Radio-carbinated Dinosaurs
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ก.ย. 2024
- Like my shirt?
www.funbibi.co...
Here is the link to the whole playlist.
• Dutko Against All Reason
This playlist addresses Bob Dutko's sermon "Answering the Skeptic"
• Answering The Skeptic ...
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @aronra
If you like what I do, please consider supporting my efforts.
PATREON► / aronra
PAYPAL► www.paypal.me/...
![[FULL EP.16] เซียนพาลุย "เผือก-ฟรอยด์" กรี๊ดลั่น จนปูหนี | เฮ็ดอย่างเซียนหรั่ง | One Playground](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FsqUvwS3b-Y/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm reminded here of the saying, "You are entitled to your own opinions, but you are not entitled to your own facts." Food for thought for mr. Dutko
Sadly for reason, Bob D does not care about truth, just donations...
@@bloodgrss we are going to love him anyway, right?
I also prefer to phrase it, "You are entitled to your own opinion, insofar as it can be rationally defended."
@ageofrocks you are getting there. If you have the love there is no need to argue a rationale, especially in a paradoxical world. Lighten up silly Billy. Go easy cheesy. The ghosts stay in the basement because they can't stand to be around good energy. You have the love within. Let it out. Here: I love you, professor. ❤️
I have always like the following quote from Brian Cox
“The problem with today’s world is that everyone believes they have the right to express their opinion AND have others listen to it.
The correct statement of individual rights is that everyone has the right to an opinion, but crucially, that opinion can be roundly ignored and even made fun of, particularly if it is demonstrably nonsense!” - Brian Cox
Young earth creationists - the only group I know of that thinks The Flintstones is a documentary.
@@tucsonorganist hatred is a weird thing.
@@BobbyBrewersmagats are wierd😂
@@reefnreefer maggots are baby flies.
Atheists - the only group I know of that declare some people think the Flintstones is a documentary and pat themselves on the back as though they said something witty.
Fun fact about the flintstones. Its the first television broadcast with a couple sitting in bed.
I'm leaving this comment to feed the 'Al Gore Rhythm'. You're Welcome.
Heh. He's a hungry boy mr rythyms. I'll see what I can find to feed him too.
That was awesome!
An inconvenient tooth? (Radio carbon dated to before the bible says the earth was poofed into existence!!)
@@HT-io1eg good morning! Peace and love. Paz y amor. Pace e amore. Shalom ahava. Pax et Caritas. Irene Kai agapi. Fred och karlek (FIEDOOSHALICK)
"Al Gore Rhythm" smh that's peak dad joke cringe attempt at humor right there. I'm not sure what's more cringe actually, the attempt itself or the fact that you thought you were being clever. Imagine thinking the concept of rhythm and Al Gore even belong anywhere near each other. Maximum CRINGE
'We have been conditioned to believe...' complains the man in the pulpit.
To be fair he was not conditioned, for most religitards I think their beliefs were hammered into them. Which as I write this I am realizing that hammering is just a very aggressive form of conditioning.
Thanks again for having me on to help clear up misconceptions in Earth science! As always, I’m happy to discuss anything I might have missed, or your questions, here in the comments.
You were so valuable on this panel! Thank you for working with me.
@ageofrocks subscribed to you just now. Keep on doing what you do. Very good, I'm not sure if you are prof. Center or Dr B. No disrespect, have memory issues: the new ones don't form well, and the old ones come a lot. Please keep going on the show. It's free education and it's actually better than most paid. A nice jar of a tapeworm would be cool. Memorial for the 4 in Georgia who are resting and gaining their solemnity in the dream. They die and live. Love for those in need of love. Hatred and fear; no thanks.
@@BobbyBrewers Dr. Baker here, and thanks for the kind words. Glad to know you find it educational. That's motivation to keep coming back!
@@ageofrocks thanks Dr Baker.
I just went to your TH-cam channel, and you appear to be _criminally_ undersubscribed to. Your channel reminds me of all of those old-school creationist-debunking channels from that sort of "Golden Age" of skeptic TH-camrs that came out a few years after TH-cam itself.
Your book also sounds awesome. I'd love to see you come back and promote it when it comes out.
Delicious carbonated dino beverages! Allosaurus Ale -- The Ginger Ale with Bite!
thats great :D
*"This episode of 'Dutko: Super-Apologist!' is brought to you by 'GEO-FIZZY'™: the only soft drink made from RADIO-CARBONATED DINOSAURS! We now join Dr. Dutko, as he struggles against his nemesis, Aron the Rational..."*
@@Lucius1958 Foil hat sold separately.
AND his consort Al-Go-Rythma!😂
Don't forget Velociraptor velocity that has FIVE times the caffeine of a single cup of coffee.
'We have to look at this through fresh eyes. Now, lets look at this 4000 year old book for answers'
Yeah. No.
That open mind of yours better vindicate the mythology I was born into 🤔
Yet some think the Bible is the only truth in the world
some scary S…. there..
This series has been so ridiculously helpful to me. I deconstructed some time ago, but I am always trying to pick apart the misinformation I was fed as a kid.
Professor Dave is doing a pretty good series all about creationist misinformation right now that covers a lot of the real science that we know
@Rhewin meditate on this once: we are all searching for God. Try to be with God. Do you remember any miracles that happened to you or curses that formed from the hatred. How was your life changed?
@@jameshall1300 not to knock dave in any way at all much repsect for the man subbed there as well . watched the dave vs falt earth vid many times lol . anyways my point aron is not only wonderful to listen to has that wisdom that many never will , again not trying to say dave is lesser than . aron is an og and a true article deserves the views . i see aron post and im sitting already . i clik and immediatly hit the like button .
@@BobbyBrewers nope.
@@Rhewin heard.
Guy makes bald jokes at the expense of himself. I respect that.
she is trying to convinse the chicks, that baldhess is sexy
@jonathankennedy1963 respect and love. I like this comment. Prof. C is a good teacher. I like how he accents the logistical jargon with a humble joke. It's like saying I'm real, I'm telling you the truth. Prof. C is cool.
And it looks like he's not too concerned about how well he can adjust a necktie - a man after my own heart right there! 👍
@discontinuedmodel232 not very cool words
@@discontinuedmodel232 he is probably putting in time teaching people how to not be ignorant.
"You can date how old I am by how bald I am", beautiful 👌
Creationists seem to want to keep things so simple that they ascribe to willful ignorance and a refusal to learn the science. But, even when they do attempt the science, it seems they half ass it. This video exposes exactly why we leave the deeper maths and science to the experts that are willing to devote their lives to these studies. Yes, of course, do your research, but part of that is to know when you are outgunned in the field.
When you are doing your own research ensure that the sites you are getting your information from are reliable and credible.
@@vestafreyja Agreed, checking several sources to be safe. I don't expect all the results to be identical but they will be very similar and give the means that they came to their results. You make a very good point.
Science began with creationists like Sir Isaac Newton. Try doing a bit of research.
@@elgatofelix8917 mistake physics for evolution. third best creationist past time.
and for be clear newton in old age repudiated his works in natural philosophy and delved very hard in theologu and esoteric matters.
I just checked ChatGPT (that counts as research in 2024, no?) and apparently Newton wasn't so knowledgeable about geology and paleontology. He didn't even attempt to address the heat problem associated with fast radioactive decay!
Dutko having the audacity to complain about indoctrination when he’s grifting for religion.
Every creationists spouting "Noah took baby dinosaurs on the Ark!" knows jack about young animals. They are bad at surviving in general. Delicate, needing constant care, prone to infections and accidents. Many have special dietary requirements - they can't survive on the same food adults eat. smh
But Noah was obviously an expert in animal husbandry, just like he was an expert in maritime construction! Because, erm, gawd majik!
I said this for a video on one of the videos on a Creationists channel on TH-cam. All I got was Yes, you are quite right that carbon dating can't be used for specimens older than 50,000 years. But guess what...IT WILL WORK for samples that (as they assert) are only 4-6000 years old. So why haven't you carbon-dated rocks, if they're only less than 6000 years old?
Good question
I wouldn't ask about carbon dating rocks, however, you can point out that ALL life forms should have tons of carbon remaining if the Earth is only 1 carbon half life old.
We should never see, for example, a 20k year old mammoth, a 10k tree ring, 25k organic material in lake sediments (which also match the annual sediment layers).
Why do we see ANY organic material with only trace amounts? Where did it all go?
Omg, I got served up a Christian sermon ad in the middle of one of dukos talk in your video. I was doing dishes while listening.. Took me a minute to figure it out.
next time, don't do dishes
@@Sergiu.antifascist lol
@@samihawasli7408 how spontaneous. Think if it was a Hindu add about Gandhi coming back to save us!
TH-cam is tricky that way, sometimes they slip into a commercial at strategic points in your video.
Last time I was this early for a video, Jesus was still riding a T-Rex throughs the plains of Nebraska XD
Nope. No one named Tony or T knows me. He was someone my friend in high school was interested in back In 1992. She mentioned him often. He is not someone who knows anything about me or my ex husband Jason or our daughters.
@@NikkiDocherty3174 Dimple monkey twice the pudding octopi for tangoman cellular...scooter my daisyheads.
The preacher claims that people have been conditioned to believe that the universe is based on billions. He ( like his precher brotherhood) condition people into believing that the universe is only a few thousand years old. We now know that the universe is larger and older than we thought it was just over a century ago.
And go back a bit more in time and forebears of his ilk were persecuting astronomers ffs. Well past time to move on..
As a fellow Godzillist, I LOVE YOUR SHIRT AND WANT ONE OF MY OWN!!!!
@SuperPuzzler I like the shirt too because Godzilla is super famous and notorious for trashing Metropolitan areas while not wearing pants!
Faith is the art of lying to yourself. Critical thinking is the art of questioning yourself.
Religion *IS* politics.
The faith you have in thinking your comment was worth posting is the most cringe form of irony I've seen in a while
@@elgatofelix8917^
True. There is very little difference, really
This Dutko guy is quite dangerous. If you aren't well informed on the topics he's covering you could come away thinking he has a point. His level of dishonesty with misrepresentation of facts is considerably higher level than the likes of WLC, the Hovinds, and even Ken Ham himself. I can see through their arguments just fine, but Dutko is spitting out factoids like with the lost squadron, however misleading, which can throw people off if they aren't familiar. He even knows the common rebuttals and is an expert well poisoner in regards. He's even balsy enough to throw out dates and name drop organizations... which most apologists won't, again however misleading.
Great work Aron. And you are rocking that shirt. Where can i find one?
Sometimes, if querried, i tell people I'm an ammonite. Thus far no one has had any follow up. Everybody just nods agreeably. (I live in the bible belt)
Lol. I like it. I'm going to start telling any Jehovah's Witnesses who come to my door that I'm a deuterostome.
No way will they know what it means. They'll just think it's a denomination.
I knew a guy from Idaho who was an Ammonite.
@@ronm3245 I know a guy from Portsmouth who is a Bible belt purple belt. Obnoxious twat.
I love how AronRa is wearing a Godzilla shirt for a discussion on Dinosaurs.
Notice how this preacher started off? "We have been conditioned to believe:"
No buddy. The conditioning has been done by the church and not the other way around. The really sad thing is the people sitting in front of him willing to forego their own logic & reasoning.
You rock, Aron. Theists keep setting themselves up. You keep knocking them down. 😀
Its possibly the funniest video title ive seen on the internet; I couldn't resist. Happy to find the content to be equally as hilarious as it is informative. Thanks Aron.
Excellent guests Aron
Nice Godzilla shirt Aron!
Lovin' the Godzilla shirt/thumbnail image!
It's good to see more Godzilla fans out in the world :)
Legendary shirt❤
@odrikronnin-gamer6579 it is. My closet only has one item of clothing that I think is cooler. It's a 1970 field utility jacket with a patch of a golden dragon in blood red background that I sewn together in his honor. My brother used to wear it and I wear it. Never wash the sweat blood and tears out of it. Thay shirt with Godzilla is cool, especially the Japanese rising sun effect in the background.
One promising thing about this video is how few people are there listening to him.
"Radio-Carbonated Dinosaur" sounds like an energy drink that would kill you on the third sip.
I reckon it would taste like fizzy chicken 😂
I so love you explaining this still, Aron! People forget that these apologist liars,(theses that make money at this) have a new crop of young believers just discovering the real world every year or so. And the apologists like these love using half-truths! But I like the 'carbonated' thought, lol. Tyranicola Rex or Tripepsitops! Or, Diplodisodacus! Ooh, Popsidactyl!👍🏼🌊💙💙💙🌊🥰✌
Oh my goodness, I love your shirt, Aron! I have the very same one! Plus 2 more like it with different prints...😊
super guests, thanks so much for sharing!
This video has the perfect intersection of interests for me and I love it. I’m right in the sweet spot where I know enough that it’s easy to follow but I still get some new information. Great guests!
Creations always lie. *Always.*
Learned a lot about how dating works in science with this one. Thank you to all involved.
atheists are among the highest percentage of incels world wide. lowest religious demographic to have kids and families per capita
@@TheSecondR That's not what being an incel means. Grow up kid.
One comforting thought for me was how empty the pews were. Presumably Dutko's crew picked the best angle for the filming ? They went for Jesus Juice and instead got misinformation about carbon dating !
A point to mention - chemistry (particularly analytical chemistry, where I spent 20 years) does not deal in "zeros" and "nones". Experimentation and statistical assessments of control samples give Limits of Detection and Limits of Quantification.
One cannot say "There is zero Uranium in this sample" because even a single U atom would falsify the statement. Instead, based on the instrumentation, one can only say "there is LESS THAN 20 parts-per-trillion (ppt) Uranium in this sample" with any confidence, if the instrumentation has been demonstrated to be accurate to that degree (given demonstrated repeatability, noise levels, and other quality control measures)
A detection limit may be in %, parts per million, billion, trillion, quadrillion in some cases. But a lab CANNOT and will not say "zero" for an elemental concentration. "None detected" is the closest, but it's a literally truthful statement that inevitably refers back to how little of an analyte the instrument can reliably quantify.
Wow, that sure is an empty set of pews in front of him. Must be a rough time making money by lyin' for Jesus.
i have a guy im arguing with trying to tell me that evolution breaks the 2nd law of thermodynamics and that stars are not formed because of gravity.
literally less than 1 minute on google could show this man that he is wrong but he just refuses to accept it.
i dont know how you have dealt with these kinds of people for as long as you have without going crazy
Carbon dating can only be done on something with carbon! Most fossils are composed of rock/minerals that have replaced the original wood/bone.
I wonder if it even registers for him that fossils are no longer bone and are in fact rocks, much less what that means in terms of chemical composition
@@ivanivonovich9863 To quote Potholer54 "Oey Hovind there is no fucking Carbon in that!".
@@verdantvixen96 He is a yec... I wonder as to what he even thinks about most things.
a preacher lying brazenly from the pulpit of a church ...
To be honest probably a deceived pastor preaching deception he thinks is true. BOTH ARE BAD, LYING WOULD BE WORSE
Must be a day with an a in the name.
A welder welding
…
Every preacher lies for their faith its what the sheeple have been taught from childhood.
You are a timeless voice of reason! World needs more people like you. Keep it up.
Merci !
I learned about the contamination of fossils by C14 via carbonates I did not know!
When we listen to these guys… they make it sound as if scientists come up with their theories simply because they do not believe in the bible…. Like… They are atheists and therefore evolution.
Get psychiatric help, though I think it's too late for you...
Well, yes, because they think they're dealing with players of the same game in a different jersey.
Welcome back Jonathan Baker
Dutko says there were only a handful of dinosaurs that grew really large. He doesn't even know (or is lying about) the extent of the fossil record we have. There were two species of triceratops alone, many more large ceratopsians. What about all the species of tyrannosaurs, titanosaurs, stegosaurs, hadrosaurs - just to name a few of the more iconic genera?
What really really bothers me is how confident people can be when they're ignorant on a subject matter. I get that faith necessarily requires one maintain ignorance, but it's still annoying 😑
@@Maxrepfitgm when you are cold, think hot thoughts. I always picture myself back in South Beach when I am numb and shivering. This is a mind flip.
I take some satisfaction from seeing that the pews are about three-quarters empty. Maybe that means few of the normal congregation have any interest in apologetics, or maybe it was the unexpected side-effect of holding a Kiddies' Snake-Handling Extravaganza the previous week.
Great information, thank you.
Appropriate shirt for the subject matter!!
I want that shirt!!!
AronRa,nobody rocks that shirt like you do!
The simple answer is that SOME rocks date SOME fossils. SOME fossils date SOME rocks.
Pre-ordered the book, can't wait!
That starting statement basically boils down to "you'd be crazy to think that if you have no apples, getting two apples will make you have 5 apples. But what if the evidence proves that to be true".
I mean yes it would be interesting and unexpected, but the evidence simply shows that it isn't true.
Regarding the "censorship", Dutko claimed that this information is censored from school textbooks specifically. Which is wild, because none of these are high school level topics. Why would they put something so niche as the challenges of carbon dating dino bones in a school textbook?!
I prefer my dinosaurs fuel-injected.
@@Cant.Take.It.Anymore oh yeah, turbo dinosaurs! Draw that!
Gas turbines are the way forward. You know, turbojet, turbofan, turboprobactrosaurus.
28 seconds ago? Sure, let's go!
I just love that Dutko thinks that the amount of Carbon-14 remains locked within an organism and there is no exchange over time. The radiometric dating process is to measure the half-life of the Carbon-14 that was present in the organism, but the system isn't completely isolated and it's a darn good thing.
If every organism that was buried on earth locked in all of their Carbon-14 atoms, wouldn't that have a significant impact on the amount of elemental Carbon within our environment?
Thanks!
"I think God was smart enough to send the giant dinosaurs on the ark as babies!"
But he wasn't smart enough to just not flood the entire Earth and murder everything just because a handful of humans pissed him off????
It's Young God theory... The deity was a teenager at the time of the flood, and was still kind of a spoiled brat, and rebellious.
@@GizzyDillespee That's a new one for me. Wait, if God is eternal, though, how was he a teenager?
Imagine going to church to a casual praying session , and have to listen to that guy bad speech, about wrong radio-carbon dating. 😂
I know, imagine trying to better yourself and here comes a dunce, dumass, unqualified, simpleton, with no credentials and a Bible. Holy shhhit. -that happend to me. I was indoctrinated. It's stolckholm for christ, don't fear. People go by data. We are blessed with that.
If I went to a *"church"* why should I expect *ANYONE* to give a *"speech"* about radio-carbon dating?
@manifold1476 quoted church and speech. Okay, it is just a dude searching for meaning. You have a service and someone just goes and talks about something then leave it to you to decide. Please, battle the hatred and join the love. It is way better on the sunny side. Right?
At 0:46 It sounds like someone giggled at him LOL. even his own congregation isn't buying it!
"evolutional dating laboratories", of course unbiased as ever
Thank you for this enlightening discussion
Thanks!
I just cannot fathom how dumb someone would need to be to believe that dinosaurs existed when Jesus did. Something tells me if Brontosaurus were walking around, number one we'd have footprints, and number two your buildings wouldn't survive. Plus, what are people going to do against a pack of Carnotaurus? Give me a break dude.
As always, appreciate the content and information!
what a panel, so interesting thanks
Great video!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
@Spinozilla109 ❤️ plus you got that handle spinozilla. Noice🤗
@@BobbyBrewersthanks
So we could prank future creationists by burying everything in chalk or limestone?
The work you do aron is so important.
😂😂😂
Carbon dating anything older than a few thousand years old is worse than weighing a glass of water with a ruler, since math can get you close on the water.
Thanks for the video and the series, Aron. These in-depth deconstructions of the bulshit artists' gish-gallops are very much needed, if only to see the sheer number of lies contained within.
Love that shirt 😂❤️❤️🦖
Great Shirt!!
Great shirt, Aron!😊
Science: take verifiable facts, create a hypothesis explaining the relationship, test hypothesis, examine results, reach conclusion based on evidence discovered in your research. Repeat to confirm results.
Religion: assume your conclusion, twist verifiable facts to fit your conclusion.
"I'm no mathematician, but let's be honest" he says... Let's be honest ROFL. You're a creationist apologist Dutko, don't be ridiculous.
26:38 "It's hard to come up with an ending to that sentence that is not insulting"
It's not an insult if it's just a true statement...
In the old days liars got their tongues cut out. Not sayin' anything, just sayin'.
And that was when religion was in charge 😂
That was when religion was in charge 😂
@@stephenhill8790actually religion is outlawed in communist countries
Just because Bob Dutko isn't Kent Hovind doesn't mean Bob Dutko isn't Kent Hovind.
The funniest and telling thing creationists always say that Noah only took the babies as if any animal that isn’t like a turtle or most species of insects is totally ok with a weird bearded man taking their kids, and saying babies don’t require much care or feeding. With those who have taken care of human children and baby pets they require serious care and attention, and we wouldn’t have a Noah’s Ark story if Noah was gored or turned into a blood stain on the ground from animals that are a lot more protective with their kids than a turtle.
Plus, by the time Noah got back from Sumatra with the baby komodo dragons, they'd be adults. There were no airlines, back then. When he got back from South America, with the macaws... dang it - they're both males! What bad luck! All the different penguins, the polar bears... it all makes the ark itself anticlimatic. The best adventures would've been traveling the world in a much bigger ship, trying to locate and catch all these animals. It would make a fantastic movie.
Don't forget that the Ark housed all these animals for nearly 15 months, not just 40 days, so they would need enough food for everything to last more than an entire year
@@Starhawke_Gaming that would also have generated a ton of fecal matter to dispose of too.
@@invaderhorizongreen8168 - not as much as what comes out of Creationists' mouths
Kangaroos and other marsupials climb out of the pouch and crawl thousands of miles the Noah without being food for other animals
I get the impression that Bob never got around to reviewing these findings of his with any actual scientists.
Honest people ask honest questions - sure seems like old Bob kept these talking points in special sermons for his congregation’s ears only.
… this is Bob’s method of staying right forever.
DUDE you are crushun 57 if thats true
This guy is a sorry sight, but I feel all the sorrier for the congregation.
Thanks for the upload Aron ❤️. I've always wanted to know how they carbon date fossils and bone that has long since decayed. You only ever hear about dating organic matter. Love your work 👍
33:48
“Evolution” covers ALL deep time adjacent science in the YEC’s mind.
❤
AronRa : Where did you get that really cool and badass radio-carbinated Godzilla T-shirt ? I want one like that !
When is your next book coming out?
Dear Dutko: If the truth is on your side, why do you have to lie so much?
If we plant a testing mesh distributed over the globe we would be able to carbon date the earth in a potentially new way. We would use geodesics of the projected oblate.
Perhaps starlink wants to help
Where are the Nobel Prizes for the discovery of young dinosaurs?
Get facts out there!
As the C14 in dinos trope comes up in Vol 2 of Rocks Were there, Jackson Wheat & I will allude to thise video at that point:
Bert Thompson & Brad Harrub 2017c went especially Golden Oldie, still relying on Dahmer et al.’s 1990 piece in the current revamp of their 2003 creationist Lesson Plan, while the recent epic six-hour creationist seminar “Evolution Exposed” couldn’t resist repeating it, which Dapper Dino dissected when he joined our coauthor JW for the Paulogia et al. 2021 video analysis. And we’ll toss in Jonathan Baker and Philip Senter similarly evaluating the misrepresented science in a recent creationism lecture by Bob Dutko (“Michigan’s #1 Christian Radio Show Host” available to discourse on such things for $600 and up, according to his website), Aron Ra et al. 2024.
Aron Ra is based af.
How about if humans and dinosaurs walked together?
OMG! Hello!