EdP is King no doubt. Even the next morning dry down is magical. I get a sweet musky mossy with a little cherry deep in the skin the next morning that makes wanna cuddle with my own hand.
With plum cherry and almond notes in there I'm imaging it has a faint scent of a boozy bakewell or marzipan type feel I love gourmand fragrances I can't wait for the cold weather so I can start wearing all the winter fragrances
Yeah I cannot agree with the hype generated by some reviewers some stating this being the best release of 2020, I give that accolade to Pasha de Cartier EDP. I find this fragrance very nice but a tad stuffy with its blending, too many strong accords clashing. It does smell really nice but I find the EDP smoother and more comforting with the incense so I prefer the EDP. My overall favourite from the line is the Cologne. But hey thats just my two cents, each to their own. Great comparison video my friend :)
I fully agree with you about everything you said! The best designer release of this year is, without a doubt, Pasha de Cartier Parfum and also my favorite flanker is the Cologne flanker! 😁👌👌 I don't understand why Guerlain replace it with the Cool flanker... Thank you for your ongoing support my friend 😊🙏
Have them both I think the edp is more wearable like fall winter and maybe spring, I wore extreme for Christmas I think it's the best pick for super cold weathers. :)
i ordered extreme from fragrance x last night after learning that it was no. 1 for the 2020 fragrances on fragrantica and multiple positive reviews, saying things like "this is what the EDP should have been" etc. however, this channel and some other reviewers, seem to suggest that it doesn't perform all that well which is a bummer. i mostly buy long lasting stuff like dior sauvage, azzaro wanted by night, moschino toy boy, bvlgari aqva atlantique etc. i hope extreme will hold up.
I tried the edp version side by side with Stronger with you intensly, I think they both are in the same realm,but the L'Homme edp got approval from 3 different ladies. It is quite versatile as he mentioned. Overall,as a soŕt of fresh with a touch of warmth,I will without a doubt give it 10/10
EDP is one of those scents that you keep smelling your hand. Yes is sweet yes is soft yes it’s not versatile and not complex. The underlying attributes of EDP is exactly that: a soft sweet gourmandish simple scent but that you get easily addicted to it. I just got a backup bottle in case they decide to discontinue or reformulate. I have my father the EDT (new), as there was no point using it after I came across the EDP.
I was in a tough position. I have edt. Should I get edp or Extreme? I've tried both of them for 2 weeks. Extreme to me is more wearable, versatile. The plum note is much better than the sour cherry note. Also, that tobacco note with the leather note is just so good. In the end, I bought extreme. I'm not saying edp is a bad fragrance. It is not. But If I would have to choose which one to wear and buy, definitely Extreme. Good video! Thank you!
First of all, great vid! About the ideal edp... I have both the new and old bottle and they do in fact smell different. I am not the one to start false rumors and I hate those people. But yeah, they do smell different
Good and nice review. Your reviews are getting very nice and more higher in terms of knowledge of note break down for your audience. I going to get it.
Have the EDP, find it quite sweet/gourmandy and very unisex, would particularly like that smell on a woman. Was considering the Extreme, but in a faceoff together with Prada Luna Rossa Black and Bvlgari Men in Black, the Luna Rossa won for me. I find the Extreme actually a bit rough, probably the pepper. My favorite from the L'Homme Ideal line is still the Cologne.
Mine too! 😁 The Cologne flanker is my favorite from this line and I have yet to understand why Guerlain replace it with the Cool flanker, which is terrible, imo. I have to revisit Luna Rossa Black, but I remember to enjoy it when I tried it
I wouldn't call this the best house in the world,but for the price range,it is very good. But, have you ever tried on Xerjoff? Good lord they smell exquisite. Very elegant,but very pricey. I would say for an avid fregrance guy/gal, you have to have at least one Xerjoff in your collection. I have bought I think 6 samples of Xerjoff from luckyscents, whenever they arrive, I will update you guys and etc you know kw which one I picked to buy a full bottle.
@@Roozy_Persepolis I have 11/12 fragrances from Xerjoff and although it's one of my favorite niche brands, I still think that Guerlain is the very best fragrance house out there.
@@ScentedMoments hmm,well let's agree to disagree 😉 will you do a complete Xerjoff review? So interested to see your opinions and see which one's are your favs
Great review, João! I bought the EDT version and when I went to check the batch code I discovered that it is from 6 years and 4 months ago. It's still sealed. Do you think I'd better return it and look for a newer batch? Thanks!
That boozy plum sounds like a delicious winner!!!! I need to get my nose on this one. Thanks for sharing and putting out the great content, Mr. Joao!!!!
Great review, João! I'm on the edge of buying this, after EDP and Cologne, and I was wondering if you are still enjoying wearing this? I think it's a lovely scent but slightly forgettable.
@@ScentedMoments good quality review as usual. I just got the Loewe7, its a definite winner I wore it to a get together and it got a lot of compliments
Could this work in the spring or summer nights? Or is it strictly for the fall and winter seasons? I have the edp version which I'm in love with at the moment.
Doesn’t Project, Low Sillage, Good Smell but its a skin scent, basically you’re smelling your hand but no one else will notice, i tried in evening, morning, afternoon it doesn’t projects
Where did you buy it? Edp sticks to my clothes for 4-5 days. From my skin I can catch the wiffs for 5 hours. I sprayed once behind my ear today, 4 hours passed and when I move my head I catch the smell
Extreme is the best of the line. It's very well balanced. I don't really reach for the EDP, I like Cologne, EDT and L'intense better. 1a. Extreme 1b. Cologne 2. EDT 3. L'intense
The Cologne version is my favorite from the line! That grapefruit/almond blend is done masterfully! So smooth, fresh and natural smelling 😍 to this day I don't understand why they replaced it with Cool, which is waaayyy worst... L'Intense is ok. I think it's a bit redundant, but it has a nice spicy kick 😊
@@ScentedMoments really good points. Losing Cologne is very disappointing. I agree, the blending of the grapefruit and almond is top notch. Great content as always. 👍🏾
@@engell3707 😂wow, you really took that personal😂😂😂. If it makes you feel better, just believe your own words, I won't offend your sensibilities any further😂😂😂😂
The EDP is still my favorite, but Extreme is still excellent! I’m just a sucker for a cherry note in a fragrance! Great review as always João!
Thank you so much my friend 😊🙏 yes, at this moment I also do prefer the EDP as I love that cherry/Tonka bean blend 😍
EdP is King no doubt. Even the next morning dry down is magical. I get a sweet musky mossy with a little cherry deep in the skin the next morning that makes wanna cuddle with my own hand.
Guerlain L'Homme Ideal has to be one of my favorite designer lines. Really can't go wrong with either the EDP, Extreme, or even the L'intense. IMO
I would also add the original EDT 😁 for me, L'Intense is a bit redundant, but it has a nice spicy kick. Great line nevertheless 👌👌
Extreme by far my favorite of the line, maybe my most fav for autumn 🍂
With plum cherry and almond notes in there I'm imaging it has a faint scent of a boozy bakewell or marzipan type feel I love gourmand fragrances I can't wait for the cold weather so I can start wearing all the winter fragrances
Yeah I cannot agree with the hype generated by some reviewers some stating this being the best release of 2020, I give that accolade to Pasha de Cartier EDP. I find this fragrance very nice but a tad stuffy with its blending, too many strong accords clashing. It does smell really nice but I find the EDP smoother and more comforting with the incense so I prefer the EDP. My overall favourite from the line is the Cologne.
But hey thats just my two cents, each to their own. Great comparison video my friend :)
I fully agree with you about everything you said! The best designer release of this year is, without a doubt, Pasha de Cartier Parfum and also my favorite flanker is the Cologne flanker! 😁👌👌
I don't understand why Guerlain replace it with the Cool flanker...
Thank you for your ongoing support my friend 😊🙏
I agree fam pasha de Cartier parfum Is super sexy
I own the EDP and love it. Will definitely try this one as soon as I see it at the stores.
This is my latest addition too. I just have to buy everything by Guerlain. What a House!
Ahahah I fully understand you 😁😁
Guerlain is a beast!
Have them both I think the edp is more wearable like fall winter and maybe spring, I wore extreme for Christmas I think it's the best pick for super cold weathers. :)
Both scents are truly delicious. Hard to pick, but I come back to the EDP, too!
Is the edp as sweet as Invictus or the one million line?
You did an excellent job of explaining the notes and differences between these two fragrances! 👍🏽
Thank you so much! Glad you enjoyed the review 😊🙏
i ordered extreme from fragrance x last night after learning that it was no. 1 for the 2020 fragrances on fragrantica and multiple positive reviews, saying things like "this is what the EDP should have been" etc. however, this channel and some other reviewers, seem to suggest that it doesn't perform all that well which is a bummer. i mostly buy long lasting stuff like dior sauvage, azzaro wanted by night, moschino toy boy, bvlgari aqva atlantique etc. i hope extreme will hold up.
Guerlain perfect line my favorite one L' intense ❤️
I tried the edp version side by side with Stronger with you intensly, I think they both are in the same realm,but the L'Homme edp got approval from 3 different ladies. It is quite versatile as he mentioned. Overall,as a soŕt of fresh with a touch of warmth,I will without a doubt give it 10/10
💥Amaizing parfum🔥
Guerlain l'homme ideal extreme ❤
EDP is one of those scents that you keep smelling your hand. Yes is sweet yes is soft yes it’s not versatile and not complex. The underlying attributes of EDP is exactly that: a soft sweet gourmandish simple scent but that you get easily addicted to it. I just got a backup bottle in case they decide to discontinue or reformulate. I have my father the EDT (new), as there was no point using it after I came across the EDP.
I was in a tough position. I have edt. Should I get edp or Extreme? I've tried both of them for 2 weeks. Extreme to me is more wearable, versatile. The plum note is much better than the sour cherry note. Also, that tobacco note with the leather note is just so good. In the end, I bought extreme. I'm not saying edp is a bad fragrance. It is not. But If I would have to choose which one to wear and buy, definitely Extreme. Good video! Thank you!
Get EDP. Wear it for yourself and don’t mind what people say.
Thanks for this. I'm gonna pick up the extreme.
First of all, great vid! About the ideal edp... I have both the new and old bottle and they do in fact smell different. I am not the one to start false rumors and I hate those people. But yeah, they do smell different
Ideal extreme is the best from the line for me. It could remind me of a light plum japonais, or an edt version of it.
A light Plum Japonais actually is a very accurate description 😁👌
Good and nice review. Your reviews are getting very nice and more higher in terms of knowledge of note break down for your audience. I going to get it.
Thank you so much my friend 😊🙏🙏
@@ScentedMoments your most welcome bro
Have the EDP, find it quite sweet/gourmandy and very unisex, would particularly like that smell on a woman. Was considering the Extreme, but in a faceoff together with Prada Luna Rossa Black and Bvlgari Men in Black, the Luna Rossa won for me. I find the Extreme actually a bit rough, probably the pepper. My favorite from the L'Homme Ideal line is still the Cologne.
Mine too! 😁
The Cologne flanker is my favorite from this line and I have yet to understand why Guerlain replace it with the Cool flanker, which is terrible, imo.
I have to revisit Luna Rossa Black, but I remember to enjoy it when I tried it
I love both version. I need to get extreme version. Best house in the world best..... Guerlain is best perfume house and KING 👑
Couldn't agree more with you my friend! Guerlain is simply the best 😁👌👌
@@ScentedMoments agree 💯💯🔝🎆🙌..... nice bro it is for real love it.
I wouldn't call this the best house in the world,but for the price range,it is very good. But, have you ever tried on Xerjoff? Good lord they smell exquisite. Very elegant,but very pricey. I would say for an avid fregrance guy/gal, you have to have at least one Xerjoff in your collection. I have bought I think 6 samples of Xerjoff from luckyscents, whenever they arrive, I will update you guys and etc you know kw which one I picked to buy a full bottle.
@@Roozy_Persepolis I have 11/12 fragrances from Xerjoff and although it's one of my favorite niche brands, I still think that Guerlain is the very best fragrance house out there.
@@ScentedMoments hmm,well let's agree to disagree 😉 will you do a complete Xerjoff review? So interested to see your opinions and see which one's are your favs
Great review, João!
I bought the EDT version and when I went to check the batch code I discovered that it is from 6 years and 4 months ago.
It's still sealed. Do you think I'd better return it and look for a newer batch? Thanks!
That boozy plum sounds like a delicious winner!!!! I need to get my nose on this one. Thanks for sharing and putting out the great content, Mr. Joao!!!!
It's wonderful! It feels like a lighter version of Plum Japonais.
Thank you so much 😊🙏🙏
I got this today! Love it! :) Love you too!
I just ordered this one. Now, I’m only missing the Cool release to complete my collection.
Great review, João! I'm on the edge of buying this, after EDP and Cologne, and I was wondering if you are still enjoying wearing this? I think it's a lovely scent but slightly forgettable.
Great review for a great fragrance.
Been waiting on this one, wanted to hear your opinion of it
Hope you enjoy it 😊🙏
@@ScentedMoments good quality review as usual. I just got the Loewe7, its a definite winner I wore it to a get together and it got a lot of compliments
Very happy to know that my friend! Enjoy that fantastic fragrance 👌👌
I own it recently...it has less performance than the edp version.
Could this work in the spring or summer nights? Or is it strictly for the fall and winter seasons? I have the edp version which I'm in love with at the moment.
Òla Joao, som galego e te sigo dende fai tempo. Parabéns polo canal.
Muito obrigado Victor! Forte abraço 🙏
Doesn’t Project, Low Sillage, Good Smell but its a skin scent, basically you’re smelling your hand but no one else will notice, i tried in evening, morning, afternoon it doesn’t projects
Where did you buy it? Edp sticks to my clothes for 4-5 days. From my skin I can catch the wiffs for 5 hours. I sprayed once behind my ear today, 4 hours passed and when I move my head I catch the smell
EDP Still the best.
I love the EDT and the EDP. This one though is very metallic and sour that puts me off. To me this is probably the worst from the line.
First one 😍😅😘💗🌹😎
Thank you for your ongoing support my friend 😊🙏🙏
João confirmaste uma dúvida que tinha acerca de qual a melhor também prefiro a EDP Tks
Fico contente por saber que ajudei na tua escolha 😊👌
Nice vid bro 👍👍
Thank you my friend 😊🙏
Scented Moments ur wlcm
Bucket list ✔
Funny how half of the fragrance review say there's a very noticeable leather note that comes out at the base of the fragrance.
Well, fragrances can develop differently on each skin, but on mine I barely detect any leather
Is it me or does this smell exactly like the original spicebomb?
Extreme is the best of the line. It's very well balanced. I don't really reach for the EDP, I like Cologne, EDT and L'intense better.
1a. Extreme
1b. Cologne
2. EDT
3. L'intense
The Cologne version is my favorite from the line! That grapefruit/almond blend is done masterfully! So smooth, fresh and natural smelling 😍 to this day I don't understand why they replaced it with Cool, which is waaayyy worst...
L'Intense is ok. I think it's a bit redundant, but it has a nice spicy kick 😊
@@ScentedMoments really good points. Losing Cologne is very disappointing. I agree, the blending of the grapefruit and almond is top notch. Great content as always. 👍🏾
I’m sure you got s bad batch of the EDP. There is no way your nose can like it behind the others. I’m pretty sure you don’t even own a EDP bottle.
@@engell3707 😂wow, you really took that personal😂😂😂. If it makes you feel better, just believe your own words, I won't offend your sensibilities any further😂😂😂😂
Projection and longetivity wise?
can it be used in summer?
👌
😊🙏