I once read a sharp comment: Modern Chinese people cannot forget the Japanese invasion of China in 1937, but they cannot recall the Cultural Revolution in 1966 and Tiananmen Square in 1989 !
I've been following the news about this case from other news sources. You are spot on. The waters run very deep from all 3 sides. The history lesson was very much needed to wake up those ignorant critics. Imagine when all this information can be easily found online.
Mr Loo, thank you so much for your great sharing to create awareness🙏appreciate if u could do a Mandarin sharing for the seniors. Our young ones travel a lot. They might target travellers soon. Some of our youth r kind hearted n trust ppl easily.. hope your sharing will remind them to be more vigilant.
Thanks for alerting to the danger to go Bangkok. Many young Malaysians already being kidnapped (or killed coz of resistance towards the scamming mafia ) in Myanmar, happening for a few years now. Be careful & be safe.
As someone who worked in a PRC state run company in Cambodia, I believe PRC govt is doing something covertly. They can't interfere with what is going on in another sovereign country.But somehow with things that they did covertly and in cooperation with the local government, many scam gangs were actually busted in Phnom Penh in 2022. With almost 2 decades of self inflicted political instability I actually have less faith in Thai police and security. Even an innocent tuk tuk ride in Thailand can end with extortion. We shall see.
@1m65 just to clarify. I think Thai police are generally trying to uphold law & order and the individual police officer acts in good faith. But Thai political instability & Extremely tough lese majeste laws has led to mistrust between the uniformed services and the masses. Furthermore, they legalise recreational cannabis and Thailand has been portrayed as prostitution capital and all these brings in other problems and creates lots of "grey areas" in upholding the law so the individual police constable have so many things to look out for and will be overwhelmed. Like how is a policeman going to tell the difference between a kidnap vs a friend helping his drugged out friend into a van. In Cambodia is quite the same except the government is a bit more beholden to PRC due to obor investments. So it's like when the PRC has enough of their own citizens running crime syndicates there affecting their image and citizens, they can pull certain strings. But not in Thailand. For better or worse.
I think SGreans' bad mandarin standard may not be a hindrance to these syndicates if they seriously really want to target SGreans. They could use other ploys such as very cheap tourism deals (e.g. hotel, resort, air tickets, tour packages ) to get you hooked. Many SGreans are already falling for these online
Singaporeans very easy to scam also. One of the most scammed nation in the world. Sadly. We need to wisen up to protect ourselves against these scammers and stop thinking that Chinese won’t 害 Chinese or the Chinese Govt will rescue these victims.
Some confirmed scams. You can Google the following to read the news. A - 680 China nationals arrested in raid on Cyberjaya-based online scam syndicate B. Rising number of Malaysians arrested in Taiwan as runners for scam syndicates
Yes Mr Loo I was waiting for this. As I said earlier that this is out of proportion. You are a regular contributor here and you should use your grey matter (no doubt you have plenty) to separate the "wheat from the chaff". Surprisingly from the comments I realized most of your followers thought you were right. Also youth unemployment is a problem of late not only in China. It is getting progressively worse now as I write in most European countries. Germany the biggest there will not be spared. Visit China and soon you will find that it is one of the best run country now on the planet. Thanks for the correction expected of a responsible character. I will continue to seek you out and wish you well always. Happy New Year!
And why no mainstream media reported on the 300,000 or 500,000 victims, Mr Lu. How about your CNA or StraitsTimes, did they report on those figs? Why not?
Show where u get the fig, not just spreading some unverfiable fig from sources of dubious credibility whose agenda is clear. Trace the source of funding of those so called " sources".
@@SayNoToIdiotskey word:”300K working as scampers”, so how is this related to Thailand not being safe? For all you know, these 300k scammers r being paid a comms ion for every scam they r successful…still fakenews by Mr loo.
Plenty of fake singaporean pretending to be one to criticise you…..especially those who claimed to be one called you a disgrace to Chinese. Real singaporean don’t associate ourselves as Chinese but singaporean….
Oh boy. You are wrong on this. There are definitely a good number of Singaporeans that are heavily brainwashed by CCP into thinking China is their motherland. This is a topic not widely or publicly discussed because there are some implications to social cohesion in Singapore.
Ok, So the article you quoted from transnational crime in South east Asia does not say that all 300,000 chinese are kidnapped. It says "many of them". That could be any number higher than a dozen. Also, I do believe there are a lot of scammers in those regions, but I doubt the number of them. Firstly I would like to know how the article estimated the number of scammers and how they verify if someone is a scammer??? Also, who funds these small research groups? Are they state funded for example. Many small crime investigative and research think tanks are usually funded by NGOs like the NED (CIA cookie cutout) and the military industrial complex. For example, ASPI who writes fake and biased articles are funded by the military industrial complex.
You spot on in your presentation on every points. One more point you could use why do so many Chinese willing to emigrate permanently to western countries given the chance. There is a push factor involved. What is it?
Mr. Loo, it’s okay to warn travellers of the risks of travelling to Thailand but please do not berate the Chinese people in favour of the Japanese and the westerners. Imagine the harm done by the forced selling of opium to the Chinese people by the British and the number of people killed by the drug besides the number of Chinese people who were killed during the Opium War
You missed my point totally. The point is historically, Chinese has no qualms go after Chinese. So stop thinking that there is cultural or racial loyalty among our Chinese community.
Not understanding the history that caused Qing dynasty to weaken and corrupt. Qing close port policy that stop innovation and outdated military. Dont blame the world for your own mistake.
@ Have you ever thought of how the white people exterminate the Red Indians in North America and they talk about genocide in Xinjiang. If you insist on using historical facts to proof your point, then I think you are being paid to do so.
2 points to share here:(1) Some news reports said the police only made phone calls to Myanmar and within 2 hours the actor was released. The actor said that there are 49 Chinese nationals in his cell but only he was released. (2) Chinese media interviews with ex workers in Myanmar and Cambodia scam operations said that about 80% of these workers were not forced labours under physical threats at all times, but willingly worked there ti pay off debts and for money.
Great that you mention the taiping rebellion, and the great famine caused by the Mao. Many ppl still doesnt realise the reality of chinese killing chinese is in a scale way more scary than one can imagine.... Great video as usual.👏👏👏
@@1m65 Mr. Loo I think u are already very "kind" by only listing the Great Famine and the Taiping Rebellion :-D Other major atrocities that resulted in numerous Chinese deaths (commited by the CCP) is way much more: Tibet Suppression (1950-Present) Anti-Rightist Campaign (1957-1959) Cultural Revolution (1966-1976) Forced Sterilizations and Abortions (1979-2015) Tiananmen Square Massacre (1989) Persecution of Falun Gong (1999-Present)
It's call 'Democide'. It's define as "the intentional killing of an unarmed or disarmed person by government agents acting in their authoritative capacity and pursuant to government policy or high command." by RJ Rummel. His estimate of CCP killing under Mao China at 76,702,000 (1949-1987) 76.7 f**king million people killed by Mao. 💀💀
@@1968gadgetyoAnd to think they still hang that giant portrait of Mao at Tiananmen Square: A man whose policies caused the deaths of tens of millions, revered as a hero. It's like glorifying the architect of a nation's deepest scars. Orwell once said, ‘The most effective way to destroy people is to deny and obliterate their own understanding of their history.’
loll roots? His roots is in SG. He speaks English and is human. He should not forget his humanity. Moreover, his ancestor root is probably Qing Dynasty or KMT, not the ruling CCP branch. Why should he care about this unrelated rotten branch today?
My roots? I am a 3rd Generation Singaporean. I am racially a Chinese. This does not mean that I need to be loyal to Mainland China. Are you loyal to Mainland China? But I am not hostile to China. Just reporting the news as it has happened and provided my views.
Just to get some facts right. The Taiping rebellion lasted 14 years and 20 to 30 million perished due to the warfare, disease, and famine exacerbated by the war. The Nanjing Massacre started in December 13, 1937 and lasted until early January 1938. An estimated 200,000 people were killed. There the statement that the Japanese killed less Chinese is hardly a good comparison?
You missed my point totally. The point is historically, Chinese has no qualms go after Chinese. So stop thinking that there is cultural or racial loyalty among our Chinese community.
@@1m65 Using historical events to make broad claims about "Chinese people" as a whole demonstrates prejudiced thinking. Every population has experienced civil conflicts throughout history. By your flawed logic, one could point to any civil war or internal conflict (American Civil War, French Revolution, Russian Civil War, etc.) to make similar claims about any ethnic or national group. The Taiping Rebellion (1850-1864) involved complex political, social, and religious factors during a different historical period. The Nanjing Massacre (1937) was part of a military invasion and occupation. The actions during the Taiping Rebellion don't justify or diminish the events at Nanjing. My thinking is clear and I am pointing out your mistake in logic which I am afraid is flawed and deeply problematic.
@@lkt56 Your attempt to moralize and deflect reeks of intellectual dishonesty. Historical civil conflicts like the Taiping Rebellion highlight the internal tragedies of Chinese governance and society, something deeply relevant when discussing the CCP's current lack of accountability and disregard for human rights. Stop using the "everyone had civil wars" argument as a shield; it's lazy, reductive, and misses the point entirely. History shows that the Chinese government has no issue exploiting, suppressing, or even killing its own people when it serves their interests. The Cultural Revolution, Great Leap Forward, and Tiananmen Square massacres are modern examples, not ancient history of this pattern. Comparing these to foreign invasions like the Nanjing Massacre is comparing apples to oranges. Your attempt to mask historical reality with lofty rhetoric is laughable. Instead of addressing the CCP’s failures or the state’s long tradition of oppressing its own people, you deflect into philosophical nonsense. Here's a tip: if you're going to defend the indefensible, at least try not to sound like you're reading off a poorly written propaganda script
Mr Loo, I've seen many other youtube sharing. They suggest that the KK Park is CCP government run project under the Belt-Road-initiative. It has been around for many years already...and the electricity, water, telephone cards etc are supplied by CCP. It is such a big compound that only government level can build and sustain. They are the reasons why the rest are not released. Probably you can research on this and share in another video as this will help people understand the source of the crime.
KK Park and other parks were indeed originally built as part of the Belt and Road Initiative. However, this does not mean that the operations within these parks are controlled by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). In countries like Myanmar, where warlords control territories, the situation has changed. In the past, the Golden Triangle was known for drug production, but now it has shifted to human trafficking and scam operations. The most likely scenario is that the Belt and Road Initiative failed in this country for various reasons, such as war or internal conflicts. Ultimately, these buildings were left behind, controlled by local warlords, and later taken over by criminal elements from China. Some of these criminals may have had contact with Xi Jinping (though this does not imply Xi Jinping supports their actions). For example, some Malaysian Chinese politicians, even unknowingly, may end up taking photos with figures from Chinese scam groups. The criminal leaders are mainly from mainland China, with some from Hong Kong, Taiwan, Malaysia, and even Singapore. Although the CCP has many flaws, there are also individuals who exploit these situations to create a narrative of slander based on 10% truth and 90% fabricated content. These individuals engage in a form of scam, brainwashing the majority. For instance, a recent "anti-China" individual in his video mentioned that Xi Jinping is the mastermind behind these operations. In that video, he showed a clip of the Thai female prime minister speaking in Thai, but the subtitles claimed she said, "She is also a descendant of the Yan and Huang clans. Her ancestors come from China. As long as China gives the order, Thailand will immediately take action and send troops to eradicate the criminals in Myanmar's parks." Such content can only deceive people who lack common sense in international politics. When has Thailand ever had the authority to send troops into another country to carry out military actions and eliminate a criminal network with thousands of bandits and numerous Myanmar warlords, all at China's command? The internet is flooded with malicious and distorted information about China and the CCP, much of which is not factual. The CCP is certainly an inadequate political party. Similarly, the utilitarian, self-glorifying, yet ineffective attitude prevalent in Chinese society is also frustrating. However, many people who have left China now engage in unethical practices to smear China in order to please another group. These people have inherited negative traits of Chinese society-lacking moral boundaries. But just because something is disliked or criticized, it doesn't make it untrue. Facts are facts, and we should not let subjective judgments or malicious slander distort them.
@@bogodoyandex9654 Your argument is a chaotic mix of biased assumptions, contradictions, and convenient deflections. Let's break it down: The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI): Claiming that parks built under BRI are later "taken over" by criminals implies a failure of the CCP’s governance and oversight. You want credit for BRI when it succeeds, but conveniently deny responsibility when it breeds corruption and crime. Can’t have it both ways. "Contact with Xi Jinping doesn’t imply support": This reeks of straw man deflection. No one credible is claiming direct orders from Xi. However, the consistent inability, or unwillingness, of the CCP to address crimes linked to its citizens and initiatives raises legitimate suspicions. "Slandering China with 10% truth and 90% fabrication": This is rich. The CCP is notorious for spreading propaganda where "truth" is buried under layers of deception. Deflecting criticism as "anti-China" is a lazy way to dodge accountability. Thailand and Military Action: You mock the feasibility of Thailand intervening militarily in Myanmar, yet conveniently ignore that China's influence often overrides sovereignty in the region. Beijing uses its economic power to sway smaller nations, so your argument only highlights the CCP’s hypocrisy. Moral high ground: Claiming people who criticize China are "inheriting negative traits" from Chinese society is laughable. It reeks of the very self-glorification and moral relativism you supposedly dislike in Chinese culture. You end by saying "facts are facts," yet your entire argument is an exercise in cherry-picking and framing. If the CCP wants to be seen as a responsible global leader, it should stop hiding behind excuses and start cleaning up the messes its policies and citizens create.
So, where did my comments ? There are censored words on Bilibili, and the same applies to TH-cam. What's worse is that even after deleting my comments, they still show me prompts for other people's comments.
@ Those videos also display the following: The Thai Prime Minister speaks in Thai, and the subtitles in Chinese say: "I am also a descendant of Yan and Huang; my ancestors came from China. As long as Xi gives the order, Thailand is ready to take military action to completely eliminate the criminals and local rebels in the KK Park area." I want to know, did the Thai Prime Minister actually say this? Have Singaporean media reported such a major event, like Thailand preparing to send troops to attack KK Park?
Thank you again for this video! Some part is quite funny whn you expressed those angry comments..but you are very *Tactful in words and you did a Good job/research on this topics!🙌👏🙌👍👍👍😅😅
Well myanmar announced and china public security bureau admitted they repatriated over 40,000 back to china in 2023 during the last crackdown. China public security bureau definitely would not lie or overstate the figures. So if 40,000 get caught a few hundred thousand still running is plausible
@1m65 U can trust CNA, that is your propaganda again? Do u know CNA is also called CIA News Agency by locals? Do u know why? And did CNA dare publish the CommsRisk fig of 300,000 and USIP ( funded by CONGRESS) 500,000? STOP SPREADING FAKE NEWS!
@@1m65 You haven't prove the 300,000 fig u cited from sources Commsrisk and Congress sponsored USIP. U blindly spread from those sources without doing homework ,Mr Lu?Yet exhorting people to trust CNA. What is your agenda? U ain't just a simple content creator, Mr Lu.
Your statement that “Chinese kill more Chinese” is over simplistic. One cannot lump civil wars etc into the calculation. During the communist early days, some economic errors were made, compounded with natural famine, causing quite a bit of suffering, but you must include the effect of foreign blockades etc into the discussion. Invaders are invaders, even causing a single death is too many.
You missed my point totally. The point is historically, Chinese has no qualms go after Chinese. So stop thinking that there is cultural or racial loyalty among our Chinese community.
@@Leongchor No one's asking China to "join the Myanmar civil war." How about starting with shutting down the flow of communications and internet services from Chinese telcos enabling these scam operations? Or are they "strategically unavoidable" too? And the "economic errors" excuse for mass suffering? Call it what it was: criminal negligence. Blaming foreign blockades while Chinese leaders massacred their own is peak deflection. China builds highly sophisticated military islands and spies network globally, yet "can't stop scams on its doorstep." Talk about selective incompetence.
My scam calls definitely increased after my visit to China in Nov 24. The callers spoke very good mandarin to the extent that I did not understand some terms used and they even wanted to help "take over" to show me what they wanted me to do. I just ignored the calls. In recent weeks, SG Police reported some people lost $$$ to scammers. Always to on guard and do not think one is smarter and will not fall prey. Be safe rather than sorry.
many china citizen display in their own homeland and in small village in china, not much help are given to find them. how can govt willing to help found them in other country so far away
There is a big difference in killing from civil war or rebellion in a country and Chinese being killed by Japanese in a war of aggression ! Hope you know the difference BUT i really believe you dont ! Too proud to see what KIASU like you choose to see !
You missed my point totally. The point is historically, Chinese has no qualms go after Chinese. So stop thinking that there is cultural or racial loyalty among our Chinese community.
Ha, I might get targeted if I go to Myanmar or Thailand. That said, I am still not fluent enough to engage in a telephone conversation to scam others in mandarin.
You can add the point that the Myanmar junta government a vety good friend of china has lost 50% of the country to the rebels. China punishing or humiliating their 'good friend' can cause the whole myanmar junta to collapsed
Many missed my point totally. The point is historically, Chinese has no qualms go after Chinese, not so much who killed more Chinese. So many of the commentators should stop thinking that there is cultural or racial loyalty among our Chinese community.
according to some other news, they have doubled the space / buildings recently so they are targeting a lot more people to "work" there. Earmarking a concert audience is not surprising. Power, internet are from where?? Also, so difficult to withdraw / transfer money in that country now so why are huge scammed sums allowed to transfer out now?
Should warn people who are looking for high paying jobs in the region. It should not affect tourists. They should interview those who hv been rescued to know the real situation
We should leave it the Singapore government to advise Singaporeans whether is it save to transfer to Thailand or China. Knowing the US government spending hundreds of millions educating the medias to manufacture stories on China, we should take those stories with a pinch of salts knowing the geopolitical rivalry between the 2 giants.
The risk is real ; and is a clear and present danger .. and it’s a good public service announcement ….. but of course beyond altruistic motivations, monetary returns from TH-cam’s is also part of the equation for you by sensationalising this issue….
fully agree...... just sidetalk...dunno why mr loo plant photocarpus which is only nice to see...? if plant a row of 8 papaya trees, will have papaya to eat...
The Nanking Massacre and the horrible unit 731 experiments are totally incomparable in brutality compared with wars. How can you actually compare war with massacre? Regardless of the number, wars happened a lot in the past all over the world and if you totalled the number of war victims because of domestic wars throughout the Chinese history of course it is huge since China has 5000 years of history. But it's totally different from massacre where Japan brutally killed & tortured defenseless civilians (infants, pregnant women, elderlies), not in war but for their maniac pleasure. It's totally demonic. Totally different in nature and incomparable. For someone to think that the Nanking massacre is far better compared to wars, I'm speechless. Nazi's holocaust is remembered for a reason.
Your moral posturing is as hollow as your logic. Yes, the Nanking Massacre was a horrific atrocity, no one's disputing that. But your attempt to dismiss centuries of Chinese-on-Chinese slaughter as "just wars" while selectively demonizing others reeks of hypocrisy. Defenseless civilians were also killed en masse during the Cultural Revolution, the Great Leap Forward, and countless other "non-war" CCP campaigns. Were those "totally different in nature"? Were those deaths somehow less tragic because they were caused by Chinese leaders instead of foreign invaders? And while you conveniently invoke the Holocaust, remember this: Germany owned up to its past, while your CCP whitewashes its atrocities, erecting Mao’s portrait in Tiananmen Square as if the millions who perished under his rule never existed. Save the righteous indignation, it’s not convincing coming from someone excusing the crimes of a regime that killed its own with the same brutality it accuses others of.
Sure. SG Goverment (MFA) are standby to support. So report your traveling with MFA. The MFA can provide assistance if you need it during an emergency. At least they had been set to do that, therefore it was formally advised.
th-cam.com/video/11WqF2w-nGo/w-d-xo.html This may give you a idea why KK park is so powerful. Even if Sg folks are kidnapped there, Sg govt is probably going to be helpless too.
As long as one practice common sense. You will be safe in Bangkok. I was based there for 2years for work. Very frequently I will go sightseeing up country and go nightspot etc. Not once I felt threaten.
Please dont watch this video cos he doesn't knows what he is talking about. He just wants viewership thats all. Thats y he ranting nonsense. No facts n figure to substantiate
This is killing me 😂.....all this started because you didn't do your research before making the video. Kidnapped indeed.....they were not kidnapped whilst in Thailand. They were tricked into Myanmar on the basis of a job. When they got there, their passports were taken. Instead of admitting your mistake, you make this video to justify the first video.
N yet the 2nd video didn’t vindicate the 1st video…this job scam by syndicates is not new…long ago,,young girls were promised good jobs in America n when they got there, their passports were confiscated n forced into prostitution to pay their airfares n lodgings…it’s still happening today..human trafficking
IF scammer watches this video…Singaporean will be safe as our MANDARIN IS MIXED WITH WATER not original. So Singaporean is out. Safe to visit BKK and wear SG FLAG..use stickers issued during National Day. It works
I appreciate that you are not afraid to speak honestly on issues you believe in, without being afraid of backlash or criticism.
Yes 👏
I once read a sharp comment: Modern Chinese people cannot forget the Japanese invasion of China in 1937, but they cannot recall the Cultural Revolution in 1966 and Tiananmen Square in 1989 !
I've been following the news about this case from other news sources. You are spot on. The waters run very deep from all 3 sides. The history lesson was very much needed to wake up those ignorant critics. Imagine when all this information can be easily found online.
Mr Loo, thank you so much for your great sharing to create awareness🙏appreciate if u could do a Mandarin sharing for the seniors. Our young ones travel a lot. They might target travellers soon. Some of our youth r kind hearted n trust ppl easily.. hope your sharing will remind them to be more vigilant.
@@cooartcraft3068 Hello , since when they took in Seniors?
Open your eyes la.
Thanks for alerting to the danger to go Bangkok. Many young Malaysians already being kidnapped (or killed coz of resistance towards the scamming mafia ) in Myanmar, happening for a few years now. Be careful & be safe.
Yes
Just last year nov, Malaysia save 121 suspected victims of job scams trapped in the Myanmar conflict.
Avoid Myanmar
Avoid Thailand too
Not only avoid Myanmar, avoid Thailand, Cambodia, Laos, Philippines, Vietnam and Dubai...
As someone who worked in a PRC state run company in Cambodia, I believe PRC govt is doing something covertly. They can't interfere with what is going on in another sovereign country.But somehow with things that they did covertly and in cooperation with the local government, many scam gangs were actually busted in Phnom Penh in 2022.
With almost 2 decades of self inflicted political instability I actually have less faith in Thai police and security. Even an innocent tuk tuk ride in Thailand can end with extortion.
We shall see.
Really ? I am surprised Thailand police is like that
@1m65 just to clarify. I think Thai police are generally trying to uphold law & order and the individual police officer acts in good faith. But Thai political instability & Extremely tough lese majeste laws has led to mistrust between the uniformed services and the masses. Furthermore, they legalise recreational cannabis and Thailand has been portrayed as prostitution capital and all these brings in other problems and creates lots of "grey areas" in upholding the law so the individual police constable have so many things to look out for and will be overwhelmed. Like how is a policeman going to tell the difference between a kidnap vs a friend helping his drugged out friend into a van.
In Cambodia is quite the same except the government is a bit more beholden to PRC due to obor investments. So it's like when the PRC has enough of their own citizens running crime syndicates there affecting their image and citizens, they can pull certain strings. But not in Thailand. For better or worse.
@@1m65 they are grossly underpaid so are subjected to the "taboo word"
Hong Kong news on this matter everyday. Advised their people to be vigilant if need to visit those places and don’t visit if not necessary.
Exactly! And there are so many that think that there is no risk for Chinese to go to Thailand.
I think SGreans' bad mandarin standard may not be a hindrance to these syndicates if they seriously really want to target SGreans. They could use other ploys such as very cheap tourism deals (e.g. hotel, resort, air tickets, tour packages ) to get you hooked. Many SGreans are already falling for these online
Singaporeans very easy to scam also. One of the most scammed nation in the world. Sadly. We need to wisen up to protect ourselves against these scammers and stop thinking that Chinese won’t 害 Chinese or the Chinese Govt will rescue these victims.
Some confirmed scams. You can Google the following to read the news. A - 680 China nationals arrested in raid on Cyberjaya-based online scam syndicate B. Rising number of Malaysians arrested in Taiwan as runners for scam syndicates
Tks for information,
Better don't take risk, many other countries can go.
Exactly
Yes, cannot go Thailand. Go Cambodia, Myanmar, Laos....... 😆
We are with you 👍
Yes Mr Loo I was waiting for this. As I said earlier that this is out of proportion. You are a regular contributor here and you should use your grey matter (no doubt you have plenty) to separate the "wheat from the chaff". Surprisingly from the comments I realized most of your followers thought you were right.
Also youth unemployment is a problem of late not only in China. It is getting progressively worse now as I write in most European countries. Germany the biggest there will not be spared.
Visit China and soon you will find that it is one of the best run country now on the planet.
Thanks for the correction expected of a responsible character.
I will continue to seek you out and wish you well always. Happy New Year!
And why no mainstream media reported on the 300,000 or 500,000 victims, Mr Lu. How about your CNA or StraitsTimes, did they report on those figs? Why not?
There are 300,000 people in myanmar working as scammers. Most of them are from china, Malaysia and SEA countries.
Show proof or u are spreading fake news like the content creator.
Show where u get the fig, not just spreading some unverfiable fig from sources of dubious credibility whose agenda is clear. Trace the source of funding of those so called " sources".
@@SayNoToIdiotskey word:”300K working as scampers”, so how is this related to Thailand not being safe? For all you know, these 300k scammers r being paid a comms ion for every scam they r successful…still fakenews by Mr loo.
I had heard people talk about it. People went to Thailand and never back.so far About 4 people, so far lost, i heard
Plenty of fake singaporean pretending to be one to criticise you…..especially those who claimed to be one called you a disgrace to Chinese. Real singaporean don’t associate ourselves as Chinese but singaporean….
Exactly !
Oh boy. You are wrong on this. There are definitely a good number of Singaporeans that are heavily brainwashed by CCP into thinking China is their motherland. This is a topic not widely or publicly discussed because there are some implications to social cohesion in Singapore.
Ok, So the article you quoted from transnational crime in South east Asia does not say that all 300,000 chinese are kidnapped. It says "many of them". That could be any number higher than a dozen. Also, I do believe there are a lot of scammers in those regions, but I doubt the number of them. Firstly I would like to know how the article estimated the number of scammers and how they verify if someone is a scammer??? Also, who funds these small research groups? Are they state funded for example. Many small crime investigative and research think tanks are usually funded by NGOs like the NED (CIA cookie cutout) and the military industrial complex. For example, ASPI who writes fake and biased articles are funded by the military industrial complex.
To say the victims deserve their plights... I think only a heartless person can say that. It's horrible that someone can say that
Thank you! For being patient and kind in a real world. ❤
You spot on in your presentation on every points. One more point you could use why do so many Chinese willing to emigrate permanently to western countries given the chance. There is a push factor involved. What is it?
Thanks for educating on Chinese history
Mr. Loo, it’s okay to warn travellers of the risks of travelling to Thailand but please do not berate the Chinese people in favour of the Japanese and the westerners. Imagine the harm done by the forced selling of opium to the Chinese people by the British and the number of people killed by the drug besides the number of Chinese people who were killed during the Opium War
You missed my point totally. The point is historically, Chinese has no qualms go after Chinese. So stop thinking that there is cultural or racial loyalty among our Chinese community.
Not understanding the history that caused Qing dynasty to weaken and corrupt. Qing close port policy that stop innovation and outdated military. Dont blame the world for your own mistake.
@ Have you ever thought of how the white people exterminate the Red Indians in North America and they talk about genocide in Xinjiang. If you insist on using historical facts to proof your point, then I think you are being paid to do so.
2 points to share here:(1) Some news reports said the police only made phone calls to Myanmar and within 2 hours the actor was released. The actor said that there are 49 Chinese nationals in his cell but only he was released.
(2) Chinese media interviews with ex workers in Myanmar and Cambodia scam operations said that about 80% of these workers were not forced labours under physical threats at all times, but willingly worked there ti pay off debts and for money.
Great that you mention the taiping rebellion, and the great famine caused by the Mao. Many ppl still doesnt realise the reality of chinese killing chinese is in a scale way more scary than one can imagine.... Great video as usual.👏👏👏
Thank u very much . A lot of people only familiar with Sino-Japanese war.
@@1m65 Mr. Loo I think u are already very "kind" by only listing the Great Famine and the Taiping Rebellion :-D Other major atrocities that resulted in numerous Chinese deaths (commited by the CCP) is way much more:
Tibet Suppression (1950-Present)
Anti-Rightist Campaign (1957-1959)
Cultural Revolution (1966-1976)
Forced Sterilizations and Abortions (1979-2015)
Tiananmen Square Massacre (1989)
Persecution of Falun Gong (1999-Present)
It's call 'Democide'. It's define as "the intentional killing of an unarmed or disarmed person by government agents acting in their authoritative capacity and pursuant to government policy or high command." by RJ Rummel. His estimate of CCP killing under Mao
China at 76,702,000 (1949-1987)
76.7 f**king million people killed by Mao. 💀💀
@@1968gadgetyoAnd to think they still hang that giant portrait of Mao at Tiananmen Square: A man whose policies caused the deaths of tens of millions, revered as a hero. It's like glorifying the architect of a nation's deepest scars. Orwell once said, ‘The most effective way to destroy people is to deny and obliterate their own understanding of their history.’
In China their history education is distorted and twisted. Youngsters dont even know what is Tian An Men massacre. That is the real humiliation.
Mandarin is very widely spoken in Spore. You do a lot of business with China. It is good to speak more languages. Do not forget yr roots Mr Loo.
loll roots? His roots is in SG. He speaks English and is human. He should not forget his humanity. Moreover, his ancestor root is probably Qing Dynasty or KMT, not the ruling CCP branch. Why should he care about this unrelated rotten branch today?
So should he not speak the truth??
My roots? I am a 3rd Generation Singaporean. I am racially a Chinese. This does not mean that I need to be loyal to Mainland China. Are you loyal to Mainland China?
But I am not hostile to China. Just reporting the news as it has happened and provided my views.
Thanks Mr Loo for sharing. Ignore those ignorants
Just to get some facts right. The Taiping rebellion lasted 14 years and 20 to 30 million perished due to the warfare, disease, and famine exacerbated by the war. The Nanjing Massacre started in December 13, 1937 and lasted until early January 1938. An estimated 200,000 people were killed. There the statement that the Japanese killed less Chinese is hardly a good comparison?
🤣
You missed my point totally. The point is historically, Chinese has no qualms go after Chinese. So stop thinking that there is cultural or racial loyalty among our Chinese community.
@@1m65 Using historical events to make broad claims about "Chinese people" as a whole demonstrates prejudiced thinking. Every population has experienced civil conflicts throughout history. By your flawed logic, one could point to any civil war or internal conflict (American Civil War, French Revolution, Russian Civil War, etc.) to make similar claims about any ethnic or national group. The Taiping Rebellion (1850-1864) involved complex political, social, and religious factors during a different historical period. The Nanjing Massacre (1937) was part of a military invasion and occupation. The actions during the Taiping Rebellion don't justify or diminish the events at Nanjing. My thinking is clear and I am pointing out your mistake in logic which I am afraid is flawed and deeply problematic.
@@lkt56 Your attempt to moralize and deflect reeks of intellectual dishonesty. Historical civil conflicts like the Taiping Rebellion highlight the internal tragedies of Chinese governance and society, something deeply relevant when discussing the CCP's current lack of accountability and disregard for human rights. Stop using the "everyone had civil wars" argument as a shield; it's lazy, reductive, and misses the point entirely.
History shows that the Chinese government has no issue exploiting, suppressing, or even killing its own people when it serves their interests. The Cultural Revolution, Great Leap Forward, and Tiananmen Square massacres are modern examples, not ancient history of this pattern. Comparing these to foreign invasions like the Nanjing Massacre is comparing apples to oranges.
Your attempt to mask historical reality with lofty rhetoric is laughable. Instead of addressing the CCP’s failures or the state’s long tradition of oppressing its own people, you deflect into philosophical nonsense. Here's a tip: if you're going to defend the indefensible, at least try not to sound like you're reading off a poorly written propaganda script
Very likely Thailand will classify Mr Loo as persona non-grata...😂
Mr Loo, I've seen many other youtube sharing. They suggest that the KK Park is CCP government run project under the Belt-Road-initiative. It has been around for many years already...and the electricity, water, telephone cards etc are supplied by CCP. It is such a big compound that only government level can build and sustain. They are the reasons why the rest are not released. Probably you can research on this and share in another video as this will help people understand the source of the crime.
KK Park and other parks were indeed originally built as part of the Belt and Road Initiative. However, this does not mean that the operations within these parks are controlled by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). In countries like Myanmar, where warlords control territories, the situation has changed. In the past, the Golden Triangle was known for drug production, but now it has shifted to human trafficking and scam operations. The most likely scenario is that the Belt and Road Initiative failed in this country for various reasons, such as war or internal conflicts. Ultimately, these buildings were left behind, controlled by local warlords, and later taken over by criminal elements from China. Some of these criminals may have had contact with Xi Jinping (though this does not imply Xi Jinping supports their actions). For example, some Malaysian Chinese politicians, even unknowingly, may end up taking photos with figures from Chinese scam groups. The criminal leaders are mainly from mainland China, with some from Hong Kong, Taiwan, Malaysia, and even Singapore.
Although the CCP has many flaws, there are also individuals who exploit these situations to create a narrative of slander based on 10% truth and 90% fabricated content. These individuals engage in a form of scam, brainwashing the majority. For instance, a recent "anti-China" individual in his video mentioned that Xi Jinping is the mastermind behind these operations. In that video, he showed a clip of the Thai female prime minister speaking in Thai, but the subtitles claimed she said, "She is also a descendant of the Yan and Huang clans. Her ancestors come from China. As long as China gives the order, Thailand will immediately take action and send troops to eradicate the criminals in Myanmar's parks." Such content can only deceive people who lack common sense in international politics. When has Thailand ever had the authority to send troops into another country to carry out military actions and eliminate a criminal network with thousands of bandits and numerous Myanmar warlords, all at China's command?
The internet is flooded with malicious and distorted information about China and the CCP, much of which is not factual. The CCP is certainly an inadequate political party. Similarly, the utilitarian, self-glorifying, yet ineffective attitude prevalent in Chinese society is also frustrating. However, many people who have left China now engage in unethical practices to smear China in order to please another group. These people have inherited negative traits of Chinese society-lacking moral boundaries. But just because something is disliked or criticized, it doesn't make it untrue. Facts are facts, and we should not let subjective judgments or malicious slander distort them.
@@bogodoyandex9654 Your argument is a chaotic mix of biased assumptions, contradictions, and convenient deflections. Let's break it down:
The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI): Claiming that parks built under BRI are later "taken over" by criminals implies a failure of the CCP’s governance and oversight. You want credit for BRI when it succeeds, but conveniently deny responsibility when it breeds corruption and crime. Can’t have it both ways.
"Contact with Xi Jinping doesn’t imply support": This reeks of straw man deflection. No one credible is claiming direct orders from Xi. However, the consistent inability, or unwillingness, of the CCP to address crimes linked to its citizens and initiatives raises legitimate suspicions.
"Slandering China with 10% truth and 90% fabrication": This is rich. The CCP is notorious for spreading propaganda where "truth" is buried under layers of deception. Deflecting criticism as "anti-China" is a lazy way to dodge accountability.
Thailand and Military Action: You mock the feasibility of Thailand intervening militarily in Myanmar, yet conveniently ignore that China's influence often overrides sovereignty in the region. Beijing uses its economic power to sway smaller nations, so your argument only highlights the CCP’s hypocrisy.
Moral high ground: Claiming people who criticize China are "inheriting negative traits" from Chinese society is laughable. It reeks of the very self-glorification and moral relativism you supposedly dislike in Chinese culture.
You end by saying "facts are facts," yet your entire argument is an exercise in cherry-picking and framing. If the CCP wants to be seen as a responsible global leader, it should stop hiding behind excuses and start cleaning up the messes its policies and citizens create.
Yes I saw those videos as well but I can’t verify those claims.
So, where did my comments ? There are censored words on Bilibili, and the same applies to TH-cam. What's worse is that even after deleting my comments, they still show me prompts for other people's comments.
@ Those videos also display the following: The Thai Prime Minister speaks in Thai, and the subtitles in Chinese say: "I am also a descendant of Yan and Huang; my ancestors came from China. As long as Xi gives the order, Thailand is ready to take military action to completely eliminate the criminals and local rebels in the KK Park area." I want to know, did the Thai Prime Minister actually say this? Have Singaporean media reported such a major event, like Thailand preparing to send troops to attack KK Park?
Thks Mr Loo.
Those who say such negative comments are unhappy people.
Ignore them.
Aiyo Mr Loo, out of 200k viewers sure got some don't believe. This is social media
Got to educate them for their own safety
❤
Thank you again for this video! Some part is quite funny whn you expressed those angry comments..but you are very *Tactful in words and you did a Good job/research on this topics!🙌👏🙌👍👍👍😅😅
Question is why such a huge number of people both country government not taking any actions
Well myanmar announced and china public security bureau admitted they repatriated over 40,000 back to china in 2023 during the last crackdown. China public security bureau definitely would not lie or overstate the figures. So if 40,000 get caught a few hundred thousand still running is plausible
Exactly…. And there are still many who believed the hundreds of thousands are a lie.
Thanks for the information. Love your truth report and caring to advice for your viewers on the risk to go to Thailand👍🙏❤.
Much appreciated
It is not fake news. It was in CNA news after this video.
Cna = CIA news agency la. U got to hv critical thinking.
@@deepone5005if you cannot trust CNA, then you might as well not trust any news out there.
@1m65 U can trust CNA, that is your propaganda again? Do u know CNA is also called CIA News Agency by locals? Do u know why? And did CNA dare publish the CommsRisk fig of 300,000 and USIP ( funded by CONGRESS) 500,000? STOP SPREADING FAKE NEWS!
@@1m65 You haven't prove the 300,000 fig u cited from sources Commsrisk and Congress sponsored USIP. U blindly spread from those sources without doing homework ,Mr Lu?Yet exhorting people to trust CNA. What is your agenda? U ain't just a simple content creator, Mr Lu.
@@1m65 u appear to be spreading false info and alarm. Why?
Mr. Loo the risk is very high. I would rather take your advice.
Your statement that “Chinese kill more Chinese” is over simplistic. One cannot lump civil wars etc into the calculation. During the communist early days, some economic errors were made, compounded with natural famine, causing quite a bit of suffering, but you must include the effect of foreign blockades etc into the discussion. Invaders are invaders, even causing a single death is too many.
Ancient Chinese torture methods were the worst
You missed my point totally. The point is historically, Chinese has no qualms go after Chinese. So stop thinking that there is cultural or racial loyalty among our Chinese community.
@1m65 As I also commented, do you expect China to join the Myanmar civil war? To rescue it's nationals, probably will need to send troops in.
@@Leongchor No one's asking China to "join the Myanmar civil war." How about starting with shutting down the flow of communications and internet services from Chinese telcos enabling these scam operations? Or are they "strategically unavoidable" too? And the "economic errors" excuse for mass suffering? Call it what it was: criminal negligence. Blaming foreign blockades while Chinese leaders massacred their own is peak deflection. China builds highly sophisticated military islands and spies network globally, yet "can't stop scams on its doorstep." Talk about selective incompetence.
THERE IS NOT TRAVEL ADVISORY ON THAILAND FROM MFA.
yes that is correct... no advisory from MFA. BUT, i will not risk myself to visit Thailand for this period.
It's good that you clear the doubts and proofing the naysayers wrong.
Haiz….. no choice, too many people with skepticism
Great video. 100% agreed with your analysis
My scam calls definitely increased after my visit to China in Nov 24. The callers spoke very good mandarin to the extent that I did not understand some terms used and they even wanted to help "take over" to show me what they wanted me to do. I just ignored the calls. In recent weeks, SG Police reported some people lost $$$ to scammers. Always to on guard and do not think one is smarter and will not fall prey. Be safe rather than sorry.
many china citizen display in their own homeland and in small village in china, not much help are given to find them. how can govt willing to help found them in other country so far away
Don't you know that ccp got a leg in this？
Confirmed that it is under belt and road with the inferior primary school mind xi jinxing
He donno la. Ask him, how many person in China goes missing annually?
There is a big difference in killing from civil war or rebellion in a country and Chinese being killed by Japanese in a war of aggression ! Hope you know the difference BUT i really believe you dont ! Too proud to see what KIASU like you choose to see !
You missed my point totally. The point is historically, Chinese has no qualms go after Chinese. So stop thinking that there is cultural or racial loyalty among our Chinese community.
thanks for the awareness
Your chinese language....very fluent.
Ha, I might get targeted if I go to Myanmar or Thailand. That said, I am still not fluent enough to engage in a telephone conversation to scam others in mandarin.
300K is like the whole Ang Moh Kio?
China hv send police to save those ib Cambodia. Myanmar may be a bit difficult as the rebels are involved.
Nah. Some CCP are involved. Forget it.
You can add the point that the Myanmar junta government a vety good friend of china has lost 50% of the country to the rebels. China punishing or humiliating their 'good friend' can cause the whole myanmar junta to collapsed
Saw in local malaysian newspapers victims ' families appealing government for help and managed to save some after ransom monies been paid
辛苦你了大哥Loo 先生，，资料丰富
不敢当。谢谢支持
@@1m65 th-cam.com/video/UTx0M4wKLwA/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Y2jzoRpK5m_vVfN-
多了解其他you tube
Now not so safe anymore after so many thing happen ☹️
Hi Mr Loo good evening 👍
Good evening!
U are spot on Mr Loo.
Give you a like 👍
Thank u very much 😊
No smoke without fire. I am sure there is something to that effect though it may not be of that significant.
Crap report from equally crap western media.
How is it that a video supposedly about human trafficking ended up with so much mention about Chinese killing Chinese and Japanese kill less Chinese?
Many missed my point totally. The point is historically, Chinese has no qualms go after Chinese, not so much who killed more Chinese.
So many of the commentators should stop thinking that there is cultural or racial loyalty among our Chinese community.
according to some other news, they have doubled the space / buildings recently so they are targeting a lot more people to "work" there. Earmarking a concert audience is not surprising. Power, internet are from where?? Also, so difficult to withdraw / transfer money in that country now so why are huge scammed sums allowed to transfer out now?
Becoz 王星is a celebrity he is lucky you are right
Should warn people who are looking for high paying jobs in the region. It should not affect tourists. They should interview those who hv been rescued to know the real situation
Tourists are kidnapped as well.
There's no smoke without fire. Of course 300k means a lot of victims. U are stating the obvious and conveniently u riding on this hot issue.
Good w a history lesson
I still believe that tourists in Thailand are safe. So far we did not know any case of tourists being kidnapped.
"Airing Dirty Laundry" should be included as the 37th Stratagem of the Chinese.
Media > Police
I realised Podocarpus is als expensive in Australia too, $3k. I really don’t have this kind of money to put into a plant
Are you based in Australia?
I support u . Thanks
Don’t go alone to Thailand is safe
Ironically, the victims went as a large group 😂
We should leave it the Singapore government to advise Singaporeans whether is it save to transfer to Thailand or China. Knowing the US government spending hundreds of millions educating the medias to manufacture stories on China, we should take those stories with a pinch of salts knowing the geopolitical rivalry between the 2 giants.
Lol...😂
USD1.6 billion many Chinese Assmerican joint in just report bad news about China easy money
The victims also thought they wouldn’t be so suay until it’s too late. There was even a movie in China about this.
The risk is real ; and is a clear and present danger .. and it’s a good public service announcement ….. but of course beyond altruistic motivations, monetary returns from TH-cam’s is also part of the equation for you by sensationalising this issue….
Lets not overeact go overboard into false paranoid like typical kiasu sg..be level headed, rational not emotional..be mindful n in context...
2024年有部电影《孤注一掷》由真实故事改编的，推荐给大家看。
fully agree......
just sidetalk...dunno why mr loo plant photocarpus which
is only nice to see...? if plant a row of 8 papaya trees, will have papaya to eat...
I no time to take care of the fruit trees, and they attract a lot of pest
Mr Loo this is so scary right …….😮🫢
Indeed!
i believe 300,000..
If u have had a blain, prove it.
1m65 in.his elements defying gravity
The Nanking Massacre and the horrible unit 731 experiments are totally incomparable in brutality compared with wars. How can you actually compare war with massacre? Regardless of the number, wars happened a lot in the past all over the world and if you totalled the number of war victims because of domestic wars throughout the Chinese history of course it is huge since China has 5000 years of history. But it's totally different from massacre where Japan brutally killed & tortured defenseless civilians (infants, pregnant women, elderlies), not in war but for their maniac pleasure. It's totally demonic. Totally different in nature and incomparable. For someone to think that the Nanking massacre is far better compared to wars, I'm speechless. Nazi's holocaust is remembered for a reason.
Your moral posturing is as hollow as your logic. Yes, the Nanking Massacre was a horrific atrocity, no one's disputing that. But your attempt to dismiss centuries of Chinese-on-Chinese slaughter as "just wars" while selectively demonizing others reeks of hypocrisy. Defenseless civilians were also killed en masse during the Cultural Revolution, the Great Leap Forward, and countless other "non-war" CCP campaigns. Were those "totally different in nature"? Were those deaths somehow less tragic because they were caused by Chinese leaders instead of foreign invaders?
And while you conveniently invoke the Holocaust, remember this: Germany owned up to its past, while your CCP whitewashes its atrocities, erecting Mao’s portrait in Tiananmen Square as if the millions who perished under his rule never existed. Save the righteous indignation, it’s not convincing coming from someone excusing the crimes of a regime that killed its own with the same brutality it accuses others of.
"Our SG Gov will go all out to recuse us" You think they give a shit about us? 🤣🤣🤣
Sure. SG Goverment (MFA) are standby to support. So report your traveling with MFA. The MFA can provide assistance if you need it during an emergency. At least they had been set to do that, therefore it was formally advised.
th-cam.com/video/11WqF2w-nGo/w-d-xo.html This may give you a idea why KK park is so powerful. Even if Sg folks are kidnapped there, Sg govt is probably going to be helpless too.
As long as one practice common sense. You will be safe in Bangkok. I was based there for 2years for work. Very frequently I will go sightseeing up country and go nightspot etc. Not once I felt threaten.
I went Bangkok for new year. quite safe. the kueh at Talat Phlu very nice 😋
I never listen to Mr Loo ..These people are really sickening .
What r u doing here....?
Most working in the center went there willingly.
Please dont watch this video cos he doesn't knows what he is talking about. He just wants viewership thats all. Thats y he ranting nonsense. No facts n figure to substantiate
th-cam.com/video/vlvvWnSvuQY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=v52hECnl9Gtiv_XP
th-cam.com/video/sSkAbDbvVOY/w-d-xo.html
This is killing me 😂.....all this started because you didn't do your research before making the video.
Kidnapped indeed.....they were not kidnapped whilst in Thailand. They were tricked into Myanmar on the basis of a job. When they got there, their passports were taken.
Instead of admitting your mistake, you make this video to justify the first video.
N yet the 2nd video didn’t vindicate the 1st video…this job scam by syndicates is not new…long ago,,young girls were promised good jobs in America n when they got there, their passports were confiscated n forced into prostitution to pay their airfares n lodgings…it’s still happening today..human trafficking
IF scammer watches this video…Singaporean will be safe as our MANDARIN IS MIXED WITH WATER not original. So Singaporean is out. Safe to visit BKK and wear SG FLAG..use stickers issued during National Day. It works