No doubt Hindenburg benefited massively from this.. they're in business of short selling.. that's their bread n butter..but wrapping this in Indian flag and making it as an attack on India is unjust.
@@tikz_patriot9207 But have you seen why they have large debt with Adhani's and there business , And there model of business & how banks are giving them loans on based of Stocks pledgeing? and Have you checked there Debt to asset ratio. If they want to attack they can do that with any other companies like Mahindra or Tata or Birla but why only adhani because they have issues.
@@jsjskskjsjsj japan Is explainable, their conservative approach over business practices and overworking their employees is the reason they are declining (also other asian countries copied their formula in 70-80’s and got ahead), but Adani became the third richest person all of a sudden while the whole world being in pandemic, thats more suspicious, also you are comparing countries to companies
There were some good points raised against the Hindenburg firm in this video. However for the sake of unbiased critical evaluation of the ongoing issue, this video did nothing to address the actual allegations on the Adani Group. The facts of the case: Yes, Hindenburg is a short selling company, it is just a 5 member organization , and yes it stands to profit from the fall of Adani stocks. But all of this information does not take away from the issues they raised and questions that the Adani groups have to answer, yes actually answer without hiding the veil of patriotism . The consequence that this report can have and have had on the Indian stock market is disastrous. However it is also true: a)That the Adani group have built a net worth of a 100 billion dollar in the last three years representing a 800 percentage rise when the NIFTY have shown a 50 percentage increase. b)The argument that the Hindenburg firm is a short selling company does not take away the authenticity of their report, I would argue , it proves the opposite, if they do an "attack " on a company, its more like they have found issues to exploit. You don't go after a company as big as the Adani's if your claims aren't backed by some actual verifiable evidences. c) I refuse to equate the attack on Adani as an attack on India, true, its effect will be negative overall for Indians but that does not mean Adani represents India. d) The question of shell companies is a pressing one and also the fact that , of the 28 percent of the Adani shares that were supposed to be in the open market, Adani owns 15 percent of the 28 percent through its intermediaries thus having a tight control on stock prices , artificially boosting the share prices due to obvious lower availability of shares. the 2007 SEBI ruling is one evident to that fact. e)The allegation that the Adani Group is overleveraged is true as per various other reports, including Fitch. So the point is, legitimate questions were asked, if the questions asked are false, the Adani's have enough resources to deal the issue in the proper platforms, in courts. There's no need to hide behind India . We need more Adanis, entrepreneurs who will earn and build for India, but we need them to be transparent, inclusive and accountable because we don't want billionaires who build their empires on the back of the people of India .
Yes I agree there are accusations against the Adani but the people who are accusing are the same people who are insecure by our government stance. Hence they are creating false narratives to bleed India which you gonna watch more like these in upcoming months.
Amit is not explaining any of the allegations about the shell companies in mauritius that are investing in Adani and Adani is did not give any answers about them as well, also the pe of adani stocks is insane. It is unsettling how an attack on Adani is treated as an attack on India, and Indian polity. But nice try defending Adani.
It is also true that the number of resources and assets Adani owns in India and outside has made them a concern of 'too big to fail' category. Independent investigations can be launched later in India if needed, but now if this company falls, it'll leave a detrimental effect on the Indian economy itself! I've never invested in their stocks, and I also know that they're overvalued at this point, but the boat has to keep floating or else it'll drown many!
Is this a good time to buy stocks/crypto in the Europe? I know everyone is saying stocks are at a discount and all, but just how long will It take for us to recover, obviously there are strategies to manoeuver in this present market but these strategies doesn't come common to the average folk, or am I better off putting my money elsewhere.
@@MajorCockbern I agree, that's the more reason I prefer my day to day investment decisions being guided by an inv-coach, seeing that their entire skillset is built around short & long term holdings for profit realisation, coupled with the exclusive analysis they possess, it's near impossible to not out-perform. I've been investing with a coach literally for 4years, and have accrued approx. $1.4m in net-profits thus far.
@@daviemanuel688 congrats. this is huge! mind sharing info on the coach that assists you? cos i’ve got a bunch of stocks that keeps tanking and don't know if its best to just dump amidst ongoing inflation.
@@MajorCockbern I am guided by Christy Vallen D'souza I found her on a CNBC interview where she was featured and reached out to her. She has since provided entry and exit points on the securities I focus on. You can look her up online if you care supervision.
@@daviemanuel688 just copied and pasted Christy Vallen D'souza and came across her appealing page, thanks for saving me hours of researching. I'm from hit-crisis Sri Lanka.
From their about us page: We view the Hindenburg as the epitome of a totally man-made, totally avoidable disaster. Almost 100 people were loaded onto a balloon filled with the most flammable element in the universe. This was despite dozens of earlier hydrogen-based aircraft meeting with similar fates. Nonetheless, the operators of the Hindenburg forged ahead, adopting the oft-cited Wall Street maxim of “this time is different”. We look for similar man-made disasters floating around in the market and aim to shed light on them before they lure in more unsuspecting victims.
India is exposing western countries hypocrisy who are silent on many matters including terrorism but want India to match theirs tone. India is ready to counter your fake narrative. #christophbecker
As a subscriber and as an individual who has little knowledge of finance and business I expected a clear explanation from you about what the allegations were and in depth analysis of the report , I didn't get anything instead you're just raising questions on hindenburg ( which I understand are legit) but what about their allegations on adani
Even I expected an academic answer to this. Raising questions at the Hindenburg in order to invalidate their report and findings is a logical fallacy. One should counter the arguments rather than raising questions against the one making the argument. This video seemed very bias from Amit’s side.
Anyone who's into markets can easily see Adani stocks over inflated for the last couple of years. What goes around must come around, Hindenburg or not it was bound to crash. End of the day for the Antics of Adani, retail investors will pay the price.
There are not much retail investors. There were only 4 lakh shares for public. Most of the shares owned by adani and his family and govt institutions like SBI AND LIC so they are not going to sell their shares so damage will be handled adani knew this kind of stuff ma ly happen in future so he kind of created a ecosystem for his company to survive in serious situations like this. But trust and prestige cannot be brought back.
Being overvalued is different from being accused as a fraud. Markets react to the negatives whether it is baseless or not. A correction in Adani was definitely overdue, but calling him a scam and then short selling to profit off of it shows Hindenburg's credibility.
@@Suhass149 Adani group has lost roughly 50-60℅ in a week, see that's not Normal market reaction, what that means is some big institution has sold.. Institutions won't sell unless there's some substance to the Allegations..
@@rock5989 Agreed, the fact that the market in general hasn't tanked much proves that, the perception that banks will handle it, but in the long run, Banks & institutions are public enterprises too, they can't hold for ever & are answerable too, so if the allegations are not defended satisfactorily, they will have to sell & that in turn creates a Domino effect in the market. Hence Retail will always be at the Receiving end.
@@hungryshan1507 75% of listed equity is with Adani. Even so called LIC which has lost thousands of crores, it's total assets under managements is still high above 30 lac crores. The free float value has fallen, not the fundamentals of the company. If you think markets react to substance, then you don't know what markets are. Yes I welcome the stock correction because I never invested in Adani. I can do that now with peace of mind. But calling Adani a fraud? That's just having vested interest. Short sellers are meant to create panic so that they can make money. If you consider panic as substance then I can't reason much. Highest lender to Adani in India is by SBI, but adani's loan is just 0.9% of SBI's loan books. Being a PSB, it's gross NPA is well below 6% mark. Even if we consider Adani defaults, it's gross NPA will still be under 6%. Only media and Hindenburg are the culprits here. No one else. Infact it works out for investors at least, I want Adani to fall so that I can enter at a healthy price, not because I believe he's a fraud.
Well, I watch and agree with most of your videos, but this is the one I strongly disagree with. If you have read the report you will find that Hindenburg did what SEBI was supposed to do. Hindenberg didn't invent any fact on their own, they just took their time and collected all the reports published (majorly by Indian sources) related to Adani. This bubble could have burst a long ago but all thanks to SEBI it didn't. This has nothing to do with NATIONALISM (I myself an Indian) and these malpractices and most importantly complete silence by our govt agencies like SEBI and RBI are neither good for our economy nor our democracy.
I completely agreed with you. If adani group is doing right then they do not need to worry about the report just give convincing clarifications to the public and come out strong in the market, thats all!
Exactly afterall it can one particular organization, not all private lending firms who doesn't value their bonds... Something is surely malicious... They just want to link each n every thing with nationalistic sentiments.,... poor lads
Hinderberg's reputation comes from their earlier works, Market won't respond to any shady reports. Their earlier targets were US based firms. The video would have been much more informative if you would have covered that too ! Adding to my earlier comment, Yes I do want adani or any Indian firm to succeed, to ace at everything they do. But at the same time, Adani definitely has a history of wrongdoings, therefore time is right to fix everything. Being a publicly listed firm with exposure to LIC funds, PSBs, you are answerable to us ! We won't get answers to everything we seek even on our deathbed, but we should not stop looking for answers....
There are many instances when market have responded to fake news and even on tweets made on twitter. They may have reputation but other companies too have reputation. If they can ask qs then other people can also raise qs about functioning and transparency of HInderberg.
Agree, their attacks on Nikola turned out to be one of their most important pillars on reputation was balanced. The report was so comprehensive and true, it shattered the company in many ways.
Amit Sengupta was a good content creator before, now he has gone full right-wing nutjob. Any criticism of India or Indian companies triggers him. And lets not forget how he defends Russia at every turn.
One doesn't correlate with the other. Just because they were correct about some US based companies in the past doesn't mean they will be true for adani as well. If adani was a fraud company then why are the banks that gave loans to adani aren't in a panic mode? where is the evidence for that? The banks and major institutions in India aren't negative about it. Accusations have no meaning until evidence is presented. And if Hindenburg is so transparent and sure about their report then they better file a case against adani in India and let the court decide.
I loved to see 3 images you shown Amit. It was really a meticulous work and observation. Asking questions is however rights that cannot be deprived upon.
They spend enormous amount of time and effort on this things...they need something return..also they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues... 🙄
@@vishalkrishan3432 his geography lectures are outstanding? This video is totally fabricated without going in detail of report he is justifying his so called analysis via Wikipedia 😂
1. Short selling, while controversial in nature, is an essential part of the dalal streets of the world. It helps in price discovery and keeps the perceived value in line with true value. 2. Short selling is not limited to intraday. 3. Since when popularity became an indicator of credibility? How many people knew about Michael Burry before 2008 (since you mentioned The Big Short movie)? How many people know about him now!? 4. Hindenburg published all this via their twitter handle. And their they've always described themselves as "Popping bubbles". Since when making money became an evil thing? See dada, I admire you. And I agree that there's a possibility of conspiracy behind all this. But what you've gotta understand is we're only as strong as our weakest link. And that there's fire where there's smoke.
In a few words, Adani’s pajama string was loose, and Hindenburg pulled it for their “limited partners” (aka Masters). Now Adani will have to pull it back tightly and tie it up for the future.
Sir, i have been watching your videos since years, but over the period of time, your core ideologies are also being reflected clearly in your videos. Which sounds bit uncomfortable. It will be better if you present arguments of both side and allow our individual wisdom to judge it. Thank you and we love you♥️.
I'm deeply saddened by the direction you have taken as a TH-cam content creator. You are merely speculating about their intentions like its a fact . Hindenburg put forward questions for Adani Group, to which Adani Group replied, however the replies were pretty half-assed and dodged the major points. I am a patriot who (naturally) support Indian businesses but I will never support Indian businesses who run several Shell Companies to dodge taxes and inflate their stock price. So please don't bring India and patriotism and "the west wants to destroy India" narrative here. You are only helping out the crooks. Crooks are crooks, whether they are Indian or American. Remember, Hindenburg exposed our Indian company Eros Entertainment which was running scams. Are you going to hate them for that too? And Hindenburg has no biases, they expose any company for profit. Most of their victims are American companies. Does this make them Anti-America ?? You should be thankful there are firms who are out there exposing these multi billion dollar businesses and their criminal activities. I think your should join Republic World or ABP news.
Following ur channel since 4 years, found it to be very informative & to the point. But since last year or so, you seem more like a govt spokeperson in most of the videos. Better give a balanced view.
Hi Amit SenGupta. I hope my comment reaches you. I have read Hindenburg report and most of the points which they raised was already known in the market and sebi is looking into those issue not sure what the outcome would be or im afraid to say that outcome would would actually be. Im in the market from 2012 onwards saw many ups and downs and even i do short-selling also buy stocks . As a retail investor i want adani to grow so that my stocks will indirectly benefit from it although i only done swing trading in adani stocks but never invested in stocks... you see the valuation is insane. Validated both adani as well hindenburg report and i genuinely dont find weightage in adani's report. Attack on adani is attach on India and its institutions. its completely rubbish statement i heard before. India is way beyond Adani. lot of companies which went bankrupt or vanished during the course of time and adani is no exception to it but India will stand tall and grow. Growth of India may be boosted by adant upto 1-2% but if adani falls India falls is completely bullshit. Hindenburg is just company. If there was no Hindenburg some other might come and point it out. FPO subscription i see only 10-11% retails investors have subscribed although i agree that FPO was fully subscribed but if you look at the way it was subscribed there is a question arises. A bubbly will gets busted now or later it doesnt not requires Pin to burst it. If you dont want to believe Hindenburg then you can use other reports as well. As a retails investor I only look at profits and safeguard other retail investors. Im not attached or detached to Adani or Hindenburg. I hope you do through research in your next topics specifically when its related to Equity or money markets as your words may impact people who least know about functionality of markets . Cheers.
@@tyrannde6392 i only wish people who have good number of subscribers and can make a impact on society need to do through research before posting a video.. People who invested their time in markets whos bread and butter is market can simply ignore the video but my concern is people who are in market like students and amateur investors who generally dont know much about market and relay of tips they will loose and most probably they wont come and invest in market again .. Building a confidence which was destroyed is hard job
@@rohankumar-hb1tg I agree with you though our concerns are quite different. I am more concern about the tall promises and free hand Adani group is having with the govt. They are quite inflated yet the govt is trying to make them like Samsung is to Korea.
@@tyrannde6392 Growth fuel by debt which cant be beared would tumble one day or other be it pvt institution, Govt or Individuals its a natures rule no one can escape
All of his debt have solid assets , assets that you can touch like ports at crucial location. So even if the company gors bankrupt you can recover 80% of the value.
@@joexavier4070 let me guess you are the envious one. ones who have achieved nothing in life so they hate one who have . Even if you have done something in your, how many people in your society you benefitting, how many people you are providing jobs and mean of life i guess no one. But Adani does provide all of these and a promise to future.
Because the credibility of the both the key financial regulators of India are put to question now (SEBI & RBI).. As the report came, SEBI immediately started scrutinizing Adani group.. if these allegations turn out even half to be true then this is a big exposé after Satyam in 2010.
This is for retail for institutions the have the option of borrowing security through SLB scheme in India and have a short position in long term and also note hindenburg have shorted the bonds of adani group and have used OTC derivatives listed in US markets. Do you really think corporate entities do intraday. When they are short they short for long periods of time watch The big short to better understand this concept
i hv read both reports too..i am following this guy but slowly he is turning into extreme right in every analysis and tries to counter every logical question on the ground that the west is against India..wtf we depend on western FDI/FPI for our development if they invest in India he says we r superpower in making but if they withdraw investment or publishes any report he bring nationalism in defense that west is against Modi/India. I wish he tries to maintain centre approach in the analysis
Read Machiavelli, in politics being good and fair doesn't matter, what's matter is being effective. Put your idealism aside and see reality as it is, and you will find politics is driven by self interest, people cloak their self interest in the veil of altruism to further their self interest. For example- For Britishers Sahid Bahgat Singh was a terrorist, similarly for Pakistan those Muslims who attack on Indian Army are Sahid.
I felt the same way. The analysis on this channel doesn't seem to be unbiased anymore. The sound of extreme right defensiveness is hard to ignore. Such a tragedy.
FYI Even SEBI started looking into the Hindenburg report. As you said this is to attack Indian markets, Indian market doesn't imply Adani shares, the market was very promising even though Adani shares were plunging..
The only stocks that seeing a nosedive are Adanis.. Tata was green all day, so it's absured to call this as a western Attack on India.. rather it's Apt to call Adani sinks as it's being exposed..
But still some questions raised by them are valid like many Mauritius firms 95% portfolio owning adani stocks and then Vinod Adani buying shares and Artificially boosting share prices and pledging them to get more loans . Also loan book is very high over leveraged .
@@Ravirocking88 If something happens , if he is not able pay all those loans . Then it is a problem for us, not only me. Banks won't have profits. They indirectly collect money from us through hidden charges like minimum balance. Hope that doesn't happen.
1/02/2023- Today market crashed by almost 2500 point due to obvious selling by foreign institutional investors (FII) after budget due to mayhem over Adani issue. You are absolutely right big players are really making a lot by fooling us ,as you said this is just the beginning.
They spend enormous amount of time and effort on this things...they need something return..also they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues.. 🙄
He didn’t explain precisely about what is written in the report but rather gave attack on the foundation on the group. It also means that the report isn’t fully incorrect as well. But he didn’t had balls to say that.
I hate to say that this channel has been losing its significance since the Russia Ukraine war started. If you look at all his videos, you'd find that he is justifying everything that Russia does. I'm not against him taking a side even I take Russia's side; but considering his huge subscriber base, he has to be more cautious and responsible while speaking. So, it's not surprising that he just attacks the group and some political parties without even looking at their view points.
The port will be owned by adani not india. And i don't understand when and why we are defending adani when his growth is fuelled by debt and might eventually hurt the common man. Adani might not have done anything illegal but the growth of his stocks in last 3 years and him taking more debts based on these stocks is definitely not good for the economy. Defending someone just coz he's indian is fickle and old mentatlity. We need to look at facts objectively and doesn't matter if we are being targetted or not. If there is a problem in our place then anyone can take advantage of it. Rather than solving the problem, we are seeing backlash and trying to protect the problem. Just coz someone outside india has pointed it out, doesn't invalidate the matter. And if someone in india points out then you will say you are backed by west so yeah what can we say. Keep defending people based on your affinity and nationalism.
Why shoud India own that port bought by Adani, basically we have to hate everybody who is rich right? He is Indian and whatever he does its for India... when somebody becomes rich you automatically think that he is rich by hurting common man.. really no logic at all!
Dude ADANI just cancelled their FPO. What have you got to say now huh? Also shame on you man, I didnt expect you to be the person to judge people based on their religion.
The question asked by hindenberg w.r.t Auditors and CFO of andani are very genuine questions. Such a small audit firm with such limited (almost no) experience and high turnover in CFO position shows that there is something problematic.
Are CFOs company employee? Yes. Do companies have right to hire and fire employees as they see fit? Yes. So, what is the crime exactly if Adanis changed CFOs? Is there any specific directive from SEBI or GOI to hire people of specific experienced auditors depending on the size of any conglomerate? No. Then Adanis are free to hire any auditor they choose.
Ok so you can question small audit firm of Adani. But can't question a firm with 5-9 employees that too a short seller firm. Not even a govt firm. That too founded in 2017. Wake up before it's too late. Learn about geopolitics and western hypocrisy. They talk of rights but ban Russian media. But if any asian countries or middle eastern countries does that, western countries talk of rights.
@@firstnamelastname5761 i would like to know are there any restrictions on taking loans for a company? if there aren't why people are butthurt of adani taking loans? but if there are then GOI should look into it
Sengupta is all time low, his ideology aligning with power is evident despite the topic needs a better clarity. Once your video epitomises the remedial solution for all aspiring UPSC candidates.
Your explanations are as good as Adanis reply to the Hindenburghs questionnaire. Can you explain why Adani still hasn’t filed a lawsuit to the claims of Hindenburgh
Surely Hindenburg is acting in concert with other players in the Indian capital market. Adani group's astronomical rise over the recent past in valuations, with prices (prior to the crash) at earnings multiples of 100 to 500; their facile acquisitions of two cement companies and the hostile takeover of an anti-government media company; their apparent clout with government and regulators: These have intimidated powerful people within and outside India.
They spend enormous amount of time and effort on this things...they need something return..also they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues... 🙄
Namasthê. Valid factors indeed. When company share price goes up steadily, not backed-up by growth, one will know the short selling is in the offing. I will not be surprised if Adâni group is one of the five partners of Hindenburg. If there a company that does business for social upliftment in Bhârath, that company will not covertly or overtly rub shoulders with the Government of the day. I will be laughed at for this comment for sure. But Dharmic companies need no share market. Pranâms.
@@bingchilling3377 Namasthê. Correction to your statement is necessary. Stock Exchange was formed for the purpose of raising funds to start businesses, or expand existing businesses, by an artificial person, because the going concern concept was introduced. If human beings corrupt it by malpractices, stock exchange is not to be blamed. The adharmic ventures will always fail. It might take years to fail, but eventually will fail. Hope you understand the mechanics. Pranâms.
I definitely understand the Indian investors after the Hindenburg report. Also in India the stakes involved are very very high for everyone.. including Indian govt., PM himself, pension funds, institutions.. other than retail investors. But heart to heart, almost all of us know the bubble in Adani... Nobody really needed Hindenburg to tell us something new... On many forums we have discussed the group's stocks earlier I do agree, we don't know Hindenburg, they maybe an entity without an address.. but they were the trigger that set everyone's pre-existing insecurities snow balling ... PS: Having said that, the stakes are too wide and too big, that it's difficult for all involved to let it fail.. and to let it fall... And support also shows up from every quarter !!
I subbed to him a few months back but after seeing some of the vids regarding geopolitics and india i had a hint that he's secretly a govt supporter. This vid actually cements my suspicion. His vids on different topics on geopolitics are still great but this video is a huge no no for me.
Standard operating procedures and regulatory disclosures are made time to time by the Adani group. The real target is India and MODI JI once we decided to unseat USD as the international currency. None of the Adani group companies have defaulted in the Banks and gave good returns to the investors and he is not running ponzi schemes. JAI HIND 🙏
@@deepdsd9629 logically even i felt it but at the end who cares all country do it and its been 60 years out of 75 years of india independence but never got a good leadership govt like the modi govt
Logically saying ur banks gives u 6% fd money ur pension u get the insurance company money they make all these company u listed have their core business of trading and investing in the stock market and also see when they bought adani stocks ull come to know that few years ago they bought his stocks
I don't care about the Hindenburg Report, but Adani is absolutely accountable for a lot of things. Additionally, I don't see why a democracy would forbid the Modi documentary; let the public judge it instead.
@@मित्रों-ल1ङ Did you watch the video? It only stated things that already happened in India! Just from a different perspective, if you think your ideas and mind can be manipulated by a single video and makes you believe in it. Your school didn't do a good job!
The way you choose your words it would be unfair to say they reek of impartiality. It's a completely fair observation made by an educated nationalist who knows how to mingle the words . What a waste of education, I must say.
Mr. Amit Sengupta. You are a totally BPJ supporter. You are misleading people. You have more than 1.7M subscribers. Don't mislead because of Modi & BJP love. Please
You said, without proof, that Hindeberg is an extreme left group. My experience is that short sellers, and indeed most investment companies, are precisely the opposite. They want to maintain the tax advantages that are championed by the GOP.
Hindenburg is a registered firm and Adani can file a case against them in a US court if they want to. Short selling and report writing are legally approved process.
But this registered firm has been banned from the new york stock exchange.. it means that this short selling research firm, is can not permitted publish reports on publicly listed companies of the new york stock exchange. Now the question is.. that why the authorites decided to ban this organization...if they are so transparent and legitimate? Why this organization is not reveling the source of their funds.. which enable them to short sell the targets and earn big chunks? Why this organization is so secretive?
u are totally right about hindenberg but what about the over priced shares of adani and the debt fuelled growth that aspect cannot be ignored irrespective of what different researched say
While everyone is making and taking sides of hindenburg for their own political motive, i would like to know about the 300 page reply of adani....why not learn about the both sides TH-camrs who change their profession in every video will keep publishing bullcrap to feed that crap into young minds
They spend enormous amount of time and effort on this things...they need something return..also they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues... 🙄
@@shivam_nagar69 yeah everyone is taking sides like you took side of BJP 😂. Actually we are trapped man , Previously scam-gress(congress),now BJP benefitting business magnets. Nothing changed basically.
@@nikhiltiwari6923 It is also a stretegically important location.. from the perspective of global trade. This can be a reason behind this targeted attack on the Adani group.
We have to increase transparency within the Indian economy, that's the only way to avoid manipulation from outside agencies like this , as they will do it regardless of geopolitics if it has financial gains as Indian economy gains prominence
There is already transparency problem is that nobody wants to check facts and just stand in the line to attack a random billionaire i mean sure little more transparency is needed but it doesnt make a difference becuz its enough transparency out there to get the data u need
Your objectivity and quality has dropped significantly, blinded by heavy nationalism wrapping any legitimately questionable matter into it, this may not matter much to you, but as a long term subscriber and a big fan of your previous videos which are purely based on facts and not feelings, i am disappointed. Adani stock price rise in the previous three years is definitely not normal and their debt, P/E ratio everything is questionable but all of this is brushed aside and put into one basket of 'nationalism'. There are many more Indian companies than Adani that have contributed more to Indian economy, so let's not get into that argument as i believe that argument is a foolish one to make in the first place.
I don’t give a F about American or Mexican company either its Hindenberg or LindenBerg . Only thing matters here is the question asked by HindenBerg are valid and Adani needs to answer in a valid way. We as a Indian want to know the truth .
I am a big fan of your youtube videos on geopolitics but is this for real ? I came here looking to understand the problem at hand, the accused suspicious promoter holding through offshore shells but instead i get a tin foil explaination of politics behind what is happening. I am a disappointed that the video title is totally misleading Context : The last time hindenburg did a report on the shady company Nikola, all of their accusations turned out to be true and the company got dumped to the ground
I do not understand, how this is a conspiracy. They also short sell their Us based companies. It is not a geo-political conspiracy but just basic finance😂. And what do you mean by democracy is fickle and demography is what matters. Sir, i respect you and sometimes i wonder why such talent has a bias. I still respect you sir and i have high hopes that someday you will see through everything. I have learnt a lot from you. Thankyou! Jai hind
@@evs059 lol when trth is not what you want then he is far right it's grat to be far right than to be chuslikm madarjaat liberandu randi muslim sperm eater😂😂🐖🐖🚩🚩
lol when truth is not what you want then he is far right it's grat to be far right than to be chuslikm madarjaat liberandu randi muslim sperm eater😂😂🐖🐖🚩🚩
a little more research on this topic was expected from you. You seemed pretty rushed to go to the conclusion. Make a video on their financial as you have pretty large audience they can make use of it while investing on Adani stocks.
In India, it is limited to Intraday. Traders or hedge funds have to square of their trade before market close. In US, one can hold their short position just as they do for long position.
I expected a better research Mr Amit Sengupta. As you say left has nothing better than asking questions. In this video I don't see anything better than asking questions.
Amit, your videos on geography deserve great respect.. but u have to keep aside ur political ideology while explaining issues like these. 😐 U are sounding like a BJP spokesperson man. Why make unnecessary statements that has nothing to do with this post on Adani-Hindenberg issue 🤷♂️ 5:47 "good amount of Muslim population" 2:33 "only thing the extreme left liberals are good at is asking questions" 6:27 "victim card" "oh we cannot even ask questions" Please don't go from being an Educational channel to becoming a political party TH-cam handle 👍 And i seriously didn't expect you to be using Wikipedia as a source to frame this explanation on the issue 😐 while u pointed out that "They" edited, u have not said about the possibility of it being edited even before u pointed out (or even edited by u).. it's Wikipedia 🤷♂️ i could have edited it 5 days ago so u can point it as a "fact" now. Also you didn't even mention a sentence about the previous exposé that Hindenberg made on an 'American' firm Nikola.. why? Because then it wouldn't seem like a western attack on Indian firm now? Because an American short seller going after an American firm wouldn't look like a western attack. Also you didn't mention a single sentence on the open challenge that Hindenberg threw at Adani group to sue them.. u know very well why Adani group is weary of taking this on directly, because Hindenberg knows that Adani has to open all his books if they sue them on defamation charges. These allegations are too huge to be ignored, they are still "allegations" as of now but it's evident that u are dismissing them outrightly and havnt even touched on what the allegations were pointing to 😐
Adani is not India, damn it !!! It was the same person who was getting ridiculously Rich at the time when peasants were on road including others depressed class during pandemic.
He showed the change in narrative in wikipedia page! Nowadays no business is built on tapasya but being brutal, killing competitions etc but the wikipedia edits did show the attack on Adani is to put nails in paths of Adani. Someone is wary of Adani"s rise and it entering a zone which can alter lots of things in India - "acquisition of NDTV"
Adani is just a businessman allegedly an unethical one, Indian economy growth won't be dented because of the exposure of one alleged unethical businessman.
Agree with you Sir but why only Adani group, if adani really have that strong pillar then it must have sustain this, and if you see the returns it generated and Rocket high PE(Price to Earning) and Debt to Equity of adani firms and compare it with Industry P/E ratio and Debt to Equity then it's not justified. Even before Hindenburg Report, Mutual Funds Managers who are having expertise in analysing fundamentals of Companies have hardly invested in any adani firms even after seeing their(adani) returns. And biggest reason for that is extraordinary high value of it's shares, they know that a bubble is creating and one day it will burst. And as a retail investor I have never invested in any adani firm because of their fundamentals. Now I find myself lucky after seeing all this mess. Though I hope that Adani firms recover from all this and bounce back. Even if I believe that all this, is a western conspiracy then also you cannot say that flaws are not there in Adani. There are problems with adani also that's why Mutual funds managers have stayed away from it.
Nice explanation. No sane-minded Indian wants to see Adani fall, as everyone will be impacted directly or indirectly. But who is responsible for this mess. If Hindenburg had not pointed this out today then somebody else would have pointed it out tomorrow.
Mr Sengupta I hope you read this. You are very good explainer. I did not understand few issues in this video. If possible rethink upon these issues. 1) Adani group, a private conglomerate who was accused. The group is not equivalent to whole country, neither a backbone of Indian Economy. Then why did you sound like its an attack on India or 'a conspiracy of west'. Do you think they are so idle and unemployed to sit and do all such stuff 2) Don't you think you are hypocrite? You use Instagram and TH-cam (American firms) as medium to decimate info and blame them as conspirators. Its their opinion and up to us to take it serious or not. In this globalized world taking a path means going for cold war times 3) I think you must revisit Constitution of India, it got words like democracy, liberty and freedom of expression. Therefore questioning is the duty of enlightened citizen as Dr B R Ambedkar envisaged 4) As a citizen we are against monopoly of one firm so that it shall not become an Economic Bubble. You release every video with detailed research. But this one is hinting that like you are a partner of adani firm. So please do not be in a rush 5) Coming to controversial docuseries, its just a binge watch for Gen Z. We all care for employment, farmer's well being, women safety and environment conservation. These are big issues to focus not rallying some support for a already popular person. Don't you think? 6) You are very much right about Haifa port and how important it is particularly after Israel-Lebanon treaty. Again you yourself saying that we need west for trade. Therefore a middle path between west and east. Do not worry this tradition is way older than me ,you, everybody and will stay longer than we can imagine. I hope i made sense and please do not categorize me liberal, extreme liberal, communist or right wing or any ideology for that matter..I believe in Constitution. I hope you also recognize its importance and enlighten us with your research in upcoming videos.
just do some research by ur self also go and see hindenburgs Track record they have targeted nikola cmigr like big companies succesfully i agree with amit that timing is politically manipulated but yess all allegations are not baseless.... can u imagine a $100 billion increase in adani net worth in last 3 year when nation was going through pandemic .... adani stocks are inflated .... why sbi and lic are still funding adani ...
Wow this guy came to conclusion even when SEBI is still looking into the matter, wonder what his source is! I think he's just too blind and couldn't think straight
"Fraud can't be obfuscated by nationalism " Forbes report also accused Adani of buying his own shares to increase stock price Credit Suisse bank also stopped accepting bonds of adani group... only time will tell the truth nevertheless we shouldn't ignore past track record of Hindenburg company?
Sir your observations are Right ! Adani Groups contributions to Indian Economy is huge , We should not fight over some Anonymous Malicious report. Instead we should stand firm with our National interests . 🙏🇮🇳
Yes he has done a lot by looting taxpayers 2.3lac crore which is now RBI asked banks to monitor the exposure Don't integrate a conman to a nationalism it's just foolishness
this is called being a mindless insecure nationalist. standing behind a corrupt, greedy and exploitative megacorp just because they're indian is unfathombly dumb. youre being led in groupthink.
@@aintnoslice3422 Who can be more dumb than a person who believes in some Anonymous Organisations Report on India's leading business men just aimed to destabilize the Corporate world's confidence in Indian Economy ! And Sir I don't think you have any idea about the Corporate Laws in India.
@@ravi5065 This is the right time to buy those shares especially a Company like the Adani with all those market captalization and Asset backing , it won't be long before the company bounces back !
I did not see any basis for your opinions...you have not even discussed the details of the allegations ....are you saying the whole report is baseless ?
We people easily get influenced by any foreign based organisation's statements & reports. I yet to understand why we valued them as much that they fool us for their own benefits? However it is not possible without support of someone who from among us and get benefitted from these foreign organisations; this is why we have history of 500 years slave. Thanks for this video, it's very informative & precise, and provide a broader outlook behind this whole mean tactics of HidenBurg .
It's upto investor to decide Anyone can see that Adani stocks are inflated and the they clearly launder money through sell companies in tax haven. You have to think critically not emotionally. Yes Hidenburg is short selling Adani stocks indirectly but not all of the allegations are baseless.
question: did you actually read the report or are you forming your opinion based on this content creator's video. do your own research friend and form your own opinion. remember: you are not immune to propaganda from either side
The Hindenburg issue was featured in the Washington Post at least twice in the past week. This is extremely suspicious, as the firm has 5 employees, why would at international Newspaper take it so seriously? It means that there are very powerful forces behind the attack on Adani (and India?).
They spend enormous amount of time and effort on this things...they need something return..also they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues... 🙄
@@PDMVPrayag ok, My bad, sebi main aim is to protect the interests of investors in securities and to promote the development of, and to regulate the securities market and for matters connected therewith Why they are not making official statement,they know importance of this things consequences
I love all ur geopolitical work ...If Adhani is honest one he wouldn't have any issue explaining the questions given by Hidenburg...the stocks wr over priced we all expected it too fall so none of my friends hold a single stock from Adhani firm....There was a public offering stocks jan27 to 29..first day only 0.1 subscription second day 1 percent and third day all 100%...it is suspicious...he got so much support from government... Should admit if mistake happens and correct....don't support this kind of corruption...
by the time adani responded the stocks had already tanked. their debt to equity is quite low and his companies has good fundamentals. hell bounce back again. in the corporation model of doing business which is pretty much the norm in every mahor developed country today, the govts of the day help the big players of that country, this is not just in india. nobody plays by the books once they become too big.
It's disappoiting how badly made this video was, not something I would expect from Amit. You never explained what was the entire issue was about. You simply started bashing the left, the opposition etc. You never got into why Adani group suddenly cancelled their FPO. It is sad how today people are backing capitalists who clearly have profits in their mind, not the country. You never mentioned once what Hindenburg's accusations were. You never mentioned once what Adani's rebuttal was. You never once mentioned how confident Hindenburg are, winning a law suit, if it ever comes to that. Its not cool to misguide your audience, sir.
No doubt Hindenburg benefited massively from this.. they're in business of short selling.. that's their bread n butter..but wrapping this in Indian flag and making it as an attack on India is unjust.
yes it was ana ttack on the govt indirectly and india's growth..
@@tikz_patriot9207 But have you seen why they have large debt with Adhani's and there business , And there model of business & how banks are giving them loans on based of Stocks pledgeing? and Have you checked there Debt to asset ratio. If they want to attack they can do that with any other companies like Mahindra or Tata or Birla but why only adhani because they have issues.
@@harigoli7326 check Debt To GDP ratio Of Japan
@@jsjskskjsjsj japan Is explainable, their conservative approach over business practices and overworking their employees is the reason they are declining (also other asian countries copied their formula in 70-80’s and got ahead), but Adani became the third richest person all of a sudden while the whole world being in pandemic, thats more suspicious, also you are comparing countries to companies
@@tikz_patriot9207 it's not
There were some good points raised against the Hindenburg firm in this video. However for the sake of unbiased critical evaluation of the ongoing issue, this video did nothing to address the actual allegations on the Adani Group. The facts of the case: Yes, Hindenburg is a short selling company, it is just a 5 member organization , and yes it stands to profit from the fall of Adani stocks. But all of this information does not take away from the issues they raised and questions that the Adani groups have to answer, yes actually answer without hiding the veil of patriotism . The consequence that this report can have and have had on the Indian stock market is disastrous. However it is also true: a)That the Adani group have built a net worth of a 100 billion dollar in the last three years representing a 800 percentage rise when the NIFTY have shown a 50 percentage increase.
b)The argument that the Hindenburg firm is a short selling company does not take away the authenticity of their report, I would argue , it proves the opposite, if they do an "attack " on a company, its more like they have found issues to exploit. You don't go after a company as big as the Adani's if your claims aren't backed by some actual verifiable evidences.
c) I refuse to equate the attack on Adani as an attack on India, true, its effect will be negative overall for Indians but that does not mean Adani represents India.
d) The question of shell companies is a pressing one and also the fact that , of the 28 percent of the Adani shares that were supposed to be in the open market, Adani owns 15 percent of the 28 percent through its intermediaries thus having a tight control on stock prices , artificially boosting the share prices due to obvious lower availability of shares. the 2007 SEBI ruling is one evident to that fact.
e)The allegation that the Adani Group is overleveraged is true as per various other reports, including Fitch.
So the point is, legitimate questions were asked, if the questions asked are false, the Adani's have enough resources to deal the issue in the proper platforms, in courts. There's no need to hide behind India . We need more Adanis, entrepreneurs who will earn and build for India, but we need them to be transparent, inclusive and accountable because we don't want billionaires who build their empires on the back of the people of India .
How can I contact you?
Very very well said. Totally agree with you
100%
Well said dude
Yes I agree there are accusations against the Adani but the people who are accusing are the same people who are insecure by our government stance. Hence they are creating false narratives to bleed India which you gonna watch more like these in upcoming months.
Amit is not explaining any of the allegations about the shell companies in mauritius that are investing in Adani and Adani is did not give any answers about them as well, also the pe of adani stocks is insane. It is unsettling how an attack on Adani is treated as an attack on India, and Indian polity.
But nice try defending Adani.
That is completely false elevation and hiddenberg has does not has any proof about it
Well said!
You are true👍better amit would become a lawyer for adani
It is also true that the number of resources and assets Adani owns in India and outside has made them a concern of 'too big to fail' category. Independent investigations can be launched later in India if needed, but now if this company falls, it'll leave a detrimental effect on the Indian economy itself! I've never invested in their stocks, and I also know that they're overvalued at this point, but the boat has to keep floating or else it'll drown many!
Then why are you watching his videos? 🤡💩 Clowns bot 😂🤣
Is this a good time to buy stocks/crypto in the Europe? I know everyone is saying stocks are at a discount and all, but just how long will It take for us to recover, obviously there are strategies to manoeuver in this present market but these strategies doesn't come common to the average folk, or am I better off putting my money elsewhere.
I'll suggest you find an investment coach or someone with market experience before the 08' crash to guide you amidst this inflation.
@@MajorCockbern I agree, that's the more reason I prefer my day to day investment decisions being guided by an inv-coach, seeing that their entire skillset is built around short & long term holdings for profit realisation, coupled with the exclusive analysis they possess, it's near impossible to not out-perform. I've been investing with a coach literally for 4years, and have accrued approx. $1.4m in net-profits thus far.
@@daviemanuel688 congrats. this is huge! mind sharing info on the coach that assists you? cos i’ve got a bunch of stocks that keeps tanking and don't know if its best to just dump amidst ongoing inflation.
@@MajorCockbern I am guided by Christy Vallen D'souza I found her on a CNBC interview where she was featured and reached out to her. She has since provided entry and exit points on the securities I focus on. You can look her up online if you care supervision.
@@daviemanuel688 just copied and pasted Christy Vallen D'souza and came across her appealing page, thanks for saving me hours of researching. I'm from hit-crisis Sri Lanka.
As a German I was surprised that those guys appropriated the good and totally inconspicuous name of Hindenburg for their shenanigans! :)
Could u rather provide wth us the inconspicuous name and details of hindenburg?
From their about us page: We view the Hindenburg as the epitome of a totally man-made, totally avoidable disaster. Almost 100 people were loaded onto a balloon filled with the most flammable element in the universe. This was despite dozens of earlier hydrogen-based aircraft meeting with similar fates. Nonetheless, the operators of the Hindenburg forged ahead, adopting the oft-cited Wall Street maxim of “this time is different”.
We look for similar man-made disasters floating around in the market and aim to shed light on them before they lure in more unsuspecting victims.
India is exposing western countries hypocrisy who are silent on many matters including terrorism but want India to match theirs tone.
India is ready to counter your fake narrative.
#christophbecker
I imagine it was the explosion not the name they identified with.
@@janagans3892 Hediousberg...
Amit Sengupta you seems baised, as a upsc teacher and mentor one should be neutral in providing facts regarding any issue
Can you point out where you see his biases?
Facts, please.
No he's not
Are you watching his videos for the first time??
As a subscriber and as an individual who has little knowledge of finance and business I expected a clear explanation from you about what the allegations were and in depth analysis of the report , I didn't get anything instead you're just raising questions on hindenburg ( which I understand are legit) but what about their allegations on adani
2:18
You can very much predict an intellectual position by caste in India
@@Kds140 Those who oppose politicians are anti-nationals in India. In short all dissent voice is considered anti- national.
good to see smart comments calling him out on this one, expected better from him
Even I expected an academic answer to this. Raising questions at the Hindenburg in order to invalidate their report and findings is a logical fallacy. One should counter the arguments rather than raising questions against the one making the argument. This video seemed very bias from Amit’s side.
Anyone who's into markets can easily see Adani stocks over inflated for the last couple of years.
What goes around must come around, Hindenburg or not it was bound to crash.
End of the day for the Antics of Adani, retail investors will pay the price.
There are not much retail investors. There were only 4 lakh shares for public. Most of the shares owned by adani and his family and govt institutions like SBI AND LIC so they are not going to sell their shares so damage will be handled adani knew this kind of stuff ma ly happen in future so he kind of created a ecosystem for his company to survive in serious situations like this. But trust and prestige cannot be brought back.
Being overvalued is different from being accused as a fraud. Markets react to the negatives whether it is baseless or not. A correction in Adani was definitely overdue, but calling him a scam and then short selling to profit off of it shows Hindenburg's credibility.
@@Suhass149 Adani group has lost roughly 50-60℅ in a week, see that's not Normal market reaction, what that means is some big institution has sold.. Institutions won't sell unless there's some substance to the Allegations..
@@rock5989 Agreed, the fact that the market in general hasn't tanked much proves that, the perception that banks will handle it, but in the long run, Banks & institutions are public enterprises too, they can't hold for ever & are answerable too, so if the allegations are not defended satisfactorily, they will have to sell & that in turn creates a Domino effect in the market. Hence Retail will always be at the Receiving end.
@@hungryshan1507 75% of listed equity is with Adani. Even so called LIC which has lost thousands of crores, it's total assets under managements is still high above 30 lac crores. The free float value has fallen, not the fundamentals of the company. If you think markets react to substance, then you don't know what markets are. Yes I welcome the stock correction because I never invested in Adani. I can do that now with peace of mind. But calling Adani a fraud? That's just having vested interest. Short sellers are meant to create panic so that they can make money. If you consider panic as substance then I can't reason much. Highest lender to Adani in India is by SBI, but adani's loan is just 0.9% of SBI's loan books. Being a PSB, it's gross NPA is well below 6% mark. Even if we consider Adani defaults, it's gross NPA will still be under 6%. Only media and Hindenburg are the culprits here. No one else. Infact it works out for investors at least, I want Adani to fall so that I can enter at a healthy price, not because I believe he's a fraud.
Well, I watch and agree with most of your videos, but this is the one I strongly disagree with. If you have read the report you will find that Hindenburg did what SEBI was supposed to do. Hindenberg didn't invent any fact on their own, they just took their time and collected all the reports published (majorly by Indian sources) related to Adani. This bubble could have burst a long ago but all thanks to SEBI it didn't. This has nothing to do with NATIONALISM (I myself an Indian) and these malpractices and most importantly complete silence by our govt agencies like SEBI and RBI are neither good for our economy nor our democracy.
I completely agreed with you. If adani group is doing right then they do not need to worry about the report just give convincing clarifications to the public and come out strong in the market, thats all!
Exactly afterall it can one particular organization, not all private lending firms who doesn't value their bonds... Something is surely malicious... They just want to link each n every thing with nationalistic sentiments.,... poor lads
"I myself an Indian" lol 😆 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@-Blue-_how much do you get paid Bhai?
Nationalism is an escape goat for adani so that Indian people can support him against the allegation.
Hinderberg's reputation comes from their earlier works, Market won't respond to any shady reports. Their earlier targets were US based firms. The video would have been much more informative if you would have covered that too !
Adding to my earlier comment, Yes I do want adani or any Indian firm to succeed, to ace at everything they do. But at the same time, Adani definitely has a history of wrongdoings, therefore time is right to fix everything. Being a publicly listed firm with exposure to LIC funds, PSBs, you are answerable to us ! We won't get answers to everything we seek even on our deathbed, but we should not stop looking for answers....
There are many instances when market have responded to fake news and even on tweets made on twitter. They may have reputation but other companies too have reputation. If they can ask qs then other people can also raise qs about functioning and transparency of HInderberg.
Agree, their attacks on Nikola turned out to be one of their most important pillars on reputation was balanced. The report was so comprehensive and true, it shattered the company in many ways.
@@HustlerRitesh Ok Scamgres chamche
Amit Sengupta was a good content creator before, now he has gone full right-wing nutjob. Any criticism of India or Indian companies triggers him. And lets not forget how he defends Russia at every turn.
One doesn't correlate with the other. Just because they were correct about some US based companies in the past doesn't mean they will be true for adani as well. If adani was a fraud company then why are the banks that gave loans to adani aren't in a panic mode? where is the evidence for that? The banks and major institutions in India aren't negative about it. Accusations have no meaning until evidence is presented. And if Hindenburg is so transparent and sure about their report then they better file a case against adani in India and let the court decide.
I loved to see 3 images you shown Amit. It was really a meticulous work and observation. Asking questions is however rights that cannot be deprived upon.
They have reverted it back to "Hindenburg takes profits..." in Wikipedia.
They spend enormous amount of time and effort on this things...they need something return..also they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues... 🙄
@@joexavier4070 stop spamming
Amit sengupta (Sanghi) hats off brother ❣️. Thanks for exposing yourself
If you watched him from beginning, you wouldn't be surprised. I'm still a fan of his geography lectures.
@@vishalkrishan3432 his geography lectures are outstanding? This video is totally fabricated without going in detail of report he is justifying his so called analysis via Wikipedia 😂
Liberandu spotted
@@madarauchiha5913 touch grass.
Haha butthurt leftists 🤣🤣
I just visited Hindenburg Research's Wikipedia page, and it says that it takes profit if target company's share's price decreases.
Also they have changed the number of employees from 5 to 9. Did they recruit anyone in last 1 hour?
@@srikar2311 yes 4 new indian youtubers who like to be expert into everything, from economist to investigator
Fun Fact: they don't live in india
@@shivam_nagar69 do they name those youtubers?
@@MandeepSingh-vt9hl Yes one of them is Dhruv Rathee although he's not fully Indian
@@laxmanrawat748 lol German Shepard ofc
Mark my words "Defending adani will embrass you soon and expose your biasness too Mr sengupta 🙂
Koi baat nahi.
He doesn't care probably he also invested in Adani group
😂hi bro 2024 hinde burg 2.0
1. Short selling, while controversial in nature, is an essential part of the dalal streets of the world. It helps in price discovery and keeps the perceived value in line with true value.
2. Short selling is not limited to intraday.
3. Since when popularity became an indicator of credibility? How many people knew about Michael Burry before 2008 (since you mentioned The Big Short movie)? How many people know about him now!?
4. Hindenburg published all this via their twitter handle. And their they've always described themselves as "Popping bubbles". Since when making money became an evil thing?
See dada, I admire you. And I agree that there's a possibility of conspiracy behind all this. But what you've gotta understand is we're only as strong as our weakest link. And that there's fire where there's smoke.
Hmm, hence continuing transaction in ₹ or Ruble 😏
This guy is only spreading the narrative of the current regime
Non-derivative instruments are intraday. hindenburg declared (without proof) they used non-indian & non-derivative bond market.
In a few words, Adani’s pajama string was loose, and Hindenburg pulled it for their “limited partners” (aka Masters). Now Adani will have to pull it back tightly and tie it up for the future.
@@suyashneelambugg 😜😜
Sir, i have been watching your videos since years, but over the period of time, your core ideologies are also being reflected clearly in your videos. Which sounds bit uncomfortable. It will be better if you present arguments of both side and allow our individual wisdom to judge it. Thank you and we love you♥️.
I'm deeply saddened by the direction you have taken as a TH-cam content creator. You are merely speculating about their intentions like its a fact . Hindenburg put forward questions for Adani Group, to which Adani Group replied, however the replies were pretty half-assed and dodged the major points. I am a patriot who (naturally) support Indian businesses but I will never support Indian businesses who run several Shell Companies to dodge taxes and inflate their stock price. So please don't bring India and patriotism and "the west wants to destroy India" narrative here. You are only helping out the crooks. Crooks are crooks, whether they are Indian or American. Remember, Hindenburg exposed our Indian company Eros Entertainment which was running scams. Are you going to hate them for that too? And Hindenburg has no biases, they expose any company for profit. Most of their victims are American companies. Does this make them Anti-America ?? You should be thankful there are firms who are out there exposing these multi billion dollar businesses and their criminal activities. I think your should join Republic World or ABP news.
@Tiger Filling Long Paragraph doesn't means there is common sense brother
Following ur channel since 4 years, found it to be very informative & to the point. But since last year or so, you seem more like a govt spokeperson in most of the videos. Better give a balanced view.
Exactly that's why I unsubscribed.
Hi Amit SenGupta.
I hope my comment reaches you.
I have read Hindenburg report and most of the points which they raised was already known in the market and sebi is looking into those issue not sure what the outcome would be or im afraid to say that outcome would would actually be.
Im in the market from 2012 onwards saw many ups and downs and even i do short-selling also buy stocks . As a retail investor i want adani to grow so that my stocks will indirectly benefit from it although i only done swing trading in adani stocks but never invested in stocks... you see the valuation is insane.
Validated both adani as well hindenburg report and i genuinely dont find weightage in adani's report.
Attack on adani is attach on India and its institutions. its completely rubbish statement i heard before. India is way beyond Adani. lot of companies which went bankrupt or vanished during the course of time and adani is no exception to it but India will stand tall and grow. Growth of India may be boosted by adant upto 1-2% but if adani falls India falls is completely bullshit.
Hindenburg is just company. If there was no Hindenburg some other might come and point it out.
FPO subscription i see only 10-11% retails investors have subscribed although i agree that FPO was fully subscribed but if you look at the way it was subscribed there is a question arises.
A bubbly will gets busted now or later it doesnt not requires Pin to burst it.
If you dont want to believe Hindenburg then you can use other reports as well.
As a retails investor I only look at profits and safeguard other retail investors. Im not attached or detached to Adani or Hindenburg.
I hope you do through research in your next topics specifically when its related to Equity or money markets as your words may impact people who least know about functionality of markets .
Cheers.
True, Amit is probably good only at International relations not economics I guess🤦🏻♂️
@@tyrannde6392 i only wish people who have good number of subscribers and can make a impact on society need to do through research before posting a video.. People who invested their time in markets whos bread and butter is market can simply ignore the video but my concern is people who are in market like students and amateur investors who generally dont know much about market and relay of tips they will loose and most probably they wont come and invest in market again ..
Building a confidence which was destroyed is hard job
@@rohankumar-hb1tg I agree with you though our concerns are quite different. I am more concern about the tall promises and free hand Adani group is having with the govt. They are quite inflated yet the govt is trying to make them like Samsung is to Korea.
@@tyrannde6392 Growth fuel by debt which cant be beared would tumble one day or other be it pvt institution, Govt or Individuals its a natures rule no one can escape
th-cam.com/video/TTVsg5vWMhY/w-d-xo.html
A much better analysis I guess
This video fails to look at how the Adani stock is fundamentally debt-fueled and how these stocks have violated Sebi rules
All of his debt have solid assets , assets that you can touch like ports at crucial location. So even if the company gors bankrupt you can recover 80% of the value.
Jeff bezos fan boy
@@iammuscular4326 they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues... 🙄
@@joexavier4070 i don't know but i pray to god that it's not real i don't want India to lose that much of money, respect and future .
@@joexavier4070 let me guess you are the envious one. ones who have achieved nothing in life so they hate one who have . Even if you have done something in your, how many people in your society you benefitting, how many people you are providing jobs and mean of life i guess no one. But Adani does provide all of these and a promise to future.
Truth cannot be hidden in what ever form of language you say. To hide the truth.
The same goes for people behind your ideology.
@@amitsengupta01 yup
These types of issues are fine for left & right, but for the people who is in the centre are having the biggest headache.
absolute right .......
sometimes we have to face both sides
Because the credibility of the both the key financial regulators of India are put to question now (SEBI & RBI).. As the report came, SEBI immediately started scrutinizing Adani group.. if these allegations turn out even half to be true then this is a big exposé after Satyam in 2010.
th-cam.com/video/KyeFTgjfb30/w-d-xo.html This might help
A small correction:
Short Selling in equity is limited to intraday
But in F&O it's not limited to intraday..
This is for retail for institutions the have the option of borrowing security through SLB scheme in India and have a short position in long term and also note hindenburg have shorted the bonds of adani group and have used OTC derivatives listed in US markets. Do you really think corporate entities do intraday. When they are short they short for long periods of time watch The big short to better understand this concept
i hv read both reports too..i am following this guy but slowly he is turning into extreme right in every analysis and tries to counter every logical question on the ground that the west is against India..wtf we depend on western FDI/FPI for our development if they invest in India he says we r superpower in making but if they withdraw investment or publishes any report he bring nationalism in defense that west is against Modi/India.
I wish he tries to maintain centre approach in the analysis
Feel free to find your own political narrative.
Lol tughe jo manna Hai man agar tughe lag reha Hai ki vo right hote ja reha Hai to unsub Kar na chomu
Read Machiavelli, in politics being good and fair doesn't matter, what's matter is being effective. Put your idealism aside and see reality as it is, and you will find politics is driven by self interest, people cloak their self interest in the veil of altruism to further their self interest. For example- For Britishers Sahid Bahgat Singh was a terrorist, similarly for Pakistan those Muslims who attack on Indian Army are Sahid.
I felt the same way. The analysis on this channel doesn't seem to be unbiased anymore. The sound of extreme right defensiveness is hard to ignore. Such a tragedy.
FYI
Even SEBI started looking into the Hindenburg report.
As you said this is to attack Indian markets, Indian market doesn't imply Adani shares, the market was very promising even though Adani shares were plunging..
True, the Indian stock index isnt even in the 52 weeks low even after the so called "Indian Economy" Collapse.
Lost all the respect for this dude.
@@anuragmukherjee1878 yup
The only stocks that seeing a nosedive are Adanis.. Tata was green all day, so it's absured to call this as a western Attack on India.. rather it's Apt to call Adani sinks as it's being exposed..
Yep. I unsubscribed after this video
@@LegacyUser3991 yep. He's just putting up a smear campaign against Hindenburg.
I don't want to sound offensive, but for the first time I thought this video lacked neutrality. In any case, thank you for the information.
But still some questions raised by them are valid like many Mauritius firms 95% portfolio owning adani stocks and then Vinod Adani buying shares and Artificially boosting share prices and pledging them to get more loans . Also loan book is very high over leveraged .
Is it problem to you...?
@@Ravirocking88 If something happens , if he is not able pay all those loans . Then it is a problem for us, not only me. Banks won't have profits. They indirectly collect money from us through hidden charges like minimum balance. Hope that doesn't happen.
1/02/2023- Today market crashed by almost 2500 point due to obvious selling by foreign institutional investors (FII) after budget due to mayhem over Adani issue.
You are absolutely right big players are really making a lot by fooling us ,as you said this is just the beginning.
Bro wtf. 45.85 actually 😂😂
Sensex closed positive
They spend enormous amount of time and effort on this things...they need something return..also they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues.. 🙄
@@joexavier4070 I think it's SEBI brother... And they are doing their job brother, they do regular audit and they will keep doing it in future.
@@harikrishnanjavahar6718 he is right sensex fall 2500 and nifty 600 point (hight 17972, low - 17353)
If you don't believe check it 👍
He didn’t explain precisely about what is written in the report but rather gave attack on the foundation on the group. It also means that the report isn’t fully incorrect as well. But he didn’t had balls to say that.
For some reason, report ok Adani = Attack on India. All the bots in chat seem to agree
I hate to say that this channel has been losing its significance since the Russia Ukraine war started. If you look at all his videos, you'd find that he is justifying everything that Russia does.
I'm not against him taking a side even I take Russia's side; but considering his huge subscriber base, he has to be more cautious and responsible while speaking.
So, it's not surprising that he just attacks the group and some political parties without even looking at their view points.
Isn't it clear that this Channel is a sangi channel now . I lost all respect on this guy now .
@@santhoshmuruganantham7435 it always was. I tolerate it but i also starting to think about unsubbing now.
@@evs059 yes you can unsub nobody cares
The port will be owned by adani not india. And i don't understand when and why we are defending adani when his growth is fuelled by debt and might eventually hurt the common man. Adani might not have done anything illegal but the growth of his stocks in last 3 years and him taking more debts based on these stocks is definitely not good for the economy. Defending someone just coz he's indian is fickle and old mentatlity.
We need to look at facts objectively and doesn't matter if we are being targetted or not. If there is a problem in our place then anyone can take advantage of it. Rather than solving the problem, we are seeing backlash and trying to protect the problem. Just coz someone outside india has pointed it out, doesn't invalidate the matter. And if someone in india points out then you will say you are backed by west so yeah what can we say. Keep defending people based on your affinity and nationalism.
Completely agree with your point sir.
Why shoud India own that port bought by Adani, basically we have to hate everybody who is rich right? He is Indian and whatever he does its for India... when somebody becomes rich you automatically think that he is rich by hurting common man.. really no logic at all!
Seems like you had also invested in adani group.😂
Dude ADANI just cancelled their FPO. What have you got to say now huh? Also shame on you man, I didnt expect you to be the person to judge people based on their religion.
Then wtf should he say? Islam is a religion of peace?😂😂
Finally you can conclude, India means Adani dada
Caution:- these are amit's view on this ongoing matter, not real or proved, thank you
Because you don't understand finance doesn't mean everyone jerk like you.. Thanks now take a hike
Bobo ... poor terrorists
Democracy is fickle, Demography is what matters 👏👏
Adani: Will sue you
Hindenburg: Bring it on
Adani: Left the chat
It seems like you've invested a lot in the Adani group😂
The question asked by hindenberg w.r.t Auditors and CFO of andani are very genuine questions. Such a small audit firm with such limited (almost no) experience and high turnover in CFO position shows that there is something problematic.
Are CFOs company employee?
Yes.
Do companies have right to hire and fire employees as they see fit?
Yes.
So, what is the crime exactly if Adanis changed CFOs?
Is there any specific directive from SEBI or GOI to hire people of specific experienced auditors depending on the size of any conglomerate?
No.
Then Adanis are free to hire any auditor they choose.
Ok so you can question small audit firm of Adani.
But can't question a firm with 5-9 employees that too a short seller firm.
Not even a govt firm.
That too founded in 2017.
Wake up before it's too late.
Learn about geopolitics and western hypocrisy.
They talk of rights but ban Russian media.
But if any asian countries or middle eastern countries does that, western countries talk of rights.
@@firstnamelastname5761 i would like to know are there any restrictions on taking loans for a company? if there aren't why people are butthurt of adani taking loans? but if there are then GOI should look into it
@@firstnamelastname5761 except that they cannot create shady companies to buy shares of their own company to keep up the stock price
So you mean the Big 4 auditors do awesome governance review of the great Google, FB, Uber, Amazon etc?
Sengupta is all time low, his ideology aligning with power is evident despite the topic needs a better clarity.
Once your video epitomises the remedial solution for all aspiring UPSC candidates.
This entire video was made to defend the adani in the name of nationalism.
Your explanations are as good as Adanis reply to the Hindenburghs questionnaire. Can you explain why Adani still hasn’t filed a lawsuit to the claims of Hindenburgh
Where will he file?
Surely Hindenburg is acting in concert with other players in the Indian capital market. Adani group's astronomical rise over the recent past in valuations, with prices (prior to the crash) at earnings multiples of 100 to 500; their facile acquisitions of two cement companies and the hostile takeover of an anti-government media company; their apparent clout with government and regulators: These have intimidated powerful people within and outside India.
They spend enormous amount of time and effort on this things...they need something return..also they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues... 🙄
Namasthê. Valid factors indeed.
When company share price goes up steadily, not backed-up by growth, one will know the short selling is in the offing. I will not be surprised if Adâni group is one of the five partners of Hindenburg. If there a company that does business for social upliftment in Bhârath, that company will not covertly or overtly rub shoulders with the Government of the day.
I will be laughed at for this comment for sure.
But Dharmic companies need no share market.
Pranâms.
@@himachalarana3454 then Adani group is adharmi company as it is listed in stock exchanges.🤣
@@bingchilling3377 Namasthê. Correction to your statement is necessary. Stock Exchange was formed for the purpose of raising funds to start businesses, or expand existing businesses, by an artificial person, because the going concern concept was introduced.
If human beings corrupt it by malpractices, stock exchange is not to be blamed. The adharmic ventures will always fail. It might take years to fail, but eventually will fail. Hope you understand the mechanics. Pranâms.
@@himachalarana3454 i wish tht all adharmic cos wld fail, but they dont. they do better than most n give many headaches to others.
I definitely understand the Indian investors after the Hindenburg report.
Also in India the stakes involved are very very high for everyone.. including Indian govt., PM himself, pension funds, institutions.. other than retail investors.
But heart to heart, almost all of us know the bubble in Adani... Nobody really needed Hindenburg to tell us something new...
On many forums we have discussed the group's stocks earlier
I do agree, we don't know Hindenburg, they maybe an entity without an address.. but they were the trigger that set everyone's pre-existing insecurities snow balling ...
PS: Having said that, the stakes are too wide and too big, that it's difficult for all involved to let it fail.. and to let it fall... And support also shows up from every quarter !!
I subbed to him a few months back but after seeing some of the vids regarding geopolitics and india i had a hint that he's secretly a govt supporter. This vid actually cements my suspicion.
His vids on different topics on geopolitics are still great but this video is a huge no no for me.
Standard operating procedures and regulatory disclosures are made time to time by the Adani group. The real target is India and MODI JI once we decided to unseat USD as the international currency. None of the Adani group companies have defaulted in the Banks and gave good returns to the investors and he is not running ponzi schemes. JAI HIND 🙏
@@deepdsd9629 logically even i felt it but at the end who cares all country do it and its been 60 years out of 75 years of india independence but never got a good leadership govt like the modi govt
Logically saying ur banks gives u 6% fd money ur pension u get the insurance company money they make all these company u listed have their core business of trading and investing in the stock market and also see when they bought adani stocks ull come to know that few years ago they bought his stocks
@@bois6969 Adani stock is overpriced and many private entities in the market knew it. But govt entities invested in that stock regardless..
I don't care about the Hindenburg Report, but Adani is absolutely accountable for a lot of things. Additionally, I don't see why a democracy would forbid the Modi documentary; let the public judge it instead.
But what if that documentry isn't well researched and gives false information in the form of a video.
What will happen?
@@मित्रों-ल1ङ Did you watch the video? It only stated things that already happened in India! Just from a different perspective, if you think your ideas and mind can be manipulated by a single video and makes you believe in it. Your school didn't do a good job!
@@harsha5512 So your school didn't do a good job and u got manipulated?
The way you choose your words it would be unfair to say they reek of impartiality. It's a completely fair observation made by an educated nationalist who knows how to mingle the words . What a waste of education, I must say.
Mr. Amit Sengupta. You are a totally BPJ supporter. You are misleading people. You have more than 1.7M subscribers. Don't mislead because of Modi & BJP love. Please
Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel.
Exactly, when dhruv rathee made a vedio , with national flag on background,with puncture boobs , I thought the same .
He is a pure scoundrel .
You said, without proof, that Hindeberg is an extreme left group. My experience is that short sellers, and indeed most investment companies, are precisely the opposite. They want to maintain the tax advantages that are championed by the GOP.
Hindenburg is a registered firm and Adani can file a case against them in a US court if they want to. Short selling and report writing are legally approved process.
But this registered firm has been banned from the new york stock exchange.. it means that this short selling research firm, is can not permitted publish reports on publicly listed companies of the new york stock exchange. Now the question is.. that why the authorites decided to ban this organization...if they are so transparent and legitimate?
Why this organization is not reveling the source of their funds.. which enable them to short sell the targets and earn big chunks? Why this organization is so secretive?
Amit sir is also becoming more and more political these days -_-
Nothing is apolitical these days.
u are totally right about hindenberg but what about the over priced shares of adani and the debt fuelled growth that aspect cannot be ignored irrespective of what different researched say
While everyone is making and taking sides of hindenburg for their own political motive, i would like to know about the 300 page reply of adani....why not learn about the both sides
TH-camrs who change their profession in every video will keep publishing bullcrap to feed that crap into young minds
They spend enormous amount of time and effort on this things...they need something return..also they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues... 🙄
@@joexavier4070 I think it's SEBI brother... And they are doing their job brother, they do regular audit and they will keep doing it in future.
@@shivam_nagar69 yeah everyone is taking sides like you took side of BJP 😂.
Actually we are trapped man ,
Previously scam-gress(congress),now BJP benefitting business magnets.
Nothing changed basically.
An explanation only Republic TV can provide ...... Kudos
even I own adani stock...but this explaiation is beyond .....any sense
Haifa port is good investment & will further strengthen Indo Israeli ties.
@@nikhiltiwari6923 It is also a stretegically important location.. from the perspective of global trade. This can be a reason behind this targeted attack on the Adani group.
I came here to know the issue but found out it’s paid partnership with adani group 😁😁
😢😢🙂
We have to increase transparency within the Indian economy, that's the only way to avoid manipulation from outside agencies like this , as they will do it regardless of geopolitics if it has financial gains as Indian economy gains prominence
There is already transparency problem is that nobody wants to check facts and just stand in the line to attack a random billionaire i mean sure little more transparency is needed but it doesnt make a difference becuz its enough transparency out there to get the data u need
Your objectivity and quality has dropped significantly, blinded by heavy nationalism wrapping any legitimately questionable matter into it, this may not matter much to you, but as a long term subscriber and a big fan of your previous videos which are purely based on facts and not feelings, i am disappointed. Adani stock price rise in the previous three years is definitely not normal and their debt, P/E ratio everything is questionable but all of this is brushed aside and put into one basket of 'nationalism'. There are many more Indian companies than Adani that have contributed more to Indian economy, so let's not get into that argument as i believe that argument is a foolish one to make in the first place.
Everyone is noticing....#PeopleChange
Yes they are short selling, but they don’t make false statements.
Lol. You would have supported Harshad Mehta instead of Sucheta Dalal.
Bhai I never expected this from you. Please stop taking sides......
chacha burnol lagao
Why ? How do u know he is taking sides?
Bhai he gave you logical points and now it's up to you how you take it.
I don’t give a F about American or Mexican company either its Hindenberg or LindenBerg . Only thing matters here is the question asked by HindenBerg are valid and Adani needs to answer in a valid way. We as a Indian want to know the truth .
Do neutral analysis... don't take sides... only one side of issue covered
When Adani stock started falling. I started buying 😂😂😂. Thanks Hidenbarg. 😂
Same here
I am a big fan of your youtube videos on geopolitics but is this for real ? I came here looking to understand the problem at hand, the accused suspicious promoter holding through offshore shells but instead i get a tin foil explaination of politics behind what is happening. I am a disappointed that the video title is totally misleading
Context : The last time hindenburg did a report on the shady company Nikola, all of their accusations turned out to be true and the company got dumped to the ground
I do not understand, how this is a conspiracy. They also short sell their Us based companies. It is not a geo-political conspiracy but just basic finance😂. And what do you mean by democracy is fickle and demography is what matters. Sir, i respect you and sometimes i wonder why such talent has a bias. I still respect you sir and i have high hopes that someday you will see through everything. I have learnt a lot from you. Thankyou! Jai hind
True.. I feel sad for Amit..
Everyone has bias but he's going too far right.
@@evs059 lol when trth is not what you want then he is far right it's grat to be far right than to be chuslikm madarjaat liberandu randi muslim sperm eater😂😂🐖🐖🚩🚩
lol when truth is not what you want then he is far right it's grat to be far right than to be chuslikm madarjaat liberandu randi muslim sperm eater😂😂🐖🐖🚩🚩
@@PranavGajjar agaya nah aapki aukat mei. The dirty language you use is what you are as a person.
a little more research on this topic was expected from you. You seemed pretty rushed to go to the conclusion. Make a video on their financial as you have pretty large audience they can make use of it while investing on Adani stocks.
But just a 5 people company asking questions should not drown 3rd richest person to 15th. Those questions might have been genuine concern of investors
Correction: Short Selling is NOT limited to Intraday
In India, it is limited to Intraday. Traders or hedge funds have to square of their trade before market close. In US, one can hold their short position just as they do for long position.
Yes, short position can be held in Future and Option segment till contract expiry.
In India it's T+1
He already mentioned "i think"
@@samindherreddy you are talking about settlement period
I expected a better research Mr Amit Sengupta. As you say left has nothing better than asking questions. In this video I don't see anything better than asking questions.
Whatever may be the cas hindenburg surely got what they were aiming for.
Lagta hai sir ne TH-cam ka income adani shares m daal rakha h.
But sir you are upsc teacher you should have 1st rational thinker then nationalist.
Amit, your videos on geography deserve great respect.. but u have to keep aside ur political ideology while explaining issues like these. 😐 U are sounding like a BJP spokesperson man.
Why make unnecessary statements that has nothing to do with this post on Adani-Hindenberg issue 🤷♂️
5:47 "good amount of Muslim population"
2:33 "only thing the extreme left liberals are good at is asking questions"
6:27 "victim card" "oh we cannot even ask questions"
Please don't go from being an Educational channel to becoming a political party TH-cam handle 👍
And i seriously didn't expect you to be using Wikipedia as a source to frame this explanation on the issue 😐 while u pointed out that "They" edited, u have not said about the possibility of it being edited even before u pointed out (or even edited by u).. it's Wikipedia 🤷♂️ i could have edited it 5 days ago so u can point it as a "fact" now.
Also you didn't even mention a sentence about the previous exposé that Hindenberg made on an 'American' firm Nikola.. why? Because then it wouldn't seem like a western attack on Indian firm now? Because an American short seller going after an American firm wouldn't look like a western attack.
Also you didn't mention a single sentence on the open challenge that Hindenberg threw at Adani group to sue them.. u know very well why Adani group is weary of taking this on directly, because Hindenberg knows that Adani has to open all his books if they sue them on defamation charges. These allegations are too huge to be ignored, they are still "allegations" as of now but it's evident that u are dismissing them outrightly and havnt even touched on what the allegations were pointing to 😐
Adani is not India, damn it !!! It was the same person who was getting ridiculously Rich at the time when peasants were on road including others depressed class during pandemic.
Allegations raised against adani does not mean disrespecting India. what kind of an analyst takes sides and cites Wikipedia as source. 🤔😅
He showed the change in narrative in wikipedia page! Nowadays no business is built on tapasya but being brutal, killing competitions etc but the wikipedia edits did show the attack on Adani is to put nails in paths of Adani. Someone is wary of Adani"s rise and it entering a zone which can alter lots of things in India - "acquisition of NDTV"
Adani is just a businessman allegedly an unethical one, Indian economy growth won't be dented because of the exposure of one alleged unethical businessman.
Comment of shame
Wasn't expecting something like this from you Mr. Sengupta! You can do better.
Wasted my time. You expressed your thoughts and feelings more than explaining issue. There is bias.
Clearly Adani has done something terrible and Amit Sengupta is trying to shoot the massenger. Pathetic.
Today I understood that amit sengupta sir is a far rightist...
Exactlyyyy...
Agree with you Sir but why only Adani group, if adani really have that strong pillar then it must have sustain this, and if you see the returns it generated and Rocket high PE(Price to Earning) and Debt to Equity of adani firms and compare it with Industry P/E ratio and Debt to Equity then it's not justified. Even before Hindenburg Report, Mutual Funds Managers who are having expertise in analysing fundamentals of Companies have hardly invested in any adani firms even after seeing their(adani) returns. And biggest reason for that is extraordinary high value of it's shares, they know that a bubble is creating and one day it will burst. And as a retail investor I have never invested in any adani firm because of their fundamentals. Now I find myself lucky after seeing all this mess. Though I hope that Adani firms recover from all this and bounce back. Even if I believe that all this, is a western conspiracy then also you cannot say that flaws are not there in Adani. There are problems with adani also that's why Mutual funds managers have stayed away from it.
Nice explanation. No sane-minded Indian wants to see Adani fall, as everyone will be impacted directly or indirectly. But who is responsible for this mess. If Hindenburg had not pointed this out today then somebody else would have pointed it out tomorrow.
Mr Sengupta
I hope you read this. You are very good explainer. I did not understand few issues in this video. If possible rethink upon these issues.
1) Adani group, a private conglomerate who was accused. The group is not equivalent to whole country, neither a backbone of Indian Economy. Then why did you sound like its an attack on India or 'a conspiracy of west'. Do you think they are so idle and unemployed to sit and do all such stuff
2) Don't you think you are hypocrite? You use Instagram and TH-cam (American firms) as medium to decimate info and blame them as conspirators. Its their opinion and up to us to take it serious or not. In this globalized world taking a path means going for cold war times
3) I think you must revisit Constitution of India, it got words like democracy, liberty and freedom of expression. Therefore questioning is the duty of enlightened citizen as Dr B R Ambedkar envisaged
4) As a citizen we are against monopoly of one firm so that it shall not become an Economic Bubble. You release every video with detailed research. But this one is hinting that like you are a partner of adani firm. So please do not be in a rush
5) Coming to controversial docuseries, its just a binge watch for Gen Z. We all care for employment, farmer's well being, women safety and environment conservation. These are big issues to focus not rallying some support for a already popular person. Don't you think?
6) You are very much right about Haifa port and how important it is particularly after Israel-Lebanon treaty. Again you yourself saying that we need west for trade. Therefore a middle path between west and east. Do not worry this tradition is way older than me ,you, everybody and will stay longer than we can imagine.
I hope i made sense and please do not categorize me liberal, extreme liberal, communist or right wing or any ideology for that matter..I believe in Constitution. I hope you also recognize its importance and enlighten us with your research in upcoming videos.
You changed my perspective on many things sir... Thank you 💓
It's a baised video my friend. He isn't fully right.
@@evs059 Then show what's right !
just do some research by ur self also go and see hindenburgs Track record they have targeted nikola cmigr like big companies succesfully i agree with amit that timing is politically manipulated but yess all allegations are not baseless.... can u imagine a $100 billion increase in adani net worth in last 3 year when nation was going through pandemic .... adani stocks are inflated .... why sbi and lic are still funding adani ...
@@evs059 these people are dumb
Don't try to explain as they will believe whatever Amit says
@@Reconciler vo nahi dikhega drub rathee ka video dekho kahega🤣🤣
Absolutely correct, just before the General elections in India lot of cheap plays (Hindenburg report & BBC report on 2002 riots) are in run
Wow this guy came to conclusion even when SEBI is still looking into the matter, wonder what his source is! I think he's just too blind and couldn't think straight
Exactly he is triggered
"Fraud can't be obfuscated by nationalism "
Forbes report also accused Adani of buying his own shares to increase stock price
Credit Suisse bank also stopped accepting bonds of adani group... only time will tell the truth nevertheless we shouldn't ignore past track record of Hindenburg company?
It is not Hindenburg. It's Hiden-Burg from now on. Basically Hiden their entire details.
Sir your observations are Right ! Adani Groups contributions to Indian Economy is huge , We should not fight over some Anonymous Malicious report. Instead we should stand firm with our National interests . 🙏🇮🇳
Yes he has done a lot by looting taxpayers 2.3lac crore which is now RBI asked banks to monitor the exposure
Don't integrate a conman to a nationalism it's just foolishness
this is called being a mindless insecure nationalist. standing behind a corrupt, greedy and exploitative megacorp just because they're indian is unfathombly dumb. youre being led in groupthink.
@@aintnoslice3422 Who can be more dumb than a person who believes in some Anonymous Organisations Report on India's leading business men just aimed to destabilize the Corporate world's confidence in Indian Economy ! And Sir I don't think you have any idea about the Corporate Laws in India.
@@ravi5065 This is the right time to buy those shares especially a Company like the Adani with all those market captalization and Asset backing , it won't be long before the company bounces back !
I don’t know why you are are trying to defend Adani when it’s clear as the day what’s going on.
Disappointed
Adani firm own Haifa port …..Amit Sengupta India own Haifa 😅
I did not see any basis for your opinions...you have not even discussed the details of the allegations ....are you saying the whole report is baseless ?
We people easily get influenced by any foreign based organisation's statements & reports. I yet to understand why we valued them as much that they fool us for their own benefits? However it is not possible without support of someone who from among us and get benefitted from these foreign organisations; this is why we have history of 500 years slave.
Thanks for this video, it's very informative & precise, and provide a broader outlook behind this whole mean tactics of HidenBurg .
It's upto investor to decide
Anyone can see that Adani stocks are inflated and the they clearly launder money through sell companies in tax haven.
You have to think critically not emotionally. Yes Hidenburg is short selling Adani stocks indirectly but not all of the allegations are baseless.
Investors wouldn't believe it unless it's not baseless, remember investors are not dumb they are highly educated. It all depends on the investors
Is there any base of those questions..or should SEBI their to answer those questions to the people India...
question: did you actually read the report or are you forming your opinion based on this content creator's video. do your own research friend and form your own opinion. remember: you are not immune to propaganda from either side
The Hindenburg issue was featured in the Washington Post at least twice in the past week. This is extremely suspicious, as the firm has 5 employees, why would at international Newspaper take it so seriously? It means that there are very powerful forces behind the attack on Adani (and India?).
They spend enormous amount of time and effort on this things...they need something return..also they don't have history of publishing fake data...why sibi and rbi silent on this issues... 🙄
@@joexavier4070 I think it's SEBI brother... And they are doing their job brother, they do regular audit and they will keep doing it in future.
@@PDMVPrayag ok, My bad, sebi main aim is
to protect the interests of investors in securities and to promote the development of, and to regulate the securities market and for matters connected therewith
Why they are not making official statement,they know importance of this things consequences
@@PDMVPrayag i think all economic forums in india sold-out.. including Rbi
@@joexavier4070 U2 brother
For the first time I am reading negative comments to a video posted from this channel. Everyone knew the reason !
For once this videos feels just like another version of AajTak news in English, very sad 😥
The earth is flat .
THANK you sir for showing corrupt practices by mudi government and Adani!!
ADANI GROUP BUYING A PORT IN ISRAEL IS NOT THE SAME AS INDIA BUYING A PORT IN ISRAEL. This is just too much nationalism in my frank opinion.
Dissent voice is considered anti-national and you may be charged under uspa.
I love all ur geopolitical work ...If Adhani is honest one he wouldn't have any issue explaining the questions given by Hidenburg...the stocks wr over priced we all expected it too fall so none of my friends hold a single stock from Adhani firm....There was a public offering stocks jan27 to 29..first day only 0.1 subscription second day 1 percent and third day all 100%...it is suspicious...he got so much support from government... Should admit if mistake happens and correct....don't support this kind of corruption...
by the time adani responded the stocks had already tanked. their debt to equity is quite low and his companies has good fundamentals. hell bounce back again. in the corporation model of doing business which is pretty much the norm in every mahor developed country today, the govts of the day help the big players of that country, this is not just in india. nobody plays by the books once they become too big.
This channel used to be good
When unbiased
Not even a single point about ADANI 's money
I was expecting a video on this issue. Thanks for meeting the demand
.
If Adani was transparent in its financial dealings or at least a bit smart in covering its shady tracks. It wouldn't have to face these repercussions
It's disappoiting how badly made this video was, not something I would expect from Amit. You never explained what was the entire issue was about. You simply started bashing the left, the opposition etc. You never got into why Adani group suddenly cancelled their FPO. It is sad how today people are backing capitalists who clearly have profits in their mind, not the country. You never mentioned once what Hindenburg's accusations were. You never mentioned once what Adani's rebuttal was. You never once mentioned how confident Hindenburg are, winning a law suit, if it ever comes to that. Its not cool to misguide your audience, sir.
Very true