My professor from Columbia class of 2004. Professor Massad was one of my favorite professors at Columbia. I’m grateful to him for all that he taught me, which allows me today to intelligently advocate for Palestine every opportunity I get. I know too much history, past and present, to fall into any conversational traps with Zionists and Israelis.
It is very important to educate the world by professors like him because most of us were completely brainwashed until this recent conflict. « We were blind ,now we see »
This is gold. As much as I’ve known and studied, I would love to debunk it with their constant rhetoric. In any event… It is coming to an end as it justly should, Thanks be to God. Inshallah.
It took 1200 Israeli lives and 40,000+ Palestinian lives to reveal Zionism as fascisn, and that's a tragedy on both sides, but if there is any silver lining to this genocide and 80 years of unpalpable cruelty, it is that Zionism will now be equated for the coming generations as a despicable horror that we can leave in the past, and work in a way we see each other as family who are all equally worthy of love, care and compassion
Excellent writing, I must add that the world has finally seen how despicable this isra-lie-e zionest movement really is! A man fighting for his freedom can never be called a terrorist, isra-lie-e for decades have done more terrorists actions on people all over the world. Worse yet to come but isra-lie-e is worse than worse!
Your optimism is without foundation and is based on nothing more than hope. We need international solidarity of the working class to create socialist revolutions, not liberal slogans.
Need to correct on the 1200 ,that is actually incorrect, Which Israel have admit they lied about that nr. In that nr a lot of them were also killed by Hannibal Directive which Israel also have admit they yes they killed many of their own. So the nr is much lower (just wanted to correct the nr )
i‘m swiss. all my life it was said, the usa are the good. i m soo tired of to be told who is the good and who is the bad! here people are remote controlled! There is only one thing i know now! long live gaza!!!!!!
“The biggest insult to the memory of the Holocaust is not denying it, but using it to commit genocide against the Palestinian people.” - Norman Finkelstein
@@bluestar6879not changing the fact that Israel commiting genocide so he speak Hebrew or Serv at mop of IDF not make him wrong all the world see Israel revenge and genocide against Palestinians so those have not all the world speak Hebrew that just racist.
@@kayzar293 Yes, like some Chinese person sells himself as an "Expert" on US politics. He does not speak or understand English. Never lived in America. Yet, he is the Expert. See the BS ???
Thank you Rania for hosting, thanks Prof. Joseph Massad for enlightening us with the history of Zionism and its bleak future and demise in the horizon....
No.. Even in Arab states Jews were tolerated but still 2nd class citizens. Self determination of both people depends on 2 states. Zio Israel and Palestine.
Yes. Especially the 7th century version of Jihadi settler-colonialism that has plagued the Land of Israel for centuries. Time for the Ishamelites to LEAVE !
@@chrisgreene2623 English is a looting language from all other languages, and it is now a world language. Everyone contributed to it. Anglosaxon is your language. Go to check it on youtube 😂 how it is barbarian like....
400,000 people died in Yemen because of Iran Saudi proxy war, 500,000 people died in Syria because of Iran help , why do you call that? In the end Palestinians suffer because of stupid choices thier leaders make , I care about Palestinians it has been over 75 years and they deserve a state.my issue is the delusion the arab/Muslim world has .you are killing each other like savages in old times in most Muslim countries and all your energy is wasted on Israel. I genunily belive now the issue is within you. logic is dead in arab/Muslim world.
Colonialism... Zionism... Nazism... It ALL needs to go!!! Old defunct ways of Human Beings behaving like wild, mindless animals! Most of us have moved on from such nonsense now... Because Human Evolution is Continuous! It never stopped... And it will never stop! Progress is Inevitable!
@@yitzhakspolter9551 No, jihadi evil became apparent many years ago with the rise of Boko Haram, Al qeda, ISIS and all these medieval barbarian outfits,
I'm Wallonian. Wallonia was a land between France and Belgium just around 500 years ago. But you don't see me going there, killing people to "take my land back". Israelis do not have the right to a land that, allegedly, their ancestors left 2000 years ago!
If France and Belgium cease to exist after a World War. Then all the countries in the League of Nations (or UN nowadays) rules that the State of Wallonia should be set up, WHY NOT ??
The Neanderthals were the first humans to settle in the area now called Israel. Does that give anyone with Neanderthal genetics the right of return over religious identity? No. European based Christian antisemitism is why the Jewish people weren't wanted in European countries.
@@bluestar6879 just because france and belgium cease to exist, does not mean that their people did too. a partition set up by and voted on by people who have the power and privilege of being unaffected by the choices they're making over another group of people is highly unethical, inhumane, and the core of colonism.
it'd be possible to argue for, file legal claims etc, if one wished.. not show up en masse, sideline everyone who lives there (palestinians, in this case), steal their land, after evicting most of them by force (i.e., so not working, done right, etc, that only 'by force' remained, which is the case 'regardless. e.g, got the door key? smashing window is still 'possible', ditto if key's forgotten)..
They are criminals. They participate in the enforcement of genocidal policies, blocking and destroying food and every form of aid intended for the Palestinians.
Ask yourselves, what are the names of those people, who have led israel past & present. They changed names to make them look Middle-Eastern. But most of them are European settlers.
@@jeffreywilheim5970 That is wrong, outdated and silly. do all Catholics get a country? What about a separate country for Buddhists only? Americans should all leave then and only those who can claim Indigenous heritage can stay in "their" country? Israel was created for the West to get a foothold into the middle East - period. They just used religion - how convenient since the bible helped them in that in the Old Testament.
@@jeffreywilheim5970 utter nonsense. Think about what you are saying. Do all ppl have a "right" to relocate en masse to a location that may or may not have harbored their ancestors for a time 2,000 yrs ago?? And the cherry on top: does this group then get the right to violently expel the local population ? This is barbaric.
@@Utube-l1pit will affect the IDF being young they will have to live with themselves. It is time now for them to see who they are serving and ask why they are giving Way their souls
A crash course on history of PALESTINIAN STATE: 1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state 2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state. 4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state. 5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state. 6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state. 7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state. 8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state. 9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state. 10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state 11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state. 12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state. 14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state. 15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state. 17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state. 20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE
The U.S should have never let the Internet free. but I'm glad they have, now we can have transparency, and it's getting better and better,. It's Three things that you can't hide.. the sun, the moon, and the truth...
The whole project started on the wrong foot. Israel basically started out being unfriendly with the work they did in the Nak bba. This settler colony of Europeans doesn't want to live with anyone it seems.
" We must Expel Palestinians at all coasts" Ben Gourion 1937, Years later " if I was a palestinian I would never negociate with Israël because we stole their Land
Stop quoting lies from that chronic madman, Ilan Pappe. All his stuff is false ! That loser was expelled from his tenured Israeli University position - he was found by a Court of law to be fabricating historical data.
They know they have been criminal in their actions against the Palestinian people. Their criminality has been fully and irrevocably exposed to the entire world. They cannot hide their true intent from the world anymore.
This guest is a perfect 10. You need to have him back. You need better questions. He is rare, having the history of a dozen settler colonial histories that intersect with Gaza in so many ways.
Wonderfully informative!! Another Pure masterclass! Thank you for organising this Rania Khalek and BreakThrough News. What Prof Massad doesn't know about this topic isn't worth knowing. I am truly in awe!! #EndTheGenocide #EndTheOccupation #DismantleZionism
@@bluestar6879 just explain something how come it is you Jewish people want to keep on going on about October 7 why don’t you refer back to what you’ve done to the Palestinian people since 1947 how about you look at your own government and how they’re killing Palestinians for their land to evict them from their land. So please give this message to your people stop crying about a war where your people were gassed where you should be setting and your people and your government should be showing the world place after what happened to your people but instead like anything the Jews have to be greedy and kill people for their land so understand that stand up as a human being and get October 7 out of your head because you’re being doing this to the Palestinian people since 1947
There was a past without israel and there will be a future without israel. Greater empires have fallen, and Israels time is coming to an end. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
If it was not for the British,,, this would never have happened,,, but now with USA,, EU,,, one has to question,, what's all this about??? But their time is running out,, the whole world has seen it,, no more going back,,, 2024, is thee year of awakening to thee young Generation of tomorrow,, bless you all,,
This gentleman is very conversant with our African history so much and can successfully link it with what is currently taking place in the Middle East and went as far as painting the picture of behaviours of colonizers then and now!
Incredible. The professor is most clear eyed. What a history of colonialism and genocides! What does the professor have to say about Haiti? Thank you, Rania!! You added much to the discussion!
Does anyone else, find it interesting that you can Spell '' Israel'' with the letters T-R-U-E, Have you ever wondered why ?Jesus say's in John 8:32 '' You will know the truth, and the truth will set you free '' Amen.
I'm from England, UK. I have never understood racism, how/why people behave the way they do towards others, just because of where they're from, how they speak, colour of their skin etc. It upsets & disgusts me. We should all be living our lives in harmony, enjoying/making the most of however much time we have on this planet. Those unable to behave like humane, compassionate, decent & kind people are the probem, be they the thug in the street, or thug in government.Their deficiencies, bias, selfishness & greed have repeatedly resulted in worldwide.suffering of The Many, to please The Few.. Not any more!
Racism occurs because the heart of Man desperately wicked, and this problem cannot be solved by political means, because it is a '' Heart '' problem in which only a new heart from Jesus Christ, who died for all our Sins can change us, as a result us accepting him as our Saviour and Lord.
How can you believe in God, and then colour code people- from a little girl ( in catholic school) sister would tell us Adam & Eve are our first parents, we are all brothers and sisters no matter were we came from- just because you were born in a land man named - doesn’t change, we all came from Adam & Eve - we are earthlings. Jesus is King. We pray for the poor people of Palestine & the good people in Israel who appose this Genocide. ✝️.
It is the ideology that promotes racism. The family who ground up in such an environment will behave the same. They are thought to discriminate against other races since birth and played as victim.
Unfortunately, the most powerful governments, the most influential media and the wealthiest people are determined that apartheid Israel's naked colonialism will continue indefinitely. To end it we need the international solidarity of the working class - including those in Israel. How do we achieve that?
Thank you Rania for this opportunity to listen to Professor Massad. Very happy to see a professor of Columbia, my old school, at work on your programme. Thanks.
This is a brilliant analysis! I'm a German of Mizrahi Jewish descent and didn't understand for a very long time why I'm considered "killable" by far too many Germans. I didn't know that I'm of Middle Eastern descent and mistook it for hatred against Jews for many decades. Germans and Jews alike treated me like a delusional impostor. Delusional I was, but not for asserting my right to live. Many thanks to both of you!
Find out how mizrahi are seen is Israel lol. They have to do the most, they're at the bottom of the pecking order. Also, I was remember watching a street interview where the Arab Jews didn't consider themselves as Arabs anymore and embarrassed and disgusted, and wanted a more European Jewry identity
Rep. Andy Kim has called for permanent ceasefire now that he secured the Senate nomination. Can we expect more U S. politicians taking a similar stand once the election is over?
Here in NZ we signed a treaty with the Māori that ended our war and since then we’ve integrated relatively well. Unlike what the Australians or Americans did to the native people they encountered. Approximately 200 years ago my Irish ancestor emigrated here and married a full blooded Maori lady. And the other half of me is English. I don’t think we deserve to be among the white countries mentioned that destroyed the culture they encountered yesterday on arrival. We have incorporated the Māori culture into our every day lives and are proud of our heritage.
Brilliant, very insightful! A history masterclass by the very professor, Bari Weiss tried to kick out of Columbia. Thanks for having Prof. Massad, Rania!
My professor from Columbia class of 2004. Professor Massad was one of my favorite professors at Columbia. I’m grateful to him for all that he taught me, which allows me today to intelligently advocate for Palestine every opportunity I get.
I know too much history, past and present, to fall into any conversational traps with Zionists and Israelis.
It is very important to educate the world by professors like him because most of us were completely brainwashed until this recent conflict. « We were blind ,now we see »
incredibly lucky, i would happily pay the premium, just not to Columbia, to learn from him
This is gold. As much as I’ve known and studied, I would love to debunk it with their constant rhetoric. In any event… It is coming to an end as it justly should, Thanks be to God. Inshallah.
Did he teach you what is the meaning of the word "palestine" ? I bet he did not 😅
@yanivush87 it means resistance at all means necessary. 😂😅😊
It took 1200 Israeli lives and 40,000+ Palestinian lives to reveal Zionism as fascisn, and that's a tragedy on both sides, but if there is any silver lining to this genocide and 80 years of unpalpable cruelty, it is that Zionism will now be equated for the coming generations as a despicable horror that we can leave in the past, and work in a way we see each other as family who are all equally worthy of love, care and compassion
Excellent writing, I must add that the world has finally seen how despicable this isra-lie-e zionest movement really is! A man fighting for his freedom can never be called a terrorist, isra-lie-e for decades have done more terrorists actions on people all over the world. Worse yet to come but isra-lie-e is worse than worse!
Your optimism is without foundation and is based on nothing more than hope. We need international solidarity of the working class to create socialist revolutions, not liberal slogans.
Most of the death on October 7 were by Zionists guns and Helicopter guns and Hannibal Killings !
Don't underestimate the ability of the right to reframe and rewrite history. The other commenter is right
Need to correct on the 1200 ,that is actually incorrect, Which Israel have admit they lied about that nr. In that nr a lot of them were also killed by Hannibal Directive which Israel also have admit they yes they killed many of their own. So the nr is much lower (just wanted to correct the nr )
i‘m swiss. all my life it was said, the usa are the good. i m soo tired of to be told who is the good and who is the bad! here people are remote controlled! There is only one thing i know now! long live gaza!!!!!!
They make Brain wash in childhood,, at end the truth wins
Free free Palestine from the evil Israel
The good at what?
one state one vote one peace, free palestine!
Yes...long live Palestine
Thank you Rania. Independent journalists with journalistic integrity are the heroes of our time.
This guy is a walking encyclopedia! Amazing! 📖
He should be hosted on main channels, but we know that wouldn’t happen, I wonder why?
Brilliant man . Thanks for this info Rania ❤
“The biggest insult to the memory of the Holocaust is not denying it, but using it to commit genocide against the Palestinian people.” - Norman Finkelstein
Value, Norman
Finkelstein speaks no Hebrew, never lived in Israel, never served in IDF.
But he is somehow a Great Expert on the topic.
@@bluestar6879not changing the fact that Israel commiting genocide so he speak Hebrew or Serv at mop of IDF not make him wrong all the world see Israel revenge and genocide against Palestinians so those have not all the world speak Hebrew that just racist.
@@bluestar6879to his eternal credit
@@kayzar293
Yes, like some Chinese person sells himself as an "Expert" on US politics. He does not speak or understand English. Never lived in America.
Yet, he is the Expert.
See the BS ???
Professor thank you for standing up for justice and telling the truth ❤❤
Thank you Rania for hosting, thanks Prof. Joseph Massad for enlightening us with the history of Zionism and its bleak future and demise in the horizon....
Massad is a member of the PLO terrorist organization.
Rania is his love interest.
Love you Rania ! Time to end Zionism !!
From the river to sea, Israel's is the only flag you'll see.
@@jeffreywilheim5970
100000% true !!!
Never ever will ... and I'm not a Jewish at all !
@@tollfree650 Then you're a zionist.
No.. Even in Arab states Jews were tolerated but still 2nd class citizens.
Self determination of both people depends on 2 states. Zio Israel and Palestine.
Colonialism must be defeated... from Ireland, the black and brown people of Europe ☘🍉
Yes.
Especially the 7th century version of Jihadi settler-colonialism that has plagued the Land of Israel for centuries.
Time for the Ishamelites to LEAVE !
Thanks for speaking the gift of English.
@@chrisgreene2623 Amadán.. póg mo thóin mhór gruagach 🇮🇪
@@chrisgreene2623 English is a looting language from all other languages, and it is now a world language. Everyone contributed to it. Anglosaxon is your language. Go to check it on youtube 😂 how it is barbarian like....
@@AnBreadanFeasa same problem is happening in Europe,by right wing
Rania podcast is always on point.
76 year long apartheid, 17 year long blockade of Gaza and now committing genocide. Evil
Fact. Jews got thrown out of gaza in 70s. Yet Arabs live in Israel
Yes Amas are evil.
Very good point.
@@victormeidan1062No ammonites to the 14th generation the bible says😅
@@Zoe-c9z
Not ammonites.
Amas
@@Zoe-c9z
Not ammonites,
Amas.
Israel started as nothing and it will end with nothing. God will even take away what they merely thought they had.
It has turned itself into something far worse than "nothing".
Fakestine - the imaginary, phantom construct is predicting the J's people demise, again.
They are good at self-delusional fantasies.
Good must prevail Palestine will be free and Jews can live there in peace and live under one ummah like we are supposed to peacefully
@@yusufalfyfer9415
Your Ummah is a 3rd World cesspit of corrupt, useless dictatorships.
Well, it is alot better than the Arab World.
This should be compulsory viewing for anyone wishing to understand Israel's ongoing genocide and the antisemitism of Zionism.
wait--Zionism is antisemitic? I'm so confused now
400,000 people died in Yemen because of Iran Saudi proxy war, 500,000 people died in Syria because of Iran help , why do you call that? In the end Palestinians suffer because of stupid choices thier leaders make , I care about Palestinians it has been over 75 years and they deserve a state.my issue is the delusion the arab/Muslim world has .you are killing each other like savages in old times in most Muslim countries and all your energy is wasted on Israel. I genunily belive now the issue is within you. logic is dead in arab/Muslim world.
A victory over Zionism is a victory for humanity.
100% true
Exactly. Imo, a person can't be a healthy, developed human until you can put aside man-made belief systems and put humanity over ideology
hard because of USA/USD
Colonialism... Zionism... Nazism... It ALL needs to go!!! Old defunct ways of Human Beings behaving like wild, mindless animals!
Most of us have moved on from such nonsense now... Because Human Evolution is Continuous! It never stopped... And it will never stop! Progress is Inevitable!
I COULDN'T HAVE SAID IT BETTER MYSELF.
Long live Gaza. Opened my eyes to so much, and there's still a lot more to learn.
Yes.
Long live an urban wasteland filled with rubble & ashes.
@@bluestar6879 interesting how everyones eyes are "opening" right after October 7th...
@@yitzhakspolter9551
No, jihadi evil became apparent many years ago with the rise of Boko Haram, Al qeda, ISIS and all these medieval barbarian outfits,
Colonialism should be criminalized.
It Is crimina,l but made to look respectable. In this case by cloaking itself in Biblical bs.
Agreed. So put the "Palestinians," who are the real colonialists in this, in prison and leave Israel and Israel's Jews alone.
Who's going to criminalize it, the colonizers?
@@patriayvida6850 Global South
Just like Naz
So great interview 👏👏👏 Gracias Joseph and Rania! 💜
I'm Wallonian. Wallonia was a land between France and Belgium just around 500 years ago. But you don't see me going there, killing people to "take my land back". Israelis do not have the right to a land that, allegedly, their ancestors left 2000 years ago!
If France and Belgium cease to exist after a World War.
Then all the countries in the League of Nations (or UN nowadays) rules that the State of Wallonia should be set up, WHY NOT ??
The Neanderthals were the first humans to settle in the area now called Israel. Does that give anyone with Neanderthal genetics the right of return over religious identity? No. European based Christian antisemitism is why the Jewish people weren't wanted in European countries.
@@bluestar6879 just because france and belgium cease to exist, does not mean that their people did too. a partition set up by and voted on by people who have the power and privilege of being unaffected by the choices they're making over another group of people is highly unethical, inhumane, and the core of colonism.
it'd be possible to argue for, file legal claims etc, if one wished.. not show up en masse, sideline everyone who lives there (palestinians, in this case), steal their land, after evicting most of them by force (i.e., so not working, done right, etc, that only 'by force' remained, which is the case 'regardless. e.g, got the door key? smashing window is still 'possible', ditto if key's forgotten)..
@@apollidoe6651
The people on the Land agreed to the creation of a Jewish National Homeland. Read the Feisal-Weitzman Agreement of 1919.
I loved his energy. No apologies for colonialism.
I think so too, you can feel it. They’re self destructing.
another US taxpayer who refuses to take responsibility?
@donHooligan another Zionist agent claiming the Universe is revolving around his feelings ?
If by "they," you mean the "Palestinians," yes, they are self-destructing.
@@donHooligan Israel are not US taxPayers , they are US taxAbusers
He sits right up there with Norm Finkelstein , illan pape , Rashid kahlidi amd other great historians
Very violent Squatters, not "Settlers".
They are criminals. They participate in the enforcement of genocidal policies, blocking and destroying food and every form of aid intended for the Palestinians.
Perfectly put … armed squatters …
Why we stop using the wanderingJews.
58:29 Thank you Rania for inviting Dr. Massad...Wow! He had me glued to my iPad screen throughout your show.
Ask yourselves, what are the names of those people, who have led israel past & present. They changed names to make them look Middle-Eastern. But most of them are European settlers.
Who have just as much right to Israel as Middle Eastern Jews as Israel is the homeland of all of the Jewish people.
@@jeffreywilheim5970 That is wrong, outdated and silly. do all Catholics get a country? What about a separate country for Buddhists only? Americans should all leave then and only those who can claim Indigenous heritage can stay in "their" country?
Israel was created for the West to get a foothold into the middle East - period. They just used religion - how convenient since the bible helped them in that in the Old Testament.
@@jeffreywilheim5970 Rubbish. Not after leaving it alone for 1850 years.
@@jeffreywilheim5970They are Khazaaars
@@jeffreywilheim5970 utter nonsense. Think about what you are saying. Do all ppl have a "right" to relocate en masse to a location that may or may not have harbored their ancestors for a time 2,000 yrs ago?? And the cherry on top: does this group then get the right to violently expel the local population ? This is barbaric.
Massad is one of my favorite scholars to listen to. I learn new amazing things EVERY TIME
Israel will never know peace, until it makes peace with it's neighbours
Occupied Palestine
They will never have peace with themselves after what they've done.
shouldnt exist in the first place,
@@Utube-l1pit will affect the IDF being young they will have to live with themselves. It is time now for them to see who they are serving and ask why they are giving Way their souls
"Israel" is the same as a criminal home-invader who has absolutely no relation to the neighbors, other than being a standing threat to everyone.
Great to hear again from Joseph Massad. Thanks Rania. Watching here in Australia.
I’m from Australia and am listing too. Thank you Rania for bringing us the truth!
You cant be both a occupier and a democracy, said what I said.
Well, Amas is just an occupier.
The Jihadis don't do democracy
Occupation by its very definition is not democratic …
You're a clown.
Said what I said.
Thank you! Extremely thorough analysis and informative. Vital!
Brilliant podcast. Insightful as always
Long live the Palestine people from Ireland
A crash course on history of PALESTINIAN STATE: 1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state 2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state. 4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state. 5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state. 6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state. 7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state. 8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state. 9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state. 10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state 11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state. 12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state. 14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state. 15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state. 17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state. 20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE
Zionism on the end . Thank you Rania
Enjoy your antisemitic fantasy while you can. We Jews aren't going anywhere.
Zionism will destroy Islam the scientology of the EAST.
Thank you Professor Joseph Massad for a lesson on brutal European racist colonial history .
The U.S should have never let the Internet free. but I'm glad they have, now we can have transparency, and it's getting better and better,. It's Three things that you can't hide.. the sun, the moon, and the truth...
The Internet is not free.
Free Julian Assange.❤ Free Palestine. ❤Stop evil USA/UK Genocide.❤ Free PS.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
That's why Tik Tok is going to be banned 😅😅😅
Organized and pushed through congress by the israel lobby
The whole project started on the wrong foot. Israel basically started out being unfriendly with the work they did in the Nak bba. This settler colony of Europeans doesn't want to live with anyone it seems.
They are happy with total control, like they have over the West.
Keep on the great work Ms. Khalik👍🙏
Thank your platform for speaking the truth
It's always good to see the amazing Rania Khalek. 👌
" We must Expel Palestinians at all coasts" Ben Gourion 1937, Years later " if I was a palestinian I would never negociate with Israël because we stole their Land
Stop quoting lies from that chronic madman, Ilan Pappe.
All his stuff is false !
That loser was expelled from his tenured Israeli University position - he was found by a Court of law to be fabricating historical data.
They know they have been criminal in their actions against the Palestinian people. Their criminality has been fully and irrevocably exposed to the entire world. They cannot hide their true intent from the world anymore.
Professor Massad is BRILLIANT. Will buy his books
So much history we're not told about. This was very informative.
Prof. Joseph Massad is on fire 🔥🔥🔥 I really enjoyed this talk
Such an in depth conversation. Thank you professor Joseph and Rania. Always on point.
Thanks for having Prof. Massad, Rania! All the best ❤
This guest is a perfect 10. You need to have him back. You need better questions. He is rare, having the history of a dozen settler colonial histories that intersect with Gaza in so many ways.
Dumping Eastern-European settler colonists smack in the middle of the Arab world was an insane idea to begin with.
Indeed
Professor Massad, what a phenomenal lecture! We’ve all been deceived here in the west ! Thank you
Thank you so much god bless you dear brave Rania. Independent journalists with journalistic integrity are the heroes of our time.
Israel has the right to go and do a Passover and never come back
👏👏👏✌🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
As my favorite Israeli rabbi says, "When they say 'go back where you came from,' I say, 'That's what I did!'"
@@jeffreywilheim5970- So he went back to Brooklyn? Good for him.
@@patriayvida6850 🤣🤣🤣🤣 savage!!
@@patriayvida6850 Nope. He lives in Beit Shemesh, between the River and the Sea. And if you don't like it, you can him where the sun don't see.
Wonderfully informative!! Another Pure masterclass! Thank you for organising this Rania Khalek and BreakThrough News. What Prof Massad doesn't know about this topic isn't worth knowing. I am truly in awe!! #EndTheGenocide #EndTheOccupation #DismantleZionism
They both can go back
Pure master buration.
PLO professor and Ms Khalek are shaggging each other.
"The nazis made me afraid of being Jewish and the zionists made me ashamed of being Jewish." - Israel Shahak
"and then came Amas on 7 October & they burned me alive"
@@bluestar6879 just explain something how come it is you Jewish people want to keep on going on about October 7 why don’t you refer back to what you’ve done to the Palestinian people since 1947 how about you look at your own government and how they’re killing Palestinians for their land to evict them from their land. So please give this message to your people stop crying about a war where your people were gassed where you should be setting and your people and your government should be showing the world place after what happened to your people but instead like anything the Jews have to be greedy and kill people for their land so understand that stand up as a human being and get October 7 out of your head because you’re being doing this to the Palestinian people since 1947
@@bluestar6879 they burned you alive. How are you still here typing from heaven?
YOU ARE TOTALLY RIGHT ✅️
Thank you for the interview. Brilliant. Free Palestine.
Free Lilliput too !
yes free palestine from evil thinking , hate an killing,
Thanks for your brilliant and informative news I must say you are the BT fireball keep up the good work Norman alwar beautiful Cape Town
There was a past without israel and there will be
a future without israel. Greater empires have
fallen, and Israels time is coming to an end. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
If it was not for the British,,, this would never have happened,,, but now with USA,, EU,,, one has to question,, what's all this about??? But their time is running out,, the whole world has seen it,, no more going back,,, 2024, is thee year of awakening to thee young Generation of tomorrow,, bless you all,,
This gentleman is very conversant with our African history so much and can successfully link it with what is currently taking place in the Middle East and went as far as painting the picture of behaviours of colonizers then and now!
Incredible historical breakdown of colonialism. Thank you!
Kudos to this Professor for spitting out FACTS !!!
Let’s hope so - free Palestine!
☮️🇵🇸🇵🇸❤️❤️🕊️
Yes, free it from 7th century illegal settler-colonists !
They need to leave ASAP.
Yes. Free it from nasty arrabb naatsees.
@@bluestar6879hasbara is so weak and self defeating these days.
@@amrabdallah368
Taqiya Troll Alert !
Taqiya Troll Alert !
@@bluestar6879 🥴
Wow. What a Great Professor. Thanks for having him.
One of the best discussions I've seen on this topic.
Thanks to Rania and her guest
This was a history master class! Thank you, Rania! 🙏❤
Wow, what a great interview with this fantastic Professor!
Wow, this is the history that we Westerners are not taught in school. Goes without saying... Thank you so, so much!!
This is the best interview I have heard on the topic! Very informative! Thank you Professor
Such a great guest. Keep up the good work BT News.
Excellent interview, great questions and very informative analysis! Thank you BTN!
Incredible. The professor is most clear eyed. What a history of colonialism and genocides! What does the professor have to say about Haiti? Thank you, Rania!! You added much to the discussion!
@savvybytes3748 The coup in Haiti is backed by france and United States
What an eye opener!...thank you Break Through News
Joseph Massad is outlining the problem and its causes and all the dimensions very accurately. Thank you so much.
Does anyone else find it interesting that you cannot spell "israel" without the letters L-I-A-R-S 🤥🤔
LOL! God does have a good sense of humor.
Wow yes 😂
Also Auskhenazi is the cousin of Nazi.
For Palestinians it is Israhell.
Does anyone else, find it interesting that you can Spell '' Israel'' with the letters T-R-U-E, Have you ever wondered why ?Jesus say's in John 8:32 '' You will know the truth, and the truth will set you free '' Amen.
Joseph Massad is incredible. May God protect him.
I always like what Nasser is supposed to have said about the Jews. He said "My problem with them is they left brown and returned white".
This is one of the most important interviews of all time.
I'm from England, UK. I have never understood racism, how/why people behave the way they do towards others, just because of where they're from, how they speak, colour of their skin etc. It upsets & disgusts me. We should all be living our lives in harmony, enjoying/making the most of however much time we have on this planet. Those unable to behave like humane, compassionate, decent & kind people are the probem, be they the thug in the street, or thug in government.Their deficiencies, bias, selfishness & greed have repeatedly resulted in worldwide.suffering of The Many, to please The Few.. Not any more!
Racism occurs because the heart of Man desperately wicked, and this problem cannot be solved by political means, because it is a '' Heart '' problem in which only a new heart from Jesus Christ, who died for all our Sins can change us, as a result us accepting him as our Saviour and Lord.
How can you believe in God, and then colour code people- from a little girl ( in catholic school) sister would tell us Adam & Eve are our first parents, we are all brothers and sisters no matter were we came from- just because you were born in a land man named - doesn’t change, we all came from Adam & Eve - we are earthlings. Jesus is King. We pray for the poor people of Palestine & the good people in Israel who appose this Genocide. ✝️.
It is the ideology that promotes racism. The family who ground up in such an environment will behave the same. They are thought to discriminate against other races since birth and played as victim.
Unfortunately, the most powerful governments, the most influential media and the wealthiest people are determined that apartheid Israel's naked colonialism will continue indefinitely. To end it we need the international solidarity of the working class - including those in Israel. How do we achieve that?
Thank you for this interview, the world needs this
wow, that was an excellent session, I wish I could bookmark it. So loaded with facts. Thank you
My brain has grown significantly after this episode. That knowledge drop is priceless.
Buen dia, am old and lived through so much of what the Prof. so clearly laid out. Thanks for a real contribution.
That is very educational, thank you
Thank you Rania for this opportunity to listen to Professor Massad.
Very happy to see a professor of Columbia, my old school, at work on your programme.
Thanks.
It's funny how the U.S. and Europe believe they are a beacon of light and civilization. Beacon of light and civilization my derriere. Pardon my french
everyone should watch this interview
poppycock
Strip Away the Lies: The Emperor Has no cloths whether it be Israel Europe, or good old USA
Brilliant lesson from the Prof. Very easy to understand the issue with more fact and accuracy.
Thank you Prof. Massad and Rania
This is a brilliant analysis!
I'm a German of Mizrahi Jewish descent and didn't understand for a very long time why I'm considered "killable" by far too many Germans. I didn't know that I'm of Middle Eastern descent and mistook it for hatred against Jews for many decades. Germans and Jews alike treated me like a delusional impostor. Delusional I was, but not for asserting my right to live.
Many thanks to both of you!
Find out how mizrahi are seen is Israel lol. They have to do the most, they're at the bottom of the pecking order. Also, I was remember watching a street interview where the Arab Jews didn't consider themselves as Arabs anymore and embarrassed and disgusted, and wanted a more European Jewry identity
Bring him back again please. We are learning from him a lot. Thank you !!!
Rep. Andy Kim has called for permanent ceasefire now that he secured the Senate nomination. Can we expect more U S. politicians taking a similar stand once the election is over?
Here in NZ we signed a treaty with the Māori that ended our war and since then we’ve integrated relatively well.
Unlike what the Australians or Americans did to the native people they encountered.
Approximately 200 years ago my Irish ancestor emigrated here and married a full blooded Maori lady. And the other half of me is English.
I don’t think we deserve to be among the white countries mentioned that destroyed the culture they encountered yesterday on arrival.
We have incorporated the Māori culture into our every day lives and are proud of our heritage.
Netayahoo should be prosecuted for his Crimes.
Just an incredible summary of historical issues related to settler colonies around the world. Very, very educational and informative.
Leading, really leading scholar when it comes to the geopolitics and colonialism of Zionism. He put me on a higher level.
Wow, what a knowledgeable man, I had to stop and replay several times to catch most of it. Thumbs up.
brilliance!
Brilliant, very insightful! A history masterclass by the very professor, Bari Weiss tried to kick out of Columbia. Thanks for having Prof. Massad, Rania!
This an incredibly important and informative interview - thank you!
Excellent !!!
Thank you both.