ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 พ.ค. 2024
- It’s been hailed as a historic milestone towards lasting peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan: Armenia said, it is willing to return several Armenian controlled enclaves to Azerbaijan. The enclaves are uninhabited - only a few people will be directly affected in neighbouring villages. But locals are angry - and worried Azerbaijan will want more land. DW’s senior international correspondent Fanny Facsar reports from Tavush province in Northern Armenia, on the border with Azerbaijan.
#azerbaijan #armenia #nagornokarabkh
Subscribe: th-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
Armenians have forgotten how Azerbaijanis were slaughtered in the 90s
Azerbaijan has the righr to defend itself and do what isreal is doing!!!
They have also forgot how Baku decided to attack the Armenians in thr 90th...
And you have forgotten how millions of Armenians have been systematically cleansed from the caucasus for the past 500 years
theres not enough proof on the highly-speculated Khojaly Massacre being done by Armenians at all, and is the only claim Azerbaijanis use against Armenia, do some research on all the other massacres being do against Armenians in the 80s and 90s: Kirovabad-pogrom, Sumgait-pogrom, Baku-pogrom, Maraga-massacre, Operation ring. you only spread misinformation.
No you forgot how AZeris slaughtered Armenians in Sumgait and Baku before anything else happened.
armenia occupied those territories. they are just giving them back. Azerbaijan isn't demanding anything more than its internationally recognized borders
Ya right only a fool can trust Azerbaijan
@@mamamiya-et4uzOnly foolish claimed Armenia is always the victim.
how about Armenia's official territories occupied by Azerbaijan?
@@jima8429 Azerbaijan is currently not occupying any internationally recognized Armenian land
@@ay.4555 Of course it is, for example in Jermuk. They occupied those territories in recent years.
Someone is trying to keep that conflict alive.
Someone is trying to keep that conflict alive. someone receiving dollars from abroad
Turkey
Yes, buddhist Space lasers and the lizard people from Congo-Atlantis
if countries return occupied land those nation will be peace but if it exist occupier no peace that place when you watch western media you think who they talk are they talking 6 years old or less than that age
Pretty clear who those guys are, the throne holders in Baku and Moscow. But the west is naive and some are corrupted by Baku deals.
As a neutral observer, I would say that the key word is 'RETURN'
As a neutral observer you dont hear about azerbaijan wanting to "return" land theyve stolen from armenia proper.
As a neutral observer, you should also point out Artsvashen, Jermuk, Lake Sev, Verin Shorzha, Kut territories that have been invaded and are not being returned.
Sensible move to avoid further confrontation with a much stronger neighbor, unlike other actors in the Middle East (and elsewhere) who choose to risk (and even sacrifice) the well being of their own population for a vain ideological struggle.
@@crayonsukrou913 come back to this post in a few weeks when Baku will be asking for more concessions.
Azerbaijan will never give back Armenian villages...
Armenia is a lesson in getting stuck with bad allies. Everyone will say it is so sad but do nothing.
Do what exactly? Help Armenia with occupation of Azerbaijan's territory? No one will. Neither Russia, nor the West. Armenia must sign the peace deal and return everything it illegally occupied.
Ukraine is rhe next armenia. US only helps Israel whole heaetedly and all others are expendable. Jewlensky should have understood it
Armenia is a lesson of hypocrisy of west, as long as Azerbaijan aligns itself with Turkey nobody will question what they do because US and Europeans are too afraid to displease the Turks
@Bakvwien go tell Stalin that who threw out the Armenians and replaced with Azeris!
Armenia itself is bad, its neighbors are good and hospitable 😊
Armenian superiority complex got them in this situation. Peace agreements were offered on numerous occasions and they rejected them thinking because they won decisively in the 90s that the Azeris stand no chance against them.
Peace agreements were always rejected by the Azerbaijani side.
@@BaykarSepoyanwhy they should do? They want their land, And take it. Why you guys Acting like a Azerbaijan is the Bad Side? İn 1990 Time, Russia take Nort Gürcia, Armenia take Karabag. After 30 Years they want Peace but Armenia dont want, Not their(Azerbaijan) came and Armenia want Peace and you guys think they gonna do? Lol
@@citizenofsuperpowerindia4453 ask them. They never wanted a peaceful solution.
Rejected? Lmao, you shoud learn some history. Armenia was marching on the gates of Baku when Russia intervened to broker a ceasefire.
Azeris were never serious about peace. They always backed down at the last minute to delay and solve the conflict by force. Now they have shown to the world that conflicts can be resolved by force and Russia took advantage of this and invaded Ukraine.
"Four former Azerbaijani villages..." Wait who is actually the invader?
Azerbaijan invaded in the 90's. Got beat and lost land. Stop playing the victim.
@@massey81 With that same logic. Armenian got beat and now losing the land. So, to be what has to be.
Am I correct?
@@mohamadsyafrimunir3685 somewhat. the whole of the land in question has historically been Armenian land or inhabited by ethnic Armenians.
As in, the land was given to the Azerbaijan Soviet Socialist Republic (not the Republic of Azerbaijan) under Stalins rule. There had been no country or an ethnic group called "Azerbaijan" up until the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Or at least, in that area of the Caucasus. The majority of those living in modern Azerbaijan were Shia turkmen that moved into its modern borders when Russia seized the area from Iran.
@@massey81Armenians comes to Garabag ın 1850 years. Nothing else.
And Azerbaijan occupies over 200 square km of Armenian land right now…wait so who is actually the invader
Aww poor Armenia, did your russian daddy leave you alone again? What a shame...
No no no your mother never abandon us
look up Operation Ring if you still think Russia is an Armenian ally. They have always lied and stabbed us in the back. they have never been an ally.
hi racist
@@Khachakirner1992Good thing you're sister is with as)
Think about your sugar daddy Erdogan first🥺
Why didn't you mention that those land are internationally recognized part of Azerbaijan?
Because DW is anti Turk and Azerbaijan is a Turkic nation. You will never see DW siding with any Turkic nation even when that nation is right.
Also why didn't you mention that Azerbaijan has occupied lands internationally recognized part of Armenia.
@@haykk5375 and where would that be? Armenia is the only one occupying land
@@Ha15679 You clearly haven't been following the events, otherwise you would know about multiple Azeri incursions into sovereign Armenia during 2021-2024, including Lake Sev, Jermuk, Verin Shorzha, etc. Not to mention Armenian territories under Azeri control since the 1990s, including Artsvashen and territories from Tavush region itself.
because more internationally recognized territories of Armenia are occupied by Azerbaijan and they are not being returned by dictator Alyev.
Azerbaijan is the owner of that land from the beginning
They cry and put a tantrum like children.
Azerbaijan has no historic connection to that land. There are 1000 year old Armenian churches on that land, that Azerbaijan destroy la or converts to mosques.
azerbaijan was created In 1920 how can it be owner since beginning
🇦🇿🇵🇰
@@abhi739Armenia also born on 1920. Let me Guess, They have Thousands of History but inside of Ottoman, Seljuk, Timur, Hazaris Etc. Empires İsint? Yeah make sense
As reported by multiple outlets, the villages belong to Azerbaijan so why is there such a worry to correct this unfair situation? It’s just that a Western ally is being held accountable for a change.
yes it is unfair when AZerbaijan is not returning territories occupied from Armenia.
@@jima8429There are other enclaves and territories occupied by both sides that need to be demarcated and exchanged post demarcations.
I hope both nations overcome mistrust, hatred to live in peace.
There is a worry because now the Armenian villages are in high danger of a war that WILL come, the road to Georgia is also highly vulnerable now.
I agree that Armenia should return those villages but in return azerbaycan has to return our villages which they have occupied for the last few years. Wouldn't you agree?
Since when is Armenia a western ally? Armenia is aligned with Russia, meanwhile Azerbaijan is aligned with Turkey, a NATO member.
@@ricardoamendoeira3800 Armenia wants to go away from nato and join the EU and NATO , they have also begun having talks with western nations and training with America because Russia betrayed them
EU will protect Armenia, in the same way it protected Ukraine and Georgia.
Unlikely considering the EU's geopolitical relationship with Israel, Turkey and Azerbaijan, and it's antagonism to Armenia's allies, Russia and Iran.
Gosh, I hadn't realised that Ukraine and Georgia had joined the EU!
Armenia was being protected by Russia but failed.
good sarcasm
The eu did nothing to help Ukraine in 2014
Interesting video. So Armenia did occupy and still occupies some Azerbaijani territory!!? We've been told repeatedly Azerbaijan was the aggressor. Something is wrong :)
That's not how it is ) one must study a bit to have objective opinion.
No your still wrong
Welcome to western media....
Nice to see you wakeup
It is the Soviets who tried to weaken Armenia. It was Stalin, which was an Azeri that decided to give parts of Armenia to Azerbaijan.
So, don't come telling me that it is Azerbaijan land when these Bolshiks are rotten criminals.
Ajarbaijan will of course take back its internationally recognized lands
and when they will return Armenia's internationally recognized territories occupied by Azerbaijan?
When will the Turks return back to Xinxiang??
@@vivviv4497 maybe tomorrow ? maybe this week. i dont know. too sleepy.
@@kizgintosbaga why is your head hammered by any chance?
And not give back Armenian land...
I'm really confused with DW's coverage. The territory in question is legally Azerbaijan's land. They just want their land back. What is wrong with that? How can DW oppose Russia's land-grab in Ukraine, but on the other hand to support Armenia taking land from its neighbor? This entire coverage of DW makes no sense!
Problem is that for Azeri it is not enough. They had this land before 94' but that didn't stop then from killing Armenians.
If you look further in the past you will see a trend: Azeri and Turks together successively killing Armenians and taking their land. Armenians now own maybe 10% of their native territory, and still Turkic peoples wants more...
Greece, Armenia and Israel are nothing on their own. They depend on other countries. They take advantage of this dependency situation to achieve gains. Nuisance countries from their tovals point of view.
just more research will give you totally different opinion. That is not just a territory, that was Armenian land for thousands of years, till the beginning of 1900's when Russians and caucasian turks (nowadays aka azeris) started to invade Artsakh (Kharabagh). Even during Soviet Union, it was mostly populated by Armenians, even some cities and villages were totally Armenian. The story of how by some paperwork it belonged to azeris, that is another theme.
how about Armenia's official territories occupied by Azerbaijan?
@@ErikVardanyan so you owned the lands that you werent even a majority ? you people and your tiny imagination.
Ironically Armenia and Azerbaijan are probably the closest to a peace deal they have been for decades.
Armenians maintained peace for 35 years. Israeli and Turkish military weapons and OIL money inspired war. Azerbaijan is a dictatorship.
but with losing so much territory, so sad :(
@@lastsovietspy Nobody lost any territory.
Azerbaijani sovereign territory was returned to Azerbaijan. The first step to peace is the resolution of disputed territories.
@@reubenmcmurray4377its not sovereign, azeris are responsible for the eradication of the armenian ppl there. azeris will never know peace. they will always be at war. forever.
@@reubenmcmurray4377thats ur opinion bud.
isnt Karabagh officially Azerbaijan official territory. its war i understand but in the whole video this isnt even mentioned once nice work DW
good thing this video wasn't talking about Karabakh territory then
It is not. It is an autonomous region, historically and ethnically Armenian, that was ethnically cleansed by Aliyev's dictatorial regime in Baku.
DW cannot be trusted. Indeed, not once did the DW mention that those 4 villages are sovereign territory of Azerbaijan, illegally occupied by Armenian, and the Azerbaijani inhabitants of those villages were killed or forced to flee for their lives. There are graphic videos of the aftermath of the massacre of Azerbaijani inhabitants in one of those villages.
@@PhillMacwasn't that Stalin?
Hos is i officially Azerbaijan? It never was Azerbaijan past break up of USSR... Same as Donbass was not Russia after the breakup... but it was Russia before USSR
This area is officially Azerbaijan. No need to cry that you have lost your land. If you have owned the area before the war, just prove it and live in Azerbaijan.
Azerbaijan: a country with a Latin alphabet, Iranian culture, Turkish language and Saudi religion that claims everyone else stole from them (even the crescent on their flag is "borrowed" from Byzantium)
@@haykk5375 classic armenian nationalist 🤡
@@dhjddjjejdjf1680 When arguments run out they use personal insults to make a point.
@@dhjddjjejdjf1680but is he wrong ?
@@haykk5375 First of all, Azerbaijani language is an Oghuz branch of Turkic language family which Turkish and other languages belong, too. And language families are pretty common. About the alphabet, you can find old Turkic alphabet and it exists, the reason why we do not use it anymore is hidden in your allies - Russia and Iran)
"Iranian" culture, the name Iran started using when Pahlavis came in power which obviously was in 1920s whereas Azerbaijani people and there culture were here pretty long ago so logically it is not possible, and if you are talking about Persian, that is an open discussion, there are lots of things we share in common however we both have our unique features as well) That cannot be count as "Persian culture"
About the religion, so you do not say like Russians adopted Byzantium Religion, isn't it? That is exactly the same, obviously)
The crescent part is just hilarious like I have not heard anything more funny than it ))
Probably you don't know similarities and what similarity and culture exchange mean as most of the Armenians consider they invented the culture, language and everything exists in the world.
My friend, try to be a bit realistic. Altough I believe you will start attacking me probably just because you faced with reality but let's hope not so) Have a nice day)
DW not try to be much armenians than armenians
Russia’s guarantees to Armenia was limited to Armenia’s land. Karabagh was occupied Azerbaijani land by Armenia over 30 years, and Putin made it very clear that security agreement did not include Karabagh. Armenia fought to keep occupied territories knowing this.
Today's borders between Armenia and azerbaijan was drawn by Stalin and kemalist turkey according to Moscow treaty March 1921
Armenian borders are defined by the resolution of the league of nations in Aug 1920 which includes not just upper karabakh but also lower karabakh and nakhicevan.
When armenia gets rid of russian agents and occupation. This issue will be raised in international court. Specially after the defeat of Russia in Ukraine.
@Rsiz
Nailed it !
Occupied? Nagorno Karabagh was ALWAYS Armenian lands until Stalin attached to the newly created territory of Azerbaijan as an Autonomous Oblast. Massacres occurred throughout 1920’s, 1990’s, 2020’s denying legal self determination and ending in Ethnic Cleansing. Get your facts right.
Russia is a weak country. Was anybody serioualy expecting that bolshevik run nation to help its closest ally?
Azerbaijan is not a glutton country as once Armenia did. They solely want to get back what belongs to them. Armenia willing to give these cities voluntarily so that they could escape an another conflict. While two countries manage to establish the peace, European media blows up the fire.
Exactly
Land is legally Azerbaijan.
Azerbaijan doesn't exist as a country it's Aran and shervan , it's called Azerbaijan fakely by USSR for political abuses ! shame on you
What about land that is legally Armenian then?
@@haykk5375 What about it
@@99muamer99 Why is Azerbaijan illegally occupying and not returning it?
@@haykk5375 that question is for the Armenian president, and if there is such land Azer. should return it.
The question should be who owns the land in the first place, you made mentioned of return the land to Azerbaijan but you make it sound like Azerbaijan is forcefully talking Armenian land
The whole of Armenia will be Azerbaijan land in a decade. Aliyev has the upper hand, and no one can save Armenia.
historically speaking, a large chunk of azeri territory is originally armenian...
It belongs to mother earth, the plants and animals... If u all leave there will be peace
@@BakvwienWhat makes that land Azeri more than Armenian?
@@jewiesnew3786Crimea is Ukraine by law. it doesn't matter if it was historically Russian
They call them Turks as insults uhmmm they are Turks. Azeri is Turk. What a reporting style
War, war, war, mankind can't live in peace.
sadly true . people keep fighting over a land after being brainwashed by greedy politicans , god help us.
dude this is not war. this is basically some group of villagers dont accept internationally recognised border, refuse to have Azerbaycani IDs but dont mind getting material Azerbaycani support. Enogh is enogh.
Thanks to UN for not able to control wars all around world. Its high time to reform UN security council or this world is doomed.
And if you compromise for keeping peace, people gonna say you gonna look weak like these guys did. FFS what they expect from Armenia? Keeping those occupied lands ang give Azerbaijan an excuse for war? Russia is f.ed up right now and there is no way to Armenia look strong whether concedes these lands or not. Pashinyan just saved thousands of lives.
Stay strong armenia 🇦🇲 greetings from india 🇮🇳❤
Rama is sleeping. Turks are in Maldives, checking on Rama's blood pressure.
@@almazchati4178 ?
@@almazchati4178 turks not independent power they need permission maldives still in indian control indian military still there
@@jj-uo9ti I will remind them they need permission from you. Indians are out of Maldives.
@@almazchati4178 haa haa good joke 🤣🤣 from vassal states
Small island India need permission running from Indian money
Instead of looking at Russia or the West for peace and security, sit down across the table and work something out together. If the land was previously Azerbaijan villages, then return it to them and give alternate lands to the villagers. The problem is not Armenia or Azerbaijan but politics... opposition party trying to go and incite people for their personal gain over the country's peace. Once you have such people, outsiders will fund them for their own good, and within no time you will see Russia and NATO fighting another war using soldiers from Azerbaijan and Armenia.
Nip the evil in the bud, have patience and compromise a little bit if you have to instead of playing in the hands of others. A peaceful region is good for both countries.
Spoken like a true clueless person on the situation and history of relation between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Armenians have always been the lamb of sacrifice in the hands of Russia and the West to get Turkey's and its little vassal brother state of Azerbaijan's favors.
@@Arshahan Yes, the sacrificial lamb that occupied 20% of a nation for good part of three decades and ethnically cleansed its habitants.
I don’t really like how you compare Russia and the west. The west has made huge efforts to not target civilians. Push Israel to back off.
Meanwhile Russia , a dictatorship, kills hundreds of thousands of women and children in Chechnya, Georgia, Syria and now Ukraine.
Putting the west and Russia in the same sentence is an insult.
Those 4 villages are indeed sovereign territory of Azerbaijan that had Azerbaijani population before the Armenian occupation. Armenian radicals want to disrupt peace efforts to keep the conflict going. It is the only way for them to stay relevant. There can be no legal arguments for occupation of another country's sovereign territory, and these local villagers playing victim simply want to continue to use property that does not belong to them
Its not that easy Armenia is willing to give up those lands for peace but its Azerbaijan who is not willing to negotiate at all there is an important road where a large percentage of trade goes as well as a major gas pipeline from Russia on that land, but Azerbaijan isnt willing to do a trade for land, they aren’t willing to return large parts of internationally recognized parts of Armenia back to Armenia, they are using force and threats of war to define the border between the two countries. They are purposely delaying peace because Russia knows once we have peace Armenia will throw their soldiers out of Armenia, and Armenia will no longer be a supposed military ally of Russia.
Nigorno karabakh belongs to Azerbaijan.... No matter if this lady, s farmland is fertile. You benefitted illegally for 30 years now leave their country.
Have you watched the video? This is not about NK but about Armenia proper. Azerbaijan illegally claims territory from Armenia itself.
No , Azerbaijan doesn't want Armenia's land. These lands belong to Azerbaijan. Armenia returns them back as it should . During the war they occupied them and now they will give them back .
This is not about Karabakh. Azerbaijan occupied territories of Armenia in recent years that are inside of borders Armenia.
@@jima8429so both of them have to sit together and discuss it. War is never good
It's belongs to Armenian ...all Turkish came from Xinjiang go Xinjiang province and live under ccp rules
I do not like Armenia because they are with Russia. As an Albanian from Kosovo I have seen many Armenians unite with Serbians against us and they kept saying orthodox brotherhood against Albanians. Do I want them to suffer like they want me to suffer. NO because I am better. I hope peace will come to this region.
There's nothing left to follow Russia. Do you think Armenia would follow Azerbaijan or Turkey?;all of their neighbors have different cultures except for Russia .
husssshhhhhhhhh
@@ronaldalexanderdamiandiaz8449 Follow EU and NOT Russia. That would be better.
@@DardaniaLion but europe is far from them.
Doesn't make sense, Kosovo was mostly inhabited by ethnic Albanians, but located in another country. Arzach/Nagorno-Karabakh was mostly inhabited by Armenians, but located in another country. Why do Kosovars deserve their own country, and Armenians not?
Azerbaijani troops never saw an Armenian church or graveyard that they didn’t want to destroy. A bunch of bigots.
They invaded Azerbaijans land in 90s. Now they no choice and return it. What is the drama about?
It is tragic for Armenia to be allied with Russia which is useless to help
We been allied with Russia in the last two hundred years
Well, maybe it's time to move on.@@Khachakirner1992
@@Khachakirner1992I hope you guys don't get dragged into war with Ukraine!
@@Khachakirner1992Russians conquered Armenia many times in history. It is not an Alliance then.
@@Khachakirner1992 and what good did it do your country?
Good to see Fanny is back!. 👍
Armenia the most Northern outpost of the middle east and it's constant child like " he got a bigger piece than me"
Armenia has no oil. Azerbaijan has oil and caviar. Azerbaijan is the gas station of Turkey and Israel. This is the real power dynamic issue. Make no mistake “neutral” observers this is not an organic conflict. This is a indigenous people group of Armenians fighting against Turkish colonizers as we have for many hundreds of years
Are you ok don’t be ridiculous armania would of got wiped out if Turks were fighting them we just want what they took they lucky we don’t want compensation for what they did
Alot of people tend to forget that armenians have inhabitated the mountains for 2k+ years. Yes Azeris are turks, they speak a turkic language and have close ties to Turks on both sides of the caspian. It's like arguing whether or not Ukrainians or Russians are Slavs.
Azerbaijan clearly has the economic initiative with baku oil fields, and Russia just staring from above, while also working with turkey and iran to get a cut of the oil proceeds by assisting in setting up future gas/oil pipelines. I wouldn't be surprised if russia hopped in later to swoop that oil or if Armenia found some natural resource in the ground that the West values and realligns priorities. But as it stands, if EU can't even agree on Ukraine policy, they won't touch armenia with a 6foot pole
France will always stand with Armenia 🇫🇷🇦🇲
France stand with Algeria first you jokers
Only India and of late France have stoodby Armenia as everybody were busy with Ukraine while appeasing Azerbaijan for its energy resources!
That's how politics are done. You prioritise! The same way how India is prioritising not to support Ukraine and help Russia to overcome sanctions.
Speaker of congress Pelosi visited and spoke about Armenia before she lost power. Same as she did with Taiwan.
@@JH-pv6rd so you are searching for sympathy? Every country looks for their interest first...by the way we are supporting to no one nither Russia nor ukrain..we always advocate for diplomacy...we help ukrain interms of humanitarian aid and at the same time we are not helping Russia by purchasing their oil instead we help our own Indian people's despite being the 5th largest economy still we have to overcome poverty so we can't afford to stop purchasing oil..we are also helping the world by purchasing Russian oil so that others buyers can get their oil from other markets..if India start buying from other market then oil price will goes up
@@JH-pv6rd India is doing their very best by providing military equipments to Armenia and also made several statements when both countries facing to each other..so what your tiny country do for Armenia? Nothing so stop writing against India
@@JH-pv6rd Oversimplification India just wants diversification of World Currency Reserves hence it supports the BRICS currency. No where does it count as "support for Russia". The more multipolar the world the better it is. Unipolar & Bipolar are terrible options as shown by Cold War. India is right to support the BRICS currency
Euronews continues to regret what happens to armenians, no word about rights of about one million of Azerbaijanis expelled from their homes, 30 years of lands occupation and many more. As always showed one side of coin, thanks God they screened UN adopted map.
🇮🇳India❤Armenia🇦🇲
Khalistan and Kashmir ❤ Azerbaijan.
Whoever attacks Azerbaijani land is attacking Turkish land. Greetings from Turkey to our brothers in Azerbaijan. God bless the Turks. 🐺💪
Pakistan supports us. Azerbaijan pakistan🇦🇿🇵🇰🤝🤝🤝🤝✊✊✊
watching from Grenada in the West Indies. the war should be against poverty. these fools to help the poor all they do is fight for lordship ignoring the simple things that matters
the guy said literally, ... "there is no alternative, but to RETURN land to Azerbaijan" . yet he seems dissatisfied that the land is RETURNED to it's rightful owner. :)
DW news, are you forgetting what you were reporting on just a couple of months ago?
The Turks just want to finish what they didn't in the early 20th Century. Azerbaijan is ethnically Turk....not sure why that's a surprise to educated people!
Things have changed. Azerbaijan is getting closer to Russia and Armenia closer to NATO. Hence the difference in reporting.
@alexlazar4738 yes Armenia is getting closer to EU, but Azerbaijan biggest backers are Turkey and US, please explain? I'm quite sure Macron went to Armenia offering security guarantees.
@@8739paulstep7 In the US Empire understanding of the world, not willing to sanction Russia, China and Iran or fight them and die as a proxy (like Ukraine and "hopefully" Taiwan) ) means "getting closer to the US enemies". Neither Turkey nor Azerbaijan are willing to do either of those, so the current situation can be considered as "getting closer".
Armenia with its small population and orthodox heritage has little value as a proxy so it is largely ignored by both sides.
@@alexlazar4738 Armenia isn't Orthodox though?
India will protect Armenia❤
I'm curious. Why? What links are there?
How, by writing comments?
@@dlkdyscot it's the defence deal just Google it..if Armenia engaging more defence deal with India...then India will surely help
@@JH-pv6rd India being a sleeping giant that does not mean we have to attack Azerbaijan..just search Azerbaijan leader condemning France and India for weapon supply...India will first appeal to both the nation to refrain from war.. diplomacy is best option
@@JH-pv6rd guess what if Armenia increase its military equipments import from India and in the mean time Azerbaijan attack Armenia..then India surely defend Armenia by force not like issuing statement
Nothing will change Azerbaijan will behave in same way !
We Indians support Armenia accept mulla and alu
no one cares
It doesn't need to be protected if doesn't occupy regions that are legally and based on UN resolutions belong to its neighbor
Stay strong Armenians. Greetings from Serbia.
??!
😂😂😂😂
If you support Armenia as a Serbian, it means that you support independent Kosovo. These territories aren't Armenian, they were just taken from Azerbaijan by Armenians illegally
nationalism is so evil
@@seymurnovruzov1016liar 😅
*🇦🇲Armenia should really consider applying for 🇪🇺EU membership & become a Candidate (like its neighbours 🇬🇪Georgia & 🇹🇷Türkiye) - it has much better democracy ratings than either of the 2 candidates.*
The EU can't do anything even with full Armenian membership and it's not their business to get involved anyhow.
Remember, it was germany which facilitated the mass slaughter of Armenians across the Ottoman Empire over a century ago. This news story is mostly a crocodile shedding its tears.
@@Perri_Redder I said EU not NATO, can you read? The point is moot anyway because Azerbaijan are close partners of NATO anyhow.
as a puppet state who had stolen it neighbours land and riches now forced to return those … what a candidate is ARMENIA. :)))
@@onurum10 They would just be puppets of America.
The land is legally Azerbaijan's unfortunately for Armenia. At the same time, Azerbaijan shouldn't be an agressor as well. There is a give and take for negotiations.
As a Filipino, far from these lands - I respect and support your opinion brother. Basically these two countries are fairly small, and tucked between major powers. Possibly a great opportunity for two countries to be SMART enough to cooperate and perhaps find other solutions to help as opposed to a war.
The world has too many wars. Avoid this one and establish peace. Show the bigger guys what you’re truly made of. Tiny nations like the Philippines from the east are watching and hoping and excited for the outcome!! ❤
I agree but Armenia has done lots of giving, where as Azerbaijan, not so much.
yes, wise words
Yes sabah is Philippines
7:08 a big mistake. BIG. Russia does not have any obligation on officially recognized Azerbaijani territory and armenians accsuing Russia of that should look to the map and CSTO again.
how about Armenia's official territories occupied by Azerbaijan?
@@jima8429 where is such territory? There is only an enclave but Azerbaijan has more enclaves not displayed in this video.
Keep hope Armenia. Stay strong. Your are not defeated and will not be defeated. Give them nothing.
Do you read news?
Whoever attacks Azerbaijani land is attacking Turkish land. Greetings from Turkey to our brothers in Azerbaijan. God bless the Turks. 🐺💪
Why not Germany? They should step up and try to protect Armenia if threy are ''sincerely'' concerned.
Whoever attacks Azerbaijani land is attacking Turkish land. Greetings from Turkey to our brothers in Azerbaijan. God bless the Turks. 🐺💪
This is not an easy decision for a PM, I think he called Moscow and he was told he is alone. No one is coming to their rescue.
Haha😂😂
The whole perspective is from the Armenian side, i think this should be both side.
Azerbaijan will not respect the international recognized borders later. As they have planned to extend their's territory further in the region step by step. However, it would then be a start to the end of eastern Turkey, tiny European land portion , and of course the entire country of Azerbaijan for erver.
cut the nonsense. Azerbaycan is basically drawing internationally recognised borders.
Whoever attacks Azerbaijani land is attacking Turkish land. Greetings from Turkey to our brothers in Azerbaijan. God bless the Turks. 🐺💪
The problem is Armenians that are close to the border don't want to see anyone in the vicinity. EU has to hold training / courses for Armenian villagers on good neighboring skills.
EU should hold training courses with Aliyev family on being less dictatorial.
I wish everyone would accept their international borders and leave it at that. Both countries should swallow their pride and move on.
That video shows who is invader and racist: "They (reference to Armenians) call them Turks - which is an insult". Yes that is the thing, there is so much hate against Azeris and Turks in Armenia that, they forcefully expelled all Azerbaijanis living there and killed the remaining ones.
Azerbaijanis are proud ethnic Turks. DW is wrongly reporting it as “insult”.
yeah I've never heard an Azerbaijani being offended at being called a turk
Saying Azerbaijanis are Turk is like Saying Brazilians are Portuguese
@@PatriotOfPersia sort of but Turk is referring to the Turkic ethnic group with Kazakhs, Uzbeks, tatars and more
@@PatriotOfPersiaI'm Azerbaijani and Turk.We are Azerbaijani Turks🇦🇿
@@turkoguzlu8578
Turks with J2 Hapologroup?😂
When you say "returned", what do you mean really?
To the people saying that Azerbaijan has a right to take back their internationally recognized land: Remember that Armenians have been living there for thousands of years and were persecuted by the apparently innocent azeris and turks for hundreds of years.
Whoever attacks Azerbaijani land is attacking Turkish land. Greetings from Turkey to our brothers in Azerbaijan. God bless the Turks. 🐺💪
@@unsalbulent How is that a relevant reply? Just make that a comment lmao
The host is like: "Armenia's Prime Minister says there is no alternative but to return lands back (!) to Azerbaijan. Why is that?" Because those are the internationally recognized territory of Azerbaijan?! What do you mean why? Logic..
And Azerbaijan will return Armenian territory, right? And give Armenians full minority rights in Arzach, right?
@@PradedaCech maybe in a few decades
@@PradedaCech Not at this time, Azerbaijan has not even mentioned to give back any lands or allow full minority rights in Artzach; Azeri's just want all of their lands back from Armenia but aren't willing to give any back to Armenia; They say we can all live in peach, you can stay where you are, you don't need to leave but as we have seen in past, when they took over Artsagh, they destroyed Armenian churches and monuments.
"This road belongs to Azerbaijanis and we are not giving them" said Armenian woman. Now the questions. How to sign a peace with them? Will this peace work?
Stay strong Armenia 🇦🇲 greetings Malta 🇲🇹
Why they occupied Azerbaijani lands???
Because Azerbaijan is committing genocide against Armenia @@alihanaydogdu6158
@@alihanaydogdu6158 the land so called occupied was populated with 95% of Armenians for thousands of years ... 1991 there was a referendum to be united with Armenia PLUS by UN law nations have right for self determination but azerbijan started a war.
@@Khachakirner1992 Irrelevant, It's recognised as Azeri regardles of demographics. If thousands of russians made a majority in a part of Azerbaijan it wouldn't be considered Russian because they happen to number more.
@@Khachakirner1992 There was a significant Armenian population only in the city center, the remaining rural areas were the lands of Azerbaijani people. The Armenians who committed the Khojaly genocide displaced and killed thousands of people. And the total Armenian population in the occupied lands did not even constitute the majority.
Here, Azerbaijan teaches the whole world a lesson in humanity. They could have done like the Armenians and taken revenge.
Ohhh plz no war 😢
As a person who dug into the history of the 2 countries, Armenia. (Wich is the older country of the 2.) Originally owned Karobach for 3000 years before Azerbaijan. Then azerbaijan took the land (in the time of the USSR). After that they were fighting for alot of things
No way Armenians can blame the Azerbaijanis. They have only themselves to blame. Armenians have NOT ADHERED to more than 50% of their legal binding obligations. When they signed the surrender peace treaty. Like providing the maps indicating exact locations of the thousands of land mines. Providing a passage through Zhengzhou. Many more obligations Armenians refuse to abide by.
Read the 9 points again. The first 8 were abandoned by Azerbaijan but you expect Armenia to respect the 9th point? Also Azerbaijan still as Armenian pows, political prisoners and occupied land near Jermuk and Goris.
Armenian stay strong, make peace treaty with India , America and western country to save country's land
Azerbaijan Stay Strong, we Khalistan support you, Just like a Kashmir, Khalistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh with Many of us. Khalistan ❤Azerbaijan
Whoever attacks Azerbaijani land is attacking Turkish land. Greetings from Turkey to our brothers in Azerbaijan. God bless the Turks. 🐺💪
@@unsalbulentwhy should we defend a nation that has a history of oppressing ethnic minorities and Genociding them?
Kurds, Armenians, Slavs
As well as being aligned with Israel
Very interesting.
I feel truly sorry for unfortunate geographical and political neighbourhood Armenia is stuck in. I hope there won't be another war there. Sending loads of love to Armenia from Lithuania ❤
is it fun being a chihuahua ? do you think you can take on russia ? complete joke
@@robo__cop8154 don't worry nobody in Lithuania is planning to attack Russia 😂
If it was up to us, we would forget about their existence but unfortunately they constantly remind about themselves by attacking their neighbours.
😂😂
🤣🤣🤡
Armenians need to fight for their land if they want to keep it. Having said that, Armenia choose the wrong partner.
They should seek help from India and france..Russia has nothing to offer and same goes to west
It's not their land, they occupied it.
@@ashis2486 Indi will never send troops to Europe again...never, especially against Russian wishes
@@icu17siberia if it necessary India will care about none..we are not listening to usa😂 and you are talking about russia
Azwrbaijan is just getting back its internationally recognized land back. What bothers you?
If the villages belonged to them in the first place I don’t see any problems
People have very small information about karabakh and how the country of Azerbaijan was created. Armenians been in that region for 3000 years but Azerbaijanis live there maybe for 100 years. It’s not that hard to research about that.
Whoever attacks Azerbaijani land is attacking Turkish land. Greetings from Turkey to our brothers in Azerbaijan. God bless the Turks. 🐺💪
I knew this was coming if Russia ever had to hit maximum combat capability in Ukraine, and it has. It's the same reason Georgia is in the middle of mass rioting and has the potential for a coup. I hear things are going better for the more democratic powers in Syria. This war was likely the worst decision russia has made in 100 years. It would not have happened without COVID. That's one heck of a rabbit hole.
one of the few sensible comments here
India will back Armenia with arms. No one can do anything... Let Modi come next month in power...
haha India also provided weapons in the 2020 war but Indian weapons are useless my friend 😅
China occupied Indian Land without any fire this is shameful for Indian whole nation
Armenia: oh, y ahora, quién podrá defenderme?
Chapulín:
YO!!!
Nadie, Saludos de Turkia
Oh i thought trading territory for peace was a sin.
As usual DW news, the German broadcaster has doubled standards. The entire territory recognizes as Azerbaijan lan and the had two war over this land recently and Armenian government agreed to return land in the name of peace and than the Armenian will have all border doors opened for visit and doing business and also Azerbaijan saying that the Armenian farmers and what have you can stay and we will treat them as Azerbaijani citizen and we will even give them passport but trouble maker like German tv is trying to create more problems for people to suffer and even start another war between Armenia and Azerbaijan just like what they been doing for so many times. I truly believe once they return the Azerbaijani land than they will have peaceful life together for ever if those evil minded politicians and governments let’s them.
Yes, now please return Northern Cyprus to Cyprus
Ah yeah no, you dont want that...
But you want these villages....
Double standards, ha?
@@frankozrin5611
When you don’t know the facts and the history behind it than no need for me to teach you or discuss anything with you because you don’t know the truth and you can’t handle the truth. Please educate yourself then come back. Stay safe and healthy.
Azerbaijan has the righr to defend itself and do what isreal is doing!!!
@@aldemir6127 What are the facts ? There are UN resolutions about Cyprus
It is occupation of another state's territory
Do you agree that Turkey should also return the occupied land back in the sovereign state or not?
Azerbaijan is currently occupying parts of Armenia. When will it be returned?
Painfully motion to loose your Home in the name of peace
Things had been calm before that nobody Pashinyan came to power. That’s a great example what a country can turn into when you choose a guy from the street.
Things were calm before Russia decided to invade Ukraine. Turkey and Azerbaijan just used an opportunity when Russia is occupied and weak, regardless of who is ruling Armenia.
@@JH-pv6rd One has nothing to do with the other. Azerbaijan, being ruled by a delusional autocrat, has long been involved in distorting history and has even gone as far as to claim Armenia as part of Azerbaijan.
Meanwhile Armenia’s new pro-Western government has worsened relations with Russia (the country that is supposed to defend Armenia should Armenia be attacked). Pashinyan’s folly is astounding.
@@maxbounce5736 Russia simply is no longer feared as before. They showed the entire world how weak they are. Also they are busy in Ukraine, they cannot afford to be involved in other conflicts, so they sacrificed Armenia. Azerbaijan used an opportunity.
@@JH-pv6rd Russia is “weak” yet somehow (based on the msm) if it’s not stopped in Ukraine, it’s going to conquer half the world or whatever.
Azerbaijan used an opportunity to do what exactly? Attack the neighbor? The Azeri government can barely pass as a civil one. It’s as close to Europe as, say, Afghanistan.
Guys these situation is so easy to understand. Basically these are historically Armenian lands which Armenia took in 1994. In 2018 after the velvet revolution in Armenia a pro western government came to power witch Russia didn't really like so Russia just gave the Azerbaijan the green light to start a war and get the land it desired so long. Russia or more correctly the USSR knew that its hard to control a union witch is so ethnically diverse and had to plant this so called time bombs which in case the USSR got weaker this bombs would go off and this countries wouldn't manage to live together (divide and conquer) and that's the reason USSR gave Artsakh which was 90% inhabited by Armenians to Azerbaijan and it is now an internationally recognized land of Azerbaijan. This signature can be find all over the post USSR countries, to name a few Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Georgia, Ukraine. So the problem isn't really between the before mentioned countries but really between Russia and the West.
oww my goddd. not this again.
Wasn’t Armenia ruled by Ottomans for hundreds of years? I’m pretty sure Turkey and Azerbaijan are working to take control of Armenia. Unfortunately for Armenia it is sandwiched between Turks, Russians, and Persians. Too small to defend itself indefinitely
The Ottomans (today Turks and Azerbaijanis) came from Xinxiang invaded lands in Armenian, Kurdish, Greek, Assyrian and Byzantine lands and never left. The whole of Azerbaijan and Eastern Turkey belongs to Armenians and Kurds!!! The Ottomans have to be brought to their knees. Their WW1 debacle has to be repeated!!
@@vivviv4497 Turks were always in Caucauses. The whole area belonged to Khazar Khanate, a ally of Romans, as early as 500CE. Khazars became Seljuk dynasty, and incroporated Uyghur Karakhan Khanate. Turks expanded into Mongolia, but did not originate from there.
no. we have no intention to take control of armenia, give them citizenship, representation in congress. they should be in their country.
@@kizgintosbaga Speak for yourself.
@@vivviv4497You are like me, When ı lost on Online Games. Ahah you guys living on Clouds, somethinks are never change
Pashinyan and Armenia learned an incredible lesson. The only door to Europe is through good relations with Türkiye and Azerbaijan. There are good developments between Türkiye and Armenia, but of course DW does not broadcast them. Because "chaos is a ladder". Pashinyan will first open the borders and then the state archives to historians, first the country's economy will be saved, then the whole world will see that there was no genocide. The diaspora in the West will also be unemployed and find a new toy.
👍
It is the Turkish economy that needs saving not the Armenian economy and our relations with European countries have nothing to do with Turkey or Azerbaijan.
Armenian archives are open to everyone and independent historians overwhelmingly state that genocide has occurred. As for peaceful relations that depends on Turkey and Azerbaijan, if you truly want peace then acknowledge your own mistakes as Armenians are doing and return occupied Armenian territories in Jermuk and Goris.
@@strpet27 🤡😂😂😂
All and everything seems to be about land recently and not about human rights and self-determination.
There is no easy solution to this conflict. People from both Azerbaijan and Armenia need to live together peacefully there. It should be part of Azerbaijan, but with a special status and guarantees for Armenians who have roots there. Similar to Northern Ireland, there must be some kind of Good Friday Agreement.
Praying for Peace on Earth ❤
Armenians should protect Armenia
I think thats what they are doing but are outnumbered 8 to 1. Then if you add the Turkish advisors assiting with Bayraktar drone operations and Syrian mercenaries in which are Turkey's proxies the number goes up to like 13 to every 1 Armenian.
@@AR9Legendu forgot to mention Martians and Klingons!
@@storm5514 That was the news around the Western World. Although in Az and TR I could imagine it would be vastly different. This is considered Turkish Airlines is basically terror airlines in which shipped those mercs to NK. Also Azeris dint have the capabilities to operated the Bayraktars without Turkish assistance which is why there were Bayraktar control centers with TRs operators within Azerbaijan. I could provide countless sources all in which were publish by Western sources. The opposite story line is only pushed by TR and AZ media.
This not defense this invade
@AR9Legend clown 🤡🤡
Azerbaijan is trying to take as much Armenian land as it can
True
You do not need to have university degree to understand what is going on. Azerbaijan say’s lets have peace agreement but same time Azerbaijan President and all Azerbaijan nation openly says that our capital city Yerevan is an old Azerbaijan city and it belongs to them and some day they will take it back. Now tell me lovely adequate people of the world how it is possible to say two different things at the same time. Azerbaijan President and all Azerbaijan people say openly that historically Armenian kingdom never existed and all Armenian historical land belongs to them
In Karabakh there are Armenian churches from the 9th century and who is occupied.
Why doesn't Azerbaijan, or should I say Alioff, leave occupied Armenian territories?
Ask him directly.
Whoever attacks Azerbaijani land is attacking Turkish land. Greetings from Turkey to our brothers in Azerbaijan. God bless the Turks. 🐺💪
This is Armenian land and this is disgrace. Armenia always was and will protect its self!
armenians 🤡
it cant protect itself, armenia has a small population and a weak military, no offence...
@@itsmagic573 haha who are you to say this my nation has a decades history for reason
@@allapetrosyan2199 yes but this is a fact, your country relied on Russian forces to protect them but they disappeared revealing the true weakness of the nation. Unfortunately it is not what it once was, it is weak now
My takeaway is that DW News is not a news channel for me, in my kindest words 😂
Atikian If you don't know, I'll write Azerbaijan Republic was established in 1918. The Republic of Armenia was founded in the same year. Azerbaijani Turks had small feudal states in this geography (Iravan Khanate, Karabakh Khanate, Nakhchivan Khanate, Baku Khanate, etc.). Before that, there were states created by Azerbaijani Turks; Seljuklus (with Turkish and Turkmenistan heritage), Atabays of Azerbaijan, Elkhanis (Hulakus), Aggoyuns, Karagouns, Safavis (Gizilbas), Afshars, Qajars. But only Armenians inform about the country called Armenia as a primary source. This is also in question
We are here for 8000 years Azerbaijan only 100 year these lines belong to Armenia
When you realize that the name of your capital is the same as the old Azerbaijan Khanate, you'll probably be disappointed, but as long as you're happy, that's all that matters.
This video is totally biased, significantly favoring armenia in this conflict though armenia is the real aggressor.
That's what you get siding with Russia, back stabbed for their interests.
Armenia should also consider returning ancient Georgian lands to Georgia.
Javakh which houses large Armenian population still belongs to georgia and yes Armenia wanted that land, but failed. In other hand Abhazia was taken by ethnic Armenians with the help of Russia and chechen mercenaries
@@edwardvalivonis23 It's not "Javakh but Javakheti and it has always been a Georgian land. Armenians living in that region were resettled there by the Russian Empire in the 19th century.
@@eagleeye182 vici eg. Magram somhebs undodat tsartmeba. Igive ponts gegmavden rogor abhazetchi gaketes. Saakashvili rom ar ikos prezidenti axla javakheti ikneboda somhetis teritoria
everything is not so simple, the borders that exist on the map were drawn in the USSR as internal, economically sound maps. In fact, after the collapse of the USSR, these turned out to be time bombs, completely inconsistent with interstate borders. Look closer - this is a sick imagination. And now, having weaker positions, Armenia has to make blatant concessions
are those borders are internationally recognized or not ?