Is the Motul 10W50 4T better than Castrol 10W50 4T? Let's check...
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- Subscribe: www.youtube.co...
@Piotr Tester
Motor oil purity test Motul 7100 4T 10W50 and Castrol Power 1 Racing 4T 10W50
How does the test run?
The same amount of oil was heated 3 times to 250°C by a 550°C hot air stream.
The oil sample is always at the same distance from the heater. The oil temperature is measured by a professional laboratory reference thermometer.
#motul7100 #motul10W50 #castrol10W50
Why do I heat oil to such a high temperature?
I want to show the limits of oil, where the oil loses its properties and dirt starts to precipitate and settle on the engine walls. This is similar to the temperature in the engine, e.g. in the upper part of the piston. Just because the temperature sensor in the engine shows 90°C does not mean that the oil has the same temperature throughout the engine.
How to evaluate the oil condition after the test?
10 - very good
1 - poorly
I will only give you one value. I take into account the degree of oil blackening as well as the amount of contamination on the tube walls. The blacker the oil, the stronger the smell of burning.
Results:
Motul 10W50: 6.5/10
Castrol 10W50: 9/10
Piotr Tester juxtaposition:
uszlachetniacz...
I think castrol is best one
Please test castrol power 1 cruise 15w50 .
Castrol is the best 👌
Castrol better for cleaning engine
🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@ghostrider..rajbhai8718 y are you laughing
Seems to be like Motul boils quicker than Castrol so the Castrol would last longer.
Não achei o teste valido por conta do motul 7100 ser um óleo já de coloração diferente, implogando a ser mais escuro, o fator que deveria ser levado em conta seria quando a resistividade em não perder suas propriedades multiviscosas ao longo do teste
Esse teste esta errado todo óleo tem suas etapas o melhor óleo e aquele q absorver temperatura 🌡 porque quem resfria é a carcaça de alumínio do motor onde o óleo tem contado e as propriedades deles mesmo quente se mantém mais viscoso
@@alexandrescolari2966 Psé, eu temho um video no meu canal falando sobre 7100, estou a 1 ano usando esse óleo, e as mudanças são fantásticas, eu falo isso tudo no meu vídeo.
@@alexandrescolari2966 Castrol Power 1 e Motul 7100 são produtos equivalentes em qualidade. Se você procurar, existem comparativos de composição química e também teste de atrito... os resultados são sempre bem próximos de ambos os produtos.
Então eu vou no que tiver mais em conta.
@@BlackLine10 Castrol é importado? se for fabricação brasileira não é e nunca será equivalente. Por lei óleo brasileiro deve ser 50% reciclado ou seja óleo velho limpo e misturado com novo. Já motul é 100% novo pois não é de fabricação brasileira.
@@canaldocarllos o Castrol Power 1 é fabricado na Itália.
Castrol win...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂🤷
ya me cambie de motul a castrol sin haber visto este video ,hay una enorme diferencia en el ruido del motor y lubricacion de taquees hidraulicos , con motul sonaban mucho ahora nada con temperaturas de cero grados ambientales
Videos así necesita el mundo ahora ya se cual es mejor sin tanto bla bla
Ganó Castrol
Busque videos más antiguo y encontré uno que este mismo Castrol a 100 grado con un peso de un kilo durante solos 2 minutos tiene un pésimo desempeño un elevados desgaste mientra que el motul con 5 minutos apena una pequeña marca en el metal creí que el Castrol era mejor
Repsol y listo
@@NeoAH90 Motul is better 🫶🏻😎
es mejor el havoline
Piotr, It is somewhat confusing to watch your video and read your description. In video 5:33, Castrol floating and clearness are both better. The color scale (middle of the screen) is marked 10 on the left (most clear) and 1 is on the right (darkest). The Castrol is the higher number and your " 9/10" description matches. However, in your "Q and A" (6:03), you indicated that the lower result is better lubricating. That Q&A claim might lead people to think Motul were better since Motul is darker so matched the scale's lower number side. That is confusing.
so actually the clearer it is the better it is? (in this case for castrol)
Der test ist Quatsch! Wenn schon, muss man den Gewichtsverlust messen, nicht die Farbe. Jedes Öl kann schon im "Neuzustand" farblich dunkler bzw gefärbt sein.
Pelo oq entedi motul ele absorver mais a temperatura 🌡 do motor na troca de Calor com a carcaça de alumínio do motor q por sua vez é refrigerado a ar isso gera troca de calor, o óleo ideal ele tem q absorver calor lubrificar e manter a característica viscosidade em temperatura altas a cor não diz nada .Se o óleo do motor está escuro sinal q está fazendo seu dever de limpeza no motor com as trocas corretas a cada km rodado
👍🏼
Trotzdem würde ich das Motul immer vorziehen gegenüber dem Castrol....der NOAK wert ist besser ....in der Praxis geringere Verdampfung . Und was sehr wichtig ist für Motorrad Öle ist die Scherbelastung auch fürs Getriebe und da ist das Motul besser ...
What A BULLSCHIT
Habe auch das Motul 7100 10W-60 im Einsatz und wundere mich schon über dessen Neigung zum Schäumen !
@@maximilianpaech1944 unter welchen Bedingungen? Cross oder Strasse ...
@@jannisya3143 Strasse/Trockensumpf
Semi vs fully synthetic what the funny😆😆😆😁😁😁
Castrol power 1 racing is full synthetic
the dumbest test for an oil ever.
Why
Flawed test. Being red in colour, it darkens by comparison to Castrol ,which is goldish yellow. And, oil darkens not because of heat alone😑
Porque este MOTUL 7100 es mas cafe obscuro que rosado como lo he visto?
Hell no it’s not. Look at that garbage boiling at 230. 😒
Empirical these numbers are. Tests that qualify which oil is better should be scientific and follow under set guidelines e.g Four-ball Wear Test, FLZ Gear Failure Protection Test, Foam Test, etc. Read your oil SDS and deliver judgment from there people. If no SDS are around for that oil or if it's too short and lack for details, skip the oil
Nice castrol
But Motul was from beginning darker…🧐
¡Hello piotr!...excuseme but i speaks a very little of english...in your opinion: ¿is ipone katana 10w40 a good motor oil, comparing with motul 7100 or castrol power 1 racing?...👍
モーテルじゃなくてモチュールな
Test the viscosity,,, not a. Color okk ,,
Don't judge a book by it's cover (color)
Hey...what is this? I can clearly see that the castrol oil colour and its not easily getting heated like motul.... And those Q&A are similar in your other videos...is all this a research or just nonsense!!!!!
El que no conoce a Dios , acualquier santo le rezan ,psdat solo por ser comercial
Old brand is always gold 🥰😇🙏
Castrol best one
Motul 7100 is better!!! 🫶🏻😎
Questo test sul colore è sbagliato perché il motul è già più scuro di suo rispetto al castrol.
Concordo!
Sipam Castrol godinama i nemam problema sa motociklima a Motul nebih vise sipao pa da mi ga dzaba daju,verovatno sam bio mlad i glup,Motul je djubre u odnosu na neka druga ulja
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
From the datasheet, both were comparable in terms of viscosity index. Can't go wrong with either of both oils. I used Motul 7100, my bike feels the same 🤷 feels normal, nothing wrong, the engine's healthy. The oil does its job. Use the correct viscosity, change at regular intervals, that's all
How often would you recommend to change oil using bike in the street 70 percent and 30% on the highway up to 130kmh? Thanks
@@empowerd1 Depends on the bike, on a small bike like a C90 every 1000 miles, on a bigger one that holds more oil it can be longer like 2000, or 4000, some bike makers say 8000 but that is too high I think. Or once a year if your milage is low. I would say change it before it starts to go black in colour. You can see the oil change from clean to dirty as it gets older.
@@dunk8157 my ktm 2021 1290 Super duke R says in the booklet every year or every 15.000km but I change every 8000 to 10000km
POR QUE SÃO ESSAS BOLHAS
A COR ESTÁ MAIS ESCURA E VOCÊ NÃO ESTÁ LIMPANDO NADA?
es falso!! justamente los dos aceites son de color rojo!
Motul ist aber von Natur aus Dunkleres Öl ...
El Castrol se demora más en llegar al punto de ebullición.. winner the Castrol. Resiste más temperatura es lo q veo .
can you do a friction test for this catrol power 1 racing again?and why type of metal you had been used in the friction test?and i suggest you to try make a test on fuchs silkolene semi-synthetic for bike.tq
Prueba Liqui Molly, Test Liqui Molly please
Castrol win 🏅
so Motul is better ؟
YES!
CUAL ES EL. MEJOR?????
oil g3 diference g 4 g5 betther
Brasil , São Paulo
Which is the best
Castrol. It keep the integrity and the color
Final verdict.
Motule sucks.....
friction test pleaseee again
Lal ghoda is best
Soo??????
No way Castrol is better than Motul ...
Already done a test with the putoline N tech pro+ 10w40?
Im 7100
Assistindo em agosto de 2021
can i use motul 7100-20w-50 synthetic, i own pulsar 150 (72 k+) never flushed ever, plz suggest.
What do you mean by the term "flush"?If you want to use an additive to,supposedly,"clean" the engine before changing the oil i strongly suggest you to NOT,repeat,NOT do it. Parts of the additive will REMAIN inside the engine and will seriously degrade the new oil performance and thus,the engine protection.DON'T DO THIS mate,you might ruin the engine.
Use 10w50 motul 5100/7100,Or u will loose mileage and power
En resumen quien gano banda ayuda ??
Castrol plebe
Just 3 passes from 20C to 250C. You need more than only 3 cycles to thermal stress the oil. Thats equivalent as 3 runs use of your car (on the ring pack area, where the oil really gets to 250C+ once you shut it down, but way more time than a few seconds, since the pistons and rings masses are greater than the oil around ring pack itself, taking longer to cool off.
Winner castrol?
yep
Yes
Castrool
🇨🇱!🖐👍
Hola para una pulsar 200 que aceite me recomiendas!.
Castrol , muy buen aceite Bro
Very nice work.
Hi, test me Castrol vs Mobile 1
Gana Castrol. El Mobil en mi motocicleta se evapora mucho más rápido
Motul is actually a lame oil. People are simply after the name.
Actually motul 7100 is better. It heats up quickly for better cold start and cools too. U must check the friction test on this channel. It did the best among all the oils this guy has tested so far. Although castrol has released new power 1 ultimate oil yesterday. So im waiting for him to test it too. Although i hav used motul, Castrol and liqui moly on my dominar and RS200. Castrol power 1 was the worst. It didn't even last 5000kms. While motul crossed 8000kms with rough use. Although its not fair to compare liqui moly as its twice the price of both this oils. But motul is best. Just try it out yourself. Or go for 300v2. As i am using on my dominar. Best oil i have tried till this day and clocked 3600kms with this oil. Butter smooth riding experience ❤
Motul is seriously overhyped oil. 7100 gives best gear shifts but oil is not good. We can't rate oil only for gearshifts. I used shell Advance Ultra which was by far better than Motul 7100 in same price range.
Issues with 7100 - heats up quickly and engine sounds harsh everytime I use 7100.
Even Shell AX7 semi synthetic oil gives better fuel economy and not harsh like 7100.
Beware of the fanboys.
Next time Castrol Power 1 Ultimate.
For cold starts also Castrol is better as per his tests.
th-cam.com/video/kBg-hpz_-TQ/w-d-xo.html
@@dcfancomics1314 Just because the oil doesn't change colour , it doesn't mean its good for the engine. I recently changed my bikes factory oil to 7100 , and now regret doing so. Its one noisy mess.
@@SuperSaiyan-1000 Castrol power 1 series did the worst job when it comes to reliability. It takes more time than motul to warm up. And the oil which u are seeing in this video is fully synthetic power 1 racing. Which costs 744 on flipkart and it doesn't even come with a pipe in india as shown in this video. Castrol power1 racing did an ultimate job for my pulsar rs200. But didn't last well enough like 300v 15w50 which cost extra 200rs. I will be trying the new Castrol power1 ultimate 20w50 on my RS200 after 2 months. As i changed my engine oil with motul 300v2 in dec.
🇸🇮🇸🇰
Try Amsoil 20w50 v-twin or any of their 4T
Can someone please explain better, Which oil is better cause I´ve always used motul
Well it looks like the Motul starts to bubble at a lower temperature, so maybe in an air cooled engine which can get very hot the Edge is a bit better. The Motul is still good though, better than the average oils. The Edge is slightly better for wear too so maybe it is just a bit better all round (you can see the wear tests in the spreadsheet link in the title). Not sure if it makes a big difference in the real world in an engine vs in a lab test.
Motul 7100 is better!
Motul is best .
Which one is better? I need the answer please.
In this test - Castrol. Please, Read description below.
@@PiotrTester Thanks 😊
@@PiotrTester ty
👏👏👏👏
Never use Castrol 4t oil in Suzuki Gsxr 1000 k4! Almost destroyed my bike, under 600 km ride.....
Which one is the bottom one?
Castrol
Castrol best one
Motul się zepsuł, to juz nie jest ten sam olej castrola też bym nie zalał. Nie zależnie od testu
Ja się przesiadłem na Liqui Moly
which was better 🤔
El título es motul amigo disculpe
Es mejor que castrol?
@@Adrian-mk8xj ante lo tenía a Castrol como unos de los mejores hasta que un compañero me recomendó motul porque lo habían usado en el dakar entonces vi las comparaciones en frío son iguales pero en 100 grados protege mejor el motul
😎🇧🇷
Motul 7100 10w50 best
Tego się nie spodziewałem po Castrolu
Castrol nie miał szans z Motulem, motul robi najlepsze oleje na świecie xD
@@300grammakipszennej z tego co widzę to Castrol jest lepszy
@@300grammakipszennejdoprawdy? To kisiel.
Pake bahasa Indonesia dong?
Vale y la pregunta del millón cual es mejor de los dos?
Motul 💪🏼
Según veo el Castrol se demora más en llegar al punto de ebullición y por ende entonces aguanta más temperatura.
Motul 7100