جزاك اللهُ خيراً Some imams even in Jummah they don’t really pause too long after each ayaah of fatihah, nor do they pause long enough after Saying “Ameen” So إن شاء الله I will act upon this opinion
The sunnah, even if you follow the opinion of those that say Al fatihah is obligatory, is to not stop and let others recite while the imam is reciting as well
From what I've read there were some Ulama that said that reading Fatihah in Sholat Sirr is Wajib however if the Imam read too fast the responsibility is on Imam especially if Imam read it in Sirr faster than in Jahr. So, be careful if you become an Imam as the hadits said كلكم رَاعٍ، وكلكم مسؤول عن رَعِيَّتِهِ
@@nether0701 then who were khawarij?? They were too extreme. Mutazilas were extremely rational Jahmiaas were extreme Mujassimas were extreme. Islam encourages us to have etadaal in any dispute.
😔some Sheikh on TH-cam said, if it's silent rakah of dhuhur/ashr etc and somehow you couldn't finish fatiha, (like I'm new to Islam) and imam rise up from ruku, then that rakah is void and suppose if it happens in 4th rakah, then that means all my earlier rakah are void and i need to repeat prayer
And there are differences of opinion amongst the scholars, and you aren't a mujtahid. Do you think all of the imams of the Hanabilah never knew this hadith?
جزاك اللهُ خيراً
Some imams even in Jummah they don’t really pause too long after each ayaah of fatihah, nor do they pause long enough after Saying “Ameen”
So إن شاء الله I will act upon this opinion
They are upon Hanafi Fiqh
The sunnah, even if you follow the opinion of those that say Al fatihah is obligatory, is to not stop and let others recite while the imam is reciting as well
Barakhallah Feek 👍
From what I've read there were some Ulama that said that reading Fatihah in Sholat Sirr is Wajib however if the Imam read too fast the responsibility is on Imam especially if Imam read it in Sirr faster than in Jahr. So, be careful if you become an Imam as the hadits said
كلكم رَاعٍ، وكلكم مسؤول عن رَعِيَّتِهِ
Mishkat al masabih 854
It is safer to recite it says the Shaykh. Muslims be on the safe side to go to Jannah.
But Sheikh Saleh Al Fawzan in other video said that one must recite it in silent rakats and should try to revite it in loud rakats if he is able to
But some Salafi scholars say it is necessary to recite it behind imam like from India, Pakistan, Europe and America.
Yes In Silent Prayers
Ajami salafis are too extreme
@@zaidshaikh4935 there's nothing too extreme in Islam it's the thought of feminists, liberals, communists and secularists
@@nether0701 then who were khawarij??
They were too extreme.
Mutazilas were extremely rational
Jahmiaas were extreme
Mujassimas were extreme.
Islam encourages us to have etadaal in any dispute.
😔some Sheikh on TH-cam said, if it's silent rakah of dhuhur/ashr etc and somehow you couldn't finish fatiha, (like I'm new to Islam) and imam rise up from ruku, then that rakah is void and suppose if it happens in 4th rakah, then that means all my earlier rakah are void and i need to repeat prayer
There are some differences of opinion but this is the view of the majority and is strong
Listen Shamshi On Dus Dawah
لا صلاة لمن لم يقرأْ بفاتحة الكتاب (صحيح البخاري)
There is no prayer for one who does not recite the fatihatul kitaab means sure fathia (Sahi Bukhari)
@@Zohaib-we9jk0:20
@@ali-fn3lemost favorable opinion is to recite whether in jahriyyah or sirriyyah whether it is imam or muqtadi واللّٰه اعلم
Mishkhat al masabih 854
Read if you are able to.
Akhī then the Ḥadīth of Rasool'Allāh ﷺ saying about Salah is not without al-fatiha(Umm al-Qur'ān)
The Imam's recitation is enough
There is another video of Shaykh Fawzan saying we have to recite in silent prayers?
@@ZaynElAbideen another cluleless muqallid, your salah is becoming more and more like the salah of the hanafis, keep your opinions to yourselves.
And there are differences of opinion amongst the scholars, and you aren't a mujtahid.
Do you think all of the imams of the Hanabilah never knew this hadith?
Both have their evidences