Jumbo Shootout - Episode 3 Guild F-250E vs. Gibson SJ-200
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- This is the final round of the Jumbo Shootout Series. The Guild F-250E goes up against the Mighty Gibson J200!
Please vote in the comments for your favorite of the two!!
Hi brother, in a cabin in the mountains without my AirPods. Listened on my iPhone, so can’t tell you yet. Tomorrow I’ll have my headphones on and will let you know then. However, even on my iPhone, I would definitely go with the king of the flatops, but don’t count that as a vote yet. A great video, brother man 👍🏻
All things considered including cost the Guild would be the one I'd buy
A wise choice. I see that they’re making them in natural finish now too. $599 - great deal.
Hi Paul, I watched your three jumbo guitar videos. And I admit that as a songwriter for my next album, I wanted to not only use my Martin guitars and wanted to put other colors with a Jumbo. The problem is that the Gibson J200 is too expensive for me. Ditto for the Eastman AC330. That for the Epiphone J200, it's out of the question because I find it very dull in sound, it has no soul. On the other hand the Guild F250e, there were not many TH-cam videos to give me an idea of this fabulous Jumbo. Also, your videos on the subject, convinced me that this Guild F250e is fabulous. If the handle is thin like my Guild P240 Parlor, then I think your videos gave me the arguments to buy this beautiful F250e.
Thanks again for your videos Paul.
🙂👍👍👍👍
Thanks Jeff, I’ve used the F-250 in the studio and it tracks like a dream. You’re going to love it
I would say the Gibson, but Guild holds its own. If you account for price, the Guild takes it easy. I would be curious to add the Guild - all-American F-55 to the comparison, It is a direct competitor to J-200 and it comes in a solid maple or rosewood configuration, both with Sitka tops.
Very close but if we take price out of the equation I have to give it to the Gibson but the Guild sounds wonderful too. Great video.
Thanks very much! I still say, this Guild punches way above its weight class. If you ever see one, buy it!
Brother you made a great series here , I did not expect an import guitar to have done what the Guild has , it held it`s own but the Gibson has more of that "punch" to put it on top.
Maybe folks do not want to admit how good the Guild really is ?
Hey Paul. Really enjoyed this series and it's helped me choose my next guitar. I've been obsessed with wanting a J-200 style guitar without the Gibson price tag. My budget is around £500 or $650 ish and I've been looking at Sigma, Epiphone, and out of the blue I find the Guild and here you are doing the perfect shootout for me! Being objective (tricky) the Gibson definitely has a greater fidelity - almost like a 4K TV against an HD TV. Both display great pictures but one has more detail and nuance. Nevertheless, at the price the Guild seems like a steal even it isn't quite as beautiful an object.
Thanks so much, and I’m so glad it was helpful. That was totally my goal. I’ll tell you, I pulled this Guild out the other day after a few months, and it just punches waaayyy above its weight class. If you get one, I promise you won’t regret it. Thanks again! 🙏🎸😎
The Guild F-250E stands out in its price range. I only played one in person, the strings were ancient and one was broken (probably rusted through, they were old). It was still sounded better than any guitar I played that day up to twice its price or even more in some cases. I'd imagine with some new strings it would really shine.
I really want that Guild because I could probably NEVER afford the Gibson, which is my dream guitar. Even the Guils is something I can’t afford right now, but I like it. It sounds warmer in the video, but I can hear/feel/tell that in the room it doesn’t quite have theat BOOM that the J-200 has. It doesn’t move as much air. But the overall rounder notes, and somewhat less dynamic range, possibly due to the compression o audio lent itself well to the recording. Even in person, sometimes the more affordable guitars can sound really good because they hit that mids region well. But I have also played both models and the Dynamic range in the Gibson Jumbo is second to none. In this video though, I’ll give the nod to the Guild. And it ceratinly hasn’t hurt my contention that I want to buy one as a consolation prize for the Gibson…In fact its more attractive even on its own now than it was.
I listen to this with my headphones and both guitars seem to be out of tune at some points.
The J-200 is my dream guitar, I’m gonna try my best to get it this year 🤞🏽
They really are the ultimate.
I hope you get one soon! 🙏😎🎸
Guild is still one of the best choice for a Jumbo, but I guess the all solid woods build Blueridge BG-2500 could be at eye level with the by far much punchier Gibson.
Greetings from Germany.
Guild for the win
Gibson wins, but for the money, I will get an imported Guild. Great review
Thanks a lot! If you find one of these Guild F250’s, you won’t regret buying it
Thanks for watching!
Hi there i have trouble finding if the Guild F-250E would classify as a super Jumbo because i want to order this Guild but it needs to be a Super Jumbo size
Hi, I can tell you it’s the same size as a Gibson J200, if that helps
@@paulgeorgia8013 yes that's a super jumbo! and you were talking about laminated etc but i'm reading It's a Solid top guitar?
@DTmaster yes solid Sitka spruce top
@@paulgeorgia8013 yeah btw there's a new model on the scene called guild f-250e deluxe maple blonde, one major lift is a bridge and top nut for example
The Gibson has strong highs, maybe a little too string. It might benefit from some darker strings.
I own the ultimate jumbo (maple Guild F-50) and the highs can be a little strong. I find the DR Veritas strings to be perfect, they usually work well with maple guitars with the rich mids so I recommend giving them a shot.
The Asian Guild holds its own pretty well here too. Definitely wins in value.
The Gibson 200 was already defeated by the Guild f50r
In my opinion the Guild has the superior sound here.. I tested one against a Gibson and bought the Guild. The Guild just has a more balanced and full sound. The Gibson is too bright sounding for me and doesn’t have the warmth and personality of the Guild. The Gibson is a much nicer guitar to look at, but I’m here for sound not looks.
Thanks for the feedback. Guild has been very underrated brand for a long time. I’m a big fan of them. Thanks for watching!
it was difficult to tell because each one was played for so long, making it hard to remember what the other sounded like? If you changed guitars quicker, it would be easier to pick out. Sorry...
Heavy or light (thin) pick?
Mediums, actually
Why did you exclude the Guild F-55
Because I don’t have one
I am a huge Guild fan and not so much a Gibson fan.
With that said, I do have to give the J-200 the edge here.
However! At it's price point, the Guild for the win.
You’re right on all counts. This Guild punches way above its weight. If you ever see one of these, my advice is: buy it
Hi brother man, the 200 wins. After listening all the way through again, I backed it up to a minute with the Guild and then a minute with the 200. Unquestionably, to my ear, the Gibson wins this one 👍🏻
Thanks Brother Man, I value your opinion.
This J200 is pretty extraordinary ❤️😎🎸
It might win, but definitely not by it's price tag if you catch my drift - it's closer than it should be.
@@shred5 spot on with that comment, for sure 👍🏻
Gibson, easily.
Its tone is so much fuller.
Guild is an amazingly well budget guitar either way.
Shame it has such a crude sunburst and slightly weird headstock because of extremely wide tuner spacing.
But I dislike the pointy shoulders the most.🤣
Great tone either way. Just not as beautiful as it could be.
Well they arent that close. The guild is kind of tight/stiff sounding and has less detail/overtones. The gibson is simply a prettier sounding guitar. It sounded like a piano with a ton of bass. The songs sounded better on the gibson.
guild
Gibson J-100 is NOT solid maple back and sides.
With all due respect, I can assure you that my 2002 Gibson J-100 XTRA is solid maple back and sides.
@@paulgeorgia8013 listed as Solid Sitka Spruce top and Maple back and sides. Note it doesn’t say “Solid Maple”…if it was they would include the word solid… marketing doesnt miss a beat. There has been some discussion about this on Gibson forums but it appears that solid maple was dropped in the 50s or 60s in favor of laminate because solid maple is difficult to work with, and there was a lot of issues with cracks, which laminate construction solves.
@jnorthrop70 have you ever actually seen, or held, or played a 2002 J100XTRA? I’ve been around guitars all my life, and I know how to SEE laminate vs solid. This guitar was built. By Ren Ferguson. He has never built a laminate jumbo guitar in his life. As far as the theory of cracking, I own 3 J200’s from the same era. All solid maple. How were they built without cracking?
@@paulgeorgia8013 I have never seen the word “solid” prefacing “maple back and sides” on any Gibson literature. Do you really think Gibson marketing wouldn’t put the word “solid” in the copy if they could? It’s a selling point. I see solid rosewood” or “solid mahogany” back and sides listed on their other guitars. And I’ve played plenty of Gibson solid, semi-hollow and hollow arch tops and flat and arch top acoustics (and owned a few, too). I prefer their electrics, frankly. My experience is if they’re vague about a feature, there is a reason for it.
@jnorthrop70 notice they also don’t say solid spruce top. I’m not interested in the variations Gibson went through in Kalamazoo, including the shitty Norland era. What I know to a serous this: The Bozeman factory does not now, nor ever has, used laminate maple on their jumbos.
Great video brother
Thank you! Thanks for watching! 🙏🎸😎