Tobo: well, it's about a lot of things I guess. It could be about the main character from The Downward Spiral looking back after suicide, but it could be about depression, but it could be about drug addiction.
WOw...Wheeww, I almost let go one night listening to this song for hours,.homeless in a 6yr Meth Hell. I didn't mean to watch this, stumbled on it from someones Vlog Vid, takes me back to that night. Didn't realize it would hit me so hard! I got well, visited Rome, Madrid, Paris, lived in Manhattan 6mnths, have a Son, Home just crying thinking of all I would have missed. 21yrs Clean, Sober.
It's crazy to me how every single version of this song seems to have its own meaning. The album version is downright depressing, the older live versions are filled with far more cynicism, while this one has a slight feeling of hope to it, warmth even I'd say. On top of that we have the Johnny Cash cover which also stands on its own. It takes one hell of a talented songwriter and performer to create something like this.
Core of this song is like soup base. By changing receipe a little, you could get quite different taste. From creepy warning by warm chicken soup to your soul to great farewell from great man.
I remember watching this on MTV as a teenager. It’s had so many different meanings to me through my lifetime - now I’m 42 and it’s such a different experience. You nailed it.
"My sweetest friend" is not an addmition to a lost relation or letting some one else down. This song is about yourself. It is about letting yourself down. About reaching in and realizing your "fragile" and sometimes you fail big time. I'm there right now. The bottom end of a bottle. I have to look at myself now and realize what I have become.
Exactly! That is the finest comment I have come across!... Fair fuckin play to u Steve. I spent 4 yrs in a cell listening to this and that is the exact conclusion I came to. Its about urself nd only u. I'm out now nd trying to improve. Meet u in Dublin some day for a drink 😈👍😎
The song is over 20 years old now and still rips through me like the first time I heard it. I'm not a huge NIN fan, I like Reznor, but not a huge fan. But this is one of the 10 best songs from my generation I think. Oh, and I love Johnny Cash, but the emotional roller coaster Trent takes people on with this song is beyond what Cash did with the song. I know Trent said it was Johnny's song now, and I appreciate his respectful nature to a great, but Trent has to know the emotional impact of a live performance like this cannot be touched.
+Ray Geetard www.google.com/search?biw=360&bih=307&ei=CeaYV5vHKcSwjwPEio34CQ&q=who+wrote+hurt+first&oq=who+wrote+hurt&gs_l=mobile-gws-serp.1.1.0l5.32940168.32944750.0.32947474.15.15.0.5.5.0.1142.5498.2-7j6j1j7-1.15.0....0...1c.1j4.64.mobile-gws-serp..3.12.2229.3..41j0i3j0i67j0i131.Rh6Z4jbXjdQ. the first info proves that it's originally nin
I hate the crowd. I mean, it looks like it was a pretty kick ass audience, but I don't want to hear any of them sing. It's not too bad in this case, as Trent's mic is up high enough to make them sound like backing vocals, but I've been to a few shows where all I can here are the people around me sing, and it's fucking annoying.
@@Kriegsbeil5577 That's really odd, because when I made that reply 11 months ago, I'm almost positive that I had just watched the live version of "Enjoy the Silence" right before this or perhaps a bit earlier. Lol, but I had the same complaint for that one as well. If I had seen them live before, then I wouldn't mind the crowd singing, but if it was my first time I would be really disappointed. I don't usually say "I hate the crowd", but that Depeche Mode live video made me say it here.
This is one of the few songs in music history that’s gotten more people sober and off of drugs than any other. This song has literally changed so many peoples lives.
This one and "Nutshell" by Alice in Chains... especially the "Unplugged" performance. 12 years clean... and that song was an important part of the journey. Still is. You can tell these dudes have hurt before.
Couldn't agree more - any time I struggle with my chemicals this brings me calm and sanity and I can survive another hour without either of my drugs of choice that became no choice. I volunteer at a drugs/alcohol clinic - if you have an issue and know it's time please seek help. Me & my colleagues world wide are there to help. Much love to all in need - there's strength in numbers
The thing I love about the live version I love is knowing that all the people singing with Trent have felt some of the same things I have. Knowing we’re not alone gives us hope through the hurt.
I just said this in another post. We've all been battling the same shit and I've met so many people that grew up on this type of music relate to each other and encourage each other to do to be ok in this world
It may not be a popular opinion but this song actually bring me to tears of joy. It reminds me of a dark period of my life yes, but it also reminds me of how I overcame that darkness and came out of the other side a better man, husband and father.
@@virginiaknighten4687 Thank you for the kind words I’m glad you loved it! It’s a deeply personal song for me and I consider it a masterpiece. Moves me every time I hear it
@@someguy9471 it is amazingly beautiful that music can stir something up inside us that we didn’t expect or know was there. I love the way different songs can do this. And you are very welcome✌️
Why do people have to always compare the 2 versions, can't we all accept that they're both beautiful insightful renditions with 2 very different meanings!
jerry argudo Yeah, but it's sad, that people outline their opinions as absolute truth. It would be nice if people would learn how to peacefully and kindly express their opinions. :)
Both versions are the most beautiful songs I've heard on the subject of pain... Here's what Trent said about Cash's version... When Trent Reznor was asked if Cash could cover his song, Reznor said he was "flattered" but worried that "the idea sounded a bit gimmicky." He became a fan of Cash's version, however, once he saw the music video. “ I pop the video in, and wow... Tears welling, silence, goose-bumps... Wow. [I felt like] I just lost my girlfriend, because that song isn't mine anymore... It really made me think about how powerful music is as a medium and art form. I wrote some words and music in my bedroom as a way of staying sane, about a bleak and desperate place I was in, totally isolated and alone. [Somehow] that winds up reinterpreted by a music legend from a radically different era/genre and still retains sincerity and meaning - different, but every bit as pure
both versions? no. one is original and one is cover. '' [I felt like] I just lost my girlfriend, because that song isn't mine anymore''... no. trent reznor is wrote the song and j. cash cover, end of story.
Where did u sleep last night ledbelly is a painful song. Good nirvana cover of it too! So is coma white thats a painful song and clown by Korn are all to me more pained than this.... korn have a hell of alot of hard hitting songs actually. I love trent and this song but now all I see when I close my eyes listening to it now is rick and morty... if u know u know 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yesterday I was at a philosophical discussion. The subject was "Are there higher and lower forms of pleasure?". Someone suggested that opera was a higher form of pleasure than common hit songs. In order to appreciate opera you must make an effort to understand it. Than it struck me, this song is not pleasure, but it´s a high form of art. In order to understand this song you must be familiar with suffering. Those who are lucky to not have suffered very much are not likely to understand it. This song is also an example that high quality art can trigger very strong emotions. I can't listen, or even think of it without tears coming from my eyes.
because Trent was more interested in creating an atmosphere of desolation and despair, while prioritizing goosebumps and emotion rather than complexity. but NIN and other Reznor's projects are quite complex
I love (yet feel the anguish and pain is palpable still) the fact this man wrote this song at a time and in a state that most musicians sadly die,or fade into obscurity. He did neither.He was meant to carry on and beat the crap out of his demons.....Not many have the strength.He did.And I applaud his strength and fight,as much as I applaud his performance of this song so many years later.And I love how a small part of the piano is so slightly different at one point.(I know nothing of music,though I'm sure ppl know what I'm on about). Everyone hates a long post,but I feel justified.....Oh,and sanctified ;) Brilliant performance,Trent.
Almost 6 million views...hmmmm..And its for something that has meaning, thats not Ironic,thats not distasteful. This song can relate to any person from anywhere. Reznor you saved my life.
Why are people so bothered about which version is better. Although they are technically the same they are both completely separate pieces of art done by people in completely different circumstances with completely different motives
I do feel like he nin version is more relatable to me en I think that’s the case for most younger people. The cash cover is more based on the experience of being old and ready to say goodbye tot your life and feeling alone in a changed world. The nin version is more about depression and/or addiction. And wanting to end it before your time. It’s a totally different song even though they’re the same. This is a nice example why music is my favorite thing in life.
Why do people even compare?? It's 2 different artist and both do the song justice. Don't like one? Don't listen to it. But don't say it's better or worst cause it isn't.
Johnny Cash's version is a whole different level. The two can't be compared. The band even liked his version more. As great as NIN is, they know they'll never be as big and as influential as Cash.
RCG yea they both are insanely emotional and sad but are in two different categories to the point where it’s stupid to compare them. This version sounds very off putting to me and is very emotional with the vocals well Johnny’s version is emotional when thinking about it and what the artist is going through at the time
bRuH Clan The NIN version is depressing in a more... emo way. Like it still hits the feels but given they're still young and don't have the reputation that Cash has it didn't stick in me as harshly.
So much emotion in this song, I can really see why Cash covered it and at that late stage in his life where he was reflecting back on his mistakes, he probably related to this song in a major way.RIP johnny
I first remember hearing this when I was but a kid on the album, "Downward Spiral". Being the last song after I'd listened to this immense new sound, this music I'd never heard before it was all ended with this song at the very end of the album. Having felt I just lived the very tale which was now sprawled throughout my mind I could only imagine the perception of life through this mans eyes. Years later, 2001 I believe, I hear this same tune and words coming through the radio from an old but familiar voice, Johnny Cash and it hit my soul like a brick. These two men have lived lives fractal to each other. Living vicariously through drugs and their loved ones only to be further damaged by the loss of both. Trent wrote this song in a very dark hour (so I understand) and Mr.Cash covered this song a very dark time toward the end of his life after the loss of his wife. I can only thank Trent for allowing such personal feelings to be shared in such a deep manner, as is with excellence in music.
I haven't used heroin for nineteen years in the upcoming 4th of December. I've stumbled upon this song a couple of times and it still hurts without being ironic. I wonder what he feels when the audience cheers while he is wide open with his pain and struggle.
Upon first discovering NIN, I spent a lot of time listening to this song and crying my heart out. I’m glad I did, it has a special place in my heart forever. Now I can listen to it with a comforting vibe forever within my heart.
Johnny Cash couldn't even get close with that polished, country and clean radio cashy hit of him. When NIN performs it, I feel every single word, the pauses, the breathes, the images... When Trent sings it, his words, man it is heart wrenching, depressing, painfull, sad, despair all over it, almost suffocating and claustrophobic for not being able to get away from the inevitability of death. The best album in the history of the genre, for sure.
Both johnny and Trent sung this song with true emotion and passion. Nobody will ever perform this song like Trent but johnny is the only one who will ever come close with his cover.
Ligeia Noire When Cash performs it.. Tears roll.. Both of them make you feel it because both of them lived it.. Johnny simply lived it a lot deeper than any other
This is one of a very short list of songs I revisit again, again, again. It takes me to a place I can't explain, it hurts and heals at the same time. Trent Reznor is out of this world.
I had always thought Cash's version was more emotional, whereas Trent's album version gave off a feeling of emptiness, but this right here does both. Absolutely incredible. A masterpiece.
In response to Johnny Cash's cover, Trent said it "was like watching someone else kiss your old girlfriend..." meaning something which was so intimate and personal to Trent has new been given a new purpose or life. Watching any video of Trent performing this beautiful song you can see how intimate it truly is for him... seeing him live chilled my bones. That's why to me, this version has so much more impact, because its so damn personal.
This song meant something totally different to us in the 90's than it did for Cash in his version. I prefer Trent's version, but both are heartwrenching and beautiful and both make me cry. I was never substance addicted, but one can be addicted to many things that crush the soul and bring us close to death. This song speaks to all of us.
Just skip to 3:15 close your eyes and imagine a crowd standing together after one of the many terrible events we are faced with struggling through together. A beautiful anthem of grieving and healing together.
fakename ya it's nice to see people atleast do that standing for the flag that represents the very own country that gives us the freedoms and opportunity to be who we are it's not at all in reflect whether you're white black dont want to get killed by a police officer Dont pull gun's on them fucking retards so sick of the soft bull shit excuses Today's American people make up for bad choices people continue to make statistics say it seems to be more on the higher end of black people? Kinda of funny coming from people that off each other every single day in america and has for some time now in record numbers but suddenly black life's matter when someone of another race commits offense there attention seeking whore's and there from My experience little bitch's with big mouth's and ego's fake insecure not all but most and I'm not a racist to any color in particular just to a coward type personality
This song is one of the best written songs I know, and I feel like it was personally suited more for Johnny Cash, then again so did Trent. But this live version is outstanding. What a performance, it is beautiful hearing it how it was intended to be played
When I see and listen to trent reznor's version, I really feel so related to his voice, his words, his pain.. I love johnny cash's version too and also he keeps that feelings on his own way and life But when it comes to trent, man I feel very connected to him. I wish someday I could sit with him and just talk about life, about those lyrics, about how it was to him to fit those shoes.. What a great performer.
Its been over 17 year since I heard this version. I was always partial to the johnny cash cover, but seeing this performance live really blew my 15 year old mind. I completely forgot they were recording for a DVD that night. So glad it to be able to revisit this memory. Thanks for the tickets Danny. Hope life treated you well.
i listen this song the first time on a version of johnny cash and i just have to say both versions are breathtaking and the lyrics do the job to make u tear up a little bit
Man that's a powerful performance,Trent is such a awesome artist.He never fails to deliver! He's One of the few musicians that never gets old and always gives me goosebumps!
I'm glad you found it. I have been a NIN fan since the 90's, and this is my favorite of Trent's performances. I'm 48. It is easy to see why Trent is so decorated with awards; Grammy's, Golden Globes, Oscars. He is a musicians musician.
Honestly one of the most true and emotionally pure songs I've ever heard. This speaks to all spectrums of people who have experienced loss or hardship. While sad and true, it inspires change. A deep feeling of connection that leads to a moment of self realization and discovery, and hopefully transformation. Bravo
I've heard this song so many times it has lost it's ability to give me the creeps and blow my mind the way it did when I first heard it but this live version brought all those emotions back to life and makes me feel again
+aaronx83 Dude this freaking Void in my chest isn't going away season finally did a number on me . I can't seem to get my shit together and put it in the shit museum
This is the best song I've ever heard to describe self harm, every lyric talks about some aspect of it,the physical and the emotional pain,the anger when the song becomes louder and harsher and the lost,broken feeling of the softer parts of the song. Really hits home
Just saw NIN live two weeks ago in Amsterdam. Whenever they play Hurt I get sad and excited at the same time. Excited because it is an incomprehensibly touching and transforming song. Then I get sad because I know they close all their concerts, always, with Hurt. Bless this man
The reason why I love this song is the way it makes you feel every emotion of being hurt; you feel really sad at the verse then a sense of desperation on the pre chorus/chorus and the rotten cherry on the top is the last line which makes you feel rage. And not just rage, it's pure hate. The song is amazing... If you've ever been hurt this song is the embodiment of it.
One of my all time faves!! Damn, this guy gets me everytime!! He's so freaking talented!! His voice is f'n amazing!! His vocals cannot be compared to any other!! DAMN!!
Here are my two cents on the discussion on the which version is "better". The main difference in Original and Cashes cover is the emotion they convey. Trents version is full of self-loathing , it was written as a medium with which to get the anger at self out. Trent said it was something he wrote se he could stay sane and live through that shitty situation he was in. Cash's cover is much different. It is a grimm realization of ones own mortality. You see a dying man, a leggend at the very end of the road. The lyrics lend themselves perfectly to the reimagined purpose. Everyone he knew, from his glorious past, was either dead or dying, while he is siting there wondering if anything even remains to live for. On me Cash's version has a deeper emotianal impact. However if I was in a depression I would likely prefer the original.
+Morclaw Two more topics I would like to tough on. 1st this is not a fucking competition. imitation is the highest form of flattery , and I imagine being covered by a legend must be pretty fattering. Well , we don't have to imagine because Trent said it himself. 2nd The point that Cash replaced the crown of shit with crown of thorns to remove profanity: well the crown of shit in the original vershion is there to hammer in the self-hatred, and it accomplishes it perfectly. Hovever , selfloathing is not part of JC's hardship.Not only would it make no sense to keep it there , it would even confuse the entire message of his version.
tbh honest when I hear these 2 songs I can't help but think of these huge fight between 2 opposing factions. nin version would essentially the mid battle song with all the chaos, bloodshed etc etc. but cash 's version would essentially be the aftermath. picking up the peices and coming to terms with who they have lost and so on.
This song destroyed me. Hearing this song at his North American tour this year is one thing I'll never forget. I just wish I could go back and listen to it again.
I’d argue it being the audience sharing the moment with Trent. Think of it as the audience saying altogether “we’re with you”/“we’ll carry you through the song” because it’s a very deep and personal song for Trent. A performance artist lives off the response from their audience. Think of when a Queen audience collectively sing “Love of My Life”. It’s truly a great thing to behold.
I agree that it's not a "happy" song but mote so the audience has understood and appreciated the song, the meaning it has for Trent, the meaning it has for a lot of us, that we'll all be here for each other collectively. I find that so many of us that have fought addictions cheer each other on. The music especially this song is such a big part of what we use to cope. I see the clapping more as a beautiful moment.
This and other songs of his.. These are the only ones that I could describe as a beautiful sadness. It makes me cry and proud of my NIN tattoo. Bless you Trent. Thankyou for your music. I wish I could write like this.
I didn’t know Cashes version was a cover because I heard it first, and then a few days later I heard the studio version and now I’ve heard three different versions of the same song that all invoke completely different emotions. This song is truly incredible
This song cures depression and sends you in it at the same time.
Agreed. Very fine line.
Ridwan Ahmed You know this song is about depression right?
it makes you aware of your state, it doesn't cure it.
This song's about heroin addiction...
Tobo: well, it's about a lot of things I guess. It could be about the main character from The Downward Spiral looking back after suicide, but it could be about depression, but it could be about drug addiction.
WOw...Wheeww, I almost let go one night listening to this song for hours,.homeless in a 6yr Meth Hell. I didn't mean to watch this, stumbled on it from someones Vlog Vid, takes me back to that night. Didn't realize it would hit me so hard! I got well, visited Rome, Madrid, Paris, lived in Manhattan 6mnths, have a Son, Home just crying thinking of all I would have missed. 21yrs Clean, Sober.
HorizonChaser congrats buddy. Keep it up!
One love
sobriety is so worth it!!
You’ve made it , you are becoming who you are meant to be . I’ve been through something similar, proud of you man
and were so proud of you friend.
Crackhead over here, recovered. I hear ya bro. This song kills. Hits our spirit right where we live.
It's crazy to me how every single version of this song seems to have its own meaning. The album version is downright depressing, the older live versions are filled with far more cynicism, while this one has a slight feeling of hope to it, warmth even I'd say. On top of that we have the Johnny Cash cover which also stands on its own. It takes one hell of a talented songwriter and performer to create something like this.
a few major piano notes starting near 2:18 help give this version a feeling of hope
Core of this song is like soup base. By changing receipe a little, you could get quite different taste. From creepy warning by warm chicken soup to your soul to great farewell from great man.
I have yet to find the version that is on the CD that I own.
I remember watching this on MTV as a teenager. It’s had so many different meanings to me through my lifetime - now I’m 42 and it’s such a different experience. You nailed it.
Regardless....that howling wind sound underneath it all...that's desert, death, and decay...
This still brings out emotions in me that I thought were long dead
This song gave me life that I thought was long gone. Funny how music works. hugs.
I know what you mean, I'm 23 years clean, and it still feels like yesterday.
Yeah it make me cry everytime skin deep
Wow same!
For real
"My sweetest friend" is not an addmition to a lost relation or letting some one else down. This song is about yourself. It is about letting yourself down. About reaching in and realizing your "fragile" and sometimes you fail big time. I'm there right now. The bottom end of a bottle. I have to look at myself now and realize what I have become.
Exactly! That is the finest comment I have come across!... Fair fuckin play to u Steve. I spent 4 yrs in a cell listening to this and that is the exact conclusion I came to. Its about urself nd only u. I'm out now nd trying to improve. Meet u in Dublin some day for a drink 😈👍😎
Thank you for this, needed it ❤️
Thank you so much, truly 💜
I don't know who you are. But I love you. Have a good life...
The bottle is always empty
The song is over 20 years old now and still rips through me like the first time I heard it. I'm not a huge NIN fan, I like Reznor, but not a huge fan. But this is one of the 10 best songs from my generation I think. Oh, and I love Johnny Cash, but the emotional roller coaster Trent takes people on with this song is beyond what Cash did with the song. I know Trent said it was Johnny's song now, and I appreciate his respectful nature to a great, but Trent has to know the emotional impact of a live performance like this cannot be touched.
Dude I'm pretty sure cash wrote this song and these hipsters are just jumping on the band wag on
+Ray Geetard www.google.com/search?biw=360&bih=307&ei=CeaYV5vHKcSwjwPEio34CQ&q=who+wrote+hurt+first&oq=who+wrote+hurt&gs_l=mobile-gws-serp.1.1.0l5.32940168.32944750.0.32947474.15.15.0.5.5.0.1142.5498.2-7j6j1j7-1.15.0....0...1c.1j4.64.mobile-gws-serp..3.12.2229.3..41j0i3j0i67j0i131.Rh6Z4jbXjdQ. the first info proves that it's originally nin
b disc Ray Geetard is just jokstering.
shut the fuck up already
Im sorry but Cash killed it and its also very relateable to his personal problems...
we're all in this together, even through the pain and suffering.
Molten_ youuuuuuu and me WE’RE IN THIS TOGETHER NOOOOOWWWWWW
The Way Out Is Through
Personally this is the live version that I enjoy the most. It's just beautiful in every aspect, Trent on the piano, the way it's directed, the crowd..
Angel Matarin totally agree
100% agree
I hate the crowd. I mean, it looks like it was a pretty kick ass audience, but I don't want to hear any of them sing. It's not too bad in this case, as Trent's mic is up high enough to make them sound like backing vocals, but I've been to a few shows where all I can here are the people around me sing, and it's fucking annoying.
So agreed!!!
@@Kriegsbeil5577 That's really odd, because when I made that reply 11 months ago, I'm almost positive that I had just watched the live version of "Enjoy the Silence" right before this or perhaps a bit earlier. Lol, but I had the same complaint for that one as well. If I had seen them live before, then I wouldn't mind the crowd singing, but if it was my first time I would be really disappointed. I don't usually say "I hate the crowd", but that Depeche Mode live video made me say it here.
This is one of the few songs in music history that’s gotten more people sober and off of drugs than any other. This song has literally changed so many peoples lives.
It’s curing me right now
This one and "Nutshell" by Alice in Chains... especially the "Unplugged" performance.
12 years clean... and that song was an important part of the journey.
Still is.
You can tell these dudes have hurt before.
Couldn't agree more - any time I struggle with my chemicals this brings me calm and sanity and I can survive another hour without either of my drugs of choice that became no choice.
I volunteer at a drugs/alcohol clinic - if you have an issue and know it's time please seek help. Me & my colleagues world wide are there to help. Much love to all in need - there's strength in numbers
You know you're the real deal when Johnny Cash rips your song
*covers
Poker Fish I dig the acoustic guitar more. Its more emotional, just my opinion
+Rohan Roy True! This is just cheasy, the way its presented, they try to be so sad, it is just feels fake for me.
Poker Fish on Hurt, between the original song by them and the cover of Johnny Cash, which is better?
Takes you down a peg when most people only know your song because Johnny Cash covered it.:)
The thing I love about the live version I love is knowing that all the people singing with Trent have felt some of the same things I have. Knowing we’re not alone gives us hope through the hurt.
I just said this in another post. We've all been battling the same shit and I've met so many people that grew up on this type of music relate to each other and encourage each other to do to be ok in this world
The cheering takes away from the emotion tho..
so true
It may not be a popular opinion but this song actually bring me to tears of joy. It reminds me of a dark period of my life yes, but it also reminds me of how I overcame that darkness and came out of the other side a better man, husband and father.
I think it’s wonderful that this song can bring joy and good memories to you. Loved your comment❤️
@@virginiaknighten4687 Thank you for the kind words I’m glad you loved it! It’s a deeply personal song for me and I consider it a masterpiece. Moves me every time I hear it
@@someguy9471 it is amazingly beautiful that music can stir something up inside us that we didn’t expect or know was there. I love the way different songs can do this. And you are very welcome✌️
Love bro 🙏🙏
Why do people have to always compare the 2 versions, can't we all accept that they're both beautiful insightful renditions with 2 very different meanings!
they just want to get their opinion out there
jerry argudo Yeah, but it's sad, that people outline their opinions as absolute truth. It would be nice if people would learn how to peacefully and kindly express their opinions. :)
Because Humans are Primitive
MrSamuel539 except that one is way better
My version of hurt has another meaning I made up in my head.
Just a shame Trent and Johnny didn't get a chance to get together for a live performance of this.
Wow, I can't believe that possibility never occurred to me. That would have been pretty unbelievable
Johnny Cash will steal the show
Not enough tissues in the world to support that audience lol
That would be horrendous
it would break youtube for sure that would of been dope to watch
Both versions are the most beautiful songs I've heard on the subject of pain...
Here's what Trent said about Cash's version...
When Trent Reznor was asked if Cash could cover his song, Reznor said he was "flattered" but worried that "the idea sounded a bit gimmicky." He became a fan of Cash's version, however, once he saw the music video.
“ I pop the video in, and wow... Tears welling, silence, goose-bumps... Wow. [I felt like] I just lost my girlfriend, because that song isn't mine anymore... It really made me think about how powerful music is as a medium and art form. I wrote some words and music in my bedroom as a way of staying sane, about a bleak and desperate place I was in, totally isolated and alone. [Somehow] that winds up reinterpreted by a music legend from a radically different era/genre and still retains sincerity and meaning - different, but every bit as pure
💖🙏
You forgot the part of the quote where he said he "didn't like it" before he saw the video. : /
exactly, the Cash fans always leave that part out when saying Reznor said its Cash's now.
both versions? no. one is original and one is cover. '' [I felt like] I just lost my girlfriend, because that song isn't mine anymore''... no. trent reznor is wrote the song and j. cash cover, end of story.
Where did u sleep last night ledbelly is a painful song. Good nirvana cover of it too! So is coma white thats a painful song and clown by Korn are all to me more pained than this.... korn have a hell of alot of hard hitting songs actually. I love trent and this song but now all I see when I close my eyes listening to it now is rick and morty... if u know u know 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yesterday I was at a philosophical discussion. The subject was "Are there higher and lower forms of pleasure?". Someone suggested that opera was a higher form of pleasure than common hit songs. In order to appreciate opera you must make an effort to understand it. Than it struck me, this song is not pleasure, but it´s a high form of art. In order to understand this song you must be familiar with suffering. Those who are lucky to not have suffered very much are not likely to understand it. This song is also an example that high quality art can trigger very strong emotions. I can't listen, or even think of it without tears coming from my eyes.
Great post.
I fucking wish I didn't get this song then but good point I guess.
I relate coming off Heroin, oxycontin, fentanyl and morphine to this song. Makes me feel sad
because Trent was more interested in creating an atmosphere of desolation and despair, while prioritizing goosebumps and emotion rather than complexity. but NIN and other Reznor's projects are quite complex
Well-put, Kristian.
I love (yet feel the anguish and pain is palpable still) the fact this man wrote this song at a time and in a state that most musicians sadly die,or fade into obscurity.
He did neither.He was meant to carry on and beat the crap out of his demons.....Not many have the strength.He did.And I applaud his strength and fight,as much as I applaud his performance of this song so many years later.And I love how a small part of the piano is so slightly different at one point.(I know nothing of music,though I'm sure ppl know what I'm on about).
Everyone hates a long post,but I feel justified.....Oh,and sanctified ;)
Brilliant performance,Trent.
Almost 6 million views...hmmmm..And its for something that has meaning, thats not Ironic,thats not distasteful. This song can relate to any person from anywhere. Reznor you saved my life.
Why are people so bothered about which version is better. Although they are technically the same they are both completely separate pieces of art done by people in completely different circumstances with completely different motives
AMEN
>old one
Nine Inch Nails version is the original one.. I like better the Jhonny Cash's one tho
titus bramble agree
I do feel like he nin version is more relatable to me en I think that’s the case for most younger people. The cash cover is more based on the experience of being old and ready to say goodbye tot your life and feeling alone in a changed world.
The nin version is more about depression and/or addiction. And wanting to end it before your time. It’s a totally different song even though they’re the same. This is a nice example why music is my favorite thing in life.
Why do people even compare?? It's 2 different artist and both do the song justice. Don't like one? Don't listen to it. But don't say it's better or worst cause it isn't.
I'm gonna be honest with you Cash's is MUCH better then this.
But Lizard...you're wrong. Haha
But Mayson... I'm not.
*sigh*
Differnt opinions I guess.
Perspective
I love the stage lighting these guys have. You can never quite see their faces. It totally gives the show a sense of depth.
There is no better version than this one...
berryfairy68 Johnny Cash's version is not even close
Johnny Cash's version is a whole different level. The two can't be compared. The band even liked his version more. As great as NIN is, they know they'll never be as big and as influential as Cash.
Ayyy, got your comment to 69. You're welcome.
RCG yea they both are insanely emotional and sad but are in two different categories to the point where it’s stupid to compare them. This version sounds very off putting to me and is very emotional with the vocals well Johnny’s version is emotional when thinking about it and what the artist is going through at the time
bRuH Clan The NIN version is depressing in a more... emo way. Like it still hits the feels but given they're still young and don't have the reputation that Cash has it didn't stick in me as harshly.
Get goosebumps on the first riff... Then the first lyrics... I get them everywhere.
The greatest song in history
So much emotion in this song, I can really see why Cash covered it and at that late stage in his life where he was reflecting back on his mistakes, he probably related to this song in a major way.RIP johnny
I first remember hearing this when I was but a kid on the album, "Downward Spiral". Being the last song after I'd listened to this immense new sound, this music I'd never heard before it was all ended with this song at the very end of the album. Having felt I just lived the very tale which was now sprawled throughout my mind I could only imagine the perception of life through this mans eyes.
Years later, 2001 I believe, I hear this same tune and words coming through the radio from an old but familiar voice, Johnny Cash and it hit my soul like a brick. These two men have lived lives fractal to each other. Living vicariously through drugs and their loved ones only to be further damaged by the loss of both.
Trent wrote this song in a very dark hour (so I understand) and Mr.Cash covered this song a very dark time toward the end of his life after the loss of his wife.
I can only thank Trent for allowing such personal feelings to be shared in such a deep manner, as is with excellence in music.
The Downward Spiral.Got me thru the toughest time in my life
this performance is so moving. all the feels right now.
I haven't used heroin for nineteen years in the upcoming 4th of December. I've stumbled upon this song a couple of times and it still hurts without being ironic.
I wonder what he feels when the audience cheers while he is wide open with his pain and struggle.
Proud for you. Are you still doing good? Take care of yourself...
Upon first discovering NIN, I spent a lot of time listening to this song and crying my heart out. I’m glad I did, it has a special place in my heart forever. Now I can listen to it with a comforting vibe forever within my heart.
best version of the song
For real bro ! Someone gets it lol
When the drums kick in, goosebumps all over the body..
Johnny Cash couldn't even get close with that polished, country and clean radio cashy hit of him. When NIN performs it, I feel every single word, the pauses, the breathes, the images... When Trent sings it, his words, man it is heart wrenching, depressing, painfull, sad, despair all over it, almost suffocating and claustrophobic for not being able to get away from the inevitability of death. The best album in the history of the genre, for sure.
Both johnny and Trent sung this song with true emotion and passion. Nobody will ever perform this song like Trent but johnny is the only one who will ever come close with his cover.
Exactly no one can cover the pain trent had when he spoke these simple words dudesef
This guy gets it art comes from the heart not when I hear someone say it then repeat it
Luke Helmke trent didnt cover it he created it
Ligeia Noire When Cash performs it.. Tears roll.. Both of them make you feel it because both of them lived it.. Johnny simply lived it a lot deeper than any other
This is one of a very short list of songs I revisit again, again, again. It takes me to a place I can't explain, it hurts and heals at the same time.
Trent Reznor is out of this world.
"what are you in for, Everything"
-Rick
feels man
his voice gives me so many fucking goosebumps!!
3:55 when the rest of the background comes in ... pure magic ...
I had always thought Cash's version was more emotional, whereas Trent's album version gave off a feeling of emptiness, but this right here does both.
Absolutely incredible.
A masterpiece.
In response to Johnny Cash's cover, Trent said it "was like watching someone else kiss your old girlfriend..." meaning something which was so intimate and personal to Trent has new been given a new purpose or life. Watching any video of Trent performing this beautiful song you can see how intimate it truly is for him... seeing him live chilled my bones. That's why to me, this version has so much more impact, because its so damn personal.
I miss Trent doing it this way. Something about the lone piano and just his voice makes it a lot more gut-wrenching in a beautiful way.
Shout out to the dude recording with a flip phone.
He was live streaming
This song meant something totally different to us in the 90's than it did for Cash in his version. I prefer Trent's version, but both are heartwrenching and beautiful and both make me cry. I was never substance addicted, but one can be addicted to many things that crush the soul and bring us close to death. This song speaks to all of us.
Just skip to 3:15 close your eyes and imagine a crowd standing together after one of the many terrible events we are faced with struggling through together. A beautiful anthem of grieving and healing together.
fakename ya it's nice to see people atleast do that standing for the flag that represents the very own country that gives us the freedoms and opportunity to be who we are it's not at all in reflect whether you're white black dont want to get killed by a police officer Dont pull gun's on them fucking retards so sick of the soft bull shit excuses Today's American people make up for bad choices people continue to make statistics say it seems to be more on the higher end of black people? Kinda of funny coming from people that off each other every single day in america and has for some time now in record numbers but suddenly black life's matter when someone of another race commits offense there attention seeking whore's and there from My experience little bitch's with big mouth's and ego's fake insecure not all but most and I'm not a racist to any color in particular just to a coward type personality
I know its about Trents struggle with heroin addiction but the lyrics resonate with all the suicidal thoughts we all have every day. Peace out
I love the harmony of the crowd singing along
this song... hurt my heart, but cure my soul! Magnific!
There go my feels
And those Columbine students.
NatFillion S you made my day😂
What makes this song beautiful are the dissonant chords.🖤
The only song that will make you hurt and heal you simultaneously.
a true historian of it only gets better from here....97 to 2016..Trent your songs always stick..
This song is one of the best written songs I know, and I feel like it was personally suited more for Johnny Cash, then again so did Trent. But this live version is outstanding. What a performance, it is beautiful hearing it how it was intended to be played
When I see and listen to trent reznor's version, I really feel so related to his voice, his words, his pain..
I love johnny cash's version too and also he keeps that feelings on his own way and life
But when it comes to trent, man I feel very connected to him.
I wish someday I could sit with him and just talk about life, about those lyrics, about how it was to him to fit those shoes..
What a great performer.
Its been over 17 year since I heard this version. I was always partial to the johnny cash cover, but seeing this performance live really blew my 15 year old mind. I completely forgot they were recording for a DVD that night. So glad it to be able to revisit this memory. Thanks for the tickets Danny. Hope life treated you well.
Wow so much emotion in those vocals
i listen this song the first time on a version of johnny cash and i just have to say both versions are breathtaking and the lyrics do the job to make u tear up a little bit
My favorite song of all time. Goosebumps every time. Been listening to NIN for over 20 years
Man that's a powerful performance,Trent is such a awesome artist.He never fails to deliver! He's One of the few musicians that never gets old and always gives me goosebumps!
I’m 71 nearly 72 and heard this amazing song for the first time yesterday 3/31/22
It has totally blown my mind.. In A Good Way!
I'm glad you found it. I have been a NIN fan since the 90's, and this is my favorite of Trent's performances. I'm 48. It is easy to see why Trent is so decorated with awards; Grammy's, Golden Globes, Oscars. He is a musicians musician.
@@upcycle.outdoorsman9629 Thank you for your reply. I’m sure that I’ll be watching this video forever!
It's amazing how music can span across some many generations and be loved by so many generations.
Johnny does an excellent version. It's awesome. Trent however owns it. He makes me cry. It's actually painful.
This is and always will be one of the most emotional and beautiful songs ever written.
Honestly one of the most true and emotionally pure songs I've ever heard. This speaks to all spectrums of people who have experienced loss or hardship. While sad and true, it inspires change. A deep feeling of connection that leads to a moment of self realization and discovery, and hopefully transformation. Bravo
I've heard this song so many times it has lost it's ability to give me the creeps and blow my mind the way it did when I first heard it but this live version brought all those emotions back to life and makes me feel again
Season 3 seems to be forever away...
+aaronx83 "What're you in for?"
"Everything"
+aaronx83 Dude this freaking Void in my chest isn't going away season finally did a number on me . I can't seem to get my shit together and put it in the shit museum
+ganyalf do shrooms or get super fuckin stoned
just don't drink
you'll become an alcoholic
I knowwww
+Tempest Exodus Thanks brother..... All the feels though
This is the best song I've ever heard to describe self harm, every lyric talks about some aspect of it,the physical and the emotional pain,the anger when the song becomes louder and harsher and the lost,broken feeling of the softer parts of the song. Really hits home
I can’t believe how it’s possible to love 2 versions of a song so much, for so complete different kind of reasons. What a song...
I cant decide which version I like better. They're both great. Gives me chills every time.
“What are you in for?” “Everything.”
This concert was insane, best concert I have ever been too. I’d see Trent live again in a heartbeat.
Just saw NIN live two weeks ago in Amsterdam. Whenever they play Hurt I get sad and excited at the same time. Excited because it is an incomprehensibly touching and transforming song. Then I get sad because I know they close all their concerts, always, with Hurt. Bless this man
Love NIN They are so unique Reznor back hope for a tour soon.
The reason why I love this song is the way it makes you feel every emotion of being hurt; you feel really sad at the verse then a sense of desperation on the pre chorus/chorus and the rotten cherry on the top is the last line which makes you feel rage. And not just rage, it's pure hate.
The song is amazing... If you've ever been hurt this song is the embodiment of it.
Via dipicting a real embodiment mass
One of my all time faves!! Damn, this guy gets me everytime!! He's so freaking talented!! His voice is f'n amazing!! His vocals cannot be compared to any other!! DAMN!!
Amazing. Perfect. Tells a story and makes me look inside to realize what matters.
I squanch this song.
stop saying it. gross.
+Do It Live Show I love how when rick was going down he stilled tried to fuck with Jerry
+Joey Thomas "If I'm going down, I'm taking you with me!"
+DILC hahahaha fuck yeah mang
Lost on so many people
One of the greatest songs ever love it
One of the best live performances of all time. Listen to the crowd.
The last verse this song hits me a lot, and thats what I'm doin now...
I feel that. The desire to start over, hoping things will be different next time.
Probably the most somber and heartfelt performance ever. Back when people had lighters.
Trent Raznor, you're a genius !!!! Thank you again for all these emotions (20 years and it is always so beautiful)
il meglio del meglio . canzone fantastica piena di emozioni. bravissimi. voi siete la musica . un capolavoro in assoluto
The beauty in this song is the dissonance and eerie sound in the verses, transition into the hopeful, beautiful chorus with the major chords.
This song means so much to me. Thank you NIN
Here are my two cents on the discussion on the which version is "better". The main difference in Original and Cashes cover is the emotion they convey. Trents version is full of self-loathing , it was written as a medium with which to get the anger at self out. Trent said it was something he wrote se he could stay sane and live through that shitty situation he was in. Cash's cover is much different. It is a grimm realization of ones own mortality. You see a dying man, a leggend at the very end of the road. The lyrics lend themselves perfectly to the reimagined purpose. Everyone he knew, from his glorious past, was either dead or dying, while he is siting there wondering if anything even remains to live for. On me Cash's version has a deeper emotianal impact. However if I was in a depression I would likely prefer the original.
+Morclaw Two more topics I would like to tough on. 1st this is not a fucking competition. imitation is the highest form of flattery , and I imagine being covered by a legend must be pretty fattering. Well , we don't have to imagine because Trent said it himself. 2nd The point that Cash replaced the crown of shit with crown of thorns to remove profanity: well the crown of shit in the original vershion is there to hammer in the self-hatred, and it accomplishes it perfectly. Hovever , selfloathing is not part of JC's hardship.Not only would it make no sense to keep it there , it would even confuse the entire message of his version.
tbh honest when I hear these 2 songs I can't help but think of these huge fight between 2 opposing factions. nin version would essentially the mid battle song with all the chaos, bloodshed etc etc. but cash 's version would essentially be the aftermath. picking up the peices and coming to terms with who they have lost and so on.
Both give me goosebumps. Beautiful song
Ur description is spot on. I have been having depression for probably 4 years for now. And I prefer the original much more.
You sir have hit the nail on the head
This song is that light in the darkness.
This is one of the best songs ever written great job Nine Inch Nails
This song destroyed me.
Hearing this song at his North American tour this year is one thing I'll never forget. I just wish I could go back and listen to it again.
Ditto. I followed them through 3 cities and cried every time.
Dear mr. Reznor
Many thanks for this.
I am a Phd in math in Montreal.
Your music has kept me alive.
Thank you
Good for you Lucas!
i love this
Astonishing song. Absolutely soul shaking.
3:56 brings tears to my eyes everytime I watch this performance
Am I the only one who thinks that this becomes a happy song when the audience sings the chorus with him?
I’d argue it being the audience sharing the moment with Trent. Think of it as the audience saying altogether “we’re with you”/“we’ll carry you through the song” because it’s a very deep and personal song for Trent. A performance artist lives off the response from their audience. Think of when a Queen audience collectively sing “Love of My Life”. It’s truly a great thing to behold.
I agree that it's not a "happy" song but mote so the audience has understood and appreciated the song, the meaning it has for Trent, the meaning it has for a lot of us, that we'll all be here for each other collectively.
I find that so many of us that have fought addictions cheer each other on. The music especially this song is such a big part of what we use to cope. I see the clapping more as a beautiful moment.
If only I was old enough to jam this back in the day. Fcking love this
This and other songs of his.. These are the only ones that I could describe as a beautiful sadness. It makes me cry and proud of my NIN tattoo. Bless you Trent. Thankyou for your music. I wish I could write like this.
This song is so powerful. For me, Its like being visited by God himself
I remember listening to this as a teen, and I thought I understood him. I know now that I was silly. I never will.
The song is one of my all-time favorites thank you Trent
One of my favorites songs ever...I never get tired of listening to it.
what are you in for?
*Everything*
You're not alone dude, trust me.
I for one didn't knew either, even though I've got quite a collection of NiN tracks, I missed out on this one.
I didn’t know Cashes version was a cover because I heard it first, and then a few days later I heard the studio version and now I’ve heard three different versions of the same song that all invoke completely different emotions. This song is truly incredible
Beautiful.