I completely disagree. I learned to crochet on amigurumi. It’s really not that hard. I find it easier than crocheting what you consider easy. When I first wanted to learn to crochet, my mom tried to get me to do a granny square and I gave up because it was too confusing and most importantly, BORING. I don’t find joy in making something that doesn’t look like anything. 6 years after I gave up on the granny square I crocheted a jellyfish from a pattern I found online. Maybe it’s my previous knowledge on hand sewing but even a couple of my friends that don’t know how to sew do amigurumi and learned how to crochet on amigurumi.
You are lucky to have enjoyed the experience as your first experience. 💕💕💕💕 It may have been easier for you knowing the basics of sewing & understanding how to put things together in a 3D type format. Majority of people don’t have those experiences. After learning to love crocheting by learning & perfecting the basics, tension, stitches, counting stitches, compiling simple patterns, yarn, etc. I still couldn’t make it through a basic amigurimi pattern. To learn I was actually researching about quilting from Melanie Ham & pulled up one of her crochet videos for a washcloth or something. Got through part of it & kept repeating that my hands will adjust to the technique with practice. I could only imagine if I had attempted an amigurumi the hooks would have been thrown away & yarn burned. 😂😂😂😂. I then branched out to learn tips & techniques from other crochet TH-camrs in perfecting what works for me with from holding the yarn, magic ring, slip knots, circles, stitches. Even forcing myself to learn about reading a basic pattern before jumping into to an amigurumi project my son had put in front of me from the beginning! The fear of starting & hating crocheting after that was real! Finally got the courage to crochet a giant spider for my son at Halloween! I did it & it was an incredible accomplishment, but once completed I was over it! If I had started my journey this way my love & growth within the craft would have never been. If I’m bored & need a challenge I’ll jump over to a bag, mini earphone covers, some amigurumi & many other options because I know the basics. Amigurumi is everything all at once in a format that many could find overwhelming & frustrating eliminating their chances of learning to grow & love what we all do. Missing out on the benefits of completing a project as small as they may be. Strange how it works for each of us as individuals. I love to see how others process things so differently. Even with this, crocheting requires us to know the basics & be confident with them to really enjoy the full process of any type of project. Oh I also do quilting by machine, but always got frustrated with clothing. That could be another reason for being thankful I didn’t start with amigurumi. Everyone has their unique way of processing information & growing in new experiences. I have to agree that when sharing or encouraging others to love what we do focusing on the basics & accomplishing a small simple project is a safer approach to help them find the joy in crocheting. Simple, doable & able to complete. If I had a crocheting friend who could do amigurumi & said she started that way I’d feel tremendous pressure to do the same. Any issues along the way would ruin the experience because it’s complex when doing amigurumi. Not only giving up & feeling like a failure for not being able to do as my friend did, I would have never learned to love this craft that has truly helped me with so much more than just creating projects or gifts. Boring isn’t always bad. The fundamentals of everything is extremely important for confidence that will lead to enjoyment. My amigurumi queen friend hyping me up to start from the basics is a huge win for all! If I had I wouldn’t have found the one thing I’ve come to love that has tremendously helped me with my current health issues. It’s literally been a life saver.
I learned to crochet at 4 years old from my great grandmother. She told me to start with a simple scarf. I have been crocheting since then and I'm 58 now. A beginner was telling me how she bought a kit to make a cute duck, and she couldn't do it, so I taught her basic stitches. Told her to practice these stitches first. Totally agree with you!
I agree Bonnie! I just started doing this type of crochet after doing traditional crochet for 30 years! After much frustration I found a TH-cam video that showed how to yarn over the hook opposite of the traditional yarn over this enabled me to get tight even stitches! Have not had a problem since!
I learnt to crochet 50 years ago, after watching my grandma. I love making intricate tablecloth’s, doilies and bed spreads with the thinnest cotton threads and also beautiful afgans and throws in yarn. I am yet to crochet any amigurumi, but I am not in any hurry.
I notice how the crafters markets are stuffed (pun intended) with bees, dolls, and others. I wish those crocheters could diversify. It’s hard to stand out. But my aunt also discouraged me from making what I wanted to learn, saying I could only learn my making an afghan with course yarn 😵💫 so learn and stay positive through the process!
Thank you very much for your open/honest words on the subject of amigurimi, I have tried these little works so many times and spent so much money on eyes etc - and yet I was almost always disappointed with the result; among other things because I couldn't cope with the thin yarn/wool required/specified Your patterns, crocheted with thicker wool, are always successful and bring joy - for me and those I give them as gifts
Bonnie .I watch you a lot. I'm so thankful that you are handing the craft of crocheting down to younger generations. Iv been crocheting since I was 15 yrs old. I simply love trying new stitches. And my phone is filled with your videos.i. so excited because iv never attempted to do an amigurumi. I will definitely watch your videos
I encourage folks to give amigurumi a try, just not at the very beginning of the learning process. Thank you so very much for your kind words and support Genny!
I taught my granddaughter to crochet dishcloths at 8 years. She is now 15. She makes amigurumi gifts for her teachers and friends at church. Gets patterns from TH-cam. Last year she made bags for all her friends. I made a kit amigurumi that a child bought me to thank me for making her several ponytail hats. The kit was difficult. Very tiny cats. Not for a beginner. I make amigurumi items every year for great nieces and nephew. How they love them and look forward to what I bring each Christmas. I agree 💯 that those kits are not for beginners. Well said, Bonnie.
When I started crocheting my mom tried to teach me granny squares when I was in my teens and when I didn’t get it but now that I’m an adult I’ve gotten back into it. I made some blankets including hooded ones. Then I recently started amigurumi. I had no idea how to read a pattern so I started with a bee and regular yarn from my stash just because I knew there was only so much yarn in the kit. Now that I have a better understanding of how to read patterns I’ve made several stuffies and look forward to doing more. I do agree that these are not ideal for a beginner as it can be frustrating. Try it in your own time, but keep in mind that if you mess up you will have to frog it and start over or will need different yarn. Good luck everyone
I 100% agree. It is so easy to be put off. The first time I attempted crochet I couldn't get the item to lie flat. No-one would or could tell me where I was going wrong! I tried again a few years later and fully fell in love with the craft. Thank you for this video. 🧶💕
You are absolutely right Bonnie because I crochet and I have never crocheted a amigurumi just because of all the details and you have to make sure those stitches are perfect in the round so thank God no this is not my first project I love crocheting😊
I get where you are coming from with this. I do. But like just about everything, I don’t think it’s one size fits all. I learned to crochet with amigurumi. Taught myself from photos in a book. If, when I was starting out, someone told me that I couldn’t make the thing I wanted to make, that I had to spend hours making these other things that I had zero interest or desire to make first, THAT would have discouraged me to the point of never picking it up at all. Was my first amigurumi perfect, absolutely not. But I learned a ton and my second was much much better. We all learn differently and there is no wrong way. I do agree with you though that some of the kits should maybe not be advertised as beginner. That said, Amigurumis usually do only use single crochet and are in the round which in many ways is easier than flat so it may really depend on definitions. My two cents.
It is good that you had a book to start and not only a kit. That really was my main point. I was just at the bookstore yesterday and most beginning and intermediate crochet books have been replaced by Amigurmi kits that lookedepretty complicated to me - all aimed at beginners. I think we agree on this one. I totally understand that some folks thrive on these items. I have just seen the opposite effect of these kits killing all motivation too many times.
I agree however I started with an Amigurumi TH-cam video and figured it out. Still have it. But I can see that trying to learn from a kit would never have worked for me as I’m a visual learner.
I agree with a lot of what you say, but I actually did learn through amigurumi! Not through a kit though… but through TH-cam! You are right that amigurumi shouldn’t be your absolute first attempt though. I began learning by making little flat squares (as you said), then moved to making a plain round ball. The first “cute” animal I made was a baby octopus, which was a very basic shape, and required zero sewing. If you are planning on starting with amigurumi as a beginner, I suggest you find a good, simple pattern (anything that looks basically like a ball is a good way to start), and follow along with a beginner-friendly video. Here are the benefits I found to starting with amigurumi rather than something like a granny square: - It takes very little yarn, and you can find projects that only require one color - It teaches you increasing and decreasing - It teaches you to be disciplined about counting your stitches - It teaches you how and when and why to use a stitch marker - It is VERY rewarding because the end product is something cute that can be displayed or played with
I agree Lauren! I have no objections once a crocheter has some basic skills. I still treasure the dolls I made as a child, but as you said, I didn't start there! Wishing you all the best!
Yes I do! Here's the video for the Celtic Braided Sweater for the summer version: th-cam.com/video/wj-ZW3M2ycU/w-d-xo.html This will refer you to this video for the winter version. You simply don't add the sleeves and use a different yarn mentioned in the above video. th-cam.com/video/ZBD1b1lEIlg/w-d-xo.html
Good video Bonnie! My 2 grandkids just got me 2 kits for Mother’s Day (needless to say it was for them) but they wanted me to make it for them. My grandson picked out a frog and my granddaughter picked out a bird of some sort. I have been crocheting for over 25 years and I even knit here and there. You are so correct about those kits misleading people to make them think they are easy and beginner friendly! I’ll tell ya I started out with the frog and here is my pet peeve as it sits here for 3 weeks now… not only did you have to keep the same tension (which is so HARD) because you normally work with the thinnest yarn but the patterns are TINY. So anyway I started with the head, body and now I’m on the arms which requires me to make a magic ring and 6 stitches in a round for 12 rows!!!! Did you hear me? 6stitches in a round for 12 rows!! My hands oh my hands! That is thee smallest piece of yarn I had to work with and needless to say I gave up on round 2 and that’s why my project is still here 3 weeks later and the bird kit hasn’t been touched. My poor grandkids keep coming saying “Mom-Mom are you finished? You said 2 days!!” I feel bad so after seeing this video I can relate to what you are trying to say and your sooo right!! But you also gave me the inspiration to finish these 2 kits and tell them no more but I can make them pillows or blankets if they like lol thanks
I would maybe consider trying one of the "Edwards Menagerie of Birds" or one of their books. You can make these beautiful creations any size, and using any yarn weight. I believe they are much better written and very reliable. My daughter made the flamingo without any issues and it came out beautifully! www.amazon.com/Edwards-Menagerie-Birds-Patterns-Crochet/dp/144630602X/ref=asc_df_144630602X/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=693352901730&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=1949060501349984786&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=c&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9007799&hvtargid=pla-556410643197&psc=1&mcid=b2795b6b45f2384abc0767bcfad1d2dd&gad_source=1
I totally agree. I was looking for something to try. I’ve tried knitting but it didn’t last. Last night I downloaded some crochet kits for beginners and noticed wow this doesn’t look beginner I have to learn to read this first. Tried on beginner dishcloth and they skipped the beginning on the slip not and how to do a chain. I like your beginner dishcloth. Thank you
I started just learning how to chain. I was about 4 or 5 and saw my mother crocheting and said I wanted to try. She gave me a hook and yarn and showed me how to make a chain. I made a chain longer than me and dragged it with me around the house. 😂
I too picked up crochet through one of the kits at Barnes and Noble before woobles even started. Trying to figure out how to make the stitches was hard by just looking at the photos. No prior experiance just wanted to make the cute bunny. My gauge was garbage and I needed more yarn. But because it was a project I was determined to do it came together. I have been crocheting ever since.
I started with Amigurumi. However, I knew about tension and such from my grandma's and mother. No, starting with Ami is a hardship for sure and can have a very negative effect on your thoughts. The fact that you have an actual book that you can gallows along with a video is AWESOME!!! I learned to crochet from videos and never learned pattern reading. Now I am running into frustration when nat able to use a video to read a pattern. I have been forcing myself to do written patterns and it is helping, but I keep having to remind myself that I am learning, and this is going to look like hell for a minute. Haha I have been crocheting for over 9 years now, and I am getting better, and I am able to understand some patterns. I have also found that some people should not write patterns because their idea of easy to follow is so deflating. I wish I had been able to read a patter and gave a video to follow as well, when I started out. Thank you for this great video!!! Take care, and God bless you and your family
I think it's unfair to generalize.. The first thing I ever crocheted was an amigurumi zebra. And i was "hooked" 😅 after that . I discovered making mufflers and sweaters and granny squares much later. I think every person has an individual journey
I'm glad that worked out for you. I just have personally seen many put off by poor quality, difficult kits in my time. Just trying to give a heads up to any wanting to begin this craft.
Many good points here. I recently followed an amigurumi tutorial and while I enjoyed the process and finished a passable version of the object, it was tricky. I have a lot of experience with knitting and embroidery, to my benefit, but wondered how the project could be targeting beginners who may not have that skill set or confidence to muster through. I like my imperfect results but had I less experience I could imagine quitting or at least entertaining tears of frustration,
Agreed! Amigurumi does not teach someone how to make a blanket or a sweater. Learn the blanket and the sweater and toys will become possible - but toys don't keep you warm in winter!
I started with amigurumi, I’ve never done any type of crocheting or knitting haha. I started by just making plain balls, then I began to experiment with changing the color like switching the yarn in the pattern. I had never done anything with any yarn before, but I will say that it might’ve been easier for me because I started when I was 19 (I’m 20 now) and I had done rainbow loom when I was a kid which I know isn’t the same but it felt familiar to me. TH-cam helped me a lot
Thank you Bonnie for sharing I tried once making an amigurumi, wasn’t so lucky I will stick to making blankets,beanies, scarves and so on Have a blessed day 🥰
I wholeheartedly agree. When asked, I always advise that someone should learn the basics first then move into the niche you desire; focus on that then move to the next. A lot of curious would be crocheters are anxious and want to 'hurry up and wait'. This is not the right approach. You can easily get frustrated a bored. I learned stitching then moved to rows, beanies and much later the Granny Square. Anything worth doing is worth learning properly. IMO. :) Thank you for your advice.
I ordered a beginner kit for my first dip into crochet. It’s SO hard, and my little dragons, while cute-leave much to be desired haha… once I finish I’m excited to try something more typical and learn a bit more. I enjoy it, and it did come with pretty detailed instructions, but I can see these little things getting very tedious as a beginner, and it really is a little discouraging to work so hard for such a lackluster item.
I am a pretty much seasoned crocheter. So when I saw this amigurumie in you tube I figured I can do that. You are so right! It took me almost a month to make princess Belle. After I finished it I swore never again. And never looked back. But fortunately it did not change my passion for crocheting. I’m currently working on the heart throw, I absolutely love the changes in the pattern and texture, it’s gonna be a beautiful Afghan. Thank you for sharing your passion.
That's great! Honestly, my main concern is all these books (and they are dominating many other good books right now) and kits that are excellent sellers online, but I wonder how many folks have been put off from crochet altogether once they try these.
HelloBonnie I’m a type of person that thinks it cute but I’d rather complete a cross stitch project and a embroidery project and of course Crochet. My granddaughters would probably be able to do that craft cause they’re teenagers ha. But I have too many projects going on right now . Thanks for your input.
Bonnie I agree with all you stated. I believe you need crochet basics before starting amigurumi and then sometimes even if you know basics,amigurumi is hard to follow. I think I'll stay with learning different stitches and try to create something from those stitches.
When I first started crocheting I tried making thoughts cute things I made a rabbit but after that I kept crocheting and I still do to this day. I started crocheting about seven years ago and love it . I am a determined person. I don't get it right the first try I try until I tackle it
I agree that they are not always easy and it's really frustrating when your child keeps asking if they can do a kit that someone has bought them and you know it's too hard for them. I actually taught my five year old daughter to crochet a number of months ago and everywhere I was driving, she was sitting in the back crocheting and working things out for herself. She can even do the ribbed neckbands using back loop only and join them on her own. I was quite surprised at what she managed to do just from watching me and watching TH-cam crocheters like you Bonnie.😁👍
My grandmother was a skilled crocheter and quilter. She crocheted only with thin cotton thread -- doilies, tablecloths, bedspreads. She tried to teach me the basics of crochet, but I could never get past the foundation chain due to getting knots too tight that had to be cut out, and start over. O was convinced for 25 years that I was incapable of learning to crochet. I jad learned to knit about 10 years after that first crochet attempt, but believed I could not do crochet. Finally a friend of mine convinced me that if I could knit, I would also be able to crochet. She was wanting to learn to knit, so we started working together and teaching each other. The roadblock of thinking I couldn't do crochet was hard to overcome. I now know that had I started with yarn, my beginning experience would have been different. I would add that a beginner should start with a light colored yarn, and a darker different colored hook to aid in seeing the thread loops and "v's".
Bonnie, you are 100% on target!!! A gal who knits with a group I belong to is in her mid-80's and thought she could pick up crocheting with fine yarn and small hooks. I tried mentioning that when I taught my second graders to crochet, we used large hooks and bulky yarn until they got the hang of it, and it worked well for them. That didn't seem to impress, and she soon gave up on the process! I wasn't trying to insult her, but it seemed that seven and eight year olds might have similar dexterity to an eighty-something person with arthritis, and I only suggested the larger materials until she got the hang of it! Just unfortunate...stick by your guns, my friend!
Thank you Amy! Your advice was excellent for your friend. Sometimes folks think this is an easy craft, especially when viewing someone with great skills. Starting big so you see a lot of progress is best. That's exactly how I teach a beginning knitting class for crocheters!
I totally agree with you! I started crochet few years ago and it's been a real "generational" thing but in the reverse way: it's my daughter who taught me! I'd always thought I was utterly hopeless until my 24yo daughter said "Nonsense!" and set up teaching me the basics :D And right now I'm crocheting the sweater you're wearing in this video for my youngest (the winter version). I've been tempted to Amigurumi a few times, but - as you say - they require a mix of skills which I sadly miss (like sewing and embroidering!). And it really annoys me to see that they're always described as "easy"!
I taught myself to crochet 52 years ago. Triangle shawls, and afghans. I hated granny squares. I did a few vests. 13 years ago. I made my first amigurumi teddy bear. I absolutely love to see these dolls and animals come to life. Just love it. I still make afghans, I have made a few of your wearables. I bought one of your books, I have my eye on another one. I agree with you on one point. NEVER buy a kit. In my opinion of any kind. Cross Stitch, Crochet, Tatting. You most always run out of stuff before the project is completed. I also agree with you, Bonnie. I want to see the Art (not the craft) of crochet to last forever. I think we should all share it with someone to keep it going. I am 72, and I never want to stop. I love your videos, thank you for all you share.
God bless you Joyce! I pray you never need to stop the "art of crochet!" I LOVE that point that you made! And like you, I have also run out of supplies using kits.
I have been crocheting for almost 20 years myself and I started with blankets, scarfs and beanies so I could get down the stitches, lengths and tensions. I’ve JUST gotten comfortable with granny squares, which in my opinion can be just as difficult as amigurumi. These take a LOT of patience and skills. I think starting at either place is like getting thrown off the deep end.
I agree with you. I struggled with them because I cannot read directions for crocheting. So I would fi like my grandma did and just make it. I made a viking hat for my son in law and his dog. He absolutely loved them. So I suggest to try it with out their instructions, have a picture of what you want, if it doesn't work try something out. It's always fun to challenge yourself and succeed. If it's not for you by all means try something else out. Thanks Bonnie for all your videos!!! My all time favorite thing is blankets❤
I agree with you about the amigurumi . It's very interesting, I love your tutorials and admire you. What I like the most of your program is the readings from the Bible and your songs. God bless you!
You are correct they are not as beginner friendly as some people make them out to be. I read some of the comments on some of those videos and shake my head thinking how can working in a simple round be so difficult, but then again those comments are coming from people with not much experience. I have been crocheting for many years, but recently started making amigurumis and I like them. It’s funny I came coming across this video bc just last night I was making a toy and I was a bit tired but wanted to crochet. I could not get my stitch count to add up when I added a second row for the life of me. Finally I said I will just make the last stitch of the round an increase and bam I completed the project. I then thought what if I did not have that skill I would have quit. So yes I think those who crochet should start with the fundamentals or crochet like you said.
No problem Michelle! I did mention in the video that some can and do learn amigurumi from the very beginning, but you all who do are exceptional. I've just seen too many others discouraged by this, and this is mostly what I am speaking into. So glad you are enjoying these!
I do believe the other big thing that turns people off are these very poorly written patterns that you can buy on Etsy, etc. I can't tell you how many patterns I have gotten that just needed to be reworked and unfortunately it is most often ami patterns. 🤷 Your patterns however, are just lovely. Seasoned old crocheter here. This is very good advice you give. ❤️
Honestly, I’ve been crocheting over 50 years and struggle with any of the stuffed items. I started teaching my 8 year old granddaughter last Summer, and we started with chain stitches, then moved on to sc,
Adding on, a lot of amigurumi patterns want you to crochet with yarning UNDER, rather than over. A lot of these people swear there's no difference, but obviously there is a difference in how the stitches look and in how dense the fabric is. That's the whole reason to do it for amigurumi, to make a tighter fabric so the stuffing stays inside better. So a lot of newbies are learning this technique first, then carrying it over to their regular crochet.
Hi from France ! I started crocheting with a very old manual and doily patterns. But quite quickly, on the occasion of the birth of my best friend's son, I turned to amigurumis to make him various cuddly toys as birth gifts. Now, two years later, I have decided not to make amigurumis anymore: I don't know how to embroider and I only have vague basics in sewing. Although I have never been tempted to deny my work, the assembly stage has always been more of a chore than a pleasure for me. Recently, I made an exception at the request of my sister, who asked me for a cuddly toy for my first nephew who had recently come into the world. I just could not say no
I too struggle with the construction part. As a teenager I never completed the 3 bears that came with the "Goldilocks" doll I showed. The heads never looked right to me.
Everything you say here is absolutely true and really great advice. I have been crocheting for over 50 years and have made countless blankets "alot from your patterns Bonnie" 😊, Have made some ammagarumi toys but never was really pleased with them. I have a bag of disasters shoved in a bag and hidden well out of sight somewhere!! It's the construction of them that let me down. It's really hard!! I can do great appliques though! 😂 I have also been teaching crochet for 20years and would NEVER dream of starting to learn anyone with ammagarumi. I always teach them the granny square first. I think it is the best as it has a good variety of learning skills within it and when mastered produces something really beautiful and my students are always so pleased when they discover they CAN do it!!
Tension is needed for amigurumi AND wearables and things like washcloths as well. I learned with amigurmi. Either way you need to start by learning the basic stitches. I don’t like kits for any reason. Many times the materials that come in them are not of good quality. The quality of them would make any kind of crochet hard to do. There a lot of things to consider with any kind of crochet. A good teacher is needed as well. Some people just can’t teach and there are many of those out there (Not you Bonnie). I feel strongly about this.
I totally agree! And thanks for not putting me on that bad list! I so appreciate that. And yes, the yarn is ofter low quality in the kits, which I how they keep up the high profit margin I believe.
I've been crocheting over 55 years and I still don't feel my amigurumi skills are good enough! I can crochet pieces all day long, but sewing them together in a cohesive manner seems to be beyond me. I had a similar experience to what you described with knitting as a child. Girl Scouts started us off with a triangular pattern. So increases and decreases right away. Never earned that badge. I finally taught myself to knit like 50 years later with squares. I still test new stitches this way (I have a great collection of both knitted and crocheted washclothes as a result). Foundation is so important for any skill.
Yes yes, I am 75 and have crocheted since my teens. Amigurumi is very hard for most everything. I have worked some very complicated ones as I am experienced and thought I could do it..... Ha ha It was very frustrating. I have gone back to easier ones, but they are so hard to put together... I am doing an ant right now and just finished a fancy complicated snail. I will never be able to do one twice... just not into that kind of self abuse...grin I always return to my simple socks to fall in love with crochet all over again.
Seems to be a lot of crochet snobbery in the comments 😅 Some people pick things up quicker than others or have a different learning style. I wouldn’t discourage anyone from trying🤷🏻♀️
@@Crocs4cats I definitely don’t want to encourage anyone from trying crochet. As a teacher though, I’ve seen too many people give up on the craft entirely because of terribly designed kits which required the skills of an experienced crocheter but marketed as “easy”. I’m not anti-amigurumi at all. Yes, some can handle jumping into the deep end of the pool, but many more cannot. I am speaking to these in this video. 😊
Thank you for saying that Bonnie! You are so right in saying that “cute is not easy”. I have been crocheting for almost 50 years, and I totally agree with you!!
I love making amigurumi, but I'm a crocheter who sets no limits on myself with crocheting. Crocheting on TH-cam for me takes away from crocheting in some aspects. A lot tends to give you commands, not suggestions or choices. I'm so fortunate that my mother taught me how to crochet she always told me to try it and see what I thought, she never told me not to when I was learning. Amigurumi and granny squares are very similar you have to sew them together, unless you're doing one large granny square. What works for some individuals, doesn't works for all individuals. I also have a large selection od crochet books as well as others. I believe life is full of options.
I totally agree Judith! I’m only suggesting that amigurumi wait until the crocheter has the necessary skills to have the confidence to enjoy the journey of making these.😊
I understood that and I understand that everything in life is a process. Some people don't have patience when learning something new. When my mother was teaching me as a child, I learned by doing a chain and my mother kept pulling it loose, because of my tension. People need to understand that they have to practice and don't give up. I really wish it is in school curriculum in states, like it is in Finland, as well as other European countries.
@@judithbrown4229 I agree. I always tell my crochet students of all ages: mistakes are allowed and the best way to learn! I'm afraid a lot of the arts (home arts, music, art, etc.) are not given much priority in schools these days, at least not where I have taught. It is very sad. I went to college to become a band director in the public schools, but could never find a job after 3 years of searching. There were many cuts to "get back to the basics", which cut out the arts basically.
I know individuals learn 5 different ways. I've had to learn to critique so many different ways to tutor individuals with math. Every person grasp things differently, I notice that when a person is learning something new it's overwhelming for them and sometimes I had to make a task analysis for them and they learn it by doing steps. Thinking back when I was learning to crochet the slip knot was a challenge for me, but I was 6 when I learned. TH-cam has changed a lot of aspects of learning to crochet. I am fortunate my mom taught me to make an unnoticeable mistake when I crochet, because only God is perfect and I always give him praise. I believe that just like people gave up on learning math, they ended up coming back from a week to a month. They will be coming back if they really need or want to learn.
I haven’t yet simply because there are so many other great teachers and designers already available. If I feel inspired in the future I may, but it will be a while.
I am 65, and I have been crocheting since I was 14. I took 4 years of sewing in high school and have sewn a lot since then. I don't feel real, comfortable crocheting these. I have tried the real easy ones, and it's a pain in my opinion.
I disagree. I don't think you should ever discourage anyone from trying any type of art form. Everyone learns differently. Personally, I had several false starts with crochet, I found granny squares difficult and boring. When I found amigurumi's it was a totally different experience, I enjoyed it, and learned a lot doing them. If someone had told me not to try it, I would have given up on crochet all together. That being said...crochet is not for everyone. However I would say that anyone wanting to try it should start with an easy project that calls their attention and if it doesn't work out try a different one until you find the one that brings you joy.
I disagree cause I learnt with it and it's mostly just 1 stitch and it gets them used to actually crocheting and then they can learn more complicated things
I can understand what you are saying. However, I enjoy crocheting amigurumi as well as most everything else too. When beginning my crochet journey, I watched a great deal of TH-cam videos to learn how to crochet various techniques. I’ve learned so much over the years through watching these videos. I did start out crocheting hats and blankets before learning amigurumi. I am so thankful to be able to do this craft, whether it be granny squares, hats, afghans, or amigurumi. It brings me so much joy. There are many beginner friendly amigurumi patterns out there, that can easily be learned. It is good to know basic stitches before beginning, but it’s really not that hard to learn. It’s like anything else, the more you do it, the better you’ll get. However, I wouldn’t suggest beginning with one of those kits. Just some prior knowledge of basic stitches, yarn, hook, stuffing, scissors, needle, and a beginner friendly crochet video or pattern to follow along with and you can create cute amigurumi as well. ❤
I'm 58, and have crocheted on and off for over 50 years. I have never done, nor been tempted to make amigurumis, so any knowledge is definitely not first hand... 😂 BUT I know I would definitely NEVER recommend that a newbie go there first. Just watching others do this has shown me that you definitely need some skill building before you go down the amigurumi path. Have a great day. 🐞
They Are adorable and i made one as a dog toy but it isnt sth i would Wanna Place in my Appartement and for laying around in the closet it’s really a tedious task like you Said.
Bonnie, you're absolutely right...Amigurumi is very difficult for a beginner. I learned that the hard way. Believe or not, I've been working on one that I began 2 yrs ago & I want to finally finish it but I keep having to crochet certain parts over again so that it doesn't end up looking like something the cat dragged in😅😂
I completely disagree. I learned to crochet on amigurumi. It’s really not that hard. I find it easier than crocheting what you consider easy. When I first wanted to learn to crochet, my mom tried to get me to do a granny square and I gave up because it was too confusing and most importantly, BORING. I don’t find joy in making something that doesn’t look like anything. 6 years after I gave up on the granny square I crocheted a jellyfish from a pattern I found online. Maybe it’s my previous knowledge on hand sewing but even a couple of my friends that don’t know how to sew do amigurumi and learned how to crochet on amigurumi.
You are lucky to have enjoyed the experience as your first experience. 💕💕💕💕 It may have been easier for you knowing the basics of sewing & understanding how to put things together in a 3D type format. Majority of people don’t have those experiences. After learning to love crocheting by learning & perfecting the basics, tension, stitches, counting stitches, compiling simple patterns, yarn, etc. I still couldn’t make it through a basic amigurimi pattern.
To learn I was actually researching about quilting from Melanie Ham & pulled up one of her crochet videos for a washcloth or something. Got through part of it & kept repeating that my hands will adjust to the technique with practice. I could only imagine if I had attempted an amigurumi the hooks would have been thrown away & yarn burned. 😂😂😂😂. I then branched out to learn tips & techniques from other crochet TH-camrs in perfecting what works for me with from holding the yarn, magic ring, slip knots, circles, stitches. Even forcing myself to learn about reading a basic pattern before jumping into to an amigurumi project my son had put in front of me from the beginning! The fear of starting & hating crocheting after that was real!
Finally got the courage to crochet a giant spider for my son at Halloween! I did it & it was an incredible accomplishment, but once completed I was over it! If I had started my journey this way my love & growth within the craft would have never been.
If I’m bored & need a challenge I’ll jump over to a bag, mini earphone covers, some amigurumi & many other options because I know the basics. Amigurumi is everything all at once in a format that many could find overwhelming & frustrating eliminating their chances of learning to grow & love what we all do. Missing out on the benefits of completing a project as small as they may be.
Strange how it works for each of us as individuals. I love to see how others process things so differently. Even with this, crocheting requires us to know the basics & be confident with them to really enjoy the full process of any type of project.
Oh I also do quilting by machine, but always got frustrated with clothing. That could be another reason for being thankful I didn’t start with amigurumi.
Everyone has their unique way of processing information & growing in new experiences. I have to agree that when sharing or encouraging others to love what we do focusing on the basics & accomplishing a small simple project is a safer approach to help them find the joy in crocheting. Simple, doable & able to complete.
If I had a crocheting friend who could do amigurumi & said she started that way I’d feel tremendous pressure to do the same. Any issues along the way would ruin the experience because it’s complex when doing amigurumi. Not only giving up & feeling like a failure for not being able to do as my friend did, I would have never learned to love this craft that has truly helped me with so much more than just creating projects or gifts. Boring isn’t always bad. The fundamentals of everything is extremely important for confidence that will lead to enjoyment.
My amigurumi queen friend hyping me up to start from the basics is a huge win for all!
If I had I wouldn’t have found the one thing I’ve come to love that has tremendously helped me with my current health issues. It’s literally been a life saver.
I learned to crochet at 4 years old from my great grandmother. She told me to start with a simple scarf. I have been crocheting since then and I'm 58 now. A beginner was telling me how she bought a kit to make a cute duck, and she couldn't do it, so I taught her basic stitches. Told her to practice these stitches first. Totally agree with you!
I agree Bonnie! I just started doing this type of crochet after doing traditional crochet for 30 years! After much frustration I found a TH-cam video that showed how to yarn over the hook opposite of the traditional yarn over this enabled me to get tight even stitches! Have not had a problem since!
I learnt to crochet 50 years ago, after watching my grandma. I love making intricate tablecloth’s, doilies and bed spreads with the thinnest cotton threads and also beautiful afgans and throws in yarn. I am yet to crochet any amigurumi, but I am not in any hurry.
@@DulceN 😂😂😂I understand that! They are indeed very cute, but how wonderful that we can choose what we want to make.😊😊😊
I notice how the crafters markets are stuffed (pun intended) with bees, dolls, and others. I wish those crocheters could diversify. It’s hard to stand out.
But my aunt also discouraged me from making what I wanted to learn, saying I could only learn my making an afghan with course yarn 😵💫 so learn and stay positive through the process!
When I show someone how to crochet I start them with a simple scarf so I can teach them SC, 1/2 DC, DC and TC in 1 project ❤️
That’s such a great way to start Johnny! Thanks for teaching others this wonderful craft! Hope you are well in FL.
@berrycarbs Absolutely! Most things in life take some practice to accomplish. This craft is no different, but time well spent!
Thank you very much for your open/honest words on the subject of amigurimi, I have tried these little works so many times and spent so much money on eyes etc - and yet I was almost always disappointed with the result; among other things because I couldn't cope with the thin yarn/wool required/specified
Your patterns, crocheted with thicker wool, are always successful and bring joy - for me and those I give them as gifts
😊❤️❤️❤️
Bonnie .I watch you a lot. I'm so thankful that you are handing the craft of crocheting down to younger generations. Iv been crocheting since I was 15 yrs old. I simply love trying new stitches. And my phone is filled with your videos.i. so excited because iv never attempted to do an amigurumi. I will definitely watch your videos
I encourage folks to give amigurumi a try, just not at the very beginning of the learning process. Thank you so very much for your kind words and support Genny!
I taught my granddaughter to crochet dishcloths at 8 years. She is now 15. She makes amigurumi gifts for her teachers and friends at church. Gets patterns from TH-cam. Last year she made bags for all her friends. I made a kit amigurumi that a child bought me to thank me for making her several ponytail hats. The kit was difficult. Very tiny cats. Not for a beginner. I make amigurumi items every year for great nieces and nephew. How they love them and look forward to what I bring each Christmas. I agree 💯 that those kits are not for beginners. Well said, Bonnie.
Thank you Dawn, and how wonderful that you are teaching the next generation this great skill!😊❤️❤️❤️
Agree! My grandmother started me with a granny square and she passed but I went on by my self to learn.
When I started crocheting my mom tried to teach me granny squares when I was in my teens and when I didn’t get it but now that I’m an adult I’ve gotten back into it. I made some blankets including hooded ones. Then I recently started amigurumi. I had no idea how to read a pattern so I started with a bee and regular yarn from my stash just because I knew there was only so much yarn in the kit. Now that I have a better understanding of how to read patterns I’ve made several stuffies and look forward to doing more. I do agree that these are not ideal for a beginner as it can be frustrating. Try it in your own time, but keep in mind that if you mess up you will have to frog it and start over or will need different yarn. Good luck everyone
I 100% agree. It is so easy to be put off. The first time I attempted crochet I couldn't get the item to lie flat. No-one would or could tell me where I was going wrong! I tried again a few years later and fully fell in love with the craft. Thank you for this video. 🧶💕
So glad you gave it another try and didn’t give up Sue!😊❤️
You are absolutely right Bonnie because I crochet and I have never crocheted a amigurumi just because of all the details and you have to make sure those stitches are perfect in the round so thank God no this is not my first project I love crocheting😊
😊😊😊
You are absolutely right, Bonnie. Thanks for your honesty! 😘❤️🌹
I get where you are coming from with this. I do.
But like just about everything, I don’t think it’s one size fits all. I learned to crochet with amigurumi. Taught myself from photos in a book. If, when I was starting out, someone told me that I couldn’t make the thing I wanted to make, that I had to spend hours making these other things that I had zero interest or desire to make first, THAT would have discouraged me to the point of never picking it up at all.
Was my first amigurumi perfect, absolutely not. But I learned a ton and my second was much much better. We all learn differently and there is no wrong way.
I do agree with you though that some of the kits should maybe not be advertised as beginner. That said, Amigurumis usually do only use single crochet and are in the round which in many ways is easier than flat so it may really depend on definitions. My two cents.
It is good that you had a book to start and not only a kit. That really was my main point. I was just at the bookstore yesterday and most beginning and intermediate crochet books have been replaced by Amigurmi kits that lookedepretty complicated to me - all aimed at beginners. I think we agree on this one. I totally understand that some folks thrive on these items. I have just seen the opposite effect of these kits killing all motivation too many times.
I agree however I started with an Amigurumi TH-cam video and figured it out. Still have it. But I can see that trying to learn from a kit would never have worked for me as I’m a visual learner.
Yes, there are many excellent videos available now, but that doesn't include many kits.
I agree with a lot of what you say, but I actually did learn through amigurumi! Not through a kit though… but through TH-cam! You are right that amigurumi shouldn’t be your absolute first attempt though. I began learning by making little flat squares (as you said), then moved to making a plain round ball. The first “cute” animal I made was a baby octopus, which was a very basic shape, and required zero sewing. If you are planning on starting with amigurumi as a beginner, I suggest you find a good, simple pattern (anything that looks basically like a ball is a good way to start), and follow along with a beginner-friendly video.
Here are the benefits I found to starting with amigurumi rather than something like a granny square:
- It takes very little yarn, and you can find projects that only require one color
- It teaches you increasing and decreasing
- It teaches you to be disciplined about counting your stitches
- It teaches you how and when and why to use a stitch marker
- It is VERY rewarding because the end product is something cute that can be displayed or played with
I agree Lauren! I have no objections once a crocheter has some basic skills. I still treasure the dolls I made as a child, but as you said, I didn't start there! Wishing you all the best!
I agree with you. I love your blouse . Do you have a pattern for the blouse you wear. I am from India
Yes I do! Here's the video for the Celtic Braided Sweater for the summer version: th-cam.com/video/wj-ZW3M2ycU/w-d-xo.html
This will refer you to this video for the winter version. You simply don't add the sleeves and use a different yarn mentioned in the above video. th-cam.com/video/ZBD1b1lEIlg/w-d-xo.html
Good video Bonnie! My 2 grandkids just got me 2 kits for Mother’s Day (needless to say it was for them) but they wanted me to make it for them. My grandson picked out a frog and my granddaughter picked out a bird of some sort. I have been crocheting for over 25 years and I even knit here and there. You are so correct about those kits misleading people to make them think they are easy and beginner friendly! I’ll tell ya I started out with the frog and here is my pet peeve as it sits here for 3 weeks now… not only did you have to keep the same tension (which is so HARD) because you normally work with the thinnest yarn but the patterns are TINY. So anyway I started with the head, body and now I’m on the arms which requires me to make a magic ring and 6 stitches in a round for 12 rows!!!! Did you hear me? 6stitches in a round for 12 rows!! My hands oh my hands! That is thee smallest piece of yarn I had to work with and needless to say I gave up on round 2 and that’s why my project is still here 3 weeks later and the bird kit hasn’t been touched. My poor grandkids keep coming saying “Mom-Mom are you finished? You said 2 days!!” I feel bad so after seeing this video I can relate to what you are trying to say and your sooo right!! But you also gave me the inspiration to finish these 2 kits and tell them no more but I can make them pillows or blankets if they like lol thanks
I would maybe consider trying one of the "Edwards Menagerie of Birds" or one of their books. You can make these beautiful creations any size, and using any yarn weight. I believe they are much better written and very reliable. My daughter made the flamingo without any issues and it came out beautifully! www.amazon.com/Edwards-Menagerie-Birds-Patterns-Crochet/dp/144630602X/ref=asc_df_144630602X/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=693352901730&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=1949060501349984786&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=c&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9007799&hvtargid=pla-556410643197&psc=1&mcid=b2795b6b45f2384abc0767bcfad1d2dd&gad_source=1
I totally agree. I was looking for something to try. I’ve tried knitting but it didn’t last. Last night I downloaded some crochet kits for beginners and noticed wow this doesn’t look beginner I have to learn to read this first. Tried on beginner dishcloth and they skipped the beginning on the slip not and how to do a chain. I like your beginner dishcloth. Thank you
I hope you find something that really blesses you!
I started just learning how to chain. I was about 4 or 5 and saw my mother crocheting and said I wanted to try. She gave me a hook and yarn and showed me how to make a chain.
I made a chain longer than me and dragged it with me around the house. 😂
That's great! I remember doing something like that too!
Thanks for this video Bonnie, that's why I never try to make the cute little toys. I stick to my lane. Blankets, beanies, scarfs, shawls.
When you are ready, definitely give them a try. They are fun once you have the skills!😊
I too picked up crochet through one of the kits at Barnes and Noble before woobles even started. Trying to figure out how to make the stitches was hard by just looking at the photos. No prior experiance just wanted to make the cute bunny. My gauge was garbage and I needed more yarn. But because it was a project I was determined to do it came together. I have been crocheting ever since.
Yes, I remember a couple of these in my history too! So glad you stuck with it Michelle!
I started with Amigurumi. However, I knew about tension and such from my grandma's and mother.
No, starting with Ami is a hardship for sure and can have a very negative effect on your thoughts.
The fact that you have an actual book that you can gallows along with a video is AWESOME!!!
I learned to crochet from videos and never learned pattern reading. Now I am running into frustration when nat able to use a video to read a pattern. I have been forcing myself to do written patterns and it is helping, but I keep having to remind myself that I am learning, and this is going to look like hell for a minute. Haha
I have been crocheting for over 9 years now, and I am getting better, and I am able to understand some patterns. I have also found that some people should not write patterns because their idea of easy to follow is so deflating.
I wish I had been able to read a patter and gave a video to follow as well, when I started out.
Thank you for this great video!!!
Take care, and God bless you and your family
I think it's unfair to generalize.. The first thing I ever crocheted was an amigurumi zebra. And i was "hooked" 😅 after that . I discovered making mufflers and sweaters and granny squares much later. I think every person has an individual journey
I'm glad that worked out for you. I just have personally seen many put off by poor quality, difficult kits in my time. Just trying to give a heads up to any wanting to begin this craft.
I learnt and crocheted amigurami dolls.but I totally agree it is not for all.i continue with sweters and shawls now.
Many good points here. I recently followed an amigurumi tutorial and while I enjoyed the process and finished a passable version of the object, it was tricky. I have a lot of experience with knitting and embroidery, to my benefit, but wondered how the project could be targeting beginners who may not have that skill set or confidence to muster through. I like my imperfect results but had I less experience I could imagine quitting or at least entertaining tears of frustration,
@@lisahase-jackson3150 thanks for understanding what I was trying to communicate. I’m glad you were able to complete your project!
It is thanks to you if I love crochet so much. I’m not perfectly bilingual but with you, it’s so easy. ❤
Just to let you know, we have closed captions for many of our newer videos - and in 11 different languages should you ever have need Rose!
That needed to be said Bonnie.
Agreed! Amigurumi does not teach someone how to make a blanket or a sweater. Learn the blanket and the sweater and toys will become possible - but toys don't keep you warm in winter!
I started with amigurumi, I’ve never done any type of crocheting or knitting haha. I started by just making plain balls, then I began to experiment with changing the color like switching the yarn in the pattern. I had never done anything with any yarn before, but I will say that it might’ve been easier for me because I started when I was 19 (I’m 20 now) and I had done rainbow loom when I was a kid which I know isn’t the same but it felt familiar to me. TH-cam helped me a lot
So glad you enjoy crochet! Sounds like you have a lot of patience and determination.
Thank you Bonnie for sharing I tried once making an amigurumi, wasn’t so lucky I will stick to making blankets,beanies, scarves and so on Have a blessed day 🥰
I wholeheartedly agree. When asked, I always advise that someone should learn the basics first then move into the niche you desire; focus on that then move to the next. A lot of curious would be crocheters are anxious and want to 'hurry up and wait'. This is not the right approach. You can easily get frustrated a bored. I learned stitching then moved to rows, beanies and much later the Granny Square. Anything worth doing is worth learning properly. IMO. :) Thank you for your advice.
I so agree with you! If you are going to make amigurumi, do it the right way, and dare I say: "Enjoy the journey too!" Take care.
I ordered a beginner kit for my first dip into crochet. It’s SO hard, and my little dragons, while cute-leave much to be desired haha… once I finish I’m excited to try something more typical and learn a bit more. I enjoy it, and it did come with pretty detailed instructions, but I can see these little things getting very tedious as a beginner, and it really is a little discouraging to work so hard for such a lackluster item.
I understand. Definitely try something on the easier side and save this kit for a bit later down the road.
Thank you for sharing this!
I am a pretty much seasoned crocheter. So when I saw this amigurumie in you tube I figured I can do that.
You are so right! It took me almost a month to make princess Belle. After I finished it I swore never again. And never looked back. But fortunately it did not change my passion for crocheting. I’m currently working on the heart throw, I absolutely love the changes in the pattern and texture, it’s gonna be a beautiful Afghan. Thank you for sharing your passion.
That's great! Honestly, my main concern is all these books (and they are dominating many other good books right now) and kits that are excellent sellers online, but I wonder how many folks have been put off from crochet altogether once they try these.
@berrycarbs yes, books can be excellent resources for items like this.
HelloBonnie
I’m a type of person that thinks it cute but I’d rather complete a cross stitch project and a embroidery project and of course Crochet.
My granddaughters would probably be able to do that craft cause they’re teenagers ha. But I have too many projects going on right now .
Thanks for your input.
Bonnie I agree with all you stated. I believe you need crochet basics before starting amigurumi and then sometimes even if you know basics,amigurumi is hard to follow. I think I'll stay with learning different stitches and try to create something from those stitches.
When I first started crocheting I tried making thoughts cute things I made a rabbit but after that I kept crocheting and I still do to this day. I started crocheting about seven years ago and love it . I am a determined person. I don't get it right the first try I try until I tackle it
I agree that they are not always easy and it's really frustrating when your child keeps asking if they can do a kit that someone has bought them and you know it's too hard for them.
I actually taught my five year old daughter to crochet a number of months ago and everywhere I was driving, she was sitting in the back crocheting and working things out for herself. She can even do the ribbed neckbands using back loop only and join them on her own. I was quite surprised at what she managed to do just from watching me and watching TH-cam crocheters like you Bonnie.😁👍
That's wonderful Ruthie! You've got a very smart 5 year old with a lot of wonderful dexterity in those hands!
My grandmother was a skilled crocheter and quilter. She crocheted only with thin cotton thread -- doilies, tablecloths, bedspreads. She tried to teach me the basics of crochet, but I could never get past the foundation chain due to getting knots too tight that had to be cut out, and start over. O was convinced for 25 years that I was incapable of learning to crochet. I jad learned to knit about 10 years after that first crochet attempt, but believed I could not do crochet. Finally a friend of mine convinced me that if I could knit, I would also be able to crochet. She was wanting to learn to knit, so we started working together and teaching each other. The roadblock of thinking I couldn't do crochet was hard to overcome. I now know that had I started with yarn, my beginning experience would have been different. I would add that a beginner should start with a light colored yarn, and a darker different colored hook to aid in seeing the thread loops and "v's".
Your recommendations are spot on Rena! I always suggest this for my classes.
Bonnie, you are 100% on target!!! A gal who knits with a group I belong to is in her mid-80's and thought she could pick up crocheting with fine yarn and small hooks. I tried mentioning that when I taught my second graders to crochet, we used large hooks and bulky yarn until they got the hang of it, and it worked well for them. That didn't seem to impress, and she soon gave up on the process! I wasn't trying to insult her, but it seemed that seven and eight year olds might have similar dexterity to an eighty-something person with arthritis, and I only suggested the larger materials until she got the hang of it! Just unfortunate...stick by your guns, my friend!
Thank you Amy! Your advice was excellent for your friend. Sometimes folks think this is an easy craft, especially when viewing someone with great skills. Starting big so you see a lot of progress is best. That's exactly how I teach a beginning knitting class for crocheters!
I agree with you Bonnie. As a someone who has be crochet for many many years the patterns cn be difficult.
I totally agree with you! I started crochet few years ago and it's been a real "generational" thing but in the reverse way: it's my daughter who taught me! I'd always thought I was utterly hopeless until my 24yo daughter said "Nonsense!" and set up teaching me the basics :D And right now I'm crocheting the sweater you're wearing in this video for my youngest (the winter version). I've been tempted to Amigurumi a few times, but - as you say - they require a mix of skills which I sadly miss (like sewing and embroidering!). And it really annoys me to see that they're always described as "easy"!
I taught myself to crochet 52 years ago. Triangle shawls, and afghans. I hated granny squares. I did a few vests.
13 years ago. I made my first amigurumi teddy bear.
I absolutely love to see these dolls and animals come to life. Just love it.
I still make afghans, I have made a few of your wearables. I bought one of your books, I have my eye on another one.
I agree with you on one point. NEVER buy a kit. In my opinion of any kind. Cross Stitch, Crochet, Tatting. You most always run out of stuff before the project is completed.
I also agree with you, Bonnie.
I want to see the Art (not the craft) of crochet to last forever. I think we should all share it with someone to keep it going.
I am 72, and I never want to stop.
I love your videos, thank you for all you share.
God bless you Joyce! I pray you never need to stop the "art of crochet!" I LOVE that point that you made! And like you, I have also run out of supplies using kits.
I have been crocheting for almost 20 years myself and I started with blankets, scarfs and beanies so I could get down the stitches, lengths and tensions. I’ve JUST gotten comfortable with granny squares, which in my opinion can be just as difficult as amigurumi. These take a LOT of patience and skills. I think starting at either place is like getting thrown off the deep end.
I agree! Glad that made some sense!
I agree with you. I struggled with them because I cannot read directions for crocheting. So I would fi like my grandma did and just make it. I made a viking hat for my son in law and his dog. He absolutely loved them. So I suggest to try it with out their instructions, have a picture of what you want, if it doesn't work try something out. It's always fun to challenge yourself and succeed. If it's not for you by all means try something else out. Thanks Bonnie for all your videos!!! My all time favorite thing is blankets❤
Exactly! Definitely try something else if a project isn't working out. Great advice!
No Bonnie I never was discouraged from crocheting a difficult project if t get too frustrated I will put it away for a couple of days ❤❤❤❤❤
Good for you Maria! That's the way to go!
I totally agree Bonnie! 💜
I agree with you about the amigurumi . It's very interesting, I love your tutorials and admire you. What I like the most of your program is the readings from the Bible and your songs. God bless you!
Thank you Maria! I love doing both the readings (I need these every day in my life), and I love any excuse to play music!
You are correct they are not as beginner friendly as some people make them out to be. I read some of the comments on some of those videos and shake my head thinking how can working in a simple round be so difficult, but then again those comments are coming from people with not much experience. I have been crocheting for many years, but recently started making amigurumis and I like them. It’s funny I came coming across this video bc just last night I was making a toy and I was a bit tired but wanted to crochet. I could not get my stitch count to add up when I added a second row for the life of me. Finally I said I will just make the last stitch of the round an increase and bam I completed the project. I then thought what if I did not have that skill I would have quit. So yes I think those who crochet should start with the fundamentals or crochet like you said.
Well said! Thank you!
i started amigurumi. i find it alot easier than wearables and brain numbing blankets. its all good if you like those but i couldnt do it
No problem Michelle! I did mention in the video that some can and do learn amigurumi from the very beginning, but you all who do are exceptional. I've just seen too many others discouraged by this, and this is mostly what I am speaking into. So glad you are enjoying these!
I do believe the other big thing that turns people off are these very poorly written patterns that you can buy on Etsy, etc. I can't tell you how many patterns I have gotten that just needed to be reworked and unfortunately it is most often ami patterns. 🤷 Your patterns however, are just lovely. Seasoned old crocheter here. This is very good advice you give. ❤️
Thank you! 😊❤️
Honestly, I’ve been crocheting over 50 years and struggle with any of the stuffed items. I started teaching my 8 year old granddaughter last Summer, and we started with chain stitches, then moved on to sc,
How wonderful that you are teaching your granddaughter to crochet! What a blessing!
great
Adding on, a lot of amigurumi patterns want you to crochet with yarning UNDER, rather than over. A lot of these people swear there's no difference, but obviously there is a difference in how the stitches look and in how dense the fabric is. That's the whole reason to do it for amigurumi, to make a tighter fabric so the stuffing stays inside better. So a lot of newbies are learning this technique first, then carrying it over to their regular crochet.
Yes, that’s not the best way to start, especially if you want to meet gauge in non-amigurumi designs in the future.
Hi from France !
I started crocheting with a very old manual and doily patterns. But quite quickly, on the occasion of the birth of my best friend's son, I turned to amigurumis to make him various cuddly toys as birth gifts. Now, two years later, I have decided not to make amigurumis anymore: I don't know how to embroider and I only have vague basics in sewing. Although I have never been tempted to deny my work, the assembly stage has always been more of a chore than a pleasure for me. Recently, I made an exception at the request of my sister, who asked me for a cuddly toy for my first nephew who had recently come into the world. I just could not say no
I too struggle with the construction part. As a teenager I never completed the 3 bears that came with the "Goldilocks" doll I showed. The heads never looked right to me.
Everything you say here is absolutely true and really great advice. I have been crocheting for over 50 years and have made countless blankets "alot from your patterns Bonnie" 😊, Have made some ammagarumi toys but never was really pleased with them. I have a bag of disasters shoved in a bag and hidden well out of sight somewhere!! It's the construction of them that let me down. It's really hard!! I can do great appliques though! 😂 I have also been teaching crochet for 20years and would NEVER dream of starting to learn anyone with ammagarumi. I always teach them the granny square first. I think it is the best as it has a good variety of learning skills within it and when mastered produces something really beautiful and my students are always so pleased when they discover they CAN do it!!
It makes sense Bonnie..❤
Tension is needed for amigurumi AND wearables and things like washcloths as well. I learned with amigurmi. Either way you need to start by learning the basic stitches. I don’t like kits for any reason. Many times the materials that come in them are not of good quality. The quality of them would make any kind of crochet hard to do. There a lot of things to consider with any kind of crochet. A good teacher is needed as well. Some people just can’t teach and there are many of those out there (Not you Bonnie). I feel strongly about this.
I totally agree! And thanks for not putting me on that bad list! I so appreciate that. And yes, the yarn is ofter low quality in the kits, which I how they keep up the high profit margin I believe.
I've been crocheting over 55 years and I still don't feel my amigurumi skills are good enough! I can crochet pieces all day long, but sewing them together in a cohesive manner seems to be beyond me. I had a similar experience to what you described with knitting as a child. Girl Scouts started us off with a triangular pattern. So increases and decreases right away. Never earned that badge. I finally taught myself to knit like 50 years later with squares. I still test new stitches this way (I have a great collection of both knitted and crocheted washclothes as a result). Foundation is so important for any skill.
Thanks for sharing this. Yes, that knitted dishcloth has a lot of skills required, plus knitting with cotton isn’t easy either!😫😂
Yes yes, I am 75 and have crocheted since my teens. Amigurumi is very hard for most everything. I have worked some very complicated ones as I am experienced and thought I could do it..... Ha ha It was very frustrating. I have gone back to easier ones, but they are so hard to put together... I am doing an ant right now and just finished a fancy complicated snail. I will never be able to do one twice... just not into that kind of self abuse...grin
I always return to my simple socks to fall in love with crochet all over again.
I'm right there with you! Sticking to what I love the most!
Seems to be a lot of crochet snobbery in the comments 😅 Some people pick things up quicker than others or have a different learning style. I wouldn’t discourage anyone from trying🤷🏻♀️
@@Crocs4cats I definitely don’t want to encourage anyone from trying crochet. As a teacher though, I’ve seen too many people give up on the craft entirely because of terribly designed kits which required the skills of an experienced crocheter but marketed as “easy”. I’m not anti-amigurumi at all. Yes, some can handle jumping into the deep end of the pool, but many more cannot. I am speaking to these in this video. 😊
@@BonnieBayCrochet Maybe your title is misleading then if you only mean kits☺️
Thank you for saying that Bonnie! You are so right in saying that “cute is not easy”. I have been crocheting for almost 50 years, and I totally agree with you!!
0:17 😮 0:17 r😅
I love making amigurumi, but I'm a crocheter who sets no limits on myself with crocheting. Crocheting on TH-cam for me takes away from crocheting in some aspects. A lot tends to give you commands, not suggestions or choices. I'm so fortunate that my mother taught me how to crochet she always told me to try it and see what I thought, she never told me not to when I was learning. Amigurumi and granny squares are very similar you have to sew them together, unless you're doing one large granny square. What works for some individuals, doesn't works for all individuals. I also have a large selection od crochet books as well as others. I believe life is full of options.
I totally agree Judith! I’m only suggesting that amigurumi wait until the crocheter has the necessary skills to have the confidence to enjoy the journey of making these.😊
I understood that and I understand that everything in life is a process. Some people don't have patience when learning something new. When my mother was teaching me as a child, I learned by doing a chain and my mother kept pulling it loose, because of my tension. People need to understand that they have to practice and don't give up. I really wish it is in school curriculum in states, like it is in Finland, as well as other European countries.
@@judithbrown4229 I agree. I always tell my crochet students of all ages: mistakes are allowed and the best way to learn! I'm afraid a lot of the arts (home arts, music, art, etc.) are not given much priority in schools these days, at least not where I have taught. It is very sad. I went to college to become a band director in the public schools, but could never find a job after 3 years of searching. There were many cuts to "get back to the basics", which cut out the arts basically.
I know individuals learn 5 different ways. I've had to learn to critique so many different ways to tutor individuals with math. Every person grasp things differently, I notice that when a person is learning something new it's overwhelming for them and sometimes I had to make a task analysis for them and they learn it by doing steps. Thinking back when I was learning to crochet the slip knot was a challenge for me, but I was 6 when I learned. TH-cam has changed a lot of aspects of learning to crochet. I am fortunate my mom taught me to make an unnoticeable mistake when I crochet, because only God is perfect and I always give him praise. I believe that just like people gave up on learning math, they ended up coming back from a week to a month. They will be coming back if they really need or want to learn.
@@judithbrown4229 Having homeschool my 5 children through various stages, I so agree with you!
Are you going to teach them. Please
I haven’t yet simply because there are so many other great teachers and designers already available. If I feel inspired in the future I may, but it will be a while.
Grazie del consiglio Bonnie, è proprio così, gli amigurumi non sono per niente facili e richiedono esperienza . Buona giornata ❤
🙂🙂🙂❤
Right on! ☮️🌎🌲
Pls we need Greek translations plss
I tell everyone this!
You ROCK Johnny!😊😊😊
I am 65, and I have been crocheting since I was 14. I took 4 years of sewing in high school and have sewn a lot since then. I don't feel real, comfortable crocheting these. I have tried the real easy ones, and it's a pain in my opinion.
We think alike Jean!
I disagree. I don't think you should ever discourage anyone from trying any type of art form. Everyone learns differently. Personally, I had several false starts with crochet, I found granny squares difficult and boring. When I found amigurumi's it was a totally different experience, I enjoyed it, and learned a lot doing them. If someone had told me not to try it, I would have given up on crochet all together. That being said...crochet is not for everyone. However I would say that anyone wanting to try it should start with an easy project that calls their attention and if it doesn't work out try a different one until you find the one that brings you joy.
@@JennyWells-t7b you should listen to my video and listen to it fully. You may find that we agree on some things.😉
I disagree cause I learnt with it and it's mostly just 1 stitch and it gets them used to actually crocheting and then they can learn more complicated things
I *Love* doing Amigurumi. I tend to get bored easy, so, Amigurumi it is for me. I must be honest, I can’t follow patterns, I follow YT tutorials. Xxx
It’s great that these tutorials are so ready available now. Enjoy!
I learned amigurumi first
no
I can understand what you are saying. However, I enjoy crocheting amigurumi as well as most everything else too. When beginning my crochet journey, I watched a great deal of TH-cam videos to learn how to crochet various techniques. I’ve learned so much over the years through watching these videos. I did start out crocheting hats and blankets before learning amigurumi. I am so thankful to be able to do this craft, whether it be granny squares, hats, afghans, or amigurumi. It brings me so much joy. There are many beginner friendly amigurumi patterns out there, that can easily be learned. It is good to know basic stitches before beginning, but it’s really not that hard to learn. It’s like anything else, the more you do it, the better you’ll get. However, I wouldn’t suggest beginning with one of those kits. Just some prior knowledge of basic stitches, yarn, hook, stuffing, scissors, needle, and a beginner friendly crochet video or pattern to follow along with and you can create cute amigurumi as well. ❤
To late. While I never bought kits, I did start with amigurumi. Loved it and I have been doing it for a couple years now.
That’s great! I’m so glad it didn’t discourage you.
I'm 58, and have crocheted on and off for over 50 years.
I have never done, nor been tempted to make amigurumis, so any knowledge is definitely not first hand... 😂
BUT I know I would definitely NEVER recommend that a newbie go there first. Just watching others do this has shown me that you definitely need some skill building before you go down the amigurumi path.
Have a great day. 🐞
Honestly i Never liked These 🙈😂
I think that they are so adorable, but like you, I personally don't enjoy the tedious journey.
They Are adorable and i made one as a dog toy but it isnt sth i would Wanna Place in my Appartement and for laying around in the closet it’s really a tedious task like you Said.
What you are saying is very true ❤
Bonnie, you're absolutely right...Amigurumi is very difficult for a beginner. I learned that the hard way. Believe or not, I've been working on one that I began 2 yrs ago & I want to finally finish it but I keep having to crochet certain parts over again so that it doesn't end up looking like something the cat dragged in😅😂
Ha ha! I understand that!
Was super simple for me as a first timer.