Well you can just bulldoze the japanese in these book with dictionary and basic understanding of japanese, just like i did back in the day. You just gotta overcome your own skill issue for things you wanna achieve. Heck phone can even translate by taking picture these days.
Anime too, trinity soul sucked but with an actual budget and a good animation studio it could be a banger, it helps that it would be a story created for the medium and not an adaptation of a 100 hour game.
@@naxzed_it If I remember correctly the person who did the translation videos for those mobile games deleted all of his accounts cause people tried cancelling him for translating a slur that was in one of the games
I remember finding this manga a long time ago on a manga app while looking for all the spinoff p5 manga. I just assumed “Crime and Punishment” was a mistranslation of “Sin and Punishment” so i never thought anything of it. This is unironically a really great story that i hope they repurpose into the main series.
p5 already takes heavy inspo from 1 and 2 and its kind of obvious from story elements to characters and their designs. i dont rhink it will ever go back because the sort of gothy morbid edgy stuff from 1 2 and even 3 was popular in the time those games came out and is only now seeing a resurgence
real. trying out p5r when i was like 16 was the coolest thing ever. now at 23 i find the games just hard to come back to. i don’t want to be a hs kid dating children, or the 30 year olds that are okay dating a 16 year old 😭 it would be cool to be an adult in a new game, but they won’t
@@chechilcheeser If you’re counting the mobile games technically more than a trilogy except the eternal punishment one is inconsistent lore wise, so it’s “canonness” is up in the air.
@@chechilcheeser There’s a ton of Persona Mobile Games, but for P2 specifically Innocent Sin got lost memories that immediately takes place after the ending and right before eternal punishment and eternal punishment got infinity mask which takes place right after it’s ending, but like I said infinity mask has lore inconsistencies. A company named GMode ported the Aigis P3 Spinoff mobile game and the persona 1 Mobile game, so I’m hoping they do the p2 games as well since without them they are lost media.
i think this is because of the fact that these villains are human rather than the p2 games' entities/deities. while I love Philemon and Nyarly as nigh unfathomable personifications of the good and evil of humanity (esp the fact that nyarly actually won at the end of p2:is!), this manga's villains have real, individual, human motivations and even better, history and relationships with the main cast, leading to much more in-depth fights and confrontations. so i'd say it's less about the quality of each media's villains but rather what they represent and bring to the table that is their respective stories!
"Crime and Punishment" a Mastema reference?!! Aside from that, the story of this "prequel" sounds cool as heck, a shame it doesn't have an official translation.
I don’t have much to add really but I’m glad to see you cover this manga! It was certainly a tough read the first time through and certain things or terminology is hard to follow due to the translation at times. What I really liked was the fact that the keys turned into swords that really changed the tides of battle. I also loved the reference to the the Black Books and the Red Book by Jung, being very explicitly mentioned in a Persona work. Overall I was a fan of the main cast and became very endeared to Kazumi! Thanks for a great video!
Reading this manga after it finally being translated allowed it to be something quite special in my heart, so I'm glad a video was done on it and a great one at that! :)
I'm French and recently found all 3 volumes at a reasonable price. I read the first two volumes and I was blown away. I haven't played any of the Persona 2 games (I've only played P5R for now) so I don't know how it compares but I for sure love the manga. Really looking forward to the final volume. I remember searching for the manga online and I could only find the Wikipedia article for it and nothing else. Glad to stumble upon this video.
Holy shit as a Persona fan i never know about this manga. I wish Atlus made a game based on this manga, with some change for the gameplay of course but should be a nice story as a spinoff or another universe from the main canon.
OHHH its this one..I read a bit of it in the internet (ofc and also obvious how), I was in a website and well I love persona but I wasn't blessed with much money so at times i literally watch gameplay, analysis vids, fact vids, anime, mangas, any form of persona content I can basically access for short and, while reading another manga, I just happen to saw this one at the side and was curious enough to read it since the cover looks really cool and its a persona i have never even heard of, Im glad to see someone talking about it, Im not really attached to it since i didn't went far cause I was reading something else at the time.
This was very interesting, I never actually paid much attention when I saw something about this previously. Thanks for sharing a neat part of persona history
Im one of the few who knew about this, mainly because i decided to open the megaten wiki protagonists page one day. I wanted to read it but saw no good translation and just kinda of gave up
Started out thinking this was just gonna be a SMT if video or something(idk anything about it beyond it sort of being Persona 0) If we ever do get that P2 remake imma need this manga adapted for a DLC expansion
Hear me out, probably aint gonna happen, but a persona spin off where the protagonist and party members are adults, but then again doing paper work instead of the school mini game would be boring but kinda funny at the same time
You talk a bit fast, even the captions can't print out what exactly are you saying. Sometimes it's not about how fast you talk too, but it's also your pronunciation that I often misunderstand.
we don’t talk about “I’m in the house like carpet.”
REALL LMAO
Ok, but what about The Velvet, turtle?
“If there’s to many heads in my blunt I’m gonna spark it, and put it in my pocket like rocket fuel”🎶
Cory
@@Ispyguy"Till' everybody's gone and it's cool, then I spark it up with my brother," 🗣️🗣️🔥🔥
Being a Megami Tensei AND a Tales of fan who doesn't know Japanese is a struggle.
I feel this with the Quantum Digital Devil Saga novels. I could only find volume 1 and 3 in english
Well you can just bulldoze the japanese in these book with dictionary and basic understanding of japanese, just like i did back in the day.
You just gotta overcome your own skill issue for things you wanna achieve.
Heck phone can even translate by taking picture these days.
FEMC / Kotone Shiomi: Where Am I?🤨
Kazumi Kiba: Hello there! Welcome to the void!😄
we need more persona manga that tell NEW stories in the world of the series
Anime too, trinity soul sucked but with an actual budget and a good animation studio it could be a banger, it helps that it would be a story created for the medium and not an adaptation of a 100 hour game.
Game so peak that even the obligatory spinoff manga is great
I thought you was gonna talk about the persona mobile games but no this is something the i never heard of
No but seriously where are those mobile games I wanna know about Akihiko's long lost cousin
@@naxzed_it If I remember correctly the person who did the translation videos for those mobile games deleted all of his accounts cause people tried cancelling him for translating a slur that was in one of the games
@@davidvandyke8182that's is a dumb thing to cancel for
swear he was gonna talk about the palm stuff
@@davidvandyke8182I hate humanity
I've heard of this before, I didn't believe I'd ever see a video on it
....I've genuinely never heard of this before
I remember finding this manga a long time ago on a manga app while looking for all the spinoff p5 manga. I just assumed “Crime and Punishment” was a mistranslation of “Sin and Punishment” so i never thought anything of it. This is unironically a really great story that i hope they repurpose into the main series.
Amazing story. I wish P6 would take notes from older Persona media and create something else instead of "school life with super powers".
no need to change if it already works
p5 already takes heavy inspo from 1 and 2 and its kind of obvious from story elements to characters and their designs. i dont rhink it will ever go back because the sort of gothy morbid edgy stuff from 1 2 and even 3 was popular in the time those games came out and is only now seeing a resurgence
real. trying out p5r when i was like 16 was the coolest thing ever. now at 23 i find the games just hard to come back to. i don’t want to be a hs kid dating children, or the 30 year olds that are okay dating a 16 year old 😭 it would be cool to be an adult in a new game, but they won’t
So technically persona 2 is a trilogy?
@@chechilcheeser If you’re counting the mobile games technically more than a trilogy except the eternal punishment one is inconsistent lore wise, so it’s “canonness” is up in the air.
@@Tasty_Tango45 There's a persona 2 mobile game???
@@chechilcheeser There’s a ton of Persona Mobile Games, but for P2 specifically Innocent Sin got lost memories that immediately takes place after the ending and right before eternal punishment and eternal punishment got infinity mask which takes place right after it’s ending, but like I said infinity mask has lore inconsistencies. A company named GMode ported the Aigis P3 Spinoff mobile game and the persona 1 Mobile game, so I’m hoping they do the p2 games as well since without them they are lost media.
villains in this p2 "prequel" manga sound way cooler than the actual p2 games ngl.
i think this is because of the fact that these villains are human rather than the p2 games' entities/deities. while I love Philemon and Nyarly as nigh unfathomable personifications of the good and evil of humanity (esp the fact that nyarly actually won at the end of p2:is!), this manga's villains have real, individual, human motivations and even better, history and relationships with the main cast, leading to much more in-depth fights and confrontations. so i'd say it's less about the quality of each media's villains but rather what they represent and bring to the table that is their respective stories!
I thought I knew most things about this franchise, like even the lost media mobile games. But somehow I’ve never heard of this. Great video!
"Crime and Punishment" a Mastema reference?!! Aside from that, the story of this "prequel" sounds cool as heck, a shame it doesn't have an official translation.
It did get translated in French, so you can grab them and reverse engineer an English translation out of that
I don’t have much to add really but I’m glad to see you cover this manga! It was certainly a tough read the first time through and certain things or terminology is hard to follow due to the translation at times. What I really liked was the fact that the keys turned into swords that really changed the tides of battle. I also loved the reference to the the Black Books and the Red Book by Jung, being very explicitly mentioned in a Persona work. Overall I was a fan of the main cast and became very endeared to Kazumi! Thanks for a great video!
Reading this manga after it finally being translated allowed it to be something quite special in my heart, so I'm glad a video was done on it and a great one at that! :)
I'm French and recently found all 3 volumes at a reasonable price. I read the first two volumes and I was blown away. I haven't played any of the Persona 2 games (I've only played P5R for now) so I don't know how it compares but I for sure love the manga. Really looking forward to the final volume.
I remember searching for the manga online and I could only find the Wikipedia article for it and nothing else. Glad to stumble upon this video.
THIS GUY IS ONE OF MY FAV PROTAGS AND NOBODY KNOW HIM😭😭
I'm barely getting into this series so I got to ask like is the first one more mysterious?
Genuinely happy to see this little side series get light, well done 😎👌
I’ve been reading the manga and enjoying it! Good to see a fellow individual in the know!
Oh MY God did they just reference demi kids subtlety?!?!
Holy shit as a Persona fan i never know about this manga. I wish Atlus made a game based on this manga, with some change for the gameplay of course but should be a nice story as a spinoff or another universe from the main canon.
Ill always love Persona 2. I have that manga trilogy personally. Bought it few yrs back. Ill never forget Crime and Punishment
I swear to god I'd heard about it before (in some other unknown persona content video ) but It's great to know what it was about
literal chillz
I have waited so long for somebody to make a video about this series Tysm
OHHH its this one..I read a bit of it in the internet (ofc and also obvious how), I was in a website and well I love persona but I wasn't blessed with much money so at times i literally watch gameplay, analysis vids, fact vids, anime, mangas, any form of persona content I can basically access for short and, while reading another manga, I just happen to saw this one at the side and was curious enough to read it since the cover looks really cool and its a persona i have never even heard of, Im glad to see someone talking about it, Im not really attached to it since i didn't went far cause I was reading something else at the time.
This was very interesting, I never actually paid much attention when I saw something about this previously. Thanks for sharing a neat part of persona history
is it tsumi to batsu?
Yup
Im one of the few who knew about this, mainly because i decided to open the megaten wiki protagonists page one day. I wanted to read it but saw no good translation and just kinda of gave up
I thought you were gonna talk about smt if being a prototype for persona 1, but this is even more interesting❤
or devil summoner..
I think The Reaper idea might've came from that
i feel like now that ive finished the p2 duology i should start reading this but uhhhhh
I know its probably not gonna happen but id play a game of this
nice pfp, I didn't think other people liked that character
@Gio-kg4gb thanks Ggio Vega is goated
I think I saw this guy in a fan art.
I actually have all 3 volumes of this manga. Its super cool
Wow this really is a forgotten Persona story.
Started out thinking this was just gonna be a SMT if video or something(idk anything about it beyond it sort of being Persona 0)
If we ever do get that P2 remake imma need this manga adapted for a DLC expansion
On 10:10 i was wondering what music that is, i realized that it was used on the House Of The Dead II ending
I don’t knew there was a fan translation for this
I’ve read this before. It’s decent but the Factory Family was by far my favourite part of it.
mission achived 🫡
Hear me out, probably aint gonna happen, but a persona spin off where the protagonist and party members are adults, but then again doing paper work instead of the school mini game would be boring but kinda funny at the same time
Really cool
I would play this
I am the REAL forgotten Persona
Fwiw, they were translated to French.
Hey what did you edit or programs did you use to make this video! Looks crisp
I use both Adobe Premiere Pro and After Effects
Lol why the start just sounds like devilman.
I actually know about this one
Tarou atlus from persona mobile online
cool where do i read this or buy this
There’s an English fan translation on Mangadex. Buying physicals, you’ll need to look online for Japanese or French copies
I thought it's gonna be vincent
I've known about it but I thought it sounded boring, my minds changed on it
hop on smt nine
why does the mc look like markiplier
So the zestiness has always been apart of persona…
You talk a bit fast, even the captions can't print out what exactly are you saying. Sometimes it's not about how fast you talk too, but it's also your pronunciation that I often misunderstand.
Who tf IS this guy
🤷🏾♀️ people just don't like him