How to ASK STRANGERS for PHOTOS
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 มิ.ย. 2024
- In this video I conquer my fear of approaching and talking to strangers with the help of TH-camr, Pablo Strong. I learn how to approach strangers and ask to take their photos. Here are the tips and techniques I learnt about how to ask strangers to take their portrait.
Visit Pablo's channel here: / @pablostrongvlogs
Check out his 'Streets of London' series:
• His One Dream in Life ...
--------------------------------
Links
💾💾💾💾💾💾
MY INSTAGRAM: / jamiewindsor
PATREON: / jamiewindsor
Retro Video Assets Packs:
💾💾💾💾💾💾
jamiewindsor.com/retroassets
jamiewindsor.com/vhsassets
Retro Assets Pack 1 & 2 deal (25% off): jamiewindsor.sellfy.store/p/r...
Lightroom Preset Packs:
💾💾💾💾💾💾
Full shop: sellfy.com/jamiewindsor/
#1 My presets: jamiewindsor.com/presets1
#2 Medium Format Film Stock: jamiewindsor.com/presets2
#3 Kodak Film Stock: jamiewindsor.com/presets3
#3.1 Kodachrome Film Stock: jamiewindsor.com/presets3-1
#3.2 Kodak Portra Stock: jamiewindsor.com/portra
#4 Cinestill Film Stock: jamiewindsor.com/presets4
#5 Fujifilm Stock: jamiewindsor.com/presets5
#6 Film Pro: jamiewindsor.com/presets6
Preset bundle deal (20% off): jamiewindsor.sellfy.store/p/l...
-
jamiewindsor.com - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
*_Question: WHY AM I CARRYING SO MUCH GEAR?_*
*Answer: Two reasons. Firstly, to test Pablo's assertion that the gear you're carrying doesn't make a difference. As Pablo was packing light with his set-up, I decided to overload myself. Secondly: A practical reason - we were obviously filming a video too. I had a tripod, microphones, cameras, batteries, a bottle of water etc. It's easy to grab a tiny camera and go out to make some portraits, not so easy to do that and also make a film of it. Despite what many people seem to think, I don't have a "camera crew" with me.*
Man I wish I didn't have the body language of a sociopathic serial killer when I try talking to strangers.
Mchl Kbrz let them know ur the craigslist photographer and u would want some real secrative photos in a non disclosed location. Ask them not to bring a cell phone or anything with a gps that works all the time
Serial killers usually have charming personality. ;)
Lol!
Maybe leave the machete at home?
Stop making up reasons: P
Took me 20min standing next to a beautiful mural to ask someone the first time. After a few no's, I moved to next corner, found a lovely colorful punk couple. Shot them for 5min. We laughed. I ended up shooting 10 more ppl that day. Never been afraid since. 😉
Stop shooting so many innocents
@@Fabianwew he even shot them for 5 min straight
Stop killing people
@@santiagomananet6927 and laughed. What a monster.
5 minutes shooting? They were dodging, I suppose? ;)
1. It's all about attitude
2. Keep it simple
3. Be genuine and honest
4. It's ok the be rejected
5. It gets easier
Brain: It's time to improve our photography. Go and talk to her then take a quick photo.
Also brain: Or we can do this tomorrow. Or any other day. Or let's learn landscape photography instead.
This is my brain too.
And mine.
My brain and your brain must come from the same hood
Ø
Wait..That's mah brain..😐😐
This was the turning point in my life. I'm a quiet, socially awkward and introverted person. I always struggled with making and holding conversation, especially typical small talk that everyone employs when first meeting someone, or trying to avoid an awkward situation. But street photography intrigued me on such a fundamental level that it forced me to leave my comfort zone and interact with total strangers in a way that I never thought I was capable of.
Photography has helped me in so many ways, but the biggest improvement by far has been my confidence and my ability to handle social interaction.
I needed to read this! Thanks for sharing.
Gonna try this myself
Thanks for sharing. I can imagine the energy you found doing this
Some tips:
1. Tell them your name - make it more personal.
2. Tell them where they can find the photo of them or show them the image you just took (e.g. give them your Instagram or offer your email - so it doesn’t seems so one sided - people feel like they are getting something out of it i.e. a free portrait of them)
3. Tell them the reason you are taking photos (freelance - if they don’t understand it’s okay to lie and say you are doing a uni project or something)
4. Make sure to shake their hand and say thank you (again be personal rather than a complete stranger)
John Smith 1. I think telling them your name is a great idea.
2. Definitely let them know where they can get their photo, but do this afterwards.
3. It’s good to let them know why, but I disagree that it’s okay to lie. This is just from my moralistic position so everyone can take their own judgement on this.
4. Definitely thank them, but use your judgement to see how long this should go on for. If people seems like they might be in a hurry, just say “Thanks so much. Have a great day.” If they look a bit more relaxed then take a little more time if you want.
I disagree with telling them your name. To me I would automatically think the person is trying to sell me something... or that there is a catch
I'd add another reply to when asked why I want to take the picture: "you just caught my eye/you stand out of the crowd" both, in a positive way. Most people enjoy a compliment. Of course, some of the strangers are privy to that or assume that to be the case.
@@med4u1 Right, it could get creepy! :O
Also, have a really good colourful business card that shows examples of what you do. Be pleasant and straight off, explain that you’re not trying to sell anything.
watched this yesterday, went into town today, spent 15 minutes telling myself I couldn't do it, then .... approached my first person, he said "of course", and immediately started chatting. I approached interesting people, they know they're interesting and seem to take it as a compliment that you want to photograph them. There's a couple of things I said which seemed to make a difference:
I said I was doing a street photo assignment, they seemed to want to help;
I said "can I take your picture", instead of photo, a little more informal;
If they said no, I said "I'd have probably said no too", and left with everyone smiling
Thanks for the video, I have so much confidence from this after day one
I started doing stranger portraits three days ago and I fucking love it. I was always the anxious and shy dude outside and now I see myself slowly transforming into someone I never would have believed I could be. Thanks for the video!
I gotta get on that
Fucking love it LOL.
The past year and particularly the past month has really gone the same for me. Cheers to this
Can you tell me tips how to do that and what to say in first line how to do it?
Fucking *A*
One time, I wanted to take a photo of a woman reading in park, while light was falling through the trees. I asked her if she minds, and she sais "No. You know that it kills people, do you? One time, I took a photo of my cat and he died." So now I have a funny story to tell when people ask me what is it like, to be a photographer))
Imagine shooting bursts indiscriminately. The carnage!
Reminds me of Amelie
And then she died. :(
Anastasia Rudenko. They believe taking a photo takes their soul.
That sounds like my mother-in-law. lol
Man Pablo really missed the mark with the cigar guy. A full body would have included the dog which is the most interesting part!
Dime a dozen blurry background pic that will be lost in a sea of Bokeh. Totally agree, there was potential there
Thats the thing about photography, each eye sees something different.
Exactly my thoughts too~
How dare he forget the dog!
Jup
"I'm doing some street portraits, do you mind if I take your photo?" That's such a great line. Right now I do the Phillip line of "Hey how's it going? Do you mind if I take your photo?" which usually leads to "oh what for?". Stating your intent in the get-go is so great.
How about no. 6: start with a friend? Like you went with Pablo.
teolinek Yes, that is a very good point.
"where do I see the pictures?" I've made very simply business cards up with my name, mobile number and insta handle up. That way I can just give them my card.
How to approach demogorgans
Demodogs?
Demigorgons?
😂🤣😂
Probably helps that Pablo is an absolute chiselled god.
Conor Stephenson 😂 Yeah… that did cross my mind. But, he’s proved it works with me too so anyone can do it.
@@jamiewindsor I'm not so sure that anyone can do it. When people first see me I'm always perceived as intimidating. There's something about my face and bearing. Once people get to know me, they don't feel that way anymore. I notice that Pablo smiles a lot. I'm always being prodded to smile; I only smile when I'm genuinely amused. I grew up in NYC and I learned to put on a stone face on the street.
@@marvinisrael1671 definitely how you carry yourself is key. People can intuit anxiety and nervousness.
Proved to work with you... At the same rejection rate ?..
@@jamiewindsor Ah! The relief this provided me. :-)
Your cuts are just masterpieces in their own right 👏👏
This was authentic, it took some courage to go out there and face that fear. I guess fear of rejection is one of the worst fears and it stops us from making so many connections! Loved the Stranger Things ambience to it also, well done!
Especially when I was young, I did not like to have my photo taken. If someone says no, it probably has nothing to do with you. They might just be anxious. I was even interested in photography back then and I still wouldn’t want my picture taken! I have not tried street photography before. I think I need to get past my fears and give it a try.
These approaches are also applicable towards helping to overcome other various social challenges and day-to-day anxieties we face. They are often more excuses than valid reasons to not try, and “failure” is far less relevant than we fear 👌 it’ll be ok.
They’re just people, just like you. Look, you already have something in common!
Great video. Thanks!!
I think i am alot older than either of you - i agree with all you say - except to add that people in general have no patience at all with someone who is learning ANYthing, and it is very off-putting...
It’s also important to remember why people say no in the first place. Maybe they really are in a rush somewhere, or they feel like they didn’t dress well, or they are just shy with photos. I’m sure we can all relate. You really shouldn’t take it personally because 99% of the time it’s nothing to do with you. Just move on to the next person.
This video reminds me of how bold I used to be 10-15 years ago, shooting street photographs, and now I'm inspired to get back into it! I also realized that this could have just as well been a video on how to ask people out on a date, or how to interact with strangers in general. It's such a lost art, as we're more and more lost in our screens. Anyways, thanks so much for the great content!
Good video. I've been pushing myself in this area. I'm in Mexico and and speak poor Spanish and it's hard for me. But this helps me want to push harder.
That’s a shame. Mexicans are usually very friendly, hopefully next time 👍🏼
I wear my college sweatshirt and tell people it’s a class assignment. Im 27, but look like I’m still in college so it works out.
Stranger : take the pose.
You : Say Brexiiiiiiiit.
You'll get a wonderful portrait. Gua-ran-ted
Lol
Well, that would make some really nice, genuine reaction shots!
I need to try that next time in london!😂
Mathiu Stern recommends "Money!"
5:47 wow
jared_ really Ha. This was so simple. It was literally just a single cut.
Jamie Windsor but it’s so good tho, don’t discredit my compliment let me have this
jared_ really Thank you. I appreciate the compliment. It just made me laugh because I showed a rough cut to Pablo a couple of days ago and when he saw that transition, he was also amazed. I just find it amusing because I spent so long doing post work to create the Upside Down scene at the beginning and everyone focuses on that transition which was so quick and simple. But it works well. I’m happy with it.
Jamie Windsor the Upside down segment was real good, don’t get me wrong! But that’s not original Jamie ya know? To me when I tell my videography buddies about ur stuff I tell them about ur really fluid transitions haha
AMAZING
When someone says “no” to me, i feel a little hurt inside, and mayority of the times i get this like crying eyes even if if i don´t feel bad lol it´s super weird! I think that´s what stops me everytime i want to take a photo of a stranger lol
Yes like I can only take so many rejections then I get unmotivated
There’s a noticeable transferrable skill to doing this. Learning to overcome approach anxiety with this can filter into overcoming anxiety with making friends, asking people on dates, networking, and so on.
5:49 really smooth transition. took me a second in this day and age to actually notice it!
This helped me. I’m going out now an...........nope, nope, nope! Not happening. I bottled it.
I’ll stick to the candid photos shot from the hip. I’m a chicken.
David Reynolds - me
@Meijin Kino good advice - people in certain situations will grab you and insist you take a pic :-)
I'll rather take a candid pic of people going about their business because portraits somewhat all look the same.
I would rather just use a long range zoom lens and take candid shots from a distance.
GDPRrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
A smile and direct eye contact will get you amazingly far in this world. What helps is stuff like good hygiene, grooming, and dressing your best. With photography it can help to present yourself either casually professional in terms of neatness and cleanliness of appearance, but sometimes you'll gain more ground by looking a bit "artsy" which helps build credibility for presenting yourself as a street photographer. Pablo hits a nice blend of avoiding collars (you don't want to look TOO professional), but still appropriate for a workplace casual look. You may have to adjust your look depending on who you're trying to photograph, but in general studies have shown people are more willing to work with you if you look a bit wealthy (really interesting studies out there involving a dime left in a phone booth, look it up).
I just had the worst interaction with another human after asking to take their photo. I was shocked! I thought to myself I may never ask anyone ever again, but after watching this I might! Thanks for making this video!
Jamie, your channel is my favorite photography channel hands down! Cheers!
Yes. This.
I would say most valuable as well. Not many photographers are really teaching you how to approach some particular things in photography.They more focused on technical aspects. Thanks Jamie!
Mine too!
Ken D your*
Two comments on this: one, in no other video you smile as much as you do in this one. Probably partly the nerves, but also contact with people make us happy, doesn't it.... and two: THANK YOU! I finally made the step to ask people on the street to take their photo instead of using long lenses O_o
The first encounter was so encouraging, the way the guy joked and asked if he could have one is the kind of casual response we all oh so want from people, I just thought it was really cool
I’ve loved street photography for many years and always had a challenge with photographing stranger portraits. I stumbled on this video by happenstance and, wow!! Jamie, your style, delivery, and thought-provoking approach to photography is really wonderful! I’ve been enjoying as many of these videos as I can binge in a sitting and look forward to more!! Keep up the great work!
Fantastic Stranger Things influence!!
Your editing is dope!!!
Dev Anand You are the dope...talk English!
Dev Anand watch peter mckkinnon channel, he is the king of videos^^
Steven Dean okay boomer
Jamie, you're a really kind person and I love that you shared this perspective. Thank you for the inspiration to get out there and do it!
I took the challenge to take strager's portraits as part of a personal growth program, and the limited time to complete my portfolio was a major factor in pushing me to finally do it. Eventually I went out to a park, and the first person that caught my eye was a girl sitting on the grass under a tree drinking tea by herlself. I went up to her, told her that I liked her look, and that she made a beautiful scene leaning against the tree, and asked if I could take her picture. She agreed without much hesitation, and we started chatting, she even offered me some tea and cookies she had prepared the day before, took her picture, then talked for maybe an hour, and had a great time. It really took away any fear I had before, people are much nicer than we usually expect
This video is a Thumbs-Up no-matter-what just after the first 40 seconds.. ahahha
I love this. It's so true. Trying new things is like embarking on a quest where, when you open the door to go, you find the area is covered in fog. You have to have the courage to walk into it and then accept that you are in the fog, outside your comfort zone. If you accept this and keep walking, the fog eventually dissipates and you find yourself in a new place. And you find that you are new yourself and have grown. But if you focus on the fog and decide instead to retreat from it, you won't get anywhere.
Also, I really love your videos. The content is amazing (I especially love how much you value people) and the style is superb. You've found a new fan in me. :)
Just Jen Again I like that analogy! 👌🏼
I second that. Great analogy.
Jamie- I’m late to the party here but want to let you know you’ve touched me. The best part of TH-cam is stumbling upon someone on the other side of the planet you’ve never met. Thanks much for such a valuable lesson, thanks for turning me on to Pablo and finally- I’ve had a difficult week. Thank you so much for making the clouds part a bit. Inspired and subscribed!
you are so right about the fear barrier! if you get over it, life is not as it was! it gets much more interesting and not only in photography! great video guys and great tips!
That intro is the best one i've seen on all of youtube!! 👌🏼 Well done man!! Amazing content as well!!
Thanks.
yeah it looks like a 80's cult movie
Really interesting seeing the simple approach. I always end up ranting for ages about who I am etc when I approach someone. Most of the time I leave the interaction on a massive high after taking the pic (some of the time the opposite!). Thanks for the vid
I think it's cool to wander around in a spot where people are taking selfies and offering to take the photo for them on their device. It's amazing how many people will just hand over their phone or camera to a stranger. It's the ultimate street photography because you only see the result yourself for an instant but hopefully you've made something for someone else that they can reflect on for ages.
One of the best videos I've watched in a while. Inspirational, informative and exactly the push I need to break that fear barrier. Thanks dude! 👍
Thanks for that James (and Pablo) i've been dong some street photography but now I'm going to try and up my game a bit and ask people rather than to do it sneakily :)
Love your shyness. Thanks for your videos.
8:41 tho 🙌🏽 great photo, very interesting guy
Love this video for many reasons, but I would say my favorite is your willingness to learn from someone else. In another video of yours, you tell us never to stop learning and be humble enough to leave space for improvement. This video is very congruent with your teachings. Thanks a lot!!
Loved this video, Jamie. It's so lovely to see you talk so openly about your feelings of anxiety. To show our vulnerabilities to others can be very liberating for someone who feels the same. I'm a teacher and have no problem whatsoever to stand in front of a crowd and hold a speech. However, taking portraits of strangers is something that I definitely wouldn't chose to do. Your video has definitely made me want to try it out! Thanks!
great tips! seems easy enough to do
Adrian Chong It really is. And the more you do it, the easier it gets.
"It hurts you a little bit inside" hahaha
I was grinning by the end of this video. I've been dying to do some proper street portraiture for ages and this has given me the confidence to finally give it a go. Thank you.
Thank you, Jamie, for this video. You faced your fear head-on, conquered it and are truly enjoying doing what you had previously feared. Very inspiring!!!!
Tip #1: Don't use a DSLR and a matching neckstrap. Those things scare away most people. Preferably, use a mirrorless (APS-C or m4/3) with an inconspicuous wrist-strap.
Tip #2: Print business cards with your social media info to hand away to your subjects. That makes you look more professional and they may be more willing to let you shoot them.
Tip #2 is a good shout.
Tip #1 … I thought this until Pablo convinced me otherwise. So I went out at different times to test it. I went out with my tiny fuji mirrorless and then I went out with a big full-frame DSLR (which I had put a battery pack onto to deliberately make it look bigger). Result: Absolutely no difference in responses. I stand corrected.
Kid Kurtz Soho is a great place for taking portraits due to the vast mix of people there.
I’ve actually had a way easier time pretending to be a full time noob. I shoot with the Fuji X100F with no strap and people seem to believe that I’m some hipster kid with his dads old film camera. In my experience my subjects are alot more relaxed when they think I’m not an ”actual” photographer.
@Unknown got something to say?
#1 I'd think it's the otherway around. A DSLR might seem a bit more intimidating, but for a lot of people it still has a more professional feel to it than a mirrorless, making you look like less of a creep and more of a pro.
Amazing video! "Rejection doesn't really matter"... that's a MAJOR lesson many of us need to learn, even outside of photography. This made me believe that making the jump to overcoming your fears might be a good thing for your creative work in general, and who knows, even your private life. So what if someone says "no"? That "no" is such a scary thing, but if you can cut it down to its actual size, that would be beneficial in all kinds of ways. Thank you!
Pablo is a legend! Such a happy confident guy. His Streets of London interviews are extremely entertaining.
Really insightful and helpful video Jamie and Pablo - thanks for sharing!
I would add to the introduction, "Hi there, I'm taking portrait photos today of interesting looking people on the street. May I take your photo?"
I was yesterday into the city, when i've seen a really interesting, foreign looking lady, i'd wished for having my DSLR with me, and asking for a picture...but i missed both, so no picture... now i am thinking about that....would have been a good picture.... before that, i've stumpled over a cool gothic couple...damn, i do really could have made some cool street shots....perhaps i do really should try it out...thanks Jamie! :)
One of your best vids man! It's always cool to see someone face a fear, and overcome it. Good job!
Cracking away at the walls of fear is always so liberating. Thanks for your honest share!
the best street photography is a celebration of life, even if you shoot tough subjects like the homeless. taking a photo is giving attention, respect, and validation to the subject and will probably make their day. if someone doesn't want their photo taken you don't want that photo either, because it lacks purpose. nice work worth a like and a comment
Interesting thought. I think the homeless thing can be tricky. It's a fine line sometimes between being a conscientious documenter of those less fortunate and fetishising the idea for a good photo. We were thinking about making a video on the subject of ethics in street photography. People have different takes on it.
For homeless inspiration, @suzanne_stein at Instagram. Amazing proximity.
7:04 I love that vintage jacket, can I have it?
This is rapidly becoming one of my favorite channels. I like your motion graphics design a lot. It makes me want to start messing with motion graphics more and more and even though they are little throwaway vignettes to act as dividers, they make this feel so much more quality.
Jason Mueller Thank you. I like to play around with my editing and have a bit of fun.
Jamie, your vids are thoughtful, insightful, helpful. Sincere on camera persona. Thx
Great stuff, you almost make it seem possible 😉
Good video.... also workable in other situations... good job, mate!
Nice pictures, btw.
Would it help, giving a business card?
I think it would be good as something to hand to them after you've taken the shot so they can check to see if their shot appears online. If it was introduced before, it would be one more thing to add into the dialogue and may also look like you're selling something.
The RealButcher gh
Adore how humble and approachable you are. You gained a sub!
Absolutely loved the opening !
why is this such a vsauce 3 styled video, don't know if you know vsauce but great video as always man!
CaviteTech People keep saying this about my videos. I haven’t checked it out yet.
@@jamiewindsor it's because of the background music. That's it, I notice that as well.
Walter Herrera Interesting. The music in this was played by me trying to imitate the style of incidental music from Stranger Things.
@@jamiewindsor Indeed it has a "Retro" "80s" "synth" style to it which is what Vsauce will use from time to time. Great video and music by the way. Hopefully one of this days I will go out and fight my fear to talk to strangers. You are an awesome creator Jamie.
4:40 So sad that Tony Northrup didn't allow you to take some photographs :(
Juan Quispe Ha ha.
hahahaha
LOL!
hahaha
lolz
Loved this video! Really helpful! SO glad you had such a lovely experience!
I loved this! Your authenticity shines through in this video - including your heartfelt response to unexpected connection. I loved Pablo too, and will check his work out. Very beautifully done.
Being somewhere between an introvert and a extrovert don't help does it
I'm usually reasonably comfortable talking to random people this seems real different tho but tip taken just get out there!
Gonna head to Hyde Park on 4/20 again next year good day for people that is well worth the day out!
oh god. These transitions…
Jamie, I applaud you first for caring about what "the other" feels; secondly, for admitting your fear. and, thirdly, for going out to face it head on. Thank you for sharing that entire human process!
Great video. Concise, to-the-point, insightful, and the video example was superb. I'm excited to try some of the tips and tricks Jamie and Pablo suggested.
I've been doing street photography for 18 months now, i've only ever had 1 no.... i think i'm lucky really
female confirmed.
How?
Come to Germany if you want more nos.
Problem I have in asking people to pose is that you end up with a load of photo's (interesting tho some may be) of posed faces which means a sort of 'I'm on camera' look. Street photo's in my opinion are best when the subject is unaware and you get a far more natural result. Personally I don't talk to anyone unless approached and then I'm polite but firm stating I'm interested in social history and if they wish me to delete an image where they are prominently the main subject I will do so. However I will stand my ground if they are part of a crowd on a street. My usual response to 'Why are you taking pictures?' Is to answer, who are you? And why do you wish to know? As I have a perfectly legal right to photograph in public places but not harass. Just a different approach - good video:)
Candid street photography and portraiture are two completely different genres of photography. I'm working on a video at the moment about the ethical dilemmas of street photography. It will be one of my next few videos I expect.
Great, looking forward to seeing it
Yep, can see where you're coming from & as with all photography, what matters is if you are pleased with the result. However, individual human portraiture, that the subject controls, rarely conveys anything other than the pose they wish to present. Which is great if they are paying you to produce something they wish to own, while capturing the unguarded moment is often when something deeper appears. With the introduction of 'selfies' people are posing ad nauseum, so to repeat the process seems rather pointless -but then, that's just me and me age I suppose, cheers:)
This video is about portraits, not street photography in it's classic sense. Two different things.
And that is what separates the skilled street portrait photographer and the not so skilled. If you are genuine in your interaction and make your subject relax you can get rid of that face, make sure that they are neutral and not overly smiling like most people will instictively do.
You’re such a great communicator. Love the uploads man
Thanks a lot for this video! Also, thanks for mentioning Pablo's Streets of London series - absolutely brilliant!
So James, this may be the neurotic lawyer talking, but it’s not a question of whether not they change their minds when you take the picture. It’s a question of whether or not they change their minds *after* you take the picture… Whether or not they want to control whatever you say you’re going to make of it. Whether or not they want creative control over the final product… Whether not they want a portion of whatever proceeds they think you’re going to make from the picture. I can tell you this from a legal perspective - dealing with the public is risky business, for all the reasons I’ve listed, and for a dozen more that I haven’t. And in today’s day and age, a lot of people don’t want to be photographed for other people’s entertainment. But I am neurotic.
And so what if they ask about that?... In the first instance you're supposed to take their picture without the intention of business, at least if you claim so. - And if they ask, afterwards, about anything business-related, you can discuss this. - You should, actually. Exactly to prevent any legal issues.
Wait, so what's the legality of taking pictures of strangers to post on instagram but later down the line say, make a book out of it? Or publish it in some magazine for monetary gain? Or even for display in an art gallery and sell prints of it?
I should mention that I live in Mauritius where people are much, much more closed off than say England and street photography or just people walking down the street with cameras isn't a common sight, but since our laws are pretty similar to England's I think whatever advice I could get in this comment thread would be very much useful down the line.
The Dead Immortal This is the very question at issue… It’s not black-and-white. If they give you permission to take a picture of them, they don’t necessarily give you permission to publish that picture. If they give you permission to publish that picture, they don’t necessarily give you permission to publish it just anywhere… Some people may not want to see their face on the cover of NRA weekly. 😝 if they give you permission to publish it, they don’t necessarily give you permission to make money off of it… This is why corporate releases are 10 pages long… Because they make you give up any and all rights to the images. They don’t want you having the ability to retroactively withdraw consent. It’s a running gag in my videos… I I tend to include the part where I ask them if they mind being in a TH-cam video. And if they hesitate in the slightest, I just don’t include them. I don’t want to get into fights with people :-)
Viva Frei
So essentially if I take a picture of a stranger and say "I'll post it on Instagram" that's the only thing I can do without getting into any legal trouble if the person changes their mind then?
So what about the people you see in all the greatest street photography books? Some of them were posed and some of them were not. Are there different laws for if you take a picture of someone without their consent and post in some online platform but later publish it in a book?
As far as I understand if you take a picture of someone in a public place they can't tell you to delete it and (this is where I'm least sure) you can post/publish it wherever you want.
Shame you can't get the pictures back to the people, they'd probably be thrilled
If they want it they can ask, I'll have business cards on hand for that so they can get in touch. But no point handing them out to everyone.
You can give them an instagram or web address and tell them the pic will be on there ... easy to print out a bunch with some labels and give them to each person ... :-) Business cards are a possible
Thank you for sharing, Jamie. It was really nice to see how genuinely happy you were once you overcame your fear and started to actually enjoy it. I'm new to street photography and this is something I'm struggling with a little but I'm going to take your advice and give it a go. Thanks again!
Awesome and simple thanks the two of you.
Could you comment on your experience approaching strangers on your own, without a camera crew?
Good point. - It really changes the dynamic for both parties involved. The photographer might be more confident being recorded by a friend, and the stranger might think "Oh, they're just doing a project or something.".
Camera crew? I don't have a camera crew. It's just me (and Pablo in this case). I've done this with and without having someone there filming it but how can I film the process if I don't have anyone filming it?
Jamie Windsor What I mean is, I suspect one’s experience is different when it’s just you, alone, doing this. When I’ve done it in the context of a workshop or class or whatever, it seems to give me permission to approach people. When it’s just me, I feel like I don’t have that permission.
Ernie Barreto I get it. The only difference is the confidence in your head though. The process doesn’t change.
Please ALWAYS ask permission to take someone’s photo! There are some people walking down the street that NEED to remain anonymous due to issues like escaping Domestic Violence… sounds dramatic to some perhaps but publishing a shot of someone anywhere without permission can potentially put that person (& their kids) into a life threatening situation. Their rejection would have nothing to do with you - so don’t be offended, just aware & respectful. ✌️
In a big city you are photographed filmed and shared all the time, these portraits with a blurred background wound't help Soviet Russia put a hand on you.
How about your human right of expression in a PUBLIC space??? In some countries this right is protected by law as far as I know.
In public you don't have to legally ask for someones permission to be photographed but yes I agree with you on a morality perspective.
The chance that somebody will by chance see this person on a photo is no bigger than the chance that they will run into them on the street.
This is extremely dramatic. Because a portrait of somebody on a street with a blurred out background shows you only 1 thing, the persons face. You already need to know the person and how they look (at which point seeing them is a non issue) to even recognize them, and beyond that, the information you already knew, there is nothing to gain from that photo.
You dont know their names, their location, the time it was taken. Nothing.
So to say somebody seeing a picture of somebody might cause them harm is extremely far fetched.
Some store surveillance footage would give you more meaningful information than a portrait like that. In a big city there are camera's recording you in every building you walk in to and every street corner.
Stella Q - That defeats the entire point of street photography.
Hey Jamie, great job getting out there and overcoming that fear barrier. That was very encouraging to see you getting through. Cheers!
Great video. You really nailed it by the end and the photos show it. People seemed more at ease.
First. Now I watch.
It's a lot better to take photos of people on their natural environment as they walk around or doing their thing. You just have to be real quick and then leave without seem like you did something bad. Most people don't mind to take photos of them and if they do they will let you know about it and then that's all. Anyway streets are public and open to anyone which means that you should expect a lot of things, for example personally I don't like to see drunk people walking around but I can't force them not to wall around, because streets are public. Same with photographers, they are there doing their thing even though some people may like it or not. No one can say to you anything so don't be afraid to shoot anyone you like. There is no law saying don't take photos of people, as long as you are on public places you are safe.
What a great mind changing work! Thank you very much Jamie! ❤
I'm a beginner photographer and still a lot to learn. Your videos are giving me tons of inspiration to go out there and learn more about the art. I'm inspired and motivated to ask strangers on the street for a photo. I'm an introvert so this is gonna be a challenge. As Pablo and you said, there will always be that anxiety in the beginning but will eventually go away. Thank you for sharing this lovely video!
Here’s a tip from my photo teacher- take the photos first and ask permission after.
This way you get natural appearances/less awkward expressions. You can delete them if they say no or you can take close ups/posed photos if they say yes.
This feels similar to asking strangers for photos, but I get super nervous when I have to travel somewhere. This attitude of pushing through it has overall been helpful in traveling with more confidence. The more I've done it the more I believe that I can do it.
I really enjoyed this video. It was a lucky find just when i needed it. Thanks!
Thank you for being vulnerable with your audience and allowing us to learn with you.