Mental health awareness is very much required. There are increasing number of patients attending emergency departments of various hospitals with symptoms related to mental disorders about which they are not aware. A good episode.
খুব ভালো। খুব প্রয়োজনীয় একটা episode. 👍👌🙏 তবে ডাক্তারীর যে কোন বিষয় একটা episode এ সম্পূর্ণ হওয়ার মত নয়, বিশেষতঃ তা যদি mental health / psychology / psychiatry হয়। খুব অনুরোধ রইল, এ বিষয়ে শিগ্গিরি আর একটা episode করার। 👍👌🙏
@@Injection_podcast Even after watching podcast with psychologist I feel humiliated as a Psychologist. This video is full of misinformation and hatred against psychologists.
How sad to see a qualified psychiatrist talk in such a casual way about mental health and mental illness and utter such horrifying nonsense about mental health profession and other mental health professionals! It is sad to see that being a pass out from CIP, one can talk about psychologists in this way. I wonder what IPS, CPSI and other psychiatrists and mental health professionals would say about such a podcast if they listen to it
Psychologist kono osudh prescribe korte pare naa, keu kore thakle seta sompurno bay aini, ar psychology porte gele 11-12 a science(physics, Chem, maths) na thakle oo chole, ota arts er subject tai, science noy
At first she requires to gain enough information about the role of "psychologists". "Psychologist der practice korar kotha e na" RCI lisence to khelar chol e issue krche. There are many many paitents who only required psychotherapy not any pharmacological intervention. If this channel feels the need to educate layman regarding their mental health awareness please bring someone who is aware of the whole picture not just "amra psychiatrist tai ekmatro kaaj kri bakira to just helping hands , icche korchena tai psychologist ese test kre dilo."
Didi joint entrance ta mone diye diley r ektuu khatley eto likhtey hoto na.. Bujhi. Mekta kharap laga kaj toh koreg.. Mbbs degree ta toh r nei.. Obosso talent o ekta factor.. Setao oneker thakey na.. Tokhn frastu kheye gyan jharey..
@@chakrabortysushant1209 ei j apni thik jeta korlen ekhne seta ke bole "na jene montobbo kore honu howa" bhobdro bhbe r apnar khetre likhte icche holo na toh apni gie apnar frustration onno jaygy jharun na. Ami ki kno ki krbo tar advice apnar theke to kew chayni. Ar ami amr field of work nie misinformation dkhle obossoi tar protest korbo. Ps- amr talent ache nki seta pore dekhben next time theke ektu guchie lekhar chesta korben porte besh osubidha e hoy.
@@chakrabortysushant1209 neet krleo je unar laab hoto na ei context e..... Clinical psychologist je neet diye hte pare na.... Ar psychiatrist ar clinical psychologist er kaajer mddhye je different and both equally important. Ebong eta niye dui community e khub aware... (Kyakjn chara)..... Baki jodi apnar er por o mne hye ekhane apnar kichu blar ache.... Apni comfortably blte paren seta.... Amra detail conversation krte raji achi on this matter.... I assure you je duto community thekei professionals ra thakbe.... Clinical Psychologist and Psychiatrists. Please feel free, we are happy to discuss...
This is ridiculous. Full of misinformation. I think she should read and know about clinical psychology and role of clinical psychologist. Psychologists can refer to psychiatrist if they feel so. Sad to hear such comments from a DPM Psychiatrist.
Psychologist ra khali tools deina. Clinical Psychologist der one of the main kaj holo diagnosis reach korte Psychiatrist ke help kora. Tar sathe sathe, tara therapy koren jar bibhinno dhoron hoi. CBT, jeta uni mention korchen seta just ekta type of therapy. Aro onek ache. Ek ekta 12 to 16 sessions dhore chole. Tar beshi o lagte pare. Please Madam get yourself updated with what's happening in your own field. Too sad to see this coming from such an experienced Psychiatrist.
Amr sondeho uni mental illness gulo nie valo kore porechen kina.. Khuby misleading kotha gulo.. And mental health er bepare erkm video onker pokhhe khotikarok.
Hello injection team , you are doing something extraordinary. Ei program ta mainstream media y asa uchit. Jodi na ase tomrai amader notun mainstream media. Chaliye jao. Please themo na.
Madam, Amar khub kharap lagche bolte kintu etai sottyi je apni prochur bhul kotha ei video te bolchen , ebong shadharon manush sheta kei dhrubo sottyo bole bichar korchen. Ami ekjon sarkari medical college r clinical psychologist. M.Phil name ekti course hoi jekhane clinical psychologist ra case history, MSE, psychometry, psychotherapy kore thaken. Research bole je je kono pt r khetre, sob cheye bhalo folafol tokhoni hoi jodi medicine ebong psychotherapy/ counselling eksathe chole. Arekti kotha referral kintu psychologist ba clinical psychologist o korte pare, erom kono kotha nei, je kono client ba pt shorashori kono clinical psychologist er kache aste parbe na. Amader she training thake jate kore proyojon porle psychiatrist der kache amrao refer kore di... private set up e Hae sarkari hospital e manishik bibhag r ticket kore seta psychiatrist r kache jai...pt r counselling proyojon hole seta psychiatrist refer kore deben. Arekta kotha madam, counselling ekhon ekta umbrella term hoe geche...pt ra ei shobdo ta byabohar kore eta bojhanor jonye je tara karo sathe kotha bolte chai, tara chan je moner kotha gulo dhele karur sathe jate alochona kora jai.eta te rege jabar kichu nei. Jodi mone hoi pt r bojhar khomota ache, take refer kora jete pare tate keu boro keu choto hoi na.. Ar jodi apnar mone hoi je pt r bojhar khomota ( insight- kharap ba poor) tahole pore psychotherapy te refer korte paren. Apni etao bollen je OCD r prognosis poor. Erom nirasha jonok kotha barta bolle to pt rai hotash hobe. Apni nije bolchen suicide barche, kintu etuku insight apnar nei je ei rokom sweeping overgeneralization korle to pt rai suicidal hoe jete pare. Ocd pt der jodi shurutai diagnosis kora jai, chikitsha taratari kora jai, occupational stability, family support thake tobe exposure and response prevention therapy die kintu onektai manageable jagai asha jai.. ami nijer erom besh kichu manusher paychotherapy korechi... tara bhalo fol o peyeche. Obosshoi er age bola dorkar je tader kintu psychiatric medication o cholchilo.. phole credit ta puro health care team r , eka kono psychiatrist ba clinical psychologist r noi. Madam apni nijei nijer kotha contradict korchen, ek somoi apni bolchen je psychiatrist ra clinical psychologist der refer kore, opor dike apni bolchen je marital counselling e jodi dekha jai je kono ekjon r paranoid schizophrenia ache , jar jonye tar bibahe nana somosya hocche, swami ke sondeho korche , tobe clinical psychologist o psychiatrist ke mediciner refer kore dite pare.. Seta amra projon porle refer o kore thaki...pt dekhe thik korte hoi je pharmacotherapy orthat oshudh naki psychotherapy primary mode of treatment Gramer ebong shohorer manush r modhye apni jerom parthokko korlen, je amader thakuma r amole a bhat chule hath dhuten, E i je OCD r bohiprokash, se kintu rural areas/ towns e ekhono ache, Etho sokri r byapar, ebong seta suburban areas e bankura bishnupur purulia, etc ( kenona amar experience r bhitti te bolchi, ami okhankar sarkari hospital e achi) te, bhalo middle class ebong upper middle class e ekhono ache.. Kintu chitiksha korale ashar alo ache... Apni bolchen, diabetes gorib borolok der eki thake, kintu psychiatry te tar financial condition oboshoi tar symptomatology, chitiksha sob kichu r opor i probhab felbe kenona manoshok somosya bio- psy- social model e hoi, mane genetic charao psychological ebong shamajik orthat social karone hoe thakbe eta ke apni ograjyo horlen kibhabe je apni bolchen 90% mental illness genetics r basis e hocche, tar mane shekhaneo amader kono hath nei, kenona genetics control er baire jetao kina ekebarei bhul.. ekhon prochur manusher family history of illness na thakleo ei pressure r jibon e tara manoshik bharshamyo harie felechen chap e r fole. Sorbo sheshe ami Dr Indrani Chatterjee je bolbo je apnar hathe onek khomota , sheta erom bhabe bhul bhal montobyo kore, health care team r proyojoneo ta ke oswikar korben na ,tate aam jonota R udbignota aro barbe. Ami ei podcase r organizer der bolbo je bach bichar kore jate tara medical fraternity r memeber der aanen, ar jate bosta pocha 50 bochor ager dharona nie jate manusher modhye bhranto dharona r basha jate na badhan... Expert r background check kore jate take ana hoi kenona emni mental health awareness khubi flawed ar media influenced .. seta aro coloured hoe gele amader gota bongo somaj odhyopoton r dike egie jabe... dhoirjo dhore porar jonyo oshoshkho dhonyobad dorshok ebong srota bondhuder.
Didi mon diye joint entrace ta diley r ektu khatley eto line likhtey hoto na.. Bujhi ekta kharap laga toh thakey after all mbbs degree ta toh r ho lo na..
Jara "ekdom shadharon manush" tader jonno apnara etota smplify kore bole dilen je "nije theke shidhhanto niye psychologist er kache chole jabena na". Eta puropuri bhul. Psychologist der kache directly jawa jai tar jonno Psychiatrist er permission lagena. Clinical psychologists have their own registration number to practice as an independent professional. Misinformation er churanto.
@@ArkadeepSaha-cg4zw ekdm e thik..... Ar eram practice hyeoche jekhane psychologist ra medicine prescribe kreche.... Jeta ekdm e bhul....tader against eo action neowar approach cholche...... Kintu psychologist ar clinical psychologist er mddhye difference ache.... Clinical psychologist ra trained, licensed.... Ar tara mental health professionals jara authorised by RCI to independently diagnose mental health conditions and apply psychosocial methods of intervention..... Amar mne hye apni practicing doctor.....apni Mental Health act ta pore dekhte paren...... Er bade evidence based practice and effective intervention for most psychiatric disorders.... Etao pore dekhte paren..... Most RCTs tar effectiveness, especially CBT te ar pharmacotherapy te kemn...... Sb available books e , internet e, various research papers & articles e. Sbar eto kichu blar karon o etai je clinical psychologists have the authority to practice, have registration BUT cannot prescribe medication at any cost....
Sir, Speech therapy niye akta podcast chai. Onek er totlamo thake ki kore thik hoi or is it even curable or not. Please sir I would be of immense help.
I would like to appreciate your (Mr. Sayan & Dr. Kushal) initiative to spread awareness about healthcare in an entertaining manner. Kintu bishoy ta holo ei video ta to sotti I khub hasyokor hoye uthechhe Mental Health Professional der jonyo. Apnara kono video upload korar age ektu speaker ja ja bolchhen setar validity ta ektu check kore nile apnader channel er description box e j AIM ta lekha seta nischoi puron hobe, nahole kichhu manser kachhe kichhu bhul tothyo pouche jabe, r kichhu manus sudhu entertained hbe... Apnader channel er to khub I bhalo subscription number. I would like to request you to please share valid content with your 28k subscribers. 🙏
health related podcast banale anek benefits hoto dada.. bortoman jibone kaj ar porasonar moddhe nijer health er dike gurutto amra anekei diyna, kono exercise o korina.. so ei bisoye normal working man ba students ra jaara junk food khai, barir theke dure ba baire thake, health er proti jotno nayna, tara kichu na holeo atleast kon kon bisoye nojor debe ki debna, ei related ekta episode banao sayanda.. please
In November 2023, NITI Aayog notified that the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 has announced the discontinuation of the award of all M. Phil. courses across the subjects. Additionally, Non medico psychology students are not permitted to prescribe drugs, they are only good for counselling which anyway can be done by a Medico psychiatrist
The name mphil has been replaced by MPsy. That's not discontinuation, that's modification. And psychologists' role is not limited to counselling. They are trained to provide evidence based psychotherapies and do psychometric assessment which anyway can not be done by all psychiatrists. Not all psychiatrists are trained to do these two because it's not usually part of their curriculum and training program. Get your facts correct before commenting on public forum.
একজন শিশুরোগ বিশেষজ্ঞ চিকিৎসকের আগমন করানো হোক, তাকে প্রশ্ন করা হোক, কথা না বলা একদম দুধের শিশুর রোগ কী করে বুঝতে পারেন? শিশুর ডাক্তারের কাছে বয়স্ক ব্যক্তি ডাক্তার দেখাতে গেলে, তার মনের অবস্থা কেমন হয়?😂😂😂
@@atithiganguly1625 It is misleading in the sense that she did not give a true impression of the role of a clinical psychologist or a psychologist in her words. If you know what are the roles and responsibilities of a clinical psychologist then you would have understood why so many people are commenting that she is giving misleading information or may be deliberately trying to defame other mental health professions other than Psychiatry. Psychiatry is neither the ONLY mental health profession existing presently nor that other mental health professionals act as the assistant of a psychiatrist, which she is trying to imply through her words.
Dr madam katha bolar dharon baro damva prakash pelo. Madam aapni so called educated bole gramer manus ar sahorer manuse vived korben na. Sayan vaya tumi ever green. Ar last akta katha boli ai madam doctor so called uneducated person der tax er paisai kam besi 35 lakhs govt support e doctor hoyechen.
One question jaglo mone tar modhe ak ta holo amr ak femal friend o ki6u korte gele ba Karo sathe kotha bolte gele a ta vabe je loke ki vabbe oke opoman korbe na to. Loker sathe miste aktu time Lage sobar sathe frankly miste o pare na guti kojon r sathe mese a rokom a ta ki problem na ki normal.plz ar ans ta next debe . A ta jante parle khub upokar hobe. thank you injection ❤
Being a licensed clinical psychologist, I am really appalled to see a professionally qualified psychiatrist talking about psychologists in such a condescending manner..Madam please arm yourself with proper knowledge before blatantly attacking or shaming other allied professionals..Psychologists are certainly NOT a second fiddle to psychiatrists and when we work collaboratively as a team, giving up our inherent biases, the patient benefits the most..Hope from now on she will get her facts correct before commenting on public forum about such socially significant and sensitive issues..
Joint entrance diye rank korey mbbs e vorti na hoye psychology niye porey esv gyan deben.. Valo korechen uni bolechen. Ami nijey psychologist er kachey frst e giye khuub suffer hoyechi.. What she said is exactly true. Frst go to a psychiatrist and if needed he/she will tell wheather to consult a psychologist or not
She even don't know what psychologists are. There are different specialization in psychology. If she don't know she should learn before commenting. This episode should be dropped as it is full of misinformation. She even don't know what psychotherapy is.
Ei video ta bhul tothye bhora. Report korte badhyo hochhi. Psychologist ra psychiatrist der assistant na. Bujhte pachhi speaker madam er nijer mbbs er gorbo ache kintu tai bole onyo professional der choto kora ki thik? Madam er psychologist profession ta niye bindumatro idea nei. Clinical psychologist der sompurno authority ache, skill training education sob ache practice korar. R ei license ta india government tader dichhe. Sadharon manush der bolbo tara nischinte psychologist ba psychiatrist je kno professional der kache jete paren. Tara proyojon bujhle nischoi joruri referral korben. Mental health er 4 te guruttopurno pillar ache- psychiatrist, psychologists, psychiatric social worker, psychiatric nurse. Protyeker role r responsibility alada. Keu karor enemy ba replacement noy. Sob pillar jokhon eksathe milemishe kaj koren tokhoni ekjon manush puropuri sustho hote paren. Madam eto awareness er kotha bolchen edike mental health er ekta guruttopurno pillar ke opoman kore gelen. Ei video ta withdraw kora uchit. Channel jara chalan tader bolbo ektu comment section ta porun. Etojon manush keno video ta ke misleading bolchen seta ekbar bojhar chesta korun. Bechhe bechhe sudhu sei comment gulo like korechen je gulo te compliment lekha ache. Adou apnara awareness baranor jonyo channel khulechen na nijeder view baranor jonyo seta niyei doubt hochhe. Na jana ta oporadh na, jiges korun, nijeder educate korun, jene jaben. Na jene ba kom jene erokom jinis ekta public forum e upload kore r manusher bibhranti baraben na. Channel r madam dujoneri psychologist fraternity ke open apology dewa uchit.
Ek hocche je tar occupational , Social and personal field e impairment hobe...due to the mental problem and 2nd Subjective well being and quality of life will be affected. If someone fulfills any of the above mentioned criteria they can see professional help.
Ridiculously misleading video with full of wrong information. She has 0 idea about what psychologists do. Psychologists are not psychiatrists' assistants. They are independent professional with training, skill, expertise and license. The speaker has also made racist and classist comments. This video is not only misleading, it's disrespectful and insulting.
I totally agree with Sudipa mam. Please reach out to someone who is empathetic and unbiased towards members of the mental health professional. She herself feels the burden of seeing hundreds of pts in ESI hospital, but amidst them she gives 30 mins to counselling family members of pts with Dissociative Disorder. Madam, I would advise you to delegate the work responsibilities (related to Psychotherapy and psychometry) to clinical psychologists, thereby helping you to actually do your own technical job of being a psychiatrist, and also not violating boundaries at the work place. This is how work is done in government set ups and private set ups , otherwise I am sorry to say, she herself would end up experiencing clinical stress and anxiety.
ম্যাডামের মনে বোধহয় ক্লিনিক্যাল সাইকোলজিস্টদের প্রতি যথেষ্ট বায়াস আছে। সাইকোলজিক্যাল ইন্টারভেনশন সম্বন্ধে আপনার মনে এতো ট্যাবু কেন, আর ক্লিনিক্যাল সাইকোলজিস্টদের এবং অন্যান্য মেন্টাল হেল্থ ওয়ার্কারদের ছোটো করার দরকারটা কেন হলো, বুঝলাম না।
Psychologist kono osudh prescribe korte pare naa, keu kore thakle seta sompurno bay aini, ar psychology porte gele 11-12 a science(physics, Chem, maths) na thakle oo chole, ota arts er subject tai, science noy
Uni to psychologist der apoman Koren ni..uni j kotha gulo bole6en segulo sotti kotha..psychiatrists are doctors psychologists are not doctors who help psychiatrists..
@abhisekgangopadhyay8681 kono nimnomaer prochar uni korenni. Uni jeta bolechen thiki bolechen. Eta hoyto apnar ba onek psychologist der digest hobe karon karon etai truth je psychologists are not doctors. They don't have registration number. So accept the truth.
Psychologist kono osudh prescribe korte pare naa, keu kore thakle seta sompurno bay aini, ar psychology porte gele 11-12 a science(physics, Chem, maths) na thakle oo chole, ota arts er subject tai, science noy
Shits like this get sm views n all....n real stuff gets like 100 views. This is the very reason how facts get distorted and popular and distorted and popular and distorted and popular.
ম্যাডাম একজন সাইক্রিয়াটিস্ট হিসাবে খুব ভালো ভাবে মনরোগ এর বিষয়টি বোঝালেন। আপনাদের অনুরোধ করবো। নামকরা কোন সাইকোলজিস্ট কে আনুন। সাইকোলজিস্ট রা ব্যাঙের ছাতার মত গজিয়ে উঠছে এর বিষয় টা কোন সাইকোলজিস্ট এর কাছ থেকে জানতে পারলে ভালো হয়।
রেফার সাইকোলিজস্ট ও করতে পারে একথা কি উনি জানেন না? সাইক্রিয়াটিস্ট সাইকোলজিস্ট এই টোটাল প্রক্রিয়া একটি যৌথ প্রক্রিয়া আগেই সাইক্রিয়াটিস্ট দের কাছে যাবেন আর সাইকোলজিস্টদের কাছে যাবেন না একথা বলার কখনোই যুক্তিযুক্ত নয়
প্রথমত অনেক ধন্যবাদ মনোরোগ বিশেষজ্ঞ আনার জন্য।
দাদা ঝারফুক, ভূতে ধরা, দেবতা ভর করা, এইগুলো নিয়ে মোনোরোগ বিশেষজ্ঞ পডকাসট চাই চাই
Great Episode and a much-needed one. Sayan da and Kushal da thank you so much for doing such episodes
মেম কে আরো অনেক বার আসার অপেক্ষায় রইলাম। ধন্যবাদ। খুব উপকার পাওয়া গেল
জায়গায় জায়গায় পাগল বলা, এবং অ্যাঙ্কররাও যখন পাগল নিয়ে মজা করছেন, তখন সেটাকে কারেক্ট না করে এনকারেজ করা.. এটা কি সাইকায়াট্রিস্টের উচিত?
Apni age poru ta bhalo kore sunben
Did you even watch the full video, my man?
mam khub valo bolechen, psychiatrist er kachei first asa uchit je kono mental issue nie
I have thoroughly enjoyed the episode.
Mental health awareness is very much required. There are increasing number of patients attending emergency departments of various hospitals with symptoms related to mental disorders about which they are not aware. A good episode.
th-cam.com/video/vfvUP0lY43o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aLOtx_ybwdCXaOIC
বেশ ভালো। তবে যেন মনে হচ্ছে কোনো প্রশ্নেরই গভীরে যাওয়া হচ্ছে না।
ডাক্তারের কথাগুলো খুবই thought provoking।
This is a very necessary episode and a wonderful effort .
খুব ভালো। খুব প্রয়োজনীয় একটা episode. 👍👌🙏 তবে ডাক্তারীর যে কোন বিষয় একটা episode এ সম্পূর্ণ হওয়ার মত নয়, বিশেষতঃ তা যদি mental health / psychology / psychiatry হয়।
খুব অনুরোধ রইল, এ বিষয়ে শিগ্গিরি আর একটা episode করার।
👍👌🙏
th-cam.com/video/vfvUP0lY43o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aLOtx_ybwdCXaOIC
@@Injection_podcast Even after watching podcast with psychologist I feel humiliated as a Psychologist. This video is full of misinformation and hatred against psychologists.
Tips to the psychiatrists: Start compeeting 'Binamulye chokh porikkha" and start your own "Binamulye moner kotha"
Khub valo laglo podcast ta ….aro hok …. Khub valo initiative…..🫡
How sad to see a qualified psychiatrist talk in such a casual way about mental health and mental illness and utter such horrifying nonsense about mental health profession and other mental health professionals! It is sad to see that being a pass out from CIP, one can talk about psychologists in this way.
I wonder what IPS, CPSI and other psychiatrists and mental health professionals would say about such a podcast if they listen to it
Psychologist kono osudh prescribe korte pare naa, keu kore thakle seta sompurno bay aini, ar psychology porte gele 11-12 a science(physics, Chem, maths) na thakle oo chole, ota arts er subject tai, science noy
i guess there is still no place for woke mentality in india.
@@ArkadeepSaha-cg4zwchup kor
At first she requires to gain enough information about the role of "psychologists".
"Psychologist der practice korar kotha e na" RCI lisence to khelar chol e issue krche.
There are many many paitents who only required psychotherapy not any pharmacological intervention.
If this channel feels the need to educate layman regarding their mental health awareness please bring someone who is aware of the whole picture not just "amra psychiatrist tai ekmatro kaaj kri bakira to just helping hands , icche korchena tai psychologist ese test kre dilo."
Didi joint entrance ta mone diye diley r ektuu khatley eto likhtey hoto na.. Bujhi. Mekta kharap laga kaj toh koreg.. Mbbs degree ta toh r nei.. Obosso talent o ekta factor.. Setao oneker thakey na.. Tokhn frastu kheye gyan jharey..
@@chakrabortysushant1209 ei j apni thik jeta korlen ekhne seta ke bole "na jene montobbo kore honu howa" bhobdro bhbe r apnar khetre likhte icche holo na toh apni gie apnar frustration onno jaygy jharun na. Ami ki kno ki krbo tar advice apnar theke to kew chayni. Ar ami amr field of work nie misinformation dkhle obossoi tar protest korbo.
Ps- amr talent ache nki seta pore dekhben next time theke ektu guchie lekhar chesta korben porte besh osubidha e hoy.
@@chakrabortysushant1209 neet krleo je unar laab hoto na ei context e..... Clinical psychologist je neet diye hte pare na.... Ar psychiatrist ar clinical psychologist er kaajer mddhye je different and both equally important. Ebong eta niye dui community e khub aware... (Kyakjn chara)..... Baki jodi apnar er por o mne hye ekhane apnar kichu blar ache.... Apni comfortably blte paren seta.... Amra detail conversation krte raji achi on this matter.... I assure you je duto community thekei professionals ra thakbe.... Clinical Psychologist and Psychiatrists. Please feel free, we are happy to discuss...
th-cam.com/video/vfvUP0lY43o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aLOtx_ybwdCXaOIC
Dhonnobaad onurodh rakhar jonno🙏
Ami prochur bar psychiatrist dekhiyechi, just to stay fit in this chaos world
This is ridiculous. Full of misinformation. I think she should read and know about clinical psychology and role of clinical psychologist. Psychologists can refer to psychiatrist if they feel so. Sad to hear such comments from a DPM Psychiatrist.
Psychologist ra khali tools deina.
Clinical Psychologist der one of the main kaj holo diagnosis reach korte Psychiatrist ke help kora. Tar sathe sathe, tara therapy koren jar bibhinno dhoron hoi. CBT, jeta uni mention korchen seta just ekta type of therapy. Aro onek ache. Ek ekta 12 to 16 sessions dhore chole. Tar beshi o lagte pare.
Please Madam get yourself updated with what's happening in your own field.
Too sad to see this coming from such an experienced Psychiatrist.
Amr sondeho uni mental illness gulo nie valo kore porechen kina.. Khuby misleading kotha gulo.. And mental health er bepare erkm video onker pokhhe khotikarok.
th-cam.com/video/vfvUP0lY43o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aLOtx_ybwdCXaOIC
দারুন episode
খুব সুন্দর বুঝিয়েছেন।
খুব ভালো লাগলো এই পর্ব টা।
Great initiative sayan da..
Keep it up..
All the best ❤❤
Rural people manei Uneducated?..eta kamon mentality?..madam er counciling dorkar
খুবই দরকার..
Thik ......
eto negative vabe nao keno sobkichu?
She is talking about majority ,there are also many illiterate in urban area
Hello injection team , you are doing something extraordinary. Ei program ta mainstream media y asa uchit. Jodi na ase tomrai amader notun mainstream media. Chaliye jao. Please themo na.
Madam,
Amar khub kharap lagche bolte kintu etai sottyi je apni prochur bhul kotha ei video te bolchen , ebong shadharon manush sheta kei dhrubo sottyo bole bichar korchen. Ami ekjon sarkari medical college r clinical psychologist. M.Phil name ekti course hoi jekhane clinical psychologist ra case history, MSE, psychometry, psychotherapy kore thaken. Research bole je je kono pt r khetre, sob cheye bhalo folafol tokhoni hoi jodi medicine ebong psychotherapy/ counselling eksathe chole.
Arekti kotha referral kintu psychologist ba clinical psychologist o korte pare, erom kono kotha nei, je kono client ba pt shorashori kono clinical psychologist er kache aste parbe na. Amader she training thake jate kore proyojon porle psychiatrist der kache amrao refer kore di... private set up e
Hae sarkari hospital e manishik bibhag r ticket kore seta psychiatrist r kache jai...pt r counselling proyojon hole seta psychiatrist refer kore deben.
Arekta kotha madam, counselling ekhon ekta umbrella term hoe geche...pt ra ei shobdo ta byabohar kore eta bojhanor jonye je tara karo sathe kotha bolte chai, tara chan je moner kotha gulo dhele karur sathe jate alochona kora jai.eta te rege jabar kichu nei. Jodi mone hoi pt r bojhar khomota ache, take refer kora jete pare tate keu boro keu choto hoi na..
Ar jodi apnar mone hoi je pt r bojhar khomota ( insight- kharap ba poor) tahole pore psychotherapy te refer korte paren.
Apni etao bollen je OCD r prognosis poor. Erom nirasha jonok kotha barta bolle to pt rai hotash hobe. Apni nije bolchen suicide barche, kintu etuku insight apnar nei je ei rokom sweeping overgeneralization korle to pt rai suicidal hoe jete pare. Ocd pt der jodi shurutai diagnosis kora jai, chikitsha taratari kora jai, occupational stability, family support thake tobe exposure and response prevention therapy die kintu onektai manageable jagai asha jai.. ami nijer erom besh kichu manusher paychotherapy korechi... tara bhalo fol o peyeche. Obosshoi er age bola dorkar je tader kintu psychiatric medication o cholchilo.. phole credit ta puro health care team r , eka kono psychiatrist ba clinical psychologist r noi.
Madam apni nijei nijer kotha contradict korchen, ek somoi apni bolchen je psychiatrist ra clinical psychologist der refer kore, opor dike apni bolchen je marital counselling e jodi dekha jai je kono ekjon r paranoid schizophrenia ache , jar jonye tar bibahe nana somosya hocche, swami ke sondeho korche , tobe clinical psychologist o psychiatrist ke mediciner refer kore dite pare..
Seta amra projon porle refer o kore thaki...pt dekhe thik korte hoi je pharmacotherapy orthat oshudh naki psychotherapy primary mode of treatment
Gramer ebong shohorer manush r modhye apni jerom parthokko korlen, je amader thakuma r amole a bhat chule hath dhuten,
E i je OCD r bohiprokash, se kintu rural areas/ towns e ekhono ache,
Etho sokri r byapar, ebong seta suburban areas e bankura bishnupur purulia, etc ( kenona amar experience r bhitti te bolchi, ami okhankar sarkari hospital e achi) te, bhalo middle class ebong upper middle class e ekhono ache..
Kintu chitiksha korale ashar alo ache...
Apni bolchen, diabetes gorib borolok der eki thake, kintu psychiatry te tar financial condition oboshoi tar symptomatology, chitiksha sob kichu r opor i probhab felbe kenona manoshok somosya bio- psy- social model e hoi, mane genetic charao psychological ebong shamajik orthat social karone hoe thakbe eta ke apni ograjyo horlen kibhabe je apni bolchen 90% mental illness genetics r basis e hocche, tar mane shekhaneo amader kono hath nei, kenona genetics control er baire jetao kina ekebarei bhul.. ekhon prochur manusher family history of illness na thakleo ei pressure r jibon e tara manoshik bharshamyo harie felechen chap e r fole.
Sorbo sheshe ami Dr Indrani Chatterjee je bolbo je apnar hathe onek khomota , sheta erom bhabe bhul bhal montobyo kore, health care team r proyojoneo ta ke oswikar korben na ,tate aam jonota
R udbignota aro barbe.
Ami ei podcase r organizer der bolbo je bach bichar kore jate tara medical fraternity r memeber der aanen, ar jate bosta pocha 50 bochor ager dharona nie jate manusher modhye bhranto dharona r basha jate na badhan...
Expert r background check kore jate take ana hoi kenona emni mental health awareness khubi flawed ar media influenced .. seta aro coloured hoe gele amader gota bongo somaj odhyopoton r dike egie jabe... dhoirjo dhore porar jonyo oshoshkho dhonyobad dorshok ebong srota bondhuder.
Khuby sundor explain korechen apni..
Dhonyobad
একদম সহমত
Madam apni bolben apnat sathe ki kore contact korbo..bcz ami last 35 yrs amr maa k nie problem face korchi..
Didi mon diye joint entrace ta diley r ektu khatley eto line likhtey hoto na.. Bujhi ekta kharap laga toh thakey after all mbbs degree ta toh r ho lo na..
important episode indeed
Ajker topic tao jemon serious chilo thik temon ajker podcast tao serious hoye gelo. Olpo chyablamo hole bhaloi lage Dodon Da🌸😁
Jara "ekdom shadharon manush" tader jonno apnara etota smplify kore bole dilen je "nije theke shidhhanto niye psychologist er kache chole jabena na".
Eta puropuri bhul. Psychologist der kache directly jawa jai tar jonno Psychiatrist er permission lagena. Clinical psychologists have their own registration number to practice as an independent professional.
Misinformation er churanto.
Sorry to say kono psychologist kono medicine prescribe korte paren na, seta illegal
@@ArkadeepSaha-cg4zw ekdm e thik..... Ar eram practice hyeoche jekhane psychologist ra medicine prescribe kreche.... Jeta ekdm e bhul....tader against eo action neowar approach cholche...... Kintu psychologist ar clinical psychologist er mddhye difference ache.... Clinical psychologist ra trained, licensed.... Ar tara mental health professionals jara authorised by RCI to independently diagnose mental health conditions and apply psychosocial methods of intervention..... Amar mne hye apni practicing doctor.....apni Mental Health act ta pore dekhte paren...... Er bade evidence based practice and effective intervention for most psychiatric disorders.... Etao pore dekhte paren..... Most RCTs tar effectiveness, especially CBT te ar pharmacotherapy te kemn...... Sb available books e , internet e, various research papers & articles e. Sbar eto kichu blar karon o etai je clinical psychologists have the authority to practice, have registration BUT cannot prescribe medication at any cost....
ধন্যবাদ। অনুরোধ রাখার জন্য
Sir, Speech therapy niye akta podcast chai. Onek er totlamo thake ki kore thik hoi or is it even curable or not. Please sir I would be of immense help.
I would like to appreciate your (Mr. Sayan & Dr. Kushal) initiative to spread awareness about healthcare in an entertaining manner.
Kintu bishoy ta holo ei video ta to sotti I khub hasyokor hoye uthechhe Mental Health Professional der jonyo.
Apnara kono video upload korar age ektu speaker ja ja bolchhen setar validity ta ektu check kore nile apnader channel er description box e j AIM ta lekha seta nischoi puron hobe, nahole kichhu manser kachhe kichhu bhul tothyo pouche jabe, r kichhu manus sudhu entertained hbe...
Apnader channel er to khub I bhalo subscription number. I would like to request you to please share valid content with your 28k subscribers. 🙏
th-cam.com/video/vfvUP0lY43o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aLOtx_ybwdCXaOIC
khubi sundar, research instituter scholar der moddhe ami anek kicu khunje pacchi
Requesting english or bengali subtitles. Makes it easier to watch.
Please invite radiologists Dr sujoy das or Dr Ashok kr moulik or Dr avijit guha majumder
Thank you Sayan da ! ❤❤
Thanks a lot for choosing such topics
Very informative ❤
Very very informative
I'm obsessed with these episodes😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Then you're suffering From OCD😂😂
@@Babaidey77 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
health related podcast banale anek benefits hoto dada.. bortoman jibone kaj ar porasonar moddhe nijer health er dike gurutto amra anekei diyna, kono exercise o korina.. so ei bisoye normal working man ba students ra jaara junk food khai, barir theke dure ba baire thake, health er proti jotno nayna, tara kichu na holeo atleast kon kon bisoye nojor debe ki debna, ei related ekta episode banao sayanda.. please
অসাধারণ
Ai podcast tar opekhahaye chilam...
I am sorry to say that madam is either misinformed about various mental health professionals or she intentionally tried to create a propaganda.
Koto ta vhulvhal information dilen apni. Odvhut. Apni please ektu thikthak information niye asun. MPhil bole ekta degree hoi 2 years er. Sekhne exposure ta puro patient oriented. Odvhut.
In November 2023, NITI Aayog notified that the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 has announced the discontinuation of the award of all M. Phil. courses across the subjects.
Additionally, Non medico psychology students are not permitted to prescribe drugs, they are only good for counselling which anyway can be done by a Medico psychiatrist
@@suchintachakraborty1983 MPhil kono vabhei discontinue kora hoini. Thik information ta aage janun
The name mphil has been replaced by MPsy. That's not discontinuation, that's modification. And psychologists' role is not limited to counselling. They are trained to provide evidence based psychotherapies and do psychometric assessment which anyway can not be done by all psychiatrists. Not all psychiatrists are trained to do these two because it's not usually part of their curriculum and training program. Get your facts correct before commenting on public forum.
দারুণ লাগলো
একজন শিশুরোগ বিশেষজ্ঞ চিকিৎসকের আগমন করানো হোক, তাকে প্রশ্ন করা হোক, কথা না বলা একদম দুধের শিশুর রোগ কী করে বুঝতে পারেন?
শিশুর ডাক্তারের কাছে বয়স্ক ব্যক্তি ডাক্তার দেখাতে গেলে, তার মনের অবস্থা কেমন হয়?😂😂😂
Khub valo laglo madam ❤
anuttama banerjee k anun....uni besh vlo kotha bolen
Khub sundor show...❤❤❤
Darun darun ❤❤❤
Erom content e bangla youtube audience deserve kore....darun❤❤
Amar vlo mone holo na inar kotha barta. Socially Biased mone holo. Kintu ekjon monorog bisesoggo der biased hole thik chikitsa hoina
Ekdom
Misleading video.... Concerned authority should verify the content before the final telecast... TH-cam please remove this video 🙏
Why misleading??
Yes
What made you feel so? Are you jealous of her? As a listener I don't feel it is misleading.
@@atithiganguly1625 It is misleading in the sense that she did not give a true impression of the role of a clinical psychologist or a psychologist in her words. If you know what are the roles and responsibilities of a clinical psychologist then you would have understood why so many people are commenting that she is giving misleading information or may be deliberately trying to defame other mental health professions other than Psychiatry. Psychiatry is neither the ONLY mental health profession existing presently nor that other mental health professionals act as the assistant of a psychiatrist, which she is trying to imply through her words.
Misinformation in the video about Clinical Psychologists and Psychologists.
Dr madam katha bolar dharon baro damva prakash pelo. Madam aapni so called educated bole gramer manus ar sahorer manuse vived korben na. Sayan vaya tumi ever green. Ar last akta katha boli ai madam doctor so called uneducated person der tax er paisai kam besi 35 lakhs govt support e doctor hoyechen.
One question jaglo mone tar modhe ak ta holo amr ak femal friend o ki6u korte gele ba Karo sathe kotha bolte gele a ta vabe je loke ki vabbe oke opoman korbe na to. Loker sathe miste aktu time Lage sobar sathe frankly miste o pare na guti kojon r sathe mese a rokom a ta ki problem na ki normal.plz ar ans ta next debe . A ta jante parle khub upokar hobe. thank you injection ❤
Khub bhalo laglo 👌
Madam r chember kothai plz
Good
Madam kon hospital OPD dekhan plz
Being a licensed clinical psychologist, I am really appalled to see a professionally qualified psychiatrist talking about psychologists in such a condescending manner..Madam please arm yourself with proper knowledge before blatantly attacking or shaming other allied professionals..Psychologists are certainly NOT a second fiddle to psychiatrists and when we work collaboratively as a team, giving up our inherent biases, the patient benefits the most..Hope from now on she will get her facts correct before commenting on public forum about such socially significant and sensitive issues..
Joint entrance diye rank korey mbbs e vorti na hoye psychology niye porey esv gyan deben.. Valo korechen uni bolechen. Ami nijey psychologist er kachey frst e giye khuub suffer hoyechi.. What she said is exactly true. Frst go to a psychiatrist and if needed he/she will tell wheather to consult a psychologist or not
th-cam.com/video/vfvUP0lY43o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aLOtx_ybwdCXaOIC
Do not promote things which are wrong!!!...I don't know how can a psychiatrist's point of view of psychologists are so cheap!....
Jara medical field e nei... Tara purppuro misleading information pelen
Office environment mental stress ta discussion holo na
Ota keu korar sahos pelo naah..as kono remedy nei😂
দারুণ দারুণ দারুণ দারুণ দারুণ দারুণ লাগল
Gramer lok ra oshikhito gorib r sahor er manus bisal sikhito borolok tai to ?
nutrition and mental disorders is not discussed :)
Two dada salut
Guest Dr Indrani mam namaskar
Dr mam address details pl
Next akjon Heart specialist k ano Sayan da.. Sathe ki ki khawa uchit to maintain our heart from the young age eta ask koro
Auto pilot, chat GPT, Gemini esob er nAm sono ni? Keno ekta podcast er oppekhai thakben..nijei dekhe nao
থ্যাংকস
She even don't know what psychologists are. There are different specialization in psychology. If she don't know she should learn before commenting. This episode should be dropped as it is full of misinformation. She even don't know what psychotherapy is.
Ei video ta bhul tothye bhora. Report korte badhyo hochhi. Psychologist ra psychiatrist der assistant na. Bujhte pachhi speaker madam er nijer mbbs er gorbo ache kintu tai bole onyo professional der choto kora ki thik? Madam er psychologist profession ta niye bindumatro idea nei. Clinical psychologist der sompurno authority ache, skill training education sob ache practice korar. R ei license ta india government tader dichhe. Sadharon manush der bolbo tara nischinte psychologist ba psychiatrist je kno professional der kache jete paren. Tara proyojon bujhle nischoi joruri referral korben. Mental health er 4 te guruttopurno pillar ache- psychiatrist, psychologists, psychiatric social worker, psychiatric nurse. Protyeker role r responsibility alada. Keu karor enemy ba replacement noy. Sob pillar jokhon eksathe milemishe kaj koren tokhoni ekjon manush puropuri sustho hote paren. Madam eto awareness er kotha bolchen edike mental health er ekta guruttopurno pillar ke opoman kore gelen. Ei video ta withdraw kora uchit. Channel jara chalan tader bolbo ektu comment section ta porun. Etojon manush keno video ta ke misleading bolchen seta ekbar bojhar chesta korun. Bechhe bechhe sudhu sei comment gulo like korechen je gulo te compliment lekha ache. Adou apnara awareness baranor jonyo channel khulechen na nijeder view baranor jonyo seta niyei doubt hochhe. Na jana ta oporadh na, jiges korun, nijeder educate korun, jene jaben. Na jene ba kom jene erokom jinis ekta public forum e upload kore r manusher bibhranti baraben na. Channel r madam dujoneri psychologist fraternity ke open apology dewa uchit.
It's a team work! Uni help near kotha bolechen. Assistant word apni use korlen!
Psychologist counseling, therapy,assessment korte paren. Medicine dite paren na.
Ami jani j psychiatrist, psychologists, special educators der network/ team ache...onara sobar help nen.
Bojha jacche apnader bebsa te khoti hocche😂
Sir Dr. Hridish narayan chakrabarty sir ke ektu show te anen
Please
Gastrointestinal treatment er opor ekta program
দারুন
Ak Jon ki vabe bujbe se mental problem a ace , seta nia details alochona ba motivational ata episode j psychiatric ar kace jaoa uchit
chaici
Ek hocche je tar occupational , Social and personal field e impairment hobe...due to the mental problem and 2nd
Subjective well being and quality of life will be affected.
If someone fulfills any of the above mentioned criteria they can see professional help.
Khub bhalo akta program dekhte pelam ❤❤😂😂😂😂
Ridiculously misleading video with full of wrong information. She has 0 idea about what psychologists do. Psychologists are not psychiatrists' assistants. They are independent professional with training, skill, expertise and license. The speaker has also made racist and classist comments. This video is not only misleading, it's disrespectful and insulting.
th-cam.com/video/vfvUP0lY43o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aLOtx_ybwdCXaOIC
❤❤❤
Ami depressed but kivabe madam r satha jogajog korbo bolte paren sir?
It's better to avoid her. Eto misinformation he day take na dekhiye onno Psychiatrist dekhan
I totally agree with Sudipa mam. Please reach out to someone who is empathetic and unbiased towards members of the mental health professional. She herself feels the burden of seeing hundreds of pts in ESI hospital, but amidst them she gives 30 mins to counselling family members of pts with Dissociative Disorder. Madam, I would advise you to delegate the work responsibilities (related to Psychotherapy and psychometry) to clinical psychologists, thereby helping you to actually do your own technical job of being a psychiatrist, and also not violating boundaries at the work place. This is how work is done in government set ups and private set ups , otherwise I am sorry to say, she herself would end up experiencing clinical stress and anxiety.
ম্যাডামের মনে বোধহয় ক্লিনিক্যাল সাইকোলজিস্টদের প্রতি যথেষ্ট বায়াস আছে। সাইকোলজিক্যাল ইন্টারভেনশন সম্বন্ধে আপনার মনে এতো ট্যাবু কেন, আর ক্লিনিক্যাল সাইকোলজিস্টদের এবং অন্যান্য মেন্টাল হেল্থ ওয়ার্কারদের ছোটো করার দরকারটা কেন হলো, বুঝলাম না।
আসলের ম্যাডামের মনে হয় মানসিক মনোরোগ চিকিৎসক হিসেবে পেশাগত কিছু খামতি আছে তাই সেটা ঢাকার জন্য এই ধরনের নিম্নমানের প্রচার করলেন এই চ্যানেলের মাধ্যমে
Psychologist kono osudh prescribe korte pare naa, keu kore thakle seta sompurno bay aini, ar psychology porte gele 11-12 a science(physics, Chem, maths) na thakle oo chole, ota arts er subject tai, science noy
Uni to psychologist der apoman Koren ni..uni j kotha gulo bole6en segulo sotti kotha..psychiatrists are doctors psychologists are not doctors who help psychiatrists..
@abhisekgangopadhyay8681 kono nimnomaer prochar uni korenni. Uni jeta bolechen thiki bolechen. Eta hoyto apnar ba onek psychologist der digest hobe karon karon etai truth je psychologists are not doctors. They don't have registration number. So accept the truth.
th-cam.com/video/vfvUP0lY43o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aLOtx_ybwdCXaOIC
Complete misinformation about psychologists. This video should be removed. The hosts and the lady should apologise to the psychologist community.
Why? What's your reason behind it
@@Babaidey77 for wrong and misleading information
What she has said about psychologists, is completely misleading.
Best phycreatry
Sayan da ❤❤❤❤
Apnar sobar age ektu counseling kora uchit
প্রতিবার শহরের শিক্ষিত মহিলা বলছেন কেন বুঝলাম না? শহরের বলেই শিক্ষিত হবে এমন কোনো কথা নেই।
Sobar pa bhanglo kivabe ,? 😂😂
Neurologist chai
Bekar episode.
Akta kotha janar chhilo. Podcast e ese ato English bolchen, bujhlam. ESI hospital er OPD te ato English bolben na plz!
Ekdom thik kotha psychologist ra ajkal nijeder psychiatrist bole chamber khule TCA, Anti depressants prescribe Kore jacche....
Neuro surgeon চাই
Besh mono-agrohi alochona...
Psychologist kono osudh prescribe korte pare naa, keu kore thakle seta sompurno bay aini, ar psychology porte gele 11-12 a science(physics, Chem, maths) na thakle oo chole, ota arts er subject tai, science noy
Amar kno janina mone hocche onar behaviour patients der proti hyto valona. Uni sympathy or empathy dite parena.
Shits like this get sm views n all....n real stuff gets like 100 views. This is the very reason how facts get distorted and popular and distorted and popular and distorted and popular.
psychologist আনা হোক
th-cam.com/video/vfvUP0lY43o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=aLOtx_ybwdCXaOIC
ম্যাডাম একজন সাইক্রিয়াটিস্ট হিসাবে খুব ভালো ভাবে মনরোগ এর বিষয়টি বোঝালেন। আপনাদের অনুরোধ করবো। নামকরা কোন সাইকোলজিস্ট কে আনুন। সাইকোলজিস্ট রা ব্যাঙের ছাতার মত গজিয়ে উঠছে এর বিষয় টা কোন সাইকোলজিস্ট এর কাছ থেকে জানতে পারলে ভালো হয়।
খুব সুন্দর! ধন্যবাদ।
রেফার সাইকোলিজস্ট ও করতে পারে একথা কি উনি জানেন না? সাইক্রিয়াটিস্ট সাইকোলজিস্ট এই টোটাল প্রক্রিয়া একটি যৌথ প্রক্রিয়া আগেই সাইক্রিয়াটিস্ট দের কাছে যাবেন আর সাইকোলজিস্টদের কাছে যাবেন না একথা বলার কখনোই যুক্তিযুক্ত নয়
Next time akjon Hematology Dr. Chaii please....
Are age eta to dekhun...
Hattt ota abar ki 🤡🤡