Rosie Duffield tells Andrew Neil the truth about her relationship with Keir Starmer
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- “That was the moment when I realised I was probably completely on my own.”
As Rosie Duffield describes the isolation she’s felt from the Labour front bench, Andrew Neil slams Keir Starmer for leaving her out to dry.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.c...
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.c...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.c...
![[Full] 4 ต่อ 4 Celebrity EP.910 | 22 ก.ย. 67 | one31](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4TR3MVpOiw8/mqdefault.jpg)
Keep going Rosie, you are brilliant. I was close to tears watching you soeak in Parliament when your Labour colleagues on the benches behind you could barely control their contempt they have for you. What a trooper 👏
Rosie Duffield is 100% right and says what millions of people think.
Starmer doesn't know the difference between a woman or a man.
well he is the son of a tool maker who managed to make huge tool called a sirkier
He does, he's just too scared to say. Which is worse.
He does, but he doesn't care enough about the consequences of lying about it to tell the truth.
Maybe he needs a health check
then
Starmer needs his organs checking by a Doctor or Nurse quick 😂
Can't vote Labour when they're so laissez-faire about women's rights and safety.
It's a woman who Rosie says is leading the attack on her. Rosie is campaigning on trans rights so I can only think you wouldn't Labour anyway.
@@Simon-zb6fp always voted Labour. Not anymore.
The largest threat is from CIS men, do you ever comment on that? CIS and Trans women's rights are not mutually exclusive.
Clearly hung out to dry by the Labour establishment....time to turn away from the 2party stranglehold
The reason you're on your own in your party Rosie is that you've actually got a spine.
Stop making excuses for Starmer, Rosie.
what lovely person Rosie Duffield is , the type of M P we need in parliament , a person of integrity ,rosie can hold her head up high
well above many other mps
I'd run to vote for her if she were standing in my area.
Lovely person a. How can someone be lovely when there’s people that she doesn’t like and against their rights ?
@@MdJ197 transactivism is anti women's rights
@@jayjaydubful lol what an absolute load of BS 😂🤦🏼♀️
@@MdJ197 so do you think women should have the right to single sex facilities, sports, personal care etc or should they make way for men who believe they are women?
Why on earth is she still in the Labour Party?? Clearly no one else agrees with her so she may as well leave.
Rosie Duffield is too forgiving, she should be furious at the way she has been treated by the trans mob and the Labour Party. I don’t know why she remains a member of the Labour Party they don’t deserve her.
She's a helpful thorn in Starmer's side by remaining in the Labour Party.
Rosie Duffield today the majority of Brits tomorrow.
TODAY - not tomorrow.
@marieparker3822 none of this ends well for any of us.
Shame on those narcissistic bullies who caused all of this. Narcissists cannot stand a difference of opinion or anything they perceive as criticism. We need to do learn about them and not tolerate it.
Rosie, don't be so nice and forgiving, your Labour 'collegues' are ruthless.
Sadly, you're entirely correct. Seemingly both Starmer and his cabal (McSeeney, Akehurst, Evans, etc) - as WELL as the more toxic elements of the extreme left - have ALL treated Rosie appallingly. I for one will NOT be voting Labour on 4th July.
This is the problem with lefties. The decent ones just aren't ruthless enough and they're reasonable and fair to people who aren't.
@@clivet3252 I think that speaks to a problem of the Labour Party itself - which has always been divided on various issues - but also to our 2-party First Past The Post electoral system.
What we need is electoral reform, to scrap FPTP in favour of PR in tandem wih the Single Transferable Vote.
That would lead to greater democracy, IMO.
All this and once in power, Labour terrifies me. God knows what’s going to happen in the future.
How sad to se that someone who is straight talking and not prepared to lie is being treated so badly by some of the toxic, horrible trouble makers around us. I don't think Labour deserve such a decent MP, far too good for them. :-(
If Keir Starmer knew what’s good for him, he’d give Rosie Duffield the Women and Equalities brief. She’s the only one in Labour who understands balancing rights.
I live in Rosie’s constituency and can honestly say she is a wonderful MP for our area
Oh really. But does she care about everyone ?
@@MdJ197 She seems to
@kieranmonk4646 do tell what wonderful things has she done for this area (i live in the constituency), and voted for her twice.
The sewage problem is no better, building more houses than the area can cope with, houses that locals cannot afford with to many second home owners buying up property. My vote is going elsewhere this time.
@@malcky630 doesn’t matter who. As an MP you are suppose to think about all kinds of people and not hate or have bad intentions of different people
@@MdJ197 Are you scared of her because she talks about women's rights? You'd better just stay home 😂
I don't believe she is 52 yrs old !
Hard work ages people
As a lifelong Labour voter, I stand 100% with Rosie Duffield, both in terms of her views on Trans Rights and in her steadfast opposition to Brexit. I'll vote Labour, only so long as people like Rosie remain within it's ranks.
And as a Labour member, I find it extraordinary that you want to align with a transphobe.
I support Rosie but I don't know how you can continue to support Labour. They will undo all of the good that we have have managed to achieve. They are going to bring in self-ID by the back door, throw transwidows under the bus and continue to embed the teaching of gender ideology in school.
@@andrewcalladine2507 @andrewcalladine2507 What right does, or should a party that purports to represent "labour" have to dictate individual members' stances on social issues like the rights of trans women to enter women only spaces?
xzAs a lifelong Labour voter, I stand 100% with Rosie Duffield, both in terms of her views on yyou arepartof a big problem Trans Rights whatrightsdont they have loon
@@andrewcalladine2507 This is precisely why I won't go near this topic with a barge pole. Both sides of the argument are justifiable, there isn't a solution that satisfies both sides, and the people who have taken sides have their heads so far up their own backside they're completely blind to the aforementioned facts.
No wonder the NHS is a disaster
She can’t help protecting the flip flopper!
Vote Reform!
I will not vote for Labour at this election because of the way Mrs Duffield has been treated.
Who are you voting for?
If you're on Mrs Duffield's side, it would make sense also to be supporting her party. Starmer has been supportive of her.
@@j.x.x.r3645 no he hasn’t. He’ll flip-flop again back to you extremist far left views.
@@j.x.x.r3645 On the contrary, Starmer said she was 'wrong' and hung her out to dry, that' clear from this interview
@@mrpocock Reform UK
Starmer can not be trusted, worse than Boris, and that is saying something 😢
Rosie Duffield is to be commended for her devotion to truth and her fortitude.
However, her main utility now is as a signal. How Rosie Duffield is treated now IS HOW ALL WOMEN WILL BE TREATED UNDER A LABOUR GOVERNMENT.
*DO NOT VOTE LABOUR.*
For Rosie Duffield to say, 'It's their right to do this' is totally wrong. They have no right to interrupt the democratic process, and it shouldn't be allowed.
Vote reform
...and reform what exactly? (though I know your a 'bot')
Labours downfall in the future will be its wokeness !! No matter how deep your support for the Party, its achillies heel is its softness on moral positions like gay rights, Trans, Diversity etc.... it should just get on with the economic recovery of this Country.
Define woke ?
@@MdJ197 In this context, I define it as having a focus or priority on matters other than those that effect the majority as a whole. Diversity wont bring the cost of living down. Trans Rights wont pay off the national debt or get us better education or a better NHS The narratives need to refocus on the things that really matter to getting this country back on its feet after 14 years of Tory mis management. Get the soft woke issues off the main agenda and start talking and focussing on the big issues that will make a huge difference to us all
@@MdJ197Social engineering ruthlessly enforced by authoritarianism
@@MdJ197pushing your gender ideology on everyone else when 80% of the population doesn't accept it.
Let's harass, bully and intimate those who don't agree with our views.
Vote Reform!
Very Well Said
I don't know why Duffield is still in the labour party the way they've treated her
I would be happy if she weren't. So we agree.
Because beneath this timorous exterior, she can see the writing on the wall and knows labour will win
STALIN STARMER
I am not a Labour supporter but if I lived in Canterbury I would definitely vote for her, and help in her campaign in whatever way I could. Keep up the great work Rosie!
What a load of driveling cowardice and disgraceful excuse-making for a party that has demonstrated an absolute lack of leadership, integrity and conviction on any subject.
What a brilliant young politician with a free and independent mind! 👍❤️
Great interview - stay strong Rosie💪🏼
Starter is a fake
The closing down of debate here is a threat to British democracy. I understand and agree that, in one way, this is an issue affecting women, but it goes far wider than that.
And this shower are about to be around for at the very least 60 months.
Accepting that Rosie has her conflicts with Starmer however why is she talking to Andrew Neil, because when was Neil ever impartial? 😒 Yes, he can come across as impartial while talking and listening to Rosie. But it's not necessarily the greater British public to whom he reports, especially if you consider how Rosie's plight could be of special interest to Neil's particular political stance and those who use the same platform. Far right or far left, they'll hijack anything.
Having said that, I was interested to hear Rosie's point about if a woman needs an abortion, for whatever reason, the hoops she has to jump through might seem particularly unfair next to someone else who wants to completely re-identify, by gender, and will soon only require approval by one medical professional.🤔
Really Piers tweeted, and you Rosie liked a tweet stating the bleeding obvious, and now it's costing the taxpayer a small fortune in security.
Good bless Rosie Duffield.
Good interview with an impressive person
I hear a distant echo of a bewildered Party member in Stalin's USSR, unable to understand why she has been purged and failing to join the dots to challenge the entire belief system.
Comes across as principled and hard working constituency MP who actually listens to opinions & doesn't subscribe to the notion of wrong / right views. Exactly what we need in a senior post; but unfortunately I dont think Starmer will pick her for high office for precisely these values. He needs people he can control - career politicians! Not what we need!
Can't believe anyone would vote for Philipson, now ludicrously in charge of our children's education, watch the LBC Ferrari interview when she just couldn't answer a basic question, which toilet does a transwoman use?. Mind boggling simple answer required. How on earth is this labour government going to deal with hugely complex issues?.
Wow top draw interview!!!!
This ought to be blockbuster politics…
drawer!
Please kick me. All best.
This is horrific and just ONE of the reasons I decided I could never Labour again. It's become the party of lunatic activists. The Tories are also useless, cowardly, & weak when confronted by activism. I guess it's not for nothing that they call him 'Slippery Starmer'. 🤣
Vote Workers Party of Britain or Independents
How about Reform - have you read their Contract - i think you will like it.
So you have to find a doctor who will certify that a man is a woman and a woman is a man. Are there doctors seriously prepared to do that!
Rosie has been very let down by tge very prople that should be supporting her and other women, the Labour Party.
Conversion therapy similar to aversion therapy minus electric shocks ?
Looking beyond the dissociation with one's sexed body to understand the reasons behind that is basic care, not a crime
avoid social media
Recommended: U-tube video 'What is Wrong with the Labour Party? Rosie Duffield is a Legend', by the brilliant The Famous Artist Birdie Rose.
Keir Starmer is so pathetic!!
As it seems that nobody can define what a woman actually is anymore, it makes me wonder what a trans woman actually feels that makes that person believe they are a woman, a term which is not definable. Are we legally furniture if we identify as such. Are you allowed to starve yourself to death if you are Anorexic and have body Dismorphia.
Andrew really comes across as a desperate old hass been who has been found out through GB nonsense.
What a strange comment!!
Mr. Neil's analysis is spot on as usual .
I'm not voting for Rosie Duffield, although I deeply sympathise with her position. I am voting for the Liberal Democrats because they are to the left of Labour. Plus, the LibDems have better green policies. Duffield is being treated badly by the Labour Party machine and has little support from the leadership
Gammons unite and vote Reform .
Lib Dems want self ID
Have you forgotten their u-turn to be in power with the tories, are the reason that young people are now stuck with thousands of pounds of student debt
Clueless boomerism.
Possibly clueless GenXerism.
Starmer flip-flop all over the place need to leave and join reform UK
The JOKE party to follow the CLOWN Party, NO ta...Just say NO to f a s c i s m...
I feel sorry for Rosie Duffield and am 100% on her side but she's being naive to be interviewed by Neil during a General Election. He'll be opportunistically seeing this as a chance to make things awkward for the Labour Party for which she is a candidate. Surely she could have found another outlet.
And do you feel sorry for the people that Rosie doesn’t like and against their rights ?. There’s people that Rosie doesn’t like and wants to take away their rights 😡
@@MdJ197 Which people doesn't she like?
@@MdJ197 I'd like to see her interviewed by James O'Brien. I'd like to know how James O'Brien would approach such an interview. But if he doesn't invite her, then there's not much she can do about it. I'd love to see J.K. Rowling on the James O'Brien Full Disclosure podcast. That would be something worth listening to
@@alansmith4748 I’d rather not say just to protect the minority group that I’m talking about. But again there’s people she doesn’t like and wants rid of 😢
Not true. She has nothing against trans people. She is concerned about the safety of women and children. Stop spreading lies!
Out of one’s depth springs to mind…
What a silly comment
@@JimMorrisonsboots she can’t even explain her position well…
Terrible mp.
She really wants to control what people are allowed to say doesn't she...
No?
The opposite of that actually
Oh dear, the Times is Scraping the bottom of the barrel with this one.
All personal threats are appalling, of course, but you should have challenged Duffield's assertion that she represents women in Labour. She certainly doesn't. She adheres to a very minority position on questions relating to trans people.
Wrong.
@@jujutrini8412Correct.
No most right thinking people who do not live in a lala land agree with Rosie.
You need to grow up.
You went against labour policy, don’t want to be held to account for your words as an elected representative and are now seeking solace in the right wing murdoch media from Andrew Neil, Tory foghorn. Let’s pity her.
Did they have an affair?!?
No
Can't vote for her as she couldn't even vote for a ceasefire for Gaza,the woman doesn't care about civilians being killed and responds with some weak #ss replies about "Israels right to defend itself",she really is spinelness and I have little sympathy for her.She does not care about the lives of innocent children in Gaza.
Like Hamas cares about children??? Are you for real
...so Who started the War? All Hamas has to do is stop using human shields and surrender their murderous mafia to be locked up - then there will be Peace.
Oh she feels unsafe and risk of violence. Well the negative things that she’s been saying towards some people/ communities has caused them people to feel unsafe and threatened with violence and in some cases actual violence has happened to them people that’s she’s spoke negatively towards. She doesn’t realise that things she has said has caused violence towards some people ☹️
What's she said?
@alansmith4748 She gave her opinion. An opinion based on her experience as a woman who suffered domestic abuse that men should not be able to self identify as women and force access to women's shelters. An opinion shared by the majority of the country according to opinion polls.
@@richardstreet7605 yes very true that. But that was from an abusive man. She’s against people completely different who aren’t like that. You’re comment is suggesting that the people she hates are exactly like abusive men which is far from the truth my friend 👍
MdJ197 how long have you hated women?
She’s in Friends of Israel, don’t care what happens to her.
Not entirely persuaded by her initial argument. It does come across as a way to mask weak debating skills. We should be respectful to all and allow others to have a contrary view.
Absolutely agree with you. But where does she suggest otherwise?
I take back my previous comment!
Rosie has been re-elected and improved her majority by 400%!! Rosie’s debating skills clearly shone on the doorsteps. Fantastic to hear, and well done to Canterbury for electing an incredibly considered representative.
As a member of LGBT community, I think Rosie’s voice is very welcome and very important! - Especially within the new Labour Government.
Hardly shocking that an ally of some of the worst bigots in modern times will draw a protest about their conduct and anti LGBT positions.
Who are these allies?
How are you defining anti LGBT?
...no wonder she's so anonymous in our constituency. Perhaps she'd be better off just stepping down...
She sounds disturbingly like a tory.
Can you explain why?
She certainly talks way too much sense to be Labour I agree
she sounds ike Israel shouting about how frightened she is whilst carrying out attacks on others.
The LGBTQ Community sound like Israel shouting about how frightened they are whilst carrying out attacks on others.
(Btw my comparison was as ridiculous as yours)
You won't be missed, bye, bye.......
She cancelled a hustings meeting because she couldn't face the criticism from her own CLP, death threats aside (which is never acceptable) other politicians have had to be subjected to far worse, she's absolutely tone deaf when it comes to her own constituents and a vox street interview in Canterbury recently showed as such.
The Metropolitan DfL’s and second home owners are now Rosie’s core supporters, just looking around the local Whitstable area at all the vote labour boards will show you that. Actual local people are now less enthused than when she first won the seat. Her student vote has all but vanished and will probably go to the Greens for Gaza.
The Greens since winning some local council seats do seem intent on solving some of the areas issues and the Green General election candidate is at least a local person. Only problem is he is rather woke.
I think Rosie will retain the seat but not with my vote this time, been burnt twice.
What a manipulative interview. Its obvious that any party would have to tread carefully around these topics.
And ignore the truth you mean?
@@JimMorrisonsboots no but in an election year devisive subjects should be handled with care.
An attempt at a Hatchet job I thought more of you Andrew Neil !!
It would be useful for an MP in the next Parliament to ask the Home Secretary for accurate figures on how many MPs now need security for their personal safety, and how many of these are female MPs? There is an alarming rise in political violence in the UK today
And how many are requiring this protection because of threats from the far left. It so often seems to be those that preach equality and inclusion and tolerance that will not tolerate any dissent from their views.
Violence against women is always underplayed.
Why does Rosie stay in the Laobour Party?? Go independent or join Party of Women
Starmer is not prime minister material. We are in for some difficult times.
Have you been ok Jack, with the last 14 years of the CON Party, cause Millions haven't, ya self-server...
@@El_Paracletowell it’s a bit like this. I have never voted Tory. I started my working life in the mines Jack and I never crossed a picket line. However the Labour Party left me about 14 years ago and generally I am appalled by the third rate politicians on offer. I cannot spot the difference between Starmer and Sunak.
I do not think Starmer will be PM for long . I think he will be replaced with a far left or Islamist . He could be just there to win the election . Don't frighten the voters !!
@@El_Paracletojust because the last 14 years have been bad it doesn't mean things won't be worse under Labour. Leeds fans used to kid themselves that each new manager was an upgrade but it was obvious they weren't.
@@El_Paracleto Vote Reform
Rosie is awesome!
Two faced Starmer
Cashman should never been ennobled in the first place.
This woman is a hero. She's the only reason I'd ever vote labour.
She’s the reason I will never vote Labour, the way the party has vilified and failed to support her is disgraceful.
It shows the Labour Party is full of spineless cowards.
@@Rosemary-iz5vc Absolutely right, the voice of reason is being treated so badly.
Cash man rose to prominence playing "dress up"and" lets pretend"
He/they still thinks that way..
Trying to smear Corbyn supporters when this has nothing to do with Corbyn or his supporters.
Whats the point of being part of a group that hates you...
Go woke go broke.
Rosie Duffield speaks well and is an impressive member of Parliament.
What a delightful lady Rosie is. No MP should ever have to go through what she has had to, just for expressing her view, and very loud alarm bells should already be ringing for all of us, because as we see fom this interview and many others, that Labour harbours a very aggressive movement who have made gender-politics a really nasty thing, and their ideology will have much more of a public platform once Labour wins the election on July 4th. God bless Rosie. I'm proud of you. Hang in there! 🙋♂
She has her right to express her views...but so have everyone else ...straight or trans ..no one should feel threatend ..everyone should..listen...dont let it get politicised ..we are all human.
I tried to ammend my c9mment below but Toutube will not let me, Andrew i see and accept your point.
What's she doing in the Labour Party. No decent human being is a member of Labour.
This interview exposes Labour for the shitshow it is.
This is why labour need a woman leader.
Yeah half the women in the labour party have apposite views to her. They have all signed up to the trans rights.
You want change vote reform
Hope your not saying Rayner.
farage should welcome this lady with open arms ! she`s working class
Rosie Duffield is a social democrat. She's far from being a fascist!! She'd never even consider Reform. She's too intelligent for Reform
All are welcome in saving Britain from the commies
Rachel Reeves , Jess Philips and Wes Streeting all strongly supported Rosie. She hasn’t been without support in the Party. Of course , the likes of Tory Andrew Neil is playing it up
Well, she’s not an MP so Neil is wrong on that
She's only technically not an MP in the sense that parliament's been dissolved and so there aren't any MPs at the moment. It's normal to refer to the outgoing MPs as MPs still.
Rosie duffield is the MP FOR CANTERBURY
No she isn’t, she is the former MP. If you go to the parliament website for the current list of mp’s it shows there are none, zero, zilch!
Lots of disillusioned tories here !!! 🤪🤪🤪
Andrew Neil is biased at best