Let's stop the charade the Palestinians have actually had numerous opportunities to create an independent state, but have repeatedly rejected the offers: In 1937, the Peel Commission proposed the partition of Palestine and the creation of an Arab state. In 1939, the British White Paper proposed the creation of a unitary Arab state. In 1947, the UN would have created an even larger Arab state as part of its partition plan. The 1979 Egypt-Israel peace negotiations offered the Palestinians autonomy, which would almost certainly have led to full independence. The Oslo agreements of the 1990s laid out a path for Palestinian independence, but the process was derailed by terrorism. In 2000, Prime Minister Ehud Barak offered to create a Palestinian state in all of Gaza and 97 percent of the West Bank. In 2008, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert offered to withdraw from almost the entire West Bank and partition Jerusalem on a demographic basis. In addition 1948 to 1967, Israel did not control the West Bank. The Palestinians could have demanded an independent state from the Jordanians. On the contrary whilst Jordan was in control Arafat said there was no longer a claim as it was no longer part of Palestine. Once it was back in Israeli hands it miraculously became disputed land again! This is one of many reasons Jews and Israelis are cynical. The Palestinians have spurned each of these opportunities.
Five separate times the, so called people of Palestine, have rejected a state of their own. They have maintained the three No's from Khartoum. No Peace, No Recognition, No Negotiation.
@@marccovitz5289 Listen to an actual historian has to say, Benny Morris: The Palestinians do not want a state if it means sharing Palestine with the Jewish people. "Look, I don’t think the Palestinian leadership, really matter what plan they’re offered. Trump’s plan, Clinton’s plan in 2000. They say no. They don’t want to divide the country with the Jews. This is the basic thing." The Palestinians own PSR surveys show two thirds want a return to violence and do not want to see two states living in peace. The Palestinians want all of what was Mandate Palestine. So, the time for waiting for a Palestinian leader to make peace is over. It is time for Israel to impose a solution on the Palestinians.
@@marccovitz5289 When the Jewish State of Israel was brought into being at the United Nations in 1947 it was roundly rejected by the Arab states. Arab immigration into the part of Palestine in which the Zionist enterprise was being developed dynamically by the Jews had increased the Arab population on the West Bank of the Jordan River. The other larger parts of what had been Palestine, namely Transjordan, as well as Syria, and Egypt, were still backwaters, offering little employment or development to its people. The Jews employed this immigrant source of labor despite the fact that acts of violence and murder were committed by Arabs on Jews. Jews in the land suffered decades of bloodshed and murder at the hands of the Arabs going back to the massacres in Safed and Hebron in 1929. So it continued, including murderous raids by what were called “fedayeen,” an early form of Arab terrorism. In 1948 the fledgling Jewish state was attacked by heavily armed and trained Arab armies. The war was initiated by the Arabs for the purpose of driving the Jews they did not kill into the sea. Victory over the newly-born state seemed inevitable. Combined forces from Iraq, Syria, Jordan, Egypt, supported by arms and soldiers from Lebanon, Yemen, and Saudi Arabia, attacked the undermanned and barely armed Jewish nation. Less than three years from the horrors of the Holocaust, Jews faced yet another genocide. The outcome, however, was a resounding defeat for the Arabs that left Israel in situ over a larger territory and the local displaced Arabs in despair. The Arab hatred of the Jews and their desire to remove the Jewish presence from the Middle East was not erased. The new narrative purported to give the lie that the Jews woke up one day and decided to execute ethnic cleansing against the indigenous Arab population. Not true. The intended ethnic cleansing of 1948 would have been of the Jews at the hands of the invading Arab armies. Another myth is that the Palestinian refugee problem is the fault of the Jews. Not true. Documented numerous orders and statements where the Arab leadership and Arab states ordered and instructed the locals to abandon their homes and possessions. It was the Jewish leaders, and even the Hagana (the newly formed Israeli army), that implored them to remain. It was the Arab military and political leaders and the Arab states that were exclusively implicated in the mass exodus of the Arab population and for the personal tragedies suffered by them. Nowhere is this more implicitly expressed than by Emile Ghoury, who was the Secretary of the Palestinian Arab Higher Command. In an interview with the Lebanese newspaper The Beirut Telegraph on September 6, 1948 he said: “The fact that there are these refugees is a direct consequence of the act of the Arab states in opposing partition and the Jewish state. The Arab states agreed upon this policy unanimously and they must share in the solution of this problem.” The Nakba, then, must point directly at the Arab leadership and not at Israel. It is a tragedy that thousands of Arabs remain in Arab refugee camps to this day. It is a tragedy perpetuated by Arab nations in conjunction with the United Nations who chose to keep them in this status for a political purpose in order to use them as pawns in their ongoing campaign against Israel. The obscenity of the decades old Arab refugee problem is completely down to the failure of the surrounding Arab nations with the collusion of the United Nations who are both guilty of perpetuating this human crisis.
Diversity of opinion is expected in a constitutional republic or a democracy. Israel nor the Arabs should dictate what should be said or the way in which things are voted.
The point of truth he made !!!!! is they must fight the evil amongst themselves first, as WeThePeople. As We must come first as One Nation under God. Made in the USA
Dude! 61 years I’ve grown old to this bullshit! Neither side can learn apparently. I have no sympathy for either side. Let them handle it like Republicans love…fight it out like then OK Corral!
Israel is Jacob, Isaac's sons from Abraham Read Your Bible Old Testament 1st book called Genesis, that's All you have to do to find out, or the 2nd book called exodus, all about Moses, and All the continuing books of the HOLY BIBLE that follow, They were around way before hamas or hezbollah, Israel had that land 1st, YHWH (GOD) gave it to the Jewish people (Israeli's) 4,000 years ago before muslims were ever around,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
@@djcflash I know that. What I’m saying is, they were all one people and in-fact lived to together before 1947 completely normal. They look alike, hmm probably since the same father and the Israelis today, have nothing in common to the original Israelites that’s a fact
Dual citizenship should end. Goes for members of Congress too.
Definitely. They are the ones creating wars and send our children there.
Mm
For members in office, yes.
No one who's loyal to any other country should be in office
thats why dean needs to drop out
Exactly. Just about all of our politicians are so beholden to Israel, it's completely weird and wrong.
The democrat party shares a lot in common with a certain sociolist party for nearly 100 years ago.
What socialist policies Democrat has?
There is no such party as the "Democrat" Party. It's " Democratic Party".
@cyborgishere9551 that's not where I was pointing.
@@noneyabizz8337 then what is common between Democrats and socialist?
@@cyborgishere9551 ugh, you're that simple?
Racism.
Great suggestions. He must have forgotten the “Palestinians” elected hamas in a free and fair vote. They want Hamas.
Hamas is not so different from the right wing cabinet in Israel.
Afterall, there is no real Palestine or Palestinians and never has been. They're simply Arabs from the surrounding area.
It was not a free and fair vote.
And Israel again elected Bibi
they haven't had an election since 2006, and 50% of the population were born before 2005, the majority of the population did not vote for hamas
enemy within
Let's stop the charade the Palestinians have actually had numerous opportunities to create an independent state, but have repeatedly rejected the offers:
In 1937, the Peel Commission proposed the partition of Palestine and the creation of an Arab state.
In 1939, the British White Paper proposed the creation of a unitary Arab state.
In 1947, the UN would have created an even larger Arab state as part of its partition plan.
The 1979 Egypt-Israel peace negotiations offered the Palestinians autonomy, which would almost certainly have led to full independence.
The Oslo agreements of the 1990s laid out a path for Palestinian independence, but the process was derailed by terrorism.
In 2000, Prime Minister Ehud Barak offered to create a Palestinian state in all of Gaza and 97 percent of the West Bank.
In 2008, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert offered to withdraw from almost the entire West Bank and partition Jerusalem on a demographic basis.
In addition 1948 to 1967, Israel did not control the West Bank. The Palestinians could have demanded an independent state from the Jordanians. On the contrary whilst Jordan was in control Arafat said there was no longer a claim as it was no longer part of Palestine. Once it was back in Israeli hands it miraculously became disputed land again! This is one of many reasons Jews and Israelis are cynical. The Palestinians have spurned each of these opportunities.
Five separate times the, so called people of Palestine, have rejected a state of their own. They have maintained the three No's from Khartoum. No Peace, No Recognition, No Negotiation.
Sorry Sir, your history is completely inaccurate.
@@marccovitz5289 Listen to an actual historian has to say, Benny Morris: The Palestinians do not want a state if it means sharing Palestine with the Jewish people.
"Look, I don’t think the Palestinian leadership,
really matter what plan they’re offered. Trump’s plan, Clinton’s plan in 2000. They say no. They don’t want to divide the country with the Jews. This is the basic thing."
The Palestinians own PSR surveys show two thirds want a return to violence and do not want to see two states living in peace. The Palestinians want all of what was Mandate Palestine.
So, the time for waiting for a Palestinian leader to make peace is over. It is time for Israel to impose a solution on the Palestinians.
@@marccovitz5289 When the Jewish State of Israel was brought into being at the United Nations in 1947 it was roundly rejected by the Arab states. Arab immigration into the part of Palestine in which the Zionist enterprise was being developed dynamically by the Jews had increased the Arab population on the West Bank of the Jordan River. The other larger parts of what had been Palestine, namely Transjordan, as well as Syria, and Egypt, were still backwaters, offering little employment or development to its people. The Jews employed this immigrant source of labor despite the fact that acts of violence and murder were committed by Arabs on Jews. Jews in the land suffered decades of bloodshed and murder at the hands of the Arabs going back to the massacres in Safed and Hebron in 1929. So it continued, including murderous raids by what were called “fedayeen,” an early form of Arab terrorism.
In 1948 the fledgling Jewish state was attacked by heavily armed and trained Arab armies. The war was initiated by the Arabs for the purpose of driving the Jews they did not kill into the sea. Victory over the newly-born state seemed inevitable. Combined forces from Iraq, Syria, Jordan, Egypt, supported by arms and soldiers from Lebanon, Yemen, and Saudi Arabia, attacked the undermanned and barely armed Jewish nation. Less than three years from the horrors of the Holocaust, Jews faced yet another genocide. The outcome, however, was a resounding defeat for the Arabs that left Israel in situ over a larger territory and the local displaced Arabs in despair.
The Arab hatred of the Jews and their desire to remove the Jewish presence from the Middle East was not erased. The new narrative purported to give the lie that the Jews woke up one day and decided to execute ethnic cleansing against the indigenous Arab population. Not true. The intended ethnic cleansing of 1948 would have been of the Jews at the hands of the invading Arab armies.
Another myth is that the Palestinian refugee problem is the fault of the Jews. Not true. Documented numerous orders and statements where the Arab leadership and Arab states ordered and instructed the locals to abandon their homes and possessions. It was the Jewish leaders, and even the Hagana (the newly formed Israeli army), that implored them to remain. It was the Arab military and political leaders and the Arab states that were exclusively implicated in the mass exodus of the Arab population and for the personal tragedies suffered by them.
Nowhere is this more implicitly expressed than by Emile Ghoury, who was the Secretary of the Palestinian Arab Higher Command. In an interview with the Lebanese newspaper The Beirut Telegraph on September 6, 1948 he said:
“The fact that there are these refugees is a direct consequence of the act of the Arab states in opposing partition and the Jewish state. The Arab states agreed upon this policy unanimously and they must share in the solution of this problem.”
The Nakba, then, must point directly at the Arab leadership and not at Israel. It is a tragedy that thousands of Arabs remain in Arab refugee camps to this day. It is a tragedy perpetuated by Arab nations in conjunction with the United Nations who chose to keep them in this status for a political purpose in order to use them as pawns in their ongoing campaign against Israel.
The obscenity of the decades old Arab refugee problem is completely down to the failure of the surrounding Arab nations with the collusion of the United Nations who are both guilty of perpetuating this human crisis.
@@marccovitz5289 I don't take a side on this issue but "No you're wrong" isn't an argument.
They should be put out of working for our Government in Congress.
I'm hoping to see a title called, "15 PEDOcrats get deported"
why? Because US should support genocide? Any idea what Israel has been doing in the past 75 years?
Amen man
Father God, protect your son and lead him further to Truth..may repentance and obedience grow in his heart.
I agree with him!!
God forbid if he doesn't include the LGBTQIA+PRS and sometimes Y in his talking points.
This is an excellent example of why I don’t vote libertarian
He’s not a libertarian.
You're a genius.. he's not libertarian.
OK Can't vote for Dean Phillips either.
Those democrats must expelled
He's right.
The old thumb nail is showing Pressley with fake hair. 😂😂😂
Good for you wanting peace and trying to stop this atrocity.
Name names. Who the Dems that voted against supporting Israel?
Diversity of opinion is expected in a constitutional republic or a democracy. Israel nor the Arabs should dictate what should be said or the way in which things are voted.
Very thoughtful answer. He is usually very smooth. However, he is very emotional here.
He should run against netanyahu, and implement your ideas there.
That’s because they refuse to support Israeli war crimes not because they support Hamas.
The point of truth he made !!!!! is they must fight the evil amongst themselves first, as WeThePeople.
As We must come first as One Nation under God. Made in the USA
Well said Dean Phillips
Yep this man is going nowhere quickly!
NO... LGBTQ !
Dude! 61 years I’ve grown old to this bullshit! Neither side can learn apparently. I have no sympathy for either side. Let them handle it like Republicans love…fight it out like then OK Corral!
The DNCCC will make sure Phillips never debates the "agreed upon" candidate.
He's shown way too much common sense so far.
I think we know it will be Nancy's nephew. That's why she's running again at 80.
@@readmylisp and he's one of the slimiest of the swamp creatures.
Cook The Irrational Numbers
The Win Is Simply Bigger .
As you are campaigning rep dean. We aren't the Israeli parliament nor are we referees. Ooorah sunblock6🪴
One decent moderate Democrat!
No jews in live in gaza that should speak miles if your real a republican you should make bill to secure southern boarder Dean
That is new and fresh political sympathy towards both Israeli and Palestinians. That is great 👍
So much hot air.
Settlements?
Israeli settlement pushing into areas where conflict is apt to happen, after being told NOT to!
What about self determination for native tribes living on reservations here in America?
Of great, just what we need, more Whataboutism...
When was Israel magically created ? And after that how did Israel magically take 95% of the area? Just asking for friend
Israel is Jacob, Isaac's sons from Abraham Read Your Bible Old Testament 1st book called Genesis, that's All you have to do to find out, or the 2nd book called exodus, all about Moses, and All the continuing books of the HOLY BIBLE that follow, They were around way before hamas or hezbollah, Israel had that land 1st, YHWH (GOD) gave it to the Jewish people (Israeli's) 4,000 years ago before muslims were ever around,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
@@djcflash I know that. What I’m saying is, they were all one people and in-fact lived to together before 1947 completely normal. They look alike, hmm probably since the same father and the Israelis today, have nothing in common to the original Israelites that’s a fact
Congratulations to you for sticking up for the Palestinians