Because of her brain. In fact she can't hear what she is singing, her brain can't analyze the sounds when she is singing. There are a lot people like her... but the problem can be solve if she practices and records her voice... 👍
PhanefromBabylone oh I see Lolol yeah I mean ur term is pretty much what tone deaf is in a way. In America tone deaf means they can’t hear what they actually sound like which is why they can get their tone or pitch right
Rachel Cabero wait...that's what tone deaf means? I thought it was the inability to produce the notes with your mouth? (Aka not being able to hit the notes)
xia has supreme visuals and is a really talented singer and dancer, hell at some point she was even the main vocal for rania. i wish she was recruited by a big company.
It so confused me....I feel happy and sad at the same time, at the moment I laugh so hard coz this is so funny...but moment later I feel so sad coz I miss SISTAR so bad (seen Soyou smile make it even harder...I miss SISTAR so bad) 😭😭😭
gotta admit the bad singer Na Young has guts, to be that bad, know your that bad, and be able to perform a whole song in front of cameras, artists, and an audience, still deserves the applause
The bad singer How is she be so fine with everyone laughing at her it needs really a lot of patience and more of a positive mind she know herself a lot such a braveness👏👏
You should watch the whole episode. They were bantering and cutely fighting like sibling lol All of them actually. Even donghyun, he was fighting with kwill like crazy hahaha
when RANIA came out with Dr. Feel Good, I remember I almost choked on my pasta. They were such a shock. I never saw anything like that in Kpop before that time. At the same time, I was lowkey impressed by their vocals and later became obsessed with their main and lead vocals.
I miss Jang Jin-young aka. Xia. She left RaNia after being apart of the group since she was like 16. I wish she would rejoin like Yina did, she has an amazing voice that i don't want to go unused, but we'll see.
I like the show but at the same time I feel bad... because it’s fun to get it right and stuff but it kinda hurts to see the person to be laughed at. But I admire how strong they can be to be on stage and face the crowds, respect to that.
@@kookiesbrownshoes7756 No she isnt here haha, Choim is in the girl group with Yuna who is the first girl to sing. I was just clarfying Horin xi's mistake of Yuna's position in her group. (Not This Group)
Believe me they can 😂 I have a friend that has no rythm and is pretty hard to even recognize the song she is singing 😌 so yeah it is possible to sing that bad 🙏
Seriously mnet, please make produce 101 2nd chance for this amazing ex idol,you guy can just sign them a 7 year contract,seriously Rania is major throwback, I love their debut song
Qim Dodol that’s what the Unit was supposed to be. I wish they stuck to it instead of letting idols who are currently active compete too but it was a good show.
This is an interesting show,the only thing I hate about this show is how they laugh and being disrespectful towards the ones that cannot sing.However,I still love this show very much.
it wasn't just about poor management. majority of people even international kpop fans didn't like their debut song. i remember majority of kpop fans called rania whores. even allkpop had to make an article defending the group. @@redblue7241
![[ENG sub] I can see your voice 6 [2회] 경악 vol.2 천재 등 스타쉽 가고 싶은 대학생 유승우! '오늘 부터 1일' 190125 EP.2](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oi8FKJW0QYY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG sub] I can see your voice 6 [2회] 경악 vol.2 천재 등 스타쉽 가고 싶은 대학생 유승우! '오늘 부터 1일' 190125 EP.2](/img/tr.png)
![[ENG sub] I can see your voice 6 [6회] 세븐틴을 울린 감동! 자체 제작돌 세분틴의 '소나기' (임도연, 홍주현, 이다원) 190222 EP.6](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5Xn1okI9vis/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#너목보4] 걸스데이 민아의 실력자 친언니 등장! 그리고 언니와의 듀엣을 위해 스튜디오에 몰래 방문한 민아?!😆 오직 너목보에서만 만날 수 있는 방 자매 듀엣 무대❤️](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lkEeyPFW6n8/mqdefault.jpg)
![ร้อยพ่อพันแม่ - WanMai [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XY2pNYASEbg/mqdefault.jpg)
One of the girls was from RANIA. Her name was Xia. She was one of the main vocals of the group. I’m glad to watch her again.
No wonder she looks familiar....
riski awan The second one who sings.
No wonder look familiar...got talent but group not famous..too bad tho
and the girl at 4:37 is a member of Camila
That's why she looks familiar.
How is it possible for her not to die of laughter when she hears her own voice. She is amazing!
아닠ㅋㅋㅋㅋ겁나 이쁜 외모에 도도한 표정으로 춤도 섹시한데 무표정으로 저렇게 노래부르니깐 웃기면서 귀엽다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I love how Soyou immediately recognized the performance based on the stance. 😂
장진영님이랑 정유나님 목소리 너무 좋다 ㅠㅠㅠ 제대로 된 나혼자 무대 보고 싶다
I'm more impressed that the other singers didn't deter from singing and dancing to the deaf singer. 👏👏👏
They're a pro idol after all 😁
How can she sing with that serious face with that voice hahahhaha
Because of her brain. In fact she can't hear what she is singing, her brain can't analyze the sounds when she is singing. There are a lot people like her... but the problem can be solve if she practices and records her voice... 👍
@@rachelcabero9890 Ah it's "tone deaf"? We don't have a term for this in french so... we just say " elle n'a pas d'oreille" ="she has not ear" 🤣
PhanefromBabylone oh I see Lolol yeah I mean ur term is pretty much what tone deaf is in a way. In America tone deaf means they can’t hear what they actually sound like which is why they can get their tone or pitch right
Rachel Cabero wait...that's what tone deaf means? I thought it was the inability to produce the notes with your mouth? (Aka not being able to hit the notes)
@@UnimpressedReviewer not at all' xD deaf tone is when your brain can't analyze the sound you make...
이상하다 음치분 목소리 뭔가 매력적이야
인정
이상하게 커엽
ㅆㅇㅈ ㅋㅋ 자꾸듣게됨
우우우우ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
와 세명 전부 실력자 인줄 포커페이스 대박
comedy gold right here she's an amazing actress for being able to sing like that with such a straight face
"OowOOwooHoOoOO!" I almost choked on my pasta🤣🤣🤣
Lol 🤣
Ohh maybe youre the one who took the sample of Jimin's pasta hahahha
shit same. im outside eating pasta.
That part come when I see your comment
She was the Impasta......................*coughs*
SOYOU SAID SHE A FAN OF RANIA. 😭😭😭
Huge fan*
Little Twinkle omg her name like my name I want see her where is it?!
@@raniarania9803 RANIA is a group
Meriem Sbai El Idrissi oh thank you
She has such great comedic sense, I really love her
와 근데 진짜 잘한다ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 나머지 두분들 다 진짜 안흔들리고 잘하신다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ마지막 분도 진짜 표정은 완전 실력자..👍👍
their harmonization is perfect
xia has supreme visuals and is a really talented singer and dancer, hell at some point she was even the main vocal for rania. i wish she was recruited by a big company.
I got so touched when Soyou started dancing. I kinda feel like she missed being in a group
음치인 사람이 목청은 제일 좋네
신기해여ㅋㅋ쏙쏙귀에박힘용
ㅇㅈㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅇㅈ여
원래잘하는데 일부로 못부르는척하라고 시킨득...근데 그런사람들 꽤많음;;
아!!! 스포 당했엌ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
It so confused me....I feel happy and sad at the same time, at the moment I laugh so hard coz this is so funny...but moment later I feel so sad coz I miss SISTAR so bad (seen Soyou smile make it even harder...I miss SISTAR so bad) 😭😭😭
Same same same same
yea...I miss SISTAR too :(, miss Bora, Hyorin, Soyou, & Dasom together on stage again :'(
😭😭😭😭
😭😭me too i miss sistar
I clicked the video because I knew that was sistar's song lol i feel happy yet my heart feels heavy 😢😢
아 음치분 너무귀여우시다❤️
When you suddenly miss SISTAR and RANIA.😑😒😞😢😭
아니 음치분 진짜 너무 귀여우시다ㅠ큐큐큐큐큐 이렇게 호감형 음치 처음 봐,,,
Bruv give that girl an award pls, she's soo confident
gotta admit the bad singer Na Young has guts, to be that bad, know your that bad, and be able to perform a whole song in front of cameras, artists, and an audience, still deserves the applause
Super good dancer and presence 😭✌️
Right I was like she has balls since the first 2 were good
The girl saying pretty 0:54 is Xia, a former member of gg Rania
Oh she has such a nice voice
애인에게
자연스럽게 화음이 ㅋㅋㅋ(불협화음)
soyou doing the dance with them! 😭💕 i miss sistar!
The bad singer How is she be so fine with everyone laughing at her it needs really a lot of patience and more of a positive mind she know herself a lot such a braveness👏👏
아직도 나는 그녀를 잊지 못한다....
When I saw this episode, I recognized Xia right away!! I missed her so much :( It was nice to hear her voice again
I can't be the only one that thinks the harmony was strangely satisfying
True hahaha
Jinyoung was Xia in Rania, and Yuna is my bias in Camila 😍 Nayoung is also really good with her confidence!
I LOVE THIS!!! Kudo to the girl who can sing! What a brave soul!!
마지막 멤버 골때리네 ㅋㅋ
너무 매력적이라서 반하는 목소리랄까
ㅎㅇ ㅋㅋ
저 시아언니 많이 좋아하는데 ㅠㅠㅠ 딱 봤을때 이미 알아 ㅜㅜㅜ
Soyou saying how she was a fan of Rania to Xia melted my heart 😭❤
음치분 웹드에서 본듯 연기 잘하시던데 악역이었지만 이뻐서 반했다는....
Even though she doesn’t sing well at least she can dance 😂
4:59 Yeonjung was ready to fight with Kihyun lol
You should watch the whole episode. They were bantering and cutely fighting like sibling lol
All of them actually. Even donghyun, he was fighting with kwill like crazy hahaha
HAHAHAHAHA I LOVE STARSHIP FAMILY 😍
the girl in the middle is yuna, she's a main vocalist and maknae of an independent group "camila"
My girl Xia is so perfect!!!! I hope she will join another group, i still love RaNia no matter what!
Xia become a gamer on twitch ❤
@@dansingone1953 I know it's been long but what's her twitch? i can't find it anywhere T.T
The bad singer has been on here before by herself. I love that she keeps coming back.
That girl with the bad voice is really confident..she really kept a straight face, I commend her for that
Low-key she can sing I think she was forcing it a bit tbh.
seeing soyou's reaction, u know rania was a HUGE thing.. but got screwed out by DRM
when RANIA came out with Dr. Feel Good, I remember I almost choked on my pasta. They were such a shock. I never saw anything like that in Kpop before that time. At the same time, I was lowkey impressed by their vocals and later became obsessed with their main and lead vocals.
태연히 끝까지 해낸 당신은 진정한 프로. 짝짝짝짝짝짝!
음치인데 노래할때마다 자막이 귀엽게 한글자씩 들어가니까 더 웃긴다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 자신감도 좋고 음치중에 이게 제일 웃긴듯ㅋㅋ
세분다 너무 예쁘네요!! 항상 좋은일만 가득하길!!!
I miss Jang Jin-young aka. Xia. She left RaNia after being apart of the group since she was like 16. I wish she would rejoin like Yina did, she has an amazing voice that i don't want to go unused, but we'll see.
용기있는 그대들을 응원합니다 화이팅
Look at kihyun jumping 😂😂😂 so cute 😂 but oh god i laugh so hard on that girl's voice 😂😂😂
2:45 라니아 시아.. 음색이랑 성량 봐 걸그룹 짬밥 나타나네..... 라니아에서 젤 눈에 띄는 멤버였는데
I like the show but at the same time I feel bad... because it’s fun to get it right and stuff but it kinda hurts to see the person to be laughed at. But I admire how strong they can be to be on stage and face the crowds, respect to that.
음치 너무 귀여운데.ㅎ
She is from Camila,,maknae and lead vocal Jeong Yuna
Main Vocal
Yeah Yuna is Main Vocalist. Choim is Lead Vocalist.
@@Kpopsegye which one is cho im? tge tone deaf one?
@@kookiesbrownshoes7756 choim isn't there
@@kookiesbrownshoes7756 No she isnt here haha, Choim is in the girl group with Yuna who is the first girl to sing. I was just clarfying Horin xi's mistake of Yuna's position in her group. (Not This Group)
I'm happy to see Donghyun here.😣
대단한 음치인데 왠지 계속보게 된다...ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Can people really sing this bad?
I feel like they’re faking it. Like they’re not even trying.
Nah, she's just tone deaf.
Believe me they can 😂 I have a friend that has no rythm and is pretty hard to even recognize the song she is singing 😌 so yeah it is possible to sing that bad 🙏
yeah there are people like that, my mom is also like that when she sings along in the church
It's possible 😃 . I have a friend who's tone deaf . She said that it's hard for her to hear the tone correctly 😃
It’s not bout singing bad. She’s tone deaf.
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ음치 매력있는 언니네
I choked on my own saliva while laughing at No. 3 singer but at least she had self confidence to be up there to perform! ❤️
음치랑 실력자랑 앨범 내라 ㅋㅋ
불협화음이 의외로 조화롭다
아니 저상황에서 어떻게 저렇게 진지하게 노랠하지??? 진짜 노래실력보다 멘탈갑이다
When you know that your a bad singer but have high level of confidence
음친데 되게 매력있다~
PLEASE GIVE MORE LOVE TO CAMILA!!! THEY'RE AN INDEPENDENT GIRL GROUP! THEIR SONG RED LIPS IS SUCH A BOP!!!
음치저여자분 진짜 매력적이다
3:55 왠지 모르겠지만 은근 화음이 되는 것 같앸ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
can the girl just be a rapper.. lol dont sing
This comment just admit that rappers can't Rap
Too mean. Everyone can learn singing.
@@zako8424 you mean sing???
@@yurix6072 but you would need to work to get even half as good as the other 2 girls...
@@dt4654 yah but learning doesnt hurt
3:02 aigoo our hamster 😂😂
Waiting for ALL Monsta X members to be here 😩
wait where is kihyun?
@@jkjaek a jumping kid on our right
wait really?! lmao
I saw a kihyun jumping and all I could think of is... That's how my hamster looks when is scared or leaping from one place to another lol
넘 재미있고
Seriously mnet, please make produce 101 2nd chance for this amazing ex idol,you guy can just sign them a 7 year contract,seriously Rania is major throwback, I love their debut song
Qim Dodol that’s what the Unit was supposed to be. I wish they stuck to it instead of letting idols who are currently active compete too but it was a good show.
실력자 두분 너무 매력적인데..
How can she do that with a serious face???!
Now I'm a fan of her😂😂
i love her professionalism
Xia RANIA? OMG HOW DARE YOU XIA. 🤩🤩 YES MY QUEEN IS BACK
She's really confident on stage even she can't sing.good job
HOLY 3:45 how can she sing like that after dancing so much
This is an interesting show,the only thing I hate about this show is how they laugh and being disrespectful towards the ones that cannot sing.However,I still love this show very much.
Y’ALL WHO REMEMBERS RANIA?! that one song was freakin ICONIC
실력자 두 분 웃길법했는데 흔들리지 않고 부르는게 대단하심
2:57 이분 그 웹드라마 찐엔딩의 김혜지역 배우 아닌가요?!?!?!?!?
어디서 많이 봤다했는데 찐엔딩이었네
맞는거 같아요 저도 그 생각나서 댓글 보다가 이 댓글 봐서 댓 남겨용
힘들고 우울할때마다 봅니다ᆢ나도 모르게 웃음이 자꾸나와요
Xia is a great singer😭 Miss RaNia so much😭😭😭
I'm crying oh my!!!
I still miss SISTAR!!
Me to 😭😭
*1:12** Kihyun heared what the audience said and laugh with them 😂😍*
I was really expecting jong kook to join in because he danced this in running man
i miss rania n sistar...happy to see soyu
You can see soyou misses performing as sistar 😢😢😢
Love the third girl. She has a fan. Enjoy yourself girl.
Seriously, im so jealous of every tone-deaf that perform on stage. They have a lot confidents.
케이윌 왜케 자꾸 쓸데없이 잘생겨지냐
Xia is like my favorite member from Rania alongside T-ae. Sad that they are n9t active anymore. And when Soyu said she was a fan!
Support Yuna!!!! Stan Camila!!!💘💘
I'm here only for Yuna! Stan talent, stan CAMILA💕
음치분 지금 찐엔딩 나오시는 배우분이시네
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 저는 마지막 분이 제일 좋아요
omg RANIAAAAAA!! that song was HELLA famous back then ;;;;;
Soyu was a fan of Rania? Wow
Glad to hear that but fuck you DRM for your poor management strategies to make RANIA so famous. Arghh!
it wasn't just about poor management. majority of people even international kpop fans didn't like their debut song. i remember majority of kpop fans called rania whores. even allkpop had to make an article defending the group. @@redblue7241
@@digiworld1989
Thanks for idea but yeah so sad hahgaha
@@digiworld1989 oh you still around after harassing idols? Hey girl. I honestly hope you changed.
@@VolumePerfection I will always be around. Worry about yourself not about me.
Kudos to the 3rd singer girl. Even if you can't sing, when you own it and have fun with it, what does it matter?
I’m actually kind of surprised that she still has a good sense of rhythm 😂😂😂
볼때마다 빠져든다.ㅋㅋㅋ