This former CEO of Raiders just explained why Raiders were so bad. How can Love, Goff and Mayfield be more "terrific" than Brock? She's off her medication
Jordon Love is playing amazingly well right now. Calling him the GOAT now is a bit early 😂. That said, I don’t think she is that wrong. Hate to say it but Mayfield being the only one obviously worse than Brock. God help me but I agree with Nick Wright. We have not seen Brock win when they are facing adversity. Closest thing would be the Raiders last year going into OT. If he shows me that over these playoffs I’ll be happy I bought that Purdy rookie card PSA 10 MNT last year.
Ya, I gave up listening to her babble at one point becasue she had no point. Some people make comments designed to get themselves viral. I think she did this with that intention.
Yeah exactly. Nothing but respect for her, but she didn’t defend her point with a single piece of data and didn’t even try. Not hating on her just because she’s wrong. I’m hating on the fact she did nothing to substantiate her perspective. It makes her sounds like a salty raiders exec. I want to assume that’s not why she’s saying this but she hasn’t made a single point to defend her point. Raiders down sooooo bad.
@@zacsinden4514I’d say he’s been facing adversity from day one. The dude was literally “Mr Irrelevant”…until he wasn’t. In the face of all the doubters, he’s prevailed and still going. They just can’t handle being wrong like most people in the world.
@@TheGillenium I wouldn't necessarily call playing with 6 All Pros "adversity". Jordan Love plays with zero All Pros and that is more "adversity" than being a QB on the 49ers with a loaded offense
The mark of a great quarterback is that they make everyone around them better. Brock has done that. The offensive line was considered our week spot and has gone without much criticism this season because of brocks play. 4 1,000 yard skill players first time in the history of the NFL once again because of Brock. He gets overlooked way too often and isn't given the credit he deserves because of the talent around him but he has helped those talented players reach their potential. JG couldn't do that with the same players and I would argue that even Josh Allen and Lamar haven't done that either
For someone who's tenure had been involved with the likes of Jamarcus Russell, Marques Tuiasosopo, Andrew Walter, and Tyler Wilson--she doesn't have a clue.
Trask accidentally showed her hand because she clearly only values physical traits that jump off the page and doesn't take into account the mental side of the game at all
She made herself look stupid. Her comment was mean, ignorant, and unnecessary. They let her off the hook. Brock is up there with 7 first round picks. That says how great he is. She knows it gets attention.
@@realistNFLyou do realize becoming all pro isn’t all about that player right? You can be the most talent running back or wide out in the world but if you aren’t featured as much as another dude playing across the country then he gets it you don’t. Also having all-pros is a team thing. If your pass offense is top tier it opens up your run game and vice versa. Saying Lamar only has one all-pro could be viewed as a slight on him for not featuring his guys more
@@PS-ub3kt You can't realistically tell me that Baltimore has their own Trent, CMC, Aiyuk, Kittle, Deebo and Juice and Lamar hasn't unlocked them. Trent, CMC, Aiyuk, Kittle, Deebo and Juice were All Pros or already elite before Purdy. Even Juice is higher rated than their All Pro fullback. The 49ers weapons on offense is historic.
@@realistNFL like Mahomes? The media gives grace to Mahomes for his lack of weapons once he got the bag. Jalen Hurts gets the bag and has the same amount of weapons as last season, but he played like trash this year. QBs need great weapons. We will see if/when Brock gets paid how he will perform with less weapons in the future.
The radio hosts just asked her a simple question (the Kurt Warner comparison) and when she realized how wrong she was she got super defensive. Calling out the hosts for being “nasty” to her. It was just a simple question Amy. You said you wanted good natured discussion on disagreeing, that’s exactly what those guys were doing!!
She really didn't have anything logic to say. Basically, she's like I'm with the raiders organization. I'm only supposed to show nothing but hate towards your team.
“Seven terrific QBs and Brock Purdy…” Well, Brock is in a class by himself. He is the smartest QB of the eight in the playoffs. He’s not like her elite 7, and per Brock, he doesn’t want to be like them (as he mentioned in his interview with Steve Young.) We love him just the way he is. ❤
You have to remember she was part of the Raiders organization. She is a hater because the Raiders has far less success the 49ers. The Raiders were always the step brother to the 49ers in Bay Area football
She deflected the criticism and avoided sharing with the public her reasoning. Notice how she devoted to say "why this or that is an issue" rather than saying "hey, I just look at the tape/stats" or "I don't look at all, but that is my feel". In psycology, that kind of avoidance, cleverly done by her by the way, is done to hide the fact that she did not use a sound rationale. So her "gut" or "feel" is what she may have to defend in this debate... and she is not willing to do it, nor hear about it. And then have a beer.
The Warner question shows she knows nothing about football. She basically is just regurgitating stuff she hears on espn. I bet she had to Google who Kurt is, after the interview.
Yup, then she tried to do what women do best and manipulate them and blame them about being caught up on the word “good and great” like Bih u decided to use those adjectives and these guys are just debating the same argument with the same supporting casts with similar QBs gets called great. She literally got cornered and tried to manipulate the convo into not disagreeing in a nasty manner. 😂😂😂 The kitchen is waiting for her.
Brock Purdy will be Super Bowl mvp and people still will not believe in him but as a guy who wanted Trey lance to be our starter at the beginning of the year I am all in on this guy, he is our qb and he is legit and I trust him to bring us our 6th ring
Steve Young 2 years in dystopian Tampa = hideous Steve Young 13 years in harmonious San Francisco = HOF player We don't question the validity of his career though. Definitely a new era of football commentary.
@@TinoR626 there's a reason why they call football the ultimate team sport. hell look at patrick mahomes this year. what good is a qb if you got recievers dropping balls.
He could run. Purdy can't. He had arm talent. Purdy doesn't. He's in the HOF. Purdy will be exposed as soon as a couple of pieces are gone from this offense.
She said it all at 5:20. "When I look at the 8 qb's". Is she an analyst? Does she know how to evaluate qb play? Does she understand what the qb is being asked to do? Does she see what Brock is improvising as things unfold? Does she see the success that Brock is manifesting vs what's being given? Some talking heads are arguing that yac shouldn't be credited to Purdy, but then the analysts are calling those 20 yard throws "handoffs". Purdy is so accurate and consistent that those throws essentially become handoffs. He's so good that haters see that as typical play.
One more thing. Mahomes literally had the best TE kelce and tyreek hill. But no one discredited Mahomes for that. It pisses me off and I just can’t wait for us to shut everyone up
THIS!!! Wonder boy mahomes makes a 40yard pass and the NFL is sucking him off. Purdy does the same thing and it’s because he’s throwing the ball to deebo or kittle. -_- seriously. Now i was purdy to win it all just to see what the media will bash him for.
Patrick Mahomes also walked in a good situation Starting after Alex Smith. The team had many of the playmakers Alex smith had, Mahomes did elevate them much like Purdy has done with BA, Deebo, Kittle, and CMC all of them hitting over 1000 yards.
The Kurt warner question was a perfect comparison with the situation Brock is in but she clearly is devious and needs to make sure her opinion is right. She is 100% being biased here. It seems like a desperation attempt to keep relevancy for herself or lime light
Not a good comparison at all. She didn't understand the question. Do you think she knows anybody on that team other than warner? I'd say the radio hosts botched the interview
There were 7 terrific quarterbacks and one quarterback who had the force in him. Also when the going gets tough the good quarterback becomes clutch and Amy Trask terrific quarterbacks throws picks
It's like being a point guard on a team where the other four starters average 30 points a game. At some point even the most clueless observer stumbles on the idea that maybe the guy distributing the ball is kind of important to making the whole thing work. Yeah, he plays on a team with great skill players. But he gets the most out of them. Which is basically the job of a quarterback. Funny that they're all, coincidentally, putting up career numbers with Brock facilitating the offense. But of course, somehow, he has nothing to do with that.
If this conversation was 4 QB's. Allen,Mahomes, Lamar, and Brock and she said 3 elite QB;s and Brock it wouldn't be a big deal. But the fact she is putting Baker and Goff into that terrific category and leaving out Brock is where she loses all merit.
She's really putting Baker Mayfield and Jordan Love above Brock Purdy? Brock has literally been one of the best QBs in the league since he stepped on the field. She obviously has no clue what she's talking about, which you can see when she was asked point blank, why? She didn't give a single answer, just repeated that she doesn't put him in the same category as the others, which obviously means that he just doesn't look like the prototypical QB and he was drafted last. It's like Gattaca, he is destined to be a terrible QB by birth. He could never outplay his "potential."
I wish they had just asked her if she actually watched tape and if so what did he need to do better to be better than Baker Mayfield, Jordan Love, CJ Stroud, or Jared Goff.
But watch what happens if we win, everyone is gonna down Purdy AGAIN and say it's "the system and his weapons" instead of his own abilities and that the packers were never good to begin with, it's never gonna stop I swear
God I hope we win or else it’s gonna be 12 months more of this insane crap this lady is spewing. They’ve created an impossible scenario for Brock. If he excels, it’s because of his surrounding talent. If he falters, it’s because he sucks. Brock had one of the most efficient seasons a QB has ever had. So there’s nothing more he can do to prove them wrong. Which is why this needs to be our year to win the last game.
This is all part of the magical story of Brock Purdy. The modest, grounded, humble 'boy next door'. Watching the story unfold before our eyes, the likes of which movies are made is good for the soul. People will say what people will say. There are villains and hero's in every story. Rooting for the underdog is what America is built on. Let the man play and let the chips fall where they may.
Let’s list the QBs Trask’s Raiders signed; Terrell Pryor Carson Palmer Jason Campbell JaMarcus Russell Josh McCown Andrew Walter Kerry Collins Rick Mirer Rich Gannon Jeff George Daunte Culpepper 11 Starting QBs in 16 years and an overall record of 98-142. The season after she left they drafted Derek Carr, statistically the greatest Raiders QB of all time by a long shot. Enough said.
No, not because he was picked last. It is because he has a genius play caller as a coach, excellent casts of RB, FB, TE and WR. I think especially he doesn't do those flashy runs is why.
@@tommydong8070 It's a combination of it all. He was the very last pick, has a lot of talent around him, and has Kyle calling the plays. With that being said, he is apart of the final four and a lot of people fail to mention that our offense improved dramatically when he first took over for Jimmy.
She took a shot at Purdy by isolating him from the other playoff QBs and she supported her claim with his surrounding cast argument that is lazy and surface level. A person that was in high rankings of an organization shouldn’t be taking shots at a player if she hasn’t watched the tape. It makes her look bad and now she’s on defense. Crazy how people are trying to knock him down a peg instead of talking him up for being in the same place as 7 other first rounders.
She still didn't explain why he is "good" because of his teammates, but not every other QB isn't?!?! The QB does not throw, catch, run, sack, int, or tackle!!!! It takes a team to win!! She kept crying about ppl being mean to her!! Lamar is 1-3 in the playoffs with 5TDs and 7INTs!!!!
I’ll say what I posted on X… if your argument is that BP is surrounded by so much talent then I would argue that with all due respect to Jimmy G, but Jimmy also had the same ammo that Brock has and wasn’t able to accomplish what Brock Purdy has. Not only has BP broke his own record as a QB in Niner franchise and played a perfect game, but he also helped 4 of his teammates surpass 1k in a single season. Oh and let’s not forget this is his 1st season as a starter, sooo yeah Purdy great to me.
Her not understanding the Kurt Warner question when that was her basis for diminishing Brock's play, completely tanks any of her credibility. She needs to sit this one out.
Purdy, literally, out-played ever QB in the NFL this year. He is 5th in yards (4,280 - club record) DESPITE being 20th in attempts. He leads in QB rating, QBR, deep-ball passing percentage (NFL record) and deep ball efficiency (NFL record). His air-yards, per attempt, is 1.5 yards deeper than the #2 QB. And he does all that behind a line with Trent Williams and the Four Mid-Guys.
I'll put it to you like this if you're irrelevant. All you have to do is mention Brock Purdy's name and boom. The views and the attention will come. Brock is the most talked about Qb in the league. Hell, at this point, kuddos to him. He is doing something right because he got everybody chatting saying his name that alone speaks volumes forget the haters. We, the fan base, know what we got, and we gone ride with Brock til the end.
yea, it sounds like clickbait. kinda like when cam said purdy was a game manager. the fact that amy isn't an evaluator any more should show how good she was at her job anyways.
The question that should have followed up after her statement was; "What is your criteria in evaluating quarterbacks?" This would help explain what her reasoning is, at the very least.
I think you could take the arguably out of that sentence. And yes I realize a lot had to do with his lack of weapons, but that kind of proves that QBs need weapons to consistently be great
She had no rebuttal for the Kurt Warner question. Completely avoided it. I had that exact same argument with some people. Used the exact same example. There are dozens of examples.
It’s so funny Jordan love wins one game and now he’s a elite quarterback, they hate on Brock because he plays the position the cleanest and most efficient and sense he’s not a first round pick he’s only doing it because of his coach and his teammates the media just finds way to hate because they were wrong about Brock
that was the problem, she put her foot in her mouth with no clarification why she felt that way about Purdy. But Instead was the same bland, generic criticism we've been hearing about Purdy all season long.
Look at the video closely. She looks like she had a few, just sayin. Her face is flush. Why was the mean girl commentary necessary AT ALL??? SHE IS GOING FOR ROGER GODELL'S JOB OR SOMETHING?
Let’s set this in perspective. After 25 starts in the NFL Brock Purdy breaks the 49ers all-time passing record and is rated in the top three this year statistically among quarterbacks all after 25 starts. Can you imagine what this kid will look like by the end of fourth season?
I think what is getting over looked, and unquestionably she’s earned respect, is exactly how she put it. It wasn’t remotely respectful: “There are 7 terrific quarterbacks… and Brock Purdy.” What reaction would she expect? Good news is it’s football. Brock can settle it with the scoreboard and a ring. The Amy Trask’s of football will die on the JaMarcus Russell hills and NEVER accept a Purdy.
@@douglasscovil3447 Yes. And kinda surprising from her as she’s usually more sincere. I have to chalk it up to her being a Niner hater. And that’s not the usual “hater” online label. She worked with the Raiders opposite side of the Bay for decades. Her 49ers hate is earned and runs deep. She probably thinks Montana was vastly overrated.
She is a certified idiot... Who can even give her the loudspeaker to give an opinion?? ... Obviously she has not even looked at the stats to compare ..
Nobody talks about how when Brock got hurt in the NFC championship game and Josh Johnson, a guy with way more NFL experience than Brock, came in and couldn't do anything with the same exact roster of players that everyone tries to discredit Brock for having. Just because you have a great supporting cast doesn't mean you can just plug and play any QB and keep doing the same things you were doing offensively. If anything, Brock helped turn Brandon Aiyuk into one of the best WR's in the league this year, but the "experts" haven't thought about that at all. We Niners fans know what we have in Brock and that's all that matters at the end of the day.
She has the credentials to have an opinion, and she's wholeheartedly entitled to it. I love Baker's enthusiasm for the game etc., but there ain't no way he's better than Purdy. Whatever Raider-infused hate she has for the 9ers, she gotta let that hurt go. Too much salt ain't good for ya soul, sister.
Does she? I understand she was a Raiders exec but exactly in what capacity was QB ANALYSIS FACTOR IN TO HER JOB DESCRIPTION? ITS JUST HER OPINION AND I SWEAR THE ACTUAL INTERVIEW SHE LOOKED LIKE SHE HAD A FEW, HER FACE WAS FLUSHED. F HER.
I even call her credentials to question considering the state of the Raiders the past few years. Essentially no playoff success and a disaster of head coaching carrousel. What have they done in her tenure to say she has accolades to merit her opinion?
No QB in the NFC is better than Brock purdy Lol 😜............ AFC. Mahomes, Allen, and Jackson are a little better because they been in the league longer Lol.
Interviewers did a terrible job pressing her on it. She got away with another vague response. Here’s the easy question: “So if I was to show you 20 high level throws Brock made this season would you say those throws are because of his teammates??” 🤔
After this foolish word salad, one has to wonder if she really did her own math to come up with 8 total remaining playoff QBs. Yet another ignorant self-promoter who either hasn't seen more than a few highlight packages or knows nothing about QB play.
I would ask her, name a QB who has won the chip without a good offense/defense. She got called out for a horrible take, and can't handle the criticisms that come with it.
@@realistNFL If that's the argument you wish to make, you could just as easily frame it as is it a case of All Pro players simply making a quarterback better or does the quarterback in fact elevate the level of play in the All Pro players around him? Case in point, Mike Evans career stats are eye-popping. 10 seasons in the league, perennial pro bowler, over 1000 years in every single one of them. Career averages of 76.2 receptions, 1168 yards and 15.2 ypc. He was BELOW his career averages in every one of those categories with Brady as his QB. He actually put up better numbers in the seasons he played with Jameis Winston and Baker Mayfield. Similarly worth noting, Chris Godwin's career highs in catches, yardage and YPC all happened in non-Brady seasons. On the other hand, perennial all-pro George Kittle just had a career high of 15.7 ypc, and Brandon Aiyuk had a breakout season, leading the league at 17.9 ypc. And if you bother to do a deep dive, the production of both players has been markedly better with Purdy at QB. I don't think the Brady comparison is the winning argument most people assume it is. Brady didn't have his breakout season until his seventh year in the league. In 22 years as an NFL QB he only had three seasons where he put up numbers on par with what Brock has accomplished in his rookie season and year two. For most of his career, Brady was the very definition of a "game manager" whose primary job was not to screw things up. He had the good fortune to have played on teams with top tier defenses and top quality offensive lines (certainly much better than Purdy has) and his role was never to be great or spectacular, but to just be good enough. And he played his role. Nothing more, nothing less.
She so disingenuous. She was taking a shot at Brock and she knows it. It was disrespectful and rude. Now she’s crying about people pushing back and being rude, saying “we don’t all have to agree! Don’t be mean to me!”
I just used the Kurt Warner argument lol. It doesn't make sense, they hold no one else to this standard. Also the words terrific and good were brought up by her, she specifically chose them to demean Purdy. You can't start an argument then question why we are arguing. This to me is just attention seeking, dive into a hot topic with a ridiculous take to get views.
😂😂😂 there's nothing nasty about the disagreement or speaking your mind but, let the reality stink in that when you have an open platform. Your vulnerable to the criticism at comes.
When baker had a loaded cleveland and didnt perform explain that brock has done more in 1.5 years than baker done in his whole nfl career baker does not do 1 thing better brock is a year younger than love and this brocks first year starting a full season too like cmon
yeah, Love has one big game and all of a sudden he's better than Brady. meanwhile Brock keeps getting dissed, even though he is easily one of the top 5 QBs in the NFL. am just so fed up with the ignorant fools in the sports media and their NFL diversity hire friends.
She is ignorant. That's all it is. She clearly hasn't watched the tape and she clearly has zero clue (NFL executive or not) of what she is talking about in regards to Brock Purdy specifically. Most of the criticisms that come at Brock Purdy this year come from shear ignorance. Analysts making comments based on simple narratives without watching the film or understanding just what Brock has been doing. I'm not going to be nasty to her or any of them (Nick Wright for example). People don't know what they don't know. Pure. Ignorance. If anything, I feel a bit of pity for them since they are making comments that will be replayed for years to show just how silly and ignorant those comments were.
When someone pushes back she cannot back it up with facts. Brock is never going to stoop to the level of these people so it’s up to us to defend Brock. 😊
She didn't answer Willard's question, she sidestepped it by asking a question about civil debate. He should have deflected her red herring and asked "If you would call 1999 Kurt Warner terrific, despite his supporting cast, why aren't you able to call Brock Purdy terrific despite his supporting cast?".
I think she clarified what she was saying pretty well. She thinks that of all the QBs left int he playoffs, that Purdy is the worst. Not that he is a bad QB, but that the others a re just better. And that's fine if she wants to think that way. I think this always comes back to his draft position, and that he gets to play with a great team. Hopefully Brock can prove this line of thought wrong.
Amy or that person doesn’t make any sense. Using her same reasoning, there will never be a Terrific Niners QB because they are with good players. So the 49ers QBs are penalized because they are in a really good team. But this never happened to the other 49ers QB. These people look down to Brock just because hes drafted last and the attention Brock is getting. Also as much as I love the 49ers we all knew what happened to them last year without Brock. Same good players but no Brock. Also Sad part is people listen to these Snotty people and this mentality will not get Brock any MVP, they can just shove that MVP up their snotty assets. They can never put a good man down. Brock is never going to stoop down to their level. Period.
I like Brock being the underdog and proving all haters wrong after each amazing performance, if Brock was 6'5" 240 and having 4300 yards Brock would be in a different light. I love how Brock blocks out this noise and rises above.
The problem is that all other QBs are judged by one standard, but Brock Purdy is judge by a different standard because of where he was taken in the draft, he's not 6'4", and because he walked into an awesome roster. This is why many 49ers, myself included, take offense to this. What does he have to accomplish to get that credit he deserves? I personally think Brock Purdy sits at # 4 / #5 of the best remaining QBs. Im not delusional and think he is at the level of Mahomes, Lamar, or Allen (yet) but to single him out like she did was ridiculous by saying their are these 7 QBs and then there is BP in ridiculous.
Two words: Jarmcus Russell. Let's not forget that Baker had OBJ, Chubb, Jarvis Landry, Njoku, Hunt, and Hooper with the Browns and couldn't win. Then had CMC and DJ Moore in Carolina.
Every time someone gets called out for crapping on Brock for no good reason, all they can come up with is double speak and gaslighting. "It's not that I don't like him, I think he's good" and yet still decided to make her ignorant initial statement singling out Brock. It's nothing but gaslighting when these clowns get called out for their verbal diarrhea. If you're going to talk crap about someone, have the guts to stand by what you said and be prepared to back it up. Not one of these clowns has done that.
“Baker Mayfield is doing what he’s doing with STAR-LESS TALENT.” At that point I paused the video and said she lost the argument already and we’re not even 1 minute in.
Great video. Great take. It was a really weird interview. Saying "Who cares what I think? Why does it matter if I said good?" She came across really defensive and didnt elaborate on anything. Alot of word salad
I agree with you. She did not clarify anything. Agreeing to disagree does not even play into this. What the W&D guys should have asked is this- you say the other 7 QB's are terrific. Brock is not. He is just good. What is your criteria for terrific? What are the differentiators between good and terrific? What is your criteria for good? What would Brock have to do to be terrific in your mind? What would the other 7 QBs have to 'lose' to be just good in your mind? THESE are the questions that need to be asked! Because we have spitload of data on Brock to provide these answers to. Has she seen the data and the graphs from David Lombardi that show no current QB is even in the neighborhood of Brock's performance this year?
People have forgotten about Joe Montana, about Phil Sims, about Drew Brees, about Fran Tarkenten. There have been many, many successful QBs in the history of the NFL that didn't have a cannon for an arm, that we're these superman heros that Trask seems to think makes a successful QB. There at least 7 rings between the 4 players I mentioned.
Boy, what a backhanded insult to every other team in the playoffs. She said that no one else compares to any other member of the 49ers who's not the QB?
Amy can do math all by herself! Why do we argue so much about good or terrific? Hey, it’s just words. Who cares. Let’s be friends and have a beer. Seven terrific QBs and then Brock Purdy. She’s all about click bait!
Seriously, if you're going to more or less say, seven great quarterbacks and then there's this other guy, you're either trolling for clicks or simply ignorant. And if you deny that you were trolling, then you're being disingenuous or straight out lying. In either case, it's a move that merits no respect. Sorry Amy, you failed to earn my respect, but if you still wanna buy me a beer, fine, but you can't buy my respect.
Great...do we remember how well the previous QBs played with the same talent, before last season? Nowhere near the level of the current QB. To me, the main difference is his ability to read defenses and go through progressions. His ability to do that is closer to Montana & Young, rather than Jimmy and his backups. The talent around him has nothing to do with his ability to read a defense and get the ball to the right spot. Brock is exceptional!
I am a 49ers fan. I have always been a 49ers fan. I agree with her. Brock Purdy is a young quarterback, he has a lot to learn. I have watched him bumble the ball more than a few times. He threw 2 pick 6s in 7 seconds of play. Everybody needs to relax, he is no Tom Brady....Yet. But I can not wait to watch him year by year. I had never heard of Amy Trask but now I have. Well played Amy!
Supporting cast. So did Steve Young and Joe Montana. They had Jerry Rice, TO, John Taylor, Rodger Craig, Brent Jones, Ricky Waters and the list goes on the support they had. Thats not including their O-line and their defense they help with. Brock Purdy beat out Joe and Steve’s passing record in his first full season without having the goat of football Jerry Rice. So put some damn respect on Purdy’s name.
"If you don't have the cast the 49ers have assembled... then having a quarterback that can do a lot with less is something to consider." What an astute observation. Get a good quarterback and solve all your problems?!? By Jove, I think she broke the code.
I like how she said: “wait 49ers fans” after she slighted Brock.. you knew what you were doing. You were looking for click bait right before Forty Niners destroy their way to their sixth chip and you wanted to take advantage of the red and gold wave… Edit: grammar. Words = difficult.
This former CEO of Raiders just explained why Raiders were so bad. How can Love, Goff and Mayfield be more "terrific" than Brock? She's off her medication
Jordan Love is goin to be next Tom Brady. He is terrific. Goff and Mayfield I agreed with you.
Don't talk shit about my girl Amy Trash
Baker had the Browns roster to work with.
He didn’t look as good as Brock
@@jianhkuanghe will be the next Deshaun Watson, a nobody loser
Jordon Love is playing amazingly well right now. Calling him the GOAT now is a bit early 😂.
That said, I don’t think she is that wrong. Hate to say it but Mayfield being the only one obviously worse than Brock.
God help me but I agree with Nick Wright. We have not seen Brock win when they are facing adversity. Closest thing would be the Raiders last year going into OT.
If he shows me that over these playoffs I’ll be happy I bought that Purdy rookie card PSA 10 MNT last year.
Amy Trask doesn't realize what she saying. She can't even elaborate her point of view.
She knows exactly what she's doing. She knew it'd generate tons of attention & it did.
Ya, I gave up listening to her babble at one point becasue she had no point. Some people make comments designed to get themselves viral. I think she did this with that intention.
Yeah exactly. Nothing but respect for her, but she didn’t defend her point with a single piece of data and didn’t even try. Not hating on her just because she’s wrong. I’m hating on the fact she did nothing to substantiate her perspective. It makes her sounds like a salty raiders exec. I want to assume that’s not why she’s saying this but she hasn’t made a single point to defend her point. Raiders down sooooo bad.
She couldn't turn the Raiders into winners. WGAF what this perennial loser thinks?
she just want controversy, thats all, and we buy into it
Brock is really good at taking adversity and shutting up the haters in the next game. Bring it on Amy Trask.
I like the fact ppl down him, it's gonna be beautiful when he shuts them down, I can't wait for the game 💯💯💯
oh Brock Purdy's gonna shut the doubters up against the Packers
Not sure what you mean by adversity since Brock doesn't have a ton of come from behind wins. The niners haven't really faced adversity all year.
@@zacsinden4514I’d say he’s been facing adversity from day one. The dude was literally “Mr Irrelevant”…until he wasn’t. In the face of all the doubters, he’s prevailed and still going. They just can’t handle being wrong like most people in the world.
@@TheGillenium I wouldn't necessarily call playing with 6 All Pros "adversity". Jordan Love plays with zero All Pros and that is more "adversity" than being a QB on the 49ers with a loaded offense
“The most valuable player is the one that makes the most players valuable.” - Payton Manning
That's great!
Spoken like someone who was the CEO of the Raiders for 17 years and only had 3 winning seasons during her entire tenure.
Not to mention when they drafted Jamarcus Russell
Well, we know why the Raiders have sucked for years.
It’s hilarious how she gets defensive when they bring up other great qbs having great supporting cast around them🤣🤣
Hire a woman for a CEO and fail for years that is the moral of story
Bingo!!! Idk why anyone cares what she thinks. Go win a SB Brock!!
Purdy has a better playoff record than Lamar...😂😂
She'd probably take issue if someone said, "Of the Raiders last 8 CEOs, there were 7 terrific ones...and Amy Trask." 😉
I take issue with that statement too. 7 terrific Raiders CEOs? Get real 😂
😂🤣😂🤣
😂😂😂😂😂
Well said
Lmao 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣
The mark of a great quarterback is that they make everyone around them better. Brock has done that. The offensive line was considered our week spot and has gone without much criticism this season because of brocks play. 4 1,000 yard skill players first time in the history of the NFL once again because of Brock. He gets overlooked way too often and isn't given the credit he deserves because of the talent around him but he has helped those talented players reach their potential. JG couldn't do that with the same players and I would argue that even Josh Allen and Lamar haven't done that either
For someone who's tenure had been involved with the likes of Jamarcus Russell, Marques Tuiasosopo, Andrew Walter, and Tyler Wilson--she doesn't have a clue.
THATS WHY RAIDERS FANS CALLED HER AMY TRASH 🚮 😂
Trask accidentally showed her hand because she clearly only values physical traits that jump off the page and doesn't take into account the mental side of the game at all
You don't understand....she was intentionally tanking the rest of the team and looking for a QB who could win anyway lol.
She made herself look stupid. Her comment was mean, ignorant, and unnecessary. They let her off the hook. Brock is up there with 7 first round picks. That says how great he is. She knows it gets attention.
Lamar Jackson's career playoff QB Rating: 68.3 and 1-3 in playoffs. Purdy 109.8 and 2-1 (and that one loss has a HUGE asterisk)
Don’t worry, Lamar Jackson will choke in the first game like he always does
Lamar Jackson plays with 1 All Pro on offense who is a fullback. He plays at an MVP level with very few weapons
@@realistNFLyou do realize becoming all pro isn’t all about that player right? You can be the most talent running back or wide out in the world but if you aren’t featured as much as another dude playing across the country then he gets it you don’t. Also having all-pros is a team thing. If your pass offense is top tier it opens up your run game and vice versa. Saying Lamar only has one all-pro could be viewed as a slight on him for not featuring his guys more
@@PS-ub3kt You can't realistically tell me that Baltimore has their own Trent, CMC, Aiyuk, Kittle, Deebo and Juice and Lamar hasn't unlocked them. Trent, CMC, Aiyuk, Kittle, Deebo and Juice were All Pros or already elite before Purdy. Even Juice is higher rated than their All Pro fullback. The 49ers weapons on offense is historic.
@@realistNFLThat’s easy to do when he runs almost on every play
It’s draft bias. This will always be part of Purdy’s legacy. He plays better with a chip on his shoulder anyway.
Right? Which, to me, proves EXACTLY why Brock is so good. If he was drafted in the 1st round, we wouldn't be having any of this nonsense.
@@darksoulnj If Mayfield had 6 All Pros on offense, would he be "better"?
He plays with a ton of All Pros. Give him the $500 million salary and see how he performs with 1 All Pro
@realist49er Mayfield has Mr consistent Mike Evans and Chris Goodwin. Both are good WRs. No excuses.
@@realistNFL like Mahomes? The media gives grace to Mahomes for his lack of weapons once he got the bag. Jalen Hurts gets the bag and has the same amount of weapons as last season, but he played like trash this year. QBs need great weapons.
We will see if/when Brock gets paid how he will perform with less weapons in the future.
She sounded so dumb and mad. She was the only one that was mad.
The radio hosts just asked her a simple question (the Kurt Warner comparison) and when she realized how wrong she was she got super defensive. Calling out the hosts for being “nasty” to her. It was just a simple question Amy.
You said you wanted good natured discussion on disagreeing, that’s exactly what those guys were doing!!
She evaded that question hella hard. All she is doing is riding the coat tails of every analyst that wrote off Purdy.
Because she knew her stance was not based on a deep researched evaluation. Just a cheap copy cat talking point.
Who really cares what this dumb itch has to say? Look at her record!
Didn't Jimmy have the same team to work with? Our offense didn't explode to full potential until Brock took over.
She’s having a Nikki Haley moment
Former CEO of The Raiders, let’s not neglect that fact.
She really didn't have anything logic to say. Basically, she's like I'm with the raiders organization. I'm only supposed to show nothing but hate towards your team.
Who the fuck is Amy Trask?
2:54 She wants a QB to be inefficient and put the team in danger of losing? Why? Why is this person talking about anything?
Former ceo of the raiders😂
She is trash
Former CEO of the Oakland Raiders. She was there when they drafted Jamarcus Russell, of purple drank fame.
The female version of Mark Davis
@@aaronnavarro1451 small wonder the raiders have gone so far downhill over the years...i don't respect her.
“Seven terrific QBs and Brock Purdy…” Well, Brock is in a class by himself. He is the smartest QB of the eight in the playoffs. He’s not like her elite 7, and per Brock, he doesn’t want to be like them (as he mentioned in his interview with Steve Young.) We love him just the way he is. ❤
You have to remember she was part of the Raiders organization. She is a hater because the Raiders has far less success the 49ers. The Raiders were always the step brother to the 49ers in Bay Area football
Truth! 😎
She deflected the criticism and avoided sharing with the public her reasoning. Notice how she devoted to say "why this or that is an issue" rather than saying "hey, I just look at the tape/stats" or "I don't look at all, but that is my feel". In psycology, that kind of avoidance, cleverly done by her by the way, is done to hide the fact that she did not use a sound rationale. So her "gut" or "feel" is what she may have to defend in this debate... and she is not willing to do it, nor hear about it. And then have a beer.
She skipped over the Warner convo 🤦♂️
Because she doesn't know him lol 😂 she is like"why are you being mean to me for having an opinion" she got exposed
The Warner question shows she knows nothing about football. She basically is just regurgitating stuff she hears on espn. I bet she had to Google who Kurt is, after the interview.
Yup, then she tried to do what women do best and manipulate them and blame them about being caught up on the word “good and great” like Bih u decided to use those adjectives and these guys are just debating the same argument with the same supporting casts with similar QBs gets called great. She literally got cornered and tried to manipulate the convo into not disagreeing in a nasty manner. 😂😂😂 The kitchen is waiting for her.
She got real emotional to try and back out of accountability
She skipped because she knew she f’ked up
Brock Purdy will be Super Bowl mvp and people still will not believe in him but as a guy who wanted Trey lance to be our starter at the beginning of the year I am all in on this guy, he is our qb and he is legit and I trust him to bring us our 6th ring
Steve Young 2 years in dystopian Tampa = hideous
Steve Young 13 years in harmonious San Francisco = HOF player
We don't question the validity of his career though. Definitely a new era of football commentary.
Walsh said it best Young had elite talent but Tampa didn't have the players or the coaches to get that out of him.
FACTS
@@TinoR626 there's a reason why they call football the ultimate team sport. hell look at patrick mahomes this year. what good is a qb if you got recievers dropping balls.
He could run. Purdy can't. He had arm talent. Purdy doesn't. He's in the HOF. Purdy will be exposed as soon as a couple of pieces are gone from this offense.
She said it all at 5:20. "When I look at the 8 qb's". Is she an analyst? Does she know how to evaluate qb play? Does she understand what the qb is being asked to do? Does she see what Brock is improvising as things unfold? Does she see the success that Brock is manifesting vs what's being given?
Some talking heads are arguing that yac shouldn't be credited to Purdy, but then the analysts are calling those 20 yard throws "handoffs". Purdy is so accurate and consistent that those throws essentially become handoffs. He's so good that haters see that as typical play.
One more thing. Mahomes literally had the best TE kelce and tyreek hill. But no one discredited Mahomes for that. It pisses me off and I just can’t wait for us to shut everyone up
Well I think mahomes is way way over-rated. Yeah, just wait & you'll see
THIS!!! Wonder boy mahomes makes a 40yard pass and the NFL is sucking him off. Purdy does the same thing and it’s because he’s throwing the ball to deebo or kittle. -_- seriously. Now i was purdy to win it all just to see what the media will bash him for.
@@manuelastoria679, agreed. When Peyton Manning had Edgerrin James, Reggie Wayne and Marvin Harrison, nobody was clowning on him.
@@jasonklein5387I was clowning him because he had a losing record in the playoffs!!!
Don't forget Hunt was on the team too.
Brock Purdy is our quarterback and will take us to great places.
Patrick Mahomes also walked in a good situation Starting after Alex Smith. The team had many of the playmakers Alex smith had, Mahomes did elevate them much like Purdy has done with BA, Deebo, Kittle, and CMC all of them hitting over 1000 yards.
The Kurt warner question was a perfect comparison with the situation Brock is in but she clearly is devious and needs to make sure her opinion is right. She is 100% being biased here. It seems like a desperation attempt to keep relevancy for herself or lime light
Not a good comparison at all. She didn't understand the question. Do you think she knows anybody on that team other than warner? I'd say the radio hosts botched the interview
The irony would be. If he wins a chip in the stadium of her old team😂
There were 7 terrific quarterbacks and one quarterback who had the force in him. Also when the going gets tough the good quarterback becomes clutch and Amy Trask terrific quarterbacks throws picks
It's like being a point guard on a team where the other four starters average 30 points a game. At some point even the most clueless observer stumbles on the idea that maybe the guy distributing the ball is kind of important to making the whole thing work. Yeah, he plays on a team with great skill players. But he gets the most out of them. Which is basically the job of a quarterback. Funny that they're all, coincidentally, putting up career numbers with Brock facilitating the offense. But of course, somehow, he has nothing to do with that.
Like John Stockton averaged 13 points a game but is in the NBA HoF.
If this conversation was 4 QB's. Allen,Mahomes, Lamar, and Brock and she said 3 elite QB;s and Brock it wouldn't be a big deal. But the fact she is putting Baker and Goff into that terrific category and leaving out Brock is where she loses all merit.
She's really putting Baker Mayfield and Jordan Love above Brock Purdy? Brock has literally been one of the best QBs in the league since he stepped on the field. She obviously has no clue what she's talking about, which you can see when she was asked point blank, why? She didn't give a single answer, just repeated that she doesn't put him in the same category as the others, which obviously means that he just doesn't look like the prototypical QB and he was drafted last. It's like Gattaca, he is destined to be a terrible QB by birth. He could never outplay his "potential."
Jordan love is absolutely better than purdy. Check the stats and compare them to the weapons and coach.
Although I rank purdy for goff and baker fs
over
@@thomasalexander5738he's not tho. He misses clear reads and has terrable footwork. He's a dak nothing more.
@@thomasalexander5738you will see who is better come Saturday.
I wish they had just asked her if she actually watched tape and if so what did he need to do better to be better than Baker Mayfield, Jordan Love, CJ Stroud, or Jared Goff.
Saturday can’t come soon enough….
Agreed 100%
But watch what happens if we win, everyone is gonna down Purdy AGAIN and say it's "the system and his weapons" instead of his own abilities and that the packers were never good to begin with, it's never gonna stop I swear
God I hope we win or else it’s gonna be 12 months more of this insane crap this lady is spewing. They’ve created an impossible scenario for Brock. If he excels, it’s because of his surrounding talent. If he falters, it’s because he sucks.
Brock had one of the most efficient seasons a QB has ever had. So there’s nothing more he can do to prove them wrong. Which is why this needs to be our year to win the last game.
More fuel for the fire 🔥
Who cares what they think. They are talking on some bs before the game even started.
BP is doing more with less money. How bout that!?
It’s a compliment to Brock so they ignore it.
This is all part of the magical story of Brock Purdy. The modest, grounded, humble 'boy next door'. Watching the story unfold before our eyes, the likes of which movies are made is good for the soul. People will say what people will say. There are villains and hero's in every story. Rooting for the underdog is what America is built on. Let the man play and let the chips fall where they may.
Let’s list the QBs Trask’s Raiders signed;
Terrell Pryor
Carson Palmer
Jason Campbell
JaMarcus Russell
Josh McCown
Andrew Walter
Kerry Collins
Rick Mirer
Rich Gannon
Jeff George
Daunte Culpepper
11 Starting QBs in 16 years and an overall record of 98-142. The season after she left they drafted Derek Carr, statistically the greatest Raiders QB of all time by a long shot.
Enough said.
This is probably why she is a FORMER executive 😆😆😆
She isnt an exec anymore and when she was an exec it was for the worst org in the league. Her words mean nothing
Purdy doesn’t get enough credit because he’s the last pick.
No, not because he was picked last. It is because he has a genius play caller as a coach, excellent casts of RB, FB, TE and WR. I think especially he doesn't do those flashy runs is why.
@@tommydong8070 It's a combination of it all. He was the very last pick, has a lot of talent around him, and has Kyle calling the plays. With that being said, he is apart of the final four and a lot of people fail to mention that our offense improved dramatically when he first took over for Jimmy.
She took a shot at Purdy by isolating him from the other playoff QBs and she supported her claim with his surrounding cast argument that is lazy and surface level. A person that was in high rankings of an organization shouldn’t be taking shots at a player if she hasn’t watched the tape. It makes her look bad and now she’s on defense. Crazy how people are trying to knock him down a peg instead of talking him up for being in the same place as 7 other first rounders.
She still didn't explain why he is "good" because of his teammates, but not every other QB isn't?!?! The QB does not throw, catch, run, sack, int, or tackle!!!! It takes a team to win!! She kept crying about ppl being mean to her!!
Lamar is 1-3 in the playoffs with 5TDs and 7INTs!!!!
I’ll say what I posted on X… if your argument is that BP is surrounded by so much talent then I would argue that with all due respect to Jimmy G, but Jimmy also had the same ammo that Brock has and wasn’t able to accomplish what Brock Purdy has. Not only has BP broke his own record as a QB in Niner franchise and played a perfect game, but he also helped 4 of his teammates surpass 1k in a single season. Oh and let’s not forget this is his 1st season as a starter, sooo yeah Purdy great to me.
Notice that she never answered the Warner comparison question and deflected to being nice lmaoooooo 😂
I felt that she was trying to buy time to think of a response and when she couldnt she wanted to shift the conversation
She had nothing to say 😂
I noticed how she couldn’t understand the simplest question and comparison possible, and now I understand why the Raiders drafted Jamarcus Russell.
Her not understanding the Kurt Warner question when that was her basis for diminishing Brock's play, completely tanks any of her credibility. She needs to sit this one out.
Purdy, literally, out-played ever QB in the NFL this year. He is 5th in yards (4,280 - club record) DESPITE being 20th in attempts. He leads in QB rating, QBR, deep-ball passing percentage (NFL record) and deep ball efficiency (NFL record). His air-yards, per attempt, is 1.5 yards deeper than the #2 QB. And he does all that behind a line with Trent Williams and the Four Mid-Guys.
I'll put it to you like this if you're irrelevant. All you have to do is mention Brock Purdy's name and boom. The views and the attention will come. Brock is the most talked about Qb in the league. Hell, at this point, kuddos to him. He is doing something right because he got everybody chatting saying his name that alone speaks volumes forget the haters. We, the fan base, know what we got, and we gone ride with Brock til the end.
yea, it sounds like clickbait. kinda like when cam said purdy was a game manager. the fact that amy isn't an evaluator any more should show how good she was at her job anyways.
The question that should have followed up after her statement was; "What is your criteria in evaluating quarterbacks?" This would help explain what her reasoning is, at the very least.
Arguably, even mahomes had a worse year than purdy.
I think you could take the arguably out of that sentence. And yes I realize a lot had to do with his lack of weapons, but that kind of proves that QBs need weapons to consistently be great
She had no rebuttal for the Kurt Warner question. Completely avoided it. I had that exact same argument with some people. Used the exact same example. There are dozens of examples.
It’s so funny Jordan love wins one game and now he’s a elite quarterback, they hate on Brock because he plays the position the cleanest and most efficient and sense he’s not a first round pick he’s only doing it because of his coach and his teammates the media just finds way to hate because they were wrong about Brock
that was the problem, she put her foot in her mouth with no clarification why she felt that way about Purdy. But Instead was the same bland, generic criticism we've been hearing about Purdy all season long.
Look at the video closely. She looks like she had a few, just sayin. Her face is flush. Why was the mean girl commentary necessary AT ALL??? SHE IS GOING FOR ROGER GODELL'S JOB OR SOMETHING?
Let’s set this in perspective. After 25 starts in the NFL Brock Purdy breaks the 49ers all-time passing record and is rated in the top three this year statistically among quarterbacks all after 25 starts. Can you imagine what this kid will look like by the end of fourth season?
I think what is getting over looked, and unquestionably she’s earned respect, is exactly how she put it. It wasn’t remotely respectful:
“There are 7 terrific quarterbacks… and Brock Purdy.”
What reaction would she expect? Good news is it’s football. Brock can settle it with the scoreboard and a ring.
The Amy Trask’s of football will die on the JaMarcus Russell hills and NEVER accept a Purdy.
yet she later tried to spin it as being respectful when it clearly wasn't...intellectually dishonest.
@@douglasscovil3447 Yes. And kinda surprising from her as she’s usually more sincere. I have to chalk it up to her being a Niner hater. And that’s not the usual “hater” online label. She worked with the Raiders opposite side of the Bay for decades. Her 49ers hate is earned and runs deep. She probably thinks Montana was vastly overrated.
She is a certified idiot... Who can even give her the loudspeaker to give an opinion?? ... Obviously she has not even looked at the stats to compare ..
Exactly! You can’t possible phrase an insult more transparently than that, and act surprised when you can’t walk it back. That’s clown behavior.
Yeah, unfortunately I think anyone associated with the raiders has a hard time recognizing talent when they see it but, cheers to disagreeing
Nobody talks about how when Brock got hurt in the NFC championship game and Josh Johnson, a guy with way more NFL experience than Brock, came in and couldn't do anything with the same exact roster of players that everyone tries to discredit Brock for having. Just because you have a great supporting cast doesn't mean you can just plug and play any QB and keep doing the same things you were doing offensively. If anything, Brock helped turn Brandon Aiyuk into one of the best WR's in the league this year, but the "experts" haven't thought about that at all. We Niners fans know what we have in Brock and that's all that matters at the end of the day.
She has the credentials to have an opinion, and she's wholeheartedly entitled to it. I love Baker's enthusiasm for the game etc., but there ain't no way he's better than Purdy. Whatever Raider-infused hate she has for the 9ers, she gotta let that hurt go. Too much salt ain't good for ya soul, sister.
Does she? I understand she was a Raiders exec but exactly in what capacity was QB ANALYSIS FACTOR IN TO HER JOB DESCRIPTION? ITS JUST HER OPINION AND I SWEAR THE ACTUAL INTERVIEW SHE LOOKED LIKE SHE HAD A FEW, HER FACE WAS FLUSHED. F HER.
I even call her credentials to question considering the state of the Raiders the past few years. Essentially no playoff success and a disaster of head coaching carrousel. What have they done in her tenure to say she has accolades to merit her opinion?
No QB in the NFC is better than Brock purdy Lol 😜............ AFC. Mahomes, Allen, and Jackson are a little better because they been in the league longer Lol.
Her credentials are riding the coat tails of so many analysts. She has no clue.
She has ZERO credentials.
Shes a LOSER. A dum wo man
Interviewers did a terrible job pressing her on it. She got away with another vague response. Here’s the easy question:
“So if I was to show you 20 high level throws Brock made this season would you say those throws are because of his teammates??”
🤔
After this foolish word salad, one has to wonder if she really did her own math to come up with 8 total remaining playoff QBs. Yet another ignorant self-promoter who either hasn't seen more than a few highlight packages or knows nothing about QB play.
Note that Trask isn't able to elucidate her point. It's because she doesn't understand football
I would ask her, name a QB who has won the chip without a good offense/defense. She got called out for a horrible take, and can't handle the criticisms that come with it.
They had good offenses but not 6 All Pros good. Tom Brady only played with 2 or 3 All Pros per year for example
@@realistNFL If that's the argument you wish to make, you could just as easily frame it as is it a case of All Pro players simply making a quarterback better or does the quarterback in fact elevate the level of play in the All Pro players around him?
Case in point, Mike Evans career stats are eye-popping. 10 seasons in the league, perennial pro bowler, over 1000 years in every single one of them. Career averages of 76.2 receptions, 1168 yards and 15.2 ypc. He was BELOW his career averages in every one of those categories with Brady as his QB. He actually put up better numbers in the seasons he played with Jameis Winston and Baker Mayfield. Similarly worth noting, Chris Godwin's career highs in catches, yardage and YPC all happened in non-Brady seasons.
On the other hand, perennial all-pro George Kittle just had a career high of 15.7 ypc, and Brandon Aiyuk had a breakout season, leading the league at 17.9 ypc. And if you bother to do a deep dive, the production of both players has been markedly better with Purdy at QB.
I don't think the Brady comparison is the winning argument most people assume it is. Brady didn't have his breakout season until his seventh year in the league. In 22 years as an NFL QB he only had three seasons where he put up numbers on par with what Brock has accomplished in his rookie season and year two. For most of his career, Brady was the very definition of a "game manager" whose primary job was not to screw things up. He had the good fortune to have played on teams with top tier defenses and top quality offensive lines (certainly much better than Purdy has) and his role was never to be great or spectacular, but to just be good enough. And he played his role. Nothing more, nothing less.
She threw rocks and put her hands up, notice she was scared to stand on what she said
She wasn't expecting push back on her stance. You can hear it in her voice.
She so disingenuous. She was taking a shot at Brock and she knows it. It was disrespectful and rude. Now she’s crying about people pushing back and being rude, saying “we don’t all have to agree! Don’t be mean to me!”
I just used the Kurt Warner argument lol. It doesn't make sense, they hold no one else to this standard.
Also the words terrific and good were brought up by her, she specifically chose them to demean Purdy. You can't start an argument then question why we are arguing. This to me is just attention seeking, dive into a hot topic with a ridiculous take to get views.
This isn't about ranking QBs. She put Purdy in a different class than the other 7 QBs which is completely insane.
Congratulations!!! A few more people now have heard your name Amy.. mission Accomplished, but Nick wright gave you the Blueprint!!
😂😂😂 there's nothing nasty about the disagreement or speaking your mind but, let the reality stink in that when you have an open platform. Your vulnerable to the criticism at comes.
Didn't this dummy help draft Jamarcus syrup ?
Yep😂
She has ZERO credibility.
Her ability to dodge questions and refusal to accept responsibility is commendable 🤣
Typical “high level” personality
When baker had a loaded cleveland and didnt perform explain that brock has done more in 1.5 years than baker done in his whole nfl career baker does not do 1 thing better brock is a year younger than love and this brocks first year starting a full season too like cmon
yeah, Love has one big game and all of a sudden he's better than Brady. meanwhile Brock keeps getting dissed, even though he is easily one of the top 5 QBs in the NFL. am just so fed up with the ignorant fools in the sports media and their NFL diversity hire friends.
What she really meant was 7 "terrific" 1st round picks... and Brock Purdy .
defensive and backtracking lol
She is ignorant. That's all it is. She clearly hasn't watched the tape and she clearly has zero clue (NFL executive or not) of what she is talking about in regards to Brock Purdy specifically. Most of the criticisms that come at Brock Purdy this year come from shear ignorance. Analysts making comments based on simple narratives without watching the film or understanding just what Brock has been doing. I'm not going to be nasty to her or any of them (Nick Wright for example). People don't know what they don't know. Pure. Ignorance. If anything, I feel a bit of pity for them since they are making comments that will be replayed for years to show just how silly and ignorant those comments were.
When someone pushes back she cannot back it up with facts. Brock is never going to stoop to the level of these people so it’s up to us to defend Brock. 😊
She didn't answer Willard's question, she sidestepped it by asking a question about civil debate. He should have deflected her red herring and asked "If you would call 1999 Kurt Warner terrific, despite his supporting cast, why aren't you able to call Brock Purdy terrific despite his supporting cast?".
I think she clarified what she was saying pretty well. She thinks that of all the QBs left int he playoffs, that Purdy is the worst. Not that he is a bad QB, but that the others a re just better. And that's fine if she wants to think that way. I think this always comes back to his draft position, and that he gets to play with a great team. Hopefully Brock can prove this line of thought wrong.
Amy or that person doesn’t make any sense. Using her same reasoning, there will never be a Terrific Niners QB because they are with good players. So the 49ers QBs are penalized because they are in a really good team. But this never happened to the other 49ers QB. These people look down to Brock just because hes drafted last and the attention Brock is getting. Also as much as I love the 49ers we all knew what happened to them last year without Brock. Same good players but no Brock. Also Sad part is people listen to these Snotty people and this mentality will not get Brock any MVP, they can just shove that MVP up their snotty assets. They can never put a good man down. Brock is never going to stoop down to their level. Period.
It's just the fact she made the point of saying "7 terrific quarterbacks and Brock Purdy". Why does she have to put him down like that.
I like Brock being the underdog and proving all haters wrong after each amazing performance, if Brock was 6'5" 240 and having 4300 yards Brock would be in a different light. I love how Brock blocks out this noise and rises above.
The problem is that all other QBs are judged by one standard, but Brock Purdy is judge by a different standard because of where he was taken in the draft, he's not 6'4", and because he walked into an awesome roster. This is why many 49ers, myself included, take offense to this. What does he have to accomplish to get that credit he deserves? I personally think Brock Purdy sits at # 4 / #5 of the best remaining QBs. Im not delusional and think he is at the level of Mahomes, Lamar, or Allen (yet) but to single him out like she did was ridiculous by saying their are these 7 QBs and then there is BP in ridiculous.
Two words: Jarmcus Russell. Let's not forget that Baker had OBJ, Chubb, Jarvis Landry, Njoku, Hunt, and Hooper with the Browns and couldn't win. Then had CMC and DJ Moore in Carolina.
Every time someone gets called out for crapping on Brock for no good reason, all they can come up with is double speak and gaslighting. "It's not that I don't like him, I think he's good" and yet still decided to make her ignorant initial statement singling out Brock. It's nothing but gaslighting when these clowns get called out for their verbal diarrhea. If you're going to talk crap about someone, have the guts to stand by what you said and be prepared to back it up. Not one of these clowns has done that.
Jamarcus, Andrew Walter, Tuiasasopo, josh mccown, matt mcgloin, bruce gradkowski, yeah she knows quarterbacks.
Isn't that what a NFL team is supposed to do get the best players
“Baker Mayfield is doing what he’s doing with STAR-LESS TALENT.” At that point I paused the video and said she lost the argument already and we’re not even 1 minute in.
Great video. Great take. It was a really weird interview. Saying "Who cares what I think? Why does it matter if I said good?" She came across really defensive and didnt elaborate on anything. Alot of word salad
I agree with you. She did not clarify anything. Agreeing to disagree does not even play into this. What the W&D guys should have asked is this- you say the other 7 QB's are terrific. Brock is not. He is just good. What is your criteria for terrific? What are the differentiators between good and terrific? What is your criteria for good? What would Brock have to do to be terrific in your mind? What would the other 7 QBs have to 'lose' to be just good in your mind? THESE are the questions that need to be asked! Because we have spitload of data on Brock to provide these answers to. Has she seen the data and the graphs from David Lombardi that show no current QB is even in the neighborhood of Brock's performance this year?
EAST COAST MEDIA!!! :LOOK AT ME!!!"
People have forgotten about Joe Montana, about Phil Sims, about Drew Brees, about Fran Tarkenten. There have been many, many successful QBs in the history of the NFL that didn't have a cannon for an arm, that we're these superman heros that Trask seems to think makes a successful QB. There at least 7 rings between the 4 players I mentioned.
Boy, what a backhanded insult to every other team in the playoffs. She said that no one else compares to any other member of the 49ers who's not the QB?
Amy can do math all by herself! Why do we argue so much about good or terrific? Hey, it’s just words. Who cares. Let’s be friends and have a beer. Seven terrific QBs and then Brock Purdy. She’s all about click bait!
Seriously, if you're going to more or less say, seven great quarterbacks and then there's this other guy, you're either trolling for clicks or simply ignorant. And if you deny that you were trolling, then you're being disingenuous or straight out lying. In either case, it's a move that merits no respect. Sorry Amy, you failed to earn my respect, but if you still wanna buy me a beer, fine, but you can't buy my respect.
why are you defending this idiot? she gets absolutely no respect.
It's just odd that somebody at her NFL knowledge level to make such a blatant statement about Purdy, when there are other comparable QBs in the mix.
Great...do we remember how well the previous QBs played with the same talent, before last season? Nowhere near the level of the current QB. To me, the main difference is his ability to read defenses and go through progressions. His ability to do that is closer to Montana & Young, rather than Jimmy and his backups. The talent around him has nothing to do with his ability to read a defense and get the ball to the right spot. Brock is exceptional!
I think everybody remember Tom Brady was a backup quarterback, and when he got the chance he never look back up.
I am a 49ers fan. I have always been a 49ers fan. I agree with her. Brock Purdy is a young quarterback, he has a lot to learn. I have watched him bumble the ball more than a few times. He threw 2 pick 6s in 7 seconds of play. Everybody needs to relax, he is no Tom Brady....Yet. But I can not wait to watch him year by year. I had never heard of Amy Trask but now I have. Well played Amy!
Supporting cast.
So did Steve Young and Joe Montana. They had Jerry Rice, TO, John Taylor, Rodger Craig, Brent Jones, Ricky Waters and the list goes on the support they had. Thats not including their O-line and their defense they help with. Brock Purdy beat out Joe and Steve’s passing record in his first full season without having the goat of football Jerry Rice. So put some damn respect on Purdy’s name.
"If you don't have the cast the 49ers have assembled... then having a quarterback that can do a lot with less is something to consider."
What an astute observation. Get a good quarterback and solve all your problems?!? By Jove, I think she broke the code.
I like how she said: “wait 49ers fans” after she slighted Brock.. you knew what you were doing. You were looking for click bait right before Forty Niners destroy their way to their sixth chip and you wanted to take advantage of the red and gold wave…
Edit: grammar. Words = difficult.