ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 พ.ค. 2024
- Let's take a quick look at GuP in this super scientific review analysis and maybe try to figure out if the anime is as silly as it looks at a first glance. Spoiler: it probably is, but you're asking the wrong questions.
00:00 - Girls und Panzer is silly
01:44 - The viewers are silly
04:46 - Families are silly
06:32 - Military is silly
09:03 - Carbon coating is silly
11:44 - The doujins are silly
Military advisor commentary:
• (ENG SUB) GuP der FILM... - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
The lesson here is that the series is *C A R B O N C O A T E D*
Honestly, that _does_ explain all the weird stuff that happens.
that's just called... hitting the invincibility button when they get in the tanks :|
thought you said C A R B O N G O A T E D
Yep the author were straight up carbon (Carbon Monoxide Poisoning)
What if i coat a cardboard box w/ cabon?
You forgot to mention that the T means it was made in Czechoslovakia
Yessir
CZECHIA MENTIONED
In the contrary. Me being into tanks is one of the biggest reasons why I love the show. While incredibly silly and outwardly, majority of the "inaccuracies" were actually just carefully, but GREATLY, exaggerated things that those tanks could do or were known for. Which together with what's already such a goofy world ties in greatly to still be a good educational tool. For example the British Crusader tank is shown in the anime to be a literal race car that weighs nothing. In the anime this is emphasized greatly, but not inaccurate if you change the context from GuP to real life. Then yes of course they're not as fast as in the anime, but in the general context of tanks, especially of that era, they were INCREDIBLY quick. It's all about the perspective the anime uses to tell about a real life thing by using it's own goofiness as exaggeration to make it easy to digest to those who may not know anything about tanks, but to also make tank nerds (like me) to appreciate the thought into each and every single vehicle and reference that was shown.
It's absolutely, BRLILLIANT
I'm not a tank nerd but I always thought that the inaccuracies in GuP were deliberately made to spice things up
You can't convince me that lolis crewing KV-2 is just a coincidence
@@SyuaibZulkarnain well that exaggeration is general in the lore and all tanks in GuP. I was specifically talking about the exaggerations of the vehicles themselves and how clever they actually are in educating in a way
There’s a big difference of doing a totally inaccurate and totally impossible elements on the film because of poor research and ignorance to the subject.
Vs,
Making an intentional inaccurate and impossible element, even though the filmmakers studied it really hard and hired real professionals to get info, just because the Rule of Cool.
As we can see, the staff really go out of their way to get all technical details, historical facts and trivia, but they still remember that their first goal is to make fun wholesome show. Tank and Military fans seems to get it, just by watching it and accepted all the silliness, because they know. That’s the fun of it.
@@inisipisTV hell yeah
all of life's lessons are condensed into sensha-dō but Nobody realized it
salvation
@@adastraarthur7154 ONE MILLION LIVES
@@M4nw1thnoname9 TARGET IS THE OSEAN CAPITAL OF OURED TO TAKE THE LIVES OF ONE MILLION PEOPLE, 5.000 KILOMETERS AWAY, WITH MY VERY OWN HANDS
The normal one or the yukiyukite senshado one
@@mohammadsyazwigeoffrey7325 let me tell you a story, I was trapped with my submarine crew at the bottom of the ocean for 698 days where we maintained our sanity by watching the same video of Houshou Marine every day, after surfacing we dove into the finer aspects of Otaku culture including Manga and similar mediums of fine art. The crew stumbled upon the unfortunate doujinshi yukiuite senshado, and the guilt was so great i devised the plan to kill one million lives, or was it the plan to save ten million lives, oh well, instead of completing the plan to kill one million people I let a rival nations top ace shoot a handful of missiles into the core of my submarine, sinking it and freeing my crew from the burden of ever having read yukiuite senshado, and bringing salvation to our ruined existence, oh and to answer your question, real sensha-do has all of life's important lessons.
If GuP had triple the episodes as one piece had i would still watch them all, i can never get bored of GuP
I. Won’t. Even. Mind. If. GUP. Had. To. The. Power. Of. 3. As. One. Piece.
it dont need, its good as it is, the films are great too.
Yukiyukite Senshadou was actually really well written and illustrated. I just wish they didn't try to force Porn into every other chapter.
The final battle in Kuromoremine was heart wrenching, and the parodies were pulled off really well too. (I liked the Downfall one especially)
Same here. Without the porn, I could actually recommend it to people without pulling an Erika, if you know what I mean.
@@notme8232 More importantly, the porn kind of undercuts the premise of the doujin IMO. Because of all the things, we don't remember the doujin as a recollection of the horrors of WWII through the eyes of GuP. We remember it because Yukari sold her body for a Tiger II model, and because the Nishizumi sisters got raped as PoW's. And honestly, the last part felt a lot better because it moved away a bit from the porn and became tragic violence. The scene where Nonna forces herself to shoot Katyusha and then kills herself gave me chills.
@@the_tactician9858I'd actually forgotten about that whole thing till now. Oof
@@the_tactician9858 god dang it i haven't read it yet but you make me regret i wanted to
I just read all of it in one sitting after watching the video and honestly, I have no words for it.
Girls und Panzer works for the same reason the old Warhammer works: the creators put a lot of effort and love into the little details while creating something silly and incredibly fun.
Girls und panzer was always so interesting and having many historical references and i just love it, at first finding out about it was weird to me at first but after looking at memes about it and a certain TH-camr I instantly became a fan of the show and i just loved how it’s silly and wholesome and some of it’s awesome scenes.
The series doesn't give a damn about cliches and it's something that is damn funny, sometime hilarous
I agree with your analysis! Also to highlight that it is one of the few series focused on teams and communitarian victory. In an era where all is about individualism, couple relationships, self importance and inside feelings (like in Nagatoro or Watamote) , this series reminds us that human is a social animal and that all victories in the past depended on groups of people beliving in a dream.
Well said
as Quentino Tarantino said:
BECAUSE IT'S SO MUCH FUN!!!
The more I rewatch the anime the more things I find and the better it gets. That's how powerful it is...
That's how powerful it is...
Agreed
It also has beaten godzilla in anime watchers in japan
(I still think the kaiju is way more famous since i once saw a list and roughly 28 percent of the worlds population knows what godzilla is)
I'm really glad someone subbed the GuP der Film commentaries.
SUPER NICE, recently got back in to GuP,and love seeing video essays about it
I recommend Ikigai Studios review for more serious side and The Antarctic Partisan review for more meme side
The anime is a masterpiece that I wanna rewatch again
Wow I missed so much thing the first time I watched gup, big tanks 4 that you summarized it in a nutshell. Great vid!
i have rewatched it to many times im gonna do it again i love tanks and i love when they make tanks SO GOD DARN FAST its really a masterpiece
sorry if i cant spell that well im swedish
He did it the lad did it and mentioned Yukiyuite. One of the best and probably most traumatic things out of the whole Franchise
what i only noticed is on the panzer 2 you can see a pucket on the barrel this is reference to the soviets putting buckets on the barrels of the t34s to make them look like IS-2s at 5:09
The exact same thing happened to the town of Shirakawa since the novels/anime series Higurashi is set there, so now you see amidst all these classical japanese houses a bunch of random anime stuff
okay okay HOWEVER.
the best scene is by far a chaffee chasing an L33 down a rollercoaster.
5:51 I've read this doujin before and its the story is bittersweet, I highly recommend
10:06 is that picture a Fury reference lmao
The secret is suspension of disbelief... it turns its utterly hilarious premise up to such a degree that you actually stop giving a fuck.
Came for the history, stayed for darjeeling. The doujins aren't bad either
One thing to remember is turtle team in the hetzer is every world of tank players that rock the Derp Gun just for shits&Giggles and watch the guy in the bigger tank rages cause you keep blowing off his tracks.
This was the show that got me into tanks as a whole, not to metion it's one of the only series I would rewatch anytime.
Thanks to this anime, I got my attention to games that portrait the tanks in question.
i have a very important question … what was dope-ass remix for music used as background called?
British Grenadiers Kiwi Remix
Pravda is kayushium coated (it's like stalinium but with a heart as big as the plains of Siberia)
This leaves just one last thing. Where do I find the British grenadiers dubstep you used in the intro and outro
Whats the name of the background music from the start cause i cant find it in TH-cam?
British Grenadiers Kiwi Remix
@@rmbtuvilla5292thanks
That background music makes me think of a certain American militiaman getting their head blown off by a cannonball while Mel Gibson watches with Heath Ledger
What are those videos with viewers text and WHERE CAN I JOIN THAT
60th sub lovely video
My reaction to that title: Excuse you, I am so addicted to GuP... Please help.
Is there going to be a Haifuri video? I think it's the closest to GuP but navy.
Oh God, I did not know there was a KanColle analog of Yukiyukite Senshadou.
AND I DID NOT WANT TO KNOW IT, TEITOKU :(
where did u get that face from. one from thumbnail
Same question here
God damn I wanna visit Oarai
i was hoping for gunmetal stug.
I notest that the DVD didn't show the battle between Anzio and oorai not sure why?
Oh yeah you have got to watch the abridged version it's brilliant
I have a theory about GuP. This takes place in the future right? I couldn't find a reliable date when it takes place. My theory is that something happened to the planets gravity and it is a lot weaker than it is now. Think about how much could be explained by a lower gravity. Tanks jumping, Miho jumping, better chance of school carriers handling all that weight. etc
It more or less takes place in the then current year of 2012.
The other stuff... don't think too hard about Nina manhandling the KV-2 shells than are literally heavier than she is.
@@JohnDoe-fi9li I believe the 2012 thing is more a fan theory as well. I don't think anything was determined. Even if that is the case though, 2012 wasn't like this at all, so if we are doing whole alternate timeline then my theory is still viable.
@@YukoValis there's some older materials that got translated that did speak about some small parallels like Bertha Benz being a pioneer in tankette races.
But yeah timeline is fuzzy. Like how in the TV Show girls all had feature phones, but in later media they all have upgraded to smartphones lol
GIRLS AND WAR CRIMES
where your gunmetal StuG nao?
10:29 actually i think that rule is: if there are civies present DONT SHOOT that's why in the movie 4 girls go into a mall and one of them says: HEY THIS IS A NO FIRE ZONE!!
Tanks
Girls in uniform
And most definitely a large amount of crack
Girls und Panzer is the ultimate experience for any History enjoyer
Hallowed are the Ooarai.
i love tanks... yet still find this show to be absolute brilliant cos its slice of life, comedy and escapist all at the same time
i remember girls
and tanks
and actual tank battles
give me another place where massive tank battles happen that isn't world of tanks or warthunder
Just imagining a ww2 tanks with modern engine more powerful engines. Thats what GuP for me. The exaggerated speed is like how singapore modernized their post ww2 tank into a modern much faster with post ww2 tank body
How can I get some of that CARBON COATED? I think is pretty useful.
As spoken by MST3K, "....Just repeat to yourself, its just a show, I should really just relax."
Someday,wanna be to Ooarai.....I only visited to Nishizumi Kojirou's monument
in Kumamoto,Japan.
ところで、外国にもニコニコ動画みたいなものがあるのか。
i read it and now i have ptsd
PERFECT
1:27 what is the name of the rimix?
found it 1777 UK the British Grenadiers March | natowave
Where can I watch the anime with the passing comments and are you going to make a video for high school fleet
what is the music in the prologue?
The British Grenadiers (Kiwi remix)
@@osez111 thnx
It's all true. Ima person that always hated anime for alot of reasons but this... thus is my favorite move/series ever. Still don't like anime though
same here, I was hoping High School Fleet would be GuP but with ships... NOPE
Thanks bandai namco for putting girls und panzer as gundam+wot
girls und panzer is good but the bad side is oarai is more buffed
Lol.😅
What is the source for those viewer comments passing by thing? Like everyone going "DUCE DUCE" with Anchovy and "USA USA" with Saunders.
Darjeeling no.1
Ahhh Yukiyukite. An absolutely heart wrenching "manga" filled with every warcrime you can think of
I was having some dumb fun watching it, till I did bit digging on how tanks works... yeah the serie defy the logic, the physics and probably reality too
where can i find the Kapitulieren? NEIN! spin off?
found it on some hentai site haha
6:58 all my neurons gangsta till i saw one of my favorite fan-art (i wonder why ^^) pop on the screen...
But, except this; it contain more details than the damn body, the stuff is actually references, i'll lets weebs and interested peoples see by themselves, as long as they know how to use pixiv or other websites.
Can you send me a link? For research purposes
Your awesome
*PLOT ARMOUR*
Hey so there’s this submarine and don’t worry it’s carbon coated
Jesus Christ that was very pleasant to watch, m8-up until you mentioned *that* manga. 😁
hey there fella over the net can you give me any source on that manga. the vid itself got me curious ngl and is it really that ptsd inducing? :D
@@california816 finished it like hours ago. Really made me look at the series from a whole another perspective not sure how I should feel about it though
@@masterhasashi. It be like that.
Finally I know that the reason I can't get a girlfriend is because I'm carbon coated
11:53 VOTOMS?
CAROBN COATING~~~
My friend falls into the "it's too unrealistic" category. He says the animations of the tanks are too 'cringe' and the plot is too cliche.
Fun fact, it’s possible to have your hair naturally like Yukari’s, as I do 😅
Btw I read the “realistic” style of Girls und Panzer. I quite enjoyed it
Some highschool girls drive some Battle Tanks
wait.
GuP is actually popular in 日本？！？
Alta heavy tonk
Ive stumbled upon this even tho im a big fan of GuP but all you do is dont recomend yukiyukite that thing is a fan porn manga who is so depressing that it can change a man literally and no its not cannon so you can relax even tho it still gives me ptsd to this day and i wish you all Einen schönen Tag, eine schöne Nacht und einen Gruß von Erikas Mitbewohnerin im Wohnheim
Pause at 10:21
Me like tonk and gun therefore me watch GuP
This has a sting of a guy embarrased by how much he likes girls and tanks so he invents whole narrative about why its good actually. And that level of dedication is a testament to how society fucks over men and mostly how good the show is if people will still try to argue about it.
I give all TK lovers a wonderful time in Hell.
XD
Gib link to music
British Grenadiers Kiwi Remix
@@rmbtuvilla5292 nice, thanks
Miho is a war criminal
Anchovy is best girl
tts kills me
I mean driving tanks is cool, it doesn't take a propaganda movie to get me into senshado if the game is pretty harmless.
P/S: Even if that means not being able to shoot each other. Because you know, safe
Where can I have a look at the yukiyukitai senshadou manga?
You stay the fuck away from it and read Ribbon Warrior instead.
@@KingofSpoons64 too late mate. I've already seen that cursed adult comic spinoff, it really obliterated my fondness of GuP.
@@annankesawa7500 It's just fan fiction, just pretend it doesn't exist and it can't hurt you.
I don't have to remember becuase I actively worship the series LMAO
GuP is like a version of King James Bible for the Weabs and Wehrboos, and Murica! and Sovietnists and Tea Lovers, any ww2 weaboos really.
False... Its exactly as good as I remember
she basic has ptsd
god plese no ._. talking about that "sequel" is prohibited
no not really
You have more likes then subs, I’m disappointed
"Quasi official" doesnt really work here lol. Its just a hentai doujinshi by hentai doujinshi artist. For some reason his K-On work was never considered anyting but hentai. As well as any other. Yukiyukite was created for the nut and exists as nothing more then hentai fanfiction, dont give this piece more credit then it deserves.
I wish that there was a season 3 and 4 and 5 and 6 and 7 got a girls and Panzer that it's going to be popular from America and it won't work so you know this of Japanese don't want to order country anyways but I have no judgement anyways because let me say this Japan is not like a popular of a fans of a girls and princess but America and the one with the world or do like girls and Panzer to release data to America and around the world that it is popular like that but it not popular in Japan can anyone just tell the difference right now because America Central America United States of America from Europe Middle East and Asia. Like overwhelmed cartoon animation of a Japan anyway but it doesn't matter. Others not popular or it is popular but the question Everyone likes girls and pizza and then after that Japan is getting popular that data from around the world but not in Japan and then they can make other brand new seasons and everyone's going to enjoy it
Anyway everyone. Are you already know this that I do have a comic books that are black and white that I ain't goes and Pastor Ortiz a 2 3 4 5 6 and 7 and beyond that but however you could buy anyway but you mister of a TV show back in the cartoon animation and then after that the pain is very very extremely expensive for Jamaica brand new season anyway because it is higher and it's too expensive and especially your dad let me say this it's not fair. Just not fair that a Japan that I want to make it more for the expensive ones it's very expensive anyway so now you know anyway everyone because I stitching him for telling the truth japanimation very expensive and make us to be sad that a welfley missed it