'Nobody Protected Us': Russian Civilians In Sudzha Angry, Unsure Of Their Future | Ukraine Incursion
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ย. 2024
- Ukrainian forces launched an incursion into Russia’s Kursk region in early August, capturing the town of Sudzha. This offensive, the largest on Russian soil since World War II, has left Russian civilians in Sudzha reacting with anger and uncertainty. Many feel abandoned by their government and have requested evacuation to Ukrainian-controlled territory.
Ukrainian troops have been supplying food, water, and medicine to the local population, who report being treated well by Ukrainian forces. Soldiers have also shown locals images of destroyed Ukrainian cities, aiming to highlight the consequences of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine. Meanwhile, Sudzha remains under threat, with regular shelling from Russian forces.
#ukrainewar #ukrainenews #ukrainerussiawar #kursk #rferl #russianews
![Counteroffensive operation of Azov recon. Mission to liberate the forests of Luhansk region [+ENG]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A03NSa-zJYU/mqdefault.jpg)
Considering vlad doesn't value the lives of his own troops, the lack of concern for civilians should shock no one.
That will cost Putin dearly in the long run. The people in Kursk region will now find out what Putin's death squads have done in Ukraine then realise how generously they've been treated by the Ukrainian troops.
Perhaps the Kursk, Belgorod, Bryansk, and Voronezh oblasts might end up becoming part of a singular “buffer state” established on Russian soil by Ukraine as a means to keep Ukrainian cities away from enemy fire. Also, if Rostov Oblast ends up in Ukraine’s established buffer zone, Russia’s hold over southern and eastern Ukraine (including Crimea) would be outright doomed.
@@roberthoyt7921 не несите чушь. Какая буферная зона. О чем вы вообще? Все украинские войска которые вторглись на территорию России будут уничтожены и позорно изгнаны. Оставьте свои фантазии при себе и сходите к психиатору. За одно свои лживые СМИ с собой возьмите
@@Tony777-o1xWith luck you’ll be conscripted and can learn for yourself, I think you’re probably too conditioned and beaten to understand otherwise.
@@Tony777-o1x пол месяца прошло. Можешь конкретные даты, когда они будут изгнаны? Через три дня?
Imagine being treated better by an occupying force then your own government. That as got to change some minds, right?
That is what we call "Liberation" in the civilized parts of the world (outside russia).
As Russians they are imprinted at birth to submit to authority. If the Ukrainians are less cruel than their own government so much the better.
I think it will, but in the end these people will have to go back to being Russian serfs, unless they organise for a change.
You can imagine whatever, depends on your imagination skills but thats not true 😅🤷🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
@@СветланаКлименко-н3м So everything in the video. Including what that Russian citizen said, was faked by the west to justify their nazi war against the honest and innocent Russian Republic?
At 1:50, "Nobody beats you" just sticks out to me. How broken are these people that they expect a beating for receiving aid of any sort?
Internal FSB troops are used by Putin to keep the Russian population in line and they're complete bastards.
It was probably one of those accusation-confessions that feature so prominently in Russian propaganda.
Might not be an expectation in general, but more the function of unending state media propaganda. If you look back to 2014-2015 when Ukraine would retake towns in the Donbas at the start of the war, you will hear a lot of similar statements to these because the residents in those towns had spent a year or more being relentlessly indoctrinated to believe that if Ukraine retook territory in the Donbas, there would be wide spread reprisals in the forms of violence and forced starvation. When those didn't materialize, it did indeed change the way a lot of people living there saw the conflict, although their perspectives were never gathered and shared by international media, so most people didn't learn the lesson.
That guy must’ve lived thru some serious soviet times.
Ukraine is just so much more civilized
😂
It's also because the Ukrainians know they will lose western backing if their troops mistreat civilians in the same way Russia's have in Ukraine.
@@Aleksa_Lomako You find wars amusing? Go and fight there, then.
@@Aleksa_Lomako you are fake
@@Manfred-ml1oq Aleksa RUS - Z -
While Russian soldiers treat ordinary Ukrainian citizens with barbaric cruelty and forced compliance, Ukraine’s soldiers treat ordinary Russian citizens with compassion and humanity.
That should send a pretty obvious message to the international community as to who the aggressor of this war is (as if it wasn’t already obvious enough from day one)
The difference in civility is crazy. Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦
Very thoughtful of Ukraine to give out medicine as well as food& water.🙏🏼🙏🏼🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
Это не забота а обязанность оккупанта по международным законам. Не обольщайтесь
@@dmitriyrogachev1082russia is filth
Don’t worry the Ukrainian army aren’t orcs. They will help when they can
They are already helping by evacuating them and providing them with food
@@PierreDeuge Did you get the irony. 🧨
@@PierreDeuge 🤦🏻♀️ evacuated one guy? Do you know the population of the town (one of the smallest in Russia) and how many people left?
@@СветланаКлименко-н3м americans nowadays can't do the math huh? If the population is 10 people, and one of them was evacuated, then it's 10% lol. The smaller the population, the lesser they evacuate
liar
better to have Ukrainians in Sudzha than Russians in Bucha
this is just a Ukraine propaganda...yeah tell me, why didnt Ukraine evacuate Bucha ? its so close to Kyiv and they knew Russia is coming, they could send hundreds of busses from Kyiv...did they ? Sudzha is at the borders, Russia had no time to do something...
@@Dudush90
So why didn't Russians simply behave in disciplined and legal manner?
Don't try to push the blame from Russians.
@@Dudush90tell me, do you have a learning disability or something?
I don't wish to offend, I am just trying to comprehend how come you don't understand the difference in those 2 situations and how best to explain it to you.
Just that.
@@Dudush90seriously? You don't understand the difference in both situations? Really?
@Dudush90 are you effing kidding me? I can think of a few reasons why there were still civilians in Bucha during the surprise attack and invasion on multiple fronts (they couldn't pull hundreds of busses out of thin air or where needed elsewhere, not everyone wanted to leave, people didn't realized yet that Russia's aim is genocide against them, etc....). That the massacres occurred under Russian occupation is an undeniable fact, despite what Russian disinformation claims.
Why do I even bother. I see you're subscribed to Redacted so you are willing to believe in every Russian conspiracy theory
Bravo for going there and reporting in person properly.
Sad, but Ukraine has been enduring for over 2 years.🕊️🕊️🕊️
Whataboutism
@@mdstate829 Wtfaboutism?
It's about Ukrainians suffering for 2,5 years or from 2014 year started from Crimea, and russians met consequences just now or month ago.
Good job on The Pillar of Shame with the photos of wrecked Ukrainian towns.
Long live Ukraine!
😡 that is the Soviet slogan for Belarus
@@Aleksa_Lomako No, the Soviet slogan for Belarus is, "We get to screw you over"
Message to Sudzha's civilians:
WELCOME TO EUROPE!
Ukraine will not be in Europe for another 50 years 😂
@@22october85 Ukraine already is European, no matter how many soldiers Moscow sends to die there.
Ukrainians have already decided their future. And because Russians are too afraid to choose their own future, they will lose everything.
@@22october85 What a strange comment
@@22october85 I hope that fifty years from today even Russia is a normal European country.
@@dubsarI do hope so, but Putin came from time where Russians at least tried to care. The next president will be the person who matured and grew in modern Russia lul, he probably will be miles worse than Putin.
thanks for giving te old guy his ventalin i have asthma to it sucks if you dont have your meds
No fear. The Ukrainians will be humane and kind.
What better way for the residents of Kursk to find happiness than through the blessings of liberation received from Ukraine? They had suffered for centuries under the tyrannical oppression of the Moskals.
@@Hrisst 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
The people of Kursk might not be interested in being russian serfs anymore. Then again... serfs love the whip. So...
@@СветланаКлименко-н3мthat the best you can do retard?.
Ukrainians should bring them democracy - for the very first time in the history of this place - by holding a referendum asking if the locals wish to join Ukraine and, later, the European Union.
@@dubsar 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️ do you know how many people are left? And how many people evacuated? What are you talking about?
@@dubsar you really gonna try to make vote a couple hundred elderly ladies?
@@AlexanderWinterborn-r6p what are you talking about, elf? He is talking nonsense, and seems to believe it
@@AlexanderWinterborn-r6p i dont need help 😅🤷🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
@@AlexanderWinterborn-r6p try to keep up yourself, analyse the info and use common sense and logic
Russia is no more.
Its not russian anymore its ukrainen now.
My sympathy must first and foremost go out to all the Ukranians affected by this stupid war. God Bless you all!
slava ukraine 👍🇺🇦
They have no clue. Remember Bucha ? Of course they do not...and they should be grateful if they knew.
❤🇺🇦
Ukraine should call this a "Special news operation" to inform russians
Russia went from being the second-best military in Ukraine to being the second-best in Russia.
Ukraine winning propaganda war, Russia winning battlefield war...
@@Dudush90 2 1/2 years into the 3 day, special military operation, everything is going great for Russia! Haha! Putin turned Russia into North Korea, then went to North Korea to publicly admit it.
@@Dudush90 Yeah, Ruzzia doing great. They took 2 settlements in 3 weeks. Ukraine took over 100. Ukraine is also gaining ground back in the South of Ukraine as well as taking Ruzzian land. Who's winning?
@@scottmorley7738 I dont know what propaganda channels u watching, but Donbass front is collapsing since Ukraine enter Kursk, Russia is already knocking on Pokrovsk and Toretsk, meanwhile Kursk is stable
@@Dudush90Considering the SMO was supposed to take like a month and now Ukraine forces are inside Russia during nearly the third year of defence, I think it's already a loss, even if Russians do manage to complete the objectives of their SMO.
We can all tell they won't be aggressive because they didn't start this war
Maybe from now on they won't believe a word the Russian government tells them, you should take them on a bus tour through Ukraine so they can see what putin has done and see that Ukraine cares about its people and it's not like Putin makes it out to be!
Putin couldn’t give a fuck
The deep compassion and humanity of Ukrainians is amazing!
"You can fool some people sometimes
But you can't fool all the people all the time
Get up, stand up
Stand up for your rights." ✌️
🇺🇦👍🏻
Almost as if the Ukrainians were.... liberating Kursk :)
That sums it up, good guys v bad guys.
By contrast, civilians on territories occupied by Russia are forced to accept Russian passports to keep their jobs and pay, men are forcefully mobilized and children forbidden to study in Ukrainian language... I would say the citizen of Sudzha got a pretty good deal.
Slava 🇺🇦
The locals should be afraid of retributions if Putin's army comes back, they will show no mercy and accuse everyone of collaboration.
Good to see Ukraine not using the stick to control civilians.
Soldiers not raping their children and women. 💙🇺🇦
They are still not ready to say no to Vladimir adolf Karen bunker poutine 😅
Have a referendum
God bless the Ukraine.
Thank you God stand for righteous and truth. Ukraine fight for their right the land that still belong to Ukraine. God's divine protection for Ukraine and AFU freedom and peace and liberty. In Jesus mighty name your shield and buckler and saviour. God bless all.
Amen
🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦✌❤✌🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
L'ego d'un petit homme nommé Poutine
thats pretty sad that the foreign occupiers are taking care of you, while your own military is shelling your own territory! if they have the opportunity to enter ukraine i would take it.
Russians cross over to Ukraine look to help the military.
Какой бред. Украинцы не знают через какую щель убежать из этой страны а вы говорите что кто то добровольно хочет туда переехать😂
You gotta admit, if you remove the debris, Sudzha urban streets looks peaceful and great
Hope Ukrainians move there in the future
It amazes me how every Russian who encounters Ukrainian warriors say the same thing. "Nobody beats us." Makes you wonder if that's what they're used to.
Imagine having your own people wanting to evacuate to the opposing country because they treat them better than your own government while you also shell them too. Good job Putin.
It is a terrible thing that civilians must endure this before discovering how their leader is letting them down, why he has brought such hardship on their nation. To be told one thing and then learn so rudely that they had been lied to.
*playing the worlds smallest violin for these people*
Then you're Putin's best friend, racist.
These people were Putin's first victims. You stood by and did nothing for decades, and now you're pissing on them? Shame.
This has to stop
It's pathetic in the Kremlin that locals to admit that the intruders (Ukrainians) to come in and help/feed us, when the Kremlin had been neglecting them. They might as well vote in a referendum to join Ukraine.
The interviewees might be terrified. They are used to living in a repressive society.
Nobody protected you? How about defending yourself. Ah you want others to die for your important life.
Putin’s heroism in a nutshell: abandoning people lol.
Pokrovsk basically had the same situation LOL, but nobody talks about it.
Ukraine can easily take over and hold kursk and make it there own, the civilians will see Ukraine is better for them.
Should write in Russian: "This is the same as what you did to us", near the pictures
Тогда почему никто их не осуждает и не называет орками и убийцами? Или это другое? Если не в курсе то они это делают с 2014 года на Донбассе и что то я не видел ваших осуждающих комментариев!
Who attack civilians, from who they need protection????
These things happen when an army attacks civilians
All russians "nothing can hurt us" Ukraine invaded russian territory, also the russians "how can this be possible"
Get angry with uncle vova then😂
👍👍 👌 💗🔱💪💪✌✌
Russia has one chance for rescue, that the ENTIRE COUNTRY is occupied by Ukraine and that it is then run as a co-operative by the surrounding countries. After a few dozen generations maybe they will realign themselves with the rest of humanity. Though as they've only known tyranny and dictatorship for centuries [and the Tsars were not better than the current lot as far as the common people went] it's going to take a long time to teach them [and I mean those who work the land, live in rural areas, only know Russian propaganda and lies, have no knowledge of what the rest of the world is like] that a different way of life exists.
Давно так не смеялся с таких детских фантазий😂😂😂 вы как в параллельной вселенной живете.
Now they know how Ukrainians feel I don’t feel so for them they know what’s been going on
I don't think they can possibly understand what Ukrainians feel, because at least their town is still standing, not bombed and shelled so flat that the locals can't even find their own way around the rubble. So these Russians are getting a very "lite" experience of their own government's war.
American Propaganda
Imagine if, 2 1/2 years after invading Iraq, the US held just 20% of the country, had lost hundreds of thousands of troops, Saddam was friendly with most of the world's leaders, visiting them and hosting them in Baghdad, with Iraqis taking over Montana.
Add to that Iraq is halfway around the world from the USA and Ukraine is on russia's border. Russia's failure is beyond measure.
@@cba4389 Yep. Russia can DRIVE into Ukraine on any number of paved roads. The US hanged Saddam, shot his sons to death, installed a US-friendly government, and stole all the oil, with only 4400 troop losses. If the goal had been to make Iraq a US colony or state like Russia wants with Ukraine, that would have been WAY easier than trying to make it an autonomous Democracy.
Only a Jew would speak like that about Iran, Iraq and Ukraine. Are you Israeli BTW?
USA invaded with 20 other countries. And no other country supported Iraq. So very lame comparison
@@LarsonJohn Yeah, rwmwmber Saddam getting an ovation in fronr of the UN? 🤪
Old movies, why not new?
Skill issue.
Смерть ворогам
Слава Україні та її воїнам!
🤢
Maybe should not be supporting Putin, hu?
ពូទីនមិនខ្វល់រឿងទាហានរុស្ស៊ីងាប់នៅក្នុងទឹកដីអ៊ុយក្រែនផងមានអ្វីដែលពូទីនត្រូវតែខ្វល់រឿងប្រជាជន? 😂
Оу вы правда в этом уверены? А чего же тогда вся Украина одно сплошное кладбище усыпанное национальными флажками? Нашему президенту и нам глубоко плевать на ваше мнение. Вы так ничего и не поняли за эти годы.
Brednie
Why?
@@joli8218 Polecam wpisać Patrick Lancaster i obejrzy jego materiały z przed 8 lat 6 lat 3 lat no i teraźniejsze. Szczególnie materiały z ograniczeniem wiekowym.
Вранье😂
As if! this channel is not a propaganda 😂😂😂
You will be better off with Ukraine than with Putin.
The diverence between civilized and barbarians
It war. N there are military strategies at play. . It’s you civilians that should of trained n prepared. Ya knew ya share a border with a nation ya at war with. Why u men not prepare n train to protect community women n children. . Question is , who side people like this guy on🤔. N when d Russian do come they will remember this video n aid you took from Ukrainian invaders.
"Don't accept humanitarian assistance because you may get in trouble later" will be a hard sell for people running low on necessities.
Lmao dude really? You show us the Moskal mindset, thanks. You proof even more how disgusting your country is. What is he supposed to do when he needs medication? "Ukrainian invaders" is so ironic. Considering you're such a patriot, when will you join the orc army?
@@chetmcmasterson u know it won’t end well for those two. Neither Ukraine nor Russia will want them. They chose a side by taking those gifts. They better now have a plan to exit to Ukraine side. Or hope get taken with Ukraine military as it gets pushed back. N pushed back will be d lucky scenario. May end much worse.
So in other words you agree with this video. The civilians should fear Russia more than Ukrainian soldiers. Maybe these people are more informed than you are, Yvan.
@@axisgalaxis lmao bad old man for accepting medicine that helps him. You're delusional.
ПРОСТО УПИТЕ ЭТИХ ПЛОХИХ СОБАК, ОНИ - ЛОВУШКА ДЛЯ ОБЩЕСТВА.
PROSTO UPITE ETIKH PLOKHIKH SOBAK, ONI - LOVUSHKA DLYA OBSHCHESTVA.