Classical Musicians React: EXO 'Going Crazy' vs 'Forever'
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ก.ค. 2018
- For the 74th reaction video of Season 2 of this series, Classical Music Majors react to EXO's Going Crazy vs Forever.
Check out the lyric video for Going Crazy here: • Video
Check out the lyric video for Forever here: • EXO (엑소) - Forever Lyr...
~Reaction Schedule:
docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
~ Complete to-react list: • Playlist
~ Will not react to list: • Will not be reacting to
~Channel instagram: @reacttothek_official
~ Channel twitter: @reacttothek
~ Channel tumblr: / reacttothek
~ Channel Facebook: / reacttothek
~Support us on Patreon and get extra access to videos you’ll never see on YT: / reacttothek
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video editing by Umu
Intro design by Alex Chen (website: www.acchen.com/)
Thumbnail credit goes to Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram: @_emcha_
/ omg-horns
/ bangtan-fanart
/ funny-vixx
(kpop, mamamoo, bts, vixx) Amino app: Umu @ ReacttotheK
(business manager) Eric:
Twitter: @ricekangaroo
Isaac:
Twitter: @IsaacJRLi
Henry:
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Tumblr: / pjohnzzz
Charlotte:
Instagram: charmander_97
Her cat’s instagram: monty_le_chat_noir
Jarod:
Instagram: @JVLPhotographic
and @Jarod_lau
Katie:
Instagram: @katieknudsvig
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
TH-cam: nerdymusicks
Insta: @nerdymusick
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Naoki:
Instagram: @naokitoyomura
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
Emiel:
Fb: Emiel De Jaegher
Insta: @trumpetoats
(Stephen & James N/A)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that. This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music. On top of that, if you think that they aren't commenting enough on the music, it's because /nothing/ is happening IN the music to comment on. It may be a great song/bop/huge hit that they're listening to, but that does not mean there are actual complicated musical things happening that they'd be able to talk about. - บันเทิง
![*READ DESCRIPTION* LDN Noise Panel KCON LA - Forever Acapella [FULL]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1nQwWIfJSo4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[EXO] The EℓyXiOn dot - 中 내가미쳐(Going Crazy)](/img/n.gif)
"I was going crazy at Going Crazy and I could listen to Forever forever" is an underrated quote 10/10
Tricia Tea I laughed really loud
BWAHHAHAHAHA
God damn true
EXO have one of the best b-sides songs in the industry. That's it.
THIS is the comment
We been knew
facts
Chae Rin Lee yes
Facts
“He sounds like a violin”
tn Even his name foreshadowed his fate in music industry. Jong Dae literally translates to Great Bell 💞
Sora Haneul really?! I didn’t know that
Sora Haneul 💓💓💓💓💓😍😍😍😍😍
@@sorahaneul7112 he be living up to his name
thats our jongdae
"Do you have a favorite?"
"Whenever he's rapping"
tbh S A M E
😅
Sehun
"I would strip to this" "Wow...wow....WOW"
I felt that lol
blacknetizen honestly 😂😂
Lol 😂
STEPH
MOOD
i remember listening to going crazy and what u do and i was like “ *these* are the b sides”
edit: wow hello likes
angeline yeah me too when i listening to diamond like damn that's the best b side song i've ever heard
angeline i thought like that for forever lol exo always have some title worthy beside tracks
I’m not lying the first time I heard going crazy I listened to it like 30 times especially chanyeols ‘up and down like a rollercoaster...’ and diamond was brilliant.
Zara SAME GURLLL
*Same reaction to Chill and Sweet Lies. I was speechless*
Umu, not trying to be THAT person, but please let them react to gravity by exo. Our lord and saviour LDN Noise also produced it and it is fuNKY
Yessssss please Gravity sounded like these songs
The live version, please
And oh la la
YEESS
and yayaya
The production of every EXO’s song is amazing.
EXO VOCALS ARE NO JOKE
“i was going crazy over going crazy. this i could listen to forever.”
i-
"He sounds like a violin" YES JONGDAE
Am I the only one who refall in love with EXO's songs after watching such reactions? I'm going to listen to THE WAR album for the millionth time
me tooo and i’m pretty proud of being exo’s fan
Same everytime I miss them I always comeback to reaction vids
@@pennyuy9432 ME TOO
ME TOO, re discovering my love for them
"spanking his face with the flowers" I CACKLED-
FOREVER IS AMAZING!!!!! My fave song on the album!!
jrose7000 me too! Every night bfore i sleep i losten to it first!! Love it very much!!!!!
GREAT MIND THINKS ALIKE BCS SAMEEEE
mary ann gallardo Me Three! I wish they would do a MV for it.
Queen Seven-Bey we should have our own team name FOREVER gang! Lol😂😂😂
Queen Seven-Bey guys have u already voted for exo in billboard? For who will perform in superbowl? Pls guys go there and vote heheheh
hugo: "oh shit that run, i wasn't ready"
COSMIC RAILWAY REACT TO COSMIC RAILWAY PLEASE
YESSSS
It's a Japanese song so it is copyrighted and they can get a strike from it
THIS IS IT CHIEF!!!!!!!!!
Yesss 😍
YES PLS
The War was a solid album can't wait for them to comeback
Koko Chen Please vote for EXO @FIFAWorlcup in Twitter so they can play power! And pass the message.
Illa GG We won!!!
Es hoy, es hoy!!!
"LDN Noise our lord and savior" MOOD
😂
8:08
“VOCALS”
*shows dominant vocal line*
(whatever you wanna call dae, baek, and soo)
Hi, can you let the musicians react to other EXO's b-side tracks:
Sweet Lies
El Dorado
Been Through
Thunder
The Eve
Lady Luck
Black Pearl
Thank you :)
Add white noise💛
Artificial love.
Lucky.
EL DORADO IS MY BOP
And Diamond too please XD
FINALLY EXO
mood for like every reaction account
baekbeaux yaaas
baekbeaux Please vote for EXO @FIFAWorlcup in Twitter so they can play power! And pass the message.
Sehun’s rapping is being recognized!!!
yahoo!! sehun the best! :D
“whenever he’s (sehun) rapping” is honestly a whole mood. She’s such an intellectual
EXO BEEN THROUGH AND SWEET LIES PLEASE
yes omfg been through is their best song
When i see EXO’s music being disected and just praised for how unique it is, i feel so proud of actually stanning this revolutionary group.
Also Henry, i see you praising EXO’s vocals😏
I'm Korean fan of EXO. I didn't expect to see the reaction of going crazy!!!!! That's my favorite EXO's song and I'm so proud of their reaction of vocals!!!! I love your reaction😁😁😁
한예진
I love EXO so much, I'm a new fan.......they are very famous here in Europe. EXO vocals are amazing.....I'm excited for their comeback.
한예진
I'm planning to buy EXO's new album.....can you tell where we can order it.
Shon A ktown4u.com
Lenti Suhin
Thank you so much.... I'll order the comeback album.
"I would strip to this." THIS MAN IS AN INTELLECTUAL LADIES AND GENTLEMEN.
6:07
"he's spanking his face with the flowers"
Im dead 💀
I mean, they’re thirsty for some live EXO, I think it’s time for El Dorado and Wolf (or Lightsaber) at the Tokyo Dome
LawlietKun11 OMG Wolf in Tokio Dome 😤😤😤
Didn't they said they want live intrumental of the song? I mean someone play the song using instrumental live?
Teh Yang maybe, I heard “live” and my mind went immediately to Tokyo Dome
13:25
YAASS THEY NEED TO MAKE THIS HAPPEN
EXO B-track is always always goood. They always deliver, which is why i don't feel it is such a waste to buy their albums. They recorded a constant millions album sales for a reason
Angel Yixing Please vote for EXO @FIFAWorlcup in Twitter so they can play power! And pass the message.
Illa GG already did. I'm active on twitter
Angel Yixing yay!! We still behind I hope others keep voting!
Ikr
Waste?? Wouldn’t you buy to support them?? That legit what helps them to keep making music
i know this is an old video but whoever did the going crazy lyric video really has no idea who exo is sksksk
Ikr like even if the voice is different they keep the same member
I feel irritated when watching the lyric video
Just the thought of strangers will mistake their voices irritates me 😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣
yup from the start i was like “is that not jongdae????”
DAMN RIGHT I WAS ANNOYED
Not surprised they win album of the year because their bsides are really good
I'm so EXO deprived so thank you
Tahmina Rahman Please go on Twitter and vote for Exo’s Power to be played at the FIFA World Cup! There are about 16 hours left to vote!!! Thank you and please help to spread the word!!!! mobile.twitter.com/fifaworldcup/status/1014523639218262016?s=21
CHANYEOL'S VOICE IS A MASTERPIECE
Finally!! You show them a song that EXO’s vocals show!!! 🔥
Exo vocals are one of the most insane things
They are the definition of a legendary group
Kings of vocals(chen baek kyungsoo and suho,true vocal line)
King of visuals
Amazing perfomers
Good rap line
Amazing dancing(kai and lay are in the top 10 best dancers of kpop,sehun too is amazing dancer)
" I would strip to this" Me to the whole War album.
EXO'S MUSIC IS ART
I feel really proud and happy when ppl like Exo and their music as well and compliment the geniuses like YES! those are my babies!!
Im not that skilled and educated in the music field to actually notice certaint things but these song are just done so well. The first time i listened to going crazy it was madness i couldn't get enough of it because it was so good. I wanna go back in time to experience listening to it for the first time again.
same it sounded like a mess. but the beautiful meant to be mess
I love when they replayed that part in going crazy and showed everyone’s reaction and all of them were surprised. Going crazy is the best song in the war. No, scratch that, the war is the album of the century 🙌🏻
GOING CRAZY AND FOREVER ARE MY NATIONAL ANTHEMS
Hahahaha
You guys are impressed because EXO has incredible voices ♥
yes exo voice are really good
Sis, wat are iu diun hir xD
Okno, es muy cierto, EXO tiene unas de las voces más increíbles del kpop
LDN Noise our lord and saviors: I know that's right. Forever is quite possibly one of, probably top 5, b-sides of EXO's. It's that good.
"whenever he's rapping"
Hear that SM? GIVE HIM MORE LINES.
YOO this is a great comparison! But if they heard how strange “Chill” sounded with that sudden change with Chanyeol’s Rap I’m sure they would flip XD
yeahh😂
If they react to the whole album, i swear at least half of them will buy the album. That good. Its like riding a rollercoster
Yes that switch up is crazy 🔥
I love Chill so much 🤣🤣
Yeah. The bridge of chill is crazy!
*SWEET LIES VS BEEN THROUGH*
i want stay but been through is the crowd favorite
Yaaasss.....I love all the songs in Universe album.
YES
I LOVE ALL SONGS TOO!!! it's labelled as a winter album, but what EXO has released is a timeless album-something you could listen to no matter what season, or whatever mood you have.
Angelo
That's so true.....my friend never heard K-pop before but I made him listen Universe album. He was surprised that the songs sounded really good......he is following EXO on Spotify now.
10:00 kevin- mhmmm pretty good, its okay...
0.5 seconds later----
Favorite moment
Me listen to forever "MELON ARE YOU READYYYYYYYYYY"
I feel like their next comeback will be legendary. I can feel it in my vEINS.
Oh My God! I felt the same!
And they will comeback soon. I can't wait 😍
Iridescent Beatrice same.
SAME
OMG BTCH SAME I CANT WAIT
*DO BEEN THROUGH AND STAY*
I'm going to faint.
Iridescent Beatrice !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YESSSS PLS if they havent yet 🙏
Yes they have to. Been Through is a total masterpiece like all of their songs 🤣
LIGHTS OUT TOO ㅠ
dodo corn omg trueee how could I forget that masterpiece too
LIGHTS OUT KFKKKFJFJFJFJ
'Forever' is the most underreated song of EXO
Dont believe me? Check out LDN's breakdown of the song
And one of the best too!
Reacting to the whole Universe album might be too much to ask for. But maybe you could do Been Through, Fall, Stay and/or Lights Out? All EXO's winter albums has always been solid 💞
15:53 I LOVE AN INTELLECTUAL😭
Yup
“whenever HE is rapping” sis same.
afnanilla yeeeeaaaah!!!!
엑소 노래에 대한 전문적인 지식을 들을 수 있어서 너무 좋아요! 덕분에 노래를 더 사랑하게 되고 파트 하나하나에 더 귀를 기울여 듣는 것 같아서 너무 감사합니다! 앞으로도 좋은 영상 부탁드려요~~♡♡
Kevin : "ouh... pretty pretty good, it's okay"
*Unexpected twist comes in*
Me : spoke too soon
The fact that the parts on the video of Going Crazy were so wrong, was making me crazy lol
frantastique me too! I lost it the moment i saw jongin's pic for jongdae's lines lmao
HONESTLY, it was even hard to watch
Ikr
Also Chen’s picture for suho’s line
Ikr me too
Please reacts to more EXO , the álbum EXODUS
Kauruko Kuin Yasss! The almighty 'Exodus' album!
Yass. The best album with the war ofc 👍💕💕💕
Kauruko Kuin yeaaah, please, exodus is gold😍
ESPECIALLY EL DORADO FJNNDJJDDNXNXJMDDM
Yess my fave album of theirs
I'm all smiles because it's EXO 💖
EXO UNIVERSE AND COSMIC RAILWAY and literally everything else lmao
EXO's The War is such a solid album! 🤩 All songs deserve to be title tracks! But actually, all EXO albums including their winter albums are so good! 👍 EXO never disappoint me! 💖 Thank you for sharing this reaction to EXO's b-sides Umu! 💗
Im actually YG stan but i stan EXO so hard, cuz all of EXO songs is fcking good, beside of YGartists the only one artist that i would listen and download their music in the album is exo
this channel talks about musical terms we normal humans don't know and i'm living for it
"He ( Chen ) sounda like s violin." Ohhh yeah... that's my baby!
This is an old-ish video but i was rewatching and just wanted to point out how different people's opinions and tastes of music can be, not only the general public but also people actually studying music. Clear example here:
Henry and Elizabeth thought that Going Crazy once had an interesting musical idea that got buried and lost within the rest of the pop-synthy song; They both preferred Forever.
Meanwhile, Kevin and Isaac thought that Going Crazy was a more well fleshed-out idea and said Forever feels like it's missing something, it doesn't feel as complete of a song.
Neither side is more valid than the other, neither side is more correct; they simply have opposing opinions.
So next time one of these reactors (or anyone really) makes a negative comment or says something you don't agree with about a song you love, please don't feel offended or hurt or angry, remember that *it's just their opinion*, yours can be different and that's totally okay. This is especially true for these reactors who (probably) have more musical knowledge than (many) of us, that doesn't mean their opinion is more "correct" than yours.
*Music is subjective and we all have different preferences and particular likes/dislikes - no need to get so fired up about it!*
whoa i don't expect these songs to be reacted. but the fact that this two song are somehow identical, i think i won't get to know that if i watch another reaction vid.
i'm loving this so much, The War is literally another masterpiece from my boys
Please go on Twitter and vote for Exo’s Power to be played at the FIFA World Cup! There are about 16 hours left to vote!!! Thank you and please help to spread the word!!!! mobile.twitter.com/fifaworldcup/status/1014523639218262016?s=21
WE ARE EXO omg 😱 is there any format for the vote?
Annisa Adelfira if you click on the link I sent you it will bring you to the twitter page that has the ballot. Then you can sign in and cast your vote!!!🤗
YASSSS I THINK THE WAR IS THE BEST ALBUM FROM EXO 😍
*this*
I think it's their best since the almighty 'Exodus'! I can't wait for their comeback!
XOXO says hi sweetie.
MOO to the ARMY 👍👍👍👍👍👍
Chae Rin Lee Yess that whole album is perfection. I had been waiting for those songs since their predebut teasers. Baby don’t cry, my lady, etc are superior
9:52:"I woukd strip to this"
Sameee
PLEASE BEEN THROUGH AND STAY!!!!
"I WOULD STRIP TO THIS" OK BUT LIKE MOOOD
yo nice skirt
"Skkrrtt"
Skareut
@@hafsyh.8075 I can hear Jungwoo 😂
@@nellwyn
me too JAJAJA
lol skurut@@nellwyn
" I would strip to this.. actually I would strip to a lot of songs. But mostly this"
"Whenever he's rapping"
Same, girl, same 💕
ChanYeol voice finally being appreciated 🙌🏻😭😭 You should react to more EXO songs maybe “Hurt” or “Diamond”
Luna C. Sehun's rap too, so proud of my boys, so talented
Hurt, the superior song
that's right Hurt is really underrated exo song eventho it's really nice song. baby dont cry too
Forever, Goin Crazy and What U Do are my favourite songs from the album ❤
Baekhyun, Seulgi & Jungkook same^^
Same
I lost my jams slipping into the diamond life OML ur usernameeeeee
they need to react to the eve dance
Baekhyun, Seulgi & Jungkook going crazy,the eve,forever and diamond...
I love the war album but this four song is my favourite😍😍😍
Exo song never dissapointed me❤❤❤
1:35 this is why I got into EXO 8 years ago
I got goosebumps @ 10:03
Been Through and Sweet Lies by EXO please
OHMAGHAD FINALLY IVE BEEN WAITING FOR AN EXO CONTENT THANKYOUUYU
Karla Eusebio yeah me too. Blooming Day is coming soon!
Idk how much i rewatch this reaction.
Really love it
Thank u soooo muchh
Been marathoning all these reacts. Make me appreciate the music more. I've always appreciated and loved their voices but now I give more attention to the instruments, harmonies and just to it fully. Been great. Loving this series.
*It's been almost 1 year since The War release and I'm still not over this album*
3:50 I love how you showed everyone's reaction to the last chorus beat drop in Going Crazy, it really shook ALL OF US when we first heard it xD
I just want to say a few reasons why this is my favorite TH-cam Channel of all time.
They actually know what they're talking about. They don't just say "Oh my god it's so good" or "I could listen to this". They teach you technicalities from their world, which is something I've only seen on this channel and Form Of Therapy. They're so funny. And Ummu closes the video while doing ASL which warms my heart to the fullest. I'm saving up to become a patreon! You guys deserve all the support you can get:)
we also got crazy about the whole album you must listen to all of their tracks.
Could you pls do exo's been through??? It's really amazing song
Thank you!
THIS.
I like been through but I feel like instrumentally the music piece has nothing much to talk about?? I might be wrong tho.
lh7 trash you're right about the instrumental, bcs it's really sound simple. But imo their vocals have pretty much to talk about
do a VS. WITH FALL PLSSS
been through vs. fall yasss
OH MY GOD I LEGIT SCREAM I DIDN'T SEE THIS ONE COMING THANKS UMMU!!! 💛💛💛💛💛
edit. Chanyeol's voice appreciation right there 💕
Charlotte let's fangirling together 😁💕💞
this is my comfort video lol im embarrassed by how many times ive watched this
엑소는 보컬이 탄탄하죠
다들 다른 매력의 보컬인데 또 조화롭고
노래를 멋지게 만들어요 ㅠㅠ
is the best EXO full album. The best mini album is .
Cheng Li EXODUS is in danger. 😂
How about “Universe”?
Well now let’s not discard exact and exodus just too soon
exodus still reigns
i beg to disagree though. exodus is still the superior album. it made me an exo l!
Going Crazy is life ❤️ one of my top 2017 songs, sadly it isn’t as known by non fans.
i'm so grateful that this channel exists, it's really a gift for these kpop songwriters.. some people can understand their songs so thank you so much
Only GOT7 and EXO can make me listen to their whole album...
I love their B-side tracks!
The best! 💕
Forever is *THAT* song
make henry's request come to life show him exo performances especially el dorado
Yassss! They have to react to that performance
I’m so ready for a El Dorado reaction 🙏🏼🙏🏼
UASS
El dorado or Wolf remix, both from concerts.. that would be awesome
IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS REACTION FOR SO LONG
been binge watching their reaction to every EXO song and i like how they point it out here that every EXO member has a distinct voice bc that’s what made me fall in love with them. it’s really amazing to hear different tones that go well together. 💕
My two favorite songs from the album, love it!
Album of the year-The War. Yes! Thank you for reacting to EXO! Please, show them live performances as Wolf, Lightsaber and El Dorado in Tokyo Dome :)
My two fav songs from the album ❤ thanks for reacting to these 💕
Please do react in *Been through* and *Fall*