Why is Pakistan's Military Losing Public Support? | TCM Explains
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ค. 2024
- With growing public distrust of Pakistan's military, the country is on the verge of a governability crisis, according to an article co-authored by Oxford University Associate Professor Dr. Adeel Malik. TCM spoke with Dr. Adeel to understand the rise and fall of military influence on Pakistan's public and politics.
TCM’s journey since 2017 has been about telling stories that people want to hear, which mainstream media has been neglecting for decades. We want to disrupt the status quo by delivering engaging content that empowers impassioned voices and impacts social change. We are defined by integrity, grit, and ingenuity, and this is what drives us.
Support independent journalism in Pakistan and get exclusive access to the full-length version of our videos: / thecentrummedia
-------------------
Subscribe to TCM Original: bit.ly/2A3pOXz
Subscribe to TCM: bit.ly/2Tu6AkW
-------------------
Follow us on
Facebook: / tcmoriginalsofficial
Facebook: / thecentrummedia
Facebook: / redbytcm
Tiktok: / tcmoriginals
Twitter: / thecentrummedia
Instagram: / thecentrummedia
Instagram: / tcmoriginals
Instagram: / redbytcm
WhatsApp Channel : whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaDQ...
-------------------
Join our Facebook community: bit.ly/35oeLVs
-------------------
Website: thecentrummedia.com
-------------------
About The Centrum Media
The Centrum Media (TCM) has the credit of Pakistan’s first digital news network specializing in visual storytelling. Being a premier online platform, TCM strives to enhance the online experience of the new generation, ranging from hard news to feature stories. TCM creates original content and curates simultaneously from multiple sources.
We will take you where the real stories happen but often go untold and unseen in the shortest possible time having more information. Unlike the traditional media, TCM aims at sharing diverse stories across multi-platforms aimed at the people who consume news through mobile and social stream. We take up the challenge in the digital arena to present the news in the most imaginative and innovative ways.
Your on-the-go lifestyle forces us to bring the news directly to your pocket devices.
Army’s role in political affairs of Pakistan has destroyed this nation & country- that’s a bitter truth & reality
Sakoot e Dhaka was blamed on IN but it was the napak foj e fquddat uz mafurrrrrrrrrat that was at fault
It has rather saved Pakistan from the bullshit political lot that you have always supported blindly
جھوٹی قوم کے باشندوں کے پسندیدہ حکمران سچے کیسے ہو گۓ ؟
@@FarhanRasool PTI will never be in peace.
@@AstralProjections-oy8ue stop burning
exactly
When army killed arshad sharif in Kenya and stole the general election in 8 February 2024 they lost public support
He was going to reveal the Drug trade of ISI
lol, you have to prove it first...
@@pearl328do we have to prove that election was Rigged ?
It's bull shit. Army is not loosing the public support. 140 Million jahil punjabies are still worshipping their Punjabi Army because they have one person in Army in every house of punjab.
No proof.
Mafia in uniform.
This Nation deserves strong danday wali sarkar but Uniform boys are still doing far better than all those lies you are fed,
Uniform boys are only better in controlling politics in Pakistan but can't win a war
@@saadomar1101these boys are corrupt and lost trust, the only way to regain it is to leave horse trading, interfering in political affairs.
Uniform boys have ruled better (financial reforms, etc)
Than politicians
@@saadomar1101 yeah the country is on skies of success under boys
Pakistan Army is not anymore for the defense of Pakistan. They have become business and political institution.
They’ve been a business since 1947!
They are a tool of Imperial powers
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Worse, they are destroying Pakistan.
@@raziahmedjalali6498 yes, you're 💯 right
Salute to IK for exposing Pakistan's biggest mafia.
Thank you so much Greate Learder Imran khan
He himself came into power via this Mafia 😂😂
@@kaaaah2003 you're right 👍
@@AlphaZuluKilo Yes maybe, then they tried to control him like a puppet. That's when the gloves came off and there will only be one winner...
@@syedshah9836 Really. Please go and see the latest message he is sending to Army Chief for negotiations via Omar Ayub and his sister
Till generals and judges aren’t held accountable we can’t progress
all should be accountable,,
esp the political person who make all the promises that fish brains forget so easily.
قوم کے مزاج میں سارے راز چھپے ہیں
جب بہانے کرتے ہیں یا کہتے ہیں جانے دو تو کیا جنرل کیا جج اور کیا وزیراعظم
@@saadomar1101 The big question, who is gonna do that? My answer: None!
@@SaramZafar but not to forget that nation is not ready to take things in it's hands. It is not well aware and not prepared for worse.
The root of all evil is the army. Why every general of Pakistani army becomes a billionaire in 3 years and escapes from the country and takes islands in foreign countries. Musharraf Pharaon - Dubai. Kayani Nimrod. Strays. Raheel Sharif. Saudi Arabia .... Bajwa Harami stole 1276 billion dollars. Belgium. Munir's hideout, engaged in dog theft and corruption. Germany ??????????????????????????????
They deserve to be shamed
@@initit7070you will be as well
@@initit7070???
@@initit7070kiun? Papa Jones ko sharam NHI aati?
It will be 2nd time, 90k surrendered in 71
@@ias3068 there brave stories of kargal are also famous in india❤❤
Jis mulk ke paas aesi DHA foj ho usy dushman ki zaroorat nahiin..
bakwas!
@@saadomar1101 here comes the.tout
@@uk4490 better than being a fulltime bitch :D
😂😂😂😂😂😂 true
Sahi kaha
This didn't start with Musharraf. During Zia's time, Generals got involved in drugs, arms and other types of smuggling.
Zia was the first traitor
@@shanebluesky7452no first was Ayyub khan then yahya
@@abdullahshabbir1622yeah he did dhaandli against Fatima Jinnah
But mushraf started legalization of corruption and made it acceptable in organization
@@zulfiqarawan3407 it started with zia he killed ZAB and the partition as well.
Army is a state within a state. Whole Pakistan cannot afford this inner-state anymore. We are sick and tired of them actually. I live in Pindi and I have seen firsthand that how Army officers live above any form of law. They are untouchables and no one can dare to challenge even their illegal activities. People are frustrated and they are just silent out of fear now a days.
I being a hardcore pakistani, always wanted to sacrifice my life for pakistan now so disheartened that i will support TTP or Afghan Taliban or even India to defeat this thug army, i would be happy to see again that this thug army surrendering to someone as they did in 1971.
My firm belief is that these thugs went to change Bangalis future generation but surrendered in front of Jagjeet Singh Arora and pakistan got disintegrated , will happen again and there will be another Yahya khan amongst these generals who will break up this pakistan. In pakistan who loves this army except punjab, no one.
@@regularguy2391 I highly doubt that you are a Pakistani. Secondly no one in Pakistan will support Taliban, India or TTP to oust Army. We know Army is corrupt to the core and we also believe that TTP and Taliban are supported by some elements from the same core group.
Pakistan Army has to understand the Public sentiment and should go back to barracks. As simple as that.
@@kawan5851yes, as simple as that but if it that simple why it never happens, it is simple for you but it is not simple for Yazid, right now I was watching a video clip in which someone is telling who was Yazid, I never knew and in video he says many don’t know that even before the assasination of Imam Husain, Yazid had invaded Madina and his forces killed 1000’s of Sahaba and about 1000 of girls gave birth to babies without a husband, why I brought Yazid here because Asim Munir is a Yazid of present time, will not obey law or constitution, because he has large military under his command with guns so he damn care about laws. Yes your doubt is correct that I am not Pakistani, because I am not a Punjabi so I am not a Pakistani.
Culprits who stolen 2024 election and brought sharif mafia in power should be given punishment and re-poll must be taken.
Why not start from Yahya Khan??
And also with 2018 elections @@FooodConfusion
Article6 on munir.yazeed, qazi fraud & thief election commissioner.
Where were all you guys when Imran Mafia was installed and 2018 elections were rigged.... Oh wait . Military was Family. Army chief was a Father figure. You guys were getting money for promoting Khan. Kind of still are making money and limelight out of Pakistan by spreading lies 😭
Sir first give punishment to culprits which did injustice with Mother of Nation Fatima Jinnah. Correct history first to settle the present
Other countries have armies, Pakistani army has a country 😂😂😂
What about Eqypt?
@@vinsin328they have asims’s brother Sisi
And the US Army?
True
@@ikhlaquechan7463I think u need to read some books and have some information before commenting
Spot on doc. We hate this DHA.mafia to the core.
Yes, to the CORE
you hate em,, but we defend the Army,, we defend every patriotic officer and ever soldier that gives lives so we defend the institute all together no matter what the general is like because the general goes away...
Guy said billionaires !!! Have you heard. @@saadomar1101
@@saadomar1101We hate this mafia this rotten institution has caught our country by the throat.
@@saadomar1101hypocrite how can you defend them when everyone involved in this mess if you are saying soldiers are innocent they just follow orders than why you guy's criticise isreali soliders they are also following orders why you guy's criticise yazeedi soliders they were just following orders which law give them the right to follow unlawful orders they are not giving anything to pak instead they are taking everything from pak
My grandfather used to tell us stories of army.I used to salute armed officials for their service and sacrifices for the nation but now there is not even little respect left.Our kids won’t hear tales of their bravery.
No they will listen to tales of corruption, papa John kinda business, DHA scams, Manhattan flats, citizenships in Canada, Island in Australia, etc have had a history of their bravery. And they would certainly say" lest we not forget"😂
Brilliant insight. I also studied at Sir Syed College Rawalpindi. Moved to United Kingdom and gained all my civil, and human rights and excellent high-paying job opportunities here. Pakistan is full of injustice on every level
Injustice is a natural out growth of the betrayal of Islam by both the civilian and military elites from Pakistan's very outset. This is not a new "development". The logical outcome is a lack of true Islam and gradually also a lack of welfare and decline of living standards. The elites have already killed the possibility of Islamic accountability over them by even contaminating the image of Islam with violence, justified and unjustified ! 😅
UK is new Pakistan. I wouldn't live there for free
@Mlridge nothing is free in the world you have to work for it. UK is lightyears ahead of Pakistan.
@shoutforit work for it in the UK?
Most immigrants are low skill people who rely on government handouts. I've travelled to the UK, Australia, US, and UAE. I'd much rather live in Pakistan than the UK. It's an absolute shit-hole destroyed by the weak Govt, and low skilled migrants.
Great decision my friend ❤
Shame on munira mistri 💩👎
Bloody generals
screw the bloody voters always falling for the promises of fake leaders.
@@mansoorahmad5694 Yes....
Not Loosing, Loosed!
Lost😅
Do these lumber 1 fools don't understand that they are playing with fire?
What fire? Punjabi army and population are sucking the other provinces of their resources. Punjabis will not rebel against their own army😂😂
@@Gappasappa screw all those who created newer versions of divide based on Punjabi / Pathan / Sindhi,,
iA all politicians will see khawari,
@@saadomar1101 he Is Indian hindu
@@Gappasappa Tu Indian Hindu he na ?
OH what a talk, profound analysis at the right moment. Readers should be obliged to listen to such a sophisticated & candor speaker. Salute sir
Dr Adeel Malik and Pakistanis like him are a voice of sanity in a sea of complexity and insane policies. What a gem for Pakistan to have - if only our civil-military elite listens to him
Just brilliant ... 100% agreed ..
We need this kind of journalist ... Educated and deep researchers
True, I used to see the military as a guardian, but not anymore.
Always wondered where the descendants of Yazeed's Army men and followers would be in our current time. It seems like they've all joined this institute/mafia.
Quality content after long time 🙌
Much better than imran riaz vlog
Story of a unlucky 3rd world country...😢 very good analysis
TCM Original got some balls making a video like this, RESPECT!!!
I don't think the establishment image which is completely destroyed among people can be rebuilt in the next few decades.
Never required again😊
you think wrong,, this has happened before.. in Bhutto's era,
but this time there will be blood
Ek or APS and they're back in buisness
@@haseebhassan6955 their loosing soldier every week in waziristan and awam still doesnt gives two hoots
@@haseebhassan6955 shame on you Haseeb,,
Not even indian SM or Israel ran this propaganda at this level the way Army haters in Pakistan are doing so esp PTI haramkhors.
Now that's what I call "analysis"
Great work TCM team. Keep bringing this kind of "unbaised", close to the truth and reality based content.
Amazing!!!
All officers in the army are millionaires and billionaires. The good thing is, this has been identified and acknowledged.
Please don't speak without proof
@@rizwanrauf4940 do you personally know some of the officers?
@@EngineerMuneeb yes
@@rizwanrauf4940 then you must know many of them mostly spend their time abroad!
Have wealth heaven in real state
@@EngineerMuneeb it's only top and in Pakistan elite are same , whether lawyers ,judges , politicians
We don't need military anymore. We wanna live peaceful life with our neighbors we need peace and stability in our country ..
wow. amazing video. if this is played on Pakistani media channels for just one week every day, most of Pakistan's critical problems will be sorted out in a few years.
Ye foj.nahiin mafia.hai
When India kicked the East India Company out in 1947,
East India made a New Military Base called Pakistan.
East India Company changed their name to Pakistan Army.
The Generals have 1 Agenda…to serve the Gora Master, not Pakistan.
Pakistan is the product of British they wanted to keep an eye on Afghanistan and their relationship with USSR and India, they created a barrier
This institution has caught our country by the throat.
Unfortunately Pak army views every problem through the lens of operation Searchlight.
The officer class lacks critical thinking and vision and is stuck in pleasing their seniors and that is seen as a merit for promotion.
Excellent Analysis... Principle stand of every Pakistani should be that Army should get out of politics. They can only be STAKEHOLDER in foreign policy other then that they should do what they are meant to do. If NAB has to remain there, NAB should be able to build cases on Army officials as well as they can on Civilians
They stole votes of people in broad daylight and attitude was " jo karna karlo asi tan sharifan nu lyauna hakoomat ch"
Talking about 2018 😂
Very aptly summarised by this gentleman. Can't disagree with even one bit.
ڈاکٹر عدیل ملک صاحب
آپ نے جو کچھ اپنے تجزیہ میں پیش کیا ہے ۔ اس کا بہت شکریہ ۔ مگر عوام الناس اس سے کہیں زیادہ باخبر اور باشعور ہوچکے ہیں ۔
عمران اپنی سیاست میں عوام کی کافی حمایت کھو چکے تھے ۔ اگلی مدت تک، جو کہ نزدیک ہی تھی، کا انتظار کر تے اور عوام اپنے ووٹ سے جسے چاہتے منتخب کرلیتے۔
عوام کے بہت بڑی تعداد، جو کل کا پچاس سے کہیں زیادہ ہے، غصے میں اس لیے ہے کہ ان کے حق راہے دہی کے برعکس ایسے لوگوں کو اقتدار سپرد کردیا (بلکہ مسلط کردیا)جسے عوام نے منتخب کیا ہی نہیں ۔
اللّہ وطن عزیز پاکستان کی حفاظت فرمائے اور تمام محبین وطن جن کا تعلق معاشرے کے کسی بھی شعبے سے ہو اس وطن کی ترقی اور خوشحالی کے لئے مل کر کام کریں ۔ آ مین
عمران خان زندہ باد۔ پٹواری مردہ باد
Agree....Aur doosri baat yeh thi k agar ley k aana hi tha to yeh chorr k bachay kyun?
In se better to Khan hai....Bajaaye ghalati maantey.....Awam pe charh gaye aur ab awam seedhi ho gayee hai
May Allah Subhan hu Tallah makes our country prosper
God's not that stupid. He only helps the ones who help themselves. Hum namazain bhi na parhain behnun ke hisse bhi khain aur phir Allah se madad mangain. Shame on us.
Shame on army
I don't think military alone has lost Public support. Judicial murder, police brutality and changing electoral results according to one's own desire also contributed a lot. They could have brought anyone on the political scene but bringing again those corrupt families in play placed them in similar category.
Imran Khan is also corrupt
Amazing Analysis. So profound and complete
One of the main points that many overlook, which he beautifully explained in the video, is the reason why, unlike other countries, our Army Chiefs do not face challenges in the form of internal military politics. We often hear fabricated stories of "internal coups" or "Khamosh Mujahideen" from individuals like Maj. Adil Raja and Imran Riaz Khan, who are clearly being used by these "Khamosh Mujahideen" to spread false hopes of good Generals and Soldiers among civilians. Despite these tales, we see no real action because from lowest to highest ranking officer "In sub k haat ghee mai hain": refer to the video starting at 5:00 for more details on this
Losing???
It has already lost
This means that the army is responsible for Pakistan's poor condition.
Obviously they are.
People of Pakistan must reclaim their ownership on State, Country will run by People's representatives not by defence bureaucrats
Precise and to the point analysis.
Thanks for such video TCM!
This current establishment has destroyed Pakistan miltary reputation..ab dil uth gia hea in se..
After 10-15 years it doesn’t seem like Pakistan will survive as a country thanks to Napak Army
Brilliant analysis
Thank you TCM for such wonderful video ❤.
Aasma Jahangir was right when she said corruption of Generals is far more than politicians
Some of the Pakistani Generals are already working for CIA and Mossad and are on the payroll of these Agencies for a long time. This is no secret and should not be taken as surprising revelation. Any operation to harm Israel would already be compromised beforehand as these elements have a hotline to CIA/Mossad and would inform of any planning of an operation. Israel has already infiltrated GHQ and planted moles inside the military, and it already knows Pakistan's capabilities regarding any potential operation; and Israel does not sit back and file complaints, but takes immediate retaliatory action. The GHQ does not have the expertise nor the resources to carry out any major offensive against Israel or even India next door.
عوام کی عزت ہو گی تو اداروں کی عزت ہو گی
They can safe the image of Army but their egos are above the sky which will never ever make our beautiful country ( Pakistan ) peaceful. This is the reality no matter how much wealth you wanted to loot but at the end of the day your all things remain here and you left for eternity. Our ALLAH will never let us down on the day of judgement. Our Army thinks that they're invincible 👎
انتہائی اعلیٰ تجزیہ۔ بہترین
*Pakistan ka mtlb kya Dubai leaks DHA plots Papa John's and Australia jazeere bana or **#bajwe** ki trha Nikl ja.or koum trn0 pe still 76years...*
Great analysis! From Pak to Napaak army 😢
Do bring more content from this person. We wanna hear more of his insight!
Good topic & work ❤
زبردست. یہی حقیقت ہے.
Amazing video..............Poor pakistani aaam admi..........what a sad situation
At 9:21, definitely agree with his statement that "Military should never be given control of the economy".
History has always shown that doing such things have allowed military to directly interfere in govt. and state. During the Roman Empire times, emperors such as Nero and the successors increased over all service life of the Pretorian Guard (elite Roman military personnel who acted as emperors bodyguards and intelligence assets). Their pay was also increased which was more than that of the pay of a Roman legionnaire (foot soldiers and officers of the Roman army). At first they were also involved with corrupt emperors in conspiracies to remove their rivals and then often times they assassinated an emperor that they didn't like and installed their own. Eventually emperors became subservient to them and they became the primary force of gaining power in Roman Empire, until the emperor Septimus Severus dismantled the Pretorian Guard.
Great Analysis..
Army and establishment needs 100 years to rebuild its image .
Since 1952 the corruption Army did is nothing near to politicians.
Imran khan is a leader and Munir should realize this.
Fake leader
@@YaSallam365 Khan is fake leader
Armyy establishment need a honest and2 public loving person who say sorry to public and go back to barcks and stop dfoing business stop ervewry thing and be just professional army
Impossible.
I am reading comments and getting the fact that the illusion of the word "PAK ARMY" is finally exposing.
Pakistani generals are billionaires. Compare any officer of Pakistani govt with a similar officer of army and you will loose your mind realizing just how much these army officers are making in terms of plots and other privileges. Truly dictators have made this army rich of a very poor country.
What is not obvious about the answer to that question - Why is Pakistan’s military losing public support? Does this question even warrant a video? Address high level questions.
The public feels vulnerable now that there's no guardian.
Actually no. We feel liberated. We shouldn’t relay on others and do nothing. This country’s success heavily depends on each of us individuals. That means we have power in our hands to make decisions and dictate results. We shouldn’t give our power to others be it police or military and then sit quietly do nothing. The action and results are in our hands.
@@sameenwaseem4803Lol. I think you are living in dream. Come to reality. You are nothing just pawns in a chess game. Your opinions don't matter. They will do whatever they want to do.
@@RahulMishra-ld2bo did I say anything about you? Fuck off.
@@sameenwaseem4803 Wake up 😂😂 Pakistan don't want to declare bankruptcy
Heard you for the first time. It was a wonderful experience of your analysis based upon research and information on the politics of the country. Which is beneficial for the people concerned about Pakistan
such a calm sophisticated yet accurate yet widespread in-depth analysis of the situation. Hats off
Army supporters are actually their family members 😂😂😂😂 living in DHA😂😂😂
Gen Faiz Hamid pulled down servers of RTS ( vote count app) after '18 election. Why should anyone respect Army ? It's duty is to defend nation , not decide who becomes PM
Didnt PTI lose 30 seats after RTS was shut down???
RTS was disrupted to bring down PTI seats count.
@@uk4490
And no pti member ever raised voice during the govt?
Did they
@@aliarham7158 PTI did raise the voice for stolen seats after 2018 elections. Grow up
My dad who retired in 1991was always critical of army generals n the way people get promoted in the army. Now a days army has degerated to the least possibly limits 😢😢😢
First time listening to this guy and he's wonderful, just talking facts , bravo and awesome
Army kaa kaam border par hy ur extension kaa system khatam kary
Pakistan is doomed and is a failed state today, the responsibility solely goes to the soulless army, the politicians and the citizens as well.
Excellent analysis..good work TCM
Never seen such an amazing and realitics analysis regarding army. Thank for sharing this person, I didn't know about him before. 👍
میرے خیال میں جنرل بھی اس وقت سوچ رہے ہوں گے کہ وہ باعزت طریقے سے واپس اپنے کام پر جاہیں لیکن ملک میں کوئی ایسا نظام موجود نہیں جہاں وہ تمام زمہ داری دے کر واپس جاسکین..
Bankruptc has no choice except to surrender
One of the top 5 reasons of Pakistan's defaulted economy and being a failed state
Wow. What a personality. Every word with wisdom. 🙏🙏🙏One day army will be held accountable.
A deep and insightful evaluation of the rot in Army. Highly concerning
quaid e azam bih badmash thay kay dha mein pakistan bana diya
One word... Imran Khan
Who was also their puppet
@@sameelahmedkhatanaakacsakh3472 No he was not, he struggled for more than 20 years.
@@sameelahmedkhatanaakacsakh3472 Imran Khan ko power fauj sey leni hai option or hai he nahi
My father's pension was Rs 2500/- but the quality of officers in those times was outstanding. Upright & intelligent officers and so we're the Jawans under them.
Today the officers come mostly from the poorest of the poor rural families with minimal education and what to talk of it's standard.
Intellectually the officers are not even second class. The element of corruption has badly affected the discipline of the force and commercial enterprises have created a distraction from the main task of security. Further more the serving officers are allowed to do real estate business and Corps Commander is in charge of DHA.
Not a single facility given to nation we are facing basic electrity gas proper roads problems lack of hositals medicine highest inflation
A balanced and summarised review. Thank you Sir
All parliment memebrs should sit together and make Parliment superior. Take control and if all will be on one side they won't have any chance. But surely this won't happen because parliament members also have to hide their records in next step.
Pakistan Army losing credibility...
Military should stay away from political Affairs...
Military establishment is the root cause of all evils of poor pakistani nation since 1947..
Exactly 💯
Best analysis I heard on current circumstances
Very insightful.. very informative.. learnt a lot from this 15 min. Video. Does adeel Malik have any social media account???
comprehensive analysis.
Beautifully put up!!
Ecellent & comprehansive research analysis
This was a great analysis. On point