I just didn't realise that 18 mins video passed like in seconds.I was so engrossed in what you were telling! Simply outstanding Mr Gaurav! You're one with so many qualities... thanks for sharing the knowledge..
Really very informative video... salute u for such a deep knowledge sharing; here I would also like to add it will be better if for normal type of flights(with full automation) particular training should be given to pilots to bypass/override the each and all automation way of controlling the flights. However for safe practises to bring the flight from automation to manual control it can be password protected and password can be allotted only for such emergency cases.
I am a teacher myself. I am also sufficiently technically close to understand some avionics. I would like to say that your presentation is simply brilliant. I think you should make a whole string of videos on flying. I would really look forward to them
It feels so good to see when someone does what they love to do! It is clearly visible from the way he is explaining the entire scenario about what must have gone wrong that he clearly cares about the craft. Your expertise is much appreciated :) May they all RIP!
@Gauranga Academy Well that's what I am saying.. doesn't matter whether he is an iitian or not. What I am impressed by is his grit. he could have had a comfortable life getting into a job with that degree. but he persisted and changed his domain completely, one which he loves so much. What I am most appreciative of is his state of mind and his determination to keep hustling.
That's what I like you like most about your videos. Exploring "Hidden" places in India, Funny & sarcastic video's, and then technical. I believe no other "current youtuber" in India creates such video's. Keep up the good work sir. :)
No one can explain so clear bhaiya...so simple and understandable.. And 9:46-11:50 inserting that example of airbus (that icing one) is very important helpful to understand mcas little bit. Thank-you to be a TH-camr too..
How is this man still not flying? There is no value for talent when big corporates only look for business. My family and I are re-watching all your videos from the beginning and we love you brother ❣You are such a perfect human being. All strength to you 👊
All of u above who said they don't understand what he was talking about, as he was explaining in Hindi, if u don't know Hindi stay away from this video and don't post unnecessary comments..pls people god has given us brain to use it, so start using it..
True I would never get bored in his class and would never make an excuse for washroom. He makes everything so interesting that I don't skip the video. Nahi to baki youtubers to information deke pakate hain.
Bro I wanted to be a pilot but turned out becoming a chartered accountant But any topic relayed to aircraft fascinates me.. This is d only reason I subscribed to ur channel. Great going bro..
Waah bhai (sir) ...even iam so interested in airlines stuff....but iam a CA student ...doing IPCC ...chlo kya hua pilot nhi bn paaonga to .... airlines ka manager bnjaoonga ....all aircrafts under my control....😃😃...i have subcribed to captain joe and DJs aviation also ....
first of all may all souls rest in peace flying beast = engineering + medical + aerodynamics+history + fitness+entertainment bhaiya ne poora school khol rakha hai idhar
I have worked on 737 max on Environmental control system. Also have knowledge on Flight control system and flight management system. I can confirm on his logic . There are deeper problem with Boeing design . I posted my report 3 years back that Boeing design is not good. They wanted to have all the components of EVS in single LRU which is complicated and more error prone. I guess they have follow the same design pattern in FMS/ FCS. I have worked also on Airbus A350 XWB. Airbus designs are neat and clear.
#SIX PACK ABS 7 DAYS TRAINING SHRHEDHED th-cam.com/video/R2psi8uxEFU/w-d-xo.html MAKE SURE TO WATCH FULL VIDEO GUYS AND JOIN WITH #MissionNaturalFitness
Automation is Good but sometimes it may be lethal from this example. ✈🚨🛑 I must say now apart from pilot, engineer & fitness trainer; you are also a very good teacher 👨🏻🏫, who can simplify anything for explanation !!
69 th bcoz 68 said they are first 1st 😂😂😂😂 Edit : saalo jb kuch accha sa likho jb sirf 6 like krte ho aaj ispe 118 😂😂 Thanku Gaurav Bhai for ❤ heart !!
Respect to all those who perished due to the failure of the aircraft but Boeing have form for producing less than safe products lately. The lithium-ion 787 issue that grounded it for months. The 737 Max is a 50 year old airframe stuffed with new technology and both probably don't sit together that well but make a great budget proposition for airlines and a big profit earner for Boeing thanks to the vastly reduced development costs. Sadly Boeing have put profit before safety and they may have to pay the price of airlines switching to products that have been engineered for the 2020's rather than the 1960's with some high tech add-ons.
Actually being is to be blamed but I think after the max returns ,it will be the safest aircraft.. Some things that boeing did wrong was that they configured the mcas to run on even one sensor so that the mcas would work if even if one of the sensor is damaged.. And for some reason, they didn't train the pilots to switch of the mcas... If the mcas is switched off, the aircraft can be trimmed. Manually.. Also mcas doesn't work in autopilot mode. Boeing has already told that they have configured the mcas to run on 2 AoA sensors, and also mcas will be easier to switch off..
Thanks for the video and detailed explanation - very informative. As far as I have read about the Air France Flight 447 crash issue, the investigation suggested that the ice caused the pitot tubes (an aspect of the plane that measures speed) to freeze and the blocked pitot tubes were no longer providing valid airspeed information, and the aircraft transitioned from normal law to alternate law and gave control to the pilot who in an attempt to reduce aircraft's roll adjusted to the altered handling characteristics of the aircraft and at the same time pulled back on his side-stick, raising the nose. The aircraft's stall warning sounded briefly twice due to the angle of attack tolerance being exceeded, and the aircraft's recorded airspeed dropped sharply. The aircraft's angle of attack increased, and the aircraft started to climb above its cruising level. By the time the pilot had control of the aircraft's roll, it was climbing at nearly 7,000 feet per minute. The icing event had lasted for just over a minute. The pilot continued making nose-up inputs. The aircraft had climbed to its maximum altitude of around 38,000 feet (12,000 m). There, its angle of attack was 16 degrees, and the engine thrust levers were in the fully forward Takeoff/Go-around detent (TOGA). As the aircraft began to descend, the angle of attack rapidly increased toward 30 degrees. A second consequence of the reconfiguration into alternate law was that stall protection no longer operated. Whereas in normal law, the aircraft's flight management computers would have acted to prevent such a high angle of attack, in alternate law this did not happen. The wings lost lift and the aircraft stalled. In response to the stall, the first officer on the left side took over control of the aircraft and pushed his control stick forward to lower the nose and recover from the stall; however, the first officer on the right side was still pulling his control stick back. The inputs cancelled each other out and triggered a "dual input" warning and eventually, the aircraft crashed into the ocean killing all 228 passengers and crew on board.
Absolutely correct! Thanks for pointing this out. While I loved the presentation on this video, the 447 crash example is not a good one to give. While it is true that the origin was the icing on the pitot tubes, the root cause of the crash was largely the limited experience of the the pilot Bonin (in addition to extremely limited resting time), who gave max nose up inputs continuously, canceling the nose down inputs from the first officer Robert. In fact, the icing conditions had meant that the computer systems smartly shifted from normal to alternate law, so as to allow the pilot to give the right inputs as the airspeed inputs were unreliable for the computer to take the right decision. So I'd attribute this crash much more down to pilot error category rather than system configuration.
Thank you so much for providing us this technical information with so much clarity. Keep posting these types of videos as it will help people to understand Aviation Sector more deeply.
Mcas, explained very well.. Ahead of time and full Details.. salute to you.. Today 2022 Feb Netflix has featured the same thing via a movie...Boeimg put aircraft profits at the cost of human lives... Horrible story'....
Thank you very much for the explanation. All these while i wanted to get an answer to the questions, as to why MAX failed 2nd time in a year? Really appreciated. RIP🙏 to all who have lost their life.
RIP all the lost souls!! #Haryanvi cmmnt for Ritu bhabi.. Taneja saab kamaal ka explanation tha 1 sec bhi dhyaan nhi bhatkya.. Hum dua kraange k yaa video #Trending no.1 hojya. Regards.
Brilliant, Gaurav. You are such a gem when it comes to these analysis videos. I've seen so many documentaries related to this air crash. They poitned out the exact same things with the only difference that they take months and years to release their videos, unlike you who completed the analysis in a matter of a few days
Please allow me to make it simple. I am a hang glider and sailplane pilot - and managed to survive 53 years. I way prefer lower performing gliders because they are more stable. We are at the cutting edge (with our current technology) of aircraft design and ANY ATTEMPT TO MAKE THEM ANY MORE HIGH PERFORMANCE (IE MORE FUEL EFFICIENT / FASTER ETC COMES ONLY WITH LESS STABILITY - WHICH "DON'T WORRY" - BECAUSE BOEING HAVE DESIGNED IN SUPERCOMPUTERS - apparently that you can trust 99.9% of the time). So Boeing chased 14% fuel "efficiency". Easy to do..... make your aircraft look more like an X15 (that CANNOT EITHER TAKE OFF OR LAND ON ITS OWN).... but is more "missile like". But try take off or land with this heap of $hit WITHOUT ANY SUPERCOMPUTER AID..... You will most likely be a toasted marshmellow. ANY CIVIL AIRCRAFT SHOULD BE CONTROLLABLE BY MANUAL FLIGHT PILOT (SUITABLY TRAINED OF COURSE) AND NOT BE A HEAP OF $HIT THAT WOULD PREFER TO TAKE ANY OPPORTUNITY / FAULT TO OVER RIDE PILOTS AND KILL EVERYONE. fU$3 YOU BOEING...... NO ONE FROM MY FAMILY WILL TRAVEL ON YOUR HIGHLY "ECONOMICAL" PIG.
When I 1st time fly from DXB to BOM in last October'18 I was so happy to see the new aircraft Max 8 but after that Lion Air crashed 😔 Again on Jan'19 when I was traveling from Ccu to Bom i was so scared ☹️ but now again Ethiopian airline. Thank you DGCA for grounding this type of aircraft 🙏 #RIP #EA #LA passengers 💐😔
The way,Sir you explained. I thought that I was watching Air Crash Investigation on Nat Geo.With all the proof what happened,comparison between the might companies, Graphs (that were actually real) blackboxes. May the souls rest in peace.
18 min went like i was watching a movie...😍..you should start jee coaching or iitecturer....it would be great for retirement plant ...people need ur knowledge..
But he wrongly mentioned AirFrance pilots or system was pushing pitch down, infact cause of stall was opposite, pilots were pushing nose up for too long leading to stall.
aap bahut achha bolte ho, bahut achche se apni baat samjhate ho.. hindi me is tarah ki technical baate samjhane ko koi nahi milta.. bht bht shukriya sir ji..
I am from aviation industry, the information you provide are very helpful for future reference. Kindly try to go for more technicalities as a pilot. Thank you
Sir, the pilot of that Ethiopian plane was my mom's friend's brother in law. He was the one who send the signal which you talked about and was also a nice and polite man.
1. AirBus wanted to introduce A320 neo. 2.This thing was powerful than Boeing 737 3. Boeing decided to add more power for 737 by moving it's engines high. 4. While using full thrust,the 737 Max nose was going rather upwards than the safe angle. 5. So to suffice this,they added MCAS Software. 6.MCAS automatically brings the nose down if the nose is high. 7.MCAS malfunctioned due to wrong sensor inputs.. 8.Result :- 320 innocent souls gone...
Lots of love from ahmedabad GAURAV SIR 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 U R THE GOD OF HARD WORK... Keep doing it... I can understand the atmosphere of your house when ritu bhabhi says u r not giving her time but i must say that IT'LL WORTH IT... UR HARD WORK IS GONNA WORK FOR SURE...! LOVE U ALOT
Thank you for the wonderful information. you explained it so well in such a simple and easy way. Keep up the good work buddy. You have very good skill in teaching complex stuff in a easy way. cheers
Sir thank you so much for explaining so well. I have finally understood why this is happening. I really loved this video. And I have finally understood many concepts related to airplanes
Hello sir, I am from Bangladesh and I am a regular follower of your Channels . and genuinely you are so inspiring . may god bless you and your family . if l will go India someday than literally I will meet you...love from Bangladesh... thank you....
I work on automation too... So much automation which defies humen logic and overrides its user.....very dangerous! Thanks a ton Gaurav for makeing this video👍
Gauravbhai it’s sheer delight to hear you .. it actually is symphony .. you simply suck the viewer in your zone with your deep understanding of something you love doing i.e. flying and Vlogging .. the stall and AoA relationship explanation was spot on ..one of the best videos by far 👍
Sharing techincal details in a language which even a generalist could understand..!!! Thats the real art. Thank you so much sir.
True....... using terms like "generalist"🤣🤣🤣
😆😆 generalist
Muah me lele phir isska!!!
Feynman
Gawar Tu gernalist hai??
I just didn't realise that 18 mins video passed like in seconds.I was so engrossed in what you were telling! Simply outstanding Mr Gaurav! You're one with so many qualities... thanks for sharing the knowledge..
OMG true! Usually i don't watch long videos but after reading ur comment I realised that 18 mins already passed.
I realised this after ur comment
Sahi me
Absolutely.. I am so enlightened of flight procedures already.. Thanks flying beast
That is what I wanted proper research and explanations........which others don't provide ......great going Captian 😊
Really very informative video... salute u for such a deep knowledge sharing; here I would also like to add it will be better if for normal type of flights(with full automation) particular training should be given to pilots to bypass/override the each and all automation way of controlling the flights. However for safe practises to bring the flight from automation to manual control it can be password protected and password can be allotted only for such emergency cases.
@Saurav Kumar Gupta but he has a better grip over the concept (technically )
1.4k dis are purely out of hatred ! This video is the most logical one i have seen on ethiopian plane crash 👍👍👍👍
That's because he changed thumbnail
Because those are Boeing fan bois
I guess it's because of thumbnail.
@@SoulforLife98 no
Bcz they not happy with the crash
I am a teacher myself. I am also sufficiently technically close to understand some avionics. I would like to say that your presentation is simply brilliant. I think you should make a whole string of videos on flying. I would really look forward to them
Venkatesh sir..... Are you from iit kanpur
@@rajtripathi5034 yes, in yes electrical engineering. But I collaborate a good deal with my aeronautical colleagues
Yes sir, i saw a no. of your video Lecture........
Thank you sir
@@venkats0iitk sir me2 electrical engineering student 😇
Because he is IITian
Normal Channels review mobiles, Flying Beast Reviews Airplanes.. that too Boeing..
#ultralegend
🤣🤣🤣
Yaa thats true its called level..🤣😎🤣😎😎
😂😂😂
Because he is a pilot.
tere pichwade me dum hai toh bhi krke dikha sale joke bana raha hai.
It feels so good to see when someone does what they love to do! It is clearly visible from the way he is explaining the entire scenario about what must have gone wrong that he clearly cares about the craft. Your expertise is much appreciated :) May they all RIP!
@Gauranga Academy Well that's what I am saying.. doesn't matter whether he is an iitian or not. What I am impressed by is his grit. he could have had a comfortable life getting into a job with that degree. but he persisted and changed his domain completely, one which he loves so much. What I am most appreciative of is his state of mind and his determination to keep hustling.
What a cool pilot!! And you explain things well, cap'n. Thank you and regards.
That's what I like you like most about your videos. Exploring "Hidden" places in India, Funny & sarcastic video's, and then technical. I believe no other "current youtuber" in India creates such video's. Keep up the good work sir. :)
Kids review phones
Men review cars
Legend review planes
#flying_beast 😂😂😂
Th fuq?!
He is in aviation field.
@Just Dab and vho bhi joke tha bro 🤦♂️
@Just Dab thnx bro 😂😂
Yeah
No one can explain so clear bhaiya...so simple and understandable..
And 9:46-11:50 inserting that example of airbus (that icing one) is very important helpful to understand mcas little bit.
Thank-you to be a TH-camr too..
Thank-you for 'the heart' bhaiya😍♥️
Sir I do not agree to the your af337 crash theory
How is this man still not flying? There is no value for talent when big corporates only look for business.
My family and I are re-watching all your videos from the beginning and we love you brother ❣You are such a perfect human being. All strength to you 👊
You explained really well thanks for this knowledgeable information.
I have no idea what he was talking about. It was 737 something, something, 737, something, something ...
@@fungames24 lol 😂
😂😂😂wtf
All of u above who said they don't understand what he was talking about, as he was explaining in Hindi, if u don't know Hindi stay away from this video and don't post unnecessary comments..pls people god has given us brain to use it, so start using it..
@@branchofficeadampur5236 If thats the case then perhaps do not post the title and description in English.
Deep condolences to All the people who died 😢😢 RIP
Thanks for discussing this topic... I was worried for my upcoming trip...
Maut jaha hona hai hoga, 🙏 u & me and flying beast cant save each other's
Bhsdk tujhe koi aur kaam Nhi hai kya Har jagah comnt krta hai...
@@mastitym6210 tere parents ne tujhe dusro ko gaali dena hi sikhaya h kya
@@mastitym6210 masti. Jyada masti suj rha hai kya tere ko.
Traveller PratikJain same
Why can't university profs explain like this, studying would have been so interesting then
Now people will.say he is from IIT
Yeah they do, first of all you will have to attend college regularly 😂
So true
@@RoshanShrestha2004 even if you attend you have to give bank SSC exams
True I would never get bored in his class and would never make an excuse for washroom. He makes everything so interesting that I don't skip the video. Nahi to baki youtubers to information deke pakate hain.
Bro I wanted to be a pilot but turned out becoming a chartered accountant
But any topic relayed to aircraft fascinates me..
This is d only reason I subscribed to ur channel.
Great going bro..
Same here
Then what about your CA?
@@pratikm1551 may 2019 me attempt hai :(
My Indian Air Force dreams were crushed when I learnt we needed PCM in 12th, just 1 day before my commerce semester.
Waah bhai (sir) ...even iam so interested in airlines stuff....but iam a CA student ...doing IPCC ...chlo kya hua pilot nhi bn paaonga to .... airlines ka manager bnjaoonga ....all aircrafts under my control....😃😃...i have subcribed to captain joe and DJs aviation also ....
first of all may all souls rest in peace
flying beast = engineering + medical + aerodynamics+history + fitness+entertainment
bhaiya ne poora school khol rakha hai idhar
Srijan Agarwal 😀sahi m teacher bhi kmaaal h
Accha hain kuch knowledge mil rahin hain
Plus Spiritual
Thats what basically...IITians are...all in one 😅
Engineer aise hi hote hai 😂
You are the best pilot, father, husband and youtuber and bodybuilder
Human hi bol do na
Not less den jonny sins 😅🤣
Gay vibes*
In the end he is a civil engg that too from IIT so u can sense his talent.
And engineer
That's what an educated vlogger known as ❤️❤️
RIP To the Victims and Condolences to the Families who lost Their Family Members in this Accident!!🙏🏻
Bhagwan Unko Shaakti De.
Bhai english k caption to de dia hota
judo is my life bt tum to hindi bol rhe ho
software was hacked by CIA / MOSSAD
th-cam.com/video/5c5MxHE_PNg/w-d-xo.html
mai islie bol rha tha taki baki out of india wale log bhi dekh ske aur bhai ka view badhe...
and kisi ko acha lge to wo like bhi kr dta
Fluid explanation. RIP To All The People Who Lost Lives In This Crash.
Always love your aviation content!
I have worked on 737 max on Environmental control system. Also have knowledge on Flight control system and flight management system. I can confirm on his logic . There are deeper problem with Boeing design . I posted my report 3 years back that Boeing design is not good. They wanted to have all the components of EVS in single LRU which is complicated and more error prone. I guess they have follow the same design pattern in FMS/ FCS. I have worked also on Airbus A350 XWB. Airbus designs are neat and clear.
And yet airbus has had issues with their systems as well. Air France flight anyone. Amazibg how you airbus freaks forget that one.
Camera looks great this time... Have you also changed the cam bro? And also full of knowledge... Cool 😎
Sony le liya hoga shayad 🤔
Rajeev yes i think so
Camera se fark nhi pdta lens se new liya hoga with minimum aperture like 2 - 1.8
@Chinmay Agrawal 1.4 bht mehenga ata ha
#SIX PACK ABS 7 DAYS TRAINING SHRHEDHED
th-cam.com/video/R2psi8uxEFU/w-d-xo.html
MAKE SURE TO WATCH FULL VIDEO GUYS
AND JOIN WITH #MissionNaturalFitness
are you lowkey a teacher?? you explain very nicely and in a transparent manner
Bhai banda iit khagadpur se passout hai...kisi normal teacher se compare mat karo
@@dogsworld11993 iit khagadpur??😂😂😂😂..it's iit kharagpur bro
@@dogsworld11993 bhai khejriwal bhi IIT se pass hai, baki tum samajh lo
@@rakshit_shan07 khadagpur type krrha tha
@@rakshit_shan07 tujhe to bht knowledge hai..ghus gya beech me...beizzti krne
Being an aircraft guy I respect you for sharing your knowledge.👍
The way you explain it, makes it so simple to understand. That's the best part.
Automation is Good but sometimes it may be lethal from this example. ✈🚨🛑
I must say now apart from pilot, engineer & fitness trainer; you are also a very good teacher 👨🏻🏫, who can simplify anything for explanation !!
Roger that!
True..if he were a teacher, he would have been a great one.
That paper aeroplane was cute
I think that ritu bhabhi make. That chotu paper plane..
As a student pilot, i really appreciate d video that u have made. Great way of explaining, thank you
The best thing i loved was providing such deep knowledge.
Loved the way you explained. So much value
I appreciate your efforts to convey the right information at right time.
Valuable Piece Of Information...
Well Researched and Explained...Even A laymen Can relate to this Video...
Amazing Stuff🙌
69 th bcoz 68 said they are first 1st 😂😂😂😂
Edit : saalo jb kuch accha sa likho jb sirf 6 like krte ho aaj ispe 118 😂😂
Thanku Gaurav Bhai for ❤ heart !!
😂😂😅
@@abhiralpandey didn't get your comment. Could u explain
@@SumantKumar-nv5hj Everyone claims they are first
@@_yukthik_ 😀😀 I thought it's a part of the vlog which I didn't get😀
@@SumantKumar-nv5hj 69=S3X
Love your technical explanations ... I can listen to you for hours !!!
Sach me aisa koi channel ni hai you tube pr .
Very good videos , I think one of the best Indian you tube channel.
Thanks for the video sir. You always doo in-dept analysis and explain veryy well. Love your content.
Respect to all those who perished due to the failure of the aircraft but Boeing have form for producing less than safe products lately. The lithium-ion 787 issue that grounded it for months. The 737 Max is a 50 year old airframe stuffed with new technology and both probably don't sit together that well but make a great budget proposition for airlines and a big profit earner for Boeing thanks to the vastly reduced development costs. Sadly Boeing have put profit before safety and they may have to pay the price of airlines switching to products that have been engineered for the 2020's rather than the 1960's with some high tech add-ons.
Boeing executives should be prosecuted and executed for mass-murder.
Did you understand the video???. It's in Hindi
Correct , except the airframe part. You see the design cannot be further improved as we have achieved saturation in aerodynamic technologies.
Actually being is to be blamed but I think after the max returns ,it will be the safest aircraft..
Some things that boeing did wrong was that they configured the mcas to run on even one sensor so that the mcas would work if even if one of the sensor is damaged.. And for some reason, they didn't train the pilots to switch of the mcas...
If the mcas is switched off, the aircraft can be trimmed. Manually..
Also mcas doesn't work in autopilot mode.
Boeing has already told that they have configured the mcas to run on 2 AoA sensors, and also mcas will be easier to switch off..
@@frodobaggins2852
They did train pilots to turn the mcas off, not everyone got the memo.
Thanks for the video and detailed explanation - very informative. As far as I have read about the Air France Flight 447 crash issue, the investigation suggested that the ice caused the pitot tubes (an aspect of the plane that measures speed) to freeze and the blocked pitot tubes were no longer providing valid airspeed information, and the aircraft transitioned from normal law to alternate law and gave control to the pilot who in an attempt to reduce aircraft's roll adjusted to the altered handling characteristics of the aircraft and at the same time pulled back on his side-stick, raising the nose. The aircraft's stall warning sounded briefly twice due to the angle of attack tolerance being exceeded, and the aircraft's recorded airspeed dropped sharply. The aircraft's angle of attack increased, and the aircraft started to climb above its cruising level. By the time the pilot had control of the aircraft's roll, it was climbing at nearly 7,000 feet per minute.
The icing event had lasted for just over a minute. The pilot continued making nose-up inputs. The aircraft had climbed to its maximum altitude of around 38,000 feet (12,000 m). There, its angle of attack was 16 degrees, and the engine thrust levers were in the fully forward Takeoff/Go-around detent (TOGA). As the aircraft began to descend, the angle of attack rapidly increased toward 30 degrees. A second consequence of the reconfiguration into alternate law was that stall protection no longer operated. Whereas in normal law, the aircraft's flight management computers would have acted to prevent such a high angle of attack, in alternate law this did not happen. The wings lost lift and the aircraft stalled. In response to the stall, the first officer on the left side took over control of the aircraft and pushed his control stick forward to lower the nose and recover from the stall; however, the first officer on the right side was still pulling his control stick back. The inputs cancelled each other out and triggered a "dual input" warning and eventually, the aircraft crashed into the ocean killing all 228 passengers and crew on board.
Absolutely correct! Thanks for pointing this out. While I loved the presentation on this video, the 447 crash example is not a good one to give. While it is true that the origin was the icing on the pitot tubes, the root cause of the crash was largely the limited experience of the the pilot Bonin (in addition to extremely limited resting time), who gave max nose up inputs continuously, canceling the nose down inputs from the first officer Robert. In fact, the icing conditions had meant that the computer systems smartly shifted from normal to alternate law, so as to allow the pilot to give the right inputs as the airspeed inputs were unreliable for the computer to take the right decision.
So I'd attribute this crash much more down to pilot error category rather than system configuration.
Who told you how it happened? Cowards!!!!!!
@@RJ-ws9qc it’s in air crash investigation
Pls Vedio make Malaysia 370 .. world big mystery aeroplane ,
Angreji bolna zaroori tha?
RIP to your grammar 😢😢😢
@@rishavmusic9051 MEIN BHI WO HEE PUCHNEKELIYE JA RAHA THA!!!
@@Xyz-pj3fm yes I am from Uganda 😂😂😂no English
@@rishavmusic9051 to tujhe English smjhna jaruri tha..
Thanks sir
AAP AUR AISE INFORMATIVE VIDEOS ( especially about aircrafts ) BANATE RAHIYE !!!!!!!!!
hmm
The Gupta Circle #hmm nahi #flying #beast
Aur aap udne k sapne dekhte rahiye
@@shantanu925 bHAI HUM TUMHAARI TARHA SIRF SAPNE DEKHNE WALE NHI HAI !!! AGAR HUM KOI SAPNA S=DEKHTE HAI TO PURA JARUR KARTE HAI !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
As Said By Elon Musk Also Too Much Of Automation Is Dangerous.
to disengage krle na
Yep he experienced that in his Tesla factory
Then why is musk making driverless cars.??
@@mviv6339 Bro in those cars u have an option to correct the drive if it is at fault...Opposite to the use of manual automation in the above case....
MUKUND VATS Donald trump is always right but his choice of words are raw and hence he gets vilified by world media.
Thank you so much for providing us this technical information with so much clarity. Keep posting these types of videos as it will help people to understand Aviation Sector more deeply.
Mcas, explained very well.. Ahead of time and full Details.. salute to you.. Today 2022 Feb Netflix has featured the same thing via a movie...Boeimg put aircraft profits at the cost of human lives... Horrible story'....
OMG! Such a great explanation.👏👏👏
Loved ur explanation brother!! Would love to see more related videos of similar content.😍❤️.
Most informative one... Which are never shown in news also... A true engineer's mind... Hats off to u man...
Thank you captain for such a informative blog. 👏👏👌👌
Everything explained is so true and technical...Being a student i studied all the stuff..
Great job Sir,. Definitely this video will cross 1M + Views..
You explained it in perfect ways.... No news reporters gave us this information....
Aeroplane-Descending Down
Pilot-Am i a joke to you
Sir aap bahut achhe insaan hai....
Aap jaise logo ki jarurat hai is duniya ko...
Thank you very much for the explanation. All these while i wanted to get an answer to the questions, as to why MAX failed 2nd time in a year? Really appreciated. RIP🙏 to all who have lost their life.
Once a legend says "artificial intelligence will end this world" and i think that's true 😟
Correction: Airplanes company are using ML not AI.
What I think pilot should have one emergency button to override ML
Einstein right?
Jack ma said that i guess
Elon musk right.
Bro Waiting for your Explanation...great video ...RIP who died in plane crash
Sir I have seen almost all the air crash investigation videos on TH-cam and your information was best of all lots of love sir ji #Respect
RIP all the lost souls!!
#Haryanvi cmmnt for Ritu bhabi..
Taneja saab kamaal ka explanation tha 1 sec bhi dhyaan nhi bhatkya..
Hum dua kraange k yaa video #Trending no.1 hojya.
Regards.
Brilliant, Gaurav. You are such a gem when it comes to these analysis videos. I've seen so many documentaries related to this air crash. They poitned out the exact same things with the only difference that they take months and years to release their videos, unlike you who completed the analysis in a matter of a few days
One of the best Video i have seen ever on your channel sir..As per knowledge
What a nice explanation I am a history student but understand the whole concept
I agree bro but this is not a concept,it is general information about automation
This vlog is just amazing.
Thank you for explaining the issue in such a simple way!!
In future we may require software engineers to fly the aircraft. But Nat Geo must have found a new episode for Air Crash Investigation.
I thought exactly the same thing.
Definitely , they should have a way to turn off automation if it's not behaving properly !!
Yashvardhan Singh Chauhan yes absolutely
air crash investigations is an awesome series...................specially the air france crash episode
Please allow me to make it simple. I am a hang glider and sailplane pilot - and managed to survive 53 years. I way prefer lower performing gliders because they are more stable. We are at the cutting edge (with our current technology) of aircraft design and ANY ATTEMPT TO MAKE THEM ANY MORE HIGH PERFORMANCE (IE MORE FUEL EFFICIENT / FASTER ETC COMES ONLY WITH LESS STABILITY - WHICH "DON'T WORRY" - BECAUSE BOEING HAVE DESIGNED IN SUPERCOMPUTERS - apparently that you can trust 99.9% of the time). So Boeing chased 14% fuel "efficiency". Easy to do..... make your aircraft look more like an X15 (that CANNOT EITHER TAKE OFF OR LAND ON ITS OWN).... but is more "missile like". But try take off or land with this heap of $hit WITHOUT ANY SUPERCOMPUTER AID..... You will most likely be a toasted marshmellow. ANY CIVIL AIRCRAFT SHOULD BE CONTROLLABLE BY MANUAL FLIGHT PILOT (SUITABLY TRAINED OF COURSE) AND NOT BE A HEAP OF $HIT THAT WOULD PREFER TO TAKE ANY OPPORTUNITY / FAULT TO OVER RIDE PILOTS AND KILL EVERYONE. fU$3 YOU BOEING...... NO ONE FROM MY FAMILY WILL TRAVEL ON YOUR HIGHLY "ECONOMICAL" PIG.
The tuktuk honking in the background of the video kills more people every day by heart attack alone
I love this channel amazing content I subbed to keep it up!!!
Beautifully explained.Well done skipper. you're outstanding.
When I 1st time fly from DXB to BOM in last October'18 I was so happy to see the new aircraft Max 8 but after that Lion Air crashed 😔
Again on Jan'19 when I was traveling from Ccu to Bom i was so scared ☹️ but now again Ethiopian airline.
Thank you DGCA for grounding this type of aircraft 🙏 #RIP #EA #LA passengers 💐😔
The way,Sir you explained.
I thought that I was watching
Air Crash Investigation on Nat Geo.With all the proof what happened,comparison between the might companies, Graphs (that were actually real) blackboxes.
May the souls rest in peace.
Well said bro
18 min went like i was watching a movie...😍..you should start jee coaching or iitecturer....it would be great for retirement plant ...people need ur knowledge..
Wow your explanation is so much better than the series "Air Craft Investigation"! Keep up good work. Thank you for parting knowledge.
Became Fan Of Yours By Watching Your Content !! I Except More Videos Like This From You !
Awsome . I loved the tech knowledge .. i remember the Air france Stalling on NatGeo. Thanks for sharing your knowledge on this 😊😊
But he wrongly mentioned AirFrance pilots or system was pushing pitch down, infact cause of stall was opposite, pilots were pushing nose up for too long leading to stall.
Videos like this should be trending, instead of vulgur content and kachra news. Guys let's like and share this video and make it no 1 trending video
aap bahut achha bolte ho, bahut achche se apni baat samjhate ho.. hindi me is tarah ki technical baate samjhane ko koi nahi milta.. bht bht shukriya sir ji..
Thank you for such detailed information 😊
Make more video in aviation topic. Love your videos 😀
Thanks a lot Gaurav thanks a lot for explaining this. I was so confused since so many days but you nailed it.
I am from aviation industry, the information you provide are very helpful for future reference. Kindly try to go for more technicalities as a pilot. Thank you
I acknowledged very well. Hope u make this type of other informative videos..
I m B.tech in aeronautical engineering ....you explained very well
Very very Informative Video
With full clarity.
Gaurab sir ye video best thi but pray to God you and ritu never face this kind of technical issue ..bhagwan aapko khush rakhe
Sir, the pilot of that Ethiopian plane was my mom's friend's brother in law. He was the one who send the signal which you talked about and was also a nice and polite man.
Your name looks Indian.... Then how come your mom's friend's brother-in-law is Ethiopian. 🤨🤨🤨
But after all.... May all the victims rest in peace
1. AirBus wanted to introduce A320 neo. 2.This thing was powerful than Boeing 737 3. Boeing decided to add more power for 737 by moving it's engines high. 4. While using full thrust,the 737 Max nose was going rather upwards than the safe angle. 5. So to suffice this,they added MCAS Software. 6.MCAS automatically brings the nose down if the nose is high. 7.MCAS malfunctioned due to wrong sensor inputs.. 8.Result :- 320 innocent souls gone...
Lots of love from ahmedabad GAURAV SIR 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 💖 U R THE GOD OF HARD WORK... Keep doing it... I can understand the atmosphere of your house when ritu bhabhi says u r not giving her time but i must say that IT'LL WORTH IT... UR HARD WORK IS GONNA WORK FOR SURE...! LOVE U ALOT
Thank you for the wonderful information. you explained it so well in such a simple and easy way. Keep up the good work buddy. You have very good skill in teaching complex stuff in a easy way. cheers
And people wonders why they get so much salary
People always wonder whether you have so much or nothing.
Sir thank you so much for explaining so well. I have finally understood why this is happening. I really loved this video. And I have finally understood many concepts related to airplanes
Fluid Mechanics ki yaad dila di...Chapter 5 :- Seperation of Boundary layer # Mechanical Rocks👍
The way he shows is just a piece of art. Hats off for this.❤
I can see Theory of machine and fluid mechanics in this video 🤗
Theory of machine??
In which part
@@NitinRaman gyroscope 😉
Mohit prashant true that!
@@sanskargupta2145 yo! Bro
Mechanical Engineers spotted...
Hello sir,
I am from Bangladesh and I am a regular follower of your Channels . and genuinely you are so inspiring . may god bless you and your family . if l will go India someday than literally I will meet you...love from Bangladesh...
thank you....
i was expecting this vide from you ....thank you so much
Your way of explaining these things is soooo gooood !!! 😊👮👩🏫
1.4 k dislikes are from the makers and engineers of boeing air 737 MAX 8😡
😂😂
nope they are from ignorant Indians who gets jealous if any youtuber succeeds ....
@@SHAURYA181 He was already a successful man before he was TH-camr
@@ShivamMishra-xd5vp there is difference between being successful and being famous.... Unfortunately being sucess alone doesn't guarantee fame.
😂😂
I work on automation too... So much automation which defies humen logic and overrides its user.....very dangerous!
Thanks a ton Gaurav for makeing this video👍
Sir aapka explanation is very clear and simple
Gauravbhai it’s sheer delight to hear you .. it actually is symphony .. you simply suck the viewer in your zone with your deep understanding of something you love doing i.e. flying and Vlogging .. the stall and AoA relationship explanation was spot on ..one of the best videos by far 👍