See-Saw Balance. Perpetual motion machine 永久運動
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2024
- See-saw balance, continues motion. The machine is able to generate an endless motion until somebody stop it. The pressure of the balls is transmitted to the opposite side due to crossed legs. Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @veproject1
This channel is created for the popularization of science and such a controversial topics in science as the concepts of perpetual motion machines
#veproject1
#perpetualmotionmachine
He's created a perpetual click-baiting machine. Great job!
This guy is a genius. He gets all PP hopefuls to watch because it is a key to "free" energy. Then he also gets people that wants to debunk his contraptions to watch, because we want to see if we can figure out his trickery.
Its just to demostrate how a perpetual motion machine would be if that was possible, have you ever read the about page?
@@XPForever Yes! Thank You!
@Glenn Clark Stfu
Well, I guess we all knew it wasn't going to work!
Next time when you wanted to have a hidden wire at the bottom of your design make sure:
1- the holes for the wires aren't visible or don't show under your design
2- make sure table you are using is not reflective cause we can totally see two thin wires under it
+Behnam saeidi not wires... i'd say these are dc pistons (no cut so he had no time to attach wires)
you can see the reflection
+Behnam saeidi definitely fake.
of course it is! no one would ever doubt that! it's against conservation of energy!
Behnam saeidi a lot of people seem to be doubting it. read the comments.
My brain can't even comprehend how anyone would think this works in any way, shape, or form.
I keep looking at it and wondering how it’s supposed to work…. They aren’t even trying anymore.
Never underestimate the stupidity of youtube viewers...
I liked the way he got the timing wrong after a few toggles and it toggled when the balls were still in the middle of their travels.
If you watch this video at 1/4 speed, you can clearly see that my comment makes no sense.
If you look closely at the way the load bearing members connect to the base you can almost see what he's trying to make you believe is happening.
Probably watching at 3am, not caring enough to commit any brainpower
Amazing how the device starts to rock before the balls start to move.
🤣🤠
It anticipates the moving of the balls..
@@markusweinreich199
Dammit, you made me watch this again (at •25 speed) and it's even more blatantly fake than I remembered it. 🤣
It could be fake, but the balls push the weight to the opposite side of the platform, causing gravity to pull that end down, and thus the balls move after.
@@AlanTherby
No, it's fake - other commenters say they can see the strings, I haven't checked, watch it again 1/4 speed, it's blatant fakery.
@@AlanTherby I can see how the design would make you think that but gravity pulls downwards. It doesn’t cantilever over to the contact point, otherwise we would have no problem holding out a weight on an outstretched arm while standing.
Some problems:
1] As other commenters have mentioned, notice that at the very beginning both balls are on the same end. Yet “somehow” the machine starts rocking in the opposite direction.
2] Similarly, notice that once the machine is rocking it only *starts* to change its tilt once the balls are all the way to the end (I.e. once the balls bump against the end-stops; in short, no smooth transition from one direction-of-tilt to the other, which would be expected if the tilt was actually controlled only by the location of the moving balls.)
3] Even more problematic, over the course of the video, if you watch closely, the directions of the balls’ motion drift “out of synch”. In other words there are very brief instants where the the balls are moving in opposite directions. (This becomes more obvious after about 0:50 )
4] Finally, as other commenters have pointed out, go to full-screen mode and look carefully under the right end of the board. You can see something moving under there. (It’s a little hard to see exactly, but some folks have suggested a string, others a rod.)
Congrats, you dissected a video for fakery that didn’t clam to be real!
If you look on the channel’s about page, you’ll find they show PMM models made for demonstrating how the maker thought they would work.
Great analysis though!
@@Music7Ada Uh, if you read the title again, it says "See-saw balance. Perpetual Motion Machine." There's nothing there, nor in the description, to indicate that it is a fake. By not doing so, it is implied that the demonstration is real.
As far as going to the channel's "about" page, well, some of us got better things to do than checking to see if such videos are nothing more than click-bait.
Look at 0:31, you could see both sides of the board at the begining are "levitating" over the table. I thnk its electeric magnets under it
@@user-sh1vq4bj6n I am not sure about “electEric magnets”. Perhaps it is just well balanced and it tips when the balls are added.
Визуально шары переходят с одной стороны на другую , но если посмотреть на опору снизу, то получается что когда шар слева, он давит правую опору, а когда справа, левую, получается что шар перенося груз на право, давит в левую часть конструкции
Despite how clever the design, their's something called the Law of Conservation of Energy and of Momentum.
And in fine, gravitation of earth lost energy to maintain this...
Then all the system will stop in a day!
@@LaurentBessondelyon. A day? It barely moves for half a minute!
@@Laine2Miel energy gets dissipated regardless
@@Laine2Miel like what u say is right, but again the force is equal in ideal conditions, otherwise force would be used to do non ideal forms of work... thats why an oscillating bob faces damping.. kinetic energy getting converted to other forms
:)
when you take a moment to take a moment, you will find out the sum of dynamic force and moment won't lead to this motion
Im that person who knows perpetual motion machines would never work but is still interested on building these types of stuff.
rules are made to be broken.
They are made to be obeyed...
is there any u know which can actually work?
most perpetual motion machines work, but they have to be made very precisely. Several of mine work, they are running as I type this.
@@someotherdude they will stop eventually
YOU CAN SEE THE REFLECTION OF THE RODS ON EACH END ON THE TABLE
I thought it was magnets but yeah you can see the rods even before he put everything on the table...
imagine being this delusional
@@GreatGig delusional as in saying this works or delusional as in pointing out that rods are being used under the table? also no one else like the main post he
has 69 likes already
@@xpduelist1312 This delusional to think the video poster is serious, the channel is built around SHOWING perpetual motion machines, which do not work. Its to spread the IDEA of them, but everyone looks at it and goes 'OH WELL HE IS FAKING OBVIOUSLY' *BECAUSE THATS THE POINT OF THE CHANNEL, IS TO SHOW YOU WHAT IT DO, NOT THAT IT ACTUALLY WORKS*
Play it back at .25 speed and it’s easy to see “something” is tipping the apparatus to force the ball to move the opposing direction. Magnets being manipulated by someone under the table … the apparatus has metal embedded in the wood.
I would never imagine anything so top heavy being able to balance so perfectly on a dowel on the table before the balls were placed
It is screwed into the base...
This is not fake. It is a lie, in that, it is not perpetual. It will eventually stop. It is a novelty like "Newton's Cradle" and "Dippy Bird".
With most perpetual motion -like machines, you can kinda see how the rationalization works. I don't see it at all in this thing. When the balls initially roll to the right side, they should _stay_ there and the whole framework should stay there: the whole thing's center of mass is resolutely stuck on the right.
+tubeist- dan There is a motor behind the table, which uses some mechanics (not seen) to drive the thing you can see. If you listen closely, cou can even hear it.
The rationalization is that when the balls are on the right, their weight somehow travels along the struts supporting the right side to push on the bottom left side. But yeah, this one *really* stretches the bounds of even the worst logic.
+kallewirsch2263 you can see strings on the ends of the wood at the bottom it's reflecting off the table
You mean you can hear the ball rolling, which is going to my answer to you every time untill you actually build this toy, post a video of it on your own channel and show that it doesn't work. That is my answer to everyone who yells fake on these videos, cause each device can be made for less than $50 so go make it. Prove it doesn't work, or else all you are is someone sitting at home crying "WITCH! HE"S A WITCH! BURN THEM!"
The (incorrect) reasoning is, that because of the criscrossed feet the balls push on the left side of the seesaw when they are on the right side of their ledges and vice versa.
Obviously this is bullsh*t, since if you sum the forces up the seesaw has to support the center of gravity. E.g. if you fix the feet to the seesaw it not only transfers a perpendicular force but also a torque.
What i'm wondering about is the motivation for spreading such nonsense.
That is beautiful. I'm sure your friend under the table agree's.
LOL He puts his hands on the table so he doesn't get moved by his tilting set.
If you look when he starts it, the entire set around the camera is tilting, and then he stabilizes himself, though you can still see his upper torso swaying the direction of the ball every time it moves.
Either that or the wires under it.
Such bullshit.
The apparatus moves opposite the balls. It’s moving opposite the leverage. An outside force has to be applied for this to happen.
The apparatus is moving before the balls begin to move in the direction it’s moving, so the balls clearly aren’t moving it.
Even if you reason that the outer legs of the apparatus attach to the inside of the opposite side of the seesaw, that just doesn’t matter once all the legs are attached, as once the apparatus is securely attached, the whole thing acts like one object that the balls are pressing on. What attaching the legs to the opposite side actually does, is provide different forces to stabilize the apparatus on the seesaw, keeping it from say, falling off the seesaw, falling over bringing the seesaw with it, or breaking from the force of the balls.
This guy can also pick himself up while sitting in a chair...
What a great video, you can barely see the push rods, reflecting off the surface of the table.
There... Are... No push rods though...
@@stanleyjiang2244 they're hard to see, but they are there
@@CorporateMarineDRG No there aren't. i know cause i built one of these myself out of lego. Perpetual machines are impossible, but technically these are considered unbalanced machines, which respond to external energy inputs, which is therefore not the same as perpetual motion, so technically this isn't considered a perpetual motion machine. Unbalanced machines do work.
@@FablestoneSeries They don't. They loose energy, and thus stop moving. And really: the holes are visible, and so are the rods reflecting on the table, on both sides.
If you want real perpetual motion then you need to strap a piece of buttered bread (buttered side up) on to the back of a cat and then drop the cat from a height.
as if I haven't heard that joke before
Do you speak for everyone?
idk but try being original making jokes for once
That would rip our galaxy apart and destroy everything! No!
Xefair if each decent joke ever created were only allowed to be used once there would be no good jokes left.
Thanks, my city now relies 100% on this free infinite energy and everyone has unlimited energy
+Renan Eich Awesome! We need to collaborate on my space program built on pulling my own hair.
I'm glad it worked out for you. Mine went faster and faster until it created a black hole. You'll be glad to know they have TH-cam on the other side.
/r/thattotallyhappened
What city is that....... the one in your imagination?
That Guy r/wooosh
Im a mechanical engineer. The reason why people not knowledgeable in strength of materials think this might work is because they dont know how forces transmit. The ball's weight acting on each oblique beam not only results in a pressure on the tip equal to the weight, but also a flexural stress superimposed on it which in some parts of the tip's surface contact area with the see-saw actually causes traction, and the wholr thing adds up to be indistinguishable from the ball just resting right above the see-saw at the position it would be if there wasnt a silly structure between them.
If you wanna try it at home, find something shaped like this:
I try this design, but it don't work... unfortunately, I have no green ball, only red and blue. So sad.
Clearly magnets. When he places it down at 0:30 it’s perfectly balanced 🙈
It's not magnets - look at the two clearly visible lengths of black thread - one under each end of the machine.
Why is he tilting with the machine?
Foot pedal that activates the electromagnets under the table.
because he is reversing the footage back and forth to make the effect. Watch at the end the balls move faster and he also tilts faster as well.
See the machine
Feel the machine
*Be the machine*
He is moving with the set/platform he is standing on that is moving from side to side to make the balls move. The momentum of that moves him as well. :)
Because he's using his feet to pull the wires attached to each end of the rear of the base (you can actually see the reflection / shadow of the wires in the gloss finish of the table as each side rises). What possible satisfaction can these clowns derive from these hoaxes?
From the VEP website
"My Perpetual Motion Machines models are of motorized versions that were built to illustrate how they were supposed to work in the minds of Inventors.........I’d like to inspire these people by demonstrating Unworkable Perpetual Motion Machines that were designed centuries ago."
Interesting how he doesn't say that on or in the intros of his videos.
Or even when he shows us how it works he says nothing about motor
If you are going to fake something, you could at least try to do a minimally plausible work.
A little bit inside the outer attachment and than below the board you see thin and black strings on both sides.
thank you, i was looking for the trick and i couldn't find it
Pretty sure that’s a reflection
Dead on. Nice catch.
Could you please be so kind and give us the time you saw that? Thanks!
Good observation, but I'm not completely sure those aren't shadows.
Apart from the unnatural movement...gotta love the way it automatically lifts itself to vertical after he puts it on the table at 0:30
At 0:19 you can clearly see two holes in the table under the contraption where the wires poke through to move it. Then at 0:38 you can clearly see the reflection of the two wires. I suspect he is using his feet to move the wires, as his whole body moves ever so slightly while resting his hands on the table.
+Q-Hack! ahd you can see the reflection of the wires when it starts to "work"
Yes, you are quite right!! Sorry, I didnt scroll down far enough to read that you had already discovered this...
Q-Hack! jajajaja puro electroimán se ve q las la estructura llevan las bolas y no lo contrario
this is literally the worst fake perpetual motion device in the history of bunk TH-cam videos 😄. it's like the designer wasn't even trying to fool us lol 😄
nah it's ok .. a good mech man ..
shit is soo fake he literally showed you you the magnets on the bottom of the board.....
If you forget about the wires and stuff, you can see the concept does not even make sense. All the weight is facing toward 1 edge, yet it goes to the other
Notice his movements in the background. He’s moving with it. The entire stage he’s on is teetering. Put a third ball in the container at the same time. I bet it moves, too.
I wanted to comment about this.
Yes i just commented the same. I think now the whole stage is rocking that's why he is putting his hands so awkward on the table.... to stabilize himself
In the center of a glass table would be great. With 2 perspectives. Close up with a timer and a mid shot so you can see no one is messing with the table.
This was very clever and almost convincing, but if you look hard enough, you can see pushrods on the left and right under the board, near the edge of the table. Also, notice how he himself sways in time as well. I would probably guess some sort of foot-operated mechanism, which is why he supports himself with his hands on the table
even the images YES SHOWN for a gestual "language" expert or an expert in postures how he YES do something forcing hes legs PLENTY SINCHRONIZED with the rebounds on/against the table !! Pay good attention to your hip in each "cycle" (or more well in each external forced cycle hehe) ...in add the house of this people is the only one in the world in wich THE GRAVITY CHANGES...that is the ONLY explanation for such a CHANGE OF VELOCITY in both "working" "shows" -->> ¡¡ WITH THE EXACT SAME BALLS !! = = same Wheights *forces* at the same speed SUBMITTED OR NOTHING AT ALL omg ... What a piece of ignorant this man because that is what really betrays everything !!!...in aaad too = other guy in comments said about ¡¡¡ cables !!! AND iiiss possibleee !! this troglodite choose such a way !! ->
when the intelligent to do was carefully introduce some neodymium "coin/shaped" magnets through the holes inside the wood; And a coil or two according-to-choice-or-preferences DOWN the table and in addition "not operated by a leg movement that is clearly seen under the table" ... but by an oscillator ... and so he could have turned away to look distractedly doing everything more convincing .....even mor convincig "were was" ( haha ) to practice the holes for the leads NOT TRASPASSING the bottom of the wood and introduce the magnets FROM THE SIDE so nothing is vissible, just qith that and two powerfull alternative powered coils under the table the scam is done...
....you even can also hide the magnets INTO THE END OF EACH SUPPORTING LEAD ANDO NOTHING IS VISSIBLE TOO...in such a case guess it's a better location to avoid detection if u assure the devices rapidly disarmed and puting it away "some far" lol...
meant it's about ZERO "VISIBLE CABLES" just in case someone "aint understood" the picture....
( only edited 1st one because ONE "H" in sincHronized was missed ) just in case "madmen" about of the writing wtf...
I wonder when this perpetual motion mania will end.
It never will. Perpetual mania.
I like to think that one day, some day, someone will invent perpetual motion completely by accident, discovering some unknown property of physics in the process.
As soon as man is no longer alive. Stupid videos about free energy machines will live on digitally even if there is no one to watch them.
As soon as anti-vax, anti-mask, anti-5g, climate change deniers, flat earthers, "big pharma is withholding cancer cure instead of monopolizing it" proponents, and everyone who says "sheeple" while being so tone-deaf they don't realize they themselves are a sheeple of a different brand, no longer exist. AKA never.
A couple thousand more years, and I think it will run its course.
Two holes are drilled into the edge of the board facing the guy. When he very carefully sits the board down, he is sliding those holes over two rods that are sticking up past the rear edge of the table and bent at 90 degrees. These rods are actuating the rocking motion. As Nicholas Olszko pointed out, you can easily see the reflection of the rods in the surface of the table in the shadowed area under either end of the board. Its entirely fake- build one and this contraption won’t rock even once without the hidden rods actuating it.
The only thing I have ever seen in a constant perpetual motion is my wife’s mouth.
Chris2008
Ah, vous aussi 🤣
You're not alone 🤣🤣🤣
Mine talks on the exhale AND while inhaling. Fascinating...🤣🤣
Adam Savage just debunked this video on Twitter.
+David Oakes who's that?
veproject1 what
+David Oakes While I agree with Adam on this, calling something Bullshit isn't the same as debunking it. You gotta show your work.
+veproject1 He's known for Mythbusters show series. But can't find anything similar or mention about this from him.
+David Oakes Also have to question why the chap needs to have his hands on the desk like that... You can see there is something else going on with this. It would not work. The balls would go to the end and just stop. And that would be it... But we do need another Mythbusters show, because we need to show stupids how things really work. ;)
I'm that kind of people who watches these kinds of video and yell:
*SCIENCE!!!*
You can see a black cable in the table reflection, right below the right corner (from the viewer's perspective) of the device every time that corner goes up (for example, exactly in 00:50, 00:51).
If you check earlier - before the device is set in motion - there's no such reflection.
The left side of the device is a bit longer, causing it to go down on its own weight when "released" (either that, or that side has extra weight). My bet is he's controlling the device with his left foot, pulling the string down when he wants that corner (right corner from viewer's perspective) to go down, and releasing when he wants the other corner (left corner from the viewer's perspective) to go down (which unsurprisingly matches his slight body movement).
PS: if you stand up and try doing the same movement, moving your left foot up and down quickly, as in the end of the video, you'll notice it's very hard for your body not to move at all. That's the reason why you see the body moving as well.
Edit: correction you can see the left side cable at 00:34, so there's a cable on both ends.
+diegoreymendez You sir, are right!
diegoreymendez .... this is funny. you've convinced yourself you can see something that isn't there. bravo!
Strange how PP builds on TH-cam like this one never seem to increase their speed, it's always a steady rhythm, almost as if there were some kind of device controlling it.
0:30
How convenient of it to balance so well. It's as if something were holding in in place
Fun fact: crossed legs don't change anything.
It took a minute to realize he was trying to imply that the ball on one end was weighing down the opposite side of the seesaw. It would take a fairly weak grasp of physics to think this would be possible.
Magikarp Used Splash but it looks cool
"...and then on DATE NIGHT, everything changed."
0:33
Why did it fall to the left even though there was more weight on the right? xD
0:36
@@Stryxxxx that doesn't make sense. Why would that zig zag shaped leg add the ball's weight to the other side?
yeah, looks sketchy, gravivity only cancels itself out, it has no leftover energy to apply force the opposite dirrection.
Did you even watch to the end?
How come the "actor" has to hold his position with both hands on the table? I would like to see this same experiment with a glass of water on the table.
+IceBlueBeard Had the exactly same thoughts, but he would probably fake the water too.
Do you think the table is tilting? The camera "on the table" would make it look like the table wasn't tilting, but the guy's body would shift from right to left. So............... The guy AND the table must be on a ramp with two people tilting it up and down.... Clever.That's why the back wall is all white. If it was a pattern or had a painting, you would see them tilting too.
Bill Streifer The light source must also be tilting with the table and the walls.
You're right.... Oops! Back to the drawing board.
Its holes in the table very close to the edge
People sure do get mad on youtube over mechanical oscillators. These contraptions are just systems that are out of equilibrium but keep pushing themselves out of equilibrium every time they try to correct themselves. It's like how a ball bounces several times before stopping completely. Just because it doesn't continue until the heat death of the universe doesn't mean it's a hoax. It's fun clever design. People in these comments need to stop acting like they're some hero of physics for understanding basic friction and learn to appreciate the fun things that are possible when you REALLY understand physics.
The dowel under the rocking platform is being rocked back and forth. It's that simple. No strings, no magnets, just a guy behind the table spinning the dowel back and forth.
You have to explain how it works for it to be called "educational".
you right!!
I will if you look when the balls go to one side the support on that side puts the weight on the other side thus moving them to the other side and so on
Irodragon
how it truely works was the question
No. Sorry. Learn about moment arms in physics 101. Better yet, build such a model as you see on your own and discover how they work. The cross supports are there to distract you.
thin rods under the table at each end of the see-saw are hidden but are pushed by an accomplice through holes you can see at the start and control the motion, not the balls.
Fake . In the reflection on the table you can see the hard wires that lead to the construction of the movement . They are located on the bottom edges of the support.
уверен?
perpetual motion is fake, so of course this video is fake. all of these videos are to display what would happen if , for example, there were no friction or gravity. In a perfect world all these experiments would work... but fuck science man.
its just there to be pretty and inspire people to make their own attempts at perpetual motion, which will fail and end up here :P
Евгений Старков this isnt real its a concept
Somebody just sent me this, just came to say the same thing. In the beginning you can see the holes where the wires go, and it moves unnaturally.
Darryn Lansdell Except this one won't work without friction, nor without gravity.
Umm...how come it moves from side to side before I the balls move !? 😂😁 Nice model though 👍👌
There are thin black lines under the planks
Because they wouldn't move unless it tilted first - lol!
Which means the balls aren't providing the energy, and kind of makes unaided perpetual motion impossible.
It's amazing how many people think these are real attempts at perpetual motion.
The channel creator has said before, they're just the documented design with some kind of automation so you can see how it was _expected to_ work.
Watch it in slow motion and you will see how the board is moving the balls side to side and not the opposite. pause the video then use your < key to go backwards and your > to go forward, thank me.
I can do the same thing with a beer in each hand.
↕🍺👈😁👉🍺↕
Imagine you were tied up in the same room as this thing and you had no idea what was going on
+King Bazi exactly
"Visual education"? More like "Visual confusion".
The dowel is placed on a mechanism when he sets it down. That's what holds it in a balance to start. Then is what rocks it to the light side.
If something is balanced it will balance.
I can't believe I just had to type that sentence to someone who seems to not understand that. Especially since you have a yin and yang avatar.
SMH...
@@HarryBalzak And I see why you use ball sack for a name.
The reason why perpetual motion is impossible is the existence of energy loss. Anything that moves with contact would lose energy through friction. Using magnets is a smart way to compensate for the loss of energy, but magnets would lose their effect over time.
物理法則が崩壊したかと心配したけど黒い紐が見えて安心した
So glad to see that most commenters know that this is fake (:
Now the question is how he did it ? Some coils under the table with two little iron plates inside the plank ?
edit: Nop, i see a thin shadow of a line on each side
Yeah, at least they know it's fake. What i can't understand is, why did the hating this man? He was just demonstrating the movement of a prepetuap machine
@@dhedetry8571 Because there is no such thing as perpetual motion machine, and people find the title a little misleading. Because mal informed people would believe
That would work for a whole one time
There are some perpetual motion machines that almost make sense. This one doesn't even come close! If you don't see it, watch this at 1/4 speed and you will see how ridiculous this is. The only way anyone would be fooled here is because it rocks back and forth so quickly that you can't catch the flaw in the idea of this machine.
I think there is a 2nd person under the table who is tapping this back and forth with their fingers. Notice that the device is placed right at the very edge of the table, giving someone underneath easy access to it. Many here have claimed they see a string and that is possible, too. I see what looks like a string but it also could just be a reflection. Notice that the camera is placed in a way that you can't see all the way under the base board to see what is really going on. Either way this isn't that difficult to reproduce.
just note that before placing a board on the table, there are holes for threads. And as soon as the movement starts, it is possible to see the reflection on the paper of the threads attached to the wooden board
one day I will prove that this perpetual thingy was possible
You can't, that's the law of physics... Energy cannot be created or destroyed, only converted from one form to another.
well that's also just a theory, how about electron that can make an endless circular movement?
Because it's energy is radiated discontinuously quantas
Haters will say this is fake. This is fake.
Hater...
The illusion would look better if the balls were in sync with the movement.
How it worked..? I did the same see-saw machine (perpetual machine) but it didn't worked at all. Explain what we have to do to make it possible. And i think perpetual motion is impossible... Am i correct..?
На 0:18 видно что под доской по краям есть маленькие кружки. Железные винтики, притягиваемыми магнитным полем из под стола, так что не важно, вы поставите не эту досточку, она все равно будет двигаться сама. Хоть бы замаскировал или не показывал.
0:39 see what he's doing for about half a second with his hands? The way he swings his hands? Scam confirmed.
+moepskie nice to see a parrot still subscribed
+veproject1 Thank you ;-)
+veproject1 prize49(dot)blogspot(dot)ca
Lotto649 Research. Good Luck
+moepskie No - looks legit. The oscillation would damp out in a minute or two. He added the energy to the system when he rolled the ball hard. Pretty cool machine.
+moepskie well am i the only one who noticed his entire upper body moving ? :P
Reported for perpetual motion scam.
I love this game, its just really hard to find the motor
magnetic. see magnet (black dots) under base
There are some perpetual motion machines that do 'work' but will eventually stop overtime due to friction and other factors, there was this one guy who makes these cool woodworks and he hangs it up on a wall, and once you spin a certain piece it will go on seemingly forever, they can go on for hours or even days before eventually stopping, its these types of perpetual motion machines that while they don't work, will be a wonderful masterpiece to see moving on your wall when given some of your energy. This one is just not good.
Also I don't believe in perpetual motion, I just think its cool to watch certain machines that almost work go on for extended periods of time before friction takes its toll on them.
0:29 to 0:30-slight movement of the 'perfectly balanced' board as he engages his feet with the pedals on
the floor attached to rods that alternately lift each end of the contraption.
The rods are at the edge of the table, thus the placement of the device at table edge.
His upper body is even swaying in time with the contraption.
Makes no sense at all (unless you introduce a hidden POWER SOURCE)
Or two pieces of thread under the ends of the machine...look for them - you'll see them easily.
Perpetual motion, yet you only show it “working” for thirty seconds or so.
Yes, precisely the duration of their attention span. Eventually they are going to get tired or bored of using their feet to control the motion of that rig.
There are some pretty suspicious holes in the table under each side of the board hmmmmmm
Bob Smith if in doubt, it’s always electromagnets.
@@AndreasDelleske yep. Why do they even bother trying that anymore...
Although this is a very clever machine, it is not a perpetual motion machine. It will eventually stop because energy is slowly being lost from friction between the ball and the wooden frame, and also from sound.
A similar see saw mechanism can be made using electrons in a wire, by connecting a fully charged capacitor to an inductor. When you connect the two together, the capacitor will charge the inductor, creating a magnetic field that stores the energy from the capacitor.
Once the electrons stop moving, the magnetic field surrounding the inductor will collapse, which will create a force that will charge the capacitor again.
Once the magnetic field surrounding the inductor is gone, the capacitor will discharge again, creating a magnetic field around the inductor that stores the energy from the capacitor.
Once the electrons stop moving, the magnetic field surround the inductor will collapse, that will charge the capacitor again. Once the capacitor is fully charged, it will discharge again, creating a magnetic field around the inductor, which stores the energy from the capacitor.
You would think that this would go on forever, but it won't, because energy is slowly being lost from the system from heat generated by the friction on the electrons moving through the wire, just a energy is lost due to the friction of the ball rubbing against the wood of the see-saw apparatus in this demonstration.
It’s interesting because seeing these seemingly plausible ideas actually realized causes the opposite effect of making you realize just how stupid it would actually be for physics to work like that.
Where does the energy come from?
And would it eventually slow to a stop like Newton's cradle?
no perpetual motion mechine will ever work, because that requires you to break the 1st and 2nd rule of thermodynamics
No matter how you pinpoint the weight, what counts is the center of mass of the whole structure, this video is fake.
I hope this was just a 1st of April joke.
It was posted on the 26th of Marsh. He does this all the time.
+Skovhusevej Stensved What an ass-wizard!
Funny how so many people here are mad, as if they were expecting it to work or something.
It's a pretty good idea, but it's quite easy to work out why it doesn't work
Wow! I'm totally convinced! Totally convinced that the stage is moving back and forth! Watch the inertia movement of the demonstrator, he even has to steady himself by placing his fingers on the table, you can see his body mass shifting side to side. Sorry to be the spoiler.
Hey, you just saved my uni homework! I wasn't sure how i should describe this bogus and there you are, saying me where to look! Like, reaally thanks! How can i serve you my graditudes? I can offer u a free bj if you're into o.o
Glad I could help you Onur, but I'll pass on the bj, give that to your lover. My regards.
jokes on you i don't have any lover xD
..
:/
:(
:'((
Then try yourself, that would make a great uni homework project, maybe even duplicate yourself.
Man take yo hands of the table I can see you tilting it
MAXIMUM
Nightmare1sd77 lmfao
Fake, the machine is leading the motion of the balls.
How else will the balls move if the machine isn’t applying the force ???????? Of course it’s leading the movement!!!!!!!!!
Good catch, didn't notice that until you mentioned it.
but like a pendulum, wouldn't it stop at some point? i want to see a longer video of this in x32 speed
+c6786 dude... are you for real? You really think this works on it's own? Do you understand that energy is lost everywhere here? In order something to be perpentual it must not lose energy after the initial given energy to start (like he uses his hand to push the green ball to start this motion). First there's shit ton of friction and ball is slowing down considerably that's first energy loss second energy loss is the whole thing moving it is losing excess energy as it goes left right.
Either magnets are pushing it up down or the table is being lifted.
+c6786 It isn't a real movement thing, the machine is moving due two strings at the bottom sides. Apparently the video is to show how it should had worked, because it can't work in this reality. Or... it's just trying to fool people, but the strings are very visible.
+c6786 Yes, it will. There is the most visible point of fraction that makes it lose energy. It is a point where it constantly touch a table.
Don't ever believe this stuff. It wont work.
Notice when he sets the machine down (before he puts the balls in) the machine balances on the center rod, rather than tip to one side or the other, as would naturally happen. Dead giveaway he has a push-rod system just behind the edge of the table.
From 0:18 to about 0:20 , if looking closely, I can see two small holes at the edge of the table. The guy places the platform of the mechanism carefully with the middle between those two holes and also hiding those holes from camera view. Then when the mechanism is rocking, look closely and can see the reflection on the table where two thin rods would be through those holes to then alternate pushing the mechanism first on one side, then the other. So either someone is below the table pushing the rods accordingly, or the guy standing there could be working it with his feet somehow. Anyways, that's my theory. Still, I give kudos to the guy for being inventive and creative with such devices and vids.
0:19 - nice magnets.. thx for showing
Magnets? I'm pretty sure those are the holes where the nails go... you know to put the freaking structure together.
magnets in the wood and electromagnets under the table.
that wouldn't work hahaha
Le Klinch sure it would. if you put small permanent magnets in the ends of the wood (sunk into the wood) and then you have electromagnets on a timer under the table so that they turn on and off thus pulling and pushing the permanent magnets up and down causing the whole set up to rock side to side.
no just strings
ah that explains the mechanical like snapping back forth.. a see saw is rather smooth when transisioning back and forth... this is exactly like an electromagnetic..
i can see two little wires just reflecting on the table :)
I can't get it
Can u send me the screenshots plz
You can tell by the motion that it's being moved by somebody's hand with a string or otherwise, the balls would not make it move like that, such an uneven rhythm as well
If let's say, the golf balls are the "eyes" of a four legged creature, who is busy scanning it's environment for enemies' missiles during its descent/attack, well then, I postulate that this is giving off a strong Space Invaders vibe that is perpetually kinda rad
ummmmm, how long will it keep doing that?
+Masa Fulgur until the variable (balls) get out of sync enough to balance each other out.
i kinda assumed, but i actually wanted to know how long would that take? just curious since it IS a perpetual motion machine but it won't last forever XD
+Masa Fulgur i think it would last for 1 week
approximately 1 hour, depending on traffic conditions
MrGarruk123
Thats a lot shorter xD
туфта!!!! шарики запаздывают когда перекатываются, т.к. их просто катают, не они двигают систему, под столом электромагниты, а
в деревяшках железяка!!!!!!!
именно
Возможно. Поставь скорость 0,25 и на 29ой секунде происходит смена изображения , едва заметно , слева направо. Т.е. делали что хотели. (В паузе)
Es uno de los peores y menos ingenioso truco sobre máquinas de movimiento perpetuo que he visto.
Sabes cuál es el truco?
0:37 Gotta love how it begins to tilt left, when the green ball is on the right and the red ball is on the right.. There is nothing to cause it to tilt left at that moment.
You need to read the description or watch the whole video. What you observed matches perfectly with how they claim this contraption works.
Good job agreeing with them. It is amazing how many comments like this there are. People try to show how smart they are but they instead show how ignorant/dull/obtuse they are.
@@HarryBalzak I can't tell if you are complimenting me or insulting me, but there is no perpetual motion
@@ST-cy6we I never said there was perpetual motion. You seem to be claiming that there should be *no* motion, and you are wrong. That is a legit device, but it is a novelty like Newton's Cradle. It will eventually stop. There is no trickery involved. It moved exactly when it was supposed to move.
I was insulting you. You tried to disprove the device by describing exactly how they claim it works.
The fact that you still cannot figure that out, nor if I was insulting you or not, means my insults were spot on.
So obvious you can even see the thin wires under each side of the pendulum that he is pulling with a fucking foot pedal.
isso não é possível, falso, mentiroso, FAKE!!!!
So much butthurt over these videos, it's incredible
just look at him moving too
FAKE
+Marco Martins too bad he's not moving for most of action, 0:40 - 1:00 :D
natsu just pay attention and you will see him balancing even on that time you said
Yeah but is the wall moving?!
Apart from people saying, "It moves wrong," and, "you can see a string," etc., the more frustrating issue is that you can't move the center of mass one way but get the mass to push on the opposite side. That's just not how that works. Imagine sitting in a golding chair that has the legs criss-cross front to back. When you lean back in such a chair, does it put more weight on the front legs? Exactly...
My point is this isn't something that actually works for a long time but would eventually slow down and stop claiming to be a perpetual motion machine. This is just something that doesn't and wouldn't work AT ALL.
I already have a perpetual motion machine, my girlfriend, just get her mad and it never ends.