Aleksandar Markovic conducts Scriabin: Symphony No 1
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2025
- A. Scriabin: Symphony No 1 in E major, Op.26
Ana Hasler-mezzosopran, Vincente Ombuena-tenor
Spanish Radio Symphony Orchestra RTVE and Choir, conducted by Aleksandar Markovic
The first movement is one of the most immersive pieces I have ever listened.
It is incredibly rare to find a performance of this, possibly the best symphony ever composed, in good video quality.
This masterpiece should he performed much more often nowadays.
I don´t understand why Scriabin First Symphony is so underrated and almost unknown. It certainly is among my favorite Scriabin symphonic works. It is complete, inspired, and technically perfect!
Me too ... my favorite symphony ... All over ... It was the same thing with Mahler before Visconti " Mort à venise " ... Unknown . i don't very understand that ...
He’s the Russian epitome, taking on various musical contexts with the help of his teacher Anton Arensky! Pretty cool stuff.
To my taste he is the musician epitome of all times not only Russia.
Scriabin is just one of a long list of composers whose works are little-known because they are rarely played in the concert halls. Concert organizers play safe, and many of the music-buying public do, too.
Nikolai Golovanov has more expressive relief!
Compare the second movement.
th-cam.com/video/SwLdWPsjO0E/w-d-xo.html
This piece is so ahead of its time, in general all of Scriabins works are insanely progressive if you take a closer look. Amazing..
Strong echoes throughout of Wagner - especially Tristan. A beautiful late late 19c language.
“A beautiful late late 19c language”
Mmm yes. Love that. A language near extinguished by the language of capital and exploitation.
Excellent and beautiful concert! Great orchestra, conductor, soloists, but the choir is a treasure with such passion and energy ! The production was great! Congratulations!!!
One of the most beautiful Symphony of all time
I wish this symphony became famous! I think of Beethoven symphony 9, Mahler symphony 2 and it as great choral symphonies.
Greeting from Japan 🇯🇵
Ladies and gentlemen of the RTVE Choir. You sat there happily and patiently for all that time. And when your opportunity finally came you sang your hearts out. You were magnificent!
Gloria al Arte ! 🌷🌷🌷
This 1st symphony of Scriabin...amazing. I love all his symphonies but this one is just so beautiful and ethereal. Truly sublime.
greatest symphony ever written
Gracias RTVE por permitir la difusión de esta bellísima sinfonía muy poco conocida y que está a la altura de otras más afamadas y difundidas. Magnífica versión.
An ordinary performance of this lovely work would have been enough for me, but clearly it is here played and sung with such commitment that it is irresistibly beautiful.
Exceptionnel, grandiose, magistral, un chef d'un très grand talent, ayant une parfaite connaissance de l'œuvre et de l'orchestre, un orchestre majestueux au talent reconnu et avéré...comme je vous remercie de cette juste vue sur une œuvre respirant ce que nous souhaiterions d'un monde meilleur....merci à vous musicien de la radio télévision espagnole...merci maestro, pendant toute l'interprétation tous réunis, vous ne fûtes QU'UN.....MERCI
Semplice, elegante,indimenticabile il do del tenore a compendio della sinfonia.
I (Lento): 0:23
II (Allegro Dramatico): 7:00
III (Lento): 16:19
IV (Vivace): 24:00
V (Allegro): 27:42
VI (Andante): 34:53
Thanks so much for the helpful track info Cameron.
Merci !
Merci !
Thank you.
What a performance!!! One of the best symphony ever!
Beautiful! All the movements are beatiful! But the last one is simply sweeping!
🤫 no spoil!
😀😀
😄
Lovely. I can't imagine how hard it is to get this many artists together to produce something so grand.
Scriabin symphonies are quite difficult to synchronize and perform properly, perhaps explaining the lack of features in regular concert seasons across the globe.
Excellent rendition of a great symphony.
This is an excellent orchestra
Magnificent composition! Can’t believe I hadn’t even heard of it until a few months ago! Though I must confess the pronunciations of the tenor and mezzo soprano were a bit amusing. Clearly they aren’t very conversant with Russian!
Ashok
And.....does it matter?
First music and words.... secondly
Stunningly beautiful!
This was a powerful performance of a surprisingly unknown work. It's very accomplished for a first symphony. Believe it or not when it premiered in November of 1900 with Lyadov conducting, the final (vocal) movement was omitted. It was not included until it's first Moscow performance in 1901.
" ... its first Moscow performance in 1961." A three-letter word and you can't spell it correctly!
@@autodidact2499 But was 1961 the first time the choir joined?
@@autodidact2499: the symphony was performed in it’s entirety for the first time on 29th March 1901 (old style). He’s right
Спасибо за видео!
Belíssima exaltação à Arte da Música e da voz humana!!! Muito agradeço pela postagem. Viva Scriabin e glória à musica!
I love your words about Scriabin and music Clarice, even though my knowledge of Portuguese is minimal.
I'll translate for ya:
Splendorous exaltation to music, art and the human voice!!! I am much obliged for posting it. Viva! Scriabin and glory to music!
Thank you Cyro!
Reading these old comments have me a sense of nostalgia, nowadays TH-cam comment sections are rarely as friendly ;(
Браво!!!
Tks for posting!
42:03
"Cast forth the moon, grants short lived fortune.
Saluting the sun, yields eternal destruction."
Слава искусству, Вовеки слава!
all the people over there playing are so beautiful. all these spanish. interesting.
めっちゃいい曲なのに何故有名じゃないんだろう
Though this symphony is fantastic, why is it NOT famous?
Doch die Symphony wunderbar ist, warum ist sie nicht berühmt?
It's famous to me!!
Because it is difficult to perform. It probably requires much rehearsal time to get it all synchronized (besides singers, choir and everything else).
Simply because there are so many works that are little-known, but just as wonderful as this, and it is not possible for everything to be famous. The very concept of being famous is a few standing out above the majority. Now whether the few that become famous are chosen because they do have an edge over everything else that's very nearly as good, or whether it is truly random, or chosen by accidents of history, is another question. I find so many pieces in the "very nearly as good category" that I could not honestly rate even a tiny bit lower that I am inclined to think it's largely accidents of history that decide which composers, and which composers, become famous.
That said, the requirement for vocal soloists and chorus probably does count against it, though. That must add to the cost and difficulty of preparing a performance. Still, that doesn't explain why Scriabin's 2nd Symphony, in C minor, is not famous: it seems just as good a composition to me, and it doesn't have any chorus or singers, and it uses a fairly normal-sized orchestra (for the late romantic period). Yet it is possibly even less known than the 1st Symphony.
The three best-known of Scriabin's 5 symphonies are, oddly, the ones that are in his later, possibly less accessible style, and require a larger orchestra, and a chorus and organ in one case - these three being Symphony no. 3 in C minor, "The Divine Poem", Symphony no. 4 in C major, "The Poem of Ecstasy", and Symphony no. 5 in F-sharp major (sort of), "Prometheus, the Poem of Fire". This last is the one with the chorus and organ, as well as a piano soloist. These three use the largest orchestra, and are probably the most difficult to perform - but they are all better know than Symphonies 1 and 2. I have no idea why - these things cannot always be explained easily.
私もそう思います。
I SHINK SO
I got to sing this with a choir. Unfortunately, it was in French. Nothing wrong with the language (I'm Canadian and huge advocate for better French education to bring our country closer together and make everyone here more cultured), but it's a bit more awkward to sing this one. I'm also fluent in Polish, so just in terms of pronunciation, Russian does feel more natural to me than French.
But what an experience it was to have had the privilege to perform this!
“Friars Rubbing Wood” brought me here
BRAVO BRAVO !!! 🌷🌷🌷 (hOLLAND)
I wonder how many of the woodwind and brass players are from the east of Spain, in particular Castellón, Valencia, Alicante and Murcia.
@42:35 ...Sublime!
Deserves so much more regognition
never play Scriabin since 40 years ago in my symphonic orchestra , sad !
Que manos negras pueden haber detrás, y no solo en su orquesta?
「芸術の詩」。
私のお葬式で流して欲しい。何回聴いても涙が出る。フルートの要の女性、サイン欲しい。
✨✨✨✨✨
46:20
_"Jesus died for our sins..._
_One more won't hurt."_
- Friar Tuck, Friar's Rubbing Wood: The Fall of Nottingham
Try Pletnev’s latest recording from Pentatone. It’s breathtaking.
Ashkenazy is a great recording as well
Conductor showing his "Musin technique" I'd say... :-)
09:11
Peut-être, - de mon point de vue de fan 500 % de Scriabine-, cette symphonie est encore tellement empreinte de l'influence grandiose Mahlerienne, que l'on n'est ni dans son langage post- Chopin, ni dans celui extraordinaire (sa signature !) totalement COSMIQUE FANTASTIQUE VISIONNAIRE, ni (forcément) dans l'atonalité ébauchée dans son dernier opus (op 74), bref : un langage qui n'est pas personnel en 1900 (je crois) où, pas plus, n'apparaissent les courants impressionnistes du moment...
Je me suis sentie un peu déçue aussi, de ce fait ; l'orchestration est, elle, bien évidemment, remarquable: en tant que "GRAND ORDONNATEUR" en herbe, Scriabine ne pouvait faire moins !
Un immense génie complètement illuminé...
(allumé, même, Haha !)
On est loin, j'ajoute, du niveau des œuvres "Spectacle total" avec... Sons lumières ET PARFUMS !!
In these weird Coronavirus times, would it be unforgiveable yet again to perform it without the chorus, or even without the whole final movt, as happened in the premiere? It's too good not to perform for reasons of practicability!
Coronavirus will be history one day - even if it is still with us, we will just live with it like we do influenza, with annual vaccinations.
As for the symphony, it would be far from ideal to perform it without the chorus or entire final movement, because it would be incomplete, and not as the composer intended it. I would not pay to attend a performance of it minus the final movement... any more than I would for Beethoven's 9th Symphony minus the final movement. The fact that, due to practical limitations, the first performance was without the final movement should not be used to justify doing likewise with later performances. The symphony is now well established as a 6-movement symphony with vocal soloists and chorus in the last movement, following a trend in choral symphonies that began with Beethoven, and I don't think a 5-movement performance would fly today.
If you like this interpretation but find the singer's not up to the music, listen to, Riccardo Muti's recording of it. The Philadelphia Orchestra and the singer's are, Stefania Toczyska and Michael Myers. They are wonderful! It's a great recording.
625
No more Bruckner and Mahler, please so help me God! Tell our younger conductors and music directors to perform the Scriabin symphonies and tone poems instead. We need these works firmly cemented in the standard repertoire, plus they are much shorter and are not so overblown!
Please correct your spelling: it's "Aleksandar Marković" not "Aleksandar Markovic [sic]". How difficult would that be?
Uhhhh, forgot the ´ .....Preposterous LOL
Le " c" avec un accent aigu n'est pas programmé sur la plupart des smartphones, non plus que sur les IPhones.
Voilà, c'est très simple.
Il vaudrait presque mieux une écriture phonétique : "itch".
Is Alexander Markovich
@@amarteville426 Pourquoi cherchez-vous des excuses pour quelqu'un que vous ne connaissez pas?
@@nicosuarez6962 You misspelled both names, dunce!
vraiment beaucoup de mal à accrocher...un peu déçu quand même!!!!!!
" beaucoup de mal à accrocher " ... Tiens donc ... La beauté à l' etat pur serait donc si difficile à appréhender ? peut-être devriez vous essayer le " Sacre du printemps " ! Bon courage ...
Peut-être, - de mon point de vue de fan 500 % de Scriabine-, cette symphonie est encore tellement empreinte de l'influence grandiose Mahlerienne, que l'on n'est ni dans son langage post- Chopin, ni dans celui extraordinaire (sa signature !) totalement COSMIQUE FANTASTIQUE VISIONNAIRE, ni (forcément) dans l'atonalité ébauchée dans son dernier opus (op 74), bref : un langage qui n'est pas personnel en 1900 (je crois) où, pas plus, n'apparaissent les courants impressionnistes du moment...
Je me suis sentie un peu déçue aussi, de ce fait ; l'orchestration est, elle, bien évidemment, remarquable: en tant que "GRAND ORDONNATEUR" en herbe, Scriabine ne pouvait faire moins !
Un immense génie complètement illuminé...
(allumé, même, Haha !)
On est loin, j'ajoute, du niveau des œuvres "Spectacle total" avec... Sons lumières ET PARFUMS !!
It would have been great if the mezzo sang in tune. Even the occasional note would have been nice. A truly appalling performance from her and utterly painful to listen to. And to think this was broadcast. If anyone should be interested in hearing how it should be performed I respectfully suggest going to Prague in 2021 where it will be featured as part of a festival of Scriabin's music to mark his 150th birthday anniversary. I am going in the hope it gets this performance out of my memory.
totally agree! the occasional note would have been nice, to help us interpolate the correct tune :D
I am not a singer but I find it not so horrible. That are a micro differences or...? I have not listened the whole symphony yet. Tell me where is such a place? I find maybe her singing a little poor in terms of color and expression but these intonation problems hm..i can't find the place where she is complete out of tune. Maybe a little bit..Tell me, I want to learn.
"150th birthday [sic] anniversary [sic]" is a tautology. The proper usage is either "150th anniversary" or "150th birthday".
Hm..in begining of singing can I hear it. She had a bad day maybe :) but then better and better. Isn't it? Nobody another in comments says it..just one after you. Even Marković is smiling a whole time :-))
@@autodidact2499 You are correct, I must grant - each of the few times I've seen you correct others' posts. But is it really necessary to go about arrogantly correcting others' spelling or grammar?
In a way, I am in sympathy with you. I'm a bit of a stickler for proper grammar, spelling, and so on, and it makes me wince a little when someone gets something wrong, especially if I think it should surely be easy to get it right. But what the...? It's not up to me to correct everyone else. People don't usually react well to being corrected, perhaps because they feel a bit humiliated, and they're not likely to like the person who corrects them. I decided long ago I didn't want to correct everything wrong I see if it's at the cost of alienating others from me.
Some people may, through no fault of their own, have had less education, and so may not be able to produce a perfect piece of writing, and some people are in a hurry in their busy lives and may not have time for proof-readingi of their comments, or they may have poor physical dexterity which makes error-free typing very difficult. Some people not conversant with computers may not know how to produce the accented characters that you have found lacking in at least one post.
Who knows? It's not for me to judge why someone else produces typing that may look careless or error-prone.
Besides, however perfect I might privately think I am, I might one day be wrong in something - make a mistake I either don't know about, or that I forget to correct - it's happened many a time, despite my attempt to be careful whenever I write. And then it will be humiliating for me to be corrected if I have gone around correcting everyone else.
I suppose you may not be like me in how you see this, and you must do what you must do. But I ask... is it really worth it to get disliked by people for the sake of being able to correct them? Personally, I don't think so.
sorry dude, mahler had you beat my 11 years haha