Karina attracting both fanboy & fangirl is nothing can change the fact that Karina is popular in South Korea and International plus her fans are soooo pretty and handsome too😭😭
Yash, she is eye catching. Trully face of the group. Other idol fansite who came to the music award always say that karina is so pretty and take a fancam of her
Winter's popularity is no joke like seriously ! Her fangirls and fanboys are so so beautiful and handsome. I hope many people will discover her and appreciate her talents and personality like we do cause I'm sure she has more to show. Let's accompany her on her journey and watch her shine while moving the hearts of many people!
NINGNING I JUST WANTS TO SAY TO YOU THAT I LOVE YOU SO MUCH AND I WILL SUPPORT YOU WHATEVER YOU DO AND ALWAYS BE CONFIDENT AND ALWAYS GIVES THE BEST OF THE BEST...AND FOR THE SOLO SONG 'WAKE UP' BOOOOMMMM THAT IS FANTASTIC AND AMAZING..HOW CAN YOU SO AMAZING...NINGNING LOVE YOU AND THANK YOU FOR EXIST IN MY LIFE...LOVE YOU SO MUCH
It's expected that karina is so popular but Giselle tho?!?!? Ig online hate doesn't equate fo being unpopular. I'm so glad she got lots of love from Koreans.
Lowkey American and western celebrities get treated worse than Korean celebrities, irl and online as well. The countless lives that young Hollywood celebrities have done, crying because of being criticized for their looks, weight, mere existence is sad ,.
Omg why Karina fangirls and fanboys are all beautiful same as Karina 😭💓 +im rlly happy that she’s well loved in korea she deserves this she’s rlly talented and her personality shines as a kind loving person and rlly caring im rlly happy for her and hope she get all the support from fans 💓
Wow Winter has more fanboy than fangirls I'm not surprised because she is very beautiful and cute she is very popular among men all my male friends love winter
@@valorie444 She can be sexy too. But I would say a lot of guys like her because she's really pretty. It also helps that she's one of the best singers in kpop right now.
I am surprised i thought karina has more fangirls than fan boys but turns out the ratio of fan girls and fanboys is well balanced for her ..she attracts both Genders equally
Karina’s the leader of the group. Leaders tend to give more of serious energy most of the time at first glance but in reality, they care a lot for their members, just like Irene and Taeyeon. This type of personality tends to attract more woman since (usually) men tend to like cuter personalities at first.
@@tytrack8965 still good looking for me, good looking doesn't mean you need to be handsome or pretty only. It can be ppl who has kind and good person vibes. They had their own attractive appearance which stranger like us don't have any rights to judge or bodyshaming them 🤷♀️
![[aesparty] EP.08 에스파 전생에 OO??](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hAggS8giVYI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[aesparty] EP.08 에스파 전생에 OO??](/img/tr.png)
에스파 좋아하는 이유가 있으세요?
-데뷔해서
와 진짜 대박적이다..내가 들은 팬이 된 이유중에 최고임..
카리나는 여자들이 진짜 엄청 좋아할 스타일인데 남자팬도 많은게 대박인듯
1:36 남녀 팬분 외모랑 분위기 장난 아니시네,, 이런 분들이 자기들 좋아한다고 생각하면 뭔가 뿌듯할 듯
마이들이 짱이다!!!!
I'm so happy to see many people supporting giselle she truly deserves the best , I hope ningning will get a better support in the future as well
I'm sure she does. it's just who they ask at random.
Happy for giselle too ❤ Giselle and Ningning working so hard in Korea, thank you all the support.
어우 만나서 너무 반가웠어요~ ㅎㅎ
와쏭 화이팅! 에스파 화이팅!!!
그리구 닝닝아 사랑한다!!!!!!!!
Karina attracting both fanboy & fangirl is nothing can change the fact that Karina is popular in South Korea and International plus her fans are soooo pretty and handsome too😭😭
I’m the Winter is sooo popular comment
난 닝닝 너무 좋은데 영상엔 많이 없네
영원히 사랑할 자신 있는데 열심히 활동 해주길
한국 와서 활동 해줘서 고맙고 평생 행복했으면 좋겠다!!!! 하얼빈 호랑이 화이팅~~
저두 닝닝이 좋아해요❤ 노래,춤,얼굴 빠지는거 없이 잘해줘서 오히려 고마워요❤
karina collecting all the pretty girls
Giselle had lot of fan I'm so proud for her😚☺️🥰
Giselle🥰👍🏻
I almost cried when I heard the first person to say her bias is Ningning 🥹 also glad Aeri got a lot of fans too. Fighting 💪💪💪
sameeee
As much as I love Ningning and I hope more fans will support her. I'm so happy for Giselle ❤️
GISELLE deserves the love🤗 and so does NingNing
It's just a few fans here in video but during concert every member got a lot of cheers. And Ningning is quite popular internationally
@@vaanshichauhan9868 i didn't even expect korean fans to like her. I know she's really popular overseas.
@@harielc8428 is she very popular internationally ? I have a lot of friends who are kpop fans and I’ve never heard them mention her
@@Fartsquad_ when you watch vidéo off them at the airport and performances. Ningning got a lot of cheers. Most of her fanbase are not Korean.
유지민 최고야💙
8:14 노래 not your girl ㅋㅋ 멕이는거아님?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
1:52 오빠 잘생겼어요❤
1:52 오빠 멋져요
Ningning love you so much 🦋
The girl who asked Giselle to marry her was honestly✨ A MOOD ✨
😂🎉i want to marry gigi too!
Giselle is cool af
Ningning we love you ❤️
닝닝 왜 적은지 모르겠지만 닝닝이 너무 사랑해 에스파 영원하자!! 💗🥺
2:12 Karina fangirl is so me when she start to list out all the reasons why she stan Karina. I feel you girl 😭😭
Its soo cool seeing how many fanboys and fangirls karina has, its pretty much 50/50 she deserves all the love in the world best girl indeed!!
유지민💙💙
so many winter fans like me!
Winter and her fanboys 😄💞
The NCT HAECHAN was so random LOL lucky her because Haechan went to see the concert ♡
Winter's fangirls and fanboys are so good looking .we love u winter
우리 에스파 콘서트 너무 수고했어 최고였어!!!!!
우리 닝닝아!!!너무너무 사랑해 혹시 영상 보고 속상해하지않았으면 좋겠다!!!
마이에게는 에스파 멤버 한명한명이 다 소중하다구
영상 올려주셔서 감사합니다☺️☺️
말 진짜 예쁘게 하신다.. 역시 그 가수와 그 팬이네요
지젤이 최고야!! 💕🌍
karina has the most numbers of fangirls and fanboys. no wonder she's crazy popular even among non fans
Yash, she is eye catching. Trully face of the group. Other idol fansite who came to the music award always say that karina is so pretty and take a fancam of her
에스파 팬들 왜케이쁘고잘생김?
저 막날 콘서트때 옆자리 여성분은 얼굴도 엄청 예쁘셨는데 착하시고 매너도 진짜 좋으셨음 ㄷㄷㄷ
그 아이돌에 그 팬이지 뭐 ㅋㅋ (좋은 말임 진짜임)
1:52 이 오빠 내꼬ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@@user-ge3kk6yj6u ??
사랑하면 닮으니까
Thank you for those who supports Ningie. There might only be a few in this video but there are a lot of us internationally.
So true! She’s actually the bias of everyone in my friend group haha
@@franka2819 that is so nice to hear. Glad to know a fellow Ningning stan
yes! ningning is actually very popular, it's just in korea that they don't support chinese idols that much
@@beatrizbasilio5922I am korean, but i love ningning❤ she is so pretty and cute❤❤❤❤❤
Still Karina and Winter popular than her internationally
Karina is very popular.She has a higher percentage of female but also a lot of male fans.I'm glad Karina has gained a lot of fans.
@@Jwa123 karina was mentioned 17x while winter 9x just fyi
@@Jwa123 most of them mentioned karina
mostly karina fans is full of female not suprise we all aware about that😭😂
@@stanacesmemberstanrelevant she got 8/7 fanboys other member like winter got 6 and giselle 1 so i think karina got 50/50
@@hatiqaherman1988 its just on video but overall mostly fangirl i said not based on this video
thank you for supporting and loving Giselle 🥺❤️
Ikr🤗
yesss ;) inlove with her fans too they’re cool!
Only 1-3 said ningning 😭💀😨
that Thai TH-camr @3:46 who is Ningning bias is pretty. Indeed, pretty people loves Ning haha
Giselle aerii i love youu
*I love all the love GISELLE got here. You got em girl, you are the best Rap queen!* 🌙✌️💕
1:35 미모뭐야...
Minjeong saranghae⭐
the J-aerishine is even wearing Giselle hairpins. so cute
Yes kawaii!
Waahhh fanboy and fangirl winterr❤❤
I'm so happy for my Giselle aaaa thank you for supporting her ❤🌙
Giselle🥰
Winter's popularity is no joke like seriously ! Her fangirls and fanboys are so so beautiful and handsome. I hope many people will discover her and appreciate her talents and personality like we do cause I'm sure she has more to show. Let's accompany her on her journey and watch her shine while moving the hearts of many people!
Ningning please come to Australia i will cheer for you 🇦🇺
유지민 최고
I love Giselle too🖤🖤🖤🌙
That Japanese aerishine outfit and voice was so cute glad giselle is getting appreciation in her home country💗
sshes wearing giselle hair clips too! Shes so kawaii
@@aechuuu right she came prepared
Isn’t this vid filmed in Korea?
@@Fer-fy8dx yes it is
Seems like each member has a very specific fan base 😂
Winter- mainly fanboys
Giselle/Ning Ning- mainly fan girls
Karina- fanboys and fangirls
I think ningning she don't even has fans 😂💔💔💔
karina has a lot of fangirls and fanboys
카리나 여덕 많은거 왤케 좋지ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ울웅니 여자사랑 많이받어
1:36 카리나 닮으신 분이 카리나 좋아하시네... 좋은 현상이다
2222
3:54 이거 찾으려고 이 채널 모든 에스파 영상이랑 쇼츠를 뒤졌다… 드디어 찾음
“영원히 사랑하지는 않겠지만 오늘은 사랑할게”
NINGNING I JUST WANTS TO SAY TO YOU THAT I LOVE YOU SO MUCH AND I WILL SUPPORT YOU WHATEVER YOU DO AND ALWAYS BE CONFIDENT AND ALWAYS GIVES THE BEST OF THE BEST...AND FOR THE SOLO SONG 'WAKE UP' BOOOOMMMM THAT IS FANTASTIC AND AMAZING..HOW CAN YOU SO AMAZING...NINGNING LOVE YOU AND THANK YOU FOR EXIST IN MY LIFE...LOVE YOU SO MUCH
I found it cute that most of Giselle biased fans here said the same thing for their messages for her which is "I love you". Giselle, you are loved.
Karina Is very popular
It's expected that karina is so popular but Giselle tho?!?!? Ig online hate doesn't equate fo being unpopular. I'm so glad she got lots of love from Koreans.
Lowkey American and western celebrities get treated worse than Korean celebrities, irl and online as well. The countless lives that young Hollywood celebrities have done, crying because of being criticized for their looks, weight, mere existence is sad ,.
03:23 SAME GIRL, OKAY GISELLE IF YOU READ THIS, MARRY ME!!!!
Karina be like: Heyyyy!!! no! 😂
@@danissegomez7953 First I'll marry Giselle and then Karina 🤭
Omg why Karina fangirls and fanboys are all beautiful same as Karina 😭💓 +im rlly happy that she’s well loved in korea she deserves this she’s rlly talented and her personality shines as a kind loving person and rlly caring im rlly happy for her and hope she get all the support from fans 💓
역시 카리나가 짱이다❤
1:36 this Karina fan girl is rlly pretty omg 😭💓 aespa fans are truly good looking ppl
She looks similiar with KimSejeong
She looks mixed of kuwahara ayana from girlsplanet 999 × that girl trainee from biscuit ent, wont be surprised if she becomes idol in the future 😅
I thought she was Wonyoung in the thumbnail 😂
I think she looks like Sumin of STAYC or Jisoo of BLACKPINK
all giselle’s fans are so sweet and cute!! they have same energy as giselle too 😂
Winter is so so popular ! Happy to see that she is loved by many people.
다 넘 귀여우심.. 에스파짱스파갓스파사랑해
에스파💗💗💗
1:37 이분….예쁘시다…
karina, my ultimate girl crush ♥️🥰
Ningning i love u
Wow！Winter has so many handsome fanboys.
최애라고 말한 사람 숫자 세어봄
카리나 남6 여11
윈터 남6 여4
지젤 여6
닝닝 여3
해찬 여1
안유진 남1
I wish one day ningning gets more support and love from the fans like the other members , she's talented too
에스파 팬들 미남미녀다 ..❤
I love Giselle Too👑✨😁
Me toooo
wow karina has many fangirls and fanboys 😱
칼프들이 짱이다💙
Karina your fan girls are so pretty
Wow Winter has more fanboy than fangirls I'm not surprised because she is very beautiful and cute she is very popular among men all my male friends love winter
yeah i think its because males like cute girls :)
@@valorie444 She can be sexy too. But I would say a lot of guys like her because she's really pretty. It also helps that she's one of the best singers in kpop right now.
@@fury9018 that is true!
@@fury9018 im a female fan of winter and karina and i personally like winter's cutesy side so thats what i was going off of :)
I think she is the most talented in the group. There is a reason sm gives her most of the killing parts in their recent comebacks
팬들 너무 귀엽다...에스파 멤버들 이거 보면 진짜 힘날듯
와 카리나 인기 많네 ㅋㅋㅋ
Ame que saliera la canción de Yesung!! Fighting
Aespa también me gusta fighting
1:39 이분 윈터 연습생때랑 똑같이 생기샸다
So much love for Giselle❤❤❤
They are full of positive vibes, thank you so much! Please love our girls 🤍🤍🤍
i’m glad giselle has so many fans ❤ sometimes she is underappreciated and i love her sooo much
6:19 You speak the truth man!! Karina is pretty, have a good voice and happy virus 😭💗
*EVEN KARINA'S biases are beautiful!* That pretty girl at 1:36 is Karina fan. Same for that handsome dude at 0:19. 💙✌️ (Me being one bragging 😎)
우와!!! 에스파당ㅋㅋㅋ 에스파 사랑해 항상 응원할게요🖤
닝닝이도 많이 사랑한다ㅠㅠ
와 저번에 에스파 노래 처음 와쏭에 나왔을때 감동했는데 이번엔 콘서트 라니 ㅠㅠ
3:22 not her propose gigi right away after saying she's her bias😹 역시 젤프
8:08 이사람 트위터에서 싸불 당하는중ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 근데 당할만함 ㅇㅇㅋㅋ
아 눈물.. 앞에 '와쏭보려고 찾아왔어요'만 뺏어도..
😂 but poor guy
역시 지젤..... 여덕들 미치게 하는 핫한 매력이 있음.... 아주 못 빠져나옴.... 핫깅이 알러뷰 💜💙
나도 지젤 좋아한다... 핫좌 다이스키요..
I am surprised i thought karina has more fangirls than fan boys but turns out the ratio of fan girls and fanboys is well balanced for her ..she attracts both Genders equally
True she gained more male fans in every years
Karina’s the leader of the group. Leaders tend to give more of serious energy most of the time at first glance but in reality, they care a lot for their members, just like Irene and Taeyeon. This type of personality tends to attract more woman since (usually) men tend to like cuter personalities at first.
ningning i love you 🫶💗
aespa stans are attractive ❤️
I am here rooting for all four members. Aespa fighting!!!
Karina's popularity is insane..and looks like winter got more fanboys than fangirls haha..
Winter is really a men magnet
Its the same happen to f(x) back then when sulli has more fanboys and krystal has so many fangirls
@@aregeegee2723 Yups.Same case with Irene that has more fangirl while seulgi has more fanboy
Wow all of winter's fans are good looking 😭😭 actually all of them are good looking
3:02 4:53
@@tytrack8965 still good looking for me, good looking doesn't mean you need to be handsome or pretty only. It can be ppl who has kind and good person vibes. They had their own attractive appearance which stranger like us don't have any rights to judge or bodyshaming them 🤷♀️