Tel Aviv and October 7 | DW Documentary
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ต.ค. 2024
- The Hamas terror attack of 7 October 2023 has had profound consequences in Israel, Gaza and beyond. This film asks how those in Tel Aviv have reacted to the subsequent war, and what they expect the future will bring.
In the summer of 2023, DW’s Kai Steinecke was in Tel Aviv filming a lifestyle series. He met nightclub owners, creatives, restaurateurs, LGBTQ activists and architects, all working in what was a lively, liberal metropolis. Then came October 7th, and everything changed.
In May of 2024, the same people return to speak about their experiences in the wake of the attack, how daily life has changed for them, and what the future may hold for their country.
The result is a moving personal documentary and a portrait of a very different city to the one that was recorded a year ago. The square in front of the Tel Aviv Museum of Art has been renamed "Hostages Square", with empty chairs commemorating the kidnapped. At the once-bustling Carmel Market, many stalls are now deserted. And cultural center Habima Square, famous for its theatre and orchestra, now has a large illuminated sign stating: "Bring them home”.
We accompany several people into their personal spaces as they show us how their individual, day-to-day lives have changed. The documentary lays these contrasts bare by juxtaposing present-day scenes with those filmed before October 7th, back when Tel Aviv was the "capital of cool" - a world-famous party city with the Middle East’s largest spaces devoted to queer life and culture. Now, the city and the country are in shock.
One example is fun-loving bureka vendor Kobi Shmuel, who was drafted into the army and had to close his stall at Carmel Market. He was initially deployed in the Gaza Strip, where one of his comrades was killed.
Or architect Shiraz Solomon, who showed us last year how she turned an old Templar building into luxury housing. Now the architect is helping others build bunkers for Israelis and accessible apartments for those injured in the war. The Palestinian workers that used to work on her construction sites are no longer allowed to enter the country.
Muhammad Zoabi, a university student and LGBTQ activist from an Arab-Muslim family, is dealing with the fact that a friend and fellow student was kidnapped at the Nova Festival on October 7th and has not been heard from since.
Shani Goldstein had led DW host Kai Steinecke through Tel Aviv in the original 2023 production. But now, because of the October 7th attack, the co-presenter has lost her jobs as a model and radio host. She doesn’t understand why Israel is becoming increasingly internationally isolated as an agressor.
These stories and others provide personal insights into a traumatized society. The film is a contemporary document that, despite deep sadness, also offers hope for a time after the war.
#documentary #dwdocumentary
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
⮞ DW Documentary (English): / dwdocumentary
⮞ DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
⮞ DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
⮞ DW Doku (German): / dwdoku
⮞ DW Documentary हिन्दी (Hindi): / dwdochindi
For more visit: www.dw.com/en/t...
Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: / dwdocumentary
Follow DW Documental on Facebook: / dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: p.dw.com/p/MF1G
The documentary appears to focus heavily on Israeli experiences and perspectives, with little to no representation of Palestinian voices or experiences.
Of course they were attacked I know they do have documentation on how the Arabs felt during that crazy time 😮
That's because they cover it in many other separate videos. They're a big channel, with a lot to pack in
Go whatch AlJazeera bro
Same as alzahj
Are you more interested in the experience of rapists and murderers? How about the kidnapping experience from the kidnappers perspective?
it doesn't provide historical context about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict or the conditions in Gaza that preceded October 7th.
The conditions in Gaza that preceded October 7th are 100% the result of what the Palestinian leadership in Gaza created. Stop playing the victim card.
People in Gaza have been saying the opposite…that Israel has destroyed the peace they enjoyed before the war…so lol
Mohammed discusses it to some extent, from 6:40 onwards.
There are 1000x videos about "Palestinians" on youtube. Go watch them.
So whatever happened before it’s on to kill average people
The land owners were living in a nightmare for about a century, and still.
The Palestinians are NOT the land owners and if they live in a nightmare then it's their own created nightmare. Enough with the LIES.
The landowners were the British.
@@sunnyperka5791
The British never owned the land-they were a colonial power that arrogantly treated Palestinian territory as theirs to dispose of, handing it over like a casual favor without any regard for the people who actually lived there
The land owners are Jews from Judea, who's ancestors were kicked out of their homes by many different empires who ruled Israel. The Jewish lineage is much longer than the Palestinian one there. If you are about decolonization, you should know that arabs colonized every inch of their land everywhere.
@@meni2410 Palestine was first documented 3200+ years ago in the late bronze age. Relying on myth narratives cannot negate archeological evidence history.
Their own government let this attack happen. That's what you should do a documentary about.
There is one key point people need to understand: the Israeli government does not prioritize its own citizens or any other nation. If they could acquire more land by sacrificing 10,000 Israelis, they would do it without hesitation.
Hamas or Hezbollah does not prioritize Palestinian or Lebanese people
Iran definitely doesn't care about their own citizens.
There is constantly war going on because everyone is winning (except local civilians). Especially arms dealers.
Also, do you know the top 2 arms dealers?
USA and Russia
so this guy can still go visit tel aviv, what about people wanting to visit their friends and family in gaza?
What about the Palestinians stop starting wars against Israel and then play the victim card??
You do know that there's always been an Egyptian border to Gaza, huh?
@@LRdRider-xq4nd ?!?! So, they need to go around through Egypt to get to current illegal territories of Shitrahell just to see their relatives?!?! Where were you when logic was being distributed to human kind?!?!
I ll get u a ticket. What a stupid question.
@@LRdRider-xq4ndthat’s it’s close
How does DW documentary call them educational information media?
information only involves one party, and that party is the criminal.
While mentioning Israeli casualties and trauma, there's no equivalent discussion of the much higher Palestinian death toll or the humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
The Palestinians started the war for god's sake, Why are you defending the aggressor??
They report in it every day stfu
Then maybe they should surrender if they are losing the war they started?
If you can't fight than don't start the war
More Israelis died than Gazans.
How many innocent men, women and children have been analived, disabled and displaced since October 7th?
Don't start wars and then play the victim!
@@zevetbarkan2247
About those consequences without judging their actions in the first place... Israel Zionists killed 2434 innocent Palestinian children from 2011 to 2021 compared to 134 Israeli children killed during the same period (source: UNICEF). That is nearly a 20-1 ratio and that was before October 7th.
Your comments are gaslighting at its best, otherwise known as hasbara.
Lmao you started it and play the victim and crying 😂😂
@@nicholasmendoza5844 2434 Palestinian children were killed by Israel Zionists from 2011-2021 compared to 134 Israeli children killed during the same period (source: UNICEF). That is nearly a 20-1 ratio started long before October 7th.
Your hasbara is baseless.
Ask Hamas and Iran
.
What about the genocide in Gaza you hypocrites
Incredible, stunning, factual, fair and honest - love this documentary. So elegant way to express truth ❤
Wild how DW (a German public broadcaster) feels obligated to keep sharing a one sided story only because of what happened in the 40s.
צא מכאן טרול! מספיק להפיץ בורות ברחבי המרשתתת!
@@zevetbarkan2247 Swing and a miss, blud.
Germans comitted genicide
Two World Wars : murder, massacres mayhem. Genocide . Displacement of populations . Lessons not learned.
“Only because of what happened in the 40s” yeah that little thing know as deliberately systemically murdering 1/3 of all the Jews in the world solely because they were Jewish, a phenomenon only a handful of other communities had experienced also for centuries up until that point. Hmmmm I wonder why they’re sensitive to Israeli views.
So sad how people loose their lives to other greed and psychopathic behavior......for power and control over what they cannot take beyond the grave...
🤡
Praying for of the peace of Jerusalem
the recent two thousand years doesnt make it look promising
I saw the whole October 7th Attack...it was just Terrible.
God remember Us.
Too sad
They should have given the Jewish people Germany rather than starting a forever war in the middle east after WWII
I think reading something that stupid actually made my brain die for a second. Jews are from Israel.
thank you so much of truth reporting, hard work, and kindness
One side of story only as usual 😢
So?
The important side
Go watch AlJazeera
@@nicholasmendoza5844they are not neutral
@@joexavier4070 so?
I really don't understand the thinking or reasoning behind kidnapping people and taking them hostage while knowing that their country will attack you back and be in persuit....Like where they planning to provock the other party to lead it back into its hometurf and fight it in its own turf of tunnels while they destroyed everything their path. like there is a lot of unanswered questions and dodgy thinking about this conflict #ReligiousConflicts
7.O.23
I don;t understand the thinking of Israel Zionists who killed 2434 innocent Palestinian children from 2011 to 2021 compared to 134 Israeli children killed during the same period (source: UNICEF)at a nearly a 20-1 ratio before October 7th.
No more commenting against Gods nation or about the conflict, as everytime I do so I get bad dreams, just like I did now
Thank you for posting an honest documentary of how this all started.
God bless everyone in Israel. I just hope n pray to god for ur safety. Whatever u have gone and going through is unimaginable and horrific. Stay strong and safe my lovely people of Israel 🙏🏻🇮🇳❤️🇮🇱
This is horrible. No one wins in war. This has to stop. The poor people who have lost lives, limbs, loved ones, homes. Political leaders never go into war with a conscience. 😔 🙏🏽 Peace y'all. ❤
In war - the Undertaker wins.✌🏿
@@lonnieford635 ain't that the truth.
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
How much money were the Palestinians paid to do oct 7th? I know it was a sum of money per head paid to pensions, but does anyone know collectively how much they got?
Great documentary
these people dont look very happy...sad all round
But you are commiting a genocide girl
Yes, I had a strong reaction to her also. What Hamas did on October 7 was a crime. What Israel has done subsequently is a travesty and yes genocide.
Oh yeah... Ravers are all about getting kidnapped and then commit genocides while being held hostage.
This is so heart breaking thank you DW for making such a film🤍🙏 and show the world these emotional stories my thoughts are with you guys be strong we can all step up this obstcale and save our world from demolition we will rise against terrorists 👊
Be safe 🙏
hahahaha
What about the genocide in Gaza, you hypocrites
How about talking about the genocides Israel (a settler colonial state) committed for years in Palestine and Lebanon
Uh jews have been in israel since before Jesus. Keep drinking the kool aid.
Wow,❤ what a great documentary on this very important day that violence of Oct 7, not only impacted the Palestinians and Israelis, but also the rest of the world. From a distance when I see the horrific crimes of Hamas and the Israeli responses, I ask myself, how can I help? Surely all the young kids that are fighting each other deserve a better world where they too can have families of their own, a home where they not only feel safe in, but a sacred space where they can raise their children and share in their happy moments and grow together as families and society of human beings. Life is too short, each one of us should lend a helping hand and peacefully encourage all sides to come together and create a breathing space for peace, life and a positive future. Thank you for creating this heartfelt documentary that shows us as outsiders, what is really going on in the hearts of Israelis.
LOL. 'Horrific crimes of Hamas' as if this thing didn't start as far as decades ago when the Israelis repelled Palestinians from their own home & lands. And as if what Israel has done isn't 100x more 'horrific' than the Hamas did. Look at the difference between those hostagers that got held by Hamas and those that got held by Israelis.. The contrast of that alone is very telling which side that's in the wrong and it's Israel!
@@judyclarkson5887 the hostages were systematically starved. A woman over 80 was give 6 dates a day. She was nearly dead upon release. The 6 murdered in the tunnel were at half to less than half their normal body weight. Other hostages were murdered. Children were psychologically tortured. Women were raped. Are these the hostages that hamas treated so well. For heavens sake do some research before you spout nonsense.
What is she saying from 12:45?
Propagandaaaaaa! it's not working anymore...
🤡🤡🤡🤖🤖
The truth is hard, evil must be shown. You are on the wrong side of history. Once again. 🎗️
Cry more. Go to Lebanon and protest.
What u watch it then? Clown 🤡
i live in Tel Aviv and this is real journalism
FREE PALESTINE.
Free byzantine empire
You dreaming.
You have entangled yourself and you are asking of free Palestine. Better coexist than fighting and die
@@mogts free babylon
What is palestine? I only heard israel. 😂😂
The whole world must immediately know the truth and take urgent actions to avoid the upcoming apocalypse.
How is it possible that Israel intelligence or mossad can target hamas, hezbollah, iran leaders, distributed telecommunication equipment with bombs, but they didn't have information that hamas was going to strike on 7 october.
They were waiting for you to tell them, shame on you u didn't
Well done, you are really smart. How did this happen? I expect that Israel allowed them to do this in order to find a reason to exterminate Palestine, and everyone knows what Israel is planning.
They had the information and passed it on, but Netanyahu's government failed to act on it.
The language used (e.g. "Hamas terror attack") adopts an Israeli-centric narrative without presenting Palestinian viewpoints on the conflict's origins.
LOL. How would you define shooting in the head of women, children, old people, babies. Really, there's no limit to the lies.
It was a terror attack by definition. We get it you support terror ism. Most people don't, which might surprise you.
Go comment on Aljazeera bro
Hamas is a recognized terror organization by most western countries. Go watch 1000x videos that conform your views, since this is your 9th comment on this video
how should israelis call this attack then?
My prayers go out to all these families all these children all these ladies all these how many people especially all those doctors and nurses that are 24/7 and please that's also pray for all the families in Ukraine my God only almost 3 years 3 years of war shortage of medical Care heating I pray my Lord and I wish you all to join me let's pray let's have all these words come to an end before the year is out that is my prayer to all these innocent people Amen ❤❤❤
I'm sure this comment section will be peaceful and respectful😅
Copy pasted comment + there is no reason to be peaceful about a subject like this when it's an active conflict that affect people unjustly
@@Elatenl exactly, the world and all these comments are showing the complete lack of understanding and justice for both the Jews and Israelis.😢
You only discuss the opinion of one side, you should be ashamed DW
Go watch Aljazeera
plan dalet
Sympathy video changes nothing for israel
It's not a documentary. It's called taking a side NAKEDLY. It does not illustrate the reason for this conflict.
My humble request is to create a documentary based on the lives in Palestine from October 7, 2023, to October 7, 2024.
Thanks in advance.
8:00 make this guy Prime Minister and you'll have peace.
It’s good too see the cost also on the Israeli side. Not for how it costs the Government, military or economy but the human costs What is occurring in the Gaza Strip is absolutely awful! But there is and was a cost on the Israeli side too. Innocent civilians, families, children etc.its good to recognise there is a genuine human tragedy there. There’s no fundamental difference between a Israelite or a Palestinian only trivial such as the flags that are flown
God willing the current violence in the region won’t get out of hand. 🇮🇱🤝🇵🇸
If they are crying, that does not mean they are right.
you just don't want to listen
It was an incredible documentary about Israelian opinions and emotions towards the 7 October Hamass assault from the Gaza strip launched base .
אני שמחה לשמוע אדם אקראי במרשתתת מתאר את המתקפה הברברית ביותר בהיסטוריה המודרנית בתור בליל של תחושות ורגשות של בני כנען. אני צריכה חתיכה של טוסט במילוי גבינה צהובה עם קטשופ בבקשה🙏🏽
There will never be a two state solution. This is one conflict I don't mind--I dislike each side equally.
In the 70s a decision was made: Safety vs. Expansion. People have been suffering ever since
Very telling doku, showing the bubble that people was living in, some people living their best life while their neighbours were living a nightmare. Peace will arrive when all people have equality
No sympathry from me.
There are always people, like you, who prefer to sympathize with terrorisrs.
Ni sympathy to palestine
If that the case then I won’t show any sympathy to the innocent Palestinians
Unfortunately, what Israel has done in terms of injustice, displacement, killing of innocent people and children, and destroying children's hospitals does not allow us to sympathize with the other party.
W giga chad
Free Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
I don't know why Germany always ends on the wrong side (smart people with no logical capabilities)
Autism
U really think u are smart then?
@@ohdear2023 🙃
This is why countries must control their borders and diversity is not necessarily a strength.
This is racist
@@calci2679 countries that enforce their borders and are highly homogenous are among the most peaceful AND prosperous
1947
Your description of Tel Aviv as a city of cool is misleading and misinformation it's the capital of a nation of apartheid domination and the illegal occupation of palestinian land and now the capital of government that committed genocide in Qaza and illegally invading a Lebanon with indiscriminate bombing and destruction.
Its not good documentary how. Can u focus on israel which this country damage on other country?
How evil do you have to be to make such a documentary and completely omit the suffering of Palestinians? No matter what you do/say, they are still human beings.
Erm i think you will find it was palstinians who went into israel and murdered innocent civilians for no reason, wise up!!
They actually do talk about it at multiple times in the video. Esp Mohammed (who is Arab himself) mentions the suffering of Palestinians (& Arabs in general in Israel), from 6:40 onwards. But I agree that more attention should be paid to what is happening.
The Palestinean entered Israel and killed 1200 civilians... what did they expect?
@@mariof1468
Resistance group temporarily broke free of their prison, and attacked their occupiers.
There, I fixed the headline for you
So DW has done multiple documentaries focused on Gaza and the Palestinian ppl, reflecting the pain and suffering inflicted by Israel. This was just one documentary focusing on October 7 to Oct 7th. I would really like to know what Hamas thought was going to happen after they attacked Israel and what their goal was, there radical positions of no two state solution is just as bad as the far right Israeli's who don't want to share equally with the Palestinian people. No fan of either extreme or the far right in Eurape or America.
Barbaric, there is war and just resistance, and then you have..
Netenyaho & Hamas ? That's how you want to finish your sentence.?
@@alphax2869 sure, Netenyahoo has admitted he wanted war with the Palestinians to justify expulsion and settlements, and Hamas wants war because they love death, their own words.
@Zyzyx442 so you believe what netenyaho tells the world ? So let's assume he wants to bombard your family's house because he is doing some settlement, you will be OK with that ?
With Hamas, they are extremist F ups . That should be obvious by now.
Feel the pain that’s Palestinians are going through since the creation of the Zionists state.
On October 7th, Israelis felt for a single day what Palestinians have been feeling since the 1940s.
Thank God there is a Judgement day.
Wallah!
According to your book, what will happen to people like me who doesn't believe in ANY god?
"the jew will always tell you what's happened to him, but hell never tell you why"
Messed up all around.
Wow, as expected, the comments are filled with jihadi bots.😂😂
how do we know that the victims get food, first aid and money from those who donate?
@Peter-b8l6o victims dont get anything free. They pay for the donations given all managed by hamas. This was also the same procedure before the war. Any cash goes to those in hamas management.
@@MoriaCampbell I expected such an answer
im sure the comments here will be reasonable and nonjudging
By by DW , you are unsubscribed now
It's totally one side Propoganda, shame
Cry for the Pali and watch Aljazeera then
Long live Israel, land of Jesus
Don’t make this about Christianity please 😭
🤡
Remember it's a colony build on Palestine land (1948)
a biased documentary quelle surprise
7:00 Queerness is not a part of Moses' Law.
Bootlickers of Israel 😂😂
🌹
🇵🇸
❤️🔥💪🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 💪❤️🔥
Those medias make a story and that’s history. Who owns the medias??
It's interesting to see that Putin's birth date is 7. October, what a strange coincidence!!!
It hurts me more what they are doing to Palestinian families now Lebanon it’s not comparable my heart it’s with 🇵🇸🇾🇪🇱🇧
Shame on Dw showing one side propagandaa
This Documentary is an absolute shame…
Freee palestaine....
🇮🇱
Humanity
Unsubscribed propaganda
It is pathetic to talk about parties there while many Palestinians don't have where to sleep nor basic necessities for living.
Both sides are suffering because of Netanyahu.
Free palesteen
Go germany and live there.leave middle east in peace!!!
If Israel has a right to defend itself, then so do Palestine and Lebanon!
Never forget the 6 trillion who perished that fateful day…..
Watching this I see people just trying to live a peaceful life and co exist like the rest of us.
Propagandaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
Propaganda
I think at this point the idea of an independent Palestinian state is dead. The state of Israel now includes Gaza and the West Bank. Eventually the people inside will have to figure out how to get along. If Israelis want a peaceful society they will have to extend the rights of citizenship to everyone living inside their country, just like the USA eventually extended full rights to former slaves and Native Americans.
no one cares
@@zevetbarkan2247 why’d you delete your previous comments? HAHA
I don't care about P*lestine
8:00
Fodus 😂🤣😂🤣😂😂
It's been a year. Happy first anniversary. 🙄
Germany should be the one leave their land for the Jewish people for the crime they did against the Jewish population not palestine.
1st 7.O.23 hostages, 2nd P.civilians and 3rd. 2xZoneSolution which by the look of things might be a 3xZoneSolution....S.A can't wakeup tomorrow and take lesotho or Swaziland. Even if countries where to split the lines tend to be drawn on language,tribes and then mountains and rivers
No more commenting against Gods nation or about the conflict, as everytime I do so I get bad dreams, just like I did now