He wouldn't have even come back if his friend didn't pass away. No excuse could justify me accepting him back after everything he did and all those years acting like a AH while sleeping around. I'd never let him anywhere close to my daughter even if she's his kid.
Jake is the realest one in this whole movie. He was straight up with Liam and was the only one holding him accountable about the consequences of his actions. Not gaslighting whatsoever
Ikr? Liam literally proved his point by leaving again because he couldn't handle someone being straight with him showing how weak minded he was. Jake should not have felt guilty about it
Jake was an ass and tried to run Liam off. He was new to being a parent and he was scared. Should he have run, probably not. But being a parent can be scary.
@@BlueDauntlesssure, being a parent is scary, tell that to Josie who raised a daughter as a single mom, not to a grown up man who didn't take responsibility over his mistakes
I hate these tropes. Guy abandons the girl and sleeps with everyone. Woman stays single and virtuous and then forgives the one that hurt them. So many "romance" books do this, especially harlequin.
The book this movie was based off of had her in a long term relationship. I want to say 6 years, but I could be wrong. Instead they replaced her boyfriend with her jackass brother-that didn’t exist in the book.
@@BlueDauntless that’s even worse then. Why would she go back to him if she was in a relationship with someone who stepped up? Unless she doesn’t go back to him in the book?
@@littlemisshowei exactly. Like if the guy was loyal, I expect her to be too. But why is it always that they are the ones who are sleeping around even with their true love existing while the woman never gets into a relationship after the guy leaves
@@littlemisshowei he probably changed and she still loved him. And it was hard for her to stay strong and do the smart thing when they were spending Time with their daughter.
My observation is that the movie portrays different society expectations for men and women. For 7 yrs, Liam was flings every nigh with different girls as Josie waited for him and expected her to remain virtuous. That's double standards.
expected her to remain virtuous???? I saw the whole movie. where did he say that??? you want double standards??? no one actually asked him why he ran. he ran because his mother had passed away. and he freaked out.
There’s no reason to think she didn’t date while he was gone - but she also had a newborn baby, so likely didn’t have time the first few years. After that, she might have hooked up with every bachelor in town, for all we know.
Hmm. A crime for deciding you don't want to marry someone? So even if you change your mind, you're forced to marry them or face jail time? Forced marriage is never a good thing. Even if it's horrible to leave someone at the alter, there are many reasons it can happen - like if the marriage was arranged and the only way the marriage could be stopped is at the actual ceremony.
The book was so much better, he wasn't such a jerk, he left when they were in college, not even engaged and he tried to talk to her before he left to pursue his music dreams and she didnt take it seriously and told him just to sleep on it before i dropped out of college and he took that as she wouldnt support him. His managers got Josie's message about the baby and just ignored it, assume she was a crazy fan. He was never that arrogant when he came back home. Josie did move on, not just wait for him, and he had to work a lot harder to earn the right to be a dad and win her back.
I'm not going to front i don't care what a man does after he left me at the alter and couldn't be bothered to call me back for 7 years. He can be a father but he would never be an option for a partner for me. Edit to add: "Not only not be bothered to call her back for 7 years, the only reason he came home was because he happened to notice one of his friends died 🥴 that man is selfish and unstable.
Yeah he chose money and fame and many random women over his ‘love’. Such a guy is not a great father figure either. As a mother, you can choose your partner yes. But your child cannot choose their dad. So, choose wisely. Choose a decent guy for a dad
@truehappiness4U true but at the end of the day every kid deserves the chance to get to know their parent so keeping him away isn't an option the kid is already here. I'd hate to have him as my kids father too but she can't change it and it would be wrong of her to negatively impact their relationship if he's not doing anything wrong involving or impacting his daughter.
@@PhotoJeticPoetno keeping him away is a good option no one want such a jerk or whore man for her own child father and it wouldn't be wrong of her to negatively impact their relationship if his not doing anything wrong involving or impacting his daughter or not it doesn't matter and his daughter my foot to be honest he never deserve to be a any pure soul child father too understand..🙃🙃
@@PhotoJeticPoetno keeping him away is a good option no one want such a jerk or whore man for her own child father and it wouldn't be wrong of her to negatively impact their relationship if his not doing anything wrong involving or impacting his daughter or not it doesn't matter and his daughter my foot to be honest he never deserve to be a any pure soul child father too understand..🙃🙃
@@youratioedurself8830and the boyfriend was a jerk he even didn't know that he had a daughter child too he left her on their wedding day and you said the book was really good wtf never ever actually the book wasn't really good too understand..😅😅
Can't believe she took him back after years of neglect and sleeping with groupies and different women without consideration of their feelings. Well, it is a movie. Kinda like a disney for grown-ups.
The guy left the girl for his career and money. When he came back, he was rich, so everyone accepted him. if he would be poor and homeless, everyone would have said this is result of your own actions and deal with it all alone.
when he came back He was rich so everyone accepted him this seen was most worst seen in this movie but it wouldn't have the reality at least not for me no matter how he was a millionaire understand..😅😅
Liam is a dad, not a father. He walked away from joise on their wedding day, refused to call her back, if he had, then maybe he would have found out about the baby. He had no part in her up upbringing.
I watched this movie years back and the young me didn't see anything wrong with it but definitely not the matured me. Liam is irresponsible no doubt. He's proven to be indecisive and easily swayed. If his manager didn't convince him to go back, he would have left the mother and daughter for the second time. There's nothing admirable about it and there's no excuse to leave a woman on the alter. He wouldn't have proposed if he hasn't healed.
@@meerxr i don't care how smart a kid is, its hardly ever the way it is portrayed in movies. Especially this particular movie. Like the guitar thing? A seven year old barely has the motor skills to write their name, but you're telling me she magically could play the guitar just from seeing someone else do it? Lmao please. I'm not saying kids can't be smart, just that its annoying when it's to an unrealistic degree
@@BlueDauntless yeah I get it, that's part of what annoys me lol. Like yeah of course THEIR kid is just soooo special lol, obviously they're just meant to be 🙄 its so cheesy
I cannot fathom how they forgave him. I get he has his own struggles inwardly but that does not give him the right to hurt the people around him. Just because you now suddenly know the reason behind his actions, doesnt mean you needed to get back together with him. I cant wrap my head around this. Darn it LOL. I got frustrated about this.
@@furqanb7530its not about just money or unfortunately that money would only his responsibility for his daughter but he doesn't deserved any chance again cheater and selfish parson shouldn't be forgiveness understand that ..😅😅
This is so stupid. Jocie is so pathetic that she took him back. He left her for years , cheated on her with multiple of girls, and she took him back? Bro don’t deserve a second chance. The self respect 🙄
Forgiveness doesn't mean you don't have self respect lol you all are just internet minded and doesn't have wide observation of life. It is not self respect if she act pathetic and the one who is begging. She is the one who is being chased not the one who beg and she make it in process before accepting him again, if you watch the movie she is not easy to get, plus Josie is the type of person who have no detatchment issue. I just hate people who have "social media" attitude and narrow observation like you calling a person like Josie is pathetic, if you don't do what she did then good for you but you are not superior to call people like Josie to be pathetic, she have peace of mind what she do then good for her(before you come to this statement read my comment again because like what I said Josie is the type of person who have no detatchment issue in any form of problem not just this type of problem, she knows how to handle herself), plus some type of person like you some not mean you are too but people like you are the one who will give sympathy if the gender switch( proven I have seen I alot, if you disagree then it's confirm you have just have "social media" attitude about observation and have narrow observation)
@@flawtee4150 tf do you mean internet minded? I am talking from experience bc I have been in a toxic relationship where I was cheated on. Do you think I was randomly saying things? I am not the type of person who is easy on people. If people did terrible shit to me in the past, then fck them. I am not an idiot to easily forgives those people. Forgiving is fine but it depends on the situation. That girl was still pathetic. No matter if she didn't chase him, or how hard she played to get, in the end, she still took him back like an idiot. How the hell does she trust him again? Even if gender was reserved, the male would be pathetic if he took her back. And I have seen dramas where a male was an idiot who still wanted his cheating ex and took her back just bc she "changed." My point still stands.
So true. He did not even try to work on her forgiveness. He just tried to be a father but it was still the josie who took the first step for them to get together. Then he left them again. And they still took him back geez
Did a man write this movie? He left his soon to be bride at the altar, didn’t check in for years to see if she’s ok, sleeps around and now he can walk back into her life. If this was real life she would have moved on and not let him back in. Who’s to say he won’t abandon his daughter? In this movie she takes him back twice? He’s a walking red flag.
10:18 no, that’s some genius brain right there. No matter how musically inclined you are, you’re not gonna just pick up a guitar for the first time and play perfectly. They literally said she’s super smart like five times already.
Everyone talks about Liam but no one talks about how the groupie just kept jumping on his phone over and over. Is she numb at the feet? She can't feel the block she's jumping on?
I might have missed it but why did he leave for 7 years on their wedding day? If im Josie I can’t forgive him no matter what as he could do the same thing again - even at the peak of their relationship. 😮 though I understand why she took him back (nostalgia, familiarity, for her daughter)
@Dru Baxter I agree 🥲 it’s so frustrating and saddening… even though the moral of the story is to forgive, this is beyond moral and is unforgivable already…
and she takes him back,end of story, this is how men literally get away with anything and all women do is nag a little he'll do bare minimum grovelling or even no grovelling but yeah as a women forgiveness is given regardless so yeah no matter what a man does he always gets forgiven 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
You can forgive someone but that does NOT mean you take them back.These are two different things. • To forgive is to no longer hold a grudge. You do it for yourself; not for the other person. The benefit is yours, not for others. It is the outcome of healing. • The decision to take them back relates to how you draw your boundaries based on the wisdom you’ve acquired from the experience (w-out healing that wisdom is hard to come by).
As a Christian, I’m just gonna say this- this is a Christian idealist fanfic. I would forgive him (that way, I can move on), but I would NEVER take him back!
it is sad that she must have really really really love him to forget how selfish and disrespectful he was and still is, for her to take him back. He can use excuses of being young and immature, but the way he left just shows that base selfishness and disrespectful nature that I would never tolerate. I f it were me, I would allow him to have a relationship with My kid, for my kids sake. and relationship with me as co-parents. Nothing more or less. I can't find this kind of forgivenss and love to carry on with that kind of man.
Sooo…just because she decided not to sleep around or get in another relationship it’s sexist or shows double standards? MAYBE this is showing a young mom who took life by the horns, decided to be responsible, and take care of herself and her daughter 👏 that’s a strong female character right there
For everyone commenting that she shouldn't have taken him back and that she shouldn't have forgiven him, yall forgot an important detail in the movie. They are christians and Josie had a Daughter for Liam, meaning that she literally had to accept and forgive him, even tho in the deepest part of her heart she didnt, Billy needs a father and in the end Liam ended up being that father and husband figure the family was missing, so if you are christian you know what im talking about.
I would maybe be able to forgive him after many years especially if he is a good father, but I would never be able to trust him with my own heart and my child’s heart.
This is only happens in movies / series all are fantasies I really life no man there is no going back after 8 years. someone left you on your wedding day ......... Iam not saint I can't forgive you ever because there's no forgiveness for some mistakes
Illogical movie!! Yes forgive but still there should be a reality check. Willing suspension of disbelief is better only in fantasy movies! My eyes feels wasted watching this movie.
That dude is the luckiest guy ever he got to get back together with his baby momma and his daughter who he never met instantly accepted him and he never even really said I'm sorry to the baby momma, after leaving her on her wedding day... I mean regardless of some childhood drama yes drama it's trauma until you completely and selfishly destroy some else's life... im a man and this movie was written by and for man an I think it's f*cked up...
Ladies who are complaining that the actor abondoned the actress on their wedding. Did you'll listen very carefully why he was doing that. In the end when he finally gave a reply to thst voice note after 8 years, he said that his mother was his love of his life and then Jose came n when his mother died, he felt that losing Jose would be like losing his mother n also when the actor was drunk after his daughter was saved by Jake, while the father-son duo opened about why father overlooked his son's feelings after his wife died and why son pushed away everyone n thought that fame n money would heal his deep trauma from his childhood but it didn't worked. You ladies can say whatever you have to say about that actors actions but you'll wouldn't go deep into why he's doing that to himself. Sometimes, the trauma caused is way more bigger n huge that a person can never recover from it in his entire lifetime n suffers till his death, though he/she might have everything but it's the trauma that causes them to never heal themselves. Yes, actor slept with everyother girl but his heart was always with Jose n no one else before he found out about his daughter. So, ladies understand that you'll always think from a women's perspective but if you'll ever think from a man's perspective then you'll see how much damage it causes to you mentally, physically n others and vise versa also 🙏
Clicked on this under my recommendations. Reason: because the title of this recap is the same as what Im experiencing now. The difference is that the man I love went MIA because he wanted to focus into his new set dreams and goals. I waited and hoped till he told me he doesnt see my relevance and so I bid him goodbye but he wouldnt let go and why he wouldnt. It was easy at first when he first said that. The following days I was numb then I longed for him. Now he is denying he ever said that I wasnt important in his life. All I ever wanted is him. To some it may be crazy and foolish but I learned to forgive and hold on. Its not because Im caught or used to or scared, its just him for me. I dont know. I can wait even if it takes so much time but I hope its something genuine and real not a one way street as I rather be in the real side even if its not for me or favors me. I can wait but I deserve to know what he thinks and feels
redionbluecat,i think he has already told you how he thinks and feels{your just not hearing it}HE TOLD ME HE DOESNT SEE MY RELEVANCE.there the key words right there.all you are to him is available on he s teams.find YOUR worth girl.
Well he is not bad but he is a coward , Relaing on him is not very inconvenient. But he is a good person by heart so I think that why she took him back 😑😑😑😑
@@kabirsardana1282 l am aware about that but he ran away once again leave them heart broken his daughter who got close to him believing he will not leave, and there is a possibility that he may do it again . Future with him is not stable.
Worst ending ever, how on earths she took him back? And why she decided to have a child is such prick that’s kinda makes it more difficult to find another partner. What a dumb woman, that’s the kind that get dumped in real life just that in real life once dumped unless they kinda remain that way. Why would someone decide to make a movie with such a negative message for woman, “stay by your men, have his kids and raise them without cheating even if he abandoned you on the altar and always have him back them you will complain your mission as a woman in this world”. I bet it was written by a man.
I remember watching this opening weekend at AMC Theaters! I was going through one of the worst heartbreaks of my life. This movie helped me through it and deserves our we watch every now and again 💙👊😎
No thank you. Guy leaves her before wedding for 8 years, director of this movie must have no respect for themselves if they think forgiveness is justifiable
Ewwww he's so ran through. This movie sends such a BAD message for women. Imagine being left at the altar HUMILIATED and preganant and your self absorbed bf is too busy being famous to even check his messages or check on the people he left behind. And he gets to come back to what's familiar to him after meaningless nights with groupies because he wants to finally settle down after being a wh*ore and drugging up the roxkstar life? Nah he's ran through. If anything Josie should be INSULTED that Liam feels like he could just come back to her anytime since she's not going anywhere and it's convenient for him.
I usually like watching recaps or summarized version of movies. But this movie deserves to be watched and not summarized so that we can understand it more..wonderful dialogues, story of forgiveness, second chances. I recommend everyone to watch the whole movie...
You know what even if they got together after all that fiasco is that man doesn't change still it's meaningless it's just gonna be another messy child custody battle😒
This I thought was just an ordinary so typical chick flix movie. But this movie made me cry a river since the beginning of the film. Actors were so into their characters which made me them so natural. They would really make you feel that you are part of their film. I seldom make comments only to those who trully deserves it and this is highly recommended ❤❤❤
I FIND IT DISGUSTING.....how every single time the one who loves the most has to suffer irrespective if the gender .......i genuinely am so sure that' no matter what you will never be liked bye someone the way you like them ......AND THE TRUE LOVE EXIST BUT is not meant for all..............
Wow, so many perfect women here, free from any mistakes or immaturity. They must think they're God, apparently, since they're perfect and cannot admit to a single mistake. Liam was a jerk, but he was young and still grieving. What he did was awful, but the book the movie is based on, and the movie itself, is absolutely beautiful. It's sweet how Liam matures and gradually falls in love with his daughter. The only 'unforgivable' thing for me was Josie hiding their child out of spite, but even then, they both grow up together throughout the story. This book is just soo wonderful, one of my all-time favorites!
He came back, stayed, and loved them. My daddy issues had me crying at that last scene of them playing guitar on stage. I have inherited both environmentally and genetically the creativity from both my fathers yet my dad doesn't make time for me even on father's day. Instead of going out, he prefers I order him the food and he stays to himself. My mom asks him to invite me on their outtings and etc, he doesnt. My bio dad lives in another country and isn't mature enough to be a father. I see people saying they wouldn't take him back, but even though it's a fictional character, I'm happy for the little girl as having a dad who loves you and wants to be around you makes a great difference not only in the mental, but also in future relationships. She'l know her worth💗
No i dont need this type of dady and he never loved them he never known that news that he had a daughter if he wasn't come back to the country the girl surely will hate her father when she would mature 18 age and will known everything what he did with her mother that time she will understanding her father never loves her too understanding that...😅😅
He literally could of relocated his wedding. Perform his song and then do his wedding in front of the world. The fees would have been easily covered. This guy just went on his own cause a crazy lottery ticket of his talent. Dude didnt think
Couldn't she just heal and move on after 8 years?! Good grief!! Of all the things going wrong in this flawed created world..... it just wasn't a relationship that was meant to be.
Why can't we have a normal, average little kid in movies anymore? Why must they be smarter, wiser, more mature than any other child in town? Predictable and boring.
They are meant for each other. There is always a chance to go back and fix life. If it didn't turned out how you wanted it to be, accept it and move on.
That kind of man is not worth it… he only comes back bc it makes him feel better for himself and its easier now. When it comes down to hard times , he will choose himself again and leave . Toxic. Stop romanticising this kind of man / relationship.
I wouldn’t accept a guy who left me at the altar and then just slept around.
This movie has some religious undertones so it makes sense
Because you have slept with clubs guys daily 😎
@@21Lauren21 If you mean forgiveness, than yes. Lots of forgiveness, and redemption, was in the movie.
I wouldn’t either but if he comes back because of its child .. thn it’s about the kid 🤷♀️
He wouldn't have even come back if his friend didn't pass away. No excuse could justify me accepting him back after everything he did and all those years acting like a AH while sleeping around. I'd never let him anywhere close to my daughter even if she's his kid.
I would never take him back ... my heart is not designed for that kind of forgiveness
saaaaame
Same. Some things shouldn't ever be forgiven. They're examples of the persons true nature.
With my own strength I could never but with the help from God i would forgive but I'm not gonna take him back nooooo
It's just a movie 🤣 never put heartbreak in your heart rather in your lungs
Same!
Jake is the realest one in this whole movie. He was straight up with Liam and was the only one holding him accountable about the consequences of his actions. Not gaslighting whatsoever
Ikr? Liam literally proved his point by leaving again because he couldn't handle someone being straight with him showing how weak minded he was.
Jake should not have felt guilty about it
Jake was an ass and tried to run Liam off. He was new to being a parent and he was scared. Should he have run, probably not. But being a parent can be scary.
Well men hold other men accountable if they are in wrong in real life too we don't don't tell them they are right like women do.
@@mohit6657 well that is a massively over generalisation of humans.
There is no one size fits all situations and relationships.
@@BlueDauntlesssure, being a parent is scary, tell that to Josie who raised a daughter as a single mom, not to a grown up man who didn't take responsibility over his mistakes
I hate these tropes. Guy abandons the girl and sleeps with everyone. Woman stays single and virtuous and then forgives the one that hurt them. So many "romance" books do this, especially harlequin.
The book this movie was based off of had her in a long term relationship. I want to say 6 years, but I could be wrong. Instead they replaced her boyfriend with her jackass brother-that didn’t exist in the book.
@@BlueDauntless that’s even worse then. Why would she go back to him if she was in a relationship with someone who stepped up?
Unless she doesn’t go back to him in the book?
@@littlemisshowei exactly. Like if the guy was loyal, I expect her to be too. But why is it always that they are the ones who are sleeping around even with their true love existing while the woman never gets into a relationship after the guy leaves
@@littlemisshowei he probably changed and she still loved him. And it was hard for her to stay strong and do the smart thing when they were spending Time with their daughter.
Its brainwash
My observation is that the movie portrays different society expectations for men and women. For 7 yrs, Liam was flings every nigh with different girls as Josie waited for him and expected her to remain virtuous. That's double standards.
expected her to remain virtuous???? I saw the whole movie. where did he say that???
you want double standards??? no one actually asked him why he ran. he ran because his mother had passed away. and he freaked out.
There’s no reason to think she didn’t date while he was gone - but she also had a newborn baby, so likely didn’t have time the first few years. After that, she might have hooked up with every bachelor in town, for all we know.
Facts
@@kabirsardana1282 oh dear running out on your wedding is a shitty thing to do unless the bride deserves it!
No one expected her to remain virtuous. They were broken up
Ghosting your partner in the altar is actually considered a crime in our country because it's considered an emotional and psychological abuse.
Good!!! As it should be!
Which country please?
What's your country,I'd love to be there
Sam A10: Which country are you from?
Hmm. A crime for deciding you don't want to marry someone? So even if you change your mind, you're forced to marry them or face jail time? Forced marriage is never a good thing. Even if it's horrible to leave someone at the alter, there are many reasons it can happen - like if the marriage was arranged and the only way the marriage could be stopped is at the actual ceremony.
The book was so much better, he wasn't such a jerk, he left when they were in college, not even engaged and he tried to talk to her before he left to pursue his music dreams and she didnt take it seriously and told him just to sleep on it before i dropped out of college and he took that as she wouldnt support him. His managers got Josie's message about the baby and just ignored it, assume she was a crazy fan. He was never that arrogant when he came back home. Josie did move on, not just wait for him, and he had to work a lot harder to earn the right to be a dad and win her back.
Thanks for the summary......the book sounds so much better.... i will definitely give the book a chance.
That is so much better. This movie is nauseating!
Is the book the same title?
@okungbowaadesuwa7363 yes, there's also 2 sequels for his band mates
@@naowright9308no this movie is better than the book..😅😅
I'm not going to front i don't care what a man does after he left me at the alter and couldn't be bothered to call me back for 7 years. He can be a father but he would never be an option for a partner for me.
Edit to add:
"Not only not be bothered to call her back for 7 years, the only reason he came home was because he happened to notice one of his friends died 🥴 that man is selfish and unstable.
Yeah he chose money and fame and many random women over his ‘love’. Such a guy is not a great father figure either. As a mother, you can choose your partner yes. But your child cannot choose their dad. So, choose wisely. Choose a decent guy for a dad
@truehappiness4U true but at the end of the day every kid deserves the chance to get to know their parent so keeping him away isn't an option the kid is already here.
I'd hate to have him as my kids father too but she can't change it and it would be wrong of her to negatively impact their relationship if he's not doing anything wrong involving or impacting his daughter.
@@PhotoJeticPoetno keeping him away is a good option no one want such a jerk or whore man for her own child father and it wouldn't be wrong of her to negatively impact their relationship if his not doing anything wrong involving or impacting his daughter or not it doesn't matter and his daughter my foot to be honest he never deserve to be a any pure soul child father too understand..🙃🙃
@@PhotoJeticPoetno keeping him away is a good option no one want such a jerk or whore man for her own child father and it wouldn't be wrong of her to negatively impact their relationship if his not doing anything wrong involving or impacting his daughter or not it doesn't matter and his daughter my foot to be honest he never deserve to be a any pure soul child father too understand..🙃🙃
The audacity of this man. This has Wattpad vibes all through it.
It’s actually ases of a book. And the book is a great read. Better than anything you’d find on Wattpad
the book was really good actually
theres no brother in the book rather there is a boyfriend who actually raised her child along with her
You can expect nothing less from Nicholas Sparks
@@youratioedurself8830and the boyfriend was a jerk he even didn't know that he had a daughter child too he left her on their wedding day and you said the book was really good wtf never ever actually the book wasn't really good too understand..😅😅
Can't believe she took him back after years of neglect and sleeping with groupies and different women without consideration of their feelings. Well, it is a movie. Kinda like a disney for grown-ups.
I'm wondering what kind of veneral diseases he brings to this marriages after sleeping with all the groupies. Disgusting.
Grow ups my foot it was bad movie i dont want that man and love understand..😅😅
Couldn't find any justifiable reason for her to take him back
They have a daughter and more important she still have feelings for him.
Why on Earth would she take him back?
must be true love -not deserved
The little kid bonds them together. They realized soulmates are ment to be together.
Probably because she was still inlove wirh him, love meant is love that Will never die
she take him back simply bcoz their breakup is not about 3rd-party.. its easy to get back and giving 2nd chances if the breakup is not cheating..
Bcs he is rich
The guy abandons her twice. Sorry, I wouldn't have given him the chance at making it 3.
The guy left the girl for his career and money. When he came back, he was rich, so everyone accepted him. if he would be poor and homeless, everyone would have said this is result of your own actions and deal with it all alone.
Winners are always forgiven
@@ailicrewnope..😅😅
when he came back He was rich so everyone accepted him this seen was most worst seen in this movie but it wouldn't have the reality at least not for me no matter how he was a millionaire understand..😅😅
@@ailicrewthis type of winners always will be a coward not forgiven for me understand..😅😅
@@ailicrewlol..😅😅
Liam is a dad, not a father. He walked away from joise on their wedding day, refused to call her back, if he had, then maybe he would have found out about the baby. He had no part in her up upbringing.
he's definitely not a daddy
Liam isn't a dad even not a father to never ever..😅😅
I watched this movie years back and the young me didn't see anything wrong with it but definitely not the matured me. Liam is irresponsible no doubt. He's proven to be indecisive and easily swayed. If his manager didn't convince him to go back, he would have left the mother and daughter for the second time. There's nothing admirable about it and there's no excuse to leave a woman on the alter. He wouldn't have proposed if he hasn't healed.
at the end of it -my mind went ( he saw a meal ticket in his daughter.) and Josie sat there gullible on the sidelines.
can you please tell me the name of the movie
@@shubhangijha7029
I think it is,
Forever my girl
@@trinibellyhe was a such a jerk guy yuck..😅😅
@@trinibellyhis daughter my foot he never deserved to be a father too...😅😅
WOW she forget what he did to her really fast I mean 🤦🏻♀️
Poor her
Exactly like a promos was all it took to forget 7 years of complete abandonment? Wild.
She was ready for that date..she’s dumb
@@PhotoJeticPoetit was a very worst movie..😅😅
@@PhotoJeticPoethe was a jerk and what you mean by that comment..😅😅
i hate when they make kids so unrealistically smart and sassy in movies. If she's actually supposed to be 7 then write her that way.
Sometimes kids really do know what's going on. They hear and see more than adults think or want to know.
Tell us you haven’t met smart kids without telling us you haven’t met smart kids lol
@@meerxr i don't care how smart a kid is, its hardly ever the way it is portrayed in movies. Especially this particular movie. Like the guitar thing? A seven year old barely has the motor skills to write their name, but you're telling me she magically could play the guitar just from seeing someone else do it? Lmao please. I'm not saying kids can't be smart, just that its annoying when it's to an unrealistic degree
@@jasminem812 I think they were trying to portray her as a prodigy, like August Rush
@@BlueDauntless yeah I get it, that's part of what annoys me lol. Like yeah of course THEIR kid is just soooo special lol, obviously they're just meant to be 🙄 its so cheesy
Don’t trust him. He’s proven who he is too many times.
I cannot fathom how they forgave him. I get he has his own struggles inwardly but that does not give him the right to hurt the people around him. Just because you now suddenly know the reason behind his actions, doesnt mean you needed to get back together with him. I cant wrap my head around this. Darn it LOL. I got frustrated about this.
She shouldn't have taken him back. He lost his chance years ago. Maybe let him see the kid once he pays back child support.
Yes.
So It's all about the money in the end, isn't it!?
@@furqanb7530its not about just money or unfortunately that money would only his responsibility for his daughter but he doesn't deserved any chance again cheater and selfish parson shouldn't be forgiveness understand that ..😅😅
he doesn't deserve her, girl stand up you can do better
This is so stupid. Jocie is so pathetic that she took him back. He left her for years , cheated on her with multiple of girls, and she took him back? Bro don’t deserve a second chance. The self respect 🙄
Forgiveness doesn't mean you don't have self respect lol you all are just internet minded and doesn't have wide observation of life. It is not self respect if she act pathetic and the one who is begging. She is the one who is being chased not the one who beg and she make it in process before accepting him again, if you watch the movie she is not easy to get, plus Josie is the type of person who have no detatchment issue. I just hate people who have "social media" attitude and narrow observation like you calling a person like Josie is pathetic, if you don't do what she did then good for you but you are not superior to call people like Josie to be pathetic, she have peace of mind what she do then good for her(before you come to this statement read my comment again because like what I said Josie is the type of person who have no detatchment issue in any form of problem not just this type of problem, she knows how to handle herself), plus some type of person like you some not mean you are too but people like you are the one who will give sympathy if the gender switch( proven I have seen I alot, if you disagree then it's confirm you have just have "social media" attitude about observation and have narrow observation)
@@flawtee4150 tf do you mean internet minded? I am talking from experience bc I have been in a toxic relationship where I was cheated on. Do you think I was randomly saying things? I am not the type of person who is easy on people. If people did terrible shit to me in the past, then fck them. I am not an idiot to easily forgives those people. Forgiving is fine but it depends on the situation. That girl was still pathetic. No matter if she didn't chase him, or how hard she played to get, in the end, she still took him back like an idiot. How the hell does she trust him again? Even if gender was reserved, the male would be pathetic if he took her back. And I have seen dramas where a male was an idiot who still wanted his cheating ex and took her back just bc she "changed." My point still stands.
Fr. They should have just co-parented.
@@AGolfHitter exactly, that's a thing too in the real world. But ofc it's a movie so it's going to be unrealistic
So true. He did not even try to work on her forgiveness. He just tried to be a father but it was still the josie who took the first step for them to get together. Then he left them again. And they still took him back geez
His reason for leaving was so dumb and the fact that she took him back 🙁 this movie was so bad...
Did a man write this movie? He left his soon to be bride at the altar, didn’t check in for years to see if she’s ok, sleeps around and now he can walk back into her life. If this was real life she would have moved on and not let him back in. Who’s to say he won’t abandon his daughter? In this movie she takes him back twice? He’s a walking red flag.
💯💯
Took him back?? Really?
I would neveeeeeer accept someone who humiliated me.
10:18 no, that’s some genius brain right there. No matter how musically inclined you are, you’re not gonna just pick up a guitar for the first time and play perfectly. They literally said she’s super smart like five times already.
Everyone talks about Liam but no one talks about how the groupie just kept jumping on his phone over and over. Is she numb at the feet? She can't feel the block she's jumping on?
probably the drugs
What means??..🙂🙃
@@nunegonoze6087no matter and what drugs??🙃🙃
I might have missed it but why did he leave for 7 years on their wedding day? If im Josie I can’t forgive him no matter what as he could do the same thing again - even at the peak of their relationship. 😮 though I understand why she took him back (nostalgia, familiarity, for her daughter)
He left because he was scared. It was explained at the later part of the recap
@@mdp020 onces a goner always a goner
@Dru Baxter I agree 🥲 it’s so frustrating and saddening… even though the moral of the story is to forgive, this is beyond moral and is unforgivable already…
@@drubaxter2514lol
@@mdp020wtf he was scared my foot he never deserve another chance from anyone..🙃🙃
WTF! This is one real messed up movie.
Also the girl has no self-respect
and she takes him back,end of story, this is how men literally get away with anything and all women do is nag a little he'll do bare minimum grovelling or even no grovelling but yeah as a women forgiveness is given regardless so yeah no matter what a man does he always gets forgiven 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
It’s… a movie
You can forgive someone but that does NOT mean you take them back.These are two different things.
• To forgive is to no longer hold a grudge. You do it for yourself; not for the other person. The benefit is yours, not for others. It is the outcome of healing.
• The decision to take them back relates to how you draw your boundaries based on the wisdom you’ve acquired from the experience (w-out healing that wisdom is hard to come by).
@@aweoak7763no he shouldn't be forgiveness he was a selfish jerk or whore man too..😅😅
@@aweoak7763benefit would also other person too..😅😅
As a Christian, I’m just gonna say this- this is a Christian idealist fanfic. I would forgive him (that way, I can move on), but I would NEVER take him back!
If it was me this dude will never dare to step foot in the town ever again.
it is sad that she must have really really really love him to forget how selfish and disrespectful he was and still is, for her to take him back.
He can use excuses of being young and immature, but the way he left just shows that base selfishness and disrespectful nature that I would never tolerate.
I f it were me, I would allow him to have a relationship with My kid, for my kids sake. and relationship with me as co-parents. Nothing more or less.
I can't find this kind of forgivenss and love to carry on with that kind of man.
This isn’t love story but how to make dead beat dad trying to be daddy lol
Sooo…just because she decided not to sleep around or get in another relationship it’s sexist or shows double standards? MAYBE this is showing a young mom who took life by the horns, decided to be responsible, and take care of herself and her daughter 👏 that’s a strong female character right there
Different perspectives. I can definitely see both. 🤷🏽♀️
Yup
she was strong until she took him back after he left her twice
@@xIQGamingnot both too ok..😅😅
@@chaosspy6723r8..😅😅
He left twice!??????! 😅 Sheesh that’s tough..
I wouldn't have married him. Girl, he left you twice.
She's not setting a good example for the kid lol
@@AGolfHitterhe is not setting a good example for the kids he never deserve any another chance from anyone too lol..🙂🙃
@@erikkartz2406 they're both garbage parents. She needs to pick better men.
For everyone commenting that she shouldn't have taken him back and that she shouldn't have forgiven him, yall forgot an important detail in the movie. They are christians and Josie had a Daughter for Liam, meaning that she literally had to accept and forgive him, even tho in the deepest part of her heart she didnt, Billy needs a father and in the end Liam ended up being that father and husband figure the family was missing, so if you are christian you know what im talking about.
The surprise thing is I'm still watching until the end 😂😂😂😂
I would maybe be able to forgive him after many years especially if he is a good father, but I would never be able to trust him with my own heart and my child’s heart.
This is only happens in movies / series all are fantasies
I really life no man there is no going back after 8 years.
someone left you on your wedding day .........
Iam not saint I can't forgive you ever because there's no forgiveness for some mistakes
All that fun with other women in that decade oh no I couldn’t take him back
forgiveness should not result in eating the cake and having it. It just a very bad precedent for society.
Illogical movie!! Yes forgive but still there should be a reality check. Willing suspension of disbelief is better only in fantasy movies! My eyes feels wasted watching this movie.
That dude is the luckiest guy ever he got to get back together with his baby momma and his daughter who he never met instantly accepted him and he never even really said I'm sorry to the baby momma, after leaving her on her wedding day... I mean regardless of some childhood drama yes drama it's trauma until you completely and selfishly destroy some else's life... im a man and this movie was written by and for man an I think it's f*cked up...
may be This movie was written by men..😅😅
Can never be me😂after what he did???
Leave whenever he pleases came back to stake his claim whenever he pleases.
I don't care how rich or famous you get after you dumped me... I hear its lonely at the top. 😉
Lonely lonely lonely
Ladies who are complaining that the actor abondoned the actress on their wedding. Did you'll listen very carefully why he was doing that. In the end when he finally gave a reply to thst voice note after 8 years, he said that his mother was his love of his life and then Jose came n when his mother died, he felt that losing Jose would be like losing his mother n also when the actor was drunk after his daughter was saved by Jake, while the father-son duo opened about why father overlooked his son's feelings after his wife died and why son pushed away everyone n thought that fame n money would heal his deep trauma from his childhood but it didn't worked. You ladies can say whatever you have to say about that actors actions but you'll wouldn't go deep into why he's doing that to himself. Sometimes, the trauma caused is way more bigger n huge that a person can never recover from it in his entire lifetime n suffers till his death, though he/she might have everything but it's the trauma that causes them to never heal themselves. Yes, actor slept with everyother girl but his heart was always with Jose n no one else before he found out about his daughter. So, ladies understand that you'll always think from a women's perspective but if you'll ever think from a man's perspective then you'll see how much damage it causes to you mentally, physically n others and vise versa also 🙏
The most important thing was that Josie and Billy were happy
I loved this movie. The book, while very different, was really good too.
wow..money talks...i would have never take him back
It not money talks ok it not matter about only money ok..🙃🙃
Clicked on this under my recommendations. Reason: because the title of this recap is the same as what Im experiencing now. The difference is that the man I love went MIA because he wanted to focus into his new set dreams and goals. I waited and hoped till he told me he doesnt see my relevance and so I bid him goodbye but he wouldnt let go and why he wouldnt. It was easy at first when he first said that. The following days I was numb then I longed for him. Now he is denying he ever said that I wasnt important in his life. All I ever wanted is him. To some it may be crazy and foolish but I learned to forgive and hold on. Its not because Im caught or used to or scared, its just him for me. I dont know. I can wait even if it takes so much time but I hope its something genuine and real not a one way street as I rather be in the real side even if its not for me or favors me. I can wait but I deserve to know what he thinks and feels
redionbluecat,i think he has already told you how he thinks and feels{your just not hearing it}HE TOLD ME HE DOESNT SEE MY RELEVANCE.there the key words right there.all you are to him is available on he s teams.find YOUR worth girl.
Please, please move on! This man is not worthy of your heart. Do not waste anymore of your precious, finite life. Take your lesson. God sent me. ♥️
He would never see your relevance but he'd come back because he knows you're always going to be waiting for him. Have some self respect and move on
Well he is not bad but he is a coward , Relaing on him is not very inconvenient. But he is a good person by heart so I think that why she took him back 😑😑😑😑
you do realise his mother had died and he freaked out???
women also do this a lot of times. runaway bride??? ring a bell???
@@kabirsardana1282 l am aware about that but he ran away once again leave them heart broken his daughter who got close to him believing he will not leave, and there is a possibility that he may do it again . Future with him is not stable.
@@kabirsardana1282 except he fuckin ghosted her and let her suffer having their daughter and then he had the audacity to come back? 🤡🤡🤡
Who likes this kind of plot? This guy is not a good guy and yet the girl just accepts him back?
Worst ending ever, how on earths she took him back? And why she decided to have a child is such prick that’s kinda makes it more difficult to find another partner. What a dumb woman, that’s the kind that get dumped in real life just that in real life once dumped unless they kinda remain that way. Why would someone decide to make a movie with such a negative message for woman, “stay by your men, have his kids and raise them without cheating even if he abandoned you on the altar and always have him back them you will complain your mission as a woman in this world”.
I bet it was written by a man.
True love forgives.. in the end they are one big family.. beautiful selfless love❤
No some time true love wouldn't forgives even shouldn't forgives too understand..😅😅
I remember watching this opening weekend at AMC Theaters! I was going through one of the worst heartbreaks of my life. This movie helped me through it and deserves our we watch every now and again 💙👊😎
One of my favorite movies!
I'm surprised ny the comments. People really dont understand how forgiveness works.
No thank you. Guy leaves her before wedding for 8 years, director of this movie must have no respect for themselves if they think forgiveness is justifiable
You're proving my point. Forgiveness isn't earned it's given.
Ewwww he's so ran through.
This movie sends such a BAD message for women. Imagine being left at the altar HUMILIATED and preganant and your self absorbed bf is too busy being famous to even check his messages or check on the people he left behind.
And he gets to come back to what's familiar to him after meaningless nights with groupies because he wants to finally settle down after being a wh*ore and drugging up the roxkstar life? Nah he's ran through.
If anything Josie should be INSULTED that Liam feels like he could just come back to her anytime since she's not going anywhere and it's convenient for him.
Nope. He could go back to his fame and fortune, and sleeping around. I'm not God, I could never forgive him.
Not everyone deserves a second chance, when that person decides to leave you or ghost you, never take him/ her back whatever his/her reason.....
Holywood romance movies are always like fairytales, forgetting that its should be more realistic.
This a cringey ass movie and it paints a bad image about forgiveness and it's problematic and should not be encouraged
this mother & daughter are so beautiful
So he left her twice and the second time he not only left her but their daughter too, oh he'll no!
I usually like watching recaps or summarized version of movies. But this movie deserves to be watched and not summarized so that we can understand it more..wonderful dialogues, story of forgiveness, second chances. I recommend everyone to watch the whole movie...
No three wouldn't wouldn't be no able to forgiveness and second chance after what he did to her ok..🙃🙃😐
Forever still exists ♥️♥️💕
I'm glad they finally got together 😊
Why didn't she sue him for not showing up to the wedding?
You know what even if they got together after all that fiasco is that man doesn't change still it's meaningless it's just gonna be another messy child custody battle😒
This men doesn't deserve any chance..😅😅
This I thought was just an ordinary so typical chick flix movie. But this movie made me cry a river since the beginning of the film. Actors were so into their characters which made me them so natural. They would really make you feel that you are part of their film. I seldom make comments only to those who trully deserves it and this is highly recommended ❤❤❤
This is the reason why subscribed to N recaps
I FIND IT DISGUSTING.....how every single time the one who loves the most has to suffer irrespective if the gender .......i genuinely am so sure that' no matter what you will never be liked bye someone the way you like them ......AND THE TRUE LOVE EXIST BUT is not meant for all..............
This movie is inrealistic. No woman would ever take a man that's been ran through and left her humilated in the altar.
Song tracks in this movie is 🔥🔥🔥🔥...❤❤❤
Wow, so many perfect women here, free from any mistakes or immaturity. They must think they're God, apparently, since they're perfect and cannot admit to a single mistake. Liam was a jerk, but he was young and still grieving. What he did was awful, but the book the movie is based on, and the movie itself, is absolutely beautiful. It's sweet how Liam matures and gradually falls in love with his daughter. The only 'unforgivable' thing for me was Josie hiding their child out of spite, but even then, they both grow up together throughout the story. This book is just soo wonderful, one of my all-time favorites!
He is a disgrace for mankind and fatherhood.
This is a horrible story, shes in for a lifetime of pain with a man like that.
Thank you so much, I have searched for this movie like crazy but this helped me a lot 🇿🇦
He came back, stayed, and loved them. My daddy issues had me crying at that last scene of them playing guitar on stage. I have inherited both environmentally and genetically the creativity from both my fathers yet my dad doesn't make time for me even on father's day. Instead of going out, he prefers I order him the food and he stays to himself. My mom asks him to invite me on their outtings and etc, he doesnt. My bio dad lives in another country and isn't mature enough to be a father. I see people saying they wouldn't take him back, but even though it's a fictional character, I'm happy for the little girl as having a dad who loves you and wants to be around you makes a great difference not only in the mental, but also in future relationships. She'l know her worth💗
No i dont need this type of dady and he never loved them he never known that news that he had a daughter if he wasn't come back to the country the girl surely will hate her father when she would mature 18 age and will known everything what he did with her mother that time she will understanding her father never loves her too understanding that...😅😅
I just speedwatched a Hallmark movie 🤣🤣😆😆
He literally could of relocated his wedding. Perform his song and then do his wedding in front of the world. The fees would have been easily covered. This guy just went on his own cause a crazy lottery ticket of his talent. Dude didnt think
Why can’t they put the title of the movie in the description box?
The stories of
Many single mothers… good part some father actually come back
Yo have a relationship with their child 🤷♀️
I would call him stupid
Couldn't she just heal and move on after 8 years?! Good grief!! Of all the things going wrong in this flawed created world..... it just wasn't a relationship that was meant to be.
They are pissed in these comments 😂😂😂😂
nothing but bashing people comments. not a society i want to be part of.
You all crazy he had all options and he still choose her , do you know how many man have option ?? It's had to be a man 😂😂
Someone in the comments really said that this movie helped them with their relationship 😬
Why can't we have a normal, average little kid in movies anymore? Why must they be smarter, wiser, more mature than any other child in town? Predictable and boring.
Such type of forgiveness is done and expected of women only.
You realize there are other books and movies where this sort of thing happens to men, tons of them haha..
Sounds like the twin flame journey ❤ not always pretty … if there’s healing you can come back together
Who wrote this stuff? Did they found this story on wattpad and thought it would be great movie?
They are meant for each other. There is always a chance to go back and fix life. If it didn't turned out how you wanted it to be, accept it and move on.
That kind of man is not worth it… he only comes back bc it makes him feel better for himself and its easier now. When it comes down to hard times , he will choose himself again and leave . Toxic. Stop romanticising this kind of man / relationship.
I would forgive him for my own peace, but I would never ever take that dude back.