Heather Cox Richardson from the 35 minute mark on is absolutely inspiring and amazing. This is the part that gives anyone paying attention hope that is required right now.
Ken Burns is the best person to make a film documentary...smart and honesty personified in all his films as we all learn from whatever film we are watching that he and his brother made for PBS!!!! Thank you Ken!! You are amazing and humble with the accolades that have been given to you for your work in documentation! You are so special and loved by many citizens in our nation and rightfully so!!
The founding fathers avarice in justify slavery is no different than current corporate greed. We cannot stop striving for true progress. We are not there yet.
I spoke to a little old lady at the grocery store a sweet little kind old lady and she said she was going to vote for Trump. And I had a kind open conversation with her and tried to explain to her republicans want to scare their voters and what they're doing to old people is disgusting. Go listen AM talk radio and listen to these republican pundits who spread fear. Do you think that's why Donald Trump keeps saying he wants to save am radio ? My grandfather fought in World War 2 in Korea and in the last years of his life listen to Michael savage and became a racist afraid of everything and everyone that wasn't white.
And I don't want to burst anybody's bubble but it was Hillary Clinton that first mentioned the rise of the republican alt right. And Mrs. Clinton was a 100% right
I went to college and got a BA in political science with heaps of philosophy and law with the objective of it aiding me in attaining my future law degree but alas my law degree was not meant to be. Though I feel otherwise I constantly have people telling me that it is a terrible shame that I wasted my BA with such a senseless major. Though my major did not empower me with the capacity to attain infinite wealth I feel it did allow me to be a better citizen. Hopefully a citizen with a greater understanding of humanity. Democracy ain’t perfect …just the best government that we can choose.
Never has it been so easy to hang out with such brilliant people than here on YT. Yes, there's no shortage of garbage, but I'm not forced to sit through that stuff. I also love the incredible range of music that various people share. I can find any genre of music throughout the history of recorded music.
I was not able to attend this in person so just now found it on social media. I actually have hope and optimism after a week of utter despair, post debate. We can save our country. And we will!
An enlightening discussion by three of our most erudite historians. Thank you. Fascinating and helpful in getting a deeper understanding of the history that's foundational to our country's strength and values.
Mr Burns, the man I trust more than anyone else. What I can think of with every mentioning that we are a country existing on the belief of LAWS, well why do I have to get an interpreter ?
Adore book festivals and these 3 jewels. What a privilege to hear them speak their passions and wisdom. The pursuit of virtue. Yes. My passion and training is in life long learning. 💙🌹
This country makes it easier to achieve an education which is just the beginning of our own personal growth. I am an immigrant who has been moderately successful and I can look back and see today my children having achieved a good education and all because of their intelligence and willingness to work hard, they did through educational programs that are available to all, I being a widow could not afford what I wanted for them but they did go after the opportunities offered.
The pursuit of character, of empathy and civic respect. Dignity of humanity. The most ordinary I find the most beautiful. The real Jesus was the Anti trump.
I come from an educational background of math and science and self education in many other areas. This program confirms much of what I believed and suspected. Thank you for my continuing education in the history of our country.
I forgot to make my point, a point I make to myself as a reminder. No matter what one’s background study, it is a better education, at least for me, to be a generalist swimming in many waters.
This discussion couldn’t be more timely. Lifelong learning to become a whole person supersedes the un-sustainable fear and hate represented in the empty symbols and slogans that substitute at this time for “patriotism”.
This was an excellent discussion. I would challenge all of you to take some time to find more scholars of a multitude of races to grow this discussion. Do the same thing to find a way to grow our Democracy and improve what the founding fathers were reaching for in America.
Excellent discussion! My goal these days is to learn something profound every day. This panel has been given me enough challenges to keep me busy for most of April. I love the assertion that the Revolutionary War is over, but the Revolution continues….we must fight against acquiescence to the MAGA authoritarianism. Trump promises a continuation of the caste system that has developed since the Supreme Court decided that corporations are people. I will not live to see this needed reversal, as Chief Justice John Roberts is certain to outlive me. I’m hoping to last longer than Clarence Thomas, though!
I am hopeful that we, the American citizenry, declare enough is enough and demand term limits and strict rules of behavior for SCOTUS. (Bribes, recusal, insider trading, conflicts of interest, etc.)
A life-long-learner is what I am. Mentally, psychologically, and spiritually. Reading non-fiction is my addiction. The concept of owning another human is anathema to me. I'm from Virginia, that divided state with plantation gentry who contributed so much good and bad to the country from the beginning. Science and art go together naturally. I'm a geologist and knew lots of geologists who played instruments. We were rock-and-roll majors. Project 2025 is diabolical.
Bless you Heather. I'm low income and educated. I cannot afford paywalls. Yet I learn. The right wing want destruction . We embrace joy and civility . Thank you all. 💙💙💙💙
This is such a fascinating and informative panel, I can't stay focused on my job for constantly and craning and straining to hear every word. So much being said here.
America your hair is on fire! Please vote, vote your conscience, vote for future. If one choice is difficult hold your nose. Democracy in the rest of the world also depends on this 😘
We need a Living Constitution. Not antiquarian. Conversation and civility is my democracy. Power and dominance are narcissistic and misogynistic. Patriarchy must go.
It's Dec 24, 2024 & the American people have elected an autocrat. I'm hopeful we can survive this & use the few tools we have left to maintain our Democracy.
A good panel. But how like the U.S> to usurp the title that the concept of democracy and equality stemmed from them, from Jefferson. Surely a bit of classical reading will point to the ancient Greeks (remember the origin of the word 'Democracy') - and of Socrates in particular, will help. Socrates himself struggled tremendously with the 'purity' and practicality of the concept.
Mr. Rosen-You may want to check out COMMONPLACE BOOKS AND READING IN GEORGIAN ENGLAND by David Allan. It is a reminder that reading used to also be about self-improvement not just entertainment. We lost something when we quit the commonplace book practice tho there are modern parallels.
I hate to remind you that at the time of the writing of the Constitution "the pursuit of happiness" referred to divorce. Anglican Virginia and Catholic Maryland had to reconcile it's beliefs with Quakers and New England Protestants so that all of the colonies could sign on to the new nation.
248 years and there are still the same problems still for the same people exists a nice idea is just that. It will take at least another 248 years at this rate and I’ll bet the same problems exist.
Yet to this very day American Equality has failed magnificently a nice idea never to be implemented in any reasonable way. WOKE was a request that, all be found equal before the law failed miserably
The US Constitution was a mutual defense pact. That's why they were called " free and independent states" not provinces or counties. The FFs had in mind agrarian fiefdoms for white landlords (most slaveowners). Themselves. The Bill of Rights was a repudiation of British military/monarchist rule. The US Senate was the check on federal power. Nearly all of the FFs were opposed to national gov't, national army, national currency etc. A lot of concessions were demanded and made to the wealthy planters particularly concerning slaves and slavery. The 3/5 clause is absurd. We all know only white male landowners could vote. The idea the Constitution was about equality and democracy is simply nonsense. Even the Continental soldiers were cut out of the mix.
>Nearly all of the FFs were opposed to national gov't, national army, national currency etc , maybe in the begining until the articles of confederation showed how poorly a noncentralized government would work
Yes, hopefully we may continue to strive for "a more perfect union." Certainly there remains work to be done. President Franklin Roosevelt's Annual Message (Four Freedoms) to Congress (1941) excerpts: "Certainly this is no time for any of us to stop thinking about the social and economic problems which are the root cause of the social revolution which is today a supreme factor in the world. "For there is nothing mysterious about the foundations of a healthy and strong democracy. The basic things expected by our people of their political and economic systems are simple. They are: "Equality of opportunity for youth and for others. "Jobs for those who can work. "Security for those who need it. "The ending of special privilege for the few. "The preservation of civil liberties for all. "The enjoyment of the fruits of scientific progress in a wider and constantly rising standard of living. "These are the simple, basic things that must never be lost sight of in the turmoil and unbelievable complexity of our modern world. The inner and abiding strength of our economic and political systems is dependent upon the degree to which they fulfill these expectations." Later he goes on: "Since the beginning of our American history, we have been engaged in change -- in a perpetual peaceful revolution -- a revolution which goes on steadily, quietly adjusting itself to changing conditions--without the concentration camp or the quick-lime in the ditch. The world order which we seek is the cooperation of free countries, working together in a friendly, civilized society. "This nation has placed its destiny in the hands and heads and hearts of its millions of free men and women; and its faith in freedom under the guidance of God. Freedom means the supremacy of human rights everywhere. Our support goes to those who struggle to gain those rights or keep them. Our strength is our unity of purpose. To that high concept there can be no end save victory."
@@Xaxtarr_Neonraven The day FDR died Wall Street/Republicans began their war on democracy and the New Deal. Soon the 22nd Amendment was ratified prohibiting Americans from voting for the most popular, twice-elected candidate for president.
Life long learning is much different from 'deep reading', Ken Burns doesn't get it. It's not about the content but rather the process and the medium of literacy, which creates self determination.
I love this, but I gotta say, using the word "enslavement" instead of "slavery" violates the George Carlin principle for me. It just puts bubble wrap between the listener's ear and the painful truth of U.S. history. Feel the pain, folks.
Ken Burns is in with Clarence Thomas and Harlan Crow. He's lost all credibility in my opinion. Makes me wonder about the validity of every history piece he's done, how he bent it to cowtow to Crow.
Heather is an American treasure.
Other nations are not so proud of their "prostitu#es
Well, I didn't know that in English the words "treasure" and "prostitute" are close synonyms.
I would love nothing more than to see President Harris presenting Heather with the medal of freedom.
What does this mean??@@anna-tn8mg
I am so grateful Ken Burns decorates this universe.
Thank you for giving me hope. Wonderful panel.
Such an important distinction: not FEELING good but BEING good. We have totally forgotten that.
Thanks for pointing to that ... What can be achieved for self and community through service
Thank you Heather Cox Richardson!!!! Thank you for giving us hope.
Heather Cox Richardson from the 35 minute mark on is absolutely inspiring and amazing. This is the part that gives anyone paying attention hope that is required right now.
Ken Burns is the best person to make a film documentary...smart and honesty personified in all his films as we all learn from whatever film we are watching that he and his brother made for PBS!!!! Thank you Ken!! You are amazing and humble with the accolades that have been given to you for your work in documentation! You are so special and loved by many citizens in our nation and rightfully so!!
The founding fathers avarice in justify slavery is no different than current corporate greed. We cannot stop striving for true progress. We are not there yet.
They have all the same states in their pocket, too!
Excellent panel. Glad we are finally starting to talk about the takeover of our democracy by fundamentalist theocrats. But it isn’t discussed enough.
Agree! Democracy is on the line in Nov. VOTE BLUE to save American democracy for our children's future.
I spoke to a little old lady at the grocery store a sweet little kind old lady and she said she was going to vote for Trump. And I had a kind open conversation with her and tried to explain to her republicans want to scare their voters and what they're doing to old people is disgusting. Go listen AM talk radio and listen to these republican pundits who spread fear. Do you think that's why Donald Trump keeps saying he wants to save am radio ? My grandfather fought in World War 2 in Korea and in the last years of his life listen to Michael savage and became a racist afraid of everything and everyone that wasn't white.
And I don't want to burst anybody's bubble but it was Hillary Clinton that first mentioned the rise of the republican alt right. And Mrs. Clinton was a 100% right
The founders were Deists. God was a choice. 💙
I adore book fests and am glad I lived in the South where writing was an art. Met Wendell Berry and Adrienne Rich in Nashville.
This is great stuff...I feel I need to rewatch every two months, as to remind myself of our blessings and our responsibilities.
Wonderful to hear two fine historians that are hopeful and confident about our Democracy!
I went to college and got a BA in political science with heaps of philosophy and law with the objective of it aiding me in attaining my future law degree but alas my law degree was not meant to be. Though I feel otherwise I constantly have people telling me that it is a terrible shame that I wasted my BA with such a senseless major. Though my major did not empower me with the capacity to attain infinite wealth I feel it did allow me to be a better citizen. Hopefully a citizen with a greater understanding of humanity. Democracy ain’t perfect …just the best government that we can choose.
You are a great American! ☺
Don't listen to them. Your degree is valuable, even if not necessarily in a capitalistic way.
We must maintain the spirit of democracy. Stay strong. 💙
And spirit it is
Never has it been so easy to hang out with such brilliant people than here on YT. Yes, there's no shortage of garbage, but I'm not forced to sit through that stuff. I also love the incredible range of music that various people share. I can find any genre of music throughout the history of recorded music.
Very satisfying- and stimulating! Thank you all. My mind will carry this conversation on.
I was not able to attend this in person so just now found it on social media. I actually have hope and optimism after a week of utter despair, post debate. We can save our country. And we will!
An enlightening discussion by three of our most erudite historians. Thank you. Fascinating and helpful in getting a deeper understanding of the history that's foundational to our country's strength and values.
Mr Burns, the man I trust more than anyone else. What I can think of with every mentioning that we are a country existing on the belief of LAWS, well why do I have to get an interpreter ?
Adore book festivals and these 3 jewels. What a privilege to hear them speak their passions and wisdom. The pursuit of virtue. Yes. My passion and training is in life long learning. 💙🌹
Thanks to all yall, as we say in Nola. ❤❤❤😊
I would give anything to spend an evening in a Maine cabin with these three and a bottle (or 5😂) of wine.
This country makes it easier to achieve an education which is just the beginning of our own personal growth. I am an immigrant who has been moderately successful and I can look back and see today my children having achieved a good education and all because of their intelligence and willingness to work hard, they did through educational programs that are available to all, I being a widow could not afford what I wanted for them but they did go after the opportunities offered.
😊
I suspect that immigrants see and appreciate many things that spoiled and entitled 3rd, 4th, and 5th generation Americans take for granted.
HCR helped me keep my sanity during the darkest hours of Trump's administration. I'm still alive because of her.
Very interesting and deep conversation. Thank you!!!
The pursuit of character, of empathy and civic respect. Dignity of humanity. The most ordinary I find the most beautiful. The real Jesus was the Anti trump.
Jesus as the Anti-Trump. Exactly
I come from an educational background of math and science and self education in many other areas. This program confirms much of what I believed and suspected. Thank you for my continuing education in the history of our country.
I forgot to make my point, a point I make to myself as a reminder. No matter what one’s background study, it is a better education, at least for me, to be a generalist swimming in many waters.
Yes! Bring back the values of virtue and service.
Excellent presentation by a panel of intellectuals whom I respect and appreciate their study & insight. It was awesome to be there to witness live.
Her prediction for 2028 gave me hope that I haven't felt in far too long.
This discussion couldn’t be more timely. Lifelong learning to become a whole person supersedes the un-sustainable fear and hate represented in the empty symbols and slogans that substitute at this time for “patriotism”.
Oof nvrmnd
This was an excellent discussion.
I would challenge all of you to take some time to find more scholars of a multitude of races to grow this discussion. Do the same thing to find a way to grow our Democracy and improve what the founding fathers were reaching for in America.
Excellent discussion! My goal these days is to learn something profound every day. This panel has been given me enough challenges to keep me busy for most of April. I love the assertion that the Revolutionary War is over, but the Revolution continues….we must fight against acquiescence to the MAGA authoritarianism. Trump promises a continuation of the caste system that has developed since the Supreme Court decided that corporations are people. I will not live to see this needed reversal, as Chief Justice John Roberts is certain to outlive me. I’m hoping to last longer than Clarence Thomas, though!
I am hopeful that we, the American citizenry, declare enough is enough and demand term limits and strict rules of behavior for SCOTUS. (Bribes, recusal, insider trading, conflicts of interest, etc.)
Learning to better SELF ! The true concept of to strive to form a more perfect union. 😊The Constitution is the roadmap ❤❤❤❤
Jeffrey Rosen is very bright
A life-long-learner is what I am. Mentally, psychologically, and spiritually. Reading non-fiction is my addiction. The concept of owning another human is anathema to me. I'm from Virginia, that divided state with plantation gentry who contributed so much good and bad to the country from the beginning.
Science and art go together naturally. I'm a geologist and knew lots of geologists who played instruments. We were rock-and-roll majors.
Project 2025 is diabolical.
Bless you Heather. I'm low income and educated. I cannot afford paywalls. Yet I learn. The right wing want destruction . We embrace joy and civility . Thank you all. 💙💙💙💙
This is such a fascinating and informative panel, I can't stay focused on my job for constantly and craning and straining to hear every word. So much being said here.
America your hair is on fire! Please vote, vote your conscience, vote for future. If one choice is difficult hold your nose. Democracy in the rest of the world also depends on this 😘
We need a Living Constitution. Not antiquarian. Conversation and civility is my democracy. Power and dominance are narcissistic and misogynistic. Patriarchy must go.
The consciousness movement shows we can change. We call it practice.
So many wretched hardcore libertarians in the GOP, like Charles Koch, hold John Calhoun in high esteem.
It's Dec 24, 2024 & the American people have elected an autocrat. I'm hopeful we can survive this & use the few tools we have left to maintain our Democracy.
A good panel. But how like the U.S> to usurp the title that the concept of democracy and equality stemmed from them, from Jefferson. Surely a bit of classical reading will point to the ancient Greeks (remember the origin of the word 'Democracy') - and of Socrates in particular, will help. Socrates himself struggled tremendously with the 'purity' and practicality of the concept.
Mr. Rosen-You may want to check out COMMONPLACE BOOKS AND READING IN GEORGIAN ENGLAND by David Allan. It is a reminder that reading used to also be about self-improvement not just entertainment. We lost something when we quit the commonplace book practice tho there are modern parallels.
I hate to remind you that at the time of the writing of the Constitution "the pursuit of happiness" referred to divorce. Anglican Virginia and Catholic Maryland had to reconcile it's beliefs with Quakers and New England Protestants so that all of the colonies could sign on to the new nation.
I want to talk about Harlan Crow and the Federalists.😊
35:55 Heather - Bob Barr "human beings are naturally sinful, impose religion on them"
Jeffrey has a long response for this first question in life long learning and the Declaration of Independence
Fantastic. Who is the fellow?
Who is Jeffrey?
Yes, who is he? Maybe can find out before this is over.
What an extraordinary discussion! Thank you all for this.
14:55 John Calhoun
248 years and there are still the same problems still for the same people exists a nice idea is just that. It will take at least another 248 years at this rate and I’ll bet the same problems exist.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
23:42 - Q :
24:04 -
The fact that she turns off comments on her videos says a lot.
Jeez! They could've written that quote in as the primary source of "George Jefferson's" anger.
12:04 Patrick Henry
Ken is our national treasure just like PBS
Yet to this very day American Equality has failed magnificently a nice idea never to be implemented in any reasonable way. WOKE was a request that, all be found equal before the law failed miserably
How funny. I wrote somnets during covid. Not very good ones but 14 lines, iambic pentameter!! Who knew?
The US Constitution was a mutual defense pact.
That's why they were called " free and independent states" not provinces or counties.
The FFs had in mind agrarian fiefdoms for white landlords (most slaveowners). Themselves.
The Bill of Rights was a repudiation of British military/monarchist rule.
The US Senate was the check on federal power. Nearly all of the FFs were opposed to national gov't, national army, national currency etc. A lot of concessions were demanded and made to the wealthy planters particularly concerning slaves and slavery. The 3/5 clause is absurd.
We all know only white male landowners could vote. The idea the Constitution was about equality and democracy is simply nonsense. Even the Continental soldiers were cut out of the mix.
>Nearly all of the FFs were opposed to national gov't, national army, national currency etc
, maybe in the begining until the articles of confederation showed how poorly a noncentralized government would work
Yes, hopefully we may continue to strive for "a more perfect union." Certainly there remains work to be done.
President Franklin Roosevelt's Annual Message (Four Freedoms) to Congress (1941) excerpts:
"Certainly this is no time for any of us to stop thinking about the social and economic problems which are the root cause of the social revolution which is today a supreme factor in the world.
"For there is nothing mysterious about the foundations of a healthy and strong democracy. The basic things expected by our people of their political and economic systems are simple. They are:
"Equality of opportunity for youth and for others.
"Jobs for those who can work.
"Security for those who need it.
"The ending of special privilege for the few.
"The preservation of civil liberties for all.
"The enjoyment of the fruits of scientific progress in a wider and constantly rising standard of living.
"These are the simple, basic things that must never be lost sight of in the turmoil and unbelievable complexity of our modern world. The inner and abiding strength of our economic and political systems is dependent upon the degree to which they fulfill these expectations."
Later he goes on:
"Since the beginning of our American history, we have been engaged in change -- in a perpetual peaceful revolution -- a revolution which goes on steadily, quietly adjusting itself to changing conditions--without the concentration camp or the quick-lime in the ditch. The world order which we seek is the cooperation of free countries, working together in a friendly, civilized society.
"This nation has placed its destiny in the hands and heads and hearts of its millions of free men and women; and its faith in freedom under the guidance of God. Freedom means the supremacy of human rights everywhere. Our support goes to those who struggle to gain those rights or keep them. Our strength is our unity of purpose. To that high concept there can be no end save victory."
@@Xaxtarr_Neonraven The day FDR died Wall Street/Republicans began their war on democracy and the New Deal. Soon the 22nd Amendment was ratified prohibiting Americans from voting for the most popular, twice-elected candidate for president.
I do not believe she is correct about the election, but..i hope. Tomorrow i vote in the Primary, because..i still hope.
Grace Lee Boggs: R/Evolution
❤thanks for reminding me of the virtue & service of Grace Lee Boggs
Economic inequality, anyone?
Madison Hemings said that Jefferson freed ALL his children, two of them while he was still alive - Beverly and Harriet. What's wrong with you?
Damn. Kenny won't stop pumping out the sedatives!
Life long learning is much different from 'deep reading', Ken Burns doesn't get it. It's not about the content but rather the process and the medium of literacy, which creates self determination.
Anderson David Hernandez Carol Miller Mary
Wonderful. Hope Trump was watching, but he would have no idea what was being discussed.
Martin Donald Harris Frank Jones Daniel
I love this, but I gotta say, using the word "enslavement" instead of "slavery" violates the George Carlin principle for me. It just puts bubble wrap between the listener's ear and the painful truth of U.S. history. Feel the pain, folks.
Ken Burns is in with Clarence Thomas and Harlan Crow. He's lost all credibility in my opinion. Makes me wonder about the validity of every history piece he's done, how he bent it to cowtow to Crow.