with avoiding tax
Half these people that are supporting farmers don’t understand how the inheritance tax and all the APR and BPR and other tax reliefs farms are subject to work
That's of the Tory one when they said once you are dead your left with nothing like thatcher said you save ten poon we will have that you can have the pound
Once Amazon is done with all food will come from Brazil fact
Lin Mai hired to amp CONFUSSION with gusto.. delivering missinfo whilst Totaly confused pays well…!?!
Lovely girl but none too bright on this subject
@@brianbell3836 She’s not too bright in any…!?! That’s the whole reason for her sponsorship..!?
@@TheLion-b3h That's a little strong
@@brianbell3836 Nah accurate, she a sponsored dunce..!? 🤭
What planet is this northern guy on at 6 mins. Being supported? Wtf…..Farmers lost eu subsidies, government didn’t support alternatively, margins and weather are terrible. Now inheritance tax with tax on some farms at similar level to income. It’s totally bonkers.
If they can't make it work, sell up
Close the boarders save millions...!!!
HOW?
Farmer V Starmer: Whose side are you on? Feat. Jonathan Ashworth & Lin Mei | Jeremy Vine 19.11.24 1206pm the folk song... which side are you on, referee...? they've right to express their dissatisfaction. they also make a hell of a lot of peoples' lives a misery...
I'm on Starmer's side. I want a functioning society I want a good economy.
Will you be saying that when farmers go on strike and you've got a lack of food on the shelves
@@Greengoblin-qk6kq We have our means and way. We'll find a way.
@@Grrreeeeeeeeeeeew There’s no chance of a good economy with Starmer and his amateurish front bench in charge!
And alongside a failing economy goes hand in hand with a disfunctional society.
@@Greengoblin-qk6kq - Why don't the Farmer's complain about being duped by Brexit - the majority of them wanted it but its damaged the economy
@@thequest3795 communist,still going on about the eu,you lost suck it up.!
I wish I had £3 million!!
Farmers haven’t got £3 million to spend on luxuries for themselves. They are too busy toiling away on their farms from morning till night just to feed ungrateful people such as yourself! 🥵 When they are lucky enough to get a profit, they reinvest that on farm machinery, crops, animals etc etc..
But profits aren’t at all guaranteed, which means a lot of farmland will gradually be sold off as farmers die. Once it’s gone, it’s gone for good! 😢
@@TonyMaronie well said 👍
I’m a farmer and I wish I had 3 million as well, but I don’t. I’ve got a 365 days a year, 7 days a week, 16 hours (minimum) a day job. I’ve got animals to look after, I’ve got land that needs to be taken care of, I’ve got a heritage to protect, I’ve got people to feed. I’m a mechanic, I’m a midwife, I’m an accountant, I’m a diet specialist, I’m a meteorologist, I’m a horticulturist. I don’t own the land, the land owns me and it’s my responsibility to look after it and everything that lives here. My sons have grown up tending this land and the generations of animals that live here, they know it, they’ve lived and breathed it and they want to pass that knowledge and love down to the next generation. They’ve attended agricultural college and are more than qualified but they won’t even get the opportunity to continue what they’ve been doing alongside me if this iht goes through. They’ve been working for bed, board and essentially pocket money their whole lives. Where are they supposed to find this money when I die? What happens to all the work they’ve invested in this land? So yeah, I wish I had 3 million as well!!
@@TonyMaronie So, sell up and live in luxury. Duh!
@@brianbell3836 What an ignorant thick stupid comment!
It's so stupid it's hardly worth bothering to reply so I'll just say this:
Will you be happier if the farmers sell up and the farms close down if it means food prices increase and your food shopping bill becomes expensive?
Without proper food security during these uncertain times it's not inconceivable that the country will slowly starve itself!
Don't start complaining if any of these things happen because you're not bothered if farms close down!
Not paying tax=not allowed to vote!!! Brexit equals
£billions lost because of Farage.
Economists and analysts at Cambridge Econometrics found that, by 2035, the UK is anticipated to have three million fewer jobs, 32% lower investment, 5% lower exports and 16% lower imports, than it would have had been. The report states that the UK will be £311bn worse off by 2035 due to leaving EU.